Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
[ 34e2 ]
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY EIGHTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENry SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
WRIT APPEAL NO: 1453 OF 2025
Writ Appeal under clause 1 5 of the Letters Patent preferred against the order
daled 3O1O712025 in W.P.No. 15827 ot 2025. on the file of the High Court.
Between:
'1. Dr. Ullahas Jagadish, S/o. J. Jagadish, aged 32 years, Occ- Doctor, R/o.H.No.149-3111, Thimmapur Village, Dharmapuri Mandal, Jagitial Dist. PIN - 505 425.
2. Dr. Anu Thankappan, S/o. N. Thankappan, aged 41 years, Occ- Doctor, R/o.
Brothers Villa, Manakala PO., Adoor Pathanamthitta, Kerala State PIN-691 551.
...APPELLANTS/
WRIT PETITIONER No.2 & 3
AND
1- Union of lndia, Rep- by its Secretary Department of Health and Family Welfare,
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi-11001'1.
2. State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Medical and Family Welfare
Department Secretariat, Hyderabad.
3. Directorate General of Health Services, rep. by its Director, Ministry of Health
and Family Welfare, Nirman Bhawan, Rajpath Area, Central Secretariat, New
Delhi, Delhi-'l 10001 .
4. National Medical Commission, rep. by its Chairperson, Satarkta Bhawan, G.P.O.
Complex, Block A, lNA, New Delhi-110023.
5. Directorate of Medical Education, rep. by its Chairman, Government of
Telangana, Koti, Hyderabad, Telangana.
6. Telangana State Medical Council, Rep. by its Chairman, P. B. 523, Sultan
Bazaar, Near Post Office, Opposite Womens College, Hyderabad, Telangana
500095.
7- Kaloji Narayana Rao University of Health Sciences, rep. by its Vice Chancellor,
Warangal, Telangana- 506007.
8. Osmania Medical College, rep. by its Principal, 5-1-876, Turrebaz Khan Rd,
Troop Bazaar, Koti, Hyderabad, Telangana 500095.
9. Gandhi Medical College, rep. by its Principal Musheerabad, MIGH Colony,
Walker Town, Padmarao Nagar, Secunderabad-500003, Telangana.
10.Dr. KW Rala Shekhar, S/o. KW Satya Narayana Rao, Aged 33 years, Occup.
Doctor, R/ o. Flat No.503, Pinnacle Pride, Umanagar Road No.1 , Kundan Bagh,
Begumpet, Hyderabad-S0O 016.
11. Dr. Kasturi Navaneeth Krishna, S/o. K.Venu Gopal, Aged 32 years, Occup.
Doctor, present R/o.Tarnaka, Hyderabad and Permanent R/ o.H.No.1-49-31/ 1,
Thimmapur village, Dharmapuri Mandal, Jagitial Dist PIN-505 425.
'12. Dr Khajanayab Rasool Shaik, S/o. Khaja Mastan Saheb, Aged 37 years, Occup.
Ranga Apartment, Seethaphal Mandi,
Doctor, R/o.Flat No.301,
Secundera bad-500 016.
13. Dr Amar Erukulla, S/o. Naga Bhushanam, Aged 33 years, Occup. Doctor,
R/o.Sree Lakshmi Nilaya 4203/10, Swami Vivekanda Badavane, Sth Main, 6th
Cross, Davanagere, Karnataka, PIN-577 004.
Sri
(R 10 to R13 are not necessary parties in this Writ Appeal)
...RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO:2OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to DIRECT the
respondents 7 and I to forthwith release the original certificates of the Petitioners along
with No-Objection Certificate for the purpose of registration and practice, pending
disposal of the above Writ Appeal.
Counsel for the Appellants: SRI SREENIVASA RAO VELIVELA
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO,
DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2,5,8 & 9: SRI K.SHANTHAN RAO,
AGP FOR HIGHER EDUCATION
Counsel for the Respondent No.7: SRI T.SHARATH, SC FOR KNRUHS
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.3,4 & 6: The Court made the following: JUDGMENT
IN TIIE HIGH COURT FOR TIIE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT IIYDERABAD
TIIE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
WRIT APPEAL No.l453 ot2025
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 28.04.2026
Between:
Dr.Ullahas Jagadish and another
Appellants.
AND
Union ol India, represented by its Secretary, Deparlment ol Heatth
and Farnily Welfare, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,
Nirman Bhawan, New Dethi and others.
Respondents.
JUDGMENT (Pcr Hon'ble Sri Justice K.LoAshnon)
I{eard Mr.Sreenivasa Rao Velivela, learned counsel lor the
appellants, Mr.K.Shanthan Rao, learned Assistant Government
Pleader lor Higher Education appearing for respondent Nos.2, 5, 8
and 9 and Mr.T.Sharath, leamed Standing Counsel for Kaloji
Narayana Rao University of Health Sciences i.e., respondent No.7.
2.
Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the order dated
30.07.2025 passed by the leamed SingleJudge in W.P.No.l5827 of
2025, unsuccesstul writ petitioners prc t'crred the present intra
coun appcal under clause l5 olthe l-etters Patent
3.
Appcllants -ioined in respondent No.8 - College in DM/MCh
(l)octor.ate ol Medicine, Mastcr of Ctrirurgiae). At the time of
Jornrng, r'csponclcnt No.8 - Collcge has obtained an undertaking to
scn'c thc (iovcntment of 1'e langana by working in Govcrnment
Hosprtals lbr a pcriod of two (2) years afier successful completion
of Supcr Specialty Coursc (if required), in case, if rhey tails to join
as Senior Rcsidcnt or in casc of not completing two years ol
sen'ice within rnaxil.nurn period of 36 months, they undertook to
pa)'a surn ot-Rs.50,00,0001 (Rupees fifty lakhs only) to
Govcrnmcnt rn ter-nrs ol'G.O.Ms.No. 165 ol 2017. dated
0(r.09 20 17. \\'hile.joining thc said course, they have submitted thc
origrnals ol' the [ollowing certificates to respondent No.8
Collcgc
i) Pcnnancnt N4cdical [tcgistration Certificate (MBBS & PC);
ii) Pe rmanent lr4 BBS Dcgree Certificate;
iii) Provisional ['(i Dcgrec Ceftificate;
iv) [ntcrnship Completion Certilicate;
v) Bonalide ('ertitlcate (MBBS & t,G);
vi) Contluct Ccililicatc (N41lBS & PG);
vii) SSC/CBSE, (t0'h) Marks Memo;
viii) 12'r'Marks Memo;
ix) MBBS Marks Memo/Consolidated Memo;
x) PG Marks Memo/Consolidated Memo;
xi) Transfer Cerrificate; and
xii) Migration Certificate.
They have successfully completed the said course during the
academic year 2024-2025. Even then, respondent No'S - College
has not returned the aforesaid original certificates on the ground
that appetlants lailed to work in Government Hospitals for a period
of two years in terms of the undertaking given by the appellants'
4.
It is the specific contention of the appellants herein in the
said writ petition that respondent No.8 - Coltege has no power or
authority to withhold the original certificates. In case of violation
I
of the aloresaid undertaking given by the appellants, at the most,
i
respondent No.8 - Coltege can file a suit seeking recovery of
l
I
money, but it can't withhold the certihcates.
l
5.
Learned counsel for the appellants has also placed reliance
on the principle laid down by this Court in Malraiu Suhitha v' The
State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Higher
Etlucution Deportnentt and Ms,Bhaslrupoka Pragna Vardhini v.
The State oJ'Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Higher
Educulion Dcpartmcni
.
Vidc thc order dated 24.01 .2020 in W.P,No.2l 137 of 2019,
the Division Bench of this Court struck down paragraph No.7 (iii)
of G.O.Ms.No. [ 14, dated 05.07 .2011 i.e., original cerlificates
submitted by the candidates shall not be returned to them, till they
complete thcil coursc of study and appear lor the university
examination holding it as un-constitu tional. A similar view was
also taken by this C'ourr in Mahatma Gandhi Law College, NTR
Nogar, I{1,slsvubatl v. State of Telanganai and in Sai Lakshnti
Saranya v. Tlrc Statc oJ'Telangarua .
7.
Thus, rcspondent No.8 College has no lien over the
original ceftitlcates of thc candidates including the appellants
herein. If appellants violates the aforesaid undertaking, respondent
No.8 Collcge is entitled fbr an amount of Rs.50,00,000/- from the
appellants on the ground of the violation ol- the said undertaking,
' W P.\o l7l(rl rril0l5. dccr,led on 12.09.1() t5
orr 09 01.10 l6
r W.P.xo +0218 <rl lLll5, dccrded
r W P No ll4l7 oi 1013. dccirlcd orr 09 ll ?0 ll
'W P.No l-)359 ol 1014. dcculetl oll 19.l0 20 l4
respondent No.8 - College lras to file a suit against the appellants
seeking recovery of money but it can't withhold the original
certificates of the appellants and it has no lien
8.
Mr.K.Shanthan Rao, leamed Assistant Government Pleader
lor Higher Education appearing for respondent Nos.2, 5, 8 and 9,
on instructions, would lairly submits that respondent No.8
Coltege has no power or authority to withhold the original
ceftificates of the appellant.
9.
Mr.T.Sharath, learned Standing Counsel for Kaloji Narayana
Rao University ol Health Sciences for respondent No.7, also fairly
submits that respondent No.8 - Coltege has no lien to withhold the
I
original certificates of the appellant.
I
10. Without considering the said aspects, vide impugned order
dated 30.07.2025 in W.P.No.l5827 of 2025, tearned Singte Judge
dismissed the writ petition filed by the appellants herern.
ll.
In the light of the aforesaid discussion, this Writ Appeat is
allowed. The impugned order dated 30.07.2025 in W.P.No. 15827
of 2025 is set aside. W.P.No.l5827 of 2025 is allowed. Respondent
No.8 - College is directed to retum the original certificates i.e., i)
,
;l
(
Pennanent Medical Registration Certificate (MBBS & pG);
Permanent MBBS Degrce Certificate; iii) provisional pG
ii)
Degree
Certificate; iv) Internship Completion Certificate; v) Bonafide
Certificate (N4BBS & l,(i), vi) Conduct Certificare (MBBS & pG);
vii) SSC/CBSE (10'h) Marks Memo; viii) t2,h Marks Memo; ix)
MBBS Marks MenroiConsolidated Memo; x) pG Marks
Memo/Consolidated Mcrno; xi) Transler Certificate; and
xii)
Migration Ceftificate, to thc appellants under due acknowledgment,
within one ( t) rveck lrom the date of receipt o[ a copy
of this
Judgment.
As a sequel thcreto, miscellaneous applications, il any,
pending in the writ Appcal shalr stand closed.
Therc shail no order
as to costs
SD/. B.SATYAVATHI
JOINT REGISTRAR
,/TRUE COPY/
I
6;
SECTION OFFICER
To
l.TheSecretary,Unionoflndia,DepartmentofHealthandFamilyWelfare'Ministry
'
Delhi-1 10011'
oi iJtni"d iamity Welfare Nirman Bhawan' New
and Family Welfare
2. The Principal Secretary, atail of Telangana' Medical
DepartmentSecretariat,Hyderabad ..
of Health a'nd
3. The Director, Directorate'6"*"i "t Health Services' Ministry
New Delhi'
Family Welfare, Nirman an";';, n'ip"th Area' Central
Delhi-1 10001
Secretariat'
G P O'
4. The Chairperson, National Medical Commission' Satarkta Bhawan'
Complex, Block A, lNA, New Delhi-1 10023'
of Telangana'
5. The Chairman, oirectoraie of Medical Education' Government
Koti, Hyderabad. Telanqana
6. The Chairman, Telangana State Medical Council, P. 8.523, Sultan Bazaar, Near
Posl Office, Opposite Womens College, Hyderabad, Telangana 500095.
7. The Vice Chancellor, Kaloji Narayana Rao University of Health Sciences,
Warangal, Telangana- 506007.
8. The Principal, Osmania Medical College, 5-1-876, Turrebaz Khan Rd, Troop
Bazaar, Koti, Hyderabad, Telangana 500095.
9. The Principal, Gandhi Medical College, Musheerabad, MIGH Colony, Walker
Town, Padmarao Nagar, Secu nderabad-500003, Telangana.
'10.One CC to SRI SREENIVASA RAO VELIVELA, Advocate
IOPUCI
1'1. One CC to SRI N BHUJANGA RAO, DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF |NDIA
loPUcI
'l2.One CC to SRI T.SHARATH, SC FOR KNRUHS
[OPUC]
13.Two CCs to GP FOR HIGHER EDUCATION, High Court for the State of
Telangana, at Hyderabad. [OUTI
14. Two CD Copies
PSK
PSK
h5.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
CC TODAY
l
HIGH COURT
\
(
DATED: 2810412026
a !)'
;i.j
i\ -"o
i-iL S i4
,ro
(. J [o B
"'
.,1:.
'-.J'
JUDGMENT
WA.No.1453 ot 2O25
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
I
.-.1.1..
';r'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review