Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010624992022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
THURSDAY, THE 16th DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 492/2022
Between:
1. DUPATI BHANU PRASANTHI,, D/O. VENKATESWARLU @
VENKATESWARA RAO, NOW AGED ABOUT 9 YEARS, BEING
MINOR REP. BY HER FATHER AND NEXT FRIEND I.E., DUPATI
VENKATESWARLU @ VENKATESWARA RAO S/O. KRISHNA RAO,
BOTH ARE RESIDENT OF THAKKELLAPADU
VILLAGE,
PEDAKAKANI MANDAL, GUNTUR DISTRICT GUNTUR DMC
...APPELLANT
AND
1. THOTA KAMESWARAMMA, W/O. SUBBA RAO, (OWNER OF AUTO
RICKSHAW BEARING REGISTRATION NO. AP 07 TE 7152 D.NO. 177-88/2, MAIN ROAD, TADIKONDA VILLAGE AND MANDAL, GUNTUR
DISTRICT, MANGALAGIRI DMC
2. RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD, REP. BY ITS
DIVISIONAL MANAGER, ESWAR PALZA 3RD FLOOR, DWARAKA
NAGAR, VISAKHAPATNAM, VISAKHAPATNAM DMC COVER NOTE
NO. 315000069522 VALID FROM 27-1-2014 TO 26-1-2015
3. DANAM VINODH, S/O. MALLESWARA RAO DRIVER OF AUTO
RICKSHAW BEARING NO. AP TE 7152, DOPPALAPUDI VILLAGE,
PONNURU MANDAL, GUNTUR DISTRICT (THE 3RD RESPONDENT
IS NOT IS NECESSARY PARTY AS NO CLAIM IS MADE AGAINST
HIM IN THE APPEAL)
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Courtpleased to set
aside the Judgment and decree passed in M.V.O.P. No. 318/2016 on the file
the Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-III Addl. District Judge,
Guntur dated 12-8-2022 and enhance the amount of compensation as entitled
by the appellant together with interest at the rate of 12 percent per annum
from the date of filing the Original Petition till the date of realization and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to permit her to amend the amount of compensation claimed from
Rs. 12,00,000/- to Rs.25,00,000/- in the Original Petition in MVOP No.
318/2016 on the file the court of the Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal-cum-III Addl. District Judge, Guntur and to pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. SANJEEVA REDDY RACHAMALLA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GUDI SRINIVASU
2.
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 492/2022
JUDGMENT:
This appeal is filed by the appellants/claimants aggrieved by the order
and decree dated 12.08.2022 passed in M.V.O.P.No.318 of 2016 by the
learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-III Additional District Judge,
Guntur, wherein the Tribunal awarded compensation of Rs.7,30,000/(Rupees Seven Lakhs Thirty Thousand only) to the claimants/appellants
herein, as against the claim of Rs.12,00,000/-, on account of the injuries
sustained by Dupati Bhanu Prasanthi (hereinafter referred to as “the injured”),
in a motor vehicle accident that occurred on 19.07.2015.
2.
For the purpose of convenience, the parties will be referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
3.
The case of the claimants, in brief, is as follows:
(a) On 19.07.2015 at about 7.15 p.m., the injured, a three-year-old child,
was travelling as a pillion rider on her father's motorcycle bearing No. AP 07
BB 1945 from Takkellapadu to Chebrolu. While proceeding on the left side of
the road, the driver of the offending auto-rickshaw bearing No. AP 07 TE 7152
drove the vehicle in a rash and negligent manner, at a high speed and without
blowing the horn, while attempting to overtake another vehicle, collided headon with the motorcycle. As a result, the injured sustained grievous injuries and
was immediately shifted to the Government General Hospital, Guntur. A case
in Crime No.358 of 2015 was registered by Nallapadu Police under Section
338 IPC against the driver of the offending vehicle.
(b) It is further pleaded that, at the time of the accident, the injured was
studying LKG. She sustained permanent facial disfigurement due to the loss
of her right eye and suffered a fracture of the left femur, resulting in shortening
of the left leg and permanent physical disability. It is contended that these
injuries have adversely affected her future prospects, including her education,
normal life and marriage prospects.
(c) The injured initially underwent treatment at Government General
Hospital, Guntur. Thereafter, she was admitted to L.V. Prasad Eye Hospital,
Vijayawada, where surgery was performed and her right eye had to be
removed. Subsequently, she underwent orthopedic treatment at a Super
Specialty Hospital and later at Lalitha Hospital, where surgery was performed
on her left thigh bone. Even after discharge, she continued to undergo followup treatment. The claimants stated that they incurred medical expenses of
about Rs.50,000/-. According to the claimants, the accident occurred solely
due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the offending autorickshaw. Hence, the owner, driver and insurer of the offending vehicle are
jointly and severally liable to pay compensation.
4.
The 2nd respondent/Insurance Company filed a written statement
denying the material averments in the claim petition. It contended that the
claimants had not produced sufficient particulars or the insurance policy to
establish that the offending vehicle was insured with it on the date of the
accident. It was further contended that the driver of the offending vehicle/3rd
respondent did not possess a valid and effective driving license and had not
complied with Rule 3 of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989. The owner /
1st respondent was alleged to have violated the terms and conditions of the
insurance policy, thereby absolving the insurer of liability. The insurer further
contended that the police had failed to comply with Section 158(6) of the
Motor Vehicles Act by not forwarding the relevant documents within the
prescribed time, and asserted that the compensation claimed, including the
rate of interest, was excessive. Accordingly, it sought dismissal of the claim
petition
5.
Respondent No.3/Driver of the offending vehicle filed a written
statement denying the material averments made in the petition, inter alia
contending that the accident did not occur due to his negligence. He further
submitted that he possessed a valid driving license and that the offending
vehicle was duly insured with the 2nd respondent. Therefore, if any liability
arose, the same was against the 2nd respondent only and prays to dismiss the
claim petition.
6.
Basing on the pleadings, the Tribunal framed the following issues for
trial:
“1.
Whether
the
petitioner-Dupati
Bhanu
Prasanthi,
D/o
Venkateswarlu @ Venkateswara Rao received injuries in the
accident on 19.07.2015 due to rash and negligent driving of the
driver of the Auto bearing No.AP 07 TE 7152?
2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to compensation, if so, to what
amount, and against whom?
3. To what relief?
7.
On behalf of the claimants, P.W.s 1 to 3 were examined and Exs.A1 to
A8 and Exs.X1 to X12 were marked. On behalf of the respondents, R.W.1 was
examined and Ex.B-1 was marked.
8.
After hearing both sides and after considering the oral and documentary
evidence on record, the Tribunal partly allowed the claim petition, with the
following terms:
“1) In the result, the petition is allowed in part with proportionate
costs by awarding compensation of Rs.7,30,000/- to the petitioner
with interest @ 7.5% per annum from the date of petition till the date
of payment or realization. The respondents 1 to 3 are jointly and
severally liable to be paid the compensation amount
2) Respondent No.2 is directed to deposit the compensation amount
within two months from this day and shall recover the same from the
1st respondent by filing Execution Petition without filing separate
Suit.
3) The petitioner is permitted to withdraw the total amount with
accrued interest and costs. Out of the total amount, the petitioner
shall withdraw Rs.2,00,000/- and the remaining amount of
Rs.5,30,000/- shall be kept in fixed deposit in any nationalized bank
till she attains the majority.”
9.
Aggrieved by the said award, the claimants have preferred the present
appeal contending that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is grossly
inadequate. It is submitted that the Tribunal erred in awarding only a sum of
Rs.4,00,000/-
towards
permanent
disability
without
awarding
any
compensation under the head of loss of future earning capacity, despite the
permanent disability suffered by the injured.
(a) It is further contended that the Tribunal failed to award just and
reasonable compensation under various heads, including pain and suffering,
loss of amenities of life, medical expenses, conveyance charges, and extra
nourishment. It is also contended that the Tribunal ought to have awarded
compensation towards loss of marriage prospects, having regard to the
permanent facial disfigurement and loss of the right eye suffered by the
injured.
(b) The learned counsel further submits that the Tribunal erred in
awarding only Rs.2,00,000/- towards future replacement of the artificial eye.
According to the evidence of P.W.3, the artificial eye requires replacement
once every four years at an approximate cost of Rs.17,000/- on each
occasion, and the said amount awarded by the Tribunal is wholly insufficient
to meet the recurring future expenditure. On the above grounds, it is
contended that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is inadequate and
requires enhancement. Accordingly, the appellants pray that the appeal be
allowed by enhancing the compensation.
10.
During pendency of the appeal, appellants/claimants filed I.A.No.1 of
2022 for amendment of the claim petition by enhancing the claim amount from
Rs.12.00 lakhs to Rs.25.00 lakhs and the said Interlocutory Application is
allowed permitting the amendment sought for with regard to the claim amount
on payment of the requisite additional court fee.
11.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents has supported
the impugned award and prayed to dismiss the appeal.
12.
Now the point for consideration is:
Whether the award of the Tribunal warrants interference?
POINT:
13.
Since the petitioner was a minor aged about three years at the time of
the accident, she was represented by her father, who was examined as
P.W.1. He deposed that on 19.07.2015, while he was riding the motorcycle
bearing No. AP 07 BB 1945 and the petitioner was travelling as a pillion rider,
the driver of the offending auto-rickshaw bearing No. AP 07 TE 7152 drove
the vehicle in a rash and negligent manner and dashed against their
motorcycle. As a result, both of them fell on the road and the petitioner
sustained grievous injuries. She was immediately shifted to Government
General Hospital, Guntur. The accident was reported to Nallapadu Police
Station, where a case in Crime No.358 of 2015 was registered under Section
338 IPC against the driver of the offending vehicle.
14.
P.W.1 further deposed that, on account of the accident, the petitioner
suffered permanent facial disfigurement due to loss of her right eye, besides
sustaining a fracture of the left femur resulting in shortening of the left leg and
permanent disability. According to him, these injuries have adversely affected
her future life, education and marriage prospects. In support of his evidence,
Exs.A1 to A8 were marked. The Tribunal, relying upon the oral testimony of
P.W.1 and Ex.A2-charge sheet, which was filed after investigation against the
driver of the offending vehicle duly holding that respondent No.3 driver of the
auto was not having any valid driving license and answered issue No.1
holding that the petitioner has proved that the accident was caused by the
auto of respondent No.1 driven by respondent No.3 and fixed the liability on
respondent Nos.1 to 3. Accordingly, directed respondent No.2 – Insurance
Company to initially deposit the compensation amount and then recover the
same from respondent No.1 i.e. owner of the auto.
15.
The only question that arises for consideration in this appeal is whether
the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is just and reasonable.
16.
In support of the claim relating to the injuries and permanent disability,
the claimants examined P.W.2, the Orthopedic Surgeon in Lalitha Super
Specialty Hospital, Guntur. P.W.2 deposed that the petitioner was admitted to
the hospital on 22.07.2015 with a fracture of the left femur. She underwent
surgery on 29.07.2015, during which intramedullary nailing was performed.
She was discharged on 31.07.2015 with an advice to attend regular follow-up
treatment.
17.
P.W.2 further deposed that, on subsequent examination, the fracture
had united, though the implants were required to be removed. According to
him, the petitioner suffers from restriction of movements of the left hip and
knee joints, difficulty in squatting and sitting on the floor, and has sustained
25% permanent partial physical disability. Exs.X-11 and X-12 were marked
through him.
18.
The claimants also examined P.W.3, the Ophthalmologist from L.V.
Prasad Eye Institute. He deposed that the petitioner sustained a severe injury
to the right eye (corneoscleral tear) in the accident and was admitted on
20.07.2015. She underwent surgery on 21.07.2015 and was discharged on
22.07.2015. Subsequently, due to persistent pain and complete loss of vision,
the right eye had to be surgically removed on 04.01.2021, and an artificial eye
was implanted on 30.03.2021 and also deposed that the petitioner sustained
40% disability which is permanent in nature. He further stated that the artificial
eye requires replacement once in every four years at an approximate cost of
Rs.17,000/-. Exs.X-1 to X-10 were marked through him.
19.
Considering the above evidence coupled with Exs.A.3 to A.8, X.1 to
X.12, the Tribunal awarded the compensation under the following heads:
Sl.No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Head
Amount in Rs.
Pain and suffering
30,000-00
Loss of amenities and loss of enjoyment
50,000-00
of life
Medical expenses, conveyance and extra
50,000-00
nourishment
Damages for permanent disability
4,00,000-00
Loss of future medical expenses
2,00,000-00
Total
7,30,000-00
20.
Learned counsel for the appellants contended that the compensation
awarded by the Tribunal is wholly inadequate. It is submitted that the Tribunal
erred in awarding only a lump sum amount towards permanent disability
without determining the loss of future earning capacity by adopting the
multiplier method. It is further contended that the amounts awarded under the
heads of pain and suffering, future medical expenses, loss of amenities and
marriage prospects are grossly inadequate. In support of his submissions,
learned counsel placed reliance upon the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Kajal v. Jagdish Chand and others1, wherein compensation was
awarded by adopting the multiplier method in the case of a minor child who
suffered permanent disability.
21.
There is no dispute that the petitioner was only three years of age on
the date of the accident. Though she had no actual income, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court has consistently held that, in the case of a minor child
suffering permanent disability affecting future earning capacity, notional
income can be adopted for determining compensation by applying the
multiplier method. The accident occurred on 19.07.2015. The minimum wages
payable to an unskilled worker during the relevant period were approximately
Rs.204/- per day, which works out to Rs.6,120/- per month or Rs.73,440/- per
annum. After Applying the appropriate multiplier i.e. ‘18’ for the minor, as per
the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in “Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport
AIR 2020 Supreme Court 776
Corporation 2 ”, the loss of earnings would come to (Rs.73,440 x 18)
Rs.13,21,920/-. The evidence of P.W.2 establishes that the petitioner has 25%
permanent partial physical disability whereas the evidence of P.W.3
establishes that the petitioner suffered 40% permanent disability. Considering
the combined effect of the permanent loss of vision in right eye, the orthopedic
disability, and the impact on the petitioner's future earning capacity and quality
of life, this Court is of the view that the functional disability can reasonably be
assessed at 60%. Accordingly, the compensation towards loss of future
earning capacity is computed at Rs.7,93,152/- (Rs.13,21,920/- x 60%).
22.
The petitioner has permanently lost her right eye at a very young age,
resulting in permanent facial disfigurement. Such disability would undoubtedly
have a serious bearing on her future marriage prospects. Therefore, this Court
deems it appropriate to award Rs.3,00,000/- towards loss of marriage
prospects.
23.
The evidence of P.W.3 further establishes that the artificial eye requires
replacement every four years throughout the petitioner's lifetime. In view of the
recurring expenditure involved, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal
towards future medical expenses is inadequate. Accordingly, the same is
enhanced to Rs.5,00,000/-.
24.
The petitioner was only three years old when she sustained multiple
grievous injuries, including the permanent loss of her right eye and a fracture
2009 ACJ 1298
of the left femur requiring surgery. The pain, trauma and lifelong
consequences suffered by the petitioner cannot be adequately measured in
monetary terms. Having regard to the nature of injuries, repeated surgeries
and permanent disability, this Court considers it just and reasonable to award
Rs.5,00,000/- towards pain and suffering.
25.
Further, considering the permanent disability suffered by the petitioner
and the assistance that she would require during her recovery and in her dayto-day activities, this Court awards Rs.1,00,000/- towards attendant charges
etc.
26.
The compensation awarded by the Tribunal under different heads and
the amounts awarded by this Court, are as follows:
Sl.
No
.
Head of the claim
Compensation
awarded by
the Tribunal
in Rs. Ps.
Amounts now
awarded by
this Court
Rs. Ps.
Loss of future earning
capacity/permanent disability
Loss of amenities including
marriage prospects
Future medical expenses
Pain and suffering
Medical expenses,
conveyance and Attendant
charges etc.
Total
4,00,000-00
7,93,152-00
50,000-00
3,00,000-00
2,00,000-00
30,000-00
50,000-00
5,00,000-00
5,00,000-00
1,00,000-00
7,30,000-00
21,93,152-00
3.
4.
5.
27.
In the result, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is partly
allowed. The compensation awarded by the Tribunal is enhanced from
Rs.7,30,000/- (Rupees Seven Lakhs Thirty Thousand only) to Rs.21,93,152/(Rupees Twenty-One Lakhs Ninety-Three Thousand One Hundred and FiftyTwo only). The enhanced compensation shall carry interest at the rate of
7.5% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition till the date of
realization. Respondents 1 to 3 shall be jointly and severally liable to pay the
compensation. However, the 2nd respondent/Insurance Company shall deposit
the entire award amount, after deducting the amount, if any, already
deposited, together with accrued interest and proportionate costs, before the
Tribunal within two (2) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment. The 2nd respondent/Insurance Company shall thereafter be entitled
to recover the amount so deposited from the 1st respondent/owner of the
offending vehicle by initiating appropriate execution proceedings, without the
necessity of filing a separate suit. On such deposit, the Tribunal shall invest
such portion of the compensation as it deems appropriate in a Nationalized
Bank until the petitioner attains majority, permitting withdrawal of periodical
interest and such amount as may be required for her education, medical
treatment and welfare. There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
Date: 16.07.2026
KA
.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 492/2022
Date: 16.07.2026
KA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review