Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED: 6th March, 2018
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Petitioner
:
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth,
Associate Professor,
Department of History,
Sikkim University,
Tadong,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
: 1.
Sikkim University,
Represented through its Registrar,
Sikkim University
Tadong,
East Sikkim.
2.
The Vice Chancellor,
Sikkim University
Tadong,
East Sikkim.
3.
The University Grants Commission (UGC)
Represented through its Secretary,
Ministry of Human Resource Development ,
New Delhi.
Application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth, Petitioner in person.
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia and Mr. Umesh Gurung, Advocates for the
Respondents No. 1 and 2.
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Advocate for the Respondent No.3.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The grievance of the Petitioner pivots around the legality
of his non-promotion under the Career Advancement Scheme
(hereinafter „CAS‟), from Stage 4 to Stage 5, viz. from Associate
Professor to Professor, despite fulfilment of eligibility criteria in
terms of the University Grants Commission Regulations, 2010 (for
short „UGC Regulations, 2010‟) . The reliefs sought for by the
Petitioner, inter alia, are a direction to the Respondents No. 1 and 2
to complete the process of his promotion from Stage 4 to Stage 5 as
per the UGC Regulations, 2010. To issue a Writ in the nature of
Mandamus directing the Respondents No.1 and 2 to consider his
Application for promotion under the 3rd amendment (of 4th May,
2016) of the UGC Regulations, 2010 and not under the 4th
Amendment (of 11th July, 2016) thereof.
2.
The facts summarised are that the Petitioner joined the
Sikkim University, Gangtok, as an Associate Professor in the
Department of Journalism and Mass Communication in 9.3.2012 and
continued in service as an Associate Professor, Department of
History from 1.7.2013, as per Orders of the Respondents No. 1 and
2. On completion of three years as an Associate Professor in Stage 4
on 30.6.2016, he accrued the requisite credit points as per the
Academic Performance Indicator (for short „API‟) based Performance
Based Appraisal System (for short „PBAS‟) methodology, provided in
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
Table I-III, Appendix-IV of the UGC Regulations, 2010 and was thus
eligible for appointment and designation as Professor from 1.7.2016.
Consequently, he submitted his Application in terms of the 3rd
amendment to the UGC Regulations, 2010, on 17.6.2016, in the
prescribed format, for promotion under CAS from Stage 4 to Stage
5, along with evidence of API score. In response, he received a
letter from the Respondents No. 1 and 2, dated 27.2.2017
requesting him to resubmit the application as the earlier Application
could not be located. In compliance thereof, he resubmitted his
Application on 1.3.2017 along with all necessary documents, duly
received by the Respondents No.1 and 2. Pursuant thereto, he
received
an
e-mail
on
18.5.2017
from
the
Internal
Quality
Assurance Cell (for short „IQAC‟) of the University, requesting
submission of his application as per the format of UGC Regulations
4th Amendment and that his API Application would be computed
accordingly. The Petitioner on 19.5.2017 responded that the request
was fallacious as his date of eligibility (1.7.2016) preceded the
enforcement of the 4th amendment (effective from 11.7.2016), apart
from remonstrating that the e-mail was not from the appropriate
authority which ought to be the Expert Committee. On 10.7.2017,
an e-mail was received by him from the Respondent No.1 stating
that he had qualified on all other points/requirements but required
him to submit proof of Ph.D. awarded under his supervision to
enable completion of interviews by early August, 2017. The
Petitioner protested this as there was no stipulation in the UGC
Regulations, 2010 of such a requirement and reminded the
Respondent No.1 of the position taken by them in this regard in
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
another matter vide a communication (Annexure P-13) sent to the
Central Bureau of Investigation in April/May 2016, stating inter alia,
that according to the UGC Regulations, 2010, the experience of
guiding research at doctoral level is not required even for the post of
Professor under CAS, leave alone for the post of Associate Professor,
hence, arbitrary inclusion of a new criterion is improper. On
17.7.2017, he followed this up with another representation to the
Respondent No.1 reiterating that the UGC Regulations of 2010 do
not insist on a Ph.D. awarded under supervision of the person
seeking promotion under CAS. Meanwhile, he learnt that meetings
of various Selection Committees were held at New Delhi, from
31.7.2017, and in the week following thereto applications submitted
much after the Petitioner‟s Application, in some other departments,
were considered by the Selection Committee, duly constituted for
promotion under CAS, while his case was excluded, thereby
violating the provisions of Article 14 and 15 of the Constitution.
That, due to non-consideration of his case for more than eighteen
months, he is deprived of appointments to various statutory bodies,
membership to which are based on ex-cadre seniority. That,
insertion of the additional qualification by the Respondents No.1 and
2 is arbitrary and mala fide, violating the Petitioner‟s rights
guaranteed under Article 14 and 15 of the Constitution of India,
hence the aforesaid prayers.
3.
The Respondents No.1 and 2 filed a joint Counter-
Affidavit disputing the averments of the Petitioner, contending that
although the Petitioner seeks parity with other Associate Professors
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
who have been promoted under CAS, he has failed to implead them
as parties to the Petition, which thus suffers from non-joinder of
parties and merits dismissal. That, the Petitioner has not challenged
the Statutory Authority of the Autonomous Sikkim University with
regard to Rule making Powers. Exercising this power under Section
12(2) of the Sikkim University Act, 2006, the norm (at Annexure-I)
requiring guidance to research scholars at the Doctoral level for
promotion from Stage 4 to Stage 5, over and above UGC standards
was included in order to maintain the quality of higher education
which cannot be assailed. Besides, mere completion of three years
as an Associate Professor does not per se entitle the Petitioner to
promotion but merely places him in the zone of consideration. That,
contrary to the averment of the Petitioner, no application of eligible
candidates have been kept beyond the time limit of six months
prescribed in the UGC Regulations, 2010. That, it was in good faith
and to enable the Petitioner to avail the benefit of the 4th
amendment to the Regulations, which relaxed the API calculations
and expanded the UGC approved journals, that he was directed to
resubmit his application on parity with other candidates. However,
he failed to submit proof of having supervised award of Ph.D. course
of any such scholar as per the required norms. That, no fault can be
attributed to issuance of letter by the IQAC, in terms of the
instructions
of
the
answering
Respondents.
That,
in
fact,
departmental inquiry against the Petitioner is being contemplated
for utilising confidential documents, being document Annexure P-13,
to fortify his case, apart from which the appointment referred to in
the correspondence pertained to 2012 and 2013, prior to adoption
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
of the new norm in 2015 and is of no avail to the Petitioner. That, a
Selection Committee constituted in anticipation of the Petitioner‟s
fulfilment of the University norms of 2015, had to be cancelled on
the Petitioner‟s failure to produce the requisite proof as elucidated
above. No question of discrimination arises as the other six
candidates were promoted on the same norm and the Petitioner
despite awareness of the norm has approached this Court. It is
prayed that the Petition be dismissed with costs.
4.
The Respondent No. 3 in its Affidavit highlighted its
functions and duties and while drawing attention to the provisions of
the second amendment dated 13.6.2013 in the “University Grants
Commission (Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers
and other Academic Staff in Universities and Colleges and other
Measures for the Maintenance of Standards in Higher Education)
(2nd Amendment) Regulations, 2013” averred that in Clause 6.0.2
thereto, it has been laid down that the Universities can if they so
desire, increase the minimum required score or devise appropriate
additional criteria for screening of candidates at any level of
recruitment. Further, that vide a Public Notice dated 21.11.2014, it
was clarified that promotion under CAS would be covered by the
UGC Regulations which were in operation on the date of eligibility
and not on the date of interview.
5.
In his Rejoinder, the Petitioner avers that he has not
sought parity with other Associate Professors, his only plea being
that the UGC Regulations, 2010 in general and Clause 6.3.1 and
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
Clause 6.4.8 in particular be complied with. That, the provisions for
promotion under CAS entails re-designation of posts involving no
contest thereby requiring no impleadment of similarly placed
persons in this Petition. That, the amendment to Clause 6.0.2 is
applicable to direct recruitment and not for promotion under CAS.
The amendment empowers the University to prescribe criteria, not
higher or additional qualifications, while the power of Respondent
No.2 is restricted to giving effect to decisions of the authorities and
not to formulate policies. That, Annexure-I of the documents of the
Respondents No. 1 and 2, prescribing the additional norm is devoid
of any details apart from which the letter head created in August
2016 bears reference to a decision of August 2015, raising doubts
about its authenticity. It was further pointed out that later in time,
on 7.3.2017 (Annexure P-16), the Respondent No. 2 issued Circular
inviting applications for promotion under CAS to all candidates who
fulfil the eligibility criteria, service requirements and other conditions
as laid down by the UGC, however no reference was made to any
additional qualification as laid down in Annexure-I. With regard to
Departmental Action contemplated against him, it is contended that
Annexure P-13 (letter to the CBI) was handed over to him by the
Office of the Respondent No.1 on the eve of his departure to
Kolkata, to present himself before the S.P., CBI in early June, 2016.
He denies knowledge of the rejection of his Application and
reiterates
that
the
Respondents
representations and remained silent.
chose
not
to
reply
to
his
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
6.
By filing I.A. No. 1 of 2018, the Respondents No.1 and 2
sought to bring to the notice of this Court that the Petitioner vide his
letter dated 20.11.2017 addressed to the Respondents No.1 and 2,
informed them that he intended to join the SRM University,
Amravati, Andhra Pradesh, as Chair and Professor in the School of
Liberal Arts and Basic Sciences on lien, before 1.3.2018 and sought
to be relieved by 25.2.2018.
Respondent
University
The Executive Council of the
approved
his
request
effective
from
23.2.2018. That, the Petitioner has thereby sought to retain his
position as “Associate Professor” on lien, in which circumstance, the
instant Petition becomes infructuous and the issues related therein
become academic as he will be working in another University in the
lien period. Refuting this contention, the Petitioner argues that the
retention of his position in the University as Associate Professor on
lien for a period of two years while he joins SRM University,
Amravati, Andhra Pradesh, does not tantamount to waiving his
rights or his prayers made before this Court and hence, the Petition
deserves no consideration.
7.
Opening his arguments, while reiterating the points
made in his averments, the Petitioner urged that despite having
fulfilled the requisite qualifications for promotion, yet the promotion
has been denied to him. Drawing attention to the UGC Regulations,
2010, specifically Clause 6.4.8, it is contended that the criteria
stipulated therein is to be achieved and duly assessed by a Selection
Committee, the Regulation makes no provision for any additional
qualification. Attention was also invited to the Sikkim University First
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
Ordinances 2016, OB-4 which at Clause 4, provides that qualification
and requirements for promotion under CAS shall be as per the
Regulations adopted by the University from time to time and no
other stipulation exists. While accepting that the University is an
autonomous organisation, it is contended that exercise of its powers
ought to be within the parameters of justice and equity and they are
not empowered to insert a fresh qualification over and above the
ones stipulated by the University Grants Commission (hereinafter
“UGC”). Contrary to this, Annexure-I of the documents of the
Respondents No.1 and 2, demands an additional qualification for
promotion under CAS but is an unknown document bereft of official
reference number, File number, process and date of decision or the
date of issuance neither was it circulated amongst faculty nor
notified. This document, the Petitioner would urge, has only been
manufactured for the purposes of the instant matter as apparent
from the fact that the letter head on which it is issued was in fact
adopted in August 2016 but contains details of adoption of higher
qualifications since 2015. That, he has no contest with the other
candidates already promoted, there being no specific vacancies to
the posts of Professors the only requirement being eligibility as per
the UGC Regulations, 2010, which they fulfilled and in any event he
does
not
seek
inter-se
seniority
vis-à-vis
the
six
promoted
candidates. That, the Respondents No. 1 and 2 misplaced his first
Application and asked him to resubmit, to comply with the time limit
of six months. That, ICAQ was in error in requiring him to resubmit
his application under the 4th amendment since the amendment has
no retrospective effect. That, the Respondents No.1 and 2, by
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
procrastinating their decision on his Application for more than 18
months has prejudiced him, hence there should be a time frame
ordered for disposal of his matter.
8.
Resisting the contentions of the Petitioner, learned
Counsel Dr. Doma T. Bhutia for the Respondents No.1 and 2,
contended
that
the
amended
Clause
6.0.2
of
the
Principal
Regulations permits the Universities to increase the minimum
required score or devise appropriate additional criteria for screening
of candidates at any level of recruitment. The Respondent No.1 thus
inserted a norm according to which an Associate Professor shall be
considered for promotion to the post of Professor only after
acquiring the experience of guiding research at the doctoral level, in
addition to the UGC norms under Section 26(1) of the UGC Act,
1956. Annexure I was issued thereby to inform all concerned. While
admitting that there was no date, File notings, administrative
process or documents to establish addition of the new criteria, it was
pointed
out
that
the
Sikkim
University
“PBAS
proforma
for
promotion under CAS form” at Number III D.1, enumerates that the
applicant has to submit details of “Ph.D. awarded/submitted”. This
detail suffices to establish that candidates who apply for promotion
ought to have guided a research scholar who was then awarded a
doctorate. That, the Petition suffers from non-joinder of necessary
parties in the absence of the other six selected candidates and the
Screening Committee, the Petition thus, ought to be rejected. That,
although the Petitioner claims to have submitted his Application for
promotion on 17.6.2016, however, no such application was in fact
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
received by them and hence, the subsequent application submitted
by him on 1.3.2017 has been considered well within the period of
six months. In any event no application is ever kept pending with
the concerned authorities for more than a period of six months. The
averment pertaining to lien was reiterated in her arguments. To
buttress her submissions, she has placed reliance on The Chancellor
and Anr. v. Dr. Bijayananda Kar and Ors and Dr. Prafulla Kumar
Mohapatra v. Dr. Bijayananda Kar and Ors.1 and Maharashtra State Board
of Secondary and Higher Secondary Education and Anr. v. Paritosh
Bhupeshkumar Sheth and Ors. And Alpana V. Mehta v. Maharashtra State
Board of Secondary Education and Anr. .
9.
called
Learned Counsel for the Respondent No.3, for his part
attention
to
Annexure
R-3,
the
Public
Notice
dated
21st November, 2014 and also to the provisions of the second
amendment dated 13.6.2013 to the UGC Regulations, specifically
Clause 6.0.2, besides reiterating his averments.
10.
The opposing arguments of the Petitioner appearing for
himself, learned Counsel for the Respondents No. 1 and 2 and
learned Counsel for the Respondent No.3 were heard at length.
Their submissions have been given careful consideration and their
pleadings and documents meticulously perused, as also the citations
made at the Bar.
(1994) 1 SCC 169
(1984) 4 SCC 27
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
11.
What falls for consideration before this Court is;
1.
Whether the Petition suffers from non-joinder of
necessary parties making it liable for dismissal?
2.
Whether
the
Respondents No. 1
and 2
are
competent to prescribe any new criterion or
qualification in addition to the criteria enumerated
in Clause 6.4.8 of the UGC Regulations, 2010 for
promotion from Stage 4 to Stage 5 under the CAS,
i.e. promotion from Associate Professor to the post
of Professor?
3.
Whether the Petitioner is entitled to consideration
for promotion from the Stage 4 to Stage 5 under
CAS, having fulfilled the necessary criteria as laid
down in Clause 6.4.8 of the UGC Regulations,
2010 and whether the 4th amendment to the
Regulations is applicable to his case?
4.
Whether
relieving
the
posting
on
as
lien,
Petitioner
per
his
for
another
request,
would
tantamount to waiving his rights to promotion?
12.
To address the first question, the Respondents No. 1
and 2 have failed to enlighten this Court as to how the Petitioner‟s
case for promotion would affect the other candidates who have
already been selected. It is not the Respondents‟ case that
promotions are confined to specific number of seats or vacancies nor
is there any proof of benefits that accrue to the six promotees on
account of their promotion. The Petitioner in his averments and
arguments has clarified that he does not seek to claim any inter-se
seniority or benefits that may accrue to him on account of such
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
inter-se seniority neither does he claim any reliefs against the
aforesaid six candidates or against the Selection Committee. In the
aforesaid facts and circumstances, when no reliefs are sought from
the other six promoted candidates or the Selection Committee, I am
of the considered opinion that the Petition does not suffer from nonjoinder of necessary parties. The issue of non-joinder of parties to
my mind, is a red herring introduced by the Respondents No.1 and
2, to digress from the main issue of promotion.
13.
While considering the second question, it is not disputed
that the Respondent No.2 is an Autonomous University and a
Statutory Authority neither have its rule making powers been
assailed. The apple of discord is whether an additional qualification
can
be
inserted
by
the
University,
to
the
UGC
prescribed
qualifications, in view of the fact that the University has in “The
Sikkim University First Ordinances, 2016” at OB-4 on Career
Advancement Scheme of the Sikkim University Act, 2006, at Clause
4 adopted the UGC Regulations. The said Clause reads as follows;
“4.
Qualification and requirements for promotion
under CAS shall be as per the UGC Regulations
adopted by the University from time to time.”
A reading of the provision impresses that the promotion under
CAS would be as per the UGC Regulations. It is not in dispute that
the University has adopted the UGC Regulations from time to time
and is thereby bound by it. That having been said, to understand
the matter in its correct perspective, it would be expedient now to
peruse the “University Grants Commission (Minimum Qualifications
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
for
Appointment
of
Teachers
and
other
Academic
Staff
in
Universities and Colleges and other Measures for the Maintenance of
Standards in Higher Education) (2nd Amendment) Regulations,
2013”, dated 13.6.2013, more pertinently Clause 6.0.2, which lays
down as follows;
“...................................................................
1.
Short
title,
commencement:
application
and
1.1 These Regulations may be called
University
Grants
Commission
(Minimum
Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers and other
Academic Staff in Universities and Colleges and other
Measures for the Maintenance of Standards in Higher
Education) (2nd Amendment) Regulations, 2013.
1.2 ......................................
2.
..........................................
3.
The clause 6.0.2 of the Principal Regulations
shall stand amended and be substituted by the
following clause:“6.0.2 The Universities shall adopt these Regulations
for selection committees and selection procedures
through
their
respective
statutory
bodies
incorporating the Academic Performance Indicator
(API) based Performance Based Appraisal System
(PBAS) at the institutional level for University
Departments and their Constituent colleges/affiliated
colleges (Government / Government aided /
Autonomous/Private
colleges)
to
be
followed
transparently in all the selection processes. An
indicative PBAS template proforma for direct
recruitment and for Career Advancement Schemes
(CAS) based on API based PBAS is annexed in
Appendix III. The Universities may adopt the
template proforma or may devise their own selfassessment cum performance appraisal forms for
teachers. While adopting this, universities shall not
change any of the categories or scores of the API
given in Appendix-III. The universities can, if they
wish so, increase the minimum required score or
devise appropriate additional criteria for screening of
candidates at any level of recruitment.
........................................................................”
[emphasis supplied]
14.
This
amendment
lays
down
with
clarity
that
the
Universities are empowered to devise appropriate additional criteria
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
for screening of candidates at any level of recruitment with the
mandate that the API scores given in Appendix-III shall not be
changed. I have to disagree with the arguments advanced by the
Petitioner that any additional criteria as contemplated in Clause
6.0.2, would be applicable only at the time of recruitment and not
for promotion. Firstly, let me clear the air on what recruitment
entails. In this context, useful reference may be made to the
decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in K. Narayanan and Others v.
State of Karnataka and Others , wherein at Paragraph 6 it was, inter
alia, held as follows;
“6. .................................‟Recruitment‟ according to
the dictionary means „enlist‟. It is a comprehensive
term and includes any method provided for inducting
a person in public service. Appointment, selection,
promotion, deputation are all well-known methods of
recruitment. Even appointment by transfer is not
unknown. .........................................................”
The ratiocination in no uncertain terms elucidates that
“recruitment” brings under its ambit “promotion” as laid down
supra. On the anvil of this interpretation, it is clear that the
amended Clause 6.0.2 of the UGC Regulations would apply even to
promotions under the CAS and not merely to initial recruitments.
Besides, the provision is to be read conjointly and not disjunctively
in order to cull out the spirit of the clause. No further discussions
need ensue on this point the argument of the Petitioner on this
count having been thus addressed. Linked to this discussion would
be the meaning of the words “Qualification” and “Criteria”, which
according to the Petitioner entail different connotations and that
“criteria” does not extend to insertion of an additional “qualification”
1994 Supp (1) SCC 44
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
as wrongly interpreted by the Respondents No. 1 and 2, while
adding the requirement of guiding scholars at the doctoral level.
According to Black‟s Law Dictionary, 10th Edition, Year 2014, the
meaning of the words “Qualification” and “Criteria” are as follows;
Qualification :-
Criterion
„The possession of qualities or properties (such
as fitness or capacity) inherently or legally
necessary to make one eligible for a position or
office, or to perform a public duty or function.‟
:- „A standard, rule or test on which a judgment or
decision can be based or compared; a reference
point against which other things can be
evaluated a characterizing mark or trait.”
In my considered opinion, there cannot be too much hair
splitting on the meanings, the prior one requiring possession of
certain qualities, while the latter refers to a reference point to
evaluate things. Qualification would be the educational qualification,
while criteria would be a yardstick required by the Respondents No.
1 and 2, for evaluation of its candidates through constituted
Committees. On a careful consideration of the facts before me,
inserting a requirement of guiding research at the doctoral level is
surely a criterion and not additional qualification. What emanates
from the provisions of Clause 6.0.2 is the undisputed conclusion that
the Respondent No.1 is clothed with powers to prescribe additional
criteria apart from those set out in Clause 6.4.8 for screening of
candidates at any level of recruitment which includes promotion.
15.
It would now be relevant to look at the provisions of
Section 12(2) of the Sikkim University Act, 2006 (hereinafter „the
Act‟). Section 12 of the Act, reads as follows;
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
“12.
(1)
The Vice-Chancellor shall be appointed by the
Visitor in such manner as may be prescribed by the
Statues.
(2)
The Vice-Chancellor shall be the principal
executive and academic officer of the University and
shall exercise general supervision and control over
the affairs of the University and give effect to the
decisions of all the authorities of the University.
(3)
The Vice-Chancellor may, if he is of the
opinion that immediate action is necessary on any
matter, exercise any power conferred on any
authority of the University by or under this Act and
shall report to such authority at its next meeting the
action taken by him on such matter:
Provided that if the authority concerned is of the
opinion that such action ought not to have been
taken, it may refer the matter to the Visitor whose
decision thereon shall be final:
Provided further that any person in the service of the
University who is aggrieved by the action taken by
the Vice-Chancellor under this sub-section shall have
the right to represent against such action to the
Executive. Council within three months from the date
on which decision on such action is communicated to
him and thereupon the Executive Council may
confirm, modify or reverse the action taken by the
Vice Chancellor.
(4)
The Vice-Chancellor, if he is of the opinion that
any decision of any authority of the University is
beyond the powers of the authority conferred by the
provisions of this Act, the Statutes or the Ordinances
or that any decision taken is not in the interest of the
University, may ask the authority concerned to
review its decision within sixty days of such decision
and if the authority refuses to review the decision
either in whole or in part or no decision is taken by it
within the said period of sixty days, the matter shall
be referred to the Visitor whose decision thereon shall
be final.
(5)
The Vice-Chancellor shall exercise such other
powers and perform such other duties as may be
prescribed by the Statutes or the Ordinances.”
16.
The provisions of Section 23 (1) of the Act may
simultaneously be perused, which provides as follows;
“23. (1) The Academic Council shall be the principal
academic body of the University and shall, subject to
the provisions of this Act, the Statutes and the
Ordinances, co-ordinate and exercise general
supervision over the academic policies of the
University.”
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
What can be culled out from the above is that the ViceChancellor being the Principal Executive and Academic Officer of the
University exercises general supervision and control over the affairs
of the University and gives effect to the decisions of the authorities.
The
Academic
Council
co-ordinates
and
exercises
general
supervision over the Academic Policies. What is rather nebulous is
as to who lays down the standards or criteria, such as the one
inserted in Annexure-I (Page 143 of the Paper-Book) as the
Academic Council presumably exercises only supervisory powers
over
the
Academic
Policies
and
the
Respondent
No.2
while
exercising general supervision over the affairs of the University is
vested with the responsibility of giving effect to the decisions of the
authorities. Nothing further is elucidated therein.
17.
That having been said, we may now turn to Annexure-I
at Page 143 of the Paper-Book, which has been called in question by
the Petitioner, as a manufactured document. This is a document
purported
to
be
“Statement
about
Sikkim
University
Norm
for
Professorship under CAS” vide which an additional criterion for
promotion has been inserted and is reproduced below for clarity;
“......................................................................
Statement about Sikkim
Professorship under CAS
University
norm
for
This is to state that Vice-chancellor of Sikkim
University, for the sake of quality of higher education,
has since 2015, established a norm according to
which an Associate Professor shall be considered for
promotion to the post of Professor under Career
Advancement Schemes only after acquiring the
experience of guiding research at doctoral level, in
addition to the norms established by the University
Grants Commission under Section 26(1) of the UGC
Act, 1956.
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
The Vice-chancellor has established the above under
Section 12(2) of the Sikkim University Act, 2006 (No.
10 of 2007).
Sd/(T.K. Kaul)
Registrar”
Before proceeding further, it may be stated that “Norm”
18.
as per the Oxford Dictionary, 12th Edition, 2011, reprinted in 2013, inter
alia, explains it as;
“A usual, typical or standard thing. A required or
acceptable standard.”
For
the
present
purposes,
it
may
be
accepted
as
a
requirement of having guided a scholar at the doctoral level. „Guided
a scholar at the doctoral level‟ is accepted by the contesting parties
as a term for award of doctorate to the scholar supervised by the
candidate seeking promotion.
19.
Reverting to Section 12(2) of the Act, this provision
empowers the Respondent No.2, inter alia, to give effect to the
decisions of all the authorities of the University which obviously
includes that of the Academic Council. The document (Annexure-I)
extracted above details that it is the Respondent No. 2 who has
“established” the norm of acquiring the experience of guiding
research at doctoral level for promotion of an Associate Professor
under Section 12(2) of the Act. However, Section 12(2) of the Act
empowers the Respondent No.2 to give effect to the decisions of the
authorities but does not spell out that he is empowered to make
unilateral decisions as the one above. Section 12(3) of the Act, inter
alia, clarifies that, if there is urgency in a matter, the Respondent
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
No.2 can exercise any power conferred on any authority of the
University by or under the Act, with the rider that such steps shall
be reported to the concerned authority at its next meeting. This
provision makes the Respondent No.2 accountable for his actions.
The records furnished by the Respondents No.1 and 2, indicate no
meeting of the Academic Council at any point of time or decision
taken thereof to include the above criterion. If it is assumed that the
Respondent No.2 had taken the decision treating the matter as
urgent, then as per Section 12(3) of the Act, he is required to bring
the steps taken by him to the notice of the concerned authority. No
documents in this regard bear witness to such proceedings. It goes
without saying that laying down a fresh criterion for promotion
ought to be accorded the seriousness that such matters deserve by
ensuring compliance of required formalities such as a meeting of the
concerned authorities and information of the addition by way of
notification. None of these formalities appear to have been observed
by the Respondents No.1 and 2, which can be concluded from the
absence of documents before this Court to buttress their case. Thus,
it stands to reason that sans compliance of the provisions of the Act,
the additional criterion is non est in the eyes of law.
20.
The argument of the Petitioner that Annexure-I is a
subsequently prepared letter head i.e. after August 2016, stands to
reason in as much as the letter head appearing at Annexure P-13,
which is a letter dated 24.5.2016, addressed to the Superintendent
of Police, CBI, Government of India, is different. Annexure P-13
having been issued in May 2016 ought to have been in the same
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
letter head as Annexure-I, which contains a decision purportedly
adopted in 2015. The difference in letter heads lends credence to
the argument of the Petitioner that it was prepared for the purposes
of this Case. The document sans date or details indeed appears to
have been put together rather hastily.
21.
The preparation and issuance of Annexure-I is shrouded
in mystery. Would it therefore be fair on the aspiring candidates if
the Respondents No.1 and 2 chose to keep the criterion closeted? It
is axiomatic that ignorance of any provision would lead to the
inability of the candidate to refer to it or take advantage of the
provisions. Annexure-I having not been notified or circulated and
evidently known only to the Respondents No. 1 and 2, the additional
criterion fails to hold any value. Besides, the assertion that the other
six promoted candidates were subjected to the same criterion
remains unfortified in the absence of documents furnished for
scrutiny by this Court.
22.
The above discussions would necessarily take us to the
next question flagged. The criteria enumerated in Clause 6.4.8 of
the UGC Regulations, 2010 for promotion from Stage 4 to Stage 5,
reads as follows;
“6.4.8.
Associate Professor completing three years of service
in stage 4 and possessing a Ph.D. Degree in the
relevant discipline shall be eligible to be appointed
and designated as Professor and be placed in the next
higher grade (stage 5), subject to (a) satisfying the
required credit points as per API based PBAS
methodology provided in Table I-III of Appendix IV
stipulated in these Regulations, and (b) an
assessment by a duly constituted selection committee
as suggested for the direct recruitment of Professor.
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
Provided that no teacher, other than those with a
Ph.D., shall be promoted or appointed as Professor.”
23.
Clause 6.3.1 relied on by the Petitioner reads as follows;
“6.3.1
24.
A teacher who wishes to be considered for promotion
under CAS may submit in writing to the
university/college, with three months in advance of
the due date, that he/she fulfils all qualifications
under CAS and submit to the university/college the
Performance Based Appraisal System proforma as
evolved by the concerned university duly supported
by all credentials as per the API guidelines set out in
these Regulations. In order to avoid delays in holding
Selection Committee meetings in various positions
under CAS, the University/College should immediately
initiate the process of screening/selection, and shall
complete the process within six months from the date
of application. Further, in order to avoid any
hardships, candidates who fulfill all other criteria
mentioned in these Regulations, as on 31 December,
2008 and till the date on which this Regulation is
notified, can be considered for promotion from the
date, on or after 31 December, 2008, on which they
fulfil these eligibility conditions, provided as
mentioned above.”
It would be necessary to first consider the arguments of
learned Counsel for the Respondents No.1 and 2, that the
Application dated 17.6.2016 was never received by them. The
Petitioner for his part had drawn the attention of this Court to
Annexure P-1 at Page 30 of the Petition, wherein his Application for
promotion under CAS from Stage 4 to Stage 5 has been endorsed as
“received” and signature follows therein, although the signature
remained
unidentified.
Later
in
time,
Annexure
P-5,
dated
27.2.2017, addressed to the Petitioner by the Assistant Registrar
reads as follows;
“.........................................................................
SU/2014/REG-03/CAS/2885/1756
To,
Dr. V. Krishna Ananth,
Associate Professor,
Department of History,
Sikkim University.
Date: 27.02.2017
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
Sub.: Application
Regarding.
for
promotion
under
CAS
–
Dear Sir,
With reference to your application for promotion
under CAS, we have not been able to locate your
application form. Hence, I am directed to request to
kindly re-submit your application. Any inconvenience
is regretted.
Yours sincerely,
Sd/(Grace D. Chankapa)
Assistant Registrar
Copy to:
1. P.S. to VC for kind information of the ViceChancellor”
The very language employed in the correspondence indicates
that the Petitioner had indeed submitted his application previously
which apparently has been misplaced by the Respondent No.1 and
hence, the request to “re-submit the application”. The request for
resubmission is evidently to ensure compliance of the time frame of
six months mandated in Clause 6.3.1 for disposal of such petitions.
25.
Clause 6.4.8 (supra) is self explanatory laying down the
requisite qualifications for promotion. A perusal of Annexure P-1 of
the Petitioner‟s document at Page 47 of the Petition, being
„Summary of Category I and II‟, would reveal that the scores
obtained by him undisputedly are over and above the requisite
scores. The „Summary of Category III‟ would also indicate that the
requisite qualifications for making him eligible for promotion from
Stage 4 to Stage 5 have been fulfilled. Annexure P-1 reveals that in
Category I, his score is 286.8 whereas the requirement is of 70 per
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
annum. In Category II, his score is 95 as against the requirement of
50. In Category III, the scores of the Petitioner at 182.50 is above
the requisite of one hundred. In all, the total requirement is 250,
however, simple calculations would reveal that his scores are well
above the requirement. Annexure P-1 would also reveal the list of
his
publications
and
research
publications.
Annexure
P-10
(documents of the Petitioner), is an e-mail addressed to the
Petitioner and one Dr. Satyanarayana dated July 10, 2017 of which
the contents, inter alia, are as herein below;
“........................................................................
Your application for CAS has been scrutinised by the
committee. Whereas you qualify for all other points
but it is reported that there is no documentary proof
attached with the application establishing the fact of
supervising award of PhD. PhD award notification
bearing the name of the supervisor may have been
issued by the competent authority. It would be
appreciated if the documentary evidence of
successfully supervising PhD is submitted by sending
scanned copy by e-mail at the earliest. We plan to
hold interviews in the first week of August, hence
urgency in the matter.
.........................................................................”
The e-mail, thus, makes it abundantly clear that the Petitioner
has qualified for promotion in terms of the criteria enumerated in
Clause 6.4.8 of the UGC Regulations, 2010. The only stumbling
block to his promotion is the alleged new criterion added by the
Respondent No.2. From the foregoing discussions, it clear that the
said additional criterion is non est having failed to comply with the
Act and not having been circulated or notified thereby placing it
outside the scope of consideration for any purpose.
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
26.
It would be apposite to state that the 4th amendment of
the UGC Regulations, 2010 was enforced from 11.7.2016. From the
facts discussed hereinabove, it is clear that the Petitioner is eligible
to be considered for appointment and designation as Professor from
1.7.2016 having accrued the requisite credit points as per the API
based PBAS methodology of the UGC Regulations. The request of
the Respondents No.1 and 2 to the Petitioner requiring him to
submit his Application under the 4th amendment is fallacious since it
is not for the Respondents No.1 and 2 to dictate terms to the
Petitioner, when specific criteria has been laid down by the UGC
Regulations and he was eligible before the 4th amendment came into
force on 11th July, 2016. This is reinforced by the Public Notice of
the UGC dated 21st November, 2014 already extracted and which for
brevity is not being reproduced. The alleged good faith extended by
the Respondents No.1 and 2, while requiring him to submit his
application under the 4th amendment finds no place in the legal
scheme of things. Needless to add that no rule can be applied
retrospectively unless it is specified therein for special consideration.
In the instant matter no such specification has been laid down. It
was clarified by the Respondents No.1 and 2 that no Forms have
been prepared as per the 3rd amendment, be that as it may, this
should not debar the Petitioner from applying as per the Regulations
applicable to him and not as per the choice and directions of the
Respondents
No.1
and
2.
The
argument
advanced
by
the
Respondents No.1 and 2 that the Form provided by them for
applying for promotion under CAS, suffices as proof of the additional
criterion, is at best a feeble argument befitting no consideration or
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
discussion. At this juncture, it is worth noticing that the Circular
dated 7.3.2017 (Annexure P-16) inviting applications for promotion
under CAS, is silent about the additional norm. Perhaps it would be
fair to assume that the criterion was meant to be applicable only to
the Petitioner.
27.
So far as retrospective application of rules is concerned,
in K. Narayanan and Others v. State of Karnataka and Others (supra), the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court at Paragraph 7, inter alia, held as follows;
“7.
Rules
operate
prospectively.
Retrospectivity is an exception. Even where the
statute permits framing of rule with retrospective
effect the exercise of power must not operate
discriminately or in violation of any constitutional
right so as to affect vested right. The rule-making
authority should not be permitted normally to act in
the past. …………………………...............................……”
In B.S. Yadav and Others v. State of Haryana and Others4, the
28.
Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed as herein below;
“76. ……………………………….Since the Governor
exercises a legislative power under the proviso to
Article 309 of the Constitution, it is open to him to
give retrospective operation to the rules made under
that provision. But the date from which the rules are
made to operate must be shown to bear, either from
the face of the rules or by extrinsic evidence,
reasonable nexus with the provisions contained in the
rules, especially when the retrospective effect
extends over a long period as in this case.
…………………………...............................................….”
The above would stand in good stead for the instant matter.
29.
The ratiocination relied on by the Respondents No. 1 and
2 are now taken up for consideration. In The Chancellor and Anr. v. Dr.
Bijayananda Kar and Ors and Dr. Prafulla Kumar Mohapatra v. Dr.
1980 (Supp) SCC 524
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
Bijayananda Kar and Ors. (supra), relied on by learned Counsel for the
Respondents No. 1 and 2, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court was pleased
to caution that the decisions of the academic authorities should not
ordinarily be interfered with by the Courts. Whether a candidate
fulfils the requisite qualifications or not is a matter which should be
entirely left decided by the academic bodies and the concerned
selection committees which invariably consist of experts on the
subjects relevant to the selection. In that matter, one Dr. Kar in his
representation before the Chancellor specifically raised the issue
that one Dr. Mohapatra did not possess the specialisation in the
“Philosophical Analysis of Values” as one of the qualifications. The
representation was rejected by the Chancellor. The Hon‟ble Supreme
Court was in no doubt that the Chancellor must have looked into the
question of eligibility of the said Dr. Mohapatra and got the same
examined from the experts before rejecting the representation of
Dr. Kar. In Maharashtra State Board of Secondary and Higher Secondary
Education and Anr. v. Paritosh Bhupeshkumar Sheth and Ors. And Alpana
V. Mehta v. Maharashtra State Board of Secondary Education and Anr.
(supra), also relied on by learned Counsel for the Respondents No. 1
and 2, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had cautioned that the Courts
should be extremely reluctant to substitute its own views as to what
is wise, prudent and proper in relation to academic matters in
preference to those formulated by professional men possessing
technical expertise and rich experience of actual day-to-day working
of educational institutions and the departments controlling them.
It is evident that the matter at hand is clearly distinguishable
from the matters referred to hereinabove. In the instant case, there
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
is no quarrel with the findings of the authorities with regard to the
qualifications laid down by the UGC for promotion. The sore point is
the
purported
additional
norm
which
is
being
taken
into
consideration by the Respondents No. 1 and 2, for promotion of the
Petitioner when it has failed to comply with established legal norms
such as circulation and notification, besides other formalities already
discussed hereinabove. This Court by no stretch of the imagination
seeks to substitute its views in place of those formulated by
academicians but is only seeking to mete out justice where it is
being denied.
30.
Coming to the question of the matter being infructuous
because of the Petitioner having been relieved from the University to
join another posting on lien, is based on an erroneous appreciation
of the law. In this context, it would be worthwhile to refer to State of
M.P. v. Sandhya Tomar ,
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed as
follows;
“10. „Lien‟ connotes the civil right of a government
servant to hold the post „to which he is appointed
substantively‟. The necessary corollary to the
aforesaid right is that such appointment must be in
accordance with law. A person can be said to have
acquired lien as regards a particular post only when
his appointment has been confirmed, and when he
has been made permanent to the said post. „The
word “lien” is a generic term, and standing alone, it
includes lien acquired by way of contract, or by
operation of law.‟ Whether a person has lien depends
upon whether he has been appointed in accordance
with law, in substantive capacity and whether he has
been made permanent or has been confirmed to the
said post.”
(2013) 11 SCC 357
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
31.
In State of Rajasthan v. S.N. Tiwari6, it was held that;
“17. It is well settled that when a person with a lien
against the post as appointed substantively to
another post, only then he acquires a lien against a
latter post. Then and then alone, the lien against the
previous post disappears. Lien connotes the right of a
civil servant to hold the post substantively to which
he is appointed. The lien of a government employee
over the previous post ends if he is appointed to
another permanent post on permanent basis. In such
a case the lien of the employee shifts to the new
permanent post. It may not require a formal
termination of lien over the previous permanent
post.”
32.
While explaining the word „lien‟ in Ram Lal Khurana v.
State of Punjab
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court elucidated that;
“8. Lien is not a word of art. It just connotes the right
of a civil servant to hold the post substantively to
which he is appointed.”
33.
The ratiocination in Arun Kumar Agarwal v. Union of India8
lays down that;
“58. It is a settled proposition of law that a
deputationist would hold the lien in the parent
department till he is absorbed in any post. …..”
34.
In Ram Lal Khurana v. State of Punjab (supra), the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court while explaining the word lien also held that;
“19. The term “lien” comes from the Latin term
“ligament” meaning “binding”. The meaning of lien in
service law is different from other meanings in the
context of contract, common law, equity, etc. The lien
of a government employee in service law is the right
of the government employee to hold a permanent
post substantively to which he has been permanently
appointed.”
35.
Need this Court explain any further on the term “lien”
when the aforesaid judgments so succinctly illuminate the meaning
(2009) 4 SCC 700
(1989) 4 SCC 99
(2014) 2 SCC 609
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
and import thereof. It is evident that the submission of the
Respondents No.1 and 2 on this Court is based on an erroneous
understanding of the word „lien‟. As the substantive post of the
Petitioner is an Associate Professor in the Sikkim University, it would
include any promotion that he obtains thereof. The question of the
Petition being infructuous and only academic consequently does not
arise.
36.
In conclusion, considering the entirety of the facts and
circumstances as discussed hereinabove, the Petition is allowed with
the following directions;
(a)
The Respondents No. 1 and 2 shall take steps to
consider the promotion of the Petitioner from
Stage 4 to Stage 5, in terms of the UGC
Regulations, 2010, Clause 6.4.8 and any other
relevant
provision.
While
doing
so,
due
consideration shall be taken of the observations in
the e-mail dated July 10, 2017 addressed to the
Petitioner and one Dr. Sathyanarayanan from
Mr. T.K Kaul, Registrar, Sikkim University, wherein
the Petitioner has been informed that he qualifies
on all other points except the criterion added vide
Annexure-I. No consideration whatsoever shall be
attached to the impugned additional criterion
inserted by the Respondent No.2 vide Annexure-I
(Page 143 of the Paper-Book), viz. requiring
supervising award of Ph.D., the same being non
est in the eyes of law.
(b)
The Respondents No. 1 and 2 shall consider the
Application of the Petitioner for promotion under
the 3rd amendment dated 4th May, 2016 of the
WP(C) No. 47 of 2017
Dr. Vaidyanathan Krishna Ananth v. Sikkim University & Others
UGC Regulations, 2010 which are applicable to
him and not under the 4th amendment dated 11th
July, 2016, which has no retrospective effect.
(b)
All necessary steps shall be completed within sixty
days hence.
37.
No order as to costs.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
6.3.2018
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review