Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
W.A. No.139 of 2023
1.
Dr. Sukomal Sarkar, son of late Nirod Baran Sarkar, resident of Melarmath,
Gangail Road, Agartala, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, Sub-division Agartala,
District West Tripura, aged about 54 years.
.....Appellant
_V_E_R_S_U_S_
1.
The State of Tripura, through the Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Health
& Family Welfare Department, New Secretariat Complex, Agartala, P.O. Agartala
Secretariat, PIN-799010, West Tripura.
2.
The Deputy Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Health & Family Welfare
Department, New Secretariat Complex, Agartala, P.O. Agartala Secretariat,
District: West Tripura, PIN-799010.
3.
The Director of Medical Education, Government of Tripura, Bidur Karta
Chowmuhani, Agartala, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District: West Tripura,
PIN-799001.
4.
The Principal, Agartala Government Medical College & GBP Hospital, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala, District: West Tripura.
5.
Dr. Dipen Roy, son of Sri Dilip Roy, resident of Akhaura Road, P.O. Agartala,
P.S. West Agartala, District: West Tripura.
.....Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing and
Judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
24.04.2024
YES/NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
_F_I_N_A_L_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
[T. AMARNATH GOUD, J]
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel and Mr. S. M. Chakraborty,
learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing
for the appellant also heard Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for
the respondents.
[2]
The present appeal has been filed as per Tripura High Court Rules as
per notification dated 21.03.2023 regarding practice and procedure for filing writ
appeal preferred against the impugned judgment and order dated 30.08.2023 passed
in WP(C) No.194 of 2022 passed by the learned Single Judge.
[3]
The appellant has prayed for the following reliefs:
“i. Admit this writ appeal.
ii. Call for the relevant records, pertaining to the impugned judgment & order
(Oral) dated 30.08.2023 (Annexure-8 supra), passed in WP(C) No.194 of 2023.
iii. After hearing the parties, in terms of the grounds set forth above, be pleased
to quash/set aside the impugned judgment & order (Oral) dated 30.08.2023
(Annexure-7 supra) passed in WP(C) No.194 of 2023, and thereafter, allow this
writ appeal.”
[4]
The facts leading to this case, in brief is that the appellant is an MS
in Orthopaedics and while working in the post of Medical Officer, under the
Tripura Health Services [THS for short] he was declared as full time
Registrar/Tutor vide notification dated 16.02.2012. In recognition of such service
as Registrar in the Department of Orthopaedics, Agartala Government Medical
College (AGMC for short) and GBP Hospital, Agartala, Head of the Department,
Orthopaedics, AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala wrote a Letter dated 06.02.2020
to the Principal, wherein a categorical statement was made with reference to the
appellant and to another Dr. Tushar Kanti Chowdhury to the effect that the said two
Senior Registrars, working in the Department for the last several years deserve
immediate uplift of their status to the post of Assistant Professor, but the same was
not considered by the respondents. Copies of the Certificate of M.S. Degree & the
Letter dated 06.02.2020, were annexed to the WP, as Annexures 1 & 3
respectively.
[5]
The appellant, in the WP, contended that the In-Charge Head of the
Department, the respondent No.4 had issued a Certificate dated 22.08.2017,
certifying that the appellant had served in the Department of Orthopaedics as a
Registrar/Senior Resident in AGMC and GBP Hospital, Agartala, under the Health
and Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura, for the period from
01.05.2011 to 25.09.2012, and that the appellant is working in the same
Department as Registrar from 30.09.2016 till the date of issuance of the Certificate.
[6]
Having all the eligibility to be appointed to the post of Assistant
Professor in the Department of Orthopaedics, AGMC and GBP Hospital, Agartala,
but for certain unintelligible reason, the respondents have not considered it
necessary & appropriate to absorb the appellant in the post of Registrar/Tutor in the
Department of Orthopedics in which he has been serving as such from the year
2012. Despite the devoted service of the appellant in the post of Registrar/Tutor,
since his engagement, the respondents have not even paid the special allowance of
Rs.3,000/- per month for working as such, and trying to disown their responsibility
& liability to recognize the said service of the appellant in the post of
Registrar/Tutor.
[7]
The respondent No.5, who is only a Diploma holder in Orthopedics,
has been absorbed as Basic Teacher in the post of Registrar/Tutor when the
appellant being a holder of Masters Degree in the said subject has been ignored. By
a Notification dated 12.09.2017, twenty three numbers of Medical Officers, who
were working in different Grades in Tripura Health Services and were engaged as
Basic Teacher (Tutor, Senior Resident, Registrar) in the AGMC & GBP Hospital
within the period of 2005 to September, 2015 and still working under the AGMC
as Basic Teacher have been absorbed on regular basis with effect from 22.08.2017
in the pay scale of Rs. 13,575-37,000/- with Grade pay of Rs.3,700/-, Special
Allowance of Rs.3,000/- and other allowances as admissible.
[8]
In the Notification dated 12.09.2017, it has been specifically
mentioned that the said absorption on regular basis in the post of Basic Teachers
have been made for those who were engaged as Basic Teacher in the AGMC &
GBP Hospital, Agartala within the period of 2005 to September, 2015 and still
working under the AGMC as Basic Teacher. The said criteria shown to have been
followed by the State respondents for the purpose of regularization is not at all
applicable in case of the private respondent No.5 as he never acted as Basic
Teacher in the AGMC and GBP Hospital, Agartala within the period of 2005 to
September, 2015.
[9]
The first posting of the respondent No.5 as Medical Officer was in
the year 1992 in Sonamura Rural Hospital. In the year 2000, he went for PG
(Diploma) in Wardha and after completion of the same he returned in the year
2002, and joined the said Sonamura Rural Hospital. In the year 2003, he was
transferred to Dharmanagar and worked there up to 2007. In the year 2007, he was
transferred to Udaipur and worked there up to May, 2012. Only in the month of
May, 2012, the said respondent No.5 was transferred to the AGMC & GBP
Hospital, Agartala, and thereby he had no occasion/scope to work in the post of
Basic Teacher in the AGMC & GBP hospital from 2005 to September, 2015.
Hence, the respondent No.5 was most wrongly & illegally absorbed in the post of
Basic Teacher (Registrar/Tutor) in the AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala in regular
capacity depriving the appellant, who has been working as Basic Teacher
continuously in the said hospital, since his initial engagement with effect from
16.02.2012, and also that the appellant is a Masters Degree Holder (MS three years
course in Orthopedics) when the respondent No.5 is a PG Diploma Holder in
Orthopedics.
[10]
Furthermore, the appellant contended that one Dr. Anupam Debnath,
who has been appointed to the post of Assistant Professor in the Department of
Orthopedics by notification dated 22.06.2020, who is admittedly junior to the
appellant, said Dr. Anupam Debnath was appointed to the post of Assistant
Professor in the AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala in regular capacity without
following the procedure of such appointment as no open advertisement was made
for the said post, inviting application from the other eligible candidates and
selection through the Tripura Public Service Commission.
[11]
That apart from his continuous working in the post of Basic Teacher
in the AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala from 16.02.2012, it would appear from
the Certificate dated 12.05.2011, issued by the RIMS, Imphal that during the 3
years period of Post Graduate Training, the appellant took active part in teaching
programmes of the Institute.
[12]
Being highly aggrieved, the appellant filed a writ petition, marked as
WP(C) No.430 of 2020, inter alia praying for his regularization to the post of
Registrar of AGMC & GBP Hospital, however, the said writ petition was
withdrawn with a liberty to file afresh. After withdrawal of the said writ petition,
the appellant submitted a Demand Notice dated 22.03.2023, upon the respondents,
to regularize the service of the appellant to the post of Registrar in the Department
of Orthopedics, in the AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala, by taking into account
his past service rendered by him in the said post following the notification dated
16.02.2012, and thereby pay the arrear allowances to the appellant, which he is
entitled at the rate of Rs.3,000/- per month.
[13]
Seeing no response thereto, the appellant presented another writ
petition, marked as WP(C) No.434 of 2021 before this Court inter alia praying for
regularization of the appellant to the post of Registrar of AGMC & GBP Hospital,
which was disposed of, thereby directing the appellant to approach before the
appropriate forum, if he is aggrieved by any decision/action of the Government.
Pursuant thereto, the appellant was under the reasonable & legitimate expectation
that the respondents would consider the genuine case of the appellant in a positive
manner, whereas, on the contrary, the respondent No.2 issued an Order dated
04.10.2021, thereby rejecting the claim of the appellant, regarding his
regularization/absorption in the post of Registrar.
[14]
In view of above and having heard the learned counsel appearing for
the parties, the learned Single Judge has observed as under:
“.....14. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner at the end has submitted that
since the petitioner has performed knee replacement surgery for the first time in
the State of Tripura successfully in AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala in the
year 2023, as such the respondent-authorities should consider him for being
engaged/absorbed in the Tripura Medical Education Service for providing
better and specialized healthcare service to the inhabitants of the State. In the
present writ petition considering the nature of the challenge, this Court is not
required to make any comments on such a plea. However, it is up to the
competent authority under the Tripura Medical Education Department to take
into consideration such plea if raised by the petitioner. Writ petition is,
therefore, dismissed......”
[15]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the same, the present appeal
has been preferred by the appellant before this Court for redress.
[16]
Mr. S. Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. P. Chakraborty,
learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that at the time of
passing the impugned Judgment & Order (Oral) dated 30.08.2023, the learned
Single Judge has failed to appreciate that by the notification dated 12.09.2017, it
was specifically mentioned those Medical Officers (of different Grades) of THS,
who were engaged as Basic Teacher (Tutor, Senior Resident/Registrar) in AGMC
& GBP Hospital, within the period 2005 to September, 2015 and still working
under AGMC, as Basic Teacher, were absorbed on regular basis with effect from
22.08.2017, along with the Special Allowance of Rs.3,000/- and other allowance as
admissible, in AGMC under Tripura Medical Education Services (Administrative
& Faculty). In such view of the matter, it can be stated that the appellant has been
working in the post of Basic Teacher in the AGMC & GBP Hospital from
16.02.2012 itself, issued by the RIMS, Imphal during the 3 years training of the
petitioner and as such, the appellant squarely covers the said condition of the
notification dated 12.09.2017.
[17]
He was engaged as Basic Teacher i.e. Registrar in AGMC & GBP
Hospital and within the period of 2005 to September, 2015 the appellant joined the
post of Basic Teacher from 16.02.2012. Hence, the appellant is wholly entitled to
be absorbed as Basic Teacher, i.e., Registrar/Tutor in AGMC & GBP Hospital, on
regular basis, with effect from the date of his initial engagement, i.e., 16.02.2012
and also the Special allowances of Rs.3,000/-.
[18]
At the time of passing of the impugned Judgment & Order dated
30.08.2023 the learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate that the first posting of
the respondent No.5 as Medical Officer was in the year 1992 in Sonamura Rural
Hospital. In the year 2000, he went for PG (Diploma) in Wardha and after
completion of the same he returned in the year 2002, and joined the said Sonamura
Rural Hospital. In the year 2003, he was transferred to Dharmanagar and worked
there upto 2007. In the year 2007, he was transferred to Udaipur and worked there
upto May, 2012. Only in the month of May, 2012, the said respondent No.5 was
transferred to the AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala, and thereby he had no
occasion/scope to work in the post of Basic Teacher in the AGMC & GBP hospital
from 2005 to September, 2015. Hence, the respondent No.5 was most wrongly &
illegally absorbed in the post of Basic Teacher (Registrar/Tutor) in the AGMC &
GBP Hospital, Agartala in regular capacity depriving the appellant, who has been
working as Basic Teacher continuously in the said hospital, since his initial
engagement w.e.f. 16.02.2012 and also that the appellant is a Masters Degree
Holder whereas, on the contrary, the respondent No.5 is a PG Diploma Holder in
Orthopedics.
[19]
The impugned Judgment & Order dated 30.08.2023, the learned
Single Judge has failed to appreciate that even though, the appellant has been
performing his duties as Registrar, but he has not been paid the Special Allowance
of Rs.3,000/-, since the date of his inception to the said post, i.e., 16.02.2012. In the
year 2012, the appellant was holding the post of Senior Registrar, which is a GradeIII post under the THS. Thereafter, after completion of five years of service in the
said post, the appellant was promoted to Grade-II, under the THS in the year 2021.
Even though, Assistant Professor is a Grade II post, and the appellant was
promoted to Grade-II, but he was not given the status of Assistant Professor of
Tripura Medical Education Service.
[20]
Pursuant to the Notification dated 16.02.2012, the appellant absorbed
as Full Time Registrar/Tutor in the AGMC & GBP Hospital, and subsequently, by
various correspondences, the said status of the appellant was duly recognized.
Subsequent Notification dated 12.09.2017 would not have any inroad on to the
status, previously conferred on to the appellant. A contrast of the Notification dated
16.02.2012 & the Notification dated 12.09.2017 would make a revelation that none
of the 14 persons, whose names find place in the Notification dated 18.02.2012,
find mention in the latter Notification dated 12.09.2017.
[21]
Without soliciting his consent, the appellant was sent on deputation,
and thereafter, the aforementioned deputation was treated as transfer, and therefore,
he continued to work in District Hospital Gomati Tripura, which was previously
named as Tripura Sundari District Hospital, Udaipur. The impugned Judgment &
Order dated 30.08.2023, the learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate that on
being sent on deputation, as a Grade-III Medical Officer of THS, by a Notification
dated 31.12.2021, the appellant was promoted to Grade-II of THS, from the feeder
post of Grade-III of THS. Unless, the service in the feeder category is regular, no
promotion can be accorded. In other words, a promotion pre-supposes that a
government servant was holding the feeder post in a substantive capacity.
[22]
It has been further contended that the post of Senior Registrar/Tutor
of Tripura Medical Education Service is equivalent to the post of Grade-III of THS,
and that the post of Assistant Professor of Tripura Medical Education Service is
equivalent to the post of Grade-II of THS. Since, the initial appointment of the
appellant was to the post of Senior Registrar/Tutor, and thereafter, only by way of
deputation, and that too, without obtaining his consent, he was sent on deputation,
in the equivalent post of Grade-III of THS, and consequent upon his promotion to
Grade-II of THS, the lien that the appellant was holding, in the substantive capacity
of Senior Registrar/Tutor of Tripura Medical Education Service, would not stand
forfeited and that on to his repatriation, the appellant is entitled to urge for his
restoration of his status, i.e., the corresponding status of Grade-II of THS, namely,
Assistant Professor of Tripura Medical Education Service.
[23]
Vide notification dated 04.08.2015, the Tripura Medical Education
(Administration & Faculty) Service Conditions Rules, 2015 was promulgated, with
a specific stipulation that the same would come into force, from the date of its
publication in the Official Gazette. Rule-9 of the said Rules has created a legal
fiction, inter alia mandating that the Registrar/Senior Resident of the AGMC &
GBP Hospital would be considered as members of Tripura Medical Education
(Administration & Faculty) Service Conditions, on & from the date of
commencement of the service. By virtue of the notification dated 16.02.2012, the
appellant on being appointed as full time Registrar/Tutor, on the strength of the
said Rule of the Rules, became a member of Tripura Medical Education
(Administration & Faculty) Service Conditions and the fortuitous circumstance,
namely, at that relevant time, the appellant was sent on deputation, but without his
consent, would not have any bearing whatsoever on to the appellant.
[24]
Rule-10 of the Tripura Medical Education (Administration &
Faculty) Service Conditions Rules, 2015, which inter alia conceives of option, has
no application to the case of the appellant inasmuch as the Proviso appended
thereto mandates that any person from THS, appointed as Basic Teacher, in the
Tripura Medical Education (Administration & Faculty) Service, who has failed to
be selected/appointed as Assistant Professor in the said service, shall be eligible for
opting out from Medical Education Service.
[25]
A bare reading of the texts of both Annexure-1 & Annexure-II of
Schedule II(A), can under no circumstances, be applied to the appellant inasmuch
as at the relevant time, the appellant was serving on deputation in the Tripura
Health Service, and not the Tripura Medical Education Service, and neither he was
holding any teaching post in any Medical College nor was her holding any post,
under the Tripura Medical Education (Administrative & Faculty) Service
Conditions, and therefore, given a chance, the appellant could not have fitted
himself in either of the two options o Annexure-1 & Annexure-II of Schedule II(A)
of the Tripura Medical Education (Administration & Faculty) Service Conditions
Rules, 2015.
[26]
On the relevant date, namely, 12.11.2017 as would be manifest from
the notification dated 12.11.2017, the private respondent No.5 was holding a post,
in the Tripura Health Service, and that at the time of his absorption, in the Tripura
Medical Education Service, he was not holding any post thereat, and therefore,
applying the same yardstick as that of the appellant, the private respondent was also
ineligible to be absorbed in the Tripura Medical Education (Administration &
Faculty) Service Conditions Rules, 2015. As such, the impugned Judgment &
Order dated 30.08.2023, passed by the learned Single Judge, needs set aside.
[27]
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. has submitted that the
appellant was never appointed on regular post to the post of full time
Registrar/Tutor as per the said notification. The appellant is not similarly situated
with others who have exercised their option in the option form and submitted
accordingly, and after that they were absorbed as Basic Teacher (Registrar) in the
Department of Orthopaedics, AGMC & GBP Hospital, whereas, other doctors had
also exercised the said option submitted the same within the stipulated time period.
[28]
Furthermore, it has been contended that Dr. Dipen Roy has
completed Post Graduate Diploma in Orthopaedics, in the year 2001, whereas, Dr.
Sukomal Sarkar was only MBBS till 2010. Therefore, it is evident that the
appellant was less qualified than Dr. Dipen Roy at that time. Since, the appellant
has not impleaded said Dr. Anupam Debnath as a party to the writ petition, no
relief could be granted to the appellant.
[29]
The appellant never joined or served as a fulltime Registrar/Tutor and
therefore has never got the benefit for the said post. In support of the said claim, the
appellant failed to submit the joining report as Registrar/Tutor, neither could he
place any document showing that he drew Rs.3000/- as a special allowance for the
said post. Furthermore, according to Tripura Medical Education (Administrative &
Faculty) Service Conditions Rules, 2015, there is no post named as "Senior most
Registrar" or "Senior Registrars", as mentioned in the Letter dated 06.02.2020
(Annexure-3 to the connected WP).
[30]
Pursuant to the joining of his service, the respondent No.5 started
serving as Registrar from 08.11.2014 and thereafter, on 13.11.2014 he was declared
as fulltime Registrar in Department of Orthopaedics in GBP & AGMC Hospital. It
was further contended that the appellant was first sent on deputation and thereafter
the aforementioned deputation was treated as transfer and therefore, he continued
to work in District Hospital Gomati Tripura, which was previously named as
Tripura Sundari District Hospital, Udaipur. The appellant was subsequently
transferred from District Hospital Gomati Tripura. Udaipur to AGMC and GBP
Hospital by Order dated 08.09.2016, wherein the post of the appellant was referred
to as Grade-IV of THS.
[31]
The Tripura Medical Education (Administrative & Faculty) Service
Conditions Rules, 2015 (referred to as the Principal Rules, 2015) came into effect
on 21.09.2015. The said Service Conditions Rules, 2015 were framed under
proviso to Article-309 of the Constitution of India and all other enabling powers in
this behalf. The appellant has neither exercised the option for absorption nor is
eligible for such absorption. The appellant after being deputed to the Tripura
Sundari Hospital, Udaipur continued to work over there and thereafter his
deputation was converted into transfer and/or he was transferred to Tripura Sundari
Hospital, Udaipur (presently known as District Hospital Gomati Tripura).
[32]
It was further alleged that the appellant claimed to be the Registrar of
Orthopaedics Department, which falls under the Tripura Medical Education, and
again, the appellant stated that he was promoted from Medical Officer, Grade-III to
Medical Officer, Grade-II, which is under the Tripura Health Service. Both the
claims made by the appellant on out in Paragraphs 6 & 7 are contradictory to his
statement made on oath, in Paragraph-11, as one person cannot hold two posts
simultaneously in different departments. The appellant failed to show any
document that he even applied to be absorbed as a faculty teacher in due time and
under due procedure. The contentions of the appellant are completely false and
hence should be dismissed. The appellant had suppressed various documents along
with the Principal Rules, 2015 along with the amendments, with a mala-fide
intention.
[33]
In view of above and having heard the learned counsel appearing for
the parties, we are of the opinion that the representation was rejected by the
competent authority but, the reasons as assigned in the order is not satisfactory
explained. In that impugned order only 2015 Rules referred and under Rule 5(b) his
option has not been exercised, thus rejected his case. It has been specifically said
that on the date of appointment he should exercise his option so on the date of his
appointment in 2012 question of option does not arise thus, how these 2015 rules
can be made retrospective effect. Unless an express provision is made and also
gives all those employees who are appointed prior to 2015 Rule to sensitize them
about the new rules that they are to exercise their option since 2012 they have not
exercised their option and for that, appropriate time was also given, such attempt
was not taken by the respondent. So in such case did the respondent inform him that
according to new rules option is necessary and the appellant has to exercise his option.
[34]
What happened to the procedure that the respondents suppose to follow
that has not been uttered in the impugned order and opportunity was also not given for
his option and that is why the appellant did not exercise his option. According to
Rule-5(b) of the rules, at the time of appointment the appellant has to exercise his
option. Since there is no specific reply to this question, it can be presumed that this
rule has not applicability in the case in hand. Now, by way of 2016 amendment, the
appellant falls under this amendment and in terms of this rule whether the respondents
gave an opportunity for exercising the option or the appellant is not at all eligible for
the same, nothing has been uttered by the respondent side. More so, the Rules referred
is 2015 and the appointment is of 2012. Rule-5(b) cannot have retrospective effect on
2012. The impugned order of the respondent is a non-speaking and un-reasoned order
on the said issue. There is no discussion by the respondent in the impugned order
about amended Rules and opportunity of option. When the Rules are framed in 2015,
the appointment is much before and thus it cannot be said or construed that the
petitioner is supposed to exercise option suo moto. It is the bounded duty of the
government respondents to sensitize its employees about the change in service
conditions subsequent to their appointment.
[35]
In view of the law as has been articulated in a large number of cases
where this Court has observed that any discriminatory action on the part of the
government would be liable to be struck down. Hence, in this case, it can safely be
said that the appellant was not provided opportunity to exercise his option. In absence
of any such material it can well be inferred that the appellant had no knowledge about
the option called by the respondents.
[36]
In that view of the matter, this Court is of the considered view that ends
of justice would be met if the matter is remand back to the appropriate authority for
fresh adjudication and take steps in accordance with law as early as possible. And
accordingly, the same is ordered. Thus, the order of the learned Single Judge and the
impugned proceeding of rejection stand set aside since the same are unreasoned. As a
sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
B. PALIT, J
A. Ghosh
ANJAN GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH Date: 2024.05.02
15:49:41 +05'30'
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review