Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:19810
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 6TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 10799 OF 2020
PETITIONER:
DR. SAMUEL MATHEW
*[AGED 1 YEARS] Deleted
ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICS, MARTHOMA
COLLEGE, THIRUVALLA - 689 103. RESIDING AT 'PLAVILA
PUTHENVEEDU', KUTTAPUZHA P. O., THIRUVALLA - 689 103.
*[THE WORDS “AGED 1 YEARS” MENTIONED IN THE ADDRESS OF THE
PETITIONER IN THE CAUSE TITLE OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
25.02.2025 IN WP(C) 10799/2020 IS DELETED AS PER ORDER DATED
01.04.2025 IN I.A. 1/2025 IN WP(C) 10799/2020.]
Sd/ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
BY ADV SHYAM KRISHNAN
RESPONDENTS:
THIS
25.02.2025,
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, HIGHER
EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 695 001.
MAHATMA GANDHI UNIVERSITY
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR, PRIYADHARSHINI HILLS,
ATHIRAMPUZHA, KOTTAYAM - 686 560.
THE PRINCIPAL
MARTHOMA COLLEGE, THIRUVALLA - 689 103.
BY ADVS.
SHRI.SURIN GEORGE IPE, SC, M.G.UNIVERSITY
SRI.GEORGE CHERIAN (SR.)
SMT.K.S.SANTHI
SMT.LATHA SUSAN CHERIAN
BY
SMT. NIMA JACOB - SC
SRI. SURIN GEORGE IPE - SC
WRIT
PETITION
ALONG
WITH
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
(CIVIL)
HAVING
WP(C).10699/2020,
BEEN
THE
FINALLLY
COURT
ON
THE
HEARD
ON
SAME
DAY
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
:2:
2025:KER:19810
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 6TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 10699 OF 2020
PETITIONER:
DR.ANILA E.I.
*[AGED 1 YEARS] Deleted
ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICS, U.C.COLLEGE,
ALUVA, PIN-683 102, RESIDING AT SAKALYAM, NMRRA-29,
MANIMALA ROAD, AIMS, PONEKKARA P.O., KOCHI-682 041.
*[THE AGE OF THE PETITIONER IS DELETED AS PER ORDER DATED
01/04/2025 IN IA 1/2025 IN WP(C) 10699/2020]
Sd/ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
BY ADV SHYAM KRISHNAN
RESPONDENTS:
THIS
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695 001.
MAHATMA GANDHI UNIVERSITY,
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR, PRIYADHARSHINI HILLS,
ATHIRAMPUZHA, KOTTAYAM-686 560.
THE PRINCIPAL,
U.C.COLLEGE, ALUVA-683 102.
THE MANAGER,
U.C.COLLEGE, ALUVA-683 102.
BY ADVS.
SRI.ASOK M. CHERIAN, SC, M.G. UNIVERSITY
SRI.SAJI VARGHESE
SMT.MARIAM MATHAI
SMT. NIMA JACOB – SC
SRI. SURIN GEORGE IPE - SC
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLLY
HEARD
ON
25.02.2025, ALONG WITH WP(C).10799/2020, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
:3:
2025:KER:19810
VIJU ABRAHAM , J.
===========================
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
============================
Dated this the 25th day of February, 2025
JUDGMENT
Since common issue is raised in both these writ petitions they
are heard and disposed of together by a common judgment, in which
WP(C) No.10699 of 2020 is treated as the leading case.
2.
The breif facts necessary for disposal of the writ petition
are as follows:Petitioner joined service as lecturer in physics in UC College, Aluva in
1988. On 01.01.2009 the petitioner became eligible to be appointed
and designated as professor according to paragraph 6.1.13 of Ext.P1
Government Order regarding the implementation of the UGC
scheme. The relevant paragraph 6.1.13 reads as follows:“Associate Professor completing three years of service in the
A.G.P. of Rs.9,000/- and possessing a Ph.D. degree in the
relevant discipline shall be eligible to be appointed and
designated as Professor, subject to other conditions of
academic performance as laid down by the U.G.C. and if any,
by the University. No teacher other than those with a Ph.D.
shall be promoted, appointed or designated as Professor. The
pay band of the post of Professors shall be Rs.37,400-67,000
with AGP of Rs.10,000/-”
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
:4:
2025:KER:19810
Based on the same it is the contention of the petitioner that the
petitioner satisfied the above condition in Ext.P1 on 01.01.2009
itself. Thereupon petitioner submitted a performa and details for
promotion as Professor under UGC Career Advancement Scheme
(CAS) as evident from Ext.P2. Ext.P3 curriculum vitae of the
petitioner was also submitted. Even after a lapse of two and half
years, the 4th respondent Manager did not care to process the
petitioner’s application. Thereupon Ext.P4 request was made before
the Manager to which Ext.P5 reply was given by the 4 th respondent
Manager stating that the 1 st respondent Government would not take
the excess financial liabilities of promoting and designating eligible
Associate Professor as Professor. It is for the said reason that the
petitioner’s application is not processed and sent to the 2 nd
respondent University for approval.
3.
Petitioner submits that Ext.P3 reply is given on the basis
of Exts.P6 and P7 Government orders. A perusal of Exts.P6 and P7
reveal that the 1st respondent Government accepts the mandate of
UGC regulation 2010 for promotion and designation of eligible
Associate Professors as Professors, however the excuse put forward
by the 1st respondent is that they will have to incur a huge financial
burden if the Associate Professors are designated as Professors in
private aided colleges. Petitioner also relies on Ext.P8 UGC
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
:5:
2025:KER:19810
regulation which also makes it clear that an Associate Professor
having three years of completed service shall be eligible to be
designated as Professor. Petitioner would further submit that by
Ext.P9 order the Government
implemented UGC Regulation 2018
strictly in accordance with the standard norms and procedure set
out by the UGC Regulation 2018, and pursuant to the said
Government order produced as Ext.P9 petitioner applied for
designation as Professor and she was desginated as Professor with
effect from 18.07.2018 as per Ext.P10 order.
4.
Petitioner relies on Ext.P13 judgment of the High Court of
Delhi, wherein a direction was issued to promote the petitioners
therein who were Associate Professors to the post of Professors with
effect from the date of eligibility. Based on the same the case of the
petitioner is that she is entitled for promotion as Professor from the
date of her eligibility i.e. from 01.01.2009. Petitioner further submits
that in the case of a similarly situated Associate Professor, this Court
by Ext.P14 judgment in WP(C) No.2688 of 2022 directed the State to
consider and take a decision on her claim for promotion under the
UGC Regulation 2010 and in compliance of the said direction in
Ext.P14 judgment, Ext.P15 order was issued granting promotion to
the petitioner therein under UGC Regulation 2010. Petitioner also
relies on Ext.P16 communication issued by the University Grants
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
:6:
2025:KER:19810
Commission which clarified in no uncertain terms that teachers who
fulful the eligibility criterial on or before 31.12.2024 will have a
choice for being considered for promotion under either 2010 or
2018 Regulation. Petitioner also relies on Ext.P17 judgment in WA
No.1093 of 2021. But as per the said judgment though relief was
granted to the party therein, the Court has also made it clear that
the said directions shall not be taken as a precedent in another
case. It is also submitted that the petitioner has already retired from
service.
5.
In WP(C) No. 10799 of 2020 the petitioner joined service
as Lecturer on 13.09.1994 in Marthomma College, Thiruvalla, and
going by Ext.P1 UGC scheme of 2010 he became eligible for
appointment and designated as Professor on 11.09.2010. Though
Ext.P2
application
in
the
prescribed
performa
and
Ext.P3
representation was submitted, no decision has been taken for grant
of promotion to the petitioner with effect from 11.09.2010 the date
on which she became eligible for grant of promotion as Professor.
However, petitioner was designated as Professor based on UGC
Regulation 2018 as per Ext.P10 order issued by the 2 nd respondent.
6.
The 1st respondent Director of Collegiate Education has
filed a detailed counter affidavit, wherein it is contended that the
method of appointment to the post of Professor is by merit
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
:7:
2025:KER:19810
promotion going by 2010 UGC scheme and the post of Professor has
not been created in Arts and Science Colleges, and therefore it is
not possible to make retrospective promotion to the post of
Professor.
7.
The University has also filed a detailed statement,
wherein it is submitted that though the Government have issued
order dated 13.10.2017 in compliance of the direction to the
judgment dated 18.01.2017 in WP(C) No.22083 of 2011 filed by a
similarly situated teacher, later the said Government order was
cancelled as per Ext.P7 order dated 15.02.2018. Since Government
is the ultimate authority and the pay master the University being
bound to adhere to direction from the Government in case of
financial liability. In view of the above none of the reliefs could be
granted to the petitioner.
8.
I have considered the rival contentions of both sides.
9.
Going by Ext.P1 Government order petitioner is eligible
for being appointed and designated as Professor on completion of
three years of service and the petitioner in WP(C) No.10699 of 2020
became eligible to become Professor on 01.01.2019, and the
petitioner
in
WP(C)
No.10799
of
became
eligible
for
appointment and desginated as Professor on 11.09.2010. In fact the
petitioner in WP(C) No.10699 of 2020 was promoted as Professor as
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
:8:
2025:KER:19810
per Ext.P10 on 30.05.2022 based on 2018 UGC Regulation and the
petitioner in WP(C) No.10799 of 2020 was promoted as per Ext.P8
on 30.12.2021. The request of the petitioner in WP(C) No.10699 of
2020 was rejected by Ext.P5 based on Exts.P6 and P7 Government
orders. Ext.P6 Government order only says that nearly 1500 to 2000
posts of Professors had to be created if the prayer of the petitioner
is to be granted and the same would create huge financial burden to
the Government. The High Court of Delhi as per Ext.P13 judgment
set aside the order of promotion granted to the petitioners therein
to the post of Professor which was made prospectively from 25 th
June, 2019 and held that the said promotion shall relate back to the
date of eligibility. So going by Ext.P13 judgment the petitioners are
entitled for promotion from the date of their eligibility i.e. on
01.01.2019 and 11.01.2010 respectively.
10.
Yet another aspect to be considered is that though the
Government has taken a stand in Ext.P6 that the relief sought for by
the petitioner cannot be granted as it will create serious financial
burden to the Government, based on the direction issued by this
Court in Ext.P14 judgment to consider the claim of the petitioner
therein,
Government
itself
has
passed
Ext.P15
order
dated
14.03.2024 granting the benefit to a similarly situated teacher
based on the 2010 UGC Regulation from the date on which the
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
:9:
2025:KER:19810
petitioner therein became eligible for promotion. The UGC has also
clarified this position as per Ext.P16. Though the stand taken by the
Government in Ext.P6 order as well as the counter affidavit is that
the Professor post is only a placement given to the teacher who
qualifies for that post and creation of post of Professor is not
necessary for that placement, and if the post of Professor is created
it will cause huge financial burden to the Government, but in the
case of a similarly situated teacher Government by Ext.P15 order
granted the benefit of promotion as per 2010 UGC Regulation from
the date on which the said teacher became eligible for promotion as
Professor with certain conditions and riders.
11.
In view of the stand taken by the Government in Ext.P15
in case of a similarly situated teacher, I am of the opinion that the
claim of the petitioners is liable to be reconsidered. If in fact in a
similar circumstance, the Government has considered the claim of a
similarly situated teacher as per Ext.P15 and if relief has been
granted to the said teacher, I am of the view that the Government is
bound to take a similar view in the case of the petitioners also. But I
am of the opinion that the Government being the ultimate authority
and the pay master has to examine as to whether the petitioners
are also similarly situated as the petitioner in Ext.P15 Government
order, and if the Government finds that they are similarly situated, I
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
: 10 :
2025:KER:19810
find no reason for the Government to take a different view in the
case of the petitioners alone. In view of the above, I am of the
opinion that the matter requires serious consideration by the
Government as the Government is the ultimate authority in such
matter and the pay master.
12.
Therefore, the above writ petition is disposed of with the
following directions:Both the petitioners shall submit a detailed request in this regard
before the 1st respondent Principal Secretary to Government, Higher
Education Department staking a claim for promotion to the post of
Professor from the date on which they become eligibile to be
appointed and designated as Professor within a period of three
weeks from the date of receipt of a copy this judgment. If such
request is submitted by the petitioners the 1 st respondent shall
consider the same in accordance with law taking into consideration
Ext.P13 judgment of the High Court of Delhi, and Ext.P15 order
granting relief to a similarly situated teacher. Petitioner shall
produce copies of these judgments and any other relevant
documents
in
support
of
their
contentions
along
with
the
representation to be filed before the 1st respondent. The 1st
respondent shall take appropriate decision in the matter taking into
consideration the documents produced by the petitioners after
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
: 11 :
2025:KER:19810
affording an opportunity of being heard to the petitioners, University
and any other affected parties.
With the above said direction, these writ petitions are disposed
of.
Sd/VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
sbk/-
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
: 12 :
2025:KER:19810
The following corrections:
i. The words “AGED 1 YEARS” mentioned after the name of the petitioner
in the cause title of the judgment is deleted.
ii. The exhibit number “Ext.P3” mentioned in the first line of Para 3, on
Page 4, is corrected as “Ext.P5”.
Iii. The date “13.09.1994” mentioned in the second line of Para 5, on Page
6, is corrected as “30.09.1994”.
iv. The word “she” mentioned in the eighth line of Para 5, on Page 6, is
corrected as “he”.
v. The date “01.01.2019” mentioned in the fourth line of Para 9, on Page 7,
is corrected as “01.01.2009”.
vi. The date “30.05.2022” mentioned in the eighth line of Para 9, on Page
8, is corrected as “13.05.2022”.
vii. The date “01.01.2019” mentioned in the last line of Para 9, on Page 8,
is corrected as “01.01.2009”.
viii. The date “11.01.2010” mentioned in the last line of Para 9, on page 8,
is corrected as “11.09.2010”.
Are effected in the common judgment dated 25.02.2025 in WP(C) No’s
10799/2020 & 10699/2020 as per common order dated 01.04.2025 in IA
No.1/2025 in WP(C) No’s 10799/2020 & 10699/2020.
Sd/JOINT REGISTRAR
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
: 13 :
2025:KER:19810
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 10699/2020
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF G.O.(P) NO. 9/2021/H.EDN
DATED 20-02-2021, ISSUED BY THE 1ST
RESPONDENT STATE OF KERALA
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO. 5078/ACB5/2022/MGU,
DATED 13-05-2022, ISSUED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P11
TRUE COPY OF CIRCULAR NO.
1192/ACB5/2019/MGU DATED 26-03-2019,
ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT
Exhibit P12
TRUE COPY OF G.O.(P)NO.9/2022/H.EDN DATED
10-03-2022, ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT
STATE OF KERALA
Exhibit P13
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMON JUDGMENT OF THE
HONOURABLE HIGH COURT OF DELHI DATED 0803-2021 IN DR. KIRAN GUPTA VS UNIVERSITY
OF DELHI AND OTHERS AND CONNECTED CASES,
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R1(a)
True copy of G.O(P) No.58/2010/H.Edn dated
27-03-2010
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P15
True copy of G.O. No: 367/2024/HEDN Dated
14.03.2024
Exhibit P16
True copy of this UGC letter dated
01.05.2024 with typed copy
Exhibit P14
True copy of Judgment dated 08.11.2022 in
W.P. (c) No: 2688 of 2022
Exhibit P17
true copy of the Judgment dated 30.11.2021
in W.A. No: 1093 of 2021 of this
Honourable Court
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
: 14 :
2025:KER:19810
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE COPY OF RELEVANT PAGES OF U.G.C.
REGULATIONS 2010.
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF CORRIGENDUM GO(RT)
NO.290/2018/H.EDN. DATED 15.02.2018.
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF GO(RT)NO.256/2018/H.EDN.
DATED 08.02.2018.
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF REPLY DATED 03.03.3030 SENT
BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT MANAGER OF THE
U.C.COLLEGE TO THE PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED
10.02.2020 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
BEFORE THE 2ND RESPONDENT REGISTRAR OF
M.G.UNIVERSITY.
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF CURRICULUM VITAE OF THE
PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE PETITIONERS PROFORMA
DATED 07.08.2017 WHICH WAS TO BE FORWARDED
TO THE 2ND RESPONDENT M.G.UNIVERSITY
THROUGH THE 3RD RESPONDENT PRINCIPAL.
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF GO(P)NO.58/2010/H.EDN. DATED
27.03.2010.
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
: 15 :
2025:KER:19810
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 10799/2020
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF G.O.(P) NO. 9/2021/H.EDN
DATED 20-02-2021, ISSUED BY THE 1ST
RESPONDENT STATE OF KERALA
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE UNIVERSITY ORDER NO:
7535/ACB5/2021/MGU DATED 30.12.2021 ISSUED
BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT MAHATMA GANDHI
UNIVERSITY
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE CIRCULAR NO.
1192/ACB5/2019/MGU DATED 26-03-2019,
ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT MAHATMA
GANDHI UNIVERSITY
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF G.O.(P)NO.9/2022/H.EDN DATED
10-03-2022, ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT
STATE OF KERALA
Exhibit P11
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMON JUDGMENT DATED 0803-2021 OF THE HONOURABLE HIGH COURT OF
DELHI, IN DR.KIRAN GUPTA VS UNIVERSITY OF
DELHI AND OTHERS AND CONNECTED CASES
Exhibit P12
True copy of G.O.(Rt) No: 256/2018/H.Edn.
dated 08.02.2018
Exhibit P13
True copy of Judgment dated 30.11.2021 in
W.A. No: 1093 of 2021 of this Honourable
Court
Exhibit P14
True copy of Judgment dated 08.11.2022 in
W.P. (c) No: 2688 of 2022 of this
Honourable Court
Exhibit P15
True copy of G.O. No: 367/2024/HEDN Dated
14.03.2024
Exhibit P16
True copy of this UGC letter dated
01.05.2024 with typed copy
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF THE
WP(C) Nos. 10799 & 10699 of 2020
: 16 :
2025:KER:19810
U.G.C.REGULATIONS 2010.
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY DATED 15.11.2019
SENT BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT IN RESPONSE TO
EXHIBIT P4 REMINDER.
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE REMINDER DATED 30.10.2019
SENT BY THE PETITIONER TO THE 2ND
RESPONDENT REGISTRAR OF THE
M.G.UNIVERSITY.
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED
22.01.2018, SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
BEFORE THE 1ST RESPONDENT, REQUESTING FOR
AN EXPEDITIOUS DECISION ON HIS PROMOTION
AS PROFESSOR.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE PERFORMA DATED 09.08.2017
CONTAINING THE BIO-DATA OF THE PETITIONER,
FORWARDED TO THE 2ND RESPONDENT MAHATMA
GANDHI UNIVERSITY, THROUGH THE 3RD
RESPONDENT PRINCIPAL, MARTHOMA COLLEGE,
THIRUVALLA.
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF G.O.(P) NO.58/2010/H.EDN.
DATED 27.03.2010 ISSUED BY THE 1ST
RESPONDENT.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review