Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List-1
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 68 of 2019
Date of Decision: 08.02.2023
Vs.
Shri Dwijen Sharma
The North Eastern Hills
University & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P.K. Tiwari, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S.P. Sharma Adv.
Mr. P.R. Sarma, Adv.
Ms. S.K. Nongrum, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Sen, Adv. (For 1-3)
Mr. S. Das, Adv. (For R 7)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioner who is presently serving as Professor in
English in North Eastern Hills University (Tura Campus), being
aggrieved by the non-counting of his past service rendered in the
Institutions where he served earlier, for the purposes of coverage under
the relevant Pension Scheme, is before this Court by way of the instant
writ petition.
2.
The brief facts are that the petitioner was first appointed as
Lecturer (English) in B.B. Kishan College in the District of Barpeta,
Assam, and in that capacity was regularized in service on 15.11.2002.
Thereafter, the petitioner was selected as Assistant Professor in the
Central University of Jharkhand and after serving the said University
for a brief period, joined North Eastern Hills University as Assistant
Professor on 27.06.2012. As B.B. Kishan College had been
provincialized by the Assam Colleges Employees (Provincialization
Act, 2005), the services of the petitioner which had been regularized
on 15.11.2002 therefore became pensionable and the petitioner was
brought under GPF and allotted a GPF Account Number. Under
Section 7 of the Act, the existing employees were to be governed by
the existing Pension Rules, with the proviso that employees who joined
on or after 01.02.2005, shall not be covered by the existing Pension
Rules. The petitioner’s case is therefore founded on the basis that he
would be covered by the Old Pension Scheme, counting his past
service, and cannot be placed under the New Pension Scheme, as has
been sought to be done by the North Eastern Hills University.
3.
Mr. P.K. Tiwari, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr.
S.P. Sharma, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner while serving in B.B. Kishan College and being appointed
prior to 2005, came under the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969,
which were amended thereafter and made applicable to employees
joining their service in the State on or before 10.02.2005. The learned
Senior counsel submits that the petitioner on being appointed on
21.12.2011 to the Central University of Jharkhand, was granted lien for
2 years w.e.f. 18.02.2012, to facilitate his joining at Jharkhand Central
University. However, he submits after joining at Jharkhand on
20.02.2012, the petitioner came to be selected by NEHU as Associate
Professor in the Department of English, and an offer of appointment
was issued on 08.06.2012. Accordingly, the petitioner tendered his
technical resignation on 25.06.2012, which was duly accepted and vide
a letter dated 07.07.2012, issued by the Director, Education Krokrajhar
was granted lien for 2 years w.e.f. 18.02.2012.
4.
Learned Senior counsel submits that in the offer of
appointment letter, it was mentioned that the petitioner would be
governed by the New Pension Scheme as applicable to Central
Government Employees w.e.f. 01.01.2004, but however, in case his
present service is governed by CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, he shall be
entitled to retirement benefits in accordance with the said Rules,
subject to production of certificates substantiating the same. Thereafter,
he submits several communications were exchanged between the
respondent NEHU and the respondent No. 8 (B.B. Kishan College) to
ascertain as to whether the services of the petitioner were to be
governed by the New Pension Scheme or the Old Pension Scheme,
which was akin to the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. Attention of this
Court has been drawn to the query of NEHU contained in a letter dated
18.05.2015, and the reply thereof dated 12.10.2015, wherein the
Principal of B.B. Kishan College had informed that the petitioner was
eligible to be governed by CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. Learned Senior
counsel then submits that further information was sought by NEHU
vide letter dated 18.08.2016, which was replied by the respondent No.
8 (B.B. Kishan College) on 08.09.2016, with regard to the petitioner’s
contribution to the GPF Account. This however, he submits came to
naught as the NEHU authorities, declined his request for counting his
past services, on the ground that the petitioner contributed to his GPF
Account only from April, 2013, when he had already joined NEHU
since 27.06.2012. It has been contended by the learned Senior counsel,
that there is no break in the services of the petitioner, as he had obtained
lien for joining his other post, and furthermore the position as regards
his service, being clear as to what Pension Scheme he was to be
governed by, the action of the respondent NEHU in not granting him
the benefits of the Old Pension Scheme is illogical and arbitrary. The
learned Senior then submits that the offer of appointment, and the letter
of appointment placing the petitioner under the New Pension Scheme,
is of no relevance, inasmuch as, the case of the petitioner is covered by
the Office Memorandums of the Government of India dated
26.07.2005, 28.10.2009 and 18.03.2014, which satisfies the
requirement as sought by NEHU. It is also argued that there can be no
estoppel against law and the acceptance of the appointment by the
petitioner in the terms contained therein cannot deprive him of his just
entitlements. Learned Senior counsel in conclusion, has placed reliance
on the judgment in the case of Valsan P… vs. State of Kerela and Ors.
reported in (2022) 1 SCC 362 which he submits that the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held that for the purpose of computing qualifying
pensionable services where permissible, a holistic consideration of
applicable Rules is to be taken.
5.
Mr. S. Sen, learned counsel for the respondent in reply,
submits that the non-counting of the earlier service rendered by the
petitioner in B.B. Kishan College, before joining the NEHU on
27.06.2012 is based on cogent reasons. He firstly submits that
admittedly the writ petitioner in his earlier institution, was under the
CPF Scheme and after the GPF Scheme was introduced an Account for
the same was allotted only in the year 2013, when the writ petitioner
was already in the service of NEHU. He further submits that the
Pension Scheme under the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules,
1972, ceased to be effective w.e.f. 31.12.2003 with the introduction of
the New Pension Scheme which came into force from 01.01.2004.
6.
The learned counsel submits that the writ petitioner even
in his brief stint in Jharkhand University had accepted an appointment,
wherein it has been categorically mentioned that he was to be governed
under the New Pension Scheme of GOI/UGC. He further submits that
similarly the offer of appointment made by NEHU, vide letter dated
08.06.2012, also mentioned that the petitioner would be governed by
the New Pension Scheme, and though it was clarified therein that he
was permitted produce a certificate from his old employer to prove
otherwise, the petitioner at the time of joining NEHU, did not produce
such certificate, which clearly was due to the fact that the petitioner
was under the CPF and not GPF. The learned counsel has referred to
Annexure-P-10 of the writ petition to substantiate his submissions, that
the petitioner contributed a sum of Rs. 22,198/- towards his GPF
Account only on 14.03.2014, in his earlier Institution after he was
already in the service of NEHU, and that too after he had submitted his
technical resignation on 18.02.2014. The learned counsel then submits
that the petitioner having accepted the terms of appointment to be under
the New Pension Scheme, has resorted to this writ petition claiming to
be put under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, only as an afterthought
and as such the writ petition deserves no consideration.
7.
From the part of respondent No. 7, the Commissioner &
Secretary to the Govt. of Assam, Education Department, represented
by learned counsel Mr. S. Das, the stand on affidavit, is however that
as the writ petitioner was serving as Assistant Professor in B.B. Kishan
College w.e.f. 15.11.2002 to 17.02.2012 and having deposited the
Government share of CPF money, is eligible for pro rata pensionary
benefits as per Rule 98 of the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969.
It is also stated in the affidavit that as per the Provincialisation Rules,
2010 at the proviso to Rule 21 (ii), it has been provided that employees
who joined service after 2005, shall be governed by Pension Rules or
Scheme as may be framed by the Government.
8.
Having heard the learned counsels for the parties and after
examining the materials on record, in the view of this Court, the
entitlements of the petitioner can be simply decided by recounting the
service journey of the writ petitioner, alongside the Acts and Rules that
are relevant for the purpose.
9.
When the petitioner initially started his career at the B.B.
Kishan College, wherein his services were regularized on 15.11.2002
the said College was under the Deficit System of Grant-in-Aid. On
22.12.2005, the College was provincialised under the Assam College
(Provincialisation) Act, 2005 and accordingly the Government of
Assam brought the services of the Teachers of Provincialised Colleges
under the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969. It would be
worthwhile to note at this juncture, that had the petitioner continued in
service in B.B. Kishan College, he would be covered by the Assam
Service (Pension) Rules, which are akin to the CCS (Pension) Rules,
1972, as he entered service in the year 2001 prior to the cutoff date of
01.02.2005 prescribed by the Provincialisation Act. As per Rule 21 of
the Assam College Employees (Provincialisation) Rules, 2010, the
existing Rules and Orders applicable to State Government employees
on Pension, GPF, Leave, TA etc. would also be applicable, to him.
10.
On his acceptance of appointment in the Central University
of Jharkhand, lien was granted to the petitioner for 2 years w.e.f.
18.02.2012, and he joined on 20.02.2012, maintaining lien and
continued there till 25.06.2012. In the intervening period while in
service, an offer of appointment dated 08.06.2012 was issued by
NEHU. It is important to note herein that in Para-3 of the said offer of
appointment, it was mentioned that the petitioner would be governed
by the New Pension Scheme as applicable with effect from 01.01.2004,
and further he was permitted to produce certificates from his present
employer to show that he was governed by CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.
The offer of appointment dated 08.06.2012, for the sake of convenience
is reproduced hereinbelow:-
“North-Eastern Hill University
NEHU Campus, Shillong – 793 022 (Meghalaya)
F. No. 26-2/Estt.II(B)/2012-995
Dated, the
June, 2012.
Subject:
Offer of appointment to the post Associate Professor
(UR) in the Department of English, Tura Campus, Tura.
On acceptance of the recommendation of the Selection
Committee by the Executive Council in its 28th Emergent meeting
held on 31.5.2012 vide resolution No. EEC:28:2012:6:1(i) Dr.
Dwijen Sharma, is hereby offered the appointment to the post of
Associate Professor (UR) in the Department of English, NEHU, Tura
Campus, Tura. The post shall carry Pay Band of Rs.37400-67000/with Academic Grade Pay of Rs.9000/- plus other allowances as
admissible.
The appointment, however, will be subject to the
following terms and conditions:1. That his services will be governed by the Act, Statutes,
Ordinances, Rules and Regulation of the University
in force including CCS (Rules) as amended from time
to time.
2. That he will be on probation for a period of one year
from the date of joining the post.
3. That he will be governed by New Pension Scheme as
applicable to the Central Government employees
w.e.f. 1.1.2004. However, in case his present service
is governed by CCS Pension Rules, 1972, he shall be
entitled to retirement benefits in accordance with the
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 subject to production of
Certificates from the present employer stating that he
is governed by CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 and shall
also transfer the service of Dr. Dwijen Sharma after
confirmation of her service in NEHU. This document
is required to be submitted at the time of joining the
post failing which he shall be governed by New
Pension Scheme in NEHU.
4. If the above terms and conditions are acceptable to
Dr. Dwijen Sharma he may report for duties to the
respective Head of the Department (within one month
from the date of issue of this Offer).
5. At the time of reporting for duties to the respective
Heads of the Departments following are to be
submitted:
a) Verification of character and antecedent
certificate
issued
by
the
Deputy
Commissioner/Magistrate of the District or any
Gazetted Officer in the prescribed proforma
enclosed.
b) Medical Certificate of fitness issued by the Civil
Surgeon of the District that he/she resides or by
the Medical Officer of NEHU in the prescribed
format enclosed.
(NOTE: Clause 3 and 5 above are not applicable to those who
are already in NEHU service as Permanent Employees).
(T.K. Singha)
Deputy Registrar (Estt. II)”
11.
Thereafter, the respondent No. 8, (B.B. Kishan College)
vide letter dated 30.06.2012, intimated the respondent NEHU about the
factum of the petitioner being covered by the Assam Service (Pension)
Rules, 1969, that he had been accorded lien leave, for a period of 2
years w.e.f. 18.02.2012, and that he had served as Assistant Professor
in the said College from 19.03.2001 to 17.02.2012. The respondent
NEHU then issued the appointment letter dated 12.07.2012 appointing
the petitioner as Associate Professor. It is to be noticed that the
clarification regarding the coverage of the petitioner under the Old
Pension Scheme was communicated to the respondent NEHU, before
the issuance of the final appointment order, which however, contained
the same condition that the petitioner was to be covered by the New
Pension Scheme. This was reiterated by a letter dated 21.08.2012
issued by the respondent NEHU, on the ground that the petitioner’s
earlier service was not covered under the CCS (Pension) Rules, while
in service in B.B. Kishan College.
12.
This back and forth exchange, to ascertain the status of the
petitioner continued between the respondent No. 8 and the respondent
NEHU and the same culminated in the impugned letter dated
Nil.11.2016, wherein the respondent NEHU rejected the prayer of the
petitioner finally, on the ground that the GPF contribution of the
employees of B.B. Kishan College, including the petitioner started only
from April, 2013, whereas he had joined NEHU on 27.06.2012 under
the New Pension Scheme. Thus, it is seen that the placement of the
petitioner under the New Pension Scheme, notwithstanding the offer of
appointment and letter of appointment, mentioning that he would be
governed by the New Pension Scheme, was finally decided on the date
in which he started his GPF contribution in the place of his initial
appointment i.e. B.B. Kishan College.
13.
Looking back into the entire sequence of events, there are
certain uncontroverted facts that are in favour of the petitioner. First, is
the date of his regular appointment and secondly, the lien obtained from
his original Institute, which covered his transition from B.B. Kishan
College to Central University Jharkhand and finally NEHU. The only
hiccup, is the date on which he started his GPF contribution which is
noted was done on 14.03.2014, for salary for the month of April, 2013,
admittedly after he had joined his present post at NEHU. This however,
has been explained by the petitioner on affidavit, that the contribution
was for a period he was on lien from B.B. Kishan College, before his
permanent absorption in NEHU, and made shortly after his technical
resignation, and as such cannot be taken to be a disqualifying feature
or unauthorized, in the consideration of his case. As observed above,
the uncontroverted position, being that he was by the operation of
Section 7 of the Assam Provincialisation Act and Rule 21 of the Rules
covered by the Old Pension Scheme, the non-counting of his earlier
service to be eligible under the Old Pension Scheme will therefore be
incorrect. Section 7 of the Provincialisation Act and Rule 21 are quoted
hereinbelow:“7.(1) The existing employees shall be governed by the
existing pension Rules of the Government for the time
being in force:
Provided that the employee who join on or after
st
the 1 day of February, 2005 shall not be covered by the
existing pension Rules of the Government. They shall be
governed by such pension Rules or Scheme, as the case
may be, as may framed by the Government from time to
time.
(2) The Director of Higher Education, Assam shall
process all pension cases and send them to the
Accountant General, Assam as per laid down
procedure.”
Rule
of
the
Assam
College
Employees
(Provincialisation) Rules, 2010
“21. i) Notwithstanding anything contained in these
Rules, the existing Rules and orders applicable to State
Government employees on pension, GPF, Leave, TA etc.
will be applicable in case of Provincialized College
Employees.
ii) The existing employees shall be governed by the
existing pension Rules of the Government;
Provided that the employees who joined on
or after 1st day of February, 2005 shall not be covered
by the existing Pension Rules of the Government. They
shall be governed by such Pension Rules or Scheme as
the case may be framed by the Government in respect of
other similarly situated employees of the Government;
iii) The Director, Higher Education, Assam shall
forward a college wise list of employees already retired
or due to retire within the next calendar year in the
format as prescribed for government Degree College, so
as to reach the Accountant General by 30th September
every year;
iv) The College shall process all Pension cases and
submit to the Director who shall sanction and authorize
provisional Pension/Gratuity on the basis of these rules
and the “Assam Service (Pension) Rules, 1969” as
applicable;
v) The employees who have opted for pension
scheme under the provision of Clause 8 of the Act will
discontinue their C.P.F. contribution, open G.P.F.
account with the Accountant General. Such employees
will compulsorily subscribe to the Fund at the prescribed
minimum rate of 6.25 % of basic pay per mensem;
vi) The Pension shall be authorized from the date
of coming into force of the Act i.e. 1st day of December,
2005;”
14.
Coupled with the above, it is also relevant to mention
herein that certain Office Memorandums of the Government of India
dated 26.07.2005, 28.10.2009 and 18.03.2014 (Annexures 19, 20 & 21
to the writ petition) which are applicable to all Central Educational
Institutions, have laid down the conditions for counting of past service.
O.M. dated 26.07.2005 has provided that where such employees submit
technical resignation on or after 01.01.2004, but entered Government
service etc. before 31.12.2003, and who were governed by the Old
Pension Scheme under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 will continue to
be governed by the Scheme for the purpose of counting their past
service. Further, the other office Memorandums, dated 28.10.2009 and
18.03.2014, with regard to mobility of personnel amongst Central/State
and Autonomous Bodies, while working under pensionable
establishments, have mentioned that on further review by the
Government of India, it was decided to continue the Old Pension
Scheme to those employees appointed on or before 31.12.2003, as also
the employees between State and Central Government who were
appointed before 31.12.2003.
15.
The entitlements of the petitioner being clear, the fact that
he had accepted the appointment wherein it was clearly written that he
would be governed by the New Pension Scheme, cannot be held against
him, inasmuch as, there can be no estoppel against law. This
observation is being made in view of the fact that in the normal course
of his service, by the operation of law, in this case the Assam College
Employees (Provincialisation) Act, 2005, the petitioner would have
been covered under the Old Pension Scheme i.e. the Assam Services
(Pension) Rules, 1969 which are akin to CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Krishna Rai (Dead)
Through Legal Representatives & Ors. vs. Banaras Hindu University
Through Registrar & Ors. reported (2022) 8 SCC 713 has held at Para32 as follows that there can be no estoppel against law.
“32. Further in Tata Chemicals Ltd. v. Commr. of
Customs, it has been laid down that there can be no
estoppel against law. If the law requires something to be
done in a particular manner, then it must be done in that
manner, and if it is not done in that manner, then it
would have no existence in the eye of the law. Para 18 of
the said judgment is reproduced below: (SCC p. 636)
“18. The Tribunal’s judgment has proceeded on
the basis that even though the samples were drawn
contrary to law, the appellants would be estopped
because their representative was present when the
samples were drawn and they did not object
immediately. This is a completely perverse finding
both on fact and law. On fact, it has been more
than amply proved that no representative of the
appellant was, in fact, present at the time the
Customs Inspector took the samples. Shri K.M.
Jani who was allegedly present not only stated that
he did not represent the clearing agent of the
appellants in that he was not their employee but
also stated that he was not present when the
samples were taken. In fact, therefore, there was
no representative of the appellants when the
samples were taken. In law equally the Tribunal
ought to have realized that there can be no
estoppel against law. If the law requires that
something be done in a particular manner, it must
be done in that manner, and if not done in that
manner has no existence in the eye of the law at
all. The Customs Authorities are not absolved
from following the law depending upon the acts of
a particular assessee. Something that is illegal
cannot convert itself into something legal by the
act of a third person.”
16.
The case cited by the learned Senior counsel for the
petitioner in the case of Valsan P… vs. State of Kerela and Ors.
(supra), has also held that when permissible, there is a necessity of
taking a holistic view to condone the non-qualifying period to reckon
the qualifying service for the purpose of computation of pensionable
service, which however does not arise in the present case as the service
of the petitioner is continuous and unbroken and therefore eligible to
be placed under the cover of the Old Pension Scheme.
17.
The writ petition on the reasons aforementioned is allowed.
Needless to add, the petitioner is to make good any short fall in his
contribution towards his GPF Account.
18.
This writ petition accordingly stands closed and disposed
of.
19.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
08.02.2023
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review