Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE P.V.ASHA
TUESDAY ,THE 08TH DAY OF JANUARY 2019 / 8TH AGRAHAYANA, 1940
WP(C).No. 8166 of 2015
PETITIONER/S:
DR. LASNA SAHIB
AGED 35 YEARS
VALIYAVEED, OPP. ASMM HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL,
ALATHUR P.O., PALAKKAD.
BY ADV. SRI.S.PRASANTH (AYYAPPANKAVU)
RESPONDENT/S:
KERALA VETERINARY & ANIMAL SCIENCES UNIVERSITY
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR, POOKODE, LAKKIDI
P.O., WAYANAD DISTRICT - 673 576.
DR.JASMINE RANI.K.
ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPARTMENT OF ANIMAL NUTRITION
COLLEGE OF VETERINARY & ANIMAL SCIENCES, MANNUTHY,
THRISSUR DISTRICT 680 651.
3.
JITH JOHN MATHEW,
S/O.JOHN MATHAI, AGED 36 YEARS,
VASHNA THOTTATHIL HOUSE,
AMAYANNUR P.O, KOTTAYAM DISTRICT-686 019.
(ADDL.R3 IS IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DT.1.6.2015 IN
I.A.NO.6923/2015)
BY ADVS.
SRI.MILLU DANDAPANI,SC,K.V & A.S. UTY
SRI.KURIAN GEORGE KANNANTHANAM (SR.)
SMT.AYSHA YOUSEFF SC KERALA VETERINARY AND ANIMAL
SCIENCES
SRI.THOMAS GEORGE
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
29.11.2018, ALONG WITH WP(C).8906/2015, THE COURT ON 08.01.2019
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE P.V.ASHA
TUESDAY ,THE 08TH DAY OF JANUARY 2019 / 8TH AGRAHAYANA, 1940
WP(C).No. 8906 of 2015
PETITIONER/S:
DR.RAMEES T.P,
AGED 28 YEARS
THADIYAMPURAM HOUSE, CHEMMARAM, NADUVATH P.O.,
WANDOOR, KERALA, INDIA 679328.
BY ADV. SRI.S.PRASANTH (AYYAPPANKAVU)
RESPONDENT/S:
KERALA VETERINARY & ANIMAL SCIENCES UNIVERSITY
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR, POOKODE, LAKKIDI
P.O., WAYANAD DISTRICT 673576.
DR.DEEPTHI VIJAY
ASSISTANT PROFESSOR, DEPARTMENT OF VETERINARY
PUBLIC HEALTH, COLLEGE OF VETERINARY & ANIMAL
SCIENCES, MANNUTHY, THRISSUR, DISTRICT-680651.
BY ADVS.
SRI.MILLU DANDAPANI
SMT.AYSHA YOUSEFF SC KERALA VETERINARY AND ANIMAL
SCIENCES
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
29.11.20187 ALONG WITH WP(C).NO.8166/2015, THE COURT ON
08.01.2019 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
P.V.ASHA, J.
-------------------------W.P(c).No.8166 of 2015-U
and
W.P(C).No.8906 of 2015-K
------------------------------------------Dated this the 8th day of January, 2019
JUDGMENT
Petitioners in both these cases submitted applications for appointment to the
post of Assistant Professors, in Animal Nutrition Department and in Veterinary
Public Health respectively in the Kerala Veterinary and Animals Sciences
University ('the University' for short) .
2.
The University invited applications for appointment to the post of
Assistant Professors in various disciplines, issuing notification dated 12.06.2014,
which is produced as Ext.P7 in W.P(c).No.8166/2015 and Ext.P4 in
W.P(c).No.8906/2015. The grievance of the petitioners is that the University
made appointments by applying the principles of reservation afresh without
reckoning the reservation already applied in the appointments to the very same
Department before its bifurcation. Candidates belonging to certain communities
are put to disadvantage; whereas certain other communities are getting double
advantage.
3. The University was incorporated by bifurcating the Kerala Agricultural
University by Act 2 of 2011. The Institutions and the Departments under the
Agricultural University relating to Veterinary and Animal Sciences were brought
under the new University. As per Section 55 of the Act, all the institutions referred
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
to in the schedule to the Act were transferred from the Agricultural University to
the new University.
The University Statutes were made in the year 2014.
Immediately thereafter the University issued notification dated 12.06.2014 for
selection and appointment to the post of Assistant Professors in various disciplines
under the University.
The petitioner in W.P(c).No.8166/2015 submitted her
application for appointment in the discipline of Animal Nutrition. Ext.P8 rank list
was issued on 11.02.2015. The petitioner, who belongs to Muslim community, is
ranked No.5 and she is the first among the candidates belonging to that
community.
4. The case of the petitioner is that the Kerala Agricultural University had
issued a notification on 08.11.2006 for appointment to the post of Assistant
Professors in various disciplines based on which a rank list was published on
10.04.2008 in the discipline Animal Nutrition.
The petitioner claims that
appointments were made upto rank No.6 and candidate with rank No.11 (Ezhava)
was also appointed.
The petitioner claims that the last selection
in the
Agricultural University was made based on Ext.P10 rank list of the year 2008. It
is also the case of the petitioner that there was an NCA vacancy of Muslim in the
department and Ext.P4 notification was published on 14.01.2010 inviting
application for appointment against that vacancy.
It is stated that
W.P(C).No.35838/2010 filed for a direction to effect the appointment based on
that notification is pending. It is also claimed that the Public Information Officer
of the University had as per Ext.P6 letter dated 04.11.2011 informed that the NCA
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
vacancy in the Animal Nutrition Department was available in the respondent
University.
5.
Therefore, the petitioner claims that the University is bound to extend
the benefit of the NCA notification to the candidates from Muslim community as it
forms its liability under Section 55 to observe the principles of reservation.
According to the petitioner, Rules 14 to 17 of KS&SSR are made applicable to the
University.
Statute 139 also makes the provisions contained in KS&SSR
applicable to the teachers. It is stated that in the event of non availability of
candidates for selection from any particular community such vacancy shall be kept
vacant and it shall be filled up by direct recruitment from that community.
According to the petitioner, the action of the University in starting the reservation
roster and communal rotation afresh, has resulted in disadvantage to the Muslim
community.
It is pointed out that by the enactment of the University, certain
departments were carved out from the Agricultural University and the
appointments to this new University is in continuation of the action which was
taken in the Agricultural University. It is stated that the candidates belonging to
Ezhava community have got additional advantage on account of the fresh roster
for communal rotation to the prejudice of candidates belonging to other
communities eligible for reservation and therefore the petitioners claim that they
are entitled to be appointed against NCA vacancy which was available as on the
date of bifurcation of the University.
6.
The 2nd respondent has filed a counter affidavit stating that 5
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
vacancies were available in Animal Nutrition discipline.
50% of the total
vacancies goes to open category and the remaining vacancies were earmarked for
the reservation communities. According to the 2nd respondent, the appointment is
to be made under Section 58 of the Act observing Rules 14 to 17 of KS&SSR;
when a new University was created by a statute it is an independent legal entity
and when vacancies are notified the cycle of reservation has to start afresh.
According to the 2nd respondent, it is not a bifurcation of the Kerala Agricultural
University. It is stated that Kerala Veterinary and Animal Sciences University was
established by Act 3 of 2011 and it came into force on 14.1.2010 and all activities
of that University are governed by the Act and Statutes of the University and it
cannot be said that appointments are made in continuation of appointments made
by the Kerala Agricultural University. When the Veterinary Science Wing of the
Kerala Agricultural University had branched out to form the University, options
were called for, from the staff members of the undivided Kerala Agricultural
University and those who opted did not conform to the reservation roster system as
some of the veterinary posts were retained by the Kerala Agricultural University
and some of the incumbents to the posts had chosen to remain in that University.
Therefore, it became imperative to organise a fresh roster system from the date of
inception of the University. It is stated that Statute is uniformly followed in
respect of all the posts following reservation as per Government instructions.
When the new University is formed the first reservation goes to Ezhava
community and accordingly, the 2nd respondent was selected.
According to the
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
respondents, the changed scenario on account of formation of University with an
independent Statute justifies a fresh roster. It is further pointed out that the
University was formed as a result of bifurcation of Kerala Agricultural University
as per the University Act, 2010 and the University has its own criteria for selection
of teaching and non teaching staff in accordance with Sections 57 and 58 of the
Act and selection procedure is governed by statute 132, 140 and 141. Therefore,
while there exists its own Statute, the University cannot make appointment in
continuation of reservation roster made by the Kerala Agricultural University.
Therefore, the petitioner, who secured the 5 th position only, cannot claim
appointment against the reservation turn. When the link between the KAU had
been broken there is no option but to adopt the reservation policy as per the Statute
governing the University and it has been uniformly adopted as per rules against all
vacancies available in the University. A separate seniority list, separate rules and
regulation and reservation roster became inevitable. It is stated that the existence
of some of the Assistant Professors belonging to Ezhava community is only a
matter of chance and the same cannot be a fact for a change in the communal
reservation.
7.
In the case of the petitioner in W.P(c).No.8906 of 2015, he is included
as rank No.7 in the rank list and he is the first candidate in the Muslim category.
Rank Nos.1, 2 and 5 belong to Ezhava community and they have already been
appointed. The 2nd respondent, who belongs to Ezhava community, has got
advantage by starting the rotation afresh. It is stated that as per the selection
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
conducted in the Agricultural University on the basis of notification issued on
08.11.2006, which is produced as Ext.P6, all candidates except rank No.1 were
appointed and the reservation benefit was granted to Ezhava community and SC
community. Muslim community was next in the rotation. Therefore, the petitioner
claims that appointment should have been granted to him in continuation of the
rotation observed in KAU. The petitioner has also produced the information he
received in an application under the Right to Information Act in which he was
informed that there are 3 Assistant Professors in Ezhava community among the
Asst.Professors in the discipline of Veterinary Public Health and one of them
belongs to SC community, as on 8.5.2015 and the petitioner seeks appointment in
continuation of the roster followed in the KAU.
8.
Having heard the contentions on either side, it would appear that the
departments to which the petitioners submitted applications
were shifted to the
new University, consequent to the operation and implementation and operation of
KVASU Act 2010. The respondents have not stated that anybody from these
departments have opted to continue in the Agricultural University. Therefore, it has
to be presumed that the entire department with its staff were shifted to the new
University. If that be so, the department has to function with the very same status,
benefits and liabilities as in the Agricultural University.
9.
Section 55 of the Act read as follows:
“55. Transfer of certain Colleges, Institutions and employees to the
University.(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Kerala Agricultural University
Act, 1971 (Act 33 of 1971), the colleges, research stations; Veterinary hospitals
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
and other institutions specified in the schedule, and the attached hostels and other
buildings together with the articles of furniture, libraries, books, laboratory,
stores, instruments, apparatus, appliances and equipments and all other property
both movable and immovable owned and managed by the Kerala Agricultural
University prior to the specified date, shall along with all the properties, assets,
liabilities and obligations stand transferred to, and vest in the University.
(2) The Government may, at any time after the commencement of this Act,
transfer to the University any of their lands for its use on such terms and
conditions as they deem proper.
(3) The Government may, at any time after the specified date, transfer to the
University, the control and management of any of their colleges or institutions on
such terms and conditions as they deem proper.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other Act relating to the
establishment of a University in the State or in the Statutes, Ordinances,
Regulations and Order made thereunder on and from the specified date, the
colleges or institutions referred to in sub-section (3) shall be disaffiliated from the
University to which they were affiliated on the date immediately preceding such
specified date and shall be deemed to be colleges or institutions affiliated to the
University.
(5) Any student of a college or institution specified in sub-section (1), who
was studying for any examination of the Kerala Agricultural University, prior to
the specified date, shall be permitted to complete his course in preparation
thereof, and the University shall make arrangements for holding for such
students, examinations, for such period as may be prescribed in accordance with
the curricula of students of the Kerala Agricultural University.
(6) Every person employed by the Kerala Agricultural University, and
serving in any of the colleges, reseaerch stations or institutions specified in subsection (1) shall, based on their option, as from the specified date, be transferred
to the University on the same conditions of service as were applicable to him
before such transfer and continue to be governed by the same conditions of
service unless and until such conditions are altered in accordance with the
provisions of the Statutes and Ordinances:
Provided that no such person who is deputed from the Government to
Kerala Agricultural University, shall be transferred to the University, without the
prior approval of the Government:
Provided further that no person employed by the State but working in
colleges, research stations or institutions mentioned in the Schedule shall be
transferred to the University, unless the Government takes a decision on the status
of his employment, and till then he shall continue to be governed by the
conditions of service under which he was employed.”
When the entire department is shifted from one place to another, though under a
different enactment, I find that there is substance in the contention of Sri. Prasant,
the learned Counsel for the petitioner, that a fresh reservation roster would only
defeat the purpose of reservation, when the
teaching staff in service in the
department were appointed following the principles of reservation and on the basis
of reservation roster.
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
Section 58 of the Act read as follows:
““58: Reservation of Appointments:- The rules for the reservation of appointments
to posts under the Government in favour of Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes and
Other Backward Classes shall apply in the case of appointment of the teachers and nonteaching staff and other employees of the University.”
The purpose of reservation is to see that there is adequate representation of the
communities eligible for reservation in tune with Rule 14 to 17 of KS&SSR. It
does not envisage any undue advantage or disadvantage to any particular
community. Clause 4 of Statute 132 which provides for application of principles
of reservation in each department, reads as follows:
“132.xxxx xxxx
xxxxx
xxxxxxx
xxxxxx
xxxxxx
xxxxxxx
xxxxxx
xxxx
(4): In making appointments to posts in any class or category in each
Department under the University, subject to the provisions contained in section
58 of the Act, the University shall observe the previsions of clauses (a), (b) and
(c) of rule 14 and rules 15, 16 and 17 of the Kerala State and Subordinate
Service Rules, 1958, as amended from time to time. “
Therefore, in case the existing staff of the department are those who got
appointment applying the principles of reservation and in case there are teachers
who got appointment against the reservation turns of Ezhava or any other
community, a re-start of the reservation roster will enure to the benefit of the
Ezhava community or the other communities which enjoyed the benefit of
reservation again. When the representation of a particular community is gathered
by way of reservation, further proceedings to make appointment from the very
same community again applying the principles of reservation would amount to
grant of double benefit, which is never contemplated under Rules 14 to 17 of
KS&SSR. It would only amount to violation of those principles leading to under
representation of other communities eligible for reservation. Over representation
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
by way of reservation is not envisaged by the Constitution of India. The contention
of the petitioners with respect to the previous selection following the principles of
reservation, based on which a candidate belonging to Muslim Community would
have been eligible for appointment against the next reservation turn is not disputed
except by stating that fresh roster was to be started on the enactment of the
University Act 2010. Any action enabling a community which enjoyed the benefit
of reservation while in Kerala Agricultural University, if gets the benefit of
reservation again on the enactment of the new University, will result in prejudice
to another community. Therefore, I am of the view that the University is duty
bound to make appointments of Assistant Professors in these two departments in
continuation of the reservation roster which was followed in the Agricultural
University for these Departments. That is, it has to start appointments from the
next turn in the 100 point roster as provided in Rules 14 to 17 of the KS&SSR.
Otherwise, the very purpose of reservation would be defeated.
10. Though the learned Standing Counsel, relying on the judgment in State
of Kerala v. Mohandas V.K: 2018 KHC 144, argued that once a new Statute comes
into force, no appointment can be made in accordance with the position or
conditions under the old statute, I find that the said judgment was not one dealing
with reservation and hence it cannot be applied to the facts of the case.
11.
In this case an interim order was already passed on 13.03.2015,
interdicting the appointments under the reservation turns. The candidates, who
were selected have not entered appearance or filed any counter affidavit. As
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
appointments have been made in all other departments and nobody has raised any
claim as in the case of the petitioners in these cases, the appointments made in
other departments shall not be affected by the directions in this judgments,
12. Therefore, there shall be a direction to the respondent University to
make appointments to the posts of Assistant Professors in the Departments of
Animal Nutrition Department and in Veterinary Public Health, set apart for the
reservation turns, in continuation of the reservation roster which was followed in
the Agricultural University for appointment to these departments. This shall be
done within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of the
judgment.
The Writ Petitions are disposed of with the above directions.
Sd/-
(P.V.ASHA, JUDGE)
rtr/
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 8166/2015
PETITIONER'S/S EXHIBITS:
EXHIBIT P1
P1: TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF
BACHELOR OF VETERINARY SCIENCE AND ANIMAL
HUSBANDRY AWARDED TO THE PETITOINER BY THE
KERALA AGRICULTURAL UNIVERSITY.
EXHIBIT P2
P2: TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF MASTER
OF VETERINARY SCIENCE IN ANIMAL NUTRITION
AWARDED BY THE TAMIL NADU VETERINARY AND
ANIMAL SCIENCE UNIVERSITY.
EXHIBIT P3
P3: TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF NET
AWARDED BY THE AGRICULTURAL SCIENTISTS
RECRUITMENT BOARD (ICAR).
EXHIBIT P4
P4: TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION DATED
14/1/2010 ISSUED BY THE KERALA AGRICULTRAL
UNIVERSITY.
EXHIBIT P5
P5: TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION DATED
24/10/2011 UNDER THE RIGHT TO INFORAMATION
ACT SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT P6
P6: TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY DATED 4/11/2011
SENT BY THE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER OF
THE 1ST RESPONDENT TO THE PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT P7
P7: TRUE COPY OF NOTIFICATION
NO.KVASU/GA/A/1648/2014 DATED 12/6/2014
ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P8
P8: TRUE COPY OF THE RANKED LIST DATED
11/2/2015 FOR THE POST OF ASSISTANT
PROFESSOR IN ANIMAL NUTRITION PUBLISHED BY
THE 1ST RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P9
P9:TRUE COPY OF NOTIFICATION
GA/K1/0554/2006 DATED 8/11/2006 PUBLISHED
BY THE KERALA AGRICULTRAL UNIVERSITY.
EXHIBIT P10
P10:TRUE COPY OF THE EXTRACT OF THE RANKED
LIST DATED 10/4/2008 FOR THE POST OF
ASSISTANT PROFESSORS IN ANIMAL NUTRITION
PUBLISHED BY THE KERALA AGRICULTURAL
UNIVERSITY.
W.P(C).Nos.8166/15 & 8906/15
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 8906/2015
PETITIONER'S/S EXHIBITS:
EXHIBIT P1
EXHIBIT-P1: TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF
BACHELOR OF VETERINARY SCIENCE AND ANIMAL
HUSBANDRY AWARDED TO THE PETITIONER BY THE
KERALA AGRICULTURAL UNIVERSITY.
EXHIBIT P2
EXHIBIT-P2: TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF
MASTER OF VETERINARY SCIENCE IN VETERINARY
PUBLIC HEALTH AWARDED BY THE INDIAN
VETERINARY RESEARCH INSTITUTE TO THE
PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT P3
EXHIBIT-P3: TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE ON
NET AWARDED BY THE AGRICULTURAL SCIENTISTS
RECRUITMENT BOARD (ICAR) TO THE PETITIONER.
EXHIBIT P4
EXHIBIT-P4: TRUE COPY OF NOTIFICATION
NO.KVASU/GA/A/1648/2014 DATED 12.06.2014
ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P5
EXHIBIT-P5: TRUE COPY OF THE RANKED LIST
DATED 11.2.2015 FOR THE POST OF ASSISTANT
PROFESSOR IN VETERINARY PUBLIC HEALTH
PUBLISHED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P6
EXHIBIT-P6: TRUE COPY OF NOTIFICATION
GA/K1/10554/2006 DATED 8.11.2006 PUBLISHED
BY THE KERALA AGRICULTURAL UNIVERSITY.
EXHIBIT P7
EXHIBIT-P7: TRUE COPY OF THE RANKED LIST
DATED 10.4.2008 FOR THE POST OF ASSISTANT
PROFESSORS IN VETERINARY PUBLIC HEALTH
PUBLISHED BY THE KERALA AGRICULTURAL
UNIVERSITY.
EXHIBIT-P8
TRUE COPY OF APPLICATION DT.10.4.2015 FILED BY THE
PETITIONER UNDER THE RIGHT TO INFORMATION ACT, 2005 TO
THE PUBLIC INFORAMATION OFFICER OF THE 1ST
RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT-P9
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY DT.8.5.2015 SUBMITTED BY THE
PUBLIC INFORAMATION OFFICER OF THE 1ST RESPONDENT
TO THE PETITIONER.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review