Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010421732022
2026:CGHC:41184
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 5701 of 2022
Dr. Shyama Agrawal W/o Dr. S.K. Agrawal Aged About 59 Years R/o
Shankar Nagar Durg, District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of Urban
Administration And Development, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nava
Raipur
Atal
Nagar,
Raipur,
District
:
Raipur,
Chhattisgarh
2 - Municipal Corporation, Durg Through The Commissioner, Municipal
Corporation,
Durg,
District
:
Durg,
Chhattisgarh
3 - Mr. Laxman Tiwari Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Durg,
District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
(Cause Title downloaded from CIS Periphery)
Digitally
signed by
SHYNA
SHYNA AJAY
Date:
AJAY
2026.09.26
17:12:09
+0530
For Petitioner(s)
: Dr. Sudeep Agrawal, Advocate
For Respondent/
: Mr. Anway Tiwari, Panel Lawyer
State
For Respondent/
: Mr. Sandeep Dubey, Advocate
Municipal
Corporation
SB: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order on Board
22/09/2026
1. By way of this petition, the petitioner challenges the validity and
propriety of the notice dated 15.12.2022 issued by the
Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Durg. By the said notice,
the Nursing Home run by the petitioner in the name and style of
‘Agrawal Nursing Home’ was sealed on the grounds of alleged
irregularities, non-compliance with the provisions of the Nursing
Home Act and failure to comply with the Rules and Regulations
prescribed by the National Green Tribunal regarding Bio-Medical
Waste management. It was further mentioned in the said notice
that in the event of any unauthorized unsealing or tampering with
the seal, necessary legal action would be initiated against the
nursing home concerned.
2. The petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs :
10.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to declare that the sealing of the Nursing Home
of the petitioner on 15.12.2022 as being illegal
and without jurisdiction.
10.2 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to impose cost upon the respondent 3 for the
illegal act committed by him as it is without
jurisdiction and with mala fide intention.
10.3 That this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased
to call for the records of the present case with
respect to sealing being carried out by the
respondent no. 2 and 3.
10.4 Any other reliefs which this Hon'ble Court may
deem fit in the facts and circumstance of the
case.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned
notice and the act of sealing are completely without jurisdiction as
the concerned Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Durg, lacks
the authority to take such action. He submits that the license in
question was granted under Section 6 of the Chhattisgarh State
Upcharyagriha
Tatha
Rogopchar
Sambandhi
Sthapanaye
Anugyapan Adhiniyam, 2010 (in short, 'the Adhiniyam, 2010').
Furthermore, while Section 9 provides for the cancellation or
suspension of a license, neither this provision nor any other
section of the Act empowers the authorities to seal a nursing
home. Learned counsel submits that even assuming proceedings
for cancellation are initiated, the concerned Commissioner
possesses no statutory authority to seal the subject premises.
Therefore, the impugned action and notice of sealing dated
15.12.2022 issued by Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 are ex-facie
illegal and without jurisdiction. He further submits that the issue
regarding
the
lack
of
statutory
power
of
the
Municipal
Commissioner possesses to seal premises is squarely covered
and affirmed by this Court in W.P.(C) No. 2248/2021 (E.S. Beena
and others v. State of Chhattisgarh and others) vide order
dated 16.08.2022. The Nursing Home of the petitioner is duly
registered and fully compliant with all requisite safety norms and
Bio-Medical Waste management protocols. He further submits
that by failing to appreciate the material records and proceeding to
seal the premises without the authority of law, the respondents
have violated the fundamental right of the petitioner to carry on
trade and business under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of
India, rendering the impugned action null and void.
4. On the other hand, learned counsel for the Municipal Corporation
submits that the
Nursing Home of the petitioner is not being
operated in accordance with the relevant provisions of law and
lacks the requisite permissions from the competent authorities.
The primary allegation against the petitioner's nursing home is
that bio-medical waste was not being managed in compliance with
the prescribed rules, but was instead being disposed of in open
areas and dumped into regular waste collection vehicles of the
Municipal Corporation.
He submits after complaints were
received from sanitation workers, the Municipal Corporation
obtained due permission from the District Collector, who serves as
the President of the District Committee under the Nursing Home
Act and subsequently sealed the premises of the petitioner.
Furthermore, pursuant to this Court's order dated 19.12.2022
directing the petitioner to submit a reply along with the relevant
documents to the notice issued by the Municipal Corporation, the
petitioner filed a reply. However, upon verification, the Municipal
Corporation found that the
documents submitted had expired.
However,
the petitioner did not
produce valid mandatory
permissions and documents and continued to operate the hospital
without regulatory compliance.
5. Heard learned counsel for the parties and also perused the record
with utmost circumspection.
6. Evidently, the Municipal Corporation, Durg, issued the impugned
notice dated 15.12.2022 and subsequently sealed the Nursing
Home without statutory competency and jurisdiction. The Nursing
Home is being lawfully operated pursuant to a valid license
granted under Section 6 of the Adhiniyam, 2010, which reads as
under:
6. Grant of License or otherwise- On the basis of the
examination of the application for license, the supervisory
authority, shall grant license to the applicant or reject the
application if it is found :(a) That the applicant, or any person employed by him at
the nursing home or the clinical establishment, is not a fit
person, whether by reason of expertise qualification or
otherwise to carry on or to be employed at the nursing
home or the clinical establishments of such a description
as the nursing home or clinical establishment named in the
application; or
(b) That the applicant or the nursing home or the clinical
establishment does not fulfill the conditions which have
been prescribed under this Act or any rule made
thereunder; or
(c) That the real object of the applicant is to use, or allow
the nursing home or clinical establishment to be used, for
anti-social/unlawful or immoral purposes or for both; or
(d) In the case of a nursing home other than a maternity
home, that the nursing home is not or will not be under the
charge of a qualified medical practitioner resident therein
and
that
the
nursing
of
persons
received
and
accommodated therein is not or will not be under the
superintendence of a qualified nurse resident therein; or
(e) In the case of a maternity home that such maternity
home is not or will not be under the charge of a qualified
midwife and that the attendance on every woman before, at
or after child birth or on any child born is not or will not be
under superintendence of a qualified midwife resident
therein; or
(f) That for reasons connected with the situation,
constructions, accommodation, staffing or equipment, the
nursing home or clinical establishment is not fit to be used
for a nursing home or clinical establishment of such a
description
as
the
nursing
home
or
the
clinical
establishment mentioned in the application, and shall in
every case, where the application is rejected, record the
grounds of rejection.
7. Furthermore, Section 9 of the Adhiniyam, 2010 exclusively governs the
cancellation or suspension of a Nursing Home license, which reads as
under:
9. Cancellation or suspension of license.— If at
any time, it is found by the supervisory authority that,
(1) A licensed nursing home or clinical establishment
has contravened or not complied with any provision of
this Act or any rule made thereunder or any condition
specified at the time of licensing; or
(2) A licensed nursing home or clinical establishment
has been convicted of an offence punishable under
this Act, he may after giving, the nursing home or a
clinical establishment, a reasonable opportunity of
being heard, cancel or suspend the licence.
(3) Notice to be given before cancellation of
licence.-Notwithstanding anything contained in this
Act, the supervisory authority shall give a 30 days'
notice to the nursing home or a clinical establishment
whose
licence
is
sought
to
be
cancelled
or
suspended. The notice shall contain the reason and
ground on the basis of which the licence is sought to
be cancelled or suspended. If the notice so requests,
a personal hearing may also be granted to hear the
defence of the notice.
If
after
following
the
above
mentioned
procedure and hearing the case of the noticee, the
supervisory authority decide to cancel or suspend the
licence, he shall pass a speaking order to this effect
which shall contain the reasons for such cancellation
or suspension of licence.
8. A plain reading of Section 9(3) of the Adhiniyam, 2010 manifests
that the power to initiate action for cancellation or suspension is
exclusively vested in the 'Supervisory Authority'. Furthermore, the
statute mandates a strict statutory prerequisite of issuing a
mandatory 30 days' advance notice containing specific grounds,
affording a personal hearing and passing a reasoned speaking
order before taking any coercive action.
9. Furthermore,
Upcharyagriha
under
Rule
of
Tatha
Rogopchar
the
Chhattisgarh
Sambandhi
State
Sthapanaye
Anugyapan Niyam, 2013 (for short, "the Rules/Niyam 2013"), the
District Collector is designated as the Supervisory Authority. Rule
3 reads as under:
3. Supervisory Authority.-(1) The District Collector of
the concerned district shall be the Supervisory Authority
under these Rules and shall be assisted by a District
Committee in discharge of the functions assigned to it
under the Act.
(2)
The
Supervisory
Authority
shall
consider
the
recommendations made by the District Committee in all
matters and will make decisions relating to registration
and/or grant of licenses to a Clinical Establishment.
10. A perusal of the statutory provisions leaves no room for doubt
that under the statutory framework of the Adhiniyam 2010 and
the Rules 2013, the sole regulatory and supervisory jurisdiction
over Clinical Establishments is vested in the Supervisory
Authority (District Collector), which shall be assisted by a District
Committee in discharge of the functions assigned to it under the
Act. The Municipal Corporation, Durg, has neither been
conferred with any power to grant, regulate or revoke licenses
nor does it possess any statutory power under the Act or Rules
to seal a Nursing Home. Therefore, the Municipal Commissioner,
having no statutory competence in this domain, committed a
manifest error of law in issuing the notice dated 15.12.2022 and
sealing the nursing home.
11. The issue in hand is well settled by this Court. In E.S. Beena
(supra_, a Coordinate Bench of this Court considered an identical
question of law and held that the Municipal Commissioner suffers
from an absolute lack of jurisdiction to seal premises or issue
regulatory
orders
under
such
enactments,
holding
such
highhanded actions by the Municipal Corporation as arbitrary,
unsustainable, and wholly without authority of law.
12. Moreover, this Court, vide interim order dated 11.01.2023,
recorded the admission
made by learned counsel for the
Municipal Corporation that the District Collector is the competent
authority under the Nursing Home Act. Satisfied that a strong
prima facie case was made out regarding the lack of jurisdiction,
this Court accordingly stayed the operation of the impugned
notice.
13. In light of the foregoing discussion, this Court has no hesitation in
reaching the conclusion that the action on the part of RespondentMunicipal Corporation is per se illegal and without authority of law.
The relevant statutory power vests solely in the Supervisory
Authority i.e. District Collector under the Adhiniyam, 2010. Since
the competent Supervisory Authority has neither cancelled nor
suspended the petitioner’s license, the impugned act of sealing
carried out by the Municipal Corporation
lacks statutory
authorisation and is accordingly unsustainable in law.
14. So far as compliance with Bio-Medical Waste Management
regulations and statutory licensing requirements is concerned, the
petitioner remains bound by the relevant statutory provisions and
the directions issued by this Court in its earlier order. The
competent authority retains full liberty to initiate appropriate
proceedings in accordance with law in the event of any violation of
the Adhiniyam, 2010 (or the applicable Nursing Home Act and
Rules) or non-compliance with judicial directions. However, any
adverse action or order passed by an authority lacking statutory
competence or jurisdiction is a nullity in the eyes of law and
cannot be sustained.
15. In the matter of Bilkis Yakub Rasool Vs. Union of India and
others reported in (2024) 5 SCC 481, the following was held in
paragraphs 115 and 116 :
115. When an authority does not have the jurisdiction to
deal with a matter or it is not within the powers of the
authority i.e. the State of Gujarat in the instant case, to be
the appropriate Government to pass orders of remission
under Section 432CrPC, the orders of remission would have
no legs to stand. On the aspect of jurisdiction and nullity of
orders passed by an authority, the decision of the House of
Lords
in
Anisminic
Ltd.
v.
Foreign
Compensation
Commission [Anisminic Ltd. v. Foreign Compensation
Commission, (1969) 2 AC 147 : (1969) 2 WLR 163 (HL)]
(“Anisminic”), is of significance and the same can be cited
by way of analogy. The House of Lords in the said case held
that the Foreign Compensation Commission had committed
an error which was a jurisdictional error as its decision was
based on a matter which it had no right to take into account
and so its decision was a nullity and subject to judicial
review. Although in Anisminic [Anisminic Ltd. v. Foreign
Compensation Commission, (1969) 2 AC 147 : (1969) 2
WLR 163 (HL)] , the scope and ambit of the concept of
“jurisdictional error” or “error of jurisdiction” was very much
extended, and of a very broad connotation, in the instant
case we are primarily dealing with a narrower concept i.e.
when an authority, which is the Government of State of
Gujarat in the instant case, was lacking jurisdiction to
consider the applications for remission. Just as an order
passed by a court without jurisdiction is a nullity, in the same
vein, an order passed or action taken by an authority lacking
in jurisdiction is a nullity and is non est in the eye of the law.
116. On that short ground alone the orders of remission
have to be quashed. This aspect of competency of the
Government of the State of Gujarat to pass the impugned
orders of remission goes to the root of the matter and the
impugned orders of remission are lacking in competency
and hence a nullity. The writ petition filed by the victim
would have to succeed on this reasoning. But the matter
does not rest at that.
16. Considering the facts and circumstances of the present case as
well as the nature of the dispute and also in light of the principles
laid down in the aforesaid judgment, this Court is of the opinion
that the impugned notice dated 15.12.2022 (Annexure P/1) and
the consequential action of sealing have been issued and
executed
by
an
authority
lacking
statutory
competence.
Consequently, the impugned notice cannot be permitted to
operate any further and is accordingly quashed.
17. With the aforesaid observations/directions, the Writ
Petition is
finally disposed of.
Sd/-
(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Shyna Ajay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review