Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SOURABH
BHILWAR
2026:CGHC:5419
NAFR
SOURABH BHILWAR
Date: 2026.02.04
10:48:47 +0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
SA No. 582 of 2024
1 - Dr. Somesh Pandey S/o Late Parmanand Pandey Aged About 67
Years R/o Subhash Ward, Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Chetan Anand Pandey S/o Late Parmanand Pandey Aged About 65
Years R/o Subhash Ward, Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
3 - Rakesh Pandey S/o Late Parmanand Pandey Aged About 58 Years
R/o
Subhash
Ward,
Jagdalpur,
District
Bastar,
Chhattisgarh.
4 - Smt. Shanti Pandey W/o Late Parmanand Pandey Aged About 84
Years R/o Subhash Ward, Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
... Appellants
versus
1 - Vishweshwar Prasad Pandey (Since Died) S/o Late Jagannath
Pandey, Through Lrs.
1(A) Devshankar Pandey S/o Late Vishweshwar Prasad Pandey R/o
Village Aasana, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
1(B) Tulsidas Pandey S/o Late Vishweshwar Prasad Pandey R/o Village
Aasana, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
1(C) Tukaram Pandey S/o Late Vishweshwar Prasad Pandey R/o
Village Aasana, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
1(D) Jagjeevan Pandey S/o Late Vishweshwar Prasad Pandey R/o
Village Aasana, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
1(E) Janki Pandey S/o Late Vishweshwar Prasad Pandey R/o Village
Aasana, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
1(F) Sharda Pandey S/o Late Vishweshwar Prasad Pandey R/o Village
Aasana, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
1(G) Gayatri Pandey D/o Late Vishweshwar Prasad Pandey R/o Village
Aasana, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
1(H) Jaineshwari Pandey D/o Late Vishweshwar Prasad Pandey R/o
Village Aasana, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Shri Krishna Pandey (Since Died) S/o Late Godawari Prasad
Pandey. Through Lrs.
2(A) Smt. Shanti Pandey (Since Died And Deleted) W/o Late Shree
Krishna
Pandey
R/o
Vijay
Ward,
Jagdalpur,
District
Bastar,
Chhattisgarh.
2(B) Manoj Pandey S/o Late Shree Krishna Pandey R/o Vijay Ward,
Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
2(C) Awdhesh Pandey S/o Late Shree Krishna Pandey R/o Vijay Ward,
Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
2(D) Lokesh Pandey S/o Late Shree Krishna Pandey R/o Vijay Ward,
Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
2(E) Bholeshankar Pandey S/o Late Shree Krishna Pandey R/o Vijay
Ward, Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
2(F) Haripriya D/o Late Shree Krishna Pandey R/o Vijay Ward,
Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
3 - Jogeshwar Pandey S/o Late Vidyadhar Pandey R/o Village Chhote
Jeerakhal, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
4 - Narendra S/o Late Laxminarayan Pandey R/o Village Chhote
Jeerakhal, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
5 - Kodand S/o Late Laxminarayan Pandey R/o Village Chhote
Jeerakhal, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
6 - Yudhisthir S/o Late Laxminarayan Pandey R/o Village Chhote
Jeerakhal, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
7 - Smt. Gandhari Devi W/o Late Laxminarayan Pandey R/o Village
Chhote Jeerakhal, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
…. Respondent(s)
(Cause title is taken from CIS)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Manoj Paranjpe, Senior Advocate
alongwith Mr. Sandeep Patel, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Justice Bibhu Datta Guru
Judgment on Board
31/01/2026
1.
The present Second Appeal has been filed under Section 100 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, assailing the impugned
judgment and decree dated 11.09.2024 passed by the learned
Second District Judge, Bastar at Jagdalpur (C.G.) in Civil Appeal
No. 30-A/2018, affirming the judgment and decree dated
31.03.2018 passed by the learned 3rd Civil Judge, Class-I,
Jagdalpur (C.G.), in Civil Suit No. 31-A/2002, whereby the civil
appeal filed by the appellants/plaintiffs was dismissed. The
present appeal has been preferred by the appellants/ plaintiffs.
For the sake of convenience, the parties shall hereinafter be
referred to as per their status before the Trial Court.
2.
The appellants/ plaintiffs filed the suit seeking declaration of title,
partition, possession and permanent injunction, pleading inter alia
that the suit properties described in Schedules (घ), (प) and (फ) are
ancestral/self-acquired properties of their predecessors, over
which the plaintiffs and defendant No.2 have joint title and
possession; that the property described in Schedule (ख) is the
self-acquired property of late Parmanand Pandey and exclusively
belongs to the plaintiffs; and that the agricultural lands described
in Schedules (ड) and (क) are ancestral properties in which the
plaintiffs are entitled to 1/6th share. It is further pleaded that an
earlier decree dated 26.03.1981 passed in Civil Suit No. 4-A/79
and affirmed in Appeal No. 186/1981 by judgment dated
16.08.1990 was obtained by defendant No.1’s predecessor by
misrepresentation, without impleading necessary parties, and
under an illegal proceeding under Order 33 Rule 1 CPC, and
therefore the said decree is not binding on the plaintiffs. Hence
the plaintiffs have sought declaration of title, partition, possession
and permanent injunction over the suit property.
3.
Per contra, defendant No.1, while admitting certain facts, denied
the remaining pleadings of the plaintiffs and contended that no
cause of action arose in their favour. It was pleaded that the
subject matter of the present suit had already been adjudicated in
Civil Suit No. 4-A/79, which was decided by judgment and decree
dated 26.03.1981 by the learned Additional District Judge, Bastar,
and the said decree was affirmed in First Appeal No. 186/1981 by
the High Court vide judgment dated 16.08.1990. It was further
contended that the parties to the earlier proceedings were
substantially the same and the subject matter and issues involved
were identical; therefore, the present suit is barred by the principle
of res judicata. According to the defendants, the suit properties
were joint family properties, and the rights of the parties stood
finally determined in the earlier proceedings, rendering the
present claim not maintainable. Hence the defendants prayed for
dismissal of the suit.
4.
After framing the issues and upon due appreciation of the oral as
well as documentary evidence available on record, the learned
Trial Court dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiffs, holding that the
plaintiffs have failed to prove their title and possession over the
suit land. Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree dated
31/03/2018, the plaintiffs preferred a First Appeal under Section
96 of the Code of Civil Procedure before the learned First
Appellate Court. The learned First Appellate Court, on reappreciation of the entire evidence on record, affirmed the
findings recorded by the Trial Court and dismissed the appeal by
the impugned judgment. Hence, the present appeal.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellants submits that both the learned
Courts have erred in dismissing the suit by mechanically applying
Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure. It is contended that the
earlier judgment and decree passed in Civil Suit No. 4-A/1979 and
affirmed in FA No. 186/1981 by the High Court were obtained on
the basis of incorrect pleadings by treating self-acquired
properties as joint Hindu family properties and without impleading
necessary parties, namely the present appellants. It is argued that
the suit properties are either self-acquired or ancestral properties,
in which the appellants are entitled to declaration and partition,
and therefore the findings recorded by the learned Courts holding
the suit to be barred by res judicata are perverse, contrary to the
evidence on record and give rise to substantial questions of law
warranting interference under Section 100 CPC.
6.
I have heard learned counsel for the appellants on the question of
admission, and the impugned judgments and decrees passed by
the learned trial Court as also the learned First Appellate Court
have been carefully examined.
7.
In the case at hand, both the learned trial Court as well as the
learned First Appellate Court, upon due appreciation of the
pleadings, oral and documentary evidence on record, have
concurrently held that the subject matter of the suit had already
been adjudicated in Civil Suit No. 4-A/1979, decided by judgment
and decree dated 26.03.1981, which stood affirmed by the High
Court of Madhya Pradesh in First Appeal No. 186/1981 vide
judgment dated 16.08.1990. Both the Courts have further
recorded a categorical finding that the parties, subject matter and
issues involved in the present suit are substantially the same as
those in the earlier proceedings and that the suit properties are
joint Hindu family properties, the rights whereof stood finally
determined. The plea of the appellants that the earlier decree is
not binding on them has been duly considered and negated. No
perversity,
misreading
of
evidence
or
legal
infirmity
is
demonstrated so as to warrant interference with the concurrent
findings of fact in exercise of jurisdiction under Section 100 of the
Code of Civil Procedure.
8.
Even otherwise, the scope of interference in a Second Appeal
under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure is extremely
limited. Interference is permissible only when the appeal involves
a substantial question of law. Concurrent findings of fact recorded
by both the Courts cannot be interfered with unless such findings
are shown to be perverse, based on no evidence, or contrary to
settled principles of law.
9.
In the present case, both the Trial Court and the First Appellate
Court have concurrently recorded findings, on the basis of
evidence available on record, that the appellants/ plaintiffs failed
to establish their case by placing cogent and sufficient material.
The appellants have failed to demonstrate any perversity,
illegality, or misapplication of law in the findings so recorded.
10.
The questions sought to be raised in the present Second Appeal
essentially relate to re-appreciation of evidence and challenge to
concurrent findings of fact. Such questions do not give rise to any
substantial question of law within the meaning of Section 100 of
the Code of Civil Procedure.
11.
It is well established that when there is a concurrent finding of
fact, unless it is found to be perverse, the Court should not
ordinarily interfere with the said finding.
12.
In the matter of State of Rajasthan and others Vs. Shiv Dayal
and another, reported in (2019) 8 SCC 637, reiterating the settled
proposition, it has been held that when any concurrent finding of
fact is assailed in second appeal, the appellant is entitled to point
out that it is bad in law because it was recorded de hors the
pleadings or based on misreading of material documentary
evidence or it was recorded against any provision of law and
lastly, the decision is one which no Judge acting judicially could
reasonably have reached.
13.
Be that as it may, the argument advanced by learned counsel for
the appellants and the proposed question of law cannot be
regarded as satisfying the test of being ‘substantial question of
law’ within the meaning of Section 100 of CPC. These questions,
in my view, are essentially question of facts. The appellants failed
to raise any substantial question of law which is required under
Section 100 of the CPC. In any event, the Second Appeal did not
involve any substantial question of law as contemplated under
Section 100 of the CPC, no case is made out by the appellants
herein. The judgments impugned passed by the learned trial
Court as as well as by the learned First Appellate Court are just
and proper and there is no illegality and infirmity at all.
14.
Having heard learned counsel for the appellants and on perusal of
the record of the case and in view of the above settled legal
proposition, I find absolutely no merit in this appeal, involving no
question of law much less substantial question of law within the
meaning of Section 100 of the CPC. In my view, the judgment and
decree passed by both the Courts appear to be just, proper and
legal. The findings recorded are based on proper appreciation of
evidence available on record and there is no illegality or perversity
in the same and they does not call for any interference.
15.
Consequently, the Second Appeal fails and is hereby dismissed
in limine resulting in upholding of the judgment and decree of the
trial Court as well as the Appellate Court.
Sd/(Bibhu Datta Guru)
Judge
$. Bhilwar
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review