Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:THC:540-DB
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.130 of 2024
Dr. Suman Adhikari, Son of Sri Samarjit Adhikari, Resident of Tithai Road,
Padmapur, Dharmanagar, North Tripura, PIN-799250
.........Appellant(s);
Versus
1. Indira Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU) (To be represented by)
The Registrar, Indira Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU), Office of
the Registrar, IGNOU, New Delhi, Maidan Garhi, New Delhi, PIN-110068
2. The Director, Academic Coordination Division, Indira Gandhi National
Open University (IGNOU), Office of the Director, Academic Coordination
Division, IGNOU, New Delhi, Maidan Garhi, New Delhi, PIN-110068
3. The Director, Regional Centre, Itanagar, IGNOU, HMCT Building, Rajiv
Gandhi Govt. Polytechnic Vivek Vihar, Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh, PIN791113
4. The Regional Director, Agartala Regional Centre, IGNOU, MBB College,
Science Block, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799004
5. The State of Tripura (to be represented by) The Secretary, Department of
Higher Education, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New
Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala, West
Tripura, PIN-799010
6. The Director, Directorate of Higher Education, Government of Tripura, 1st
Floor, Shiksha Bhawan, Office lane, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799001
.........Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. K.N. Bhattahcharyya, G.A.,
Mr. D. Sarkar, Advocate,
Mr. Manojit Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
23/04/2026
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by
learned counsel Mr. Dipjyoti Paul for the appellant and Mr. D. Sarkar, learned
counsel for respondents No.1 to 4.
2026:THC:540-DB
Background Facts:
2.
The appellant was working as Assistant Professor in the
Department of Higher Education, Government of Tripura at which point of
time an advertisement dt.05.08.2021 was issued by the Indira Gandhi National
Open University, New Delhi [“The University”, for short] for the post of
Assistant Regional Director (North East Region).
3.
Appellant applied and he was issued an Offer of Appointment on
16.03.2022.
4.
The said appointment was on deputation for a period of two years
as Assistant Regional Director (on deputation basis), Regional CentreItanagar, Arunachal Pradesh.
5.
Clause 2(i) and 2(ii) of the said Offer of Appointment given to
the appellant state as under:
“2. i) Your appointment is on deputation basis in the Academic
Level 10 (Rs.57,700-1,82,400/-) of the 7th CPC pay matrix. During the
period of deputation, you will have the option either to get your pay
fixed in the deputation post under the operation of the normal rules or
to draw pay of the post held by you in your parent department plus a
Deputation (Duty) Allowance in accordance with and, subject to the
conditions, as modified from time to time and such other general or
special orders issued by the Govt. of India.
ii) In addition to the basic pay, you will draw such other
allowances as per Govt. of India rules and as determined by the
University from time to time.” ( emphasis supplied)
6.
Admittedly, appellant, in terms of the said Clause 2(i), opted on
07.07.2022 [Annexure-9] to draw the pay of the post held by him in his parent
department plus other allowances as per DoPT norms.
7.
2026:THC:540-DB
He started working in the post of Assistant Regional Director on
20.04.2022. Appellant got relieved from his job as Assistant Regional Director
on 31.03.2023.
8.
It is not in dispute that there was a Revision of pay scales
undertaken by the Government of Tripura enhancing the pay scale for the post
of Assistant Professor, from the pay scale of Rs.57,700-1,82,400/- to
Rs.68,900-2,05,500/- with effect from 21.04.2020 [Annexure-11], which post
the appellant was holding, before he went on deputation.
9.
Appellant’s case is that he is entitled to the said pay band of
Rs.68,900-2,05,500/- for the period he worked on deputation in the University
and that he should get the pay band of Rs.68,900-2,05,500/- ( revised pay
band) for the period 20.04.2022 to 31.03.2023.
10.
The case of the University is that he is not entitled to the same in
view of Clause 2(ii), which mandates that he would draw only the basic pay
and allowances as determined by the Government of India rules and as
determined by the University.
Judgment dt.27.08.2024 of the learned Single Judge:
11.
The learned Single Judge, in the impugned judgment, agreed with
the respondents and interpreted Clause 2 referred to supra. He held that under
sub-Clause (i) of Clause 2, the petitioner/appellant herein was no doubt given
the option during the period of deputation of taking the pay of the post of
Assistant Regional Director, or to draw the pay of Assistant Professor in the
State of Tripura. But his service conditions on deputation basis under IGNOU
including his pay and deputation duty allowance, would be governed by and in
2026:THC:540-DB
accordance with and subject to the conditions as modified from time to time,
and such other general or special orders issued by the Government of India.
12.
The learned Single Judge held that after entry into the service on
deputation, the service of the petitioner would be governed by the terms and
conditions as would be issued by the Government of India from time to time,
but not by the Government of Tripura.
13.
He also relied on sub-Clause (ii) of Clause 2 to come to the said
conclusion.
14.
In addition, he also refers to sub-Clause (vii) of Clause 2 which
states that during the period of his appointment in the University, in addition
to Government of India Rules, he would be governed by the Act, Statutes,
Ordinances and Regulations of the University and other Rules relating to the
conditions of service applicable to other academic staff of the University
modified from time to time.
15.
According to the learned Single Judge, only at entry time of the
petitioner into the service of respondents No.1 to 4, Clause 2(i) applies but not
afterwards, and that when the pay scale of Assistant Regional Director, NE
Region has been specified in the advertisement, the University cannot have
any obligation to pay a pay scale which is more than that of the pay scale
mentioned in the advertisement as well as in the Offer of Appointment issued
in favour of the appellant.
16.
According to the learned Single Judge, at the time of entry into
service, the University accepted the pay scale applicable to the appellant for
the post of Assistant Professor under the Higher Education Department of the
Government of Tripura, and the second part of sub-Clause (i) of Clause 2
2026:THC:540-DB
should not be read in isolation, but it must be read conjointly with other
clauses mentioned in the advertisement as well as the Offer of Appointment
dt.16.03.2022.
The instant Writ Appeal:
17.
Challenging the same, this Writ Appeal is filed by the appellant.
18.
Learned senior counsel for the appellant contends that the
reasoning given by the learned Single Judge, is erroneous because once the
appellant has been given the choice to draw the pay of the post held by him in
his parent department in sub-Clause (i) of Clause 2, it is not open to the
respondents to contend that he should draw only the pay fixed by the Central
Government.
19.
According to him, the words “as modified from time to time” in
sub-Clause (i) of Clause 2, not only applies to a modification in the pay scale
of post of Assistant Regional Director (if he exercised that option), but also to
the pay fixed in the post of Assistant Professor ( when he exercise that
option), which post was held by him in his parent department.
20.
Counsel for the University refutes the said contentions and
supports the judgment of the learned Single Judge.
Consideration by the Court:
21.
We have already referred to Clause 2 and sub-Clauses (i) and (ii)
thereof, which we shall repeat again:
“2. i) Your appointment is on deputation basis in the Academic
Level 10 (Rs.57,700-1,82,400/-) of the 7th CPC pay matrix. During the
period of deputation, you will have the option either to get your pay
fixed in the deputation post under the operation of the normal rules or
to draw pay of the post held by you in your parent department plus a
Deputation (Duty) Allowance in accordance with and, subject to the
2026:THC:540-DB
conditions, as modified from time to time and such other general or
special orders issued by the Govt. of India.
ii) In addition to the basic pay, you will draw such other
allowances as per Govt. of India rules and as determined by the
University from time to time.”
22.
Admittedly in the sentence “During the period of deputation ... in
your parent department” in sub-Clause (i) of Clause 2, option has been given
to the appellant to choose either the pay (7th CPC) fixed in the deputation post
( Regional Director), or to draw the pay of the post held by him ( Assistant
Professor) in his parent department. This is not in dispute.
23.
In sub-Clause (i) of Clause 2, it is also stated that the appointment
on deputation basis will be with a particular pay (either Central Government
or Government of Tripura) plus a deputation duty allowance in accordance
with and subject to the conditions as modified from time to time.
24.
In our view, the words “as modified from time to time” apply to
both pay and deputation duty allowance.
25.
If there is a pay revision by the Central Government of the pay
for the post of Regional Director, the University would have to pay the same
to the deputationist, who opts for the said pay.
26.
A fortiorari the same logic applies if there is a revision of pay in
the post of Assistant Professor by the State Government as well. It has to pay
as revised even for the post of Asst.Professor.
27.
Consequently the deputationist like the appellant is entitled to
modification / revision of pay of the post of Assistant Professor in the State of
Tripura (if he opts for it).
28.
2026:THC:540-DB
It is not open to the respondents to confine the words “as
modified from time to time” only to a pay revision in the Central Government
pay scale, and not to the pay revision in the post of Assistant Professor in the
State of Tripura, which post the appellant was holding in his parent
department before being appointed on deputation as Regional Director.
29.
We also are of the opinion that, as regards ‘pay’, sub-Clause (ii)
of Clause 2 will not apply to a person like the appellant who exercises the
option to draw the pay of the post held by him in his parent department in the
State Government.
30.
Also it will only apply if he exercises the option to choose to
receive the pay fixed in the deputation post of Assistant Regional Director for
which the pay and allowances are fixed by the Government of India.
31.
The learned Single Judge has not noticed the words “as modified
from time to time” in sub-Clause (i) of Clause 2, or the fact that the said words
apply to the modification in both the Central Government pay scale and the
State Government pay scale, and erroneously denied relief to the appellant.
32.
Now coming to Clause 2 (vii), it states:
“During the period of your appointment in this university, in
addition to Govt. of India rules, you will be governed by the Act,
Statutes, ordinances and regulations of the University and other
Rules relating to conditions of service applicable to academic
staff of the University modified from time to time.”
33.
This clause has no relevance as far as pay and allowances are
concerned and will apply only for other service conditions like leave,
disciplinary proceedings, etc. This is because the aspect of ‘pay’ is already
dealt with in Clause 2(i) and (ii).
34.
2026:THC:540-DB
So once the appellant exercised the option, and opted to take the
pay of the post held by him in his parent department i.e. the post of Assistant
Professor in the State of Tripura, the University cannot turn around and say
that in view of sub-Clauses (ii) and (vii), he cannot seek more pay than what
the Government of India fixes for the deputation post.
35.
Therefore, the judgment dt.27.08.2024 of the learned Single
Judge is set aside; the Office Order dt.23.01.2023 issued by the Director,
ACD, IGNOU rejecting the claim of the appellant for re-fixation of pay in
conformity with the revised pay structure relating to the post of Assistant
Professor under the Department of Higher Education, Government of Tripura,
is also set aside; and the respondents No.1 to 4 are directed to pay to the
appellant the revised pay structure relating to the post of Assistant Professor
under the Department of Higher Education, Government of Tripura for the
period 20.04.2022 to 31.03.2023 within 2(two) months.
36.
The instant Writ Appeal is allowed with the above observations
and directions. No costs.
(BISWAJIT PALIT, J)
Pijush/
PULAK BANIK
Date: 2026.04.28 15:27:05 +05'30'
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review