Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
1.
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.191 of 2026
======================================================
Surya Nestbuild Limited having its Head Office at Surya Signature Building,
Besides Hira Sweets Lane, Boring Canal Road, P.S. S.K. Puri, District and
Town-Patna, Bihar represented through its one of the Directors, namely, Shri
Tarun Kumar aged about 57 years Son of Late Shri Jagdish Prasad Singh,
resident of Flat No. 303, Block-A-1, Nutan Tower, Kankarbagh, Patna-800
020, Bihar.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
The State of Bihar represented through the Additional Chief Secretary,
Revenue and Land Reforms Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
2.
The Divisional Commissioner, Patna Division, Patna.
3.
The District Magistrate, Patna.
4.
The Additional District Magistrate/Additional Collector, Patna Sadar, Patna
(Revisional Authority).
5.
The Deputy Collector Land Reforms, Danapur, District Patna (Appellate
Authority).
6.
The Circle Officer, Danapur, District Patna (Original Authority).
7.
M/s Helios Corporation Limited, Address Helios Bhawan, Station Road, P.S.
Kotwali, P.O. G.P.O., District and Town Patna.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s
For the State
For the Resp. No.7
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
Mr. Mrigank Mauli, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Kumar Ravish, Advocate
Mr. Yashvardhan Singh, Advocate
Mr. Additional Advocate General (5)
Mr. Bijoy Kumar Sinha, AC to AAG-5
Mr. Abhinav Shrivastava, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Navin Kumar, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV ROY
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 30-06-2026
Heard Mr. Mrigank Mauli, learned Senior Counsel
for the petitioner duly assisted by Mr. Kumar Ravish and Mr.
Abhinav Srivastava, learned Senior Counsel representing the
respondent no.7 duly assisted by Mr. Naveen Kumar as also Mr.
Bijoy Kumar Sinha, learned counsel for the State.
2. The present petition has been preferred for the
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
2/17
grant of following relief(s):
“(a) to quash and set aside at Pg. 177
(Annexure P/15) i.e. an ex parte order dated
14.10.2025 passed by the Revisional Authority
i.e. Additional District Magistrate/Additional
Collector (ADM), Patna in Mutation Revision
(MR)
No.
Corporation
of
2025-26
Limited,
(M/s
Helios
Dist-Patna
Versus
D.C.L.R. Danapur and Others, Dist. Patna)
under
which
the
order
dated
6.11.2024
(Annexure P/13) passed in Mutation Appeal
Case No. 09/2024-25 by the Deputy Collector
Land Reforms, Danapur (Appellate Authority)
was set aside with restoration of Jamabandi of
the private respondent no. 7 as mentioned in the
concluding portion of the impugned order.
(b) to direct for an expeditious disposal of
Mutation
Revision
No.
of
2024-25
(Annexure P/11) pending in the Court of
Revisional Authority i.e. the Additional District
Magistrate/Additional Collector, Patna which
was filed at the instance of this petitioner against
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
3/17
an order dated 18.10.2024 (Annexure P/10)
passed in Mutation Appeal Case No. 365 of
2024-25 under which the mutation order passed
in favour of this petitioner was set aside.
(c) to direct for restoration of Jamabandi of
this petitioner bearing Jamabandi No. 1078 with
respect to the property situated at Mauza
Babkarpur,
Pargana
Phulwarisharif,
P.S.
Danapur, District Patna, Thana No. 35, Tauzi
No. 5061, Khata No. 106, Survey Plot No. 104
[The same is in Halka Lakhnibigha, Circle
Danapur].
(d) to direct for payment of costs of this
litigation.
(e) any other relief or relief (s) which this
petitioner may be found entitled to in the facts
and circumstances of the case.”
3. The facts relating to the present writ petition is/are
as follows:
4. The petitioner claims to be a company incorporated
under the laws in vogue in the country and its directors, officials
and staffs are citizens of India.
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
4/17
5. Further, the petitioner-M/s Surya Nestbuild
Limited claims to have acquired the property in question
situated at Mauza Babkarpur, Pargana Phulwarisharif, P.S.
Danapur, District Patna, Thana No. 35, Tauzi No. 5061,
Khata No. 106, Survey Plot No. 104 [The same is in Halka
Lakhnibigha, Circle Danapur] vide following three sale deeds
admeasuring a total area of 64 decimals:
(a) vide Sale Deed No. 8318 dated
10.05.2008 from Ajay Kumar acquiring 21.5
decimals;
(b) vide Sale Deed No. 13827 dated 4.8.2008
from Suban Rai and Krishna Mistry acquiring
31.5 decimals;
(c) vide Sale Deed No. 13854 dated 5.8.2008
from Suban Rai acquiring 11 decimals.”
6. Further, as per the petition, the vendors of this
petitioner above named had earlier purchased the land in
question from Smt. Ahilya Devi, Smt. Rampyari Devi, Keshav
Singh and others by way of different sale deeds and since then,
they came in peaceful, vacant and exclusive possession of the
land in question and also got their names mutated in the revenue
records.
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
5/17
7. Later, upon execution of the sale deeds in favour of
this petitioner company, it came in peaceful, vacant and
exclusive possession of the entire chunk of land with boundary
wall duly constructed. The petitioner also constructed iron gate
for ingress and egress and further took electricity connection
from the Power Holding Corporation.
8. The further case of the petitioner is that upon
acquiring the property under three different sale deeds,
applications were preferred for the mutation of the name of the
company in the revenue records and accordingly, the same were
also mutated under two separate orders passed by the Circle
Officer, Danapur in following manner after carrying out
necessary inquiries:
(a) Sale Deed No. 8318 dated 10.05.2008.
Name of the petitioner was mutated in Mutation
Case No. 492/2008-09 vide an order dated
25.06.2008;
(b) Sale Deed No. 13827 dated 4.8.2008 and
Sale Deed No. 13854 dated 5.8.2008. Name of
the petitioner was mutated in Mutation Case No.
904/2008-09 under an order dated 29.08.2008.
9. The name of this petitioner company accordingly
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
6/17
got entered into the Register-II and Jamabandi No. 1078 was
created in his name. The Circle Officer, Danapur also issued
land ownership/possession certificate for a total area of 64
decimals acquired by this petitioner under valid sale deeds. It
also records that Jamabandi No. 1078 was created in favour of
the petitioner. The said certificates were duly issued on
15.04.2013, 01.07.2014 and 16.05.2017 by the said office.
10. The further case of the petitioner is that the
company started paying rent to the State Government and the
competent authority also issued rent receipts for the land in
question accordingly based on the revenue records till the year
2024-25 when due to the erroneous orders passed against by the
revenue authorities, the names of the old Jamabandi holders
were restored. As a result, for the year 2025-26, the petitioner
could not pay the rent revenue.
11. The case of the petitioner further is that at the
behest of the respondent no.7, the Jamabandi Cancellation
Case No. 119 of 2013-2014 was initiated against the petitioner
company which was decided against the said respondent on
31.01.2015 by the Additional Collector, Patna with a
direction/liberty to file proper Civil Suit (Annexure P/5 to the
writ petition).
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
7/17
12. Aggrieved, the respondent no.7 moved before the
Collector, Patna in Jamabandi Cancellation Appeal Case No.
09 of 2015-2016 assailing the order dated 31.01.2015 passed by
the Additional Collector (in the Jamabandi Cancellation Case
No. 119 of 2013-2014). It was decided on 30.09.2023 and the
Collector, Patna remitted the matter back to the Circle Officer,
Danapur for taking a fresh decision.
13. The further contention of the petitioner is/are that
during the pendency of the Jamabandi Cancellation Appeal Case
No. 09 of 2015-16, the respondent no.7 filed a Title Suit No. 04
of 2018 dated 04.11.2018 before the Learned Sub Judge 1st,
Danapur impleading the petitioner as Defendant no. 1 as also
the vendors of the petitioner as the other Defendants. The prayer
in the Title Suit was for the declaration of their title over the
property in question as also a declaration to hold that this
petitioner has no title with further prayer to hold that the
mutation order passed in favour of the petitioner be declared as
illegal and without any title.
14. The averment in the writ petition is that the civil
suit was ultimately dismissed as withdrawn on 17.05.2025 with
further orders that the private respondent herein shall be
precluded from instituting any fresh suit with respect to the
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
8/17
subject matter.
15. The story once again goes back to the order
passed by the Collector, Patna on 30.09.2023 which followed
institution of the Mutation Case No. 1422-R-27/24-25 on the
petition filed by the petitioner and Mutation Case Nos. 7706 of
2023-2024 and 7727 of 2023-2024 registered on the petitions
preferred by the respondent no.7.
16. The petition preferred by the petitioner was
allowed by the Circle Officer, Danapur on 15.06.2024 holding
his possession over the land (Annexure P/9 to the writ petition).
Aggrieved, the respondent no.7 moved before the Deputy
Collector Land Reforms, Danapur vide Mutation Appeal
No.365 of 2024-2025 which was decided on 18.10.2024 against
the petitioner after observing that since the title suit (of the
respondent no.7) is pending vide Title Suit No.04 of 2018
before a competent Civil Court, the Circle officer, Danapur
ought not have passed the order. The order dated 15.06.2024
passed by the Circle Officer, Danapur was thus set aside.
17. The petitioner thereafter preferred Mutation
Revision Case No.101 of 2024-25 against the said order dated
18.10.2024 passed by the Deputy Collector Land Reforms,
Danapur which is presently pending before the learned
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
9/17
Additional Collector, Patna.
18. The parallel story of the present case is that
meanwhile, the Circle Officer, Danapur vide an order dated
28.10.2024 allowed the petitions (Mutation Case No. 7706 of
2023-24 and 7727 of 2023-24) preferred by the respondent no.7
based on the order passed by the Collector, Patna in Jamabandi
Appeal Case No. 09 of 2015-16. The contention is that this
order was passed on 28.10.2024 when the suit was still pending
which ultimately came to be dismissed as withdrawn with cost
against the respondent no.7 on 17.05.2025.
19. The further contention is that having realized his
mistake, the Circle Officer, Danapur himself referred the matter
to the Deputy Collector Land Reforms, Danapur which led to
the registration of the Appeal No. 09 of 2024-2025 and after
hearing the parties, vide an order dated 06.11.2024, the order
dated 28.10.2024 passed by the Circle Officer, Danapur was
set aside (Annexure P/13 to the writ petition).
20. Thereafter, the respondent no.7 moved in
Mutation Revision No. 25 of 2025-26 before the Additional
Collector, Patna. It is to be noted that the Mutation Revision No.
101 of 2024-25 preferred by the petitioner relating to the same
cause/land was already pending before the Additional Collector,
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
10/17
Patna.
21. However, instead of taking up the two cases
together and/or noticing the petitioner in the Mutation Revision
Case No.25 of 2025-26, in a haste, the Additional Collector,
Patna vide an order dated 14.10.2025 allowed the said revision
application preferred by the respondent no.7.
22. Aggrieved, the present writ petition.
23. Mr. Mrigank Mauli, learned Senior Counsel for
the petitioner has taken this Court to the said application
(Mutation Revision No. 25 of 2025-26) preferred by the
respondent no.7 to show that it clearly records his contention
that the petitioner has illegally got the land transferred in his
name.
24. The submission is that despite dedicating number
of paragraphs in his application leveling allegation against the
petitioner, the respondent no.7 deliberately failed to ensure that:
(i) the Mutation Revision Case No. 101 of
2024-25 preferred by the petitioner is tagged
with its case;
(ii) to request the Additional Collector,
Patna to notice the petitioner in Mutation
Revision No. 25 of 2025-26 so that he can also
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
11/17
be heard following the principle of natural
justice before an order is passed.
25. The submission is that despite the petitioner being
the stakeholder to the said property and in peaceful physical
possession and the respondent no.7 fighting the legal battle for
the last one decade with it, without issuance of any notice
and/or deciding the revision application preferred by the
petitioner pending before the same respondent alongwith the
petition of the respondent no.7, in a haste, the order in question
dated 14.10.2025 was passed by the learned Additional
Collector, Patna which warrants interference.
26. The respondent no.7 upon notice has appeared and
Mr. Abhinav Shrivastav, learned Senior Counsel is representing
it. The contention put forward is that the purchase of the land by
the respondent no.7 is earlier to the present petitioner having
been purchased on 26.09.1996 and since then, not only the
respondent no.7 is in possession of the land, has regularly
fought the legal battle with the petitioner.
27. The further contention is that number of times, the
matter moved from the Circle Office, Danapur to the office of
the Collector, Patna and ultimately, the respondent no.7
preferred Title Suit No. 04 of 2018 which in the particular facts
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
12/17
and circumstance was withdrawn on 17.05.2025.
28. The contention further is that lastly, while the
respondent no.7 preferred Mutation Revision No. 25 of 202526 before the Additional Collector, Patna against the order
passed by Deputy Collector Land Reforms, Danapur, the
Mutation Revision Case No.101 of 2024-25 also preferred by
the petitioner is still pending before the Additional Collector,
Patna.
29. The contention of the learned Senior Counsel
further is that though the Mutation Revision Case No. 25 of
2025-26 of the respondent no.7 has been disposed of, the
Mutation Revision Case No. 101 of 2024-25 preferred by the
petitioner is still pending before the Additional Collector, Patna
where he can raise all the points available to him. The
submission is that in that background, no interference is
required and the writ petition be dismissed.
30. Learned State Counsel, Mr. Bijoy Kumar Sinha
though tried to justify the order in question candidly concedes
that when the details of the petitioner was/were available in the
Mutation Revision petition preferred by the respondent no.7 and
the Mutation Revision application of the petitioner was also
pending, allegations were directly made against him in the plaint
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
13/17
by the respondent no.7 which reflects from the order itself, an
opportunity of hearing must have been given to the petitioner.
31. This Court has heard the parties at length. The
issues/points that need consideration by this Court is/are that:
“(i) whether the petitioner as also the
respondent no.7 is/are fighting the battle relating
to the land in question before the different courts
since last one decade or not;
(ii) in case, the answer to the first question
is in affirmative, whether both the parties have
to be heard before an order is passed with regard
to the land in question or not;
(iii) if
question
again, the answer to the second
is
in
affirmative,
whether
the
respondent Additional Collector, Patna in that
background erred in passing the order in
question without the issuance of notice the
petitioner and/or allowing him to present his
case or not;
(iv) whether in the aforesaid circumstances,
an interference is required in the matter or not.”
32. This Court has detailed out the entire facts of the
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
14/17
case and finds that in the roller coaster journey of the legal
battle fought between the petitioner and the respondent no.7, in
almost every order, the presence of both the parties have been
recorded. Further, the Mutation Revision Case No.101 of
2024-25 filed by the petitioner was already pending before the
Additional Collector, Patna which followed the Mutation
Revision Case No.25 of 2025-26.
33. Further, the plaint preferred by the respondent
no.7 in Mutation Revision Case No. 25 of 2025-26 contained
allegation/grievance against the petitioner clearly, the Additional
Collector, Patna failed to follow the principle of natural justice.
34. The sole purpose of principle of natural justice is
to prevent miscarriage of justice to any individual/party who
may in any manner stands affected by the order.
35. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in number of cases
has held that even an administrative order which involves civil
consequences must be consistent with the rules of natural
justice.
36. The civil consequences was referred as not merely
a property or personal rights but of civil liberties, material
deprivation as also non-pecuniary damages. In other words,
anything and everything that affects a citizen his civil life
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
15/17
warrants application of principle of natural justice.
37. In the aforesaid context, it is surprising that the
Additional Collector, Patna completely overlooked the interest
of the petitioner while passing the order in question in a haste. It
is more disturbing considering the fact that the Mutation
Revision preferred by the petitioner was already pending before
the said court which was not taken up/ignored.
38. In the aforesaid background, this Court is of the
opinion that having taken note of the allegation made by the
respondent no.7 against the petitioner in the plaint, the least that
was expected from the Additional Collector, Patna was to notice
and hear him. However, not only the respondent Additional
Collector, Patna failed to follow the principle of natural justice,
it further erred in not tagging the Mutation Revision Case No.
101 of 2024-25 alongwith the Mutation Revision No. 25 of
2025-26 and in a very mechanical manner disposed it of vide an
order dated 14.10.2025.
39. Thus, the points/issues that were framed in para
29 stands answered as follows:
(i) for the said land, both the petitioner as
also the respondent no.7 have locked horns for
the last one decade and the plaint of Mutation
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
16/17
Revision No. 25 of 2025-26 had contents
dedicating to the petitioner;
(ii) in that background, before passing any
order, the respondent Additional Collector, Patna
was duty bound to notice/hear the petitioner in
the Mutation Revision application no.25 of
2025-26 preferred by the respondent no.7;
(iii) the Additional Collector, Patna by
ignoring the contents of the plaint preferred by
the respondent no.7 and having failed to notice
the petitioners clearly erred in passing the order
dated 14.10.2025 in question;
(iv) thus, the order dated 14.10.2025 passed
in Mutation Revision Case No. 25 of 2025-26
needs interference.
40. Accordingly, ordered. The order dated 14.10.2025
passed in Mutation Revision Case No. 25 of 2025-26 by the
Additional Collector, Patna stands quashed.
41. The Mutation Revision Case No. 25 of 20252026 (preferred by the respondent no.7) stands revived and is
remitted back to the concerned respondent no. 4, the Additional
Collector, Patna who shall ensure that the case is tagged with the
Patna High Court CWJC No.191 of 2026 dt.30-06-2026
17/17
Mutation Revision Case No.101 of 2024-25 (preferred by the
petitioner)
and
after
noticing
all
the
relevant
parties/stakeholders, a proper/ reasoned/ comprehensive order
has to be passed in accordance with law, at an earliest.
42. Both the parties have undertaken to maintain
status quo with regard to land in question till an order comes
from the Additional Collector, Patna.
43. The writ petition is disposed of with the aforesaid
observations.
(Rajiv Roy, J)
vinayak/AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date
Transmission Date
AFR
NA
02.07.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review