Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
DR. S. ANIL KUMAR
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. T.V. George, Adv.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Vikram Jetly, CGSC with
Ms. Shreya Jetly, Adv. for UOI
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE OM PRAKASH SHUKLA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
21.04.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
The petitioner is a 2010 batch officer of the Indian Revenue
Service. He was posted as Assistant Commissioner of Customs and
Central Excise1 in Cochin, and was stationed at the Cochin Airport.
He was arrested on 17 October 2013 on the basis of an information
gathered by one Mr. T.K. Faiz, pertaining to alleged smuggling of 3.6
kg of gold and other material during the period when the petitioner
served as AC.
2.
The petitioner was placed under suspension on 28 October 2013
with effect from 17 October 2013. The order of suspension was
revoked on 3 July 2015 and the petitioner was transferred to Patna.
“AC” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
3.
On 30 January 2015, a Departmental Promotion Committee2
convened to consider the case of the petitioner for promotion as
Deputy Commissioner of Customs. The recommendations of the DPC
were placed in a sealed cover. The petitioner approached the Central
Administrative Tribunal3, aggrieved thereby. The Tribunal disposed of
the OA with liberty to the petitioner to address a representation to the
respondent. He did so. The respondent, vide order dated 4 October
2016 informed the petitioner that sealed cover could not be opened till
the criminal case against him was decided.
4.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner re-approached the Tribunal by
way of OA 1044/2017, in which the presently impugned judgment has
been rendered. Before the Tribunal, the petitioner contended that, as
no charge-sheet had been filed against him in the criminal proceedings
or departmentally, and he was not under suspension, the adoption of
the sealed cover procedure in his case was contrary to the law laid
down by the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Anil Kumar
Sarkar4.
5.
The respondent, in response, placed reliance before the Tribunal
on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. K.V.
Jankiraman5, and Office Memorandum dated 14 September 1992
issued by the Department of Personnel and Training6 to contend that
the sealed cover in which the recommendations of the DPC which met
on 30 January 2015 had been placed could be opened only on
“DPC” hereinafter
3 “the Tribunal”, hereinafter
4 (2013) 4 SCC 161
5 (1991) 4 SCC 109
6 “DOPT”, hereinafter
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
completion of the criminal case against the petitioner.
6.
The Tribunal dismissed the OA filed by the petitioner,
reasoning thus :
“9.
It is not in dispute that a criminal case was pending against
the applicant by the time the DPC met. In addition to that, he
remained under suspension for a considerable time before the DPC
met. Under these circumstances, the occasion to open the sealed
cover would arise only when the criminal case is terminated in his
favour.
10.
Reliance is placed upon the judgment of the Supreme Court
in Anil Kumar Sarkar’s case (supra). Their Lordships referred to
the judgment in K.V. Jankiraman's case and the DoP&T OM
dated 14.09.1992. In that case, the employee in respect of whom
sealed cover procedure was adopted, was neither placed under
suspension nor any charge-sheet was issued in the departmental
proceedings. Though a criminal case was registered, charge-sheet
was not filed, by the time the DPC met. Therefore, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court took the view that the relief granted to the
employee by the High Court does not warrant interference. Para 14
of the judgment reads as under:
"14. As per Para 2 of the said memorandum, at the time
of consideration of the government servants for promotion,
the following details of government servants in the
consideration zone for promotion falling in the categories
mentioned should be specifically brought to the notice of
the DPC viz. (i) Government servant is under suspension;
(ii) Government servant has been served with a chargesheet and the disciplinary proceedings are pending; and (iii)
Government servant is facing prosecution for a criminal
charge and the said proceedings are pending. As rightly
observed by the High Court, if the above conditions are
available, even one of them, then the DPC has to apply the
"sealed cover process". In the case on hand, it is not in
dispute that the relevant date is 21-4-2003, when the
respondent's batchmates were promoted, admittedly on that
date the respondent was not under suspension, no chargesheet was served upon him nor was he facing any criminal
prosecution. In such circumstances, in terms of Para 2
referred to above, the recommendation of the DPC has to be
honoured and there is no question of applying "sealed cover
process"."
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
Specific reference was made to the judgment in K.V. Jankiraman's
case on the point, as to when the disciplinary/criminal proceedings
can be said to have commenced. It was observed that it is only
when a charge-sheet in the disciplinary proceedings or a criminal
case is filed, that it can be said that departmental proceedings /
criminal prosecution are initiated. In the instant case, it is no doubt
true that the charge-sheet in the criminal case was not filed by the
time the DPC met. However, it is not in dispute that the applicant
was placed under suspension in respect of those very proceedings.
11.
The plea of the applicant that though he was placed under
suspension earlier, he stood reinstated by the time the DPC met,
and in that view of the matter, sealed cover procedure should not
have been adopted, cannot be accepted. In the judgment in K. V.
Jankiraman's case as well as in the DoP&T OM dated
14.09.1992, suspension of an employee is treated as a basis to
adopt the sealed cover procedure. The same was reiterated in Anil
Kumar Sarkai’s case also. In none of them, it is mentioned that the
suspension must be in force as on the date of the meeting of the
DPC. The following observations contained in para 16 in K. V.
Jankiraman’s case, referred to by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Anil Kumar Sarkar's case, assumes significance in this regard:
“…What is further, if the charges are that serious, the
authorities have the power to suspend the employee under
the relevant rules, and the suspension by itself permits a
resort to the sealed cover procedure.... (emphasis supplied}"
From this, it becomes clear that the factum of an employee having
been placed under suspension provides adequate ground to adopt
the sealed cover procedure, as long as the proceedings/allegations
in relation to which, the employee was placed under suspension,
have not assumed finality. The fact that he was reinstated after
some time does not make much difference.”
7.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid decision, the petitioner has
approached this Court by means of the present writ petition.
8.
We have heard Mr. T.V. George, learned counsel for the
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
petitioner and Mr. Jetly, learned counsel for the respondents, at length.
9.
The law relating to the circumstances in which the
recommendations of the DPC which considered a public servant for
promotion can be placed in a sealed cover is no longer res integra.
The field is covered by the judgments of the Supreme Court as well as
the OM issued by the DOPT.
10.
In K.V. Jankiraman, the Supreme Court held as under:
“8.
The common questions involved in all these matters relate
to what in service jurisprudence has come to be known as “sealed
cover procedure”. Concisely stated, the questions are: (1) What is
the date from which it can be said that disciplinary/criminal
proceedings are pending against an employee? (2) What is the
course to be adopted when the employee is held guilty in such
proceedings if the guilt merits punishment other than that of
dismissal? (3) To what benefits an employee who is completely or
partially exonerated is entitled to and from which date? The
“sealed cover procedure” is adopted when an employee is due for
promotion, increment etc. but disciplinary/criminal proceedings are
pending against him at the relevant time and hence, the findings of
his entitlement to the benefit are kept in a sealed cover to be
opened after the proceedings in question are over. Hence, the
relevance and importance of the questions.”
11.
Following the judgment in K.V. Jankiraman, the DOPT issued
O.M. dated 14 September 1992, on which the respondent had placed
reliance before the Tribunal as well as before us. Mr. Jetly, learned
counsel for the respondent has drawn our attention to paras 1 and 2 of
the aforesaid OM:
“1.
The undersigned is directed to refer to Department of
Personnel & Training OM No.22011/2/86-Estt.(A) dated 12th
January, 1988 and subsequent instructions issued from time to time
on the above subject and to say that the procedure and guidelines to
be followed in the matter of promotion of Government servants
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
against whom disciplinary/court proceedings are pending or whose
conduct is under investigation have been reviewed carefully.
Government have also noticed the judgement dated 27.08.1991 of
the Supreme Court in Union of India etc. v. K.V. Jankiraman etc.
As a result of the review and in supersession of all the earlier
instructions on the subject (referred to in the margin), the
procedure to be followed in this regard by the authorities
concerned is laid down in the subsequent paras of this OM for their
guidance.
2.
At the time of consideration of the cases of Government
servants for promotion, details of Government servants in the
consideration zone for promotion falling under the following
categories should be specifically brought to the notice of the
Departmental Promotion Committee:i)
Government servants under suspension;
ii)
Government servants in respect of whom a charge
sheet has been issued and the disciplinary proceedings are
pending; and
iii)
Government servants in respect
prosecution for a criminal charge is pending.
of
whom
2.1
The Departmental Promotion Committee shall assess the
suitability of the Government servants coming within the purview
of the circumstances mentioned above alongwith other eligible
candidates without taking into consideration the disciplinary case
criminal prosecution pending. The assessment of the DPC,
including "Unlit for Promotion', and the grading awarded by it will
be kept in a sealed cover. The cover will be superscribed Findings
regarding suitability for promotion to the grade/post of …………..
in respect of Shri …………………….. termination of (name of the
Government servant), Not to be opened till the disciplinary
case/criminal prosecution against Shri ……………… The
proceedings of the DPC need only contain the note "The findings
are contained in the attached sealed cover. The authority competent
to fill the vacancy should be separately advised to fill the vacancy
in the higher grade only in an officiating capacity when the
findings of the DPC in respect of the suitability of a Government
servant for his promotion are kept in a sealed cover.
2.2
The same procedure outlined in para 2.1 above will be
followed by the subsequent Departmental Promotion Committees
convened till the disciplinary case/criminal prosecution against the
Government servant concerned is concluded.”
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
12.
The aforesaid OM dated 14 September 1992 required some
further elucidation, which prompted the DOPT to issue a subsequent
OM on 2 November 2012 of which we deem it appropriate to
reproduce paras 1 to 8 :
“Instructions issued vide O.M. No. 22012/1/99-Estt. (D) dated
25.10.2004 based on the O.M. No. 22011/4/1991-Estt. (A) dated
14.09.1992 (issued on the basis of procedure laid down by
Supreme Court in K.V. Jankiraman case) makes it clear that
vigilance clearance for promotion may be denied only in the
following three circumstances: (i)
Government servants under suspension;
(ii)
Government servants in respect of whom a charge
sheet. has been issued and the disciplinary proceedings are
pending; and
(iii) Government servants in respect
prosecution for a criminal charge is pending.
of
whom
Withholding of vigilance clearance to a Government servant who is
not under suspension or who has not been issued a charge sheet
and the disciplinary proceedings are pending or against whom
prosecution for criminal charge is not pending may not be legally
tenable in view of the procedure laid down in the aforesaid O.Ms.
2.
Existing instructions provide for processing the cases of
disciplinary proceedings in a time bound manner. A number of
cases have however, come to notice where initiation of disciplinary
proceedings/issue of chargesheet/processing of the case is
considerably
delayed
by
the
administrative
Ministries/Departments. Such delays allow an officer whose
conduct is under cloud, to be considered for promotion. It becomes
essential in respect of officer(s) in whose case disciplinary
proceedings are contemplated or pending and are included in
consideration zone for promotion, necessary action be taken for
placing the proposal before the DPC so that vigilance clearance is
not allowed as per conditions mentioned in para 1 above.
3.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in its judgment dated
27.08.1991 in Union of India v. K.V. Jankiraman etc has held:
“5. An employee has no right to promotion. He has only a
right to be considered for promotion. The promotion to a
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
post and more so, to a selection post, depends upon several
circumstances. To qualify for promotion, the least that is
expected of an employee is to have an unblemished record.
That is the minimum expected to ensure a clean and
efficient administration and to protect the public interests.
An employee found guilty of misconduct cannot be placed
on par with the other employees and his case has to be
treated differently. There is therefore, no discrimination
when in the matter of promotion, he is treated differently".
4.
The issue of promotion of an officer who may be
technically cleared from vigilance angle but in whose case it may
not be appropriate to promote him/her in view of doubtful integrity
or where a charge-sheet is under consideration etc has been under
examination in this Department.
5.
The O.M No. 22012/1/99-Estt. (D) dated 25th October,
2004 further provides that a DPC shall assess the suitability of the
Government servant coming within the purview of the
circumstances mentioned in para 2 of the Office Memorandum No.
22011/4/91-Estt. (A) dated 14.09.1992, alongwith other eligible
candidates, without taking into consideration the disciplinary
case/criminal prosecution pending. No promotion can be withheld
merely on the basis of suspicion or doubt or where the matter is
under preliminary investigation and has not reached the stage of
issue of charge sheet etc. If in the matter of corruption/dereliction
of duty etc., there is a serious complaint and the matter is still
under investigation, the Government is within its right to suspend
the official. In that case, the officer's case for promotion would
automatically be required to be placed in the sealed cover.
6.
When a Government servant comes under a cloud, he may
pass through three stages, namely, investigation, issue of charge by
either sheet in Departmental Proceedings and/or prosecution for a
criminal charge followed penalty/conviction exoneration/acquittal.
During the stage of investigation prior to issue of charge sheet in
disciplinary proceedings or prosecution, if the Government is of
the view that the charges are serious and the officer should not be
promoted, it is open to the Government to suspend the officer
which will lead to the DPC recommendation to be kept in sealed
cover. The sealed cover procedure is to be resorted to only after the
charge memo/charge sheet is issued or the officer is placed under
suspension. The pendency of preliminary investigations prior to
that stage is not sufficient to adopt the sealed cover procedure.
7.
The law on sealed cover based on the judgment of the Apex
Court in Union of India v. K.V. Janakiraman etc., is by now well
settled. The O.M. dated 14.9.92 confined the circumstances for
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
adopting sealed cover to the three situations mentioned in para 2 of
the said O.M. Even after recommendation of the DPC, but before
appointment of the officer if any of the three situations arise, the
case is deemed to have been kept in sealed cover by virtue of para
7 of the O.M. dated 14.9.92.
8.
As regards the stage when prosecution for a criminal
charge can be stated to be pending, the said O.M. dated 14.9.92
does not specify the same and hence the definition of pendency of
judicial proceedings in criminal cases given in Rule 9 (6)(b)(i) of
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 is adopted for the purpose. The Rule 9
(6)(b)(i) of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 provides as under:"(b)
-
judicial proceedings shall be deemed to be instituted
(i)
in the case of criminal proceedings, on the
date on which the complaint or report of a Police
Officer, of which the Magistrate takes cognizance,
is made.”
13.
Subsequently, in Anil Kumar Sarkar, K.V. Jankiraman, was
revisited. The Supreme court held in the said case that where no
criminal case was registered, charge-sheet filed and where the officer
was not under suspension on the date when the DPC met, the case
could not be placed in a sealed cover.
14.
The position as it emerges from the decisions in K.V.
Jankiraman, and Anil Kumar Sarkar, as well as OMs dated 14
September 1992 and 2 November 2012 issued by the DOPT is clear
and categorical. Vigilance clearance may be denied and the case of an
officer for promotion may be placed in sealed cover only if (i)
criminal proceedings are pending against the officer, or (ii) the officer
is the recipient of a charge-sheet initiating disciplinary proceedings
against him, or (iii) the officer is under suspension, on the date when
the DPC meets.
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
15.
The concept of pendency of criminal proceedings has further
been clarified by the OM dated 2 November 2012 issued by the DOPT
which, placing reliance on Rule 9(6)(b)(i) of the CCS (Pension) Rules
1972 deems criminal proceedings to be instituted on the date when the
complaint or report of a police officer and Magistrate takes
cognizance. However, this position stands clarified by the judgment
of the Supreme Court in K.V. Jankiraman, which has approved the
view adopted by a Full Bench of the Tribunal to the extent that it is
only when a charge-memo in a disciplinary proceedings or a chargesheet in a criminal prosecution is issued to the employee that it can be
said that the departmental proceedings/criminal prosecution is initiated
against the employee. The sealed cover procedure is to be resorted to
only after the charge-memo/charge-sheet is issued. The pendency of
preliminary investigation prior to that stage will not be sufficient to
enable the authorities to adopt the sealed cover procedure. We are in
agreement with the Tribunal on this point.
16.
In the present case on the date when the DPC met, there were
no departmental charge-sheet had been issued to the petitioner, no
charge-sheet had been filed against the petitioner before the Criminal
Court as it came to be filed only later on 10 February 2016 and
suspension order of the petitioner had already been revoked.
17.
Mr. Jetly has placed reliance on some decisions which we deem
it appropriate to deal with. Mr. Jetly first cites State of Madhya
Pradesh v. Syed Naseem Zahir7. This decision in fact supports the
7 (1992) Supp 1 SCR 962
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
petitioner. In that case, the Supreme Court has specifically held as
under:
“The tribunal allowed the application of Syed on the short ground
that the Departmental Promotion Committee which met on October
28, 1987 acted illegally in adopting the "sealed cover" procedure.
Relying upon the judgment of this Court in Union of India v. K.V.
Jankiraman and Others, the tribunal came to the conclusion that
"sealed cover" procedure could be adopted only after the date of
issuance of charge-sheet, that being the date from which
disciplinary proceedings could be taken to have been initiated.
Since in this case, admittedly, on the date when the DPC met the
charge sheet had not been served on Syed, resort could not be had
to the "sealed cover" procedure. The reasoning and the conclusion
of the tribunal are unexceptionable. The only question for our
consideration is whether in the facts and circumstances of this case
specially in view of the events subsequent to the meeting of the
DPC, it would be in the interest of justice to promote respondent
Syed to the post of Chief Engineer.”
18.
The Supreme Court was in this case dealing not with criminal
proceedings but with disciplinary proceedings. The Tribunal had held
that as no charge-sheet had been served on the employee prior to the
DPC, the DPC could not have adopted the sealed cover. The Supreme
Court has clearly held that the reasoning and conclusion of the
Tribunal were unexceptionable. The Supreme Court proceeded,
however, to examine whether keeping in view the events which took
place after the meeting of the DPC, it was in the interests of justice to
promote the employee to the post of Chief Engineer.
19.
We are not concerned with events which took place after the
holding of the DPC. The lis before us is, whether the sealed cover
should or should not have been opened. As such, this case does not
operate against the view that we have adopted.
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
20.
Mr. Jetly next cites Union of India v. Kewal Kumar8. This was
a case in which, on the date of meeting of the DPC, a charge-sheet
proposing initiation of disciplinary proceedings for major penalty had
already stood issued to the employee concerned. This case is,
therefore, clearly distinguishable from the case before us.
21.
The Tribunal was, therefore, to our mind, in error in holding
that the sealed cover procedure could have been adopted in the case of
the petitioner.
22.
Resultantly, the OA filed by the petitioner before the Tribunal
would stand allowed. The impugned judgment of the Tribunal is
quashed and set aside. The petitioner would be entitled to
consequential relief as available in law.
23.
In case after opening of the sealed cover, the petitioner is found
fit for promotion, he shall be entitled to promotion from the date on
which others who were considered for promotion to the post of
Deputy Commissioner of Excise and Customs by the same DPC.
24.
The writ petition is allowed in the aforesaid terms.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J.
APRIL 21, 2026/yg
8 (1993) 3 SCR 45
W.P.(C) 13366/2018
KUMAR
18:18:11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review