Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC040009272023
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/324/2023
Dr. Satish Kumar
Son of Late Badri Nath,
PO and PS Rehari, District Jammu, Jammu and Kashmir. Mobile No. 9419124218
VERSUS
The Secretary and 3 Ors.
University Grant Commission, Ministry of Human Resources, Govt. of India.
2:The Vice-Chancellor cum Chairman Executive Council
Age: 0
Occupation :
Rono Hills
Doimukh
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
3:The Registrar
Age: 0
Occupation :
Rajiv Gandhi University
Rono Hills
Doimukh
Papumpare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
4:The HOD/DEAN
Age: 0
Occupation :
Faculty of Education
Rajiv Gandhi University
Rono Hills
Page No.# 2/13
Doimukh
Papumpare District
Arunachal Pradesh
- B e f o r eHON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
Advocates for the petitioner
:
Dr. Satish Kumar, petitioner-inperson
Advocate for the respondents
:
Mr. R. Nabam, Standing Counsel,
Rajiv Gandhi University.
Arunachal Pradesh
Date of which Judgment is reserved
: 26.03.2026
Date of pronouncement of Judgment
: 25.05.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
: N/A
operative part of the Judgment?
Whether the full judgment has been
: Yes
pronounced?
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Dr. Satish Kumar, petitioner-in-person and Mr. R. Nabam, learned
Standing Counsel, Rajiv Gandhi University, being respondent No.2, 3 and 4.
2.
In this petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner
has challenged the Order, dated 24.02.2023, issued vide Memo No.
Page No.# 3/13
ET/145/Appt/2017/1063, dated 25.02.2023, by the Registrar, Rajiv Gandhi
University; and the petitioner also prayed for issuing direction to the respondent
authorities to hold a review meeting and thereafter, to promote the petitioner to
the post of Professor with retrospective effect from the date of eligibility, at par
with similarly situated persons, in the same department.
Background facts :3.
The background facts, leading to filing of the present petition, are briefly
stated as under “The petitioner-in-person had joined at Rajiv Gandhi University, Rono Hills,
Doimukh, in Arunachal Pradesh, as Associate Professor, in the Department of
Education, in the year 2015. The next stage of his promotion is Professor, under
Career Advancement Scheme (for short, CAS); after completion of 3 (three)
years of regular service in the post of Associate Professor with 110 points
Academic Performance Index (for short, API).
It is the contention of the petitioner that he became eligible for being
promoted to the post of Professor in the year 2018, in terms of the University
Grants Commission (for short, UGC) Notification, dated 04.05.2016; being No.
F.1-2/2016PS/ (Amendment) and UGC Regulations, February 2018. But, the
respondent authorities did not conduct interview in the years 2018, 2019 &
2020.
Thereafter, the petitioner’s name was short-listed for interview in the year
2020, for being promoted to the post of Professor, but he was not called for the
said interview.
Thereafter, the petitioner appeared for the interview in the year 2023, in
Page No.# 4/13
terms of UGC Rules 2016, and was accordingly promoted as Professor, w.e.f.
24.02.2023,
by
order
dated
24.02.2023,
vide
Memo
No.
ET/145/Appt/2017/1063; issued on 25.02.2023.
It is also the case of the petitioner that in view of the impugned order,
issued vide Memo No. ET/145/Appt/2017/1063, dated 25.02.2023; the
petitioner has submitted a series of representations to the respondent
authorities ,with a request to give him retrospective promotion, i.e., w.e.f,
06.08.2018, which is the date of his eligibility for being promoted in terms of the
2016 UGC Notification and also, in terms of UGC Regulations, 2018. But, the
said representations had failed to evoke any response from the respondent
authorities.
It is also the case of the petitioner that in terms of UGC Regulations, 2016,
he is entitled to retrospective promotion with effect from the year 2018 and the
same is also affirmed by the letter, dated 21.06.2021, of the Joint Secretary,
UGC; to the effect that financial benefits to university/college teachers on grant
of CAS, will be admissible from the date of eligibility.”
4.
The respondent Nos. 2, 3 & 4 have filed their affidavit-in-opposition,
wherein, a stand has been taken that the CAS interview is being held by the
University at regular intervals. But, due to nationwide lockdown on account of
COVID-19 pandemic, the interview could not be conducted in time and from the
date of qualifying in the interview, the candidates are promoted retrospectively
and the petitioner herein was found to be qualified and he has passed the
interview in the year 2023.
4.1 It is also stated that in respect of not calling the petitioner for interview in
the year 2020, is that under the new UGC Regulations, 2018, the evidence of
Page No.# 5/13
successfully guiding a Ph.D. scholar is mandatory and in the application of the
petitioner, no evidence of successfully guiding a Ph.D. scholar was enclosed and
also, no scholar had been awarded Ph.D. degree under the guidance of the
petitioner, at the time of screening of his CAS application and moreover, his
application was found to be incomplete and consequently, he was asked to reapply and therefore, the prayer of the petitioner could not be considered for
being promoted to the post of Professor, with retrospective effect, i.e. form
2018.
4.2 It is the further contention of the respondent authorities that the University
authorities, in its circular, dated 19.02.2020, had requested all the candidates to
apply under the UGC Regulations form of 2016; and that the petitioner has
submitted his application in the year 2018, for promotion from the post of
Associate Professor to Professor, under CAS, in terms of UGC Regulations, 2018.
However, the screening committee had found that, the eligibility criteria of
"evidence of having successfully guided doctoral candidates" was not fulfilled by
the petitioner and therefore, he was found to be ineligible for interview for
promotion from Associate Professor to Professor; and the petitioner, having
found to be not qualified, was asked to apply afresh, as per the format of UGC
Regulations, 2016.
Thereafter, the petitioner and others had applied afresh, in the format of
2016, in the year 2020, under UGC Regulations, 2016, for promotion from
Associate Professor, to Professor under CAS promotion. However, due to the
poor performance of the petitioner in the interview held in the year 2021, the
Selection Committee did not promote him from the post of Associate Professor
to Professor under CAS. But, the University authority had asked the petitioner to
apply in a fresh format as per UGC Regulations, 2016, and in the year 2022, he
Page No.# 6/13
had applied for the said post again as per the format of UGC Regulations, 2016,
and he was found to be successful in the interview and the Selection Committee
had selected him for promotion from Associate Professor to Professor under
CAS.
5.
The petitioner has filed his affidavit-in-reply in response to the affidavit-in-
opposition filed by the respondent authorities, denying the statements and
averments made by the respondent authorities in the affidavit-in-opposition.
According to him, similarly situated teachers of the University have been
granted CAS promotion, with effect from the date of their eligibility, but the
petitioner-in-person herein has been denied such benefit; and that the
respondent
authorities,
with
mala-fide
intention,
have
declared
him
unsuccessful.
5.1. His further contention is that he has not applied for promotion under UGC
Regulations, 2018, but, he had applied under UGC Regulations, 2016 and under
the said Regulations, the requirement of being a guide for Ph.D. candidates is
not necessary; and that, the decision of the University authorities of denying
him the benefit of CAS, with effect from the date of his eligibility, is illegal and
arbitrary and the same is liable to be interfered with.
5.2. The petitioner has also filed an additional affidavit, wherein, he has
annexed the copies of the Order, dated 22.10.2025, as Annexure- 4 (Series); by
which, 9 (Nine) applicants, namely, Dr. Miazi Hazam, Dr. Marpe Sora, Dr. (Mrs.)
Joram Yalam Nabam, Dr. Lijum Nochi, Dr. Prasenjit Bujar Baruah, Dr. Nipen
Saikia, Dr. Anup Kumar Das, Dr. (Mrs.) Punyo Yarang and Dr. Tabang Mibang;
were given promotion from the date of their eligibility, instead of the date of
interview and therefore, the petitioner has prayed for granting similar benefit to
Page No.# 7/13
him.
Submission of the Petitioner-in-Person:6.
Mr. Satish Kumar, the petitioner-in-person submits that he became eligible
for being promoted to the post of Professor in the year 2018, under the CAS.
But, on account of COVID-19 pandemic, the University authorities did not
conduct the interview, during the years 2018, 2019 and 2020, and though, he
had applied in the year 2020 and also appeared in the interview, he was
declared un-successful, with melafide intention of promoting only the local
candidates. Subsequently, he had again applied and that time, he was promoted
to the post of Professor, and after his promotion, he had requested the
respondent authorities to give effect of the same from the date of his eligibility,
but the same has been denied by the respondent authorities.
6.1 The petitioner-in-person also submits that similarly situated Professors of
the University have been promoted from the date of their eligibility; and that, he
had applied for being promoted in the format, given under UGC Regulations,
2016 and he had never applied in the format, given under UGC Regulations,
2018; which requires the experience of being a Ph.D. guide, but the same is not
a requirement of the UGC Regulations, 2016. And under such circumstances, he
has contended to allow this petition, by giving him the benefit from the date of
his eligibility.
Submission of learned counsel for the respondent:7.
Per contra, Mr. Nabam, learned Standing Counsel for the respondent
University has vehemently opposed the petition. Referring to the affidavit-inopposition filed by the respondent authorities, Mr. Nabam submits that on
account of COVID-19 pandemic, interview of the teachers, for being promoted
Page No.# 8/13
to Professor, from Associate Professor, could not be conducted and it was
subsequently conducted in the year 2020 and in that interview, the petitioner
was found to be ineligible, as he had applied in the format given under UGC
Regulations, 2018; which requires the experience of guiding a Ph.D. candidate,
which, admittedly, the petitioner does not possess and thereafter, the
respondent authorities had advised the petitioner to apply in the format given
under UGC Regulations, 2016 and accordingly, the petitioner had applied in the
said format and also appeared in the interview and he was accordingly
promoted to Professor.
7.1 Mr. Nabam also submits that the benefit of retrospective promotion could
not be given to the petitioner, as he was found to be unqualified in the interview
earlier. He also submits that there is no merit in this petition and accordingly, he
has contended to dismiss the same.
8.
Having heard the submission of the learned counsel for both the parties,
this Court has carefully gone through the petition and the documents placed on
record, and perused the UGC Regulations, 2016 and also, the UGC Regulations,
2018.
Discussion and Analysis:9.
The basic facts herein this case is not in dispute. The petitioner has joined
as Associate Professor, in the department of Education, of Rajiv Gandhi
University, in the year 2015. As per the required qualification under the CAS, 3
(three) years of regular service as Associate Professor, with 110 points API is
required. And the petitioner herein, became eligible in the year 2018, in terms
of the UGC Notification, dated 04.05.2016, and UGC Regulations, February
2018. However, the interview could not be conducted in the years 2018, 2019
Page No.# 9/13
and 2020, on account of COVID-19 pandemic. Thereafter, the interview was
conducted in the year 2020, but the petitioner was not called for the interview.
Subsequently, he had appeared in the interview in 2023, in terms of the UGC
Regulations, 2016 and he was promoted as Professor, w.e.f., 24.02.2023.
10.
It is also not in dispute that thereafter, the petitioner has filed several
representations for giving the benefit of promotion with retrospective effect, but
the same have failed to evoke any response from the respondent authorities.
11. It is also not in dispute that under the UGC Regulations, 2018, in order to
be promoted from the post of Associate Professor to the post of Professor, the
teacher must possess an expertise of guiding a Ph.D. scholar and it is the
contention of the respondent authorities that the petitioner did not possessed
the same, for which, his CAS could not be considered for being promoted to the
post of Professor. But, he was advised to apply in the format given under the
Regulations, 2016 and after applying in the said format, the petitioner was
promoted to the post of Professor.
12. Further, from the letter, dated 21.06.2021, issued by the Joint Secretary,
UGC, the University/College teachers for grant of CAS, will be admissible from
the date of eligibility. But, in spite of the same, the petitioner has not been
given the benefit, from the date of his eligibility.
13. Even though the respondent authorities have taken a stand that the
petitioner could not be given the benefit of retrospective promotion, as he had
applied in the format prescribed under the UGC Regulations, 2018; but the
same has left this Court unimpressed.
14. Though, another contention is being made by the respondent authorities in
Page No.# 10/13
the affidavit-in-opposition that the petitioner was found ineligible in the
interview, on account of poor performance in the interview boars, held on
May/June 2021 yet, the ‘Annexure 2’ of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
respondent authorities, yet the EC Resolution, being EC: 39:06, dated
10.06.2021; indicates that the Committee did not recommend the name of Dr.
Satish Kumar, for being promoted to the post of Professor under CAS. It was
held that the future eligibility will be as per UGC Regulation. But, no reason has
been recorded as to why the name of the petitioner could not be considered. It
is well settled that when the E.C. Resolution is silent as to why the petitioner’s
name could be considered, the reason cannot be supplied in the form of an
affidavit. This proposition is laid down in the case of Moninder Singh Gill
vs. Chief Election Commissioner
reported in (1978)1 SCC 405,
Hon’ble the Supreme Court held in paragraph 8 that reasons for an
administrative order cannot later be supplied through affidavits or explanations
in court. The validity of an order must be judged by the reasons stated in the
order itself.
15. Further, from the Minutes of the Meeting of the 63rd Executive Council,
held on 18.09.2025, which is annexed to the additional affidavit, dated
31.01.2026, filed by the petitioner-in-person, as ‘Annexure-3’; indicates that as
many as 9 (nine) teachers have been given the CAS promotion from the date of
their CAS eligibility, instead of the date of their interview, pursuant to the
Resolution No. EC:63:12, held on 18.09.2025, in the 63 rd meeting of the
Executive Council. It is also stated that similar practice is being adopted by
Maulana Azad National Urdu University. Notably, these averments are not being
controverted by the respondents in Rajiv Gandhi University and as such the
same deemed to have been accepted by the respondent authorities, in view of
Page No.# 11/13
Doctrine of Non-Traverse.
16. If as many as 9 (nine) teachers have been given the CAS promotion from
the date of their CAS eligibility, instead of the date of their interview, pursuant
to the Resolution No. EC:63:12, held on 18.09.2025, in the 63 rd meeting of the
Executive Council, and if the petitioner is similarly situated with those 9
teachers, such benefit cannot be denied to the petitioner. Else it would violate
the right of the petitioner guaranteed by Article 14 and also by Article 16 of the
petitioner.
16.1. It is also well settled in the case of Manager, Government Branch
Press and Another vs. D.B. Belliappa, reported in (1979) 1 SCC 477,
that the expression ‘matters relating to employment’ under Article 16(1) of the
Constitution of India is not confined to initial matters prior to the act of
employment, but comprehends all matters in relation to employment both prior
and subsequent, to the employment which are incidental to the employment
and form part of the terms and conditions of such employment, such as
provisions
as
to
salary,
increments,
leave,
gratuity,
pension,
age
of
superannuation, promotion and even termination of employment. It is further
well established that Articles 14, 15(1) and 16(1) of the Constitution of India
form part of the same constitutional code of guarantees and supplement each
other and if any authority is needed for the above enunciation, reference may
be made to the observations made in the case of General Manager Southern
Railway vs. Rangachari, reported in (1962) 2 SCR 586.
16.2. Thus, the decision of the respondent authorities, declining to grant the
CAS benefit from the date of interview instead of the date eligibility suffers from
the vice of arbitrariness and as such, it is violative of Article 14 of the
Page No.# 12/13
Constitution. It is worth mentioning in this context that in the case of S.G.
Jaisinghani vs. Union of India [AIR 1967 SC 1427], a Constitution
Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as under:“14.
… absence of arbitrary power is the first essential of
the rule of law upon which our whole constitutional system is
based. … the rule of law from this point of view means that
decisions should be made by the application of known
principles and rules and, in general, such decisions should
be predictable and the citizen should know where he is. If a
decision is taken without any principle or without any rule
it is unpredictable and such a decision is the antithesis of
a decision taken in accordance with the rule of law.”
16.3. It is to be noted here that while dealing with the issue of arbitrariness,
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
State of Orissa v. Mamata
Mohanty, reported in (2011) 3 SCC 436, held as under:“59. The rule of law inhibits arbitrary action and also makes
it liable to be invalidated. Every action of the State or its
instrumentalities should not only be fair, legitimate and
above board but should be without any affection or aversion.
It should neither be suggestive of discrimination nor even
give an impression of bias, favouritism and nepotism.
Procedural fairness is an implied mandatory requirement to
protect against arbitrary action where statute confers wide
power coupled with wide discretion on an authority. If the
procedure adopted by an authority offends the fundamental
fairness or established ethos or shocks the conscience, the
order stands vitiated. The decision-making process remains
bad.”
17. Under the abovementioned facts and circumstances, granting the benefit of
CAS to the petitioner from the date of his interview instead of the date
Page No.# 13/13
eligibility; is liable to be interfered with on account of the same being illegal and
arbitrary. Accordingly, that part of the impugned order, dated 24.02.2023; by
which the benefit of CAS is granted to the petitioner, w.e.f., 24.02.2023, i.e.,
from the date of his interview; instead of the date of eligibility, is set aside and
quashed. It is being clarified that except what has been interfered with, as
indicated above, rest of the part of the impugned order, is not interfered with.
18. By a mandamus of this Court, the respondent authorities are directed to
give the benefit of the CAS, with effect from the date of his becoming eligible
for being promoted to the post of Professor.
19. Let the abovementioned exercise shall be carried out within a period of 3
months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order. The petitioner
shall obtain a certified copy of this order and place the same before the
respondent authorities within a period of 1 (one) week from today.
20. In terms of the above, this writ petition stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review