Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary
List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 118 of 2018
Date of Decision: 30.03.2022
Dr (Mrs.) Philamon Nongbet
Vs
Union of India & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv.
Mr. K. P. Bhattacharjee, GA. for R 2-4.
Ms. P. Bhattacharjee, Adv. for R 5.
None for R 1.
_______________________________________________________________
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
What could be gathered from the averments made in this petition is
that the petitioner is the owner of a plot of land at Lum Umpih, Umsning,
Ri-Bhoi District and the adjacent land was owned by her sister Smti. Sainara
Nongbet.
2.
The petitioner has also stated that she has since developed her land
with the construction of an Assam type 2 BHK cottage, a swimming pool
and a proper farm which consists of a fishery, cow sheds, poultry, piggery
as well as a duck and swan pond amongst others.
3.
For the purpose of construction of a 4(four) lane Umsning bypass on
the Shillong-Guwahati highway, the respondent No. 4 (District Collector)
had initiated land acquisition proceedings under the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 during the year 2010. In the process, the land of the petitioner’s sister
was acquired, while the land of the petitioner which was adjacent was not
acquired. However, in the declaration under Section 6 of the said Land
Acquisition Act, dated 25.02.2014 issued by the Deputy Secretary to the
Government of Meghalaya, Revenue & Disaster Management Department,
the name of the petitioner appeared at serial No. 63, 66, 67, & 69, which is
actually the land belonging to Smti. Sainara Nongbet. Smti Sainara Nongbet
has accordingly clarified this fact by way of a letter addressed to the Deputy
Commissioner, Ri-Bhoi District dated 06.05.2014 and eventually, the land
compensation award for the said plots mentioned above was received by the
said Smti Sainara Nongbet.
4.
The respondent No 5, the National Highway Authority of India
(NHAI) then took over the land acquired and commenced with the
construction of the said bypass. In the process of construction of the said
road, huge amount of earth was dumped in the land of the petitioner without
taking any precautionary measures of construction of a retaining wall to
contain the spillage into the land of the petitioner. In fact, soil which was
dumped beyond the land acquired resulted in tonnes of soil, rocks and other
debris being deposited into the petitioner’s land. Drains which directly
discharged unto the land of the petitioner were constructed without any
outlets, again resulting in silt and mud flowing thereby destroying the
cultivation, piggery structure and the fish pond being filled with mud and
silt.
5.
To this effect, the petitioner had submitted a representation to the
respondent No. 4 on 25.01.2018 for redressal of her grievances, however no
action was taken even to cause inspection to ascertain the extent of the
damages, which compelled the petitioner to approach this Court with this
petition.
6.
The respondent No 5, on receipt of notice has filed a counter affidavit
refuting the assertions of the petitioner, and has also filed a number of
additional affidavits at every juncture where it considered necessary to do
so.
7.
It may be mentioned that this Court in course of these proceedings
has, vide order dated 01.11.2018 directed that inspection be carried out to
ascertain the extent of the damage in the land of the petitioner and again, on
24.04.2019 has directed the respondent No. 4 to fix a date for another
inspection with advance intimation to the parties concerned. The same has
been complied with and the Inspection Report dated 09.05.2019 was brought
on record by the respondent No. 4 by way of an additional affidavit dated
26.06.2019.
8.
The report dated 09.05.2019 filed on the basis of the inspection
conducted on 07.05.2019 is reproduced herein for better clarity:
“SITE INSPECTION REPORT AND ASSEMMENT OF DAMAGE
DUE TO CONSTRUCTION OF 4- LANE BY NAHI IN THE LAND
OF Dr. (Mrs). PHILAMON NONGBET, LUMUMPIH, UMSNING
BYE PASS.
In pursuance of your letter No. DCRB (LA)
43/2018/Rev/67/848: dated Nongpoh, the 30th April, 2019, the
undersigned have re-conducted inspection along with the Officials
from NHAI, Agriculture, Horticulture, PWD (Building) and
Fisheries Department on the 7th May, 2019 and it is found that the
land/structures and crops of Dr. (Mrs). Philamon Nongbet at Lum
Umphi have been affected by spillage of soil during the construction
of Umsning Bye-Pass by NHAI. Accordingly the Officers of various
Departments were asked to assess the damage and estimates are
submitted as follows:1. Horti Culture Department:- has submitted a report that the
total damage is Rs. 1,50,000/- Rupees (One lakh fifty thousand) only.
2. Agriculture Department:- has submitted a report that the total
damage is Rs. 72,000/- Rupees (Seventy two thousand) only.
3. Fisheries Department:- has submitted a report that the total
damage is Rs. 69,950/- Rupees (Sixty nine thousand nine hundred
fifty) only.
4. PWD (Building) Department:- has submitted a report that the
total damage is Rs. 5,48,622/- Rupees (Five lakhs forty eight
thousand six hundred twenty) only.
Considering the above the total damage is Rs. 8,40,572/Rupees (Eight lakhs forty thousand five hundred seventy two) only.
It is suggested that NHAI should compensate the affected
landowner Dr. (Mrs). Philamon Nongbet of an amount of Rs.
8,40,572/- Rupees (Eight lakhs forty thousand five hundred seventy
two) only.
Further, it was found that NHAI had taken some corrective
measures like construction of Metal Crash Barrier (MCB) all along
the Umsning Bye-Pass and some steps to prevent flow of water into
the land of Dr. (Mrs). Philamon Nongbet.
Submitted for favour of your kind information and further
order.
Sd/Shri. H.K. Thabah, MCS,
Extra Assistant Commissioner (Revenue)”.
9.
The respondent No. 5 by way of an additional affidavit dated
29.07.2019 has refused to admit to the veracity of the contents and details
contained in the Inspection Report dated 09.05.2019 (though referred to as
inspection and assessment dated 13.05.2019) basically on the ground that
the said report prepared by the various departments of the Government of
Meghalaya are presumptive in nature and are without justification with no
supporting documents/drawings relied upon and was also not based on real
facts, but was based only on the verbal/oral facts provided by the petitioner
to the various department and DC, Ri-Bhoi.
10.
The petitioner in response, has filed a rebuttal affidavit to the said
additional affidavit dated 29.07.2019 stating that the said land was acquired
by the Government in the month of February, 2014 and immediately
thereafter, the respondent No. 5 commenced with the marking, digging and
construction of ROW (right of way) pillars, which resulted in spillage of soil
and debris initially during that period and after the main construction work
was carried out, the condition of the fish ponds, the paddy and piggery
structure got damaged due to the immense spillage of soil and debris.
11.
The allegation that the said report was prepared by the respondent
No. 4 based on presumption was also refuted by the petitioner who in the
said rebuttal affidavit has stated that the report was prepared based upon the
spot inspection of specialist officers of various departments of the
Government of Meghalaya and was also conducted in the presence of the
petitioner and the representative of the respondent No. 5.
12.
Yet again, the respondent No. 5 in reply to the rebuttal affidavit of
the petitioner has filed an affidavit dated 13.03.2020, wherein it was
admitted that on acquisition of the land, marking, digging and construction
of ROW pillars was commenced by this respondent on either side of the road
land opposite every 200-metre stone and kilometre stone and the
measurement of excavation of the said pillar is 0.5 m in width and depth is
0.75 m which in no way would cause spillage of soil and debris. The
respondent No. 5 has however admitted that the said report was prepared
upon inspection, but as per the claim of the petitioner.
13.
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, learned counsel for the petitioner in his
submission before this Court has focused mainly on the factum of the two
inspections conducted and the assessment of damages which comes to ₹
8,40,572/- (Rupees eight lakhs forty thousand five hundred and seventytwo) only for which the respondent No. 5 is under strict liability to
compensate the petitioner for the said sum indicated. To support his case,
Mr. Nongbri has cited the case of Creamson War v. Union of India & Ors:
2020 SCC Online Megh, 220, particularly paragraphs 2 and 9 of the same.
14.
Ms. P. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the respondent No. 5, in
reply to the submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that the NHAI has started construction of the said Umsning
bypass in November, 2015. The Project Highway and the road structure has
been constructed as per the approved plan and profile within ROW (Right
of Way) of NHAI and all the cross-drainage structure are planned as per the
natural flow of the rain water passing through the fields. The NHAI has
never used the non-acquired land of the petitioner.
15.
It is also further submitted that the NHAI has constructed I-Kerb to
divert water Chute Drains, Stone Pitching and Metal Beam Crash Barrier
within March, 2019 and as such, technically no other work is required to be
carried out.
16.
As to the fact that after acquisition of the land, marking, digging and
construction of ROW pillars was commenced by NHAI, the same is
admitted. However, in course of construction of the said ROW pillars which
are fixed on either side of the road, every 200-metre stone and kilometre
stone the said pillars being 0.5 m in width with the depth of excavation being
0.75 m, the same cannot be the cause for spillage of soil and debris into the
land of the petitioner, asserts the respondent No. 5.
17.
On the inspection report, the learned counsel has submitted that the
report of the Agriculture and Horticulture Department seems to be
confusing, since in the said report only ginger cultivation in the land of the
petitioner was mentioned and as per the report, the season for ginger is AprilDecember, but the construction of the said road started only in January,
2016. The report is also presumptive as the same is prepared on inspection,
but only as per the claim of the petitioner. It is therefore, submitted that the
claim of the petitioner is false and malafide and the same is liable to be
dismissed.
18.
This Court has given due consideration to the contention and
submission of the rival parties herein, the principal respondent being
respondent No. 5, the National Highway Authority of India (NHAI).
19.
From the pleadings of the parties, the fact that the land of the
petitioner is adjacent to the now completed Umsning bypass road is not
disputed, inasmuch as, the respondent No. 5 has referred to the same as the
non-acquired land of the petitioner.
20.
Though the respondent No. 5 has claimed that in course of
construction of the said bypass, the land of the petitioner was not at all
damaged in any respect and even if it is so, the same could only have
happened before January, 2016, the month in which the actual construction
started, that is, sometime in November, 2015, the fact that on being directed
by this Court, a joint inspection comprising of the relevant departments of
the Government of Meghalaya, the petitioner and the respondent No. 5 was
carried out, first in the absence of the respondent No. 5 and by virtue of a
subsequent order, another inspection was conducted on 07.05.2019, in
which a representative of the respondent No. 5 was also present, is a matter
of record.
21.
As regard the said inspection, the respondent No. 5 has not made or
register any objection to the effect that the land inspected does not belong to
the petitioner, but as stated above, had voluntarily participated in the said
inspection, which was also carried out in the presence of the representatives
of the Agriculture, Horticulture, PWD (Building) and Fisheries Department.
The said report also indicated the assessment of damage of the land of the
petitioner, as a result of spillage of soil during the construction of Umsning
bypass by the NHAI. The corrective measures taken by the NHAI such as
construction of Metal Crash Barrier (MCB) to prevent flow of water into the
land of the petitioner was also duly noted in the said report.
22.
As noted from the contents of the additional affidavit filed by the
respondent No. 4 on 28.06.2019, wherein a copy of the site inspection report
and assessment of damages was placed before this Court in the same
affidavit, the assessment of damages by the departments concerned was also
attached thereto and on perusal of the same, it is seen that the assessment
report of the respective departments is comprehensive, giving all the details
necessary and the findings of the estimated value in terms of monetary value
does not imply that the same was done presumptively and there is no
indication whatsoever that the findings in the said assessment was at the
behest or on the dictate of the petitioner herein. The contention of the
respondent No. 5 suggesting that the said assessment of damage was based
on the dictation of the petitioner cannot be fathom by this Court. The said
contention is rejected.
23.
Apart from the inspection report which by itself is conclusive, the
photographs annexed by the petitioner in this petition also revealed that there
is a clear indication of soil, stones and debris being deposited in the land of
the petitioner.
24.
In the case of Creamson War (supra) relied upon by the petitioner,
this Court has elaborately and copiously emphasised on the law of ‘absolute
liability’ which rule was evolved by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of M.C. Mehta & Anr v. Union of India & Ors: (1987) 1 SCC 395 on
interpretation of the case of Rylands v Fletcher.
25.
Paragraph 2, of the Creamson War case quoting order dated
27.11.2019 and the relevant paragraph being paragraph 7 of the same, speaks
of the applicability of the doctrine of negligence and the requisite thereof,
that is, ‘Duty of Care’ to the negligent act of the respondent No. 5 therein,
which can be equally applied to the case in hand since the situation is exactly
like the present case of the petitioner herein, inasmuch as, in that case, the
dispute relates to the Umsning bypass road and the damages caused to the
land of the petitioner therein due to the negligent act of the respondent No.
5.
26.
In view of the observations made above, this Court finds that the
petitioner has been able to make out a case for compensation on account of
the damages caused to her land due to the negligence of the respondent No.
5 for which, as assessed by the competent authority duly reflected in the said
inspection report dated 09.05.2019 amounting to ₹ 8,40,572/- (Rupees eight
lakhs forty thousand five hundred seventy-two) only has to be satisfied by
the respondent No. 5 herein.
27.
The respondent No. 5 accordingly is directed to make payment to the
petitioner for the sum of ₹ 8,40,572/- (Rupees eight lakhs forty thousand five
hundred seventy-two) only within a period of 4(four) weeks from the date
of receipt of a copy of this order.
28.
Accordingly, this writ petition is hereby disposed of. No cost.
Judge
Meghalaya
30.03.2022
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review