Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASANTA KUMAR BARIK
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 20-May-2026 13:50:14
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.36249 of 2025
(In the matter of an application under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India)
Dr. Nurul Amin and another
….
-versus-
State of Odisha and others
….
Petitioners
Opposite Parties
Advocate(s) appeared in this case:For Petitioner
: Mr. G. Mukherji, Senior Advocate
For Opposite Parties
: Mr. G. Tripathy, A.G.A.
For O.P. No.1
Ms. N. Pattnaik, Advocate on
behalf of Mr. K.K. Mukhi,
Advocate for O.P. Nos.2 & 3
Mr. S. Mishra, Advocate for the
proposed intervenor, i.e. one of
the brothers of Petitioner No.1
CORAM: JUSTICE B.P. ROUTRAY
JUDGMENT
18th May 2026
B.P. Routray, J.
1.
Heard Mr. G. Mukherji, learned Senior Advocate for the
Petitioner, Mr. G. Tripathy, learned Additional Government Advocate
for State-Opposite Party No.1, Ms. N. Pattnaik, learned Advocate on
behalf of Mr. K.K. Mukhi, learned Advocate for Opposite Parties 2 &
W.P.(C) No.36249 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASANTA KUMAR BARIK
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 20-May-2026 13:50:14
3 and Mr. S. Mishra, learned Advocate for the proposed intervenor, i.e.
one of the brothers of Petitioner No.1.
2.
Petitioner No.1 is the owner of the case property, i.e. House
No.HIG-4, Drawing No.CA/283/R-1, Plot No.241(P) measuring area
2700 sq. ft. in Khata No.619 of mouza – Chandrasekharpur, more fully
described in Annexure-2.
He filed present writ petition along with Petitioner No.2, who is
his niece, i.e. daughter of his sister, praying for quashing of impugned
order dated 24th November 2025, whereby the alleged prayer of
Petitioner No.1 for transfer of the property by way of gift has been
rejected by Opposite Party No.2.
3.
The Petitioner No.1 had earlier approached this Court in
W.P.(C) No.28720 of 2025 and the same was disposed of on
13.10.2025, by a Coordinate Bench with a direction to present
Opposite Party No.2 to consider the representation of Petitioner and to
dispose of the same in accordance with law. Pursuant to said direction
of this Court dated 13.10.2025, Petitioner No.1 appeared before the
Secretary of Odisha State Housing Board (Opposite Party No.2) and
upon examination of him, Opposite Party No.2 denied to record his
W.P.(C) No.36249 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASANTA KUMAR BARIK
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 20-May-2026 13:50:14
consent for the alleged gift. Said order dated 24th November 2025 is the
subject matter of challenge in present writ petition.
4.
Considering the contentions of the Petitioners, this Court
referred Petitioner No.1 for examination through a competent Medical
Board to be constituted by the Director of Capital Hospital,
Bhubaneswar. Accordingly, Petitioner No.1 was examined by the
Medical Board at Capital Hospital, Bhubaneswar. As per the report of
Medical Board, it is opined that Petitioner No.1 is of sound mental
health with exhibits of symptoms of old brain stroke with features of
atypical Parkinsonism and mild dementia. For better reference, the
report dated 17.04.2026 is re-produced below:“On dt.08.04.2026 at 11.00 AM the Petitioner Dr. Nurul
Amin has appeared before the Special Medical Board at
Capital Hospital, Bhubaneswar. He was accompanied and
identified by following persons.
1.Afsana Sahid (Niece of the Petitioner)
2.Susanta Kumar Dhar (Caretaker of the Petitioner)
He was examined by team of experts including
Psychiatrist, Neurophyscian and Medicine Specialist.
Required preliminary examination was conducted and
necessary investigation was advised by the Medical Board
to know the Petitioner’s condition. After completion of
investigation the Medical Board again evaluated the
W.P.(C) No.36249 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASANTA KUMAR BARIK
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 20-May-2026 13:50:14
Petitioner’s present Mental State with Medical investigation
reports on dt.17.04.2026 and the opinion of the Medical
Board are as follows:
1.Dr. Nurul Amin the Petitioner is found to be sound mental
health but exhibits symptoms of old brain stroke with
features of Atypical Parkinsonism and mild Dementia.
2.He is not fully capable of basic self care. He is capable of
taking simple decisions but lacks full capacity to manage
complex
financial
or
legal
situations
or
matters
independently.
3. His condition is progressive in nature and periodic
reassessment is required.”
5.
Upon further consideration of the prayer of the Petitioners, this
Court has also called for the detail examination report of the Petitioner
No.1 to arrive such opinion by the Medical Board. Consequent to the
direction of this Court, a copy of the Medical Examination Report
along with questionnaire put to Petitioner No.1 is produced by Mr. G.
G. Tripathy, learned A.G.A. in Court. It is seen from said Medical
Examination Report that, different questions were asked to determine
the mental state of Petitioner No.1 and based on the response of
Petitioner No.1 thereof, he secured total score 20 out of 30 as evaluated
by the Medical Board. Therefore, taking note of such Medical
Examination of Petitioner No.1 and the opinion of the Medical Board,
W.P.(C) No.36249 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASANTA KUMAR BARIK
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 20-May-2026 13:50:14
as stated above, it is not convinced why Petitioner No.1 remained silent
before the Secretary, Odisha Housing Board (Opposite Party No.2)
while questioned regarding gifting of the property in favour of
Petitioner No.2.
6.
The specific observation of Opposite Party No.2 in the
impugned order is to the effect that Petitioner No.1 did not give any
opinion/consent and also was not able to speak anything for such
transfer of property by way of gift. The relevant observations in the
impugned order under Annexure-5 are re-produced below:
“During the course of personal hearing, the undersigned
asked the petitioner, Dr. Nurul Amin who is the allottee of
House
No.HIG-4
(7
Acres),
Chandrasekharpur,
Bhubaneswar to give his opinion on the matter of transfer of
the House No.HIG-4, Chandrasekharpur, Bhubaneswar by
way of Gift to Afsana Sahid. Inspite of giving enough time
and opportunity to the petitioner Dr. Narul Amin, he did not
give any opinion/consent and also not able to speak any
thing for such transfer of property by way of Gift. Further
opportunity was also given for recording his statement. He
only expressed that "we have 05 brothers. I am the 3rd
brother of the family. My eider brother is in USA. Recently
he expires. Now we are 03 brothers". The recorded
statement forms a part of the case record.
W.P.(C) No.36249 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASANTA KUMAR BARIK
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 20-May-2026 13:50:14
It is also mentioned that, earlier as called for, the petitioner
also appeared before the Secretary on 25.09.2025. On that
day also, the O.P.No.2 i.e Secretary put repeated questions
as to whom he is going to transfer the case house by way of
Gift. But he did not speak anything regarding transfer of the
house.
In this matter, the O.P. No.4 Afsana Sahid appeared before
the Secretary, OSHB i.e. O.P.No.2 on dtd. 12.11.2025 and
she stated that, "this is Afsana Sahid niece of Dr. Nurul
Amin beg to state that I am a genuine person and not
pressuring anyone specially Dr. Nurul Amin. I have taken
care of Dr. Nurul Amin since last 05 years and his misses
Dr. Puspa Amin was also taken care by me. He is staying at
his own property with his own wife, no one is pressurized
him. He is taken care by physically and monetary". The
recorded statement forms a part of the case record.
Hence, Dr Nurul Amin (petitioner) in course of personal
hearing on 12.11.2025 in presence of A.O (Urban), Law
Officer, concerned Dealing Asst. Sri S.N. Mohanty and
Afsana Sahid has not opined/consented/able to speak
expressing his intention to transfer the house by way of Gift
in favour of Afsana Sahid.”
7.
The medical report and the opinion of the Medical Board, as
referred above, do not suggest the state of mind of Petitioner No.1 so
feeble for not to answer such relevant questions of Opposite Party No.2
during his examination. In such context, keeping in view the state of
mind of Petitioner No.1 as per the Medical Board vis-à-vis the
W.P.(C) No.36249 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASANTA KUMAR BARIK
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 20-May-2026 13:50:14
observation made by Opposite Party No.2 in the impugned order under
Annexure-5, it is felt appropriate to send the matter back to Opposite
Party No.2 for re-examination of Petitioner No.1 with regard to his
intention to gift.
8.
Accordingly, the impugned order under Annexure-5 is set aside
and Opposite Party No.2 is directed to reconsider the prayer of
Petitioner No.1 with regard to gifting of the property in question upon
further examination of Petitioner No.1, on any working day between
10.30 A.M. to 11.30 A.M. on or before 29th May 2026, and to pass
necessary order accordingly without delay.
9.
With the aforesaid observation and direction, the writ petition is
disposed of.
(B.P. Routray)
Judge
B.K. Barik/A.R.-cum-Senior Secretary
W.P.(C) No.36249 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review