Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t 3488 l
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY,THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT
NO:11
OF
writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Prefened Against order Dated
2610911025 in W.P.No.2011 1 ot 2025 on the file of the High Court'
Between:
years' occ ; Professor of
Dr.K.Ravi Sekhar Rao, S/o. Late K.Subramanyam, Age. 6'.t
Opninalmotogy, Gandhi Medical College, Secunderabad'
....APPELLANT/3d WRIT PETITIONER
AND
State of Telangana, Rep.,by its principal Secretary., Health' Medical
' . The
i;;il, W-df"ie oefiartment, Se6retariat, Saifabad, Hvderabad'
and
2. The Director of Medical Education, Government of Telangana' Koti'
Hyderabad.
3.ThePrincipal'GandhiMedicalCollege/GandhiHospital,Secunderabad.
4. The PrinciPal, GMH, Hanumakonda.
5. The Principal, MGM/KMC, Warangal.
of
6.
- Dr.A.Subodh Kumar' Sio.Late A.Sriramulu, Age 56 years' Occ' Professor
FiJsiii Surgeon, Gandhi Medical College' Secunderabad'
7- Dr.K.Naqariuna, S/o. late K.Ranga Rao, Age' 57 years, Occ'Professor of
Paediatiic Surgery, Gandhi Medical College, Secunderabad'
of
8.
- Dr.Ratnam Andallu, Wo.Dr.M.Vijaya Kumar' Age' 63.years' Occ'Professor
OBGV, Government Maternity Hospital, Hanumakonda'
and
9.
- Dr.A.Aoarna, W/o.Dr'K.Ramesh Kumar, Age' 61 years,.Occ'Professor
Warangal'
HOD iaediatrics, MGM Hospital/KMC, Hanumakonda,
0. Dr.Ch.Madhu Babu, S/o.Ch.
Occ.Professor of STD/DVL' N/IG
, Age.60 years,
Hanumakonda, Warangal.
(Respondents 4 to 10 are not necessary to this Appeal)'
....RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS
|.A.NO:2 OF 2025
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the operation of the impugned judgment dt.26l912025 in W.P.No .20111 of
2025, to the extent it upholds the promotion of the Appellant (Writ Petitioner No.3)
under G.o.Rt.No.298, Health, Medical & Family welfare (A) Department,
dl-O7.O7.2025, and consequently direct the Respondents to retain and continue
the Appellant in his present position as Professor of Ophthalmology, Gandhi
Medical colle<;e, secunderabad, pending disposal of the above writ appeal.
Counsel for lrppellant : SRI L.RAV|CHANDER FoR SRt SRtN|VAS BoBBlLt
counselfor tlTe Respondent Nos.l to 5 : sRl S.SATYANARAYANA RAo, AGp
FOR SERVICES -I
Counsel for trhe Respondent Nos.6 to 10 : The Court marde the following ORDER
IN THE HIGH COT'RT r1OR THE STATE OF TELI\NGANA
AT ITYDERABAT)
THE HON'BI.E THE CHIEF JUSrICE SRI APARESH KT'MAR SINGH
AI{D
THI HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHruDDIN
WRIT APPEAL
o.LL92 of 2o25
DATE: I? .o3.20.26
Between:
Dr.K.Ravi Shekar Rao
.Appellant
And
The State of Telangana,
represented by its Principal Secretary,
Health, Medical & Family Welfare Department,
Secretariat, Hyderabad and 9 others
....Respondents
JUDGMENT
Heard Sri L.Ravichander, learned Senior counsel representing
Sri Srinivas Bobbiti, learned counsel appearing for the appellant and
Sri Santhapur Satyanarayana Rao, learned Government Pleader for
Seryices-l appearing for respondent Nos.l to 5 and perused the
record.
2.
This writ appeal, prelerred under clause 15 of the Letters
Patent, assails the order dated 26.09.2025 passed by the learned
Single Judge in W.P.No.20111 of 2025. The appellant (3'a writ
petitioner), calls in question the refusal of the learned Single Judge to
grant him the relief of foregoing his promotion to the post of Principal,
Government Medical College, Mahabubabad, under Rule 11(b) of the
\..
-
Telangana State and Subordinate Service Rules, L9g6 (for short,
'1996 Rutes').
3. The grievance of the appellant essentially stems from the
dismissa. of the writ petition as regards him, while similar relief was
granted to certain other petitioners in the same writ proceedings.
Factual:matrix
4.
Thr: appellant is a Professor of Ophthalmologr at Gandhi
Medical College, Secunderabad. By G.O.Rt.No.298, dated
O7.O7.2O25, issued by the Government of Telangana, the appellant
was prornoted and posted as Principal, Government Medical College,
Mahabubabad.
5.
Upon issuance of the said promotion order, the appellant
submitte d representations expressing his unwillingness to accept the
post and sought permission to forego the promotion. In his
representations, the appellant stated that he was discharging
important academic responsibilities in the Department of
ophthal:molory, including supervision of six postgraduate students,
and also referred to certain personal circumstances relating to the age
and serious health condition of his 86 years old mother. Despite this,
the authorities insisted the appellant to join the promoted post.
6.
The appellant along with hve other professors, who were
similarlS' aggrieved,
.,pY their respecrive promorional postings,
approached this Court by filing W.P.No.2O1t 1 of 2OZS.
'f"t ,:.
7.
The learned Single Judge, by order dated 26.09.2025, partly
allowed the aforesaid writ petition. The learned Singte Judge set aside
the promotions of petitioners 2, 4, 5, and 6, whereas the writ petition
was dismissed in respect of petitioner No.1 and petitioner No.3. The
learned Single Judge distinguished their cases on the ground that
they had been promoted to the posts of Principal, which is a teaching
post, and that the State had demonstrated the existence of public
interest in posting them to newly established medical colleges to
ensure compliance with the norms of the National Medical
Commission (NMC).
8.
Aggrieved by the said order, the appellant has preferred the
present writ appeal.
Submissions on behalf of the appellant
9.
Learned Senior Counsel representing the appellant assailed the
order dated 26.09.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge and has
advanced his submissions as under:
i) That the learned Single Judge committed an error in treating
the post of Principal as a teaching post. Placing reliance on the
National Medical Commission (NMC) Regulations, 2023 (for
short '2023 Regulations') and the Minimum Standards for
Establishment of Medical Colleges, it was submitted that the
Principal is the administrative head of the institution and is not
counted as part of the teaching faculty for determining the
teacher-student ratio.
ii) Th at the role of the Principal is supervisory and administrative,
distinct from the teaching cadres of Professor, Associate
Professor and Assistant Professor.
iii) That Rule 11(b) of the 1996 Rules expressly permits an
errrployee to forego a promotion by not joining the promoted
post within the stipulated period of hfteen days. The
consequence of such non-joining, is only the forfeiture of the
prrmotion for the concerned panel year, and the rule does not
enrpower the Govemment to compel an employee to accept the
promotion or to treat the refusal as misconduct.
iv) TtLat the learned Single Judge erred in invoking the concept of
ptrblic interest to override the statutory right under Rule 11(b)
of the 1996 Rules, as the impugned promotion order
G O.Rt.No.298 dated 07 -O7.2025 does not contain any recital or
reason based on public interest for compelling the appellant to
a<:cept the promotion.
v) That the plea of public interest, raised subsequently in the
counter affidavit, amounts to an impermissible post-hoc
ju.stification, contrary to the principle laid down by the Apex
Court in Mohinder Singh @ill v. The Chief Election
Commissiotter, New Delhi and, othersl, wherein it was held
that zrn administrative order must stand or fall on the reasons
co n ta i r",.ed'lhe re in.
' (197ti) SCC 405
vi) That the impugned order is also assailed as being arbitrary and
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution, inasmuch as in the
very same writ petition, the learned Single Judge granted relief
to petitioners 2, 4, 5 and 6, who were promoted to the post of
Superintendent, which is likewise an administrative post.
Further, in another connected w.P.No.20489 of 2025, similar
relief was granted to a doctor promoted as Superintendent.
Thus, the appeltant, whose case stands on an identical footing,
has been subjected to differential treatment without any
rational basis.
vii) That there exists a consistent administrative practice whereby
the State has permitted several doctors to forego promotions.
Reference was made to: i) G.o.Rt.No.698 dated o7.I2.2O21
permitting eleven Professors to forego promotion; ii) orders
dated 24.O7.2024 permitting thirteen Assistant Professors to do
so; and iii) orders dated 05.08.2025 permitting six Associate
Professors to forego promotion to the cadre of ProfessorTherefore, the option under Rule 11(b) has been consistently
recognised in practice, and its denial to the appellant amounts
to a selective application of the rules.
viii) That compelling the appellant to accept the promotion would
itself be contrary to public interest, as he is the only Professor
supervising six postgraduate students in the Department of
Ophthalmolory at Gandhi Medical College, Secunderabad, and
hi:; removal would adversely affect postgraduate teaching and
compliance with the faculty requirements prescribed by the
NI\4C.
ix) That the appellant, who is about 6i years o[ age, is the sole
caregiver for his 86-year-old mother suffering from serious
ailments. Compelling him to relocate to Mahabubabad would
cause grave personal hardship and would be inconsistent with
the protections guaranteed under Article 2I of the Constitution.
Submis:lions on behalf of the Respondents
1(). k,arned Government Pleader for the Services-I, appearing for
respondent Nos.l to 5 supported the order dated 26.09.2025 passed
by the iearned Single Judge and has advanced his submissions as
under:
i)
That the Government has recently established twenty-live new
medical colleges, and the sanctioned strength for the posts of
Alditional Director of Medical Education (including principals)
is sixty-four, whereas only fifteen posts are presently occupied,
le
aving a substantial number of vacancies. In order to ensure
that these newly established colleges function effectivety and
comply with the norms of the NMC, the Government promoted
fcrrty- four Professors, including the appellant.
ii) That the appellant's characterization of the post of principal as
purely admiz=istrative, whereas the principal is both the
academic and administrative head of the institution,
responsible for supervising teaching programmes and
maintaining academic standards.
iii) That the right under Rule 11(b) of the 1996 Rules cannot be
construed as absolute and must yield to the larger public
interest. Placing reliance on the observations of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in State of llttar Pradesh u. Achal Singh2, it
was argued that the State, in discharge of its obligations as a
welfare State and in furtherance of the directive contained in
Article 47 of the Constitution, is entitled to take administrative
decisions necessary for the effective functioning of public
institutions.
iv) That the postings were necessitated by the impending
inspections of the NMC, and the absence of a Principal in a
newly established medical college would constitute a
fundamental deliciency that could jeopardize recognition of the
institution. Thus, the posting of the appellant as Principal of the
Government Medical College, Mahabubabad, was stated to be a
bona fide administrative decision taken to safeguard the
institu tion's recognition.
v) That the post of Superintendent of a hospital and the post of
Principal of a medical college are functionally different. While
the former is essentially hospital-administration oriented, the
2 (2018) 17 SCC s78
lat-ter is intrinsically connected with the academic leadership of
a -eaching institution.
vi) Rr:liance was also placed on the decision of the Hon'ble
Srrpreme Court in SIc. Nausord. Rahcrmcrn a. tlnion of Indias to
ccntend that an employee does not possess a vested right to
insist upon a particular posting and that administrative
e>:igencies must prevail over individual convenience.
vii) That permitting the appellant to forego the promotion would
disturb the promotion panel and seniority structure, and may
create administrative complications in hlling tl.e resultant
vtrcancies.
11. [rL support of the above submissions, reliance was placed on the
in the decisions of M.A.Kha,der Mohiud.din a. Honourable rrigh
Court, and. State of Telangorna, Ilgderabad. and. othersa and
Bo.barura Machched u. Union of India. and. otherss.
12. \lre have taken note of the respective contentions urged and
perusecl the material on record.
Consideration by this Court
13. E,efore proceeding to examine the issues involved, it would be
approp:iate to advert to the impugned order passed by the learned
Single.ludge, the same is reproduced hereunder:
3 (20221 12 SCC I
4 2025 (r)ALD 134 (TSl
- (20241 5 SCC 306
2) This Couri dealt with similar issue in W.P.No.20489 of 2025 and
allowed the said writ petition uide order dated 26.09.2O25.
3) In view of the aboue and for the reasons alike in the order dated
26.09.2025 in W.P. No.2O489 of 2O25, the present Writ Petition is also
liable to be allowed in respect of petitioners 2, 4, 5 and 6 alone.
Howeuer, ttrc case of petitioners 1 and 3 ould not be ansidered by this
Couri since tley were promoted as faatlty/ teaching members and tlrc
respondents haue proued the element of public interest in respect of
petitioners 1 and 3 as their seruices are required in tle newly
establbted Medical Colleges to get ouer tlrc inspections of National
Medical Commission.
4) Acardingly, the Writ Petition is allowed in part and the impugned
G.O.RI.No.298, dated 07.07.2025, is hereby set oside in respect of the
petitioner Nos.2,4, 5 and 6 alone.
Miscellaneous petitions pending, if ang, shall stand closed. No cosfs.
On perusal of the above, it indicates that the learned Single
Judge allowed the writ petition insofar as petitioners 2, 4, 5 and 6,
who were promoted as Superintendents, are concerned, placing
reliance on the reasoning adopted in W.P.No.20489 of 2025, wherein
the learned Single Judge had granted similar relief to a doctor
promoted to the post of Superintendent.
14. The principat issue that arises for consideration is whether the
appetlant being a Professor in the Medical Education Department who
is promoted to a higher administrative post as a Principal, can be
competted to accept such promotion against his will, or whether the
statutory framework under Rule 11(b) of the 1996 Rules, permits the
appellant to forego the promotion by declining to join the promoted
post. While administrative exigencies and considerations of public
interest undoubtedly play an important role in matters of service
administration, the exercise of such power must necessarily conform
to the governing statutory framework. Administrative action cannot be
sustainr:d if it is contrary to the express provisions of the rules or
suffers liom arbitrariness, for the rrle of law requires that executive
action remain hrmly anchored in legality. It is in this backdrop that
the statutory provision in question, namely Rule 11(b) of the 1996
Rules, requires to be examined.
15. R'tle I l(b) of the 1996 Rules, is reproduced hereunder:
" 1 1. The time
limit for joitting either on first selection or on promotion or
or, appointment by transkr:-
(a,'.....
(b.t Time to join a post on appointment/temporary appointment under
Rrd,e 10 including appointment by transfer or by promotion otherwise
than by direct recruitment, shall be allowed a joining time of 15 (fifieen)
duys to joirt the post from the date of receipt of the order of appointment
se nt to the candidate by Registered Post with acknowledgement due or
by ang other means. An emplogee who does not join the post within the
stLpulated time or euades to join the post by proceeding on leaue, shall
/ose his promotion right/offer for the current panel gear and the name of
the candidate shall be placed before the nert Departmental promotion
atmmittee for onsideration in the next year panel subject to auaitabitity
oJ uacancg. In case of non-selecfion posts, the name of the candidate
who does not join within the stipulated time in the promotion posts shalt
be ansidered for promotion again after a period of one year from the
dote of offer of appointment subject to auailability of uacancy-"
16. A plain reading of the aforesaid provision indicates that the rule
itself contemplates a situation where an employee may not join the
promot'ld post within the stipulated period. Significantly, the rule
does not prescribe any disciplinary action as a consequence for such
non-joi:ring. The only consequence stipulated is that the employee
shall lcse the promotion right/offer for the current panel year, and
his/her case may thereafter be considered in the next panel year,
subject to ava'ilability of vacancy.
17. It is pertinent to note that the scheme of the rule, recognizes the
possibility that an employee may, for various reasons, choose not to
assume the higher post at a particular point of time. By expressly
prescribing the consequence of such non-joining, the rule provides a
clear statutory right to forego a promotion- In this regard, Rule I 1(b)
cannot be interpreted in a manner that would render the provision
otiose. The rule clearly envisages that if an employee does not join the
promoted post within the prescribed time, the consequence is limited
to the loss of the promotion for the relevant panel year. The provision
does not indicate that the employee can be compelled to accept the
promotion notwith standing such unwillingness.
18. The primary reason assigned by the learned Single Judge for
denying relief to the appellant is the characterization of the post of
Principal as a "faculty/teaching member." It is to be noted that, such
characterization does not appear to be consistent with the regulatory
framework governing medical education. The distinction between a
teaching faculty member and the administrative head of a medical
institution is well recognised in the scheme of medical education. The
Medical Institutions (Qualifications of Faculty) Regulations 2025,
clearly delineate between faculty positions and administrative posts,
which is reproduced as under:
7. Short tltle and corrtrmencem.enL - (l) These regulations may be
colled the Medical lnstitutions (Qualifications of Faculty) Regulations,
2025.
(2) They shall come into force on the date of their publication in the
Official Gaz,ette.
t2
2. Deftnittons.
requires,
-
(1) In these regulations, unless the context otherwise
(a) "Act" means the National Medical Commission Act, 2019 (3O of 2019);
(b) "administratiue posts" means the posts of Medical Supeintendent or
Detn or Director or Principal of a medical institution;
(c) "broad specialty" means the specialties in Master of Surgery or Doctor
of Wedicine or Diploma specified in Table A and Table B of the Schedule;
(d) "Commission" means the National Medical Commission;
(e) "facultg" includes, (i) 'medical facultg" oonsisfing of Professor or Associate Professor or
Assisfant Professor hauing Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of
Surgery degree and higher qualiJications as specifted in tables A, B, C
and D of the Schedule;
(ii) "non-medical faanlty" consrsting of Professor or Associate Professor
or Assistant Professor hauing Master of Science with Dodor of
Philosophy qualifications as specrfed in regulation 11; and
(iiil "dental faailtg" consisfing of Professor or Associate Professor or
Assistant Professor hauing Bachelor of Dental Surgery and higher
qualifications as specified in regulation 2O.
19. It is pertinent to note that faculty positions are those which are
directly involved in teaching and guiding students, such as
Professors, Associate Professors, and Assistant Professors. The
PrincipeLl is designated as the Head of the Institution, who is
responsible for its overall administration, academic oversight, and
compliance with statutory requirements. While the incumbent of the
post of ?rincipal may ordinarily be drawn from the teaching cadre, the
Principril is not treated as part of the teaching faculty even for the
purposo of determining the prescribed teacher-student ratio for
recogni':ion of a medical college.
20. Further, the distinction is also borne out from the relevant
service rules. Under the Andhra Pradesh Medical Education Service
Rules, issued in G.o.Ms.No.154 dated o4.os.2oo2, the posrs are
classified under different categories. The relevant portion of the said
G.O. is extracted hereunder:
In exercise of the powers confened by tlrc prouiso to article 309
of the constitution of India and all others powers hereunto enabling, and
in supersession of the G.Os. Ist to 24 and 27 read aboue, the Gouemor
of Andhra Pradesh hereby makes the following Special Rules or th.e
Andhra Pradesh Medical Mucation Seruice.
RULES
Shott title:
These rules moy be called ttw Andhra Pradesh Medical Education
Serutce Rules.
Constitution:
Th.e Seruice in the Andhra Pradesh Medical Education Seruice shall
oonsist of the following Categories o/posfs namelA:-
Category (1): Director of Medtcal Education.
Category p): Additional Director of Medical Educatbn including
Principal of Medical College; and Superintendent of
Te aching Ge ner aI H o s pital.
Category p| (a) Special Grade Professor (Clinical)/ (non-Clinical).
(b) Superintendent of Teaching Specialist Hospital.
This above structur:al separation itself indicates that the post of
Principal is a distinct category from that of a professor. Although the
feeder category for appointment as Principal is the cadre of Professors,
upon such appointment the post assumes the character of the
administrative head of the institution.
21. Having regard to the above, the appellant, who was serving as a
Professor, was being promoted to the post of Principal, which is
essentially an administrative position. Thus, the situation is broadly
comparable to that of his co-petitioners who were promoted to the
post of Superintendent, which is also an administrative post. The
distinction sought to be drawn by the learned Single Judge between
the pos:s of Superintendent and Principal, for the purpose of denying
the benefit of Rule 1 1(b) to the appellant, does not appear to be borne
out by the scheme of the serwice rules or the regulatory framework
governing medical education
22. It is pertinent to note that the State as well as the learned
single .ludge had placed reliance on the concept of public interest to
justify t.he insistence that the appellant accept the promotional post.
However, upon careful examination, we find that such reliance does
not withstand closer scrutiny for the following reasons:
a. while considerations of public interest undoubtedly play an
inrportant role in matters of service administration, they cannot
br: invoked to override an express statutory provision, where the
ruLle-making authority has consciously provided a framework
which contemplates the consequence of an employee not joining
tl.e promoted post under Rule 11(b) of the 1996 Rules. The
e>recutive cannot negate the effect of such provision by resorting
tc a general invocation of public interest. To permit such an
approach would, in effect, amount to rewriting the rule, which is
inrpermissible. It is well settled that executive/administrative
ir:.structions cannot supplant statutory rules, a principle
rr:iterated by the Hon'ble Supreme court in sant Ram shanna.
a, state of Rajastho,n and other{, wherein it is held as under:
,, MANU/',SC
/O33O/t967
15......h is true that Gouemment cannot amend or supersede
statutory ruIes by administratiue instructions, but if the rules
are silent on anA particular point Gouernment can fill up tlw
gaps and supplement the rules and i-ssue instructions not
inconsistenf with the rules already framed.
b. The principle laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Mohind.er Singh's case (supra 1) that an administrative order
must stand or fall on the reasons contained therein, squarely
applies to the present case. Similarly, the Apex Court in State
of Himachal Prad.esh rrnd. others a. Oasys Cgbernatics
Priaate LinitedT has held as under:
31. The more appropiate ourse, in our onsidered uiew, would
haue been to adopt a two-step approach: first, to hold the
cancellation vitiated for want of reasoning; and seand, to remit
the matter to the Competent Authoitu to reansider the question
upon recordinq aoent reasons and affordino due opportunitu to
the affected bidder. Such a calibrated remedu would ltaue
preserued both the euoluinq anstitutional discipline of fair
procedure and the administratiue necessitu of efficiencu in oublic
procurement.
(emphasb supplied)
The promotion order in G.O.Rt.No.298 dated 07.O7.2025 is a
routine promotion order and does not record any reasons
indicating that acceptance of the promotion was being insisted
upon in public interest.
c. The justification relating to public interest and compliance witJ:
inspections of the NMC appears to have been raised for the lirst
time in the counter-affidavit before the Court. Such subsequent
explanations cannot ordinarily be relied upon to sustain an
7 MANU/SC lrs79/2025
ad:ainistrative action which does not disclose such reasons in
thr: order itself.
d. The Sterte's contention that the impugned action advances public
interest does not appear persuasive, particularly when the
appellant is presently supervising six postgraduate students in
thr: Department of Ophthalmologr at Gandhi Medical College,
Secunderabad, and the NMC norms mandate maintenance of
thr: prescribed faculty-student ratio.
e. Further, by promoting and relocating the appellant, the State is
not merely filling a vacancy at Mahabubabad but is
sirnultaneously creating a corresponding vacancy in the teaching
cadre at Gandhi Medical College, Secunderabad, thereby
potentially affecting postgraduate teaching and patient care at
that institution. Therefore, a balanced view of public interest
would require the State to address existing vacancies in the
te;lchirrg cadre rather than creating fresh deficiencies by
displacing senior professors from their core teaching
responsibilities.
23. It is apposite to note that the learned Single Judge granted the
very same order and relief to four petitioners who were promoted as
SuperirLtendents, the same relief was denied to the appellant who was
promot:d as.Prfncipal. As already observed, no valid distinction can
be drarun between these two posts for the purpose of applying Rule
1l(b), since both are essentially administrative posts. More
L7
importantly, in another order passed in w.p.No.2o4ag of 2o2s, the
learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition of a doctor promoted as
superintendent, holding that the state's plea of public interest in
posting him to a non-teaching post was untenable. The reasoning
adopted therein, that if the objective was to strengthen teaching
standards for regulatory inspections, the doctor ought to be retained
in a teaching post, applies with equal force to the case of the
appellant.
24- In the present case, though principle embodied in Article 14 of
the Constitution of India mandates that similarly situated persons be
treated alike, there exists no intelligible differentia between the
appellant and the other petitioners who were granted relief, nor has
the State demonstrated any rational nexus for the differential
treatment. To that extent, the impugned order results in an arbitrary
discrimination against the appellant and cannot be sustained.
25. On perusal of the record, it is evident that the appellant has
cited several instances where the State has permitted doctors to
forego promotions in the past- Orders dated 24.02.2024 and
O5.O8.2O25, permitting Assistant Professors and Associate Professors
to forego their promotions, are illustrative of such practice. Though
estoppel may not strictly operate against the State, a consistent and
settled administrative practice is indicative of the correct
interpretation of a rule in the perception of the state. Further, it gives
rx
rise to a legitimate expectation- In the absence of any convincing
explanalion for departing from such practice in the appellant's case,
the action appears arbitrary.
26. The precedents relied upon by the State and accepted by the
learned Single Judge are clearly distinguishable and inapplicable for
the follcwing reasons:
i) lrt Achal Sfngh's case (supra 21, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
dr:att with refusal of an application for voluntary retirement in
p.:blic interest, which involves cessation of service and the
ernployer-employee relationship. The present case, however,
rt:lates only to declining a promotion while continuing in
sr:rvice, a situation expressly contemplated under Rule 11(b).
The decision is therefore inapplicable.
ii) The reliance placed on M.A. I{hader Mohiuddin's case
(s;upra 4) is misplaced. The said decision arose in the context of
the judicial service, where promotions are closely tied to the
functioning of the judicial hierarchy and are governed by a
distinct constitutional and statutory framework, with
crnsiderations of institutional discipline and continuity of
jgdicial administration playing a central role- In contrast, the
present case concerns the promotion of a medical professor to
the post of Principal of a Government Medical College, which is
.',4
.r"..rii.lty an administrative position distinct from the teaching
cadre. More importantly, the governing service rules applicable
herein expressly recognise the possibility of an employee
declining promotion, subject only to the cbnsequence stipulated
under Rule 11(b). Therefore, the said decision is inapplicable to
the facts of the present case.
iiil sk. Nausad Ro,haman's case (supra 3) reiterates that an
employee has no vested right to claim a posting of choice. The
appellant is not seeking any particular posting, but merely
. exercising the statutory option not to accept a promotion. The
reliance on the said decision is therefore misplaced.
i.r) In Babo,nna Machched's case (supra 5), the issue arose under
a different statutory frame'*,ork lt here the applicable service
rules did not confer any specific option upon an employee to
decline promotion, and the observations of the court were made
in the context of the administrative requirements of that service.
ln the present case, however, the matter is expressly governed
by Rule 11(b) of the Telangana state and subordinate service
Rules, L996, which specifically permits an employee to forego
promotion by not joining the promoted post rvithin the
stipulated period, the consequence being only the forfeiture of
promotion for that panel year. Thus, the statutory scheme
governing the present case is materially different, and the ratio
of Babanna Mo,chched's case (supra 5) cannot be applied to
the facts of the present case.
27. Alter a thoughtful consideration, this Court is constrained to
observe that the learned Single Judge committed a palpable error in
denying the benefit of Rule 11(b) of the 1996 Rules to the appellantThe reasoning suffers from patent inconsistency and is without any
intelligible d"ifferentia to justify granting relief to Superintendents while
denying the same to the appellant promoted as Principal. The
invocation of "pubtic interest" by the learned single Judge is
miscon<:eived, being an impermissible post-hoc rationalization,
without any indication in the promotion order itself-
28. Our conclusion primarily rests on the legal grounds discussed
above: i) the doctrine of parity; ii) the incorrect reliance on public
interests and iii) the appellant's personal circumstances. While such
hardship b), itself may not override administrative exigencies, when
couplec, with a legal entitlement, it warrants a fair and humane
consideration by this Court in the context of the facts and
circumr;tzrnces of the present case.
Conclusion
29. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the considered
opinion that Rule tl(b) of the 1996 Rules, permits an employee to
decline a promotional post by not joining within the prescribed time,
the consequence being forfeiture of the promotion for the relevant
panel 1'ear that the State cannot compel the appellant to accept the
promotion j6ntrary to the statutory scheme. We further f-rnd that the
2t
post of Principal of a Government Medical College is essentially an
administrative position distinct from the teaching cadre of Professors,
and the learned Single Judge erred in treating it as a faculty/teaching
post for the purpose of denying the benefirt of the Rule 11(b) of 1996
Rules.
30. Accordingly, the Writ Appeal is allowed. The order dated
26.09.2025 passed in W.P.No .2OLIL of 2025 by the learned Single
Judge is set aside insofar as it relates to the appellant. Consequently,
it is declared that the appellant is entitled to forego the promotion in
terms of Rule 11(b) of the Telangana State and Subordinate Service
Rules, 1996. The G.O.Rt.No.298, Health, Medical and Family Welfare
(A) Department, dated O7.O7.2O25, is set aside to the extent it
promotes and posts the appellant as Principal, Government Medical
College, Mahabubabad.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any, stand
closed. No costs.
SD/. K.SRIN
JOINT
//TRUE COPYII
t
SECTION OFFICER
One fair copy to the HON'BLE CHIEF JUSTICE CHALLA
: (For His Lordship's Kind
KUMAR SINGH
AND
One fair copy to the HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
(For His Lordship's Kind Perusal)
To
1. The Principal Secretary, Health, lvledical and Family Welfare Department,
Secretariat, Saifabad, State of Telangana at Hyderabad.
2. The Director of fi/edical Education, Government of Telangana, Koti,
Hyderabad.
3. The Principal, Gandhi Medical College/ Gandhi Hospital, Secunderabad.
4. The Principal, GlVlH, Hanumakonda.
5. The Principal, MGIvI/KMC, Warangal.
6. 11 L.R. Copies.
7. The Under Secretary, Union of lndia, tMinistry of Law, Justice and Company
Affairs. New Delhi.
G,,r
\
8. The secretary, Telangana Advocates Association Library, High court
Buildings, Hyderabad.
9. Two OCs to GP FOR SERVICES- l, High Court for the State of Telangana at
Hyderabad. [OUT]
10.One CC to SRI SRIN|VAS BOBB|L|, Advocate [OpUC]
11.Two CD Copies
SA
TKS
tu,
l\--.
I
HIGH COURT
DATED i1710312026
I
E S}A
o
u
JUDGMENT
-k
T
WA.No.'1192 of 2025
ALLOWING THE W.A
WITHOT'T COSTS.
2a
&
l,]
0 B APil 2026
7-rt
rf+fzc
{:t'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review