Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1 / 22
CGHC010416042023
2026:CGHC:41638-DB
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
FA No. 212 of 2023
Dr. Omprakash Makhija S/o Shri Nanakram Makhija Aged About 40 Years
S/o Shri Nanakram Makhija, R/o Mitra Vihar Colony, Link Road, Bilaspur,
Tehsil And District - Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh. (Plaintiff)
... Appellant (s)
versus
1 - Jaspal Sethi S/o Gurudayal Sethi Aged About 61 Years R/o Tikrapara,
Bilaspur, Tehsil And District - Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Sunil Bali S/o B.S. Bali Aged About 61 Years R/o Near Torwa Water
Tank, Bilaspur, Tehsil And District - Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant
:Mr. Sunil Otwani, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Shobhit Koshta, Advocate
For Respondents
:Mr. J.K. Gupta, Advocate
For Applicant (Mr. Ashok Tuteja) :Mr. Ratnesh Kumar Agrawal, Advocate
D.B. : Hon'ble Shri Justice Parth Prateem Sahu &
Hon'ble Smt. Justice Sushma Sawant
Judgment on Board
23/09/2026
Per Parth Prateem Sahu, J.
1. This appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated 4th
November 2023 passed by learned District Judge, Bilaspur, whereby
Digitally
signed by
PRAVEEN
KUMAR
SINHA
Date:
2026.10.03
11:04:25
+0530
2 / 22
Civil Appeal No.A-9/2019 filed by the appellant/plaintiff seeking decree
of specific performance of contract against respondents/defendants has
been dismissed.
2. Facts relevant for disposal of this appeal are that appellant/plaintiff
filed a civil suit seeking decree of specific performance on the pleadings
inter alia that on 22.02.2017 defendants entered into an agreement
with him for sale of the suit land and house situated in diverted land
Khasra No.- 588/17, Lrkj No.-4/6, Plot No.- 322, Area- 2600 sq feet and
Khasra No.- 588/7, Lrkj No.- 4/6, Plot No.- 321, area- 1900 sq feet,
Total Area- 4500 sq feet for sale consideration amount of Rs
1,80,00,000/- (one crore eighty lakh) out of which an amount of Rs.18
lakh was paid in advance to the defendants on the date of agreement.
Execution of the agreement is based on the condition precedent that
the defendants are required to regularize the illegal construction over
some part of the suit property and remove the transformer and build the
boundary wall. However, even after repeated request, defendants did
not execute the sale deed. The plaintiff thereafter, send legal notice to
defendants through his Advocate on 15/03/2018 requiring the defendant
to perform his part of contract within a period of 15 days, which was
replied by the defendants on 17/03/2018 stating that that the plaintiff
has failed to perform his part of the contract. Thereafter, plaintiff send
another legal notice on 27/03/2018 which was not replied by the
defendant. On 20/11/2018 defendant sent a letter though his Advocate
stating that the agreement has become unenforceable
due to non-
compliance of the conditions mentioned in agreement and hence
refused to execute the sale deed, asked the plaintiff to take back the
3 / 22
advance amount paid at the time of agreement. Thereafter plaintiff,
through his Advocate, sent another legal notice dated 07/12/2018
whereby the plaintiff asked the defendants to appear before the
registrar office on 20/12/2018 for execution of sale deed but the
defendants refused to appear on the said date. Therefore, decree of
specific performance of contract be granted directing the defendant to
register the sale deed in favour of plaintiff.
3. Defendants filed their written statement denying the averments
made by the plaintiff. While admitting the execution of the agreement
dated 22.02.2017 and receipt of Rs.18 lakh as advance, the defendants
pleaded that the plaintiff failed to perform his part of the agreement by
not providing the requisite funds and cooperation for regularisation of
the property, clearance of the mortgage and utility dues, removal of the
transformer, and completion of other necessary formalities. The
defendants further asserted that they were ready and willing to execute
the sale deed within the stipulated period, but the plaintiff’s failure to
perform his obligations resulted in a delay of approximately two years,
during which the market value of the property increased. They denied
that they deliberately avoided execution of the sale deed or agreed to
sell the property to any other person for a higher consideration. The
defendants accordingly claimed compensation /revaluation at the
prevailing market rate, denied the plaintiff’s entitlement to specific
performance or injunction, and prayed for dismissal of the suit.
4. Learned trial Court on the basis of pleadings made by the parties,
framed following main issues for consideration:
4 / 22
“1.
Whether
the
defendants
entered
into
an
agreement to sell the disputed property to the
plaintiff for Rs. 1 crore 80 lakhs and after receiving
advance payment of Rs. 18 lakhs, executed the sale
deed on 22/02/2017 ?
2. Whether the balance consideration amount of the
disputed property was decided to be paid at the time
of registration of sale deed as per the terms of the
sale agreement dated 22/02/2017 ?
3. Whether the plaintiff performed his part of contract
under sale agreement dated 22/02/2017 ?
4. Whether the defendants failed to perform their part
of
contract
under
sale
agreement
dated
22/02/2017 ?
5. Whether the plaintiff has been willing and ready to
purchase the disputed property ?
6. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to obtain a decree
for specific performance of the sale agreement
dated 22/02/2017 ?
5.
Learned trial Court upon consideration and appreciation of the
pleadings, oral and documentary evidence adduced by the parties held
that in the facts of the case, it is not possible to order specific
performance of contract and further considered that in para-8 of
evidence, plaintiff had pleaded that in the event the order directing
specific performance of contract is not possible then the amount of
Rs.18 lakh be returned with interest at the rate of 18%, allowed the suit
in part and ordered for return of advance amount of Rs.18 lakh with
interest at the rate of 9% per annum from 22.02.2017 to 04.02.2019
5 / 22
and thereafter at the rate of 6%
per annum from 04.02.2019 till
impugned judgment and decree.
6.
Assailing legality, validity and correctness of the impugned
judgments and decree, learned counsel for the appellant- plaintiff would
argue that learned trial court erred in holding that the appellant was not
ready and willing to perform his part of the contract, despite his having
pleaded and proved the same and there being no evidence to the
contrary. It was contended that the defendants had failed to perform
their corresponding obligations under the agreement to sell dated
22.02.2017. It was further submitted that the trial court wrongly treated
non-regularization of construction over a portion of the suit property as
rendering the agreement unenforceable, particularly when there was no
evidence that the defendants had called upon the appellant to pay the
regularization charges or that he had refused to do so. Under the
agreement, sale deed was to be executed within one month of the
defendants fulfilling their obligations; therefore, the appellant could not
be faulted for non-execution of the sale deed. Learned counsel
accordingly submitted that, upon proof of the agreement and the
appellant's readiness and willingness, trial court ought to have granted
the relief of specific performance. The findings of the trial court, being
contrary to the oral and documentary evidence on record, therefore, are
erroneous and liable to be set aside. In support of his submissions, he
places reliance upon the judgments of Hon’ble Supreme Court in case
of Govindbhai Gordhanbhai Patel & Ors. v. Gulam Abbas Mulla
Allibhai Ors. reported in (1977) 3 SCC 179,
Laxman Tatyaba
Kankate & Anr. Vs. Taramati Harishchandra Dhatrak reported in
6 / 22
(2010) 7 SCC 717 and
Delhi Development Authority v. Kenneth
Builders & Developers (P) Ltd. & Ors. reported in (2016) 13 SCC
561. He lastly contended that appellant is ready to get the sale deed
executed without regularization of unauthorized construction.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents/defendants would
submit that the learned trial Court, upon proper appreciation of the
pleadings and oral and documentary evidence, rightly dismissed the
suit for specific performance. It was contended that although execution
of the agreement to sell dated 22.02.2017 and receipt of Rs.18 lakhs as
advance were admitted, the appellant failed to perform his reciprocal
obligations under the agreement and was therefore not entitled to seek
specific performance. It was further submitted that the proceedings for
regularization of the construction, removal of the transformer and other
necessary steps were undertaken by the defendants on the assurance
that the appellant would provide the requisite funds and fulfill his part of
the contract. However, the appellant failed and refused to provide the
necessary amount and assistance, including the amount required for
redemption of the mortgage over the property. Consequently, the
defendants could not complete the formalities necessary for execution
of the sale deed. Learned counsel would further contend that the
appellant's conduct clearly demonstrated that he was neither ready nor
willing to perform his part of the contract. Despite the agreement being
executed on 22.02.2017, the appellant took no effective steps for nearly
two years and instituted the proceedings only after the value of the
property had substantially increased. The subsequent legal notices
issued by the appellant could not cure his prior failure to perform his
7 / 22
contractual obligations. It was also submitted that the appellant cannot
take advantage of the condition requiring the defendants to complete
the regularization proceedings, as such proceedings were being
undertaken pursuant to the agreement and required the appellant's
financial cooperation. The appellant, having failed to discharge his
reciprocal obligations, cannot allege that the defendants alone were in
breach of the agreement. The burden lay upon the appellant to
establish such readiness and willingness, and mere
assertion of
readiness could not substitute actual performance of his contractual
obligations. Findings of the learned trial Court were based on proper
appreciation of the evidence and did not suffer from any perversity or
illegality. In support of his submission, he places reliance upon the
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Jaswinder Kaur Vs.
Gurmeet Singh reported in (2017) 12 SCC 810.
8.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and also perused the
records of the case.
9. The execution of the agreement to sell dated 22.02.2017 and
payment of advance amount of Rs.18,00,000/- by the appellant/plaintiff,
to the respondents/defendants are not in dispute. The controversy
essentially concerns the performance of the respective obligations of
the parties under the said agreement and, in particular, whether the
appellant/plaintiff was ready and willing to perform his part of the
contract and whether the respondents/defendants had fulfilled the
conditions precedent to execution of the sale deed of their part.
8 / 22
10. The appellant/plaintiff, in his examination-in-chief tendered by way of
affidavit under Order 18 Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, stated
that he was aware that construction had been raised over an area in
excess of the permissible limit and that the same was required to be
regularized.
He
further
stated
that
the
expenditure
towards
regularization was to be borne by him. Plaintiff also stated that the
defendants had undertaken to remove the electricity transformer and
construct the boundary wall. According to him, he had remained ready
and willing to perform his part of the agreement, had arranged the
balance sale consideration and registration expenses, and had
remained in contact with the defendants. He alleged that the defendants
repeatedly sought time and consequently failed to complete the
transaction. The plaintiff further stated that, in March 2018, when he
came to know that the defendants were proposing to sell the property to
third parties for a higher consideration, he approached them and they
agreed to execute the sale deed without awaiting regularization by the
Municipal Corporation. According to him, despite fixing dates for
registration of sale deed, the defendants continued to postpone the
transaction. The plaintiff stated that he thereafter issued the legal notice
dated 15.03.2018, calling upon the defendants to execute the sale deed
within fifteen days. The defendants, in their reply dated 17.03.2018,
asserted that the contractual conditions had not been fulfilled and
referred to expenses allegedly incurred by them. The plaintiff
maintained that the defendants had neither informed him regarding
release of the mortgage nor called upon him to deposit the amount
required for regularization.
9 / 22
11. In his cross-examination, plaintiff (PW1) admitted that, even prior to
execution of the agreement, he was aware that construction had been
raised over the excess area and had not been regularized. He further
admitted that he had undertaken to bear the expenses of regularization.
He denied the suggestion that, after payment of the advance amount,
he had failed to provide assistance to the defendants or that no demand
had been made upon him. He also admitted that the defendants had
submitted
applications
for
regularization
before
the
Municipal
Corporation.
12. Defendant Sunil Bali, examined as DW-1, stated that the plaintiff had
not provided financial assistance for making the property free from
mortgage and had failed to bear the expenses relating to removal of the
transformer and construction of the boundary wall. He further stated
that despite repeated demands, expenses relating to regularization had
not been paid. In his cross-examination, he admitted that an application
for regularization, marked as Ex.D-1, had been submitted before the
competent authority. He stated that the application had subsequently
been rejected. Significantly, however, he admitted that the plaintiff had
not been informed about the rejection.
13. The documentary and oral evidence, therefore, establishes that the
agreement cast distinct obligations upon both sides. The defendants
were required to redeem the mortgage over the property and to
discharge the liabilities relating to electricity, water and property taxes.
They were also required to undertake the process of regularization of
the property, remove the transformer and construct the boundary wall.
The
expenses
of
regularization,
removal
of
transformer
and
10 / 22
construction of the boundary wall, however, were to be borne by the
plaintiff.
14. Thus, while the financial burden of certain acts was to be borne by
the plaintiff, the corresponding acts themselves were required to be
undertaken by the defendants in accordance with the terms of the
agreement.
15. The record further establishes that the defendants had submitted an
application for regularization, Ex.D-1, on 24.03.2017, shortly after
execution of the agreement. However, there is no satisfactory
documentary evidence on record demonstrating that the regularization
process was completed. Although defendant DW-1 stated that the
application had been rejected, no order or other document evidencing
such rejection was produced before the Court.
16. More importantly, the defendants admittedly did not communicate
the alleged rejection of the regularization application to the plaintiff. In
the absence of such communication, the plaintiff cannot, merely on the
basis of the defendants' subsequent assertion, be held responsible for
the non-completion of the regularization process. The agreement itself
contemplated execution and registration of the sale deed after
fulfillment of the stipulated conditions, including regularization of the
property. The evidence on record indicates that the completion of the
regularization process depended upon action by the competent
authority and was not wholly within the control of the defendants. At the
same time, the plaintiff had specifically undertaken to bear the
expenses associated with regularization and construction of the
11 / 22
boundary wall. The evidence, however, does not establish by cogent
material that the defendants had made a specific demand upon the
plaintiff for payment of the requisite amount towards regularization and
that the plaintiff had thereafter refused or neglected to make such
payment. On the contrary, the plaintiff consistently maintained that he
was ready and willing to perform his part of the agreement and that the
defendants had not called upon him to make the requisite payment. The
defendants' own evidence establishes that they had initiated the
regularization proceedings, but the record does not establish that the
plaintiff was duly informed of the subsequent status thereof or that he
was afforded an effective opportunity to fulfill the financial obligations
resting upon him.
17. The Court, while exercising jurisdiction in a suit for specific
performance, cannot disregard the express terms and conditions of the
agreement or substitute a different bargain for that agreed between the
parties. Where execution of the sale deed is made subject to fulfillment
of specified requirements, such requirements cannot be dispensed with
merely because the plaintiff has established his readiness and
willingness. In the present case, the condition relating to regularization
remained unfulfilled and was dependent upon the competent authority.
The appellant’s readiness and willingness, therefore, cannot override or
dispense with such contractual condition.
18. The contention of the appellant/plaintiff that proof of readiness and
willingness necessarily entitles him to a decree for specific performance
cannot, therefore, be accepted. Readiness and willingness constitute an
essential requirement for seeking specific performance, but do not
12 / 22
confer an absolute right to such relief or authorize the Court to
disregard the substantive terms of the contract. The grant of specific
performance remains subject to the provisions of the Specific Relief Act
and the enforceability of the contractual obligation. Accordingly, in the
absence of fulfillment of the agreed condition regarding regularization,
the appellant cannot claim specific performance merely on the basis of
his readiness and willingness to perform his part of the contract.
19. It is not in dispute that learned trial Court framed an issue with
regard to readiness and willingness and gave a finding to have been
proved. However, there is no finding of learned trial Court with regard to
proof of continuous readiness and willingness on the part of
plaintiff/appellant but for pleading made in the plaint that plaintiff is
ready and willing to perform his part of contract from the beginning and
was having arrangement of balance amount to be paid in consideration
as also registration fee. In evidence, the plaintiff had not specifically
stated as to what arrangement he is having to pay huge amount of
Rs.1,62,00,000/-
(one crore sixty two lakh rupees) plus amount
required towards registration fee of sale deed.
20. True it is that this is the appeal by plaintiff against partly allowing of
his suit with regard to refund of money, with a prayer to direct
respondent/defendant for specific performance of contract.
21. If no evidence is adduced in this regard by way of documentary
evidence, no prudent man would come to the conclusion that person
has proved possession of funds. In absence of any such documentary
evidence being produced, it will be a case of being not proved. Plaintiff
13 / 22
cannot expect the Court to pass a decree for specific performance of a
contract of sale when the plaintiff has not proved his readiness to
perform his part of contract.
22. In case of Umabai and Another vs. Nilkanth Dhondiba Chavan
(Dead) By LRs. and another, reported in (2005) 6 SCC 243, it has
been held as under:“30. It is now well settled that the conduct of the
parties, with a view to arrive at a finding as to
whether the plaintiff-respondents were all along and
still are ready and willing to perform their part of
contract as is mandatorily required under Section 16
(c) of the Specific Relief Act must be determined
having regard to the entire attending circumstances.
A bare averment in the plaint or a statement made
in the examination-in- chief would not suffice. The
conduct of the plaintiff- respondents must be judged
having regard to the entirety of the pleadings as
also the evidence brought on records."
23. In case of R.Kandaswamy (since dead) & Ors. vs. TRK
Saraswathi and Anr. reported in (2025) 3 SCC 513, Hon’ble Supreme
Court has held that relief of specific performance is discretionary and
equitable in nature. The plaintiff must plead and prove continuous
readiness and willingness to perform the essential terms of the contract
from the date of the agreement until the decree. The expression 'ready
and willingness' signifies that the plaintiff must possess both the
intention and financial capacity to perform the contractual obligations,
particularly the obligation to pay the balance sale consideration. Mere
assertions in pleadings are insufficient; plaintiff must place material on
14 / 22
record demonstrating availability of funds or capacity to arrange the
same within the stipulated time. In absence of the same, plaintiff would
not be entitled to the discretionary relief of specific performance.
24. In case of His Holiness Acharya Swami Ganesh Dassji v. Sita
Ram Thapar reported in
(1996) 4 SCC 526, while considering the
issue of readiness and willingness to get the sale deed executed had
also given weightage of the availability of sufficient funds to pay the
consideration amount, Hon’ble Supreme Court observed thus :“2. There is a distinction between readiness to
perform the contract and willingness to perform the
contract. By readiness may be meant the capacity of
the plaintiff to perform the contract which includes his
financial position to pay the purchase price. For
determining his willingness to perform his part of the
contract, the conduct has to be properly scrutinized.
There is no documentary proof that the plaintiff had
ever funds to pay the balance of consideration.
Assuming that he had the funds, he has to prove his
willingness to perform his part of the contract.
According to the terms of the agreement, the plaintiff
was to supply the draft sale deed to the defendant
within 7 days of the execution of the agreement, i.e.,
by 27-2-1975. The draft sale deed was not returned
after being duly approved by the petitioner. The
factum of readiness and willingness to perform
plaintiff's part of the contract is to be adjudged with
reference to the conduct of the party and the
attending circumstances. The court may infer from the
facts and circumstances whether the plaintiff was
ready and was always ready and willing to perform
his part of the contract. The facts of this case would
amply demonstrate that the petitioner/plaintiff was not
15 / 22
ready nor had the capacity to perform his part of the
contract as he had no financial capacity to pay the
consideration in cash as contracted and intended to
bide for the time which disentitles him as time is of the
essence of the contract.”
25. Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of U.N. Krishnamurthy (since
deceased) through LRs v. A.M. Krishnamurthy reported in (2023) 11
SCC 775 has considered the importance of readiness and willingness
for enforcement of specific performance and held thus :“45. It is settled law that for relief of specific
performance, the plaintiff has to prove that all along
and till the final decision of the suit, he was ready
and willing to perform his part of the contract. It is
the bounden duty of the plaintiff to prove his
readiness and willingness by adducing evidence.
This crucial facet has to be determined by
considering all circumstances including availability
of funds and mere statement or averment in plaint
of readiness and willingness, would not suffice.”
26. The aforementioned decisions have been taken into consideration
by this Court only with a view as to whether even if the finding of
learned trial Court is not put to challenge by respondent/defendant on
readiness and willingness then also whether direction for specific
performance of contract can be issued to respondent or not in the facts
of case.
27. Grant of relief of specific performance is a discretionary relief. Court
while considering the prayer for grant of specific relief has to exercise
16 / 22
judicially based on sound principle ensuring that granting relief of
specific performance is just and equitable in the circumstances of the
case.
28. In the case at hand, date of agreement is dated 22.02.2017. In that
case, purchaser/plaintiff/appellant was well aware that construction of
the building on the land was more than the area and sanctioned plan
and therefore the clause has been put in agreement that sale deed is to
be executed after regularization of unauthorized construction and it is
for respondent-defendant to file application and all the expenses to be
borne by purchaser i.e. appellant/plaintiff. He has to bear all other
expenses for shifting of transformer and construction of boundary wall
In the record, it is not in dispute that respondent/defendant had
submitted an application for regularization. It is the evidence of
defendant that after filing of application, plaintiff has not bothered about
the status of application and kept quite for long time and first legal
notice was issued only on 15.03.2018. In reply to notice which is filed as
Ex.P-3 there is mention that at the time of entering into agreement to
sell it was informed to purchaser that property is mortgaged and only
after making payment of amount of loan it will be released from the
Bank and only to meet out liability of loan, property is being sold. It is
also stated in the reply to legal notice that even after about one year
purchaser had
not made arrangement of amount towards the sale
consideration for release of property. It is also mentioned that plaintiff
has not paid any amount towards expenses of regularization. Perusal of
subsequent notice Ex.P-4 sent on behalf of the plaintiff/appellant would
show that there is no averment in notice that, plaintiff/appellant is ready
17 / 22
to pay the bank dues or other expenses towards regularization or to get
the sale deed executed of the property as it is. Suit is filed only on
04.02.2019 i.e. after lapse of two years from the date of execution of
agreement to sell . From reply to notice it appears that respondent
entered into the agreement to sell, only to meet out his financial needs
and to re-pay loan amount. Not paying the loan amount in time has
consequence of adding interest as per bank rates (that may be
compound interest rate ) and on the other side value of the properly has
been increased in these two years.
29. In the aforementioned facts of case, we have to consider whether
the grant of decree of specific performance of contract in favour of
appellant will be equitable in the facts and circumstances of the case.
30. Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Kamal Kumar Vs. Premlata
Joshi & Ors. reported in (2019) 3 SCC 704 held that grant of relief of
specific performance is a discretionary and equitable relief and further
formulated the questions required to be gone into for grant of relief for
specific performance as under:
“7. It is a settled principle of law that the grant of
relief of specific performance is a discretionary and
equitable relief. The material questions, which are
required to be gone into for grant of the relief of
specific performance, are:
7.1. First, whether there exists a valid and
concluded contract between the parties for
sale/purchase of the suit property.
7.2. Second, whether the plaintiff has been
ready and willing to perform his part of contract
18 / 22
and whether he is still ready and willing to
perform his part as mentioned in the contract.
7.3. Third, whether the plaintiff has, in fact,
performed his part of the contract and, if so,
how and to what extent and in what manner he
has performed and whether such performance
was in conformity with the terms of the contract;
7.4. Fourth, whether it will be equitable to grant
the relief of specific performance to the plaintiff
against the defendant in relation to suit property
or it will cause any kind of hardship to the
defendant and, if so, how and in what manner
and the extent if such relief is eventually
granted to the plaintiff;
7.5. Lastly, whether the plaintiff is entitled for
grant of any other alternative relief, namely,
refund of earnest money, etc. and, if so, on
what grounds.”
31. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the aforementioned judgment has further
observed with regard to pleading and evidence to meet out the statutory
requirement under Section 16 (c), 20, 21, 22, 23 of the Specific Relief
Act, 1963 and held as under :
“8. In our opinion, the aforementioned questions
are part of the statutory requirements [See
Sections 16(c), 20, 21, 22, 23 of the Specific
Relief Act, 1963 and Forms 47/48 of Appendices
A to C of the Code of Civil Procedure]. These
requirements have to be properly pleaded by the
parties in their respective pleadings and proved
with the aid of evidence in accordance with law. It
is only then the Court is entitled to exercise its
discretion and accordingly grant or refuse the
relief of specific performance depending upon the
case made out by the parties on facts.”
19 / 22
32. Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Janardan Das and Ors. Vs.
Durga Prasad Agarwalla & Ors. reported in (2024) 19 SCC 276
observing that relief of specific performance under the Specific Relief
Act, 1963 to be discretionary in nature, observed thus:
“31. The relief of specific performance under the
Specific Relief Act, 1963, is discretionary in nature.
Section 20 of the Act (applicable to this case as it
predates the 2018 Amendment) explicitly stated that
the court is not bound to grant such relief merely
because it is lawful to do so. The discretion must be
exercised judiciously and based on sound principles,
ensuring that granting specific performance is just
and equitable in the circumstances of the case.
32. In the present case, several factors weigh against
granting specific performance. The agreement to sell
was
incomplete
and
unenforceable
against
Defendants 6 to 8, who held a majority share in the
property; enforcing such an agreement would be
inequitable. The plaintiffs failed to demonstrate
readiness and willingness to perform their obligations
and did not take necessary steps to secure the
consent
of
all
co-owners.
Granting
specific
performance would unfairly prejudice the defendants,
especially Defendants 6 to 8, who never consented to
the sale to the plaintiffs. Furthermore, the plaintiffs
can be adequately compensated by a refund of the
earnest money with interest; there is no evidence to
suggest that monetary compensation would not
suffice.
x x x
x x x
35. In conclusion, considering the discretionary nature
of the relief and the principles governing its exercise,
we find that granting specific performance in this case
20 / 22
would be neither just nor equitable. The plaintiffs'
failure to fulfil essential contractual terms, coupled
with the lack of authority to bind all co-owners,
renders
the
grant
of
specific
performance
inappropriate. The equitable remedy sought by the
plaintiffs cannot be granted in light of their conduct
and the circumstances of the case.”
33. Reverting back to the facts of the case at hand, plaintiff was well
aware on the date of entering into agreement to sell about the extra
construction made than that of sanctioned plan which requires
regularization. Plaintiff could have very well purchased the property as it
is but has imposed the condition that it is for the defendant to submit an
application and get the unauthorized construction regularized and
further condition is imposed for removing of transformer and
construction of boundary wall. Plaintiff after execution of sale deed
could have taken all the above activities of his own being owner of
house subject matter of agreement but he has not done so, for the
reason known to him.
34. There is no evidence of the plaintiff/appellant to prove the averment
made in the plaint that plaintiff was ever ready and willing for getting the
sale deed executed after payment of sale consideration . In the case at
hand, balance amount of sale consideration is of Rs.1,62,00,000/- (one
crore sixty two lakh rupees) plus registration fee which is required to be
paid at the time of execution of sale deed. Plaintiff has not brought any
evidence with regard to source or availability of said fund with him.
Upon consideration of entire facts and circumstances of the case, we
21 / 22
are of the considered view that it will not be equitable to grant the relief
of specific performance to the appellant/plaintiff against defendant. In
fact it will cause great hardship to defendant because the defendant
though agreed to sell the land in the year 2017, has not been paid the
major balance amount of Rs.1,62,00,000/- (one crore sixty two lakh
rupees) and now the value of property is also increased drastically in
last 9 years. Defendant before trial Court had stated that he is ready to
execute the sale deed in favour of plaintiff as per the rate prevailing on
the date of recording of evidence but no offer has been made by plaintiff
in this regard.
35. Learned trial Court has rightly considered to grant alternate relief to
appellant/plaintiff of refund of money with interest as mentioned therein,
which, in the facts of case appears to be just and proper.
36. Reliance placed by learned counsel for the appellant/plaintiff in case
of Govindbhai Gordhanbhai Patel (supra) is distinguishable on facts.
In that case, Hon’ble Supreme Court has considered Section 56 of the
Contract Act, 1872, which talks of agreement to do impossible act,
which is not applicable to the facts of case. In case at hand, according
to terms of agreement, provision under Section 32 of the Contract Act
1872 would be attracted.
37. In case Kenneth Builders & Developers (supra), which is relied
upon by learned counsel for the appellant, Hon’ble Supreme Court has
taken into consideration the provision under Section 56 of the Contract
Act and considering facts and circumstances of the case therein held
that certain circumstances had intervened, making it impracticable for
22 / 22
Kenneth Builders to commence the construction activity on the project
land and further held that it could certainly be said that the contract
between the DDA and Kenneth Builders was impossible of performance
within the meaning of that word in Section 56 of the Contract Act.
38. For the foregoing discussions, relevant law under Specific
Performance of contract and the decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court
as referred to above, we are of the considered opinion that there is no
error or infirmity in impugned judgment and decree passed by learned
trial Court warranting interference. Appeal being devoid of substance is
liable to be and is accordingly dismissed.
39. Let a decree be drawn accordingly.
S
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
Praveen
Sd/(Sushma Sawant)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review