Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.13 of 2026
Dr. Sumana Majumdar, age 53 years, W/O Sri Dipak Chandra Lodh, R/O-near
SDPO Office, Dak Banglow Road, P.O and P.S. - R.K. Pur, District- Gomati
Tripura, PIN-799120
.........Appellant(s);
Versus
1. The State of Tripura to be represented by Principal Secretary, Department of
(Higher) Education, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010
2. The Director, The Department of Higher Education, Government of Tripura,
Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura
3. The Principal Secretary, Finance Department, Government of Tripura, New
Secretariat Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010
.........Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Saktimoy Chakraborti, Advocate General,
Mr. Kohinoor Narayan Bhattacharyya, G.A.,
Mrs. Pinki Chakraborty, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Date of hearing
: 12.02.2026 & 05.03.2026
Date of Judgment & Order : 05.03.2026
Whether Fit for Reporting
: YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
(M.S. Ramachandra Rao, C.J.)
1.
Heard Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by learned counsel Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee and learned counsel Mr.
Kawsik Nath appearing for the appellant, and Mr. Saktimoy Chakraborti,
learned Advocate General assisted by learned counsel Mrs. Pinki Chakraborty
for the respondents-State.
2.
This Writ Appeal is preferred by the appellant challenging the
judgment dt.08.12.2025 of the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.140/2025.
3.
Appellant was appointed as a Post Graduate Teacher (PGT)
pursuant to a memo dt.10.06.2010 issued by the Special Secretary and Director
of Higher Education, Tripura.
The Judgment dt.16.03.2021 in WP(C) No.1391/2019 and batch
4.
Other PGTs, who were similarly situated like the appellant, and
who also possess, like her, the qualifications required for the post of Assistant
Professor as per UGC guidelines, approached this Court in WP(C)
No.1391/2019 and batch.
5.
The learned Single Judge allowed the Writ Petition by a judgment
dt.16.03.2021 holding that the petitioners in that Writ Petition, had all the
qualifications for appointment to the post of Assistant Professor in colleges, and
they cannot be deprived of equal pay attached to the post of Assistant Professor,
and a direction was given to the respondents to fix the pay of the said
petitioners in the pay scale of Rs.15,600-39,100/- with AGP of Rs.6000/- (prerevised).
6.
A direction was also given to frame a scheme within a period of
six months to absorb or designate the petitioners in the said Writ Petition in the
post of Assistant Professor by considering their long tenure of service of
teaching in the general degree colleges, as there was no blemish in respect of
their competence by relaxing the maximum age.
7.
While deciding as above, learned Single Judge did not accept the
plea of the State Government that PGTs are not the feeder post for promotion to
post of Assistant Professor, and so there is no question of upgradation or
promotion from PGTs to post of Assistant professor. He also did not accept the
plea of UGC that in respect of designating the PGTs as Assistant Professors,
there is no provision contained in the UGC regulations.
WA No.201/2021 and batch
8.
Thereafter, the State Government preferred WA No.201/2021 and
batch before the Division Bench.
9.
In the Writ Appeals, the State Government contended that the
appointment of Post Graduate Teachers was made on the basis of Recruitment
Rules of Post Graduate Teachers under the School Education Department,
which is not at par with the Recruitment Rules of Assistant Professor under
UGC; that the respondents in the Writ Appeals have not challenged the
Recruitment Rules at the time of joining into service and that there is no rule,
policy for promotion to the post of Assistant Professor directly from the post of
Post Graduate Teacher under UGC guidelines.
The Interim Order dt.14.12.2021 of the Division Bench in W.A.
No.201/2021 and batch
10.
Notwithstanding the said plea taken by the State Government, on
14.12.2021, as an interim measure, while admitting the Writ Appeals, the
Division Bench held that the State Government was obliged, during the
pendency of the Writ Appeals, to comply with the direction of framing of
scheme within a period of six months to absorb or designate the petitioners
therein in the post of Assistant Professor. It however granted a stay of operation
of the directions contained in the judgment of the learned Single Judge only
with regard to fixation of pay.
11.
If the State Government had any legal objection to this direction to
frame the scheme, it should have challenged this interim direction in the
Supreme Court, or sought its vacation by the same Division Bench. It however
did not do so.
12.
It consciously and deliberately acquiesced to the said direction,
and issued a notification on 21.09.2022 styling it as a ―Scheme to designate
PGTs working under the Department of Higher Education, Government of
Tripura by absorbing them in the post of Assistant Professor‖ mentioning
therein that the scheme was being introduced because of the interim order
granted on 14.12.2021 in WA No.201/2021 and batch.
13.
On 15.10.2022, the State Government issued a Memorandum
designating the respondents in W.A.No.201/2021 and batch as Assistant
Professors by way of absorption in available vacant posts. The State
Government thus gave the benefit to the 5 respondents in the said Writ Appeals
– the benefit of absorption to the post of Assistant Professor from PGT post,
though this was not, according to the State Government, in accordance with the
applicable Rules.
The final Judgment dt.17.05.2023 in WA No.201/2021 and batch
14.
When the Writ Appeals were finally heard by the Division Bench,
and decided on 17.05.2023, the State Government’s Counsel informed the
Court that they had introduced the above scheme vide notification
dt.21.09.2022 as was directed by the learned Single Judge for absorption of
PGTs in the post of Assistant Professors. He confined his arguments in the Writ
Appeal only as regards the direction given by the learned Single Judge in
WP(C) No.1391/2019 and batch regarding fixation of pay scale. The Division
Bench set aside the said direction to fix pay scale only, and granted relief to the
State Government only to that extent.
15.
Had the State Government felt that the interim direction was
legally unsustainable, it could have declined to frame the scheme itself or at
least argued, when the matter was being finally heard and decided, that the
direction of the Single Judge in his final judgment and of the Division Bench in
its interim order, cannot be sustained. This is also in our opinion a deliberate
and conscious act on the part of the State Government.
16.
As recorded by the Division Bench in its order dt.17.05.2023 in
WA No.201/2021 and batch, the State Government had indeed issued a
notification on 21.09.2022 styling it as a scheme to designate PGTs working
under the Department of Higher Education, Government of Tripura by
absorbing them in the post of Assistant Professor mentioning therein that the
scheme was being introduced because of the interim order granted on
14.12.2021 in WA No.201/2021 and batch.
WP(C) No.254/2021 and batch and Judgment dt.28.11.2022 therein
17.
Seeking similar benefit, 19 other persons similarly situated to that
of the respondents in the said Writ Appeals referred to supra, filed other Writ
Petitions being WP(C) No.254/2021 and batch.
18.
On 28.11.2022, the learned Single Judge allowed the Writ
Petitions, and gave a direction to the respondents to consider absorption of the
petitioners in WP(C) No.254/2021 and batch against available vacancies, and to
designate them as Assistant Professors in accordance with the scheme, if they
are found eligible. The learned Single Judge granted four weeks’ time to
complete the said exercise.
WP(C) No.276/2022 and Judgment dt.06.12.2022 therein
19.
Since the appellant herein was also denied the said benefit of
absorption as Assistant Professor, though she stood on the similar footing like
that of the persons who were absorbed on 15.10.2022 pursuant to the order
dt.16.03.2021 in WP(C) No.1391/2019 and batch, the appellant filed WP(C)
No.276/2022 seeking the same benefit.
20.
The learned Single Judge, on 06.12.2022, allowed the said Writ
Petition, and directed the respondents to consider the case of the appellant for
absorption and designation as Assistant Professor in accordance with the
scheme subject to availability of vacant post, and granted six weeks’ time to do
so.
21.
The appellant thereafter submitted a representation on 13.12.2022
to the Director, Directorate of Higher Education, Government of Tripura,
Agartala.
WP(C) No.272/2023 and Judgment dt.19.03.2024 therein
22.
The State Government then issued Memorandum dt.05.01.2023
designating 16 of the 19 petitioners in WP(C) No.254/2021 and batch as
Assistant professors, against available vacancies, but appellant and 3 others
were left out. The appellant therefore filed WP(C) No.272/2023.
23.
The said Writ Petition was also allowed by the learned Single
Judge on 19.03.2024, and a direction was issued to the respondents to consider
the grievance of the appellant at the earliest keeping in view the spirit of the
order dt.06.12.2022 in WP(C) No.276/2022. The learned Single Judge also
referred to a communication dt.05.01.2023 of the Additional Secretary to the
Government of Tripura that eligible PGTs of different subjects will be
accommodated as per the availability of category wise posts by the Higher
Education Department in future, following the direction of the High Court.
24.
No plea was raised by appellants-State Government that the
previous orders passed by the Court, cannot be applied to the appellant, or that
such absorption is not permitted by Recruitment Rules.
The order dt.20.01.2025 and memorandum dt.13.02.2025 issued by the
respondents
25.
Thereafter on 20.01.2025, the respondents issued an order stating
that the absorption of appellant and others cannot be done as there exists no
vacant post in respective subject and category-wise in the Higher Education
Department.
26.
They went further and also issued a Memorandum on 13.02.2025
withdrawing the scheme notified on 21.09.2022. In this memorandum it was
stated that the scheme had been implemented for absorption of the PGTs into
the post of Assistant Professor as one time arrangement in order to comply with
particular cases following the direction of the High Court of Tripura, and since
the said order of the High Court had been complied with, the scheme is being
withdrawn.
WP(C) No.140/2025 and Impugned Judgment dt.08.12.2025 passed therein
27.
Challenging the same, the appellant has filed WP(C) No.140/2025
before this Court.
28.
The learned Single Judge however dismissed the Writ Petition by
his judgment dt.08.12.2025.
29.
In the said Judgment, the learned Single Judge noted that there was
a vacancy which would arise on account of the retirement of Dr. Arpita
Acharyya on 31.12.2025, but he refused to grant relief to the appellant. He held
that there was no scope to absorb into the post of Assistant Professor without
proper selection process through Public Service Commission following
Recruitment Rules of Assistant Professor.
30.
He also held that under Art.226 of the Constitution of India, the
High Court cannot direct the State Government to frame any scheme, since it is
a welfare State, and framing any scheme is completely under the domain of the
State; and that though the respondents had not challenged the direction given
for framing of the scheme at that point of time, still the appellant cannot rely
upon the order passed on 16.03.2021 in WP(C) No.1391/2019 and batch, which
was per incuriam.
31.
Assailing the same, this Writ Appeal is filed.
Consideration by the Court:
32.
From the narration of the facts mentioned above, it is clear that
though as per the Recruitment Rules, there was no scope to absorb PGTs into
the post of Assistant Professor without proper selection process through Public
Service Commission, the High Court in WP(C) No.1391/2019 and batch on
16.03.2021, had directed the respondents to frame a scheme to absorb the PGTs
as Assistant Professors. As stated supra, the learned Single Judge did not accept
the plea of the State Government that PGTs are not the feeder post for
promotion to post of Assistant Professor, and so there is no question of
upgradation or promotion from PGTs to the post of Assistant professor. He also
did not accept the plea of UGC that in respect of designating the PGTs as
Assistant Professors, there is no provision contained in the UGC regulations.
33.
Thereafter when the State preferred Writ Appeals, there was an
interim direction on 14.12.2021 in WA No.201/2021 and batch directing the
farming of the scheme for absorption of PGTs rendering duty of Assistant
Professors in degree colleges having qualifications made for Assistant
Professors.
34.
The State Government acquiesced in the said order, and did not
challenge the said interim order in the Supreme Court, and also did not seek
vacation of the said order by the Division Bench.
35.
It instead went ahead, and notified the scheme on 21.09.2022 for
absorption of the five persons who were parties in the said Writ Appeals, for
absorption as Assistant Professors in degree colleges.
36.
Not only did it do so, when the said Writ Appeals were finally
heard and decided, it chose not to canvass before the Division Bench on
17.05.2023, the correctness of the interim direction granted by the Division
Bench to frame the scheme, and only confined its submission to the other point
about fixation of pay scale to the respondents therein.
37.
More importantly, when other 19 persons similarly situated to the
appellant, had filed WP(C) No.254/2021 and batch, and a direction was given
to consider their case for absorption as Assistant Professors, and to designate
them as Assistant Professors in accordance with the scheme, if they are found
eligible, and absorb them against available vacancies, the State Government
issued a memo on 05.01.2023 absorbing 16 such persons as Assistant
Professors without demur, without challenging either by way of a Writ Appeal,
or by way of an SLP the direction contained in the order dt.28.11.2022 in
WP(C) No.254/2021 and batch.
38.
But when it came to the case of the appellant, she was driven to
file not only WP(C) No.272/2023, but also WP(C) No.140/2025, and after the
appellant obtained a favourable order on 19.03.2024 in WP(C) No.272/2023, to
consider her case for absorption as Assistant Professor, the respondents then on
20.01.2025, rejected her case on the ground that there was no vacant post, and
on 13.02.2025 withdrew the scheme altogether.
39.
It is clear that the respondents have discriminated against the
appellant. After having acquiesced to the directions to frame scheme for
absorption of PGTs as Assistant Professors issued on 16.03.2021 in WP(C)
No.1391/2019 and batch, and the interim order dt.14.12.2021 in WA
No.201/2021 and batch, the State Government had framed the scheme on
21.09.2022 and absorbed the respondents therein as Assistant Professors on
15.10.2022, also granted similar absorption on 05.01.2023 to the 16 petitioners
in WP(C) No.254/2021 and batch without objecting their right to seek such
absorption.
40.
Only when it came to the case of the appellant, a totally new case
has been pleaded before the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.140/2025,
though there was a vacancy which would be available from 31.12.2025 in the
post of Assistant Professor, where the appellant could have been
accommodated and absorbed as Assistant Professor.
41.
The State cannot withdraw the scheme by contending that it was
only one time arrangement to absorb the 5 respondents in WA.No.201/2021
and batch on 15.10.2022, because it had also absorbed at a different point of
time, 16 others like the appellant on 05.01.2023. Thus it had accepted twice,
even though the Recruitment Rules did not permit, the absorption of PGTs as
Assistant Professors. It had thus accepted the process of absorption of PGTs as
Assistant Professors as an alternative method to fill up the vacant posts of
Assistant professors. So the order dt.13.02.2025 is set aside.
42.
The point whether the Court can direct the framing of the scheme
of absorption of PGTs as Assistant Professors or not, not having been argued by
the State Government in WP(C) No.1391/2019 and batch, or in WA
No.201/2021 and batch, is presumed to have been given up by the State
Government, and cannot be selectively applied, when it comes to the case of
the appellant.
43.
In fact such a plea does not appear to have been raised when the
appellant had filed WP(C) No.276/2022 at all. Since it was not raised in that
Writ Petition, the respondents are also barred by the principle of constructive
res judicata from raising the same in WP(C) No.140/2025.
44.
It is also not open to the learned Single Judge to comment on the
judgment dt.16.03.2021 in WP(C) No.1391/2019 and batch, and hold the said
judgment to be per incuriam. As held in State of Bihar v. Kalika Kuer alias
Kalika Singh and Others1, an earlier decision may seem to be incorrect to a
Bench of a coordinate jurisdiction considering the question later, on the ground
that a possible aspect of the matter was not considered or not raised before the
court or more aspects should have been gone into by the court deciding the
matter earlier, but it would not be a reason to say that the decision was rendered
per incuriam and liable to be ignored. The earlier judgment may seem to be not
correct yet it will have the binding effect on the later Bench of coordinate
jurisdiction. Easy course of saying that earlier decision was rendered per
(2003) 5 SCC 448, at page 453
incuriam is not permissible and the matter will have to be resolved only in two
ways — either to follow the earlier decision or refer the matter to a larger
Bench to examine the issue, in case it is felt that earlier decision is not correct
on merits.
45.
We cannot lose sight of the fact that the State did not argue the
correctness of judgment dt.16.03.2021 of the learned Single Judge in WP(C)
No.1391/2019 as regards the direction contained therein to frame a scheme of
absorption of PGTs as Assistant Professors in (i) WA No.201/2021 and batch,
(ii) in WP(C) No.254/2021 and batch, and also (iii) in WP(C) No.276/2022
filed by the appellant, but had accepted and implemented it (except for the
appellant).
46.
The State cannot selectively allow some PGTs to get absorbed as
Assistant Professors while opposing the appellant’s claim for the same by
raising pleas which it had not raised when other persons similar to the appellant
had approached this Court.
47.
Therefore, the judgment of the learned Single Judge cannot be
sustained, and is accordingly set aside, and the instant Writ Appeal is allowed;
the memo dt.13.02.2025 cancelling the notification dt.21.09.2022, is set aside,
and the respondents are directed to absorb the appellant in the post of Assistant
Professor within 8(eight) weeks.
48.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of. No costs.
(BISWAJIT PALIT, J)
Pijush/
signed by PIJUSH KANTI NAG
PIJUSH KANTI NAG Digitally
Date: 2026.03.09 14:10:13 +05'30'
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review