The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Accordingly, writ petition is allowed. Impugned communicated dated
28. 07.2025 (Annexure P-2) is quashed. Respondents are directed to convene a Review Departmental Promotion Committee (Review DPC) 10 / 10 to re-consider the case of the petitioner for promotion to the post of Professor, by ignoring the uncommunicated ACRs with adverse entries.
16. In the event the petitioner is found fit for promotion by the Review DPC recommends her name, she shall be granted promotion from the date her immediate junior was promoted, with all consequential benefits, including notional seniority and fixation of pay. However, she will not be entitled for arrears of salary.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1 / 10
2026:CGHC:19738
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Order Reserved on 21.04.2026
Order Delivered on 29.04.2026
Order Uploaded on
29.04.2026
WPS No. 12628 of 2025
Dr. Smt. Sunanda Maravi W/o Shri Manoj Markam Aged About 55 Years
Presently Posted And Working As Assistant Professor (Hindi) Government E.
Raghvendra Rao Postgraduate Science College, Bilaspur District- Bilaspur
(C.G.)
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through- Secretary Department Of Higher
Education Mantralaya, New Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.)
2 - The Commissioner, Higher Education Department, Block-3, Indravati
Bhawan, Naya Raipur, Atal Nagar, District- Raipur (C.G.)
3 - The Principal Government, E. Raghvendra Rao Postgraduate Science
College, Bilaspur District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner
For Respondents/State
Digitally
signed by
PRAVEEN
KUMAR
SINHA
Date:
2026.04.29
17:35:20
+0530
: Mr. Rahul Jha, Advocate
: Mr. Love Sharma, Panel Lawyer
2 / 10
S.B.: Hon'ble Shri Parth Prateem Sahu, Judge
CAV Order
1.
Petitioner
has
filed
this
writ
petition
aggrieved
by
the
communication/order dated 28th July 2025 (Annexure P-2) passed by
respondent authority by which her representation for inclusion of her
name in the list of eligible candidates for promotion to the post of
Professor has been rejected on the ground that petitioner failed to
secure the minimum benchmark of 13 marks in the evaluation of her
ACRs.
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that petitioner was initially
appointed as Assistant Professor (Hindi) with respondent No.3/College
on 14.12.1996. She successfully completed her Ph.D. in the year 2003
and thereafter she was awarded senior pay-scale and then selection
grade pay scale. On completion of three years on selection grade payscale, petitioner was granted academic grade-pay of Rs.9000/- since
14.12.2010. Petitioner fulfilled all the requisite eligibility criteria
prescribed for promotion to the post of Professor. When the petitioner
was in the zone of consideration of her promotion to the post of
Professor, surprisingly, she received communication dated 18.02.2025
by the respondent -Department wherein it was informed to her that
Annual Confidential Report (ACR) of the year 2011 contained adverse
remarks and petitioner was directed to submit her representation along
with relevant documents to which petitioner replied on 21 st February
2025 pleading therein different grounds including the crucial ground
that she was never communicated about adverse entry made in her
ACR for the relevant period. However, respondent authorities ignoring
3 / 10
representation of the petitioner, issued promotion order dated 29 th May
2025 excluding the name of petitioner. It is the contention of learned
counsel for the petitioner that adverse ACR had not been
communicated to the petitioner and as such she was not aware about
the adverse remarks entered in her ACR. Communication dated
18.02.2025 made to petitioner informing her about adverse grading in
the year 2011 i.e. after lapse of 14 years is clearly an empty formality.
She was never given any opportunity to file representation against her
adverse ACR. Since she was not considered for promotion only on the
basis of un-communicated ACR, the entire proceeding adopted by the
authorities for not considering her name for promotion by the DPC is
against the settled law. Non-communication of adverse ACR deprived
the petitioner of an opportunity to represent against the same. Relying
upon the Circular dated 16.12.2010 (Annexure P-4) issued by the State
Govt., learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that it is
made mandatory for all concerned authorities/departments to ensure
communication of every entry made in the ACR of employee within
time. Reasons assigned for denying consideration in respect of case of
the petitioner for grant of promotion is unwarranted. Consequently, the
grounds raised by the respondents to justify the non-consideration of
petitioner's case for promotion does not appear to be just, reasonable
and proper. In support of his contention, he placed reliance upon the
decision in the case of Dr. Smt. Veena Tripathi Vs. State of
Chhattisgarh & Ors. (WPS 7053 of 2016, decided on 09.10.2023).
3.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the State vehemently opposed
submission of learned counsel for the petitioner and submitted that the
4 / 10
DPC, after due evaluation and consideration of ACR of petitioner and
other candidates for the last 5 years commencing from 2008 to 2012
recommended the name of eligible candidates for promotion whereas
petitioner has been found unfit for promotion as the evaluation of the
marks of ACR of petitioner is not up to the benchmark as she had
failed to secure minimum 13 marks. There is no arbitrariness or
illegality in not considering the petitioner for promotion to the post of
Professor.
4.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and also perused the
documents enclosed along with this writ petition.
5.
It is not in dispute that the petitioner has had a long and unblemished
service career, having been initially appointed in the year 1996. It is
further undisputed that she acquired the requisite eligibility criteria for
promotion to the post of Professor. It is also an admitted position that
no departmental enquiry or criminal case was pending against her at
the relevant time when, the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC)
considered her candidature for promotion. Date of communication
made to petitioner of adverse entry recorded in his ACR for relevant
period is also not disputed by learned counsel for respondent/State i.e.
in the year 2025.
6.
Perusal of the documents enclosed along with writ petition revealed
that the petitioner was informed for the first time on 18.02.2025 about
an adverse remark in her ACR for the year 2011. The said
communication was issued long after the relevant period and at the
stage when her case for promotion was under consideration. Prior to
5 / 10
this, no adverse entry or below-benchmark grading had ever been
communicated to her, nor was she afforded any opportunity to
represent against the same. It is also pleaded by petitioner that after
receipt of the communication dated 18.02.2025, she submitted
representation on 21.02.2025 which remained undecided.
7.
The law relating to consideration of uncommunicated ACRs for
promotion or upgradation is no longer res integra. It is well settled that
non-communication of ACR entries which have civil consequences are
not to be considered. An employee must be made aware of any entry
that may adversely impact career progression so as to enable him/her
to improve performance or challenge the entry. Denial of such
opportunity is violative of principles of natural justice.
8.
In case of Dev Dutt Vs. Union of India, reported in (2008) 8 SCC
725, Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under :
“17. In our opinion, every entry in the A.C.R. of a
public servant must be communicated to him within a
reasonable period, whether it is a poor, fair, average,
good or very good entry. This is because noncommunication of such an entry may adversely affect
the employee in two ways : (1) Had the entry been
communicated to him he would know about the
assessment of his work and conduct by his superiors,
which would enable him to improve his work in future
(2) He would have an opportunity of making a
representation against the entry if he feels it is
unjustified, and pray for its upgradation. Hence noncommunication of an entry is arbitrary, and it has been
held by the Constitution Bench decision of this Court
6 / 10
in Maneka Gandhi vs. Union of India (supra) that
arbitrariness violates Article 14 of the Constitution.”
9.
In case of Sukhdev Singh Vs. Union of India & Ors. reported in
(2013) 9 SCC 566, Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under:
“8. In our opinion, the view taken in Dev Dutt that every
entry in ACR of a public servant must be communicated
to him/her within a reasonable period is legally sound
and helps in achieving threefold objectives. First, the
communication of every entry in the ACR to a public
servant helps him/her to work harder and achieve more
that helps him in improving his work and give better
results. Second and equally important, on being made
aware of the entry in the ACR, the public servant may
feel dissatisfied with the same. Communication of the
entry enables him/her to make representation for
upgradation of the remarks entered in the ACR. Third,
communication of every entry in the ACR brings
transparency in recording the remarks relating to a
public
servant
and
the
system
becomes
more
conforming to the principles of natural justice. We,
accordingly, hold that every entry in ACR – poor, fair,
average, good or very good – must be communicated to
him/her within a reasonable period.”
10.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Rukhsana Shaheen Khan Vs.
Union of India & Ors. reported in (2018) 18 SCC 640, relying upon its
earlier decision in case of Sukhdev Singh (supra), held as under:
“1. The sole issue involved in this appeal is whether
the uncommunicated Annual Confidential Reports
(ACRS), which are adverse to the appellant, should
7 / 10
have
been
relied
upon
for
the
purpose
of
consideration of the appellant for promotion.
2. In view of the decision of this Court in Sukhdev
Singh Vs. Union of India (2013) 9 SCC 566, there
cannot be any dispute on this aspect. This Court has
settled the law that uncommunicated and adverse
ACRs cannot be relied upon in the process.
3. This appeal is, accordingly, allowed and the
impugned judgment is set aside with the following
directions:
(a) the competent authority is directed to
ignore the uncommunicated adverse ACRs
and take a fresh decision in accordance with
law
(b) The appellant shall be afforded an
opportunity of hearing in the process."
11.
In case of Union of India & Ors. Vs. G.R. Meghwal reported in 2022
SCC
OnLine
SC
1291,
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
held
that
uncommunicated, downgraded Annual Confidential Reports (ACRs) or
Annual Performance Appraisal Reports (APARs) cannot be used to
deny promotions. The judgment reiterates that all performance ratings
(good, very good, etc.) must be communicated to the employee.
12.
Hon’ble Supreme Court again in the matter of R.K. Jibanlata Devi Vs.
High Court of Manipur through its Registrar General and Ors.
reported in 2023 Live-law (SC) 139 has held in para 6.4 and 6.7 as
under:
“6.4 In the present case the petitioner got “Good”
gradings for the year 2016-17 and received “Very
Good” gradings in her ACRs for the years 2017-18 and
8 / 10
2018-2019. It was the specific case on behalf of the
petitioner which has not been denied that the ACRs
grading of “Good” for the year 2016-17 was never
communicated to the petitioner even till the DPC met.
Therefore, as per the law laid down by this Court in
catena of decisions more particularly, as observed and
held by this Court in Rukhsana Shaheen Khan (supra);
Sukhdev Singh (supra) and Dev Dutt vs. Union of India
and Ors, (2008) 8 SCC 725 uncommunicated adverse
ACRs may be even with “Good” entry which can be
said to be adverse in the context of eligibility for
promotion is not to be relied upon for consideration of
promotion.
6.7 The sum and substance of the aforesaid discussion
would be that as the ACR Grading of “Good” for the
year 2016-17 was not communicated till the DPC met,
the same is to be ignored and/ or be not relied upon for
consideration of promotion. Similarly, the grading for
the year 2019-2020 also is to be excluded and/or be
not relied upon for consideration for promotion as the
same was communicated on 08.04.2021 and the
petitioner was granted 15 days’ time to make
representation and before the representation could be
made the DPC met on 09.04.2021 and considered the
case of the petitioner for promotion.”
13.
In the present case, the petitioner was not promoted on the ground that
she did not secure the minimum benchmark of 13 marks for the period
2008 to 2012. However, admittedly, ACR’s were never communicated
to her in time. The communication made in the year 2025 with respect
to adverse ACR for the year 2011 is clearly belated and it deprived the
petitioner of an opportunity to make a representation at the relevant
time. The very purpose of maintaining and sharing ACRs is to ensure
9 / 10
transparency, fairness, and professional development by informing an
employee of their performance evaluation. When such a report is
withheld for an extended period, it undermines principles of natural
justice. The belated communication of the adverse ACR defeats the
very purpose of communication. Uncommunicated below benchmark
ACRs cannot be looked into by the DPC while making assessment of
an officer for promotion to the higher grade. The petitioner, in the
present case, was deprived of such an opportunity at the relevant time.
Further, it is evident that the petitioner’s non-consideration for
promotion is directly linked to the ACR gradings falling below the
prescribed benchmark. Once such gradings are founded upon entries
which were not communicated in time, the entire process of evaluation
stands vitiated. Consequently, the action of the respondents in
declaring the petitioner unfit for promotion on the basis of such
uncommunicated adverse ACR is arbitrary, unjust and contrary to
settled principles of law. In the facts of case, DPC should have ignored
the adverse uncommunicated ACR.
14.
For the foregoing discussions and decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court,
I am of the view that action of the respondents in not promoting the
petitioner on the basis of uncommunicated ACR having adverse
remark is arbitrary, violative of principles of natural justice, and
unsustainable in law.
15.
Accordingly, writ petition is allowed. Impugned communicated dated
28.07.2025 (Annexure P-2) is quashed. Respondents are directed to
convene a Review Departmental Promotion Committee (Review DPC)
10 / 10
to re-consider the case of the petitioner for promotion to the post of
Professor, by ignoring the uncommunicated ACRs with adverse entries.
16.
In the event the petitioner is found fit for promotion by the Review DPC
recommends her name, she shall be granted promotion from the date
her immediate junior was promoted, with all consequential benefits,
including notional seniority and fixation of pay. However, she will not be
entitled for arrears of salary.
17.
The entire exercise, as directed above, shall be completed within a
period of three months from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
Praveen
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review