The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. Rules and Regulations are made for regulating governance and social behaviour. One should look at the purpose of the rules while implementing/executing the same. In this case, the Government of Kerala, Department of Health Sciences has framed Rules enabling Government servants joining duty to take long leave for pursuing higher education. It is as per the provisions of Appendix XIIB Part I KSR that the petitioner has been granted leave by the Government of Kerala to pursue higher education. As long as there is no express 2025:KER:26532 : 12 : prohibition for taking up such employment without affecting the quality of DNB training, there is no reason why the petitioner's training should be terminated prematurely. The 2 nd respondent should take an informed decision in the matter, taking note of the Rules of the Government of Kerala as also the willingness of the 5th respondent-College. In the circumstances of the case, the writ petition is disposed of directing that if the petitioner makes an application for ex post facto sanction to join Kerala Medical Service along with a consent / No Objection Certificate of the 5th respondent -College, within a period of two weeks, the 2nd respondent shall consider the same and take appropriate decision thereon, taking note of the observations made hereinabove, within a further period of two weeks. Sd/N. NAGARESH, JUDGE aks/26.03.2025 2025:KE…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:26532
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.NAGARESH
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 7TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 8713 OF 2024
PETITIONER:
DR. GAYATRI.G.J.
AGED 33 YEARS
S.R. VIEW, PRA – 149,
KAMALESWARAM, MANACAUD.P.O.
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695009
BY ADVS.
TONY GEORGE KANNANTHANAM
N.MAHESH
THOMAS GEORGE
BIBIN B. THOMAS
RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
MINISTRY OF HEALTH & FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT,
NEW DELHI – 110001, PIN - 110001
THE NATIONAL BOARD OF EXAMINATIONS IN MEDICAL SCIENCES
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR,
MAHATMA GANDHI MARG (RING ROAD),
ANSARI NAGAR, NEW DELHI, PIN - 110299
STATE OF KERALA
REP. BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT,
SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
:2:
THE DIRECTOR OF HEALTH SERVICES
PALAYAM – AIRPORT ROAD,
NEAR GENERAL HOSPITAL ROAD,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695035
ARAVIND EYE HOSPITAL
S.N.HIGH ROAD, TIRUNELVELI JUNCTION,
TAMIL NADU, REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR,
PIN - 627001
BY ADV SHRI.T.SANJAY, SC, NATIONAL BOARD OF
EXAMINATIONS IN MEDICAL SCIENCES (NBEMS)
SRI. PREMCHAND R NAIR, SR. GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR
ADMISSION ON 25.03.2025, THE COURT ON 28.03.2025 DELIVERED
THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
:3:
N. NAGARESH, J.
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
W.P.(C) No.8713 of 2024
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
Dated this the 28th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
~~~~~~~~~
The petitioner, who is a Medical Postgraduate
undergoing her DNB Program at the 5th respondent-College,
seeks to quash Exts.P9 and P11 and to direct the 2 nd
respondent-National
Board
of
Examinations
in
Medical
Sciences (NBEMS) to permit the petitioner to complete the DNB
Course which she has been undergoing under the 5 th
respondent-College.
2.
The petitioner completed MBBS Course from
the Government Medical College, Kalamassery in 2015. The
petitioner also
completed
her Postgraduate Diploma
in
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
:4:
Ophthalmology in the year 2011 from Sree Gokulam Medical
College, Thiruvananthapuram.
3.
In the year 2017, the Kerala Public Service
Commission (PSC) invited applications for appointment to the
post of Assistant Surgeon in the Kerala Medical Services. The
petitioner was ranked at Serial No.125 in the PSC ranklist.
While so, the National Board of Examinations in Medical
Sciences (NBEMS) invited applications for
admission to
Postgraduate Diploma Courses (DNB). Selection to the DNB
Courses is on All India basis.
Entrance test for DNB was
conducted in September, 2021. The petitioner was selected for
DNB (Ophthalmology) Course in February, 2022. The petitioner
was to complete the Course by February, 2024.
As the
petitioner took maternity leave for about five months, her DNB
Course stood extended upto August, 2024.
4.
In July, 2023, the PSC advised the petitioner
for recruitment as Assistant Surgeon as per Ext.P1 advice
memo dated 24.07.2023.
The petitioner appeared for the
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
:5:
counselling and the petitioner was appointed as Assistant
Surgeon under the DMO, Kasaragod as per Ext.P4.
The
petitioner took casual leave for four days from the 5 th
respondent-College and reported for joining at Kasaragod on
04.10.023.
The petitioner was allotted to Family Healthcare
Centre (FHC), Manakkad. On the very same day, the petitioner
was relieved from duty enabling the petitioner to continue in the
5th respondent-College for finishing her DNB Program.
The
petitioner resumed her duty in the 5th respondent-College.
5.
The petitioner was served with Ext.P7 show-
cause notice alleging that the petitioner accepted a Government
job and availed leave without permission and rejoined the DNB
training thereafter. Ext.P7 stated that there is no provision to
seek employment while undergoing DNB training.
The
petitioner states that Ext.P7 is unsustainable as the petitioner
had taken leave with permission, in order to join the job. The
petitioner submitted Ext.P8 explanation to Ext.P7 notice. The
2nd respondent, however, rejected the explanation given by the
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
:6:
petitioner and cancelled the petitioner's registration for DNB.
Ext.P9 stated that an NBEMS trainee is not permitted “to seek
and join” any employment while in training. The DNB training is
a full time residency program and taking up Government job is
not permitted.
6.
The
petitioner
submitted
Ext.P10
representation requesting to reconsider the matter. The request
was rejected as per Ext.P11 order. The petitioner states that
she has not violated any norms or principles of residency
program. She had not deserted the course nor was on long
leave.
The petitioner did not work even for a day in the
Government service. The employment of the petitioner is only
notional. Therefore, Exts.P9 and P11 are liable to be quashed.
7.
The 2nd respondent resisted the writ petition
filing counter affidavit. The 2nd respondent submitted that DNB
training is a full time residency program wherein the trainee and
the institute are in an employee-employer relation for which the
trainee is paid a stipend by the institution for the services
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
:7:
offered. The 2nd respondent-NBEMS has no rule that allows a
trainee to take up employment while undergoing DNB training.
8.
The petitioner informed the National Board that
she has got a posting at Kasaragod District through the PSC.
The National Board sought clarification from the petitioner. The
petitioner sent Ext.R2(c) reply. The petitioner has abandoned
the course midway to take up Government employment without
obtaining permission from the NBEMS.
9.
judgment
The Hon’ble Apex Court has held in the
in
Kerala
Solvent
Extractions
Limited
v.
Unnikrishnan [(2006) 13 SCC 619] that relief by the Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India should not tend to
degenerate into misplaced sympathy, generosity and private
benevolence. The 2nd respondent further submitted that the writ
petition is not maintainable as no part of the cause of action has
taken place within the territorial limits of Kerala. The petitioner
is not entitled to any relief.
to be dismissed.
The writ petition is therefore liable
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
:8:
10.
I have heard the learned counsel for the
petitioner and the learned Standing Counsel representing the
2nd respondent.
I have also heard the learned Senior
Government Pleader representing respondents 3 and 4.
11.
as regards maintainability of the writ petition, I
find that the petitioner's registration for DNB Course stands
cancelled for her joining employment in Kasaragod District in
Kerala. Part of the cause of action has taken place in Kerala
and therefore the writ petition is maintainable.
12.
Ext.P2 proceedings dated 14.08.2023 would
indicate that the petitioner was advised for appointment to the
post of Assistant Surgeon. The petitioner was undergoing the
DNB Course when Ext.P2 advice was made. The petitioner
took casual leave for four days from the 5th respondent-College
and joined duty. The petitioner immediately took leave from the
Family Health Centre and resumed the DNB training before the
expiry of casual leave.
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
:9:
13.
Ext.P2 proceedings of the Director of Health
Services provides that in case of a candidate pursuing higher
studies and willing to seek extension of joining time, their case
will be considered as per the Government Orders.
Ext.P2
further states that in case of candidates pursuing higher studies
and require extension of joining time beyond six months, they
should join duty at the posted station and avail leave without
allowance further for the requisite period to complete the course
in accordance with the provisions laid down in Appendix XIIB
Part I KSR.
It is therefore evident that the rules of the
Government of Kerala permits Government servants to pursue
higher studies taking leave without allowance.
14.
The counsel for the 2nd respondent would,
however, submit that the DNB Training is a full time residential
program wherein the trainee and the institute are
in an
employee-employer relation for which the trainee is paid a
stipend by the institution for the services offered at the
institution while taking training.
The 2 nd respondent-NBMES
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
: 10 :
has no rule that allows a trainee to take up an employment
while undergoing DNB training. The petitioner has not taken
any permission before joining a job while she is already on the
rolls of the institute for a paid training program.
15.
It is stated in the counter affidavit filed by the
NBEMS that the Board has no rule that allows a trainee to take
up an employment while undergoing DNB training. No rule has
been brought to the notice of the Court either, prohibiting joining
of employment while undergoing DNB training, without causing
any hindrance to the DNB Training Program. The contention of
the 2nd respondent is that the trainee and the institute are in an
employee-employer relation for which the trainee is paid a
stipend by the institution for the services offered at the
institution while taking training.
Therefore, the employee-
employer relation being between the trainee and the institute, it
is for the institute to grant or decline permission to the petitioner
to join a Government employment during the period of training.
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
: 11 :
16.
The pleadings in the counter affidavit would
indicate that the 5th respondent-College has no serious
objection in allowing the petitioner to join the Kerala Medical
Service, without causing any interruption to the Training
Program. The petitioner has taken long leave from the Kerala
Medical Service in order to complete the DNB training.
Knowing that the petitioner is joining the Kerala Medical
Service, the 5th respondent has granted casual leave to the
petitioner to join the Kerala Medical Service.
17.
Rules and Regulations are made for regulating
governance and social behaviour.
One should look at the
purpose of the rules while implementing/executing the same. In
this case, the Government of Kerala, Department of Health
Sciences has framed Rules enabling Government servants
joining duty to take long leave for pursuing higher education. It
is as per the provisions of Appendix XIIB Part I KSR that the
petitioner has been granted leave by the Government of Kerala
to pursue higher education. As long as there is no express
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
: 12 :
prohibition for taking up such employment without affecting the
quality of DNB training, there is no reason why the petitioner's
training should be terminated prematurely. The 2 nd respondent
should take an informed decision in the matter, taking note of
the Rules of the Government of Kerala as also the willingness
of the 5th respondent-College.
In the circumstances of the case, the writ
petition is disposed of directing that if the petitioner makes an
application for ex post facto sanction to join Kerala Medical
Service along with a consent / No Objection Certificate of the 5th
respondent -College, within a period of two weeks,
the 2nd
respondent shall consider the same and take appropriate
decision thereon, taking note of the observations made
hereinabove, within a further period of two weeks.
Sd/N. NAGARESH, JUDGE
aks/26.03.2025
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
: 13 :
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 8713/2024
PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
Exhibit-P1
TRUE COPY OF THE ADVICE MEMO
(3)12257/13/GW DATED 24-7-2023
NO.RIE
Exhibit-P2
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
NO.DHS/15655/2023- EA3 DATED 14-8-2023
Exhibit-P3
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
15655/2023/DHS DATED 7-9-2023
Exhibit-P4
COPY OF THE ORDER NO.EA3-15655/2023/DHS
DATED 27-9-2023
Exhibit-P5
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
NO.DMOHKSD/23/2023-A1 DATED 4-10-2023 BY THE
DMO KASARGOD
Exhibit-P6
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. 308/2023
DATED 4-10-2023 OF THE MEDICAL OFFICER,
PHARMACY HEALTH CENTRE, MOUCODE.
Exhibit-P7
TRUE COPY OF THE SHOW CAUSE
DATED 6-1-2024 BY THE PETITIONER
Exhibit -P8
TRUE COPY OF THE DRAFT EXPLANATION,
DATED NIL. BY THE PETITIONER
Exhibit-P9
TRTUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.NBEMS/
DOTM/C&R/31007/12101543/2122101414
DATED 30-1-2024
Exhibit -P10
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED
NIL. SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
Exhibit-P11
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
DOTM/C&R/23101543/
DATED 1-3-2024
NO.EA3-
NOTICE
ORDER
NO.NBEMS/
2122101414/43845
2025:KER:26532
W.P.(C) No.8713/2024
: 14 :
RESPONDENT'S EXHIBITS
Exhibit R2 (b)
Communication
10.10.2023
webportal
Exhibit R2 (d)
Reply to show cause issued.06.01.2024
Exhibit R2 (c)
Re seeking clarification-05.11.2023
Exhibit R2 (e)
Reply for board-07.012024
Exhibit R2 (a)
Communication
3.10.2023
webportal
of
of
NBE-
NBE-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review