Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
I32s2l
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALU NANDA
Contempt Case Nos.237 6 0F 2024
IN/AND
WP.Nos.11366 OF 2024
CC NO: 2376 oF 2024
contempt case under sections 1o to 12 of contempt of courts Act
punish the respondent herein for the wiilfur
1971 to
and deriberate disobedience of the order
datd 22 07 .2024 passed in r.A.No. 1 of 2024 in w.p.No. 1 .l 36
6 of 2024.
Between:
Dr.l.S.Praveen Kumar. S/oJ.Stephen
Aged 57 years, Working as Associate
Pro{essor of English, Government
oegreE Cotbje, B-ettampalty R/o.H.No.2g_
4-57, ca ttex Area, Bela
mpaly M;
b;iri."i?"L"ng.n,
il;;
st tu.
...Contempt petitioner/petitioner
AND
Smt.Devasena, l.A.S.,
Thr
Governmenr"r'r.i""-g"""'ii,f
:Hff :?:'J#r"?"*:X,il"rr:?jff Xon(FAC)
...RespondenURespondents
Counset for the petitioner:
Dr. T.S. praveen Kumar
Counsel for the Respondent:
(party_in_person)
Government pleader For
Services t
t
WP NO: '11366 OF 2024
Petition under A(icle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a Writ, Order or Direction, more particularly one in the nature of the Writ of
Mandamus, declaring the action of the respondents in issuing impugned rejection
orders dated 1601 .2023 and 26.03.2024 through which rejecting claim of the
petitioner for notional promotion from the date of acquiring eligibility in accordance
with G O.Ms.No 159 dated 30.06.1990 and G.O.Rt.No.438, dated 28.06.2011 and
the provisional of Special Rules and Rule 6 of the A.P. State and Subordinate
Service Rules, '1996, even though the Government decided and consider the request
of the petitioner for notional promotion from the date of eligibility in the subsequent
DPCs conducted in 2002,2005 and 2006 instead of 2010 vide Memo dated
07.03.2022 and consequently set them aside as bad, illegal, arbitrary, uniust,
improper, contrary to law, contrary to rules, amounts to non-application of mind,
amounts to colourable exercise of their power, discrimination and Unconstitutional
and consequently direct the respondents to grant notional promotion to the
petitioners as Leiturer/Assistant Piofessor and further promotions from the date of
his eligibility with all consequential benefits.
Between:
57 years' Working 'as
Dr.T. S Praveen Kumar, S/o T Stephen' Aged
AssociateProfessoroffnghsh,GovernmentD-egleeCollege'Bellampally'
Maniherial District' Telangana
R/o H No 284-57, Cattex irir,' eJfrrp"lly,
State
...Petitioner
AND
its principar ,secretary to Government,
The state of relangana, Rep. by
1.
'
Secietariat' Hyderabad'
HI
g'n."r'Ed]r;tion Deiartinent'
E9Ytl"-,"
2.
- The Commissioner of Collegiate.Hyderaoao'
(FAC)' Government of Telangana'
Hijn"t Education Department
Occ Principal at
Known' Aged abor.rt 60 vears'
Not
S/o
3. Sri Y.Satyanarayana '
Near old Bus Stand'
Government D"s'""
Joi;;;'{W
Telangana
'ln:iq!-I:
Enli*rprii'n."d, Lagtili JAlai oistrict'
state
l'A'No'
As per Court Order Dated t0-07-20'24'
ll3ilGlzozlResponoent No'3
2 ol 2024 in W'P'
is lmpleaded'
...ResPondents
\. A.
20 24
Peti(ron
affidavit
under Se
$sd rn suPPo
:x'[':::r'il:""]]:
il:ilI;ff
.-.i ;l ;[::
-1
the impugned rejection orders dated 16.01.2023 and 26.03.2024 issued by the
respondents
LA. NO: 1OF 2025
Between
SEtg of Tetangana, R9p. Oy i,;s principat Secretary to Government,
Ilg
Higher Education Department,
Secietariat, Hyderabad.
The commissioner of coflegiate Education (FAC), Government
of rerangana,
Higher Education Departme'nt, Hyderabad.
...petitioners/Respondents
AND
Dr.l. .S- Praveen Kumar, S/o T^ Stephen, Aged 57 years, Working
as
Associate Professor of English, Government O"egree Cottege, gettamiaily,
R/o H.No.28-4-57, Caltex Area, BellampaUy, fvfan"cfrerial
District,
Telangana
State.
... Respondents/Petitioners
Sri Y.Satyanarayana, S/o Not Kn-own, Aged about 60 years,
Occ principal at
Government_ Degree College (W), JJgtial, R/o Near
Otd Bus dtand,
Dharmapuri Road, Jagtial, Jagtial District, ielangana State.
...Respondents/Respondents
Petition under Section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances
stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court
may be preased to vacate the
interim orders dated.22-07-2024 in wp.No.11366 0f 2024
and dismiss the writ
Petition.
l.A. NO; 2 OF 2025
Pelition under section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances
stated in the
affidavit_fited in support of. the petition, ite- Hlgh
Court may Oe pfeaJeO to pass
lnterim Directions for keeoing on. pori or erin"cipar
vacant by disposing the said
W P. No. 1 1366 of 2024
Counsel for the Petitioner: Dr. T.S. praveen
Kumar (party_in_person)
counsel for the Respondent No.3: Government preader
The Court made the following: COMMON
For Services r
ORDER
!
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
CONTEMPT CASE No.2376 o F 2()24
IN/AND
w.P. NO. 11 66 0F 2024
DA
t22
Between :
W.P. No.1 136 6 oJ 2024
Dr.T.S. Praveen Kumar
, . Pa
rty- in - person/Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana rep. by its principal
Secretary to Govt. Higher Education Department
Secretariat, Hyderabad & 2 others
... Respondents
Betw een :
c.c. o.2376 o f 2024
Dr.T. S. Praveen Kumar
...Contempt petitioner
AND
Smt. Devasena, IAS
The Commissioner of Coltegiate Education (FAC)
Govt. of Telangana
Higher Education Department, Hyderabad.
... Respondent
cc_2316 2024
ln/And
wp | 1366_2021
COMMON ORDER:
Heard Dr. T.S. Praveen Kumar, Party-inperson/Petitioner and learned Government Pleader
for Services-I, appearing on behalf of respondent
No.3.
2, The Detitaoner approached the Court seekinq
fa
rinW
2024 as
"...to issue a Writ, Order or Direction, more particularly
one in the nature of the Writ of Mandamus, declaring
the action of the respondents in issuing impugned
rejection orders dated 16.01.2023 and 26.03.2O24
through which rejecting claim of the petitioner for
notional promotion from the date of acquiring eligibility
in accordance with G.O.Ms.No.159 dated 30.06.1990
and G.O.Rt.No.438, dated 28.06.2011 and the
provisional of Special Rules and Rule 6 of the A.P.
State and Subordinate Service Rules, 1996, even
though the Government decided and consider the
request of the petitioner for notional promotion from
the date of eligibility in th€ subsequent DPCS
conducted in 2OO2, 2005 and 2006 instead of 2010
vide Memo dated 07.03.2022 and consequently set
them aside as bad, illegal, arbitrary, unjust, improper,
contrary to law, contrary to rules, arnounts to nonapplication of mind, amounts to colourable exercise of
\
cc 2176-2024
ln/And
tlp I l166 2024
their power, Crscrimination and u nconstitutiona I and
consequently drrect the respondents to grant notional
promotion to the petitioners as Lecturer/ Assistant
Professor ani further promotions from the date of his
eligibllity with all consequential benefits and pass...".
3.
PERUSED THE RECORD
The oetitione r in the o resent writ Detition as the
2nd oetit one r in W.P. No. (TR) No. 6O29 oJ 2Ot7.
The relevant oortio no f the order of this Court dated
01.11.2O19 oassed in W.P. (TR) No. 6O 29 of 2O!7 is
extracted h ereun der : -
"
This Court, having considered the rival
submissions made by the learned counsel for the
respective parties, is of the considered view that this
writ petition can be disposed of directing the
petitioners to submit an a ppea l/ representation to the
1't respondent within a period of two weeks from the
date of receipt of a copy of this order seeking fixation
of pay scales in accordance with Career Advancement
Scheme and other related issues. Upon such
tation being received, the 1't
respondent shall consider the same and pass
a ppea l/rep rese n
appropriate orders in accordance with law within eight
weeks thereafter.
With the above observations, the writ petition is
disposed of, No order as to costs".
i
:
l
i
cc _2376-2014
ln/And
!!p_ r ll66-2024
il
4. Both t e Partv-in-De
cou n el aoo eaflno on
conten d that the o
d
3.1
DP s
ut
lo
h
ekin
cond ucted
d
ti
w h
ur
in the orese nt writ
ers tmDuone
tt resDond ent could b e set
r
e
ti n
otion
m
rmm diatel
tn
e
5.
ro
u n
after the aoplica nts
ubm
th
ner
h
rh
th
r
ld
er
n
r as on ab e
learned
half of the resDon dents
Detiti on Dasse dbvthel
id
n and the
nc
a
d
n
e
w th
a
s
r
d
a o s
Taking into consideration
circumstances of the
the aforesaid facts and
case and the submissions
by the party-in-person,/petitioner
Government pteader for
behalf of respondent
made
and learned
Services_f, appearing on
No.3, without goang into
merits of the rivat contentions
learned party-in-person
the
put_forth by both the
and learned Government
t
cc-2376_1024
ln/And
qp I It66 2024
Pleader for Services-I, appearing on behalf of
respondent No.3 and upon consent, this Court passed
the following order:
The writ Detition is allowed, The imouoned
reiection orders dated 1 .01.2023 and 26.03.2024
are set aside and the matter is remitted back to the
1't resoondent fo r consideration of the laim/reouest
of the oetitioner for notion alo romot ion from t he date
a c o ul rino
of
M
.15
a
eli o ibi itv
ln
.06
a
a
o
fna
r
wit
nc
les
s
o1
d
N
ol w
r
e
so e
ro n
r
r d f
r 4 w e
t
r n
r vt n
a
e
h
t
t isC
e
b v
ki
o
m
t
,
n
er
t
t
o
No.
T
f
d
confo
ti
inW
e etiti on er he r ln.
LE-
nd
rs
to
ef
G. o.
n
ft
to
al he n
f
r
acc o rda ce
r
e
t
cL-2316_2024
i
In/Ard
I
rl
wp-11366_2021
II
6. The Contempt Case No.2376 ot 2024 has been
I
filed complaining violation of the order dated 22.O7.2024
i
passed by this Court in LA. No.1 of 2024 in W.p. No.11366
of 2024
7. In view of the fact that W.p. No.11366 of 20'24
has been allowed by setting aside the impugned
1l
ir
rejection orders dated 16.01.2023 and 26.03..2024
il
passed by the 1't respondent vide its order dated
22.04.2026, the present Contempt Case is closed.
However, there shall be no order as to costs.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand
closed.
SO/- N.SRIHARI
DEPU TY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
\
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. Dr.T.S.Praveen Kumar,
..Working as Associate professor of Enolish.
Governmenr Deoree cores",
BeltampalyMancieriat oistrLt, _drr#prli"iiJir. ruo. za_o_57, ca rtex Area,
2. Two CCs to Government p^teager
' v' w' v"/sr ,' IHigh Court for the State of
Tetangana, at Hyderabad
r"r""sllr"it#]'
^
3. Two CD Copies
s
\
toUTI
#S";#;i,
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2210412026
/i
I _:-
,':, n\
COMMON ORDER
CC.Nos.2376 OF 2024
IN/AND
WP.Nos.l1366 OF 2024
CLOSING THE CC
ALLOWING THE WP
I
$
n
.;.
-)
..1
\r'x'
' 4- n -'-'' .: "j1
-r,,_._ I .l
t'//
,..,f
.:1
d
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review