Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.A. No.44 of 2024
Dr. Pradip Dey, S/O. Late Dinesh Dey, R/O. Gandhigram, School Tilla, P.O.Gandhigram, P.S.-Airport, District-West Tripura, PIN-799012.
…….Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, Represented by its Principal Secretary to the Higher
Education Department, Govt. of Tripura, P.O.-Secretariat, P.S.-New Capital
Complex, District-West Tripura, PIN-799010.
2. The Director, Higher Education Department, Govt. of Tripura, P.O.-Agartala,
P.S.-West Agartala, District-West Tripura, PIN-799001.
3. The Tripura Public Service Commission, Represented by its Secretary,
Akhaura Road, P.O.-Agartala, P.S.-West Agartala, District-West Tripura, PIN799001.
4. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, Akhaura Road, P.O.Agartala, P.S.-West Agartala, District-West Tripura, PIN-799001.
5. Sri Debabrata Bhattacharjee, S/O. Shri Sambhunath Bhattacharjee, West
Joynagar, Road No.6, Netaji Lane, P.O.-Agartala, P.S.-West Agartala, PIN799001, District-West Tripura.
6. University Grants Commission, Represented by its Chairperson, having
office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi, PIN-110002, India.
…….Respondent(s)
7. Smt. Mahua Choudhury, D/O. Sri Sunil Ranjan Chaudhury, Notice to be
served through the Principal, Micheal Madhusudhan Datta College, Sabroom,
P.O.-Sabroom, District-South Tripura, PIN-799145
…….Proforma Respondent(s)
alongwith
W.A. No.45 of 2024
Dr. Pradip Dey, S/O. Late Dinesh Dey, R/O. Gandhigram, School Tilla, P.O.Gandhigram, P.S.-Airport, District-West Tripura, PIN-799012.
…….Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, Represented by its Principal Secretary to the Higher
Education Department, Govt. of Tripura, P.O.-Secretariat, P.S.-New Capital
Complex, District-West Tripura, PIN-799010.
2. The Director, Higher Education Department, Govt. of Tripura, P.O.-Agartala,
P.S.-West Agartala, District-West Tripura, PIN-799001.
3. The Tripura Public Service Commission, Represented by its Secretary,
Akhaura Road, P.O.-Agartala, P.S.-West Agartala, District-West Tripura, PIN799001.
4. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, Akhaura Road, P.O.Agartala, P.S.-West Agartala, District-West Tripura, PIN-799001.
5. Sri Kamal Deb, S/O. Late Mano Ranjan Deb, resident of 79 Tilla,
Ramkrishna Palli, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex, District-West
Tripura, PIN-799006.
6. University Grants Commission, Represented by its Chairperson, having
office at Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi, PIN-110002, India.
…….Respondent(s)
7. Smt. Mahua Choudhury, D/O. Sri Sunil Ranjan Chaudhury, Notice to be
served through the Principal, Micheal Madhusudhan Datta College, Sabroom,
P.O.-Sabroom, District-South Tripura, PIN-799145
…….Proforma Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, Advocate,
Ms. Ishpa Chakma, Advocate.
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. Sankar Kr. Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.,
Mr. Suman Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. Kundan Pandey, Advocate,
Ms. Adwitiya Chakraborty, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Date of hearing
: 07.01.2026.
Date of pronouncement : 29.01.2026.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(M.S. Ramachandra Rao, C.J.)
1)
Since both these Writ Appeals arise out of the same judgment of
the learned Single Judge, they are being disposed of by this common
judgment.
2)
The respondents No.5 in both the Writ Appeals had filed WP(C)
No.885/2022
and
WP(C)
No.886/2022
respectively
challenging
the
appointment of the appellant on 1.2.2022 to the post of Assistant Professor
(Education Subject) by the Director, Higher Education Department, Govt. of
Tripura
(respondent
no.2)
pursuant
to
advertisement
No.01/2021
dt.08.02.2021 and the addendum dt.30.04.021 issued by the Tripura Public
Service Commission (respondent No.3 in both the Writ Appeals) (for short
‘TPSC’).
3)
The appellant was arrayed as respondent no.5 in the respective
Writ Petitions.
The case of the respondent No.5 in the Writ Appeals:
4)
In the advertisement dt.8.2.2021 issued by the TPSC, the
essential qualifications prescribed for filling the post of Assistant Professor in
various disciplines including the subject ‘Education’ mentioned therein was as
under:
“EDUCATIONAL & OTHER QUALIFICATIONS:
(1) ESSENTIAL QUALIFICATIONS:
(i)
A Master’s Degree with at least 55% of the marks (or
equivalent grade in a point-scale wherever the grading system is
followed) in a concerned / relevant/ allied subject from an Indian
University, or an equivalent degree from an accredited foreign
University.
(ii)
Besides fulfilling the above qualifications, the candidates
should have cleared the National Eligibility Test (NET) conducted
by UGC or the CSIR-or a similar test accredited by the UGC like
SLET/ SET or who are or have been awarded a Ph. D degree in
accordance with the University Grants Commission (Minimum
Standards and Procedure for Award of M. Phil/ Ph. D Degree)
Regulations, 2009 or 2016 and their amendments from time to
time as the case may be exempted from NET/SLET/SET.
Provided the candidates registered for the Ph. D
programme prior to July 11, 2009 shall be governed by the
provisions of the then existing Ordinances/ By Laws/ Regulations
of the Institution awarding the degree and such Ph. D candidates
shall be exempted from the requirement of NET/SLET/SET for
recruitment and appointment of Assistant Professor or equivalent
positions in Universities/Colleges/Institutions subject to the
fulfillment of the following conditions:a)
The Ph. D degree of the candidate has been awarded in a
regular mode;
b)
Ph. D thesis has been evaluated by at least two external
examiners;
c)
An open Ph. D viva voce of the candidate has been
conducted;
d)
The candidate has published two research papers from
his/her Ph. D work, out of which at least one in a referred journal;
The candidate has presented at least two papers based on
his/her Ph. D work in conferences, seminars sponsored/funded/
supported by the UGC/ICSSR/CSIR or any similar agency. The
fulfillment of these conditions is to be certified by the Registrar or
Dean (Academic Affairs) of the University concerned.
OR
The Ph. D degree obtained from a foreign university/
institution with a ranking among top in the World University
Ranking (at any time) by any one of the following Quacquarelli
Symonds (QS) (ii) The times Higher Education (THE) or (iii) the
Academic Ranking of World Universities (ARWU) of the Shanghai
Jiao Tong University (Shanghai)
Note:-NET/SLET/SET shall not be required for such
Masters
Degree
Programmes
in
disciplines
for
which
NET/SLET/SET is not conducted by the UGC, CSIR or similar test
accredited by the UGC like NET/SET. (e.g. Kokborok and
Engineering discipline).”
The above qualification was laid down in accordance with the
UGC Regulations, 2018 for direct recruitment to the post of Assistant
professor in Govt. Degree Colleges in education subject.
5)
It is undisputed that the TPSC adopted Academic Performance
Index (for short ‘API’) method to shortlist the candidates. Annexure-B to the
advertisement indicated how the same was to be calculated/computed by
awarding marks for various parameters specified therein. In that Annexure-B
it was indicated that if a candidate has a Ph.D Qualification, 25 marks were to
be awarded.
6)
On 30.04.2021, there was an addendum issued by the TPSC
which stated that for the post of Assistant Professor in Education in degree
colleges, the candidates should possess NET/SLET/Ph.D in Education besides
M.A. Education or M.Ed.
7)
The appellant possesses educational qualification in MA in
Political Science, M.Ed, M.Phil in Political Science, Ph.D in Political Science,
SET in Political Science, SET in Education subject.
8)
Thus vide the addendum dt.30.4.2021, the requirement of
possessing Ph.D in Education subject for the purpose of appointment to the
post of Assistant Professor in Education was introduced in addition to M.Ed
qualification, which the appellant possessed.
9)
So as per the addendum dt. 30.04.2021 the appellant is eligible
for consideration for the post of Assistant Professor in Education though he
did not have Ph.D in Education and possessed only Ph.D in Political Science.
The counsel for the respondents No.5 also does not dispute this.
10)
Admittedly, the TPSC, after constituting a scrutiny committee for
API calculation, and on the basis of scrutiny committee’s recommendation,
published the API scores of candidates. In that list, the appellant as well as the
respondents No.5 secured API score of 82/100.
11)
Thereafter 7 days time was given to file representations to all
shortlisted candidates including the respondents No.5.
12)
Though 23 representations were received and were considered,
the respective respondents No.5 gave no such representation challenging the
API score given to appellant in those 7 days.
13)
The final API Score was published on 23.9.2021 and the TPSC
published the result on 1.12.2021. Thereafter an interview was held by TPSC
on 08.11.2021 and the appellant was recommended for appointment for the
said post on 3.12.2021. The State appointed appellant as Asst. Professor in
Education subject on 1.2.2022.
14)
The contention of the counsel for the respondents No.5 is that in
Annexure-B to the advertisement issued on 08.02.2021, 25 marks in the API
were earmarked for possessing Ph.D qualification and since the appellant did
not possess Ph.D in Education subject, the appellant was wrongly awarded 25
marks by the TPSC in the API.
15)
The TPSC refuted the said contention by saying that in clause
4.1. of UGC regulations, 2018 applicable, it is nowhere mentioned that for
appointment to the post of Asst. Professor, Ph.D in concerned/relevant /allied
subject is required, and that it only mentions Ph.D. But possession of Masters
Degree in the concerned subject is essential and the appellant fulfils the same.
It contends that the respondents No.5 did not raise during the entire selection
process objection regarding the qualification of the appellant, that they
participated consciously in the selection process, and when not selected after
interview, they filed Writ petitions, which are therefore not maintainable. It is
stated that in the interview the respective respondents No.5 got less marks
than appellant and so he was recommended for the post of Asst. Professor in
Education department.
16)
The State Government stated that they appointed the appellant as
Asst. Professor ( Education) on recommendation by the TPSC and the latter is
an expert body and the State has no role in it.
The judgment of the learned Single Judge and our findings thereon:
In Anand Yadav and others v. State of Uttar Pradesh and
17)
others1, the Supreme Court has held that M.Ed is equivalent to M.A.
(Education) and that M.Ed is a Post graduate degree in Education subject and
for the post of Asst. Professor (Education), persons holding both M.A.
(Education) and M.Ed are eligible. It declared:
“30. The stand put forth before us by the UGC Respondent 4 is
unequivocal in its terms that M.Ed degree is indeed a Master’s
degree in Education in terms of the notification issued by it under
the UGC Act in terms of Section 22. In that sense, the matter is
put to rest in terms of recognition of M.Ed as a postgraduate
degree by the competent authority.
31.
The question of equivalence, as submitted by Respondent 4
UGC was to be left to NCTE. It is in view thereof that NCTE was
added as a party (Respondent 5) and has, once again, put forth its
position quite unequivocally. NCTE has drawn a distinction
between the two degrees to the extent that while MA (Education)
is a degree in the discipline of Education, the MEd degree is a
practitioner’s degree. Reference has also been made to a
committee constituted in pursuance of the impugned judgment 3,
which is an expert committee. ... It is in these circumstances a
conclusion was reached that, from the point of view of duration
(2021) 12 SCC 390
and curricular inputs, M.Ed qualifies itself as a Master’s
programme in Education and is even recognised by the UGC and
NCTE as such. …. There is also a categorical statement in the last
paragraph of the counter-affidavit of NCTE to the effect that the
M.Ed is a Master’s degree recognised by apex bodies like the
UGC and NCTE for appointment as Assistant Professor in
Education and they are also eligible for the NET/SLET/JRF.
33. …. there is no doubt about the M.Ed degree being a
postgraduate degree, in view of not only what the UGC stated
before us, but having promulgated the relevant Regulations as far
back as 2010 as amended from time to time. The issue of
equivalence has been rightly considered by NCTE and while
recognising some distinct aspects of the two degrees, it has
clearly stated that for the job of Assistant Professors
(Education), both are eligible.
34.
We may notice that it is not as if a person with an M.Ed
degree is eligible for all the posts which were advertised for
Science, Arts and others. Their eligibility has been found only for
the post of Assistant Professor (Education), which is directly
relatable to the subject to be taught. … and once the expert body
being NCTE, inter alia, has taken that aspect into consideration
apart from other factors to opine equivalence for the purpose of
appointment to the post of Assistant Professor in Education, it
would not be appropriate to take a contra view.
35.
We say so in view of the fact that matters of education must
be left to educationists, of course subject to being governed by the
relevant statutes and regulations. It is not the function of this
Court to sit as an expert body over the decision of the experts,
especially when the experts are all eminent people as apparent
from the names as set out. This aspect has received judicial
imprimatur even earlier and it is not that we are saying something
new. We may refer to the pronouncement in Zahoor Ahmad
Rather in this behalf which has dealt with the dual aspects : (a) it
is for the employer to consider what functionality of qualification
and content of course of studies would lead to the acquisition of
an eligible qualification; and (b) such matters must be left to
educationists.
37.
There are even some other judgments of the High Courts,
which in turn were then sought to be relied upon to canvas a
proposition that there is a widespread acceptance of MEd not
being equivalent to MA (Education). That they are two different
degrees is obvious; this is even recognised by NCTE while
emphasising the subtle distinction between the two degrees as one
being a Master’s degree but not a professional degree, while the
other being a professional degree. If the two degrees are
identical, there is no question of equivalence. The issue of
equivalence only arises when there are two different degrees and
what is to be decided whether for certain purposes they can be
treated as equivalent. This is exactly what has happened as a
result of the respective expert committees set up by Respondents 2
& 5. The employer i.e. Respondent 2, had accepted the
recommendation of the expert committee. The UGC has also taken
a stand that insofar as the two degrees are concerned, both are
postgraduate degrees, and the equivalence authority being
Respondent 5 has also opined on the basis of an expert committee,
that the two can be treated as equivalent for the post of Assistant
Professor in Education. Thus, it is neither for the contesting party
i.e. Respondent 3, nor for this Court to sit as a court of appeal
over the decision of the experts. We may also note that
Respondent 3 has in fact been selected in the 2014 selection
process as per the final list released on 22-5-2018.”
(emphasis supplied)
18)
In the impugned judgment, learned Single Judge held that M.Ed
cannot be substituted for M.A. (Education) by the official respondents. This
view is contrary to the above decision of the Supreme Court that for post of
Asst. Professor (Education) M.Ed qualified candidates are also eligible for
consideration for the said post and that both UGC and NCTE are agreed on
this. When the Supreme Court has already taken a view on this, the Single
Judge has to follow the same in view of Art.141 of the Constitution of India
and cannot decide contrary to the said decision of the Supreme Court.
19)
In the judgment in Bhanu Prasad Panda (dr.) v. Sambalpur
University2 cited by counsel for respondents it was no doubt held that mere
possession of Masters Degree in Public Administration with requisite
percentage is not sufficient to appoint the candidate in post of lecturer in
Political Science, though Political Science subject is also taught in a Masters
program of Public Administration. Unlike in that case, in the instant case,
M.Ed is specifically mentioned as a qualification for the post of Asst.
Professor in Education in the addendum dt.30.4.2021 and appellant is eligible
according to it. He is not pleading any equivalence between M.A. (Education)
and M.Ed, which he possesses. The said judgment is thus distinguishable.
20)
In Ganapath Singh Gangaram Singh Rajput v. Gulbarga
University3, in the advertisement, applications were invited for filling up
various posts in different subjects including the post of Lecturer in MCA. The
advertisement requires postgraduate degree in the “relevant subject”. The
relevant subject, in the context of appointment to the post of Lecturer in MCA
was held by the Supreme court to mean Postgraduate degree in MCA and not
Masters degree in Mathematics. Unlike in that case, in the instant case, M.Ed
is specifically mentioned as a qualification for the post of Asst. Professor in
(2001) 8 SCC 532
(2014) 3 SCC 767
Education in the addendum dt.30.4.2021. The said judgment is also thus
distinguishable.
21)
The judgment in Chandra Shekhar Singh v. State of
Jharkhand4 cited by counsel for the respondents is also inapplicable inasmuch
as that in that case, the question considered there was whether a candidate
possessing a higher degree of qualification can be rejected because a lower
degree of qualification is required for a particular post. The question in the
instant appeals is entirely different.
22)
More so, when there is no challenge in the Writ Petition filed by
respective respondents No.5 to the prescription of M.Ed qualification for
appointment to the post of Asst. Professor by way of addendum dt.30.4.2021.
23)
It is also, in our view, not necessary for the appellant to possess
Ph.D in Education subject for the reason that the appellant possesses the M.Ed
degree, which is one of the alternative qualifications prescribed for
appointment to the post of Assistant Professor in Education. In our opinion, it
is not necessary that a person must possess both M.Ed and Ph.D in Education
to become eligible for the post of Assistant Professor in Education and it was
sufficient that he possessed either of the two qualifications.
24)
So the learned Single Judge clearly erred in holding that the
appellant was not possessing the requisite academic qualification because he
possessed a Ph.D in the subject of Political Science and not in the subject of
Education.
25)
Next, the method of calculation of the API for shortlisting of the
candidates is mentioned in Annexure-B to the advertisement dt.08.02.2021
2025 Live Law SC 336
and it merely mentions “Ph.D”. It does not mention “Ph.D in Education
subject”.
26)
When the addendum was issued on 30.04.2021, there was no
amendment made to Annexure-B and the word “Ph.D” in Annexure-B was not
changed to “Ph.D in Education”.
27)
If the respondents had intended that “Ph.D” also should be in the
same subject of Education for the purpose of shortlisting of candidates for post
of Asst. Professor (Education) on the basis of API, they would have
undoubtedly amended the Annexure-B as well by proposing marks for Ph.D
(Education) instead of retaining the qualification in the Annexure B as Ph.D.,
but they did not choose to do so.
28)
Therefore, no fault can be attributed to the TPSC for awarding 25
marks for the Ph.D qualification possessed by the appellant in the API score to
the appellant though his Ph.D is not in the subject of Education.
29)
When admittedly the appellant as well as the respective
respondents No.5 were found qualified for interview on the basis of their API
score, and in the interview, the appellant was selected, and not the respective
respondents No.5, it is not permissible for them to question the appointment of
the appellant on untenable grounds, particularly, when they had not chosen to
complain against the grant of the API Score to the appellant.
30)
So we hold that the learned Single Judge erred in holding that the
appellant was not validly selected for the post of Assistant Professor
(Education) and in setting aside his selection to the said post.
31)
Accordingly, the appeals are allowed; the common judgment
dt.20.2.2024 of the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.885/2022 and WP(C)
No.886/2022 is set aside; the appointment of the appellant dt.01.02.2022 to
the post of Assistant Professor (Education) is held to be valid; and the
appellant shall be restored to the post of Assistant Professor (Education)
which he was holding pursuant to the appointment order issued on 01.02.2022
with continuity of service and all attendant benefits within 6 weeks from
today. The other directions issued by the learned Single Judge are also set
aside except the direction which sustained the appointment of the respondent
No.6 in the Writ petitions.
32)
The Writ Appeals are accordingly disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
(BISWAJIT PALIT), J
PULAK BANIK
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO), CJ
Date: 2026.01.29 15:53:09 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review