Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:23790
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.NAGARESH
WEDNESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 28TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 2559 OF 2024
PETITIONER:
DR. VISWANATH C. NARAYANAN
AGED 44 YEARS, S/O. C.K. NARAYANANAN,
CHUTHIPARAMBIL HOUSE, CORA 23, PRATHIBHA ROAD,
CHIYYARAM P.O., THRISSUR – 680026
WORKING AS PROFESSOR, DEPARTMENT OF MATHEMATICS,
GOVERNMENT ENGINEERING COLLEGE,
THRISSUR, PIN – 680009.
BY ADVS.
ELIZEBATH GEORGE
M.S.RADHAKRISHNAN NAIR
RAJU G.
RESPONDENTS:
UNIVERSITY OF CALICUT
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR, UNIVERSITY CAMPUS,
THENJIPPALAM, MALAPPURAM, PIN – 673635.
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:2:
2025:KER:23790
THE VICE CHANCELLOR
UNIVERSITY OF CALICUT, UNIVERSITY CAMPUS,
THENJIPPALAM, MALAPPURAM, PIN – 673635.
BY ADV.SRI. P.C. SASIDHARAN, STANDING COUNSEL
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 19.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:3:
2025:KER:23790
CR
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 19th day of March, 2025
The petitioner, who is now working as Professor in the
Department of Mathematics, Government Engineering College,
Thrissur, has filed this writ petition seeking to set aside Ext.P10
and to direct the respondents to consider the claim and
interview the petitioner on the basis of Ext.P2 application
submitted by the petitioner for the post of Professor in
Mathematics as per Clause 4.1 (III) A (ii) of UGC Regulations,
2018 and Ext.P1 notification, without delay.
2.
The petitioner states that the respondents have
invited application for selection and appointment to the post of
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:4:
2025:KER:23790
Professors in various Departments in the University as per
Ext.P1 notification. As the petitioner is qualified for the post of
Professor in Mathematics, the petitioner submitted Ext.P2
application.
3.
The petitioner learnt that the interview for the post of
Professor in Mathematics was held on 18.01.2022 and no
candidates are ranked. According to the petitioner, the petitioner
is fully qualified as per UGC Regulations, 2018 and as per
Ext.P1 notification. He is entitled to be called for the interview
and to get his candidature considered for appointment to the
post of Professor in Mathematics.
4.
The petitioner, therefore, submitted a representation
to the 2nd respondent. The petitioner filed W.P.(C) No.27065 of
2023. This Court directed the matter to be considered, as per
Ext.P9 judgment. The respondents, however, have rejected the
representation of the petitioner as per Ext.P10 order. In Ext.P10
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:5:
2025:KER:23790
order, the Deputy Registrar has stated that the petitioner's
application for appointment to the post of Professor in the
Department of Mathematics stands rejected for want of the
mandatory qualifications as stipulated by the UGC.
5.
Counsel for the petitioner relied on Ext.P1 notification
and stated that the petitioner has all the requisite qualifications
prescribed in Ext.P1. Ext.P1 states that a minimum of ten years
of teaching experience in University / College as Assistant
Professor / Associate Professor / Professor and / or research
experience at equivalent level at the University / National Level
Institutions with evidence of having successfully guided doctoral
candidate.
6.
Counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
petitioner has more than ten years teaching experience as is
evident from Ext.P2 and for persons having more than ten years
teaching experience, research experience equivalent level need
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:6:
2025:KER:23790
not be insisted. The words “and / or” contained in Clause
1 (A)(ii) is to be treated as “or” only and any other meaning will
defeat the very purpose of the rules and will create an awkward
situation.
7.
The eligibility conditions as prescribed in Ext.P1 is in
tune with Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers
and other Academic Staff in Universities and Colleges and
Measures for the Maintenance of Standards in Higher
Education Regulations, 2018 of the UGC. As the petitioner
satisfies the eligibility conditions and essential qualifications as
prescribed in Ext.P1, the petitioner's candidature is liable to be
considered for selection and appointment to the post of
Professor, urged the Counsel for the petitioner.
8.
Standing Counsel entered appearance on behalf of
the respondents and resisted the writ petition. On behalf of the
respondents, the Standing Counsel submitted that “evidence of
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:7:
2025:KER:23790
having successfully guided doctoral candidate” is one of the
mandatory qualifications for the post. The petitioner cannot be
considered to have required qualification as per notification as
there
is
no
evidence
of
successfully
guiding
doctoral
candidates. In the selection process, only one candidate was
found to have the requisite qualifications. That candidate was
interviewed by the Selection Committee. The single candidate
could not score the minimum marks required as per the
interview criteria. Therefore, the single candidate was not
ranked.
9.
On behalf of the respondents, it is submitted that the
words “and / or” in the Clause is not meant for research
experience only. A candidate should possess either teaching
experience of ten years or research experience of ten years at
an equivalent level or a total of ten years of experience in
teaching and research combined together. But, even though the
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:8:
2025:KER:23790
petitioner
is
having
research
experience
and
teaching
experience, still he should have the further qualification of
successfully guiding doctoral candidates.
10. I have heard the learned Counsel for the petitioner
and
the
learned
Standing
Counsel
representing
the
respondents.
11.
The petitioner responded to Ext.P1 notification and
applied for selection to the post of Professor in Mathematics.
Ext.P2 is the copy of application submitted by the petitioner.
Ext.P2 would indicate that the petitioner has three years and
zero months and 19 days of teaching experience in
Government Engineering College, Sreekrishnapuram and 12
years, 7 months and 16 days teaching experience in
Government Engineering College, Thrissur.
12. Ext.P1 notification gives essential qualifications for
candidates. The essential qualifications read as follows:-
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:9:
2025:KER:23790
Essential qualifications:
1) For the Disciplines of Arts, Commerce,
Humanities, Social Sciences, Sciences, Languages,
Library Science and Journalism & Mass
Communication.
Eligibility (A or B)
A.
i)
An eminent scholar having a Ph.D Degree in the
concerned/allied/relevant discipline and published work
of high quality, actively engaged in research with
evidence of published work with, a minimum of 10
research publications in the peer reviewed or UGC
listed journals and a total research score of 120 as per
the criteria given in Appendix II, Table 2 of UGC
Regulations, 2018.
ii) A minimum of ten years of teaching experience in
University/College as Assistant Professor/Associate
Professor/Professor and/or research experience at
equivalent level at the University/National Level
Institutions with evidence of having successfully guided
doctoral candidate.
OR
B.
An
outstanding
professional,
having
a
Ph.D.Degree in the relevant/allied/applied disciplines,
from any academic institutions (not included in A
above) / industry, who has made significant
contribution
to
the
knowledge
in
the
concerned/allied/relevant discipline, supported by
documentary evidence provided he/she has ten years'
experience. (emphasis supplied)
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:10:
2025:KER:23790
13. Ext.P11 is the UGC Regulations on Minimum
Qualification for Appointment of Teachers and other Academic
Staff in the Universities and Colleges and Measures for the
Maintenance
of
Standards
in
Higher
Education,
2018.
Regulation 4.1(III) of the Regulations, 2018 reads as follows:
III. Professor:
Eligibility (A or B):
A.
i)
An eminent scholar having a Ph.D.
Degree in the concerned/allied/relevant discipline,
and published work of high quality, actively engaged
in research with evidence of published work with, a
minimum of 10 research publications in the peerreviewed or UGC-listed journals and a total research
score of 120 as per the criteria given in Appendix II,
Table 2.
ii)
A minimum of ten years of teaching
experience in University/College as Assistant
Professor/Associate
Professor/Professor,
and/or
research experience at equivalent level at the
University/National Level Institutions with evidence of
having successfully guided doctoral candidate.
OR
B.
An outstanding professional, having a
Ph.D.Degree in the relevant/allied/applied disciplines,
from any academic institutions (not included in A
above) / industry, who has made significant
contribution
to
the
knowledge
in
the
concerned/allied/relevant discipline, supported by
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:11:
2025:KER:23790
documentary evidence provided he/she ten years'
experience.
14. Regulation 4.1 (III) would show that the University
has practically adopted the qualification prescribed by the UGC.
The contention of the petitioner is that a candidate need either a
minimum of ten years of teaching experience in University /
College as an Assistant Professor / Associate Professor /
Professor and / or research experience at equivalent level at
the University / National Level Institutions with evidence of
having successfully guided doctoral candidate.
15. According to the petitioner, the term “and / or”
appearing above, is evidently a mistake and the term should be
treated to mean as “or”, because any other meaning attributed
to the qualification part would result in an anomaly. In other
words, the argument of the petitioner is that if persons having
minimum ten years of teaching experience in University /
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:12:
2025:KER:23790
College as Assistant Professor / Associate Professor /
Professor, then such candidates are entitled to apply for the
post even if the candidates do not have research experience at
an equivalent level at the Universities / National Level
Institutions with evidence of having successfully guided doctoral
candidates.
16. Going through Exts.P1 and P11, I find that the
proposition advanced by the petitioner cannot be accepted. It is
for the reason that the rationale behind prescribing such
qualifications is that, the post being of a Professor in the
University, experience in research guidance cannot alone be
taken as a desirable qualification. Apart from teaching
experience, experience in guiding research scholars is
important in the matter of discharge the duties of a Professor. It
is for that reason that the UGC, as well as the respondents,
insisted that for appointment as a Professor, there should be
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:13:
2025:KER:23790
evidence of having successfully guided doctoral candidates.
17. It is further to be noted that the experience in
successfully
guiding
doctoral
candidates
is
a
distinct
requirement unconnected with the experience in teaching or
experience in research. Either way, whether a candidate is
experienced in teaching or whether a candidate is experienced
in research, such candidates should have a minimum
experience in guiding doctoral candidates, the post held being
that of a Professor.
18. In the circumstances, I find that the essential
qualifications for appointment to the post of Professor
prescribed in Exts.P1 and P11 should be taken as one insisting
for successfully guiding doctoral candidates, which is applicable
to both categories, namely, candidates having teaching
experience and candidates having research experience.
Admittedly, the petitioner does not have evidence of having
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:14:
2025:KER:23790
successfully
guiding
doctoral
candidates.
Therefore,
the
respondents were justified in not considering the candidature of
the petitioner.
The writ petition fails and it is therefore dismissed.
Sd/N. NAGARESH
JUDGE
ams
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:15:
2025:KER:23790
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 2559/2024
PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE DETAILED NOTIFICATION
INVITING APPLICATION TO APPOINTMENTS TO
PERMANENT POST OF PROFESSORS DATED
31/12/2019
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THAT APPLICATION SUBMITTED
BY THE PETITIONER
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THAT RANK LIST TO THE POST
OF ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR/PROFESSORS IN
VARIOUS TEACHING DEPARTMENTS IN THE
UNIVERSITY OF CALICUT DATED 15-03-22
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION UNDER RTI
ACT SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER DATED
23-06-23
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY NO. 152616/ADREC-ASST-2/2021/ADMN
GIVEN
BY
THE
PUBLIC
INFORMATION
OFFICER
TO
THE
APPLICATION
SUBMITTED
BY
PETITIONER
UNDER RTI ACT DATED 30-06-23
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE APPEAL SUBMITTED BY
THE PETITIONER AGAINST EXT.P5 REPLY
DATED 11-07-23
Exhibit P7
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
RS/1029/2023/28 REJECTING
DATED 07-08-23
ORDER
NO.
THE APPEAL
W.P.(C)No.2559 of 2024
:16:
2025:KER:23790
Exhibit P8
TRUE
COPY
OF
SUBMITTED BEFORE
DATED NIL
THE
REPRESENTATION
THE VICE CHANCELLOR
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN W.P.(C)
NO. 27065/2023 OF THIS HONOURABLE COURT
DATED 10.10.2023
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THAT ORDER NO. 152616/ADREC-ASST-2/2021/ADMN. DATED 22.12.2023
EXHIBIT P11
TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF UGC
REGULATION
PUBLISHED
BY
UNIVERSITY
GRANTS COMMISSION DATED 18.7.2018
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT R1(a)
A TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION DATED
SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review