Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No.89807 of 2025
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-715 Year-2025 Thana- MOHANIYA District- Kaimur (Bhabua)
======================================================
Dr. Kavita Kumari @ Kavita Kumari D/o- Sudama Singh Village- Akorhi PSMohania District- Kaimur Bhabhua Work Place Address Jay Maa
Mundeshwari Hospital PS-Mohania District- Kaimur Bhabhua
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
The State of Bihar
... ... Opposite Party/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s
:
For the Opposite Party/s :
Mr. Krishna Prasad Singh, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Saket Kumar Singh, Advocate
Mr. Jitendra Kumar Singh, APP
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV ROY
ORAL ORDER
28-01-2026
Yet another unfortunate case has come to this Court,
though in the State of Bihar, it has become a regular feature. A
young pregnant woman visits a private Nursing Home
anywhere in the State to deliver a child, her eyes filled with
joy. The unregistered private Nursing Homes make the parents
bleed through their noses showing them moon while charging
hefty sum. However, the fact remains that it lacks even the
basic necessities/equipments, forget the presence of a
Specialist/Doctor.
2. The result is that post delivery, alongwith the
child, the parents carry the lifeless body of the young lady on
the stretcher while walking out of the Hospital. Meanwhile,
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
2/15
the District Administration and the office of the Civil Surgeon
of the said district look the other way.
3. Heard Mr. Krishna Prasad Singh, learned Senior
counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Jitendra Kumar Singh,
learned APP.
4. The petitioner is apprehending arrest in
connection with Mohania P.S. Case No. 715 of 2025 for the
offence under section 105 of the BNS lodged on 20.08.2025
by the informant, Chandan Singh.
5. As per the FIR, the informant’s husband, Chandan
Singh alleged that his wife, Shweta Kumari (since deceased)
had labour pain, was taken to the Maa Mundeshwari
Hospital, G.T. Road, Mohania belonging to this petitioner.
Later, the petitioner called another Doctor who came on a
vehicle (the registration number recorded in the FIR). The
lady was operated and the child delivered but she died in the
process. The Nursing home was unregistered. This followed
the FIR.
6. Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner submits
that a perusal of the FIR would show that the delivery took
place through a Doctor who came in a vehicle, his name has
come up as Doctor Saroj Kumar. This petitioner is actually a
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
3/15
Nurse but only to implicate, the Doctor word has been affixed
with her name. She further has no criminal antecedent and the
last submission is that to show her bona fide and for the future
of the newly born baby child who arrived in this world but
will never see the mother, the petitioner intends to deposit Rs.
1,00,000/- as fixed deposit.
7. Learned APP, Mr. Jitendra Kumar Singh opposes
the prayer submitting that the unregistered Nursing Home is
being run by the petitioner where unfortunate death took place
and as such, she cannot escape the responsibility.
8. As recorded above, the unregistered/illegal
Nursing Homes are flourishing in the State of Bihar. The Civil
Surgeon-cum-Chief Medical Officers of the districts have
allowed said Nursing Homes to function. They never collect
data of their district to know how many young women left this
world due to such criminal negligence on the part of the
unregistered Nursing Homes.
9. However, in the present case, since the stand is
that she is serving as Nurse, the operation took place through
Dr. Saroj Kumar and she has no criminal antecedent, in that
background, this Court is inclined to extend her the privilege
of anticipatory bail subject to the payment of Rs. 1,00,000/- to
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
4/15
the infant child.
10. The amount of Rs. 1,00,000/- shall be deposited
in the form of fixed deposit issued by the State Bank of India
Local Branch in the name of the child with all details which
will be en-cashed by the said child only after he attains sixteen
years of age for his education. The Chief Manager of the
State Bank of India shall incorporate in the certificate that in
view of the order of Patna High Court in Cr. Misc. No.
89807 of 2025, it can be en-cashed only after the child attains
sixteen years of age.
11. The concerned Court where the petitioner will be
submitting the fixed deposit certificate of Rs. 1,00,000/- shall
satisfy himself/herself that all the facts have been correctly
incorporated on the said certificate issued by the SBI.
12. If the birth certificate of the child has not been
issued, the Sub Divisional Officer, Mohania shall ensure that
the same is immediately issued to the child so that the fixed
deposit is prepared in time.
13. Let the petitioner be released on bail in the event
of arrest or surrender within a period of four weeks from the
receipt of this order, on furnishing bail bond of Rs. 10,000/(Ten thousand) with two sureties of like amount each to the
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
5/15
satisfaction of learned ACJM, Kaimur at Bhabhua in
connection with Mohanai P.S. Case No. 715 of 2025 subject to
the following conditions:
(i) one of the bailor should be the family
member/relative of the petitioner who shall provide official
document (Aadhaar Card/Pan Card/Voter ID Card/Driving
License) to show his/her bona fide;
(ii) the petitioner shall appear on each and every date
before the Trial Court and failure to do so for two consecutive
dates without plausible reason will entail cancellation of his
bail bond by the Trial Court itself;
(iii) the petitioner shall in no way try to induce or
promise or threat the witnesses or tamper with the evidences,
failing which the State shall be at liberty to take steps for
cancellation of the bail bonds;
(iv) the petitioner shall desist from committing any
criminal offence again, failing which the State shall be at
liberty to take steps for cancellation of his bail bonds.
14. Having disposed of the petition, this Court must
record that the District Administration failed to conduct
raid/investigate the functioning of the Nursing Homes in the
district and see to it that whether there are proper facilities to
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
6/15
function as such and thus cannot escape responsibility for the
death of Shweta Kumari.
15. In that background, the District Magistrate,
Kaimur is duty bound to direct the Sub-Divisional Officer,
Mohania to hand over certificate on behalf of the District
Administration to the child (through his parent) certifying that
he shall be getting free education/health in the State.
16. The Civil Surgeon, Kaimur shall also be
providing the Health Insurance Certificate to the child for his
treatment in the district of Kaimur.
17. It is to be noted that on 02.05.2025, while
disposing of the Cr. Misc. No. 24566 if 2025 (Dr. Dilip
Kumar & Anr. vs State), this Court in paragraphs nos. 10
and 14 recorded as under:
“10. Having disposed of the anticipatory
bail application, this Court is really surprised: how
this unregistered Hospital (Nidan Emergency
Hospital) was running in Piro without any
information
whatsoever
Administration/Police
to
the
District
Officials/Civil
Surgeon.
Further, whether pursuant to the loss of an
innocent life, the local administration/Police/Civil
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
7/15
Surgeon have taken up the issue seriously and
conducted raid/investigation of
all the Private
Hospitals/Nursing Homes running in Piro to
know:
(i)
how
many
Hospitals/Nursing
are
functioning
Homes
illegally/unauthorizedly
in
Piro
without license;
(ii) even if any of the Hospital/Nursing
Home is having license, whether it is
fully equipped with the
emergency
services or not?;
(iii) whether the Doctors are present
there 24X7 or not?;
(iv)
whether
the
fire
fighting
equipments are present in it or not?
(v) whether all these necessary facts
stand
incorporated on the display
board of the Hospital/Nursing Home
or not?
14.
The
District
Administration,
Bhojpur specially those sitting in Piro as also the
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
8/15
Civil Surgeon, Bhojpur having failed to check the
running of the illegal Hospitals/Nursing Homes
leading to the death of the infant’s mother; they
will have to take the responsibility of shaping up
the future of the infant. The certificate declaring
free education/health insurance to the infant (name
to be incorporated after checking
the birth
certificate issued by Municipal Authority) have to
be handed over through parent/parents-in-law in
the next thirty days and the reports regarding
compliance of the directions incorporated in paras
10 and 13 have to be made available by the offices
of the D.M., Bhojpur, the S.P., Bhojpur as also the
Civil Surgeon cum Chief Medical Officer,
Bhojpur.”
18. The said matter vide modification petition (Cr.
Misc. No. 43257 of 2025) again came up for hearing on
04.07.2025 and 25.07.2025 under the heading ‘To be
Mentioned’ to peruse the Action Taken Report wherein the
stand of the Civil Surgeon, Bhojpur was that the notification
no. 480 dated 04.03.2025 issued by the Health Department,
Bihar, Patna allows Hospitals/Nursing Homes upto 40 beds
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
9/15
to function without registration. The Court, as such, in
paragraphs 15 to 17 and 22 recorded as under:
15. This is an alarming situation, on the
one hand, the illegal Nursing Homes/Hospitals are
running in the district/Sub-divisions/remote blocks
without any obstacle, on the other hand, the Civil
Surgeon cum Chief Medical Officer, Bhojpur at Ara
who is head of the district is raising his hands
stating that he has no power either to ensure that
the Hospitals are
registered or to seal it, if
irregularities are detected and/or if it is found that
it is being run illegally without any Doctor and/or
no emergency services are available there. In other
words, his contention is that the poor/illiterate
people cannot be stopped from visiting those illegal
Nursing Homes/Hospitals due to the prevailing
rules/regulations and accordingly, guidelines have
been sought for from the Health Department which
is awaited.
16. On further query whether repeated
inspections/repeated fines can be imposed upon the
said Nursing Homes or not and/or at least the local
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
10/15
innocent people can be informed through regular
Newspaper publication/Public Address System as
also the Posters at the strategic places including
government buildings or not, the answer is in
affirmative.
17. For the record, this Court has to
observe that similar incidents are happening
across
the
State
where
for
want
of
Doctor/treatment/fake Doctors, the innocents are
dying in the private Nursing Homes. The onus
clearly lies
on the Health Department, Bihar
through its Additional Chief Secretary to look into
the matter and take remedial measures.
22. Mr. Prashant Pratap, learned G.P.-2
shall be filing comprehensive affidavit on behalf of
the Additional Chief Secretary, Health Department
throwing light not only
on the letter dated
04.03.2025 issued by the said Department but also
to the guidelines that has been sought for by the
Civil Surgeon cum Chief Medical Officer, Bhojpur
at Ara dated 24.03.2025. The A.C.S. shall also be
answering to the statements made by the Civil
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
11/15
Surgeon, Bhojpur that even if an illegal Nursing
Home during an inspection is found to be run
without the Doctor, no action can be taken against
it. This is just putting the lives of innocents at the
mercy of any Nursing Home in the opinion of the
Court.
19. The said case (Cr. Misc. No. 43257 of 2025) was
finally consigned on 24.11.2025 after recording the Health
Department’s reply as follows:
“5. That it is stated and submitted
that the Health Department, Government of
Bihar has taken note of the matter as per the
direction of this Hon'ble Court issued by
order dated 22.08.2025 and in that course,
two State Level Committee for Saran,
Tirhut, Darbhanga, Koshi and Purnia
Division
headed
by
Director-in-Chief
(Administration), Health Services, Bihar,
Patna and another committee for Patna,
Magadh Munger and Bhagalpur Division
headed by Director-in-Chief (Nursing),
Health Services, Bihar, Patna have been
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
12/15
constituted by the Health Department,
Bihar by order issued vide Memo No.
1875(18) dated 08.09.2025 for inspection of
all
Government
and
Private
Hospitals/Nursing Homes/Pathology Center
and submitting a report to the Department
with specific instructions to inspect the
hospitals/Nursing homes in at least one
district every fortnight and provide the
inspection report to the department.
6. That it is relevant to state here
that by departmental letter no. 1845 (18)
dated
28.11.2013,
Bihar
Clinical
Establishment (Registration and Regulation)
Rules, 2013 has been framed in exercise of
powers conferred by Section 54 of the
Clinical Establishment (Registration and
Regulation) Act, 2010.
7. That it is further relevant to
state here that by departmental notification
No. 480 (18) dated 04.03.2025, Bihar
Clinical Establishment (Registration and
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
13/15
Regulation) Rules, 2013 has been amended
and hospitals with 01-40 beds have been
exempted from the said rules. Thereafter,
guidelines have been sought by various
Civil Surgeons of Bihar regarding the
control and renewal of hospitals having 0140 beds and other facts. In this background
and in view of the order of this Hon'ble
Court passed in this case, a six-member
committee headed by Dr. Pramod Kumar
Singh, Director-in-Chief, Health Services,
Bihar, Patna has been constituted by the
Health Department by office order Memo
No. 1853(18) dated 02.09.2025 to issue
guidelines
at
departmental
level
for
controlling Hospitals/Nursing Homes with
01-40 beds running in the surgeries.
8. That although the constituted
committee was directed to provide the
necessary guidelines to regulate 1-40 bedded
hospitals/nursing homes within two days in
the light of the guidelines sought by various
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
14/15
Civil Surgeons. But due to the committee
reviewing the matter in depth, the report
could not be provided on time.
9. That the Health Department,
Government of Bihar is actively pursuing the
matter as per the direction of this Hon'ble
Court.”
(emphasis added)
20. This Court has recorded the paragraph nos. 10
and 14 of the order dated 02.05.2025 in the Cr. Misc. No.
24566 of 2025 as also the paragraph 3 of the order dated
24.11.2025 in Cr. Misc. No. 43257 of 2025 and would expect
the Health Department, Bihar, Patna, the District Magistrate,
Kaimur as also the Civil Surgeon-cum-Chief Medical Officer,
Kaimur to file their respective response(s) on the aforesaid
subject matter.
21. While Mr. Prashant Pratap, learned GP.2 shall be
filing the affidavits on behalf of the Health Department, Bihar,
Patna, Mr. Jitendra Kumar Singh, learned APP shall be filing
the response of the District Administration, Kaimur and the
Civil Surgeon, Kaimur.
22. Learned counsel for the petitioner shall be
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.89807 of 2025(2) dt.28-01-2026
15/15
providing copy of the petition both to Mr. Prashant Pratap,
learned GP-2 and Mr. Jitendra Kumar Singh, learned APP and
the receipt(s) shall be filed in the office positively by
02.02.2026.
23. List this case on 12.03.2026 under the heading
‘To Be Mentioned’ to peruse the affidavit(s) of the Health
Department, Bihar, Patna, the District Magistrate, Kaimur and
the Civil Surgeon, Kaimur.
(Rajiv Roy, J)
Adnan/U
T
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review