Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 33031
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO
RIMINAL PETITI
NO: 8510 OF 20
Between:
Dr. G. Satya Sheela Reddy, S/o. G. Bheem Reddy, aged about 68 years, Occ.
Homeopathic Doctor, Rl/o. 1-7-147, Police Lines, New Gunj Road, Mahabubnagar
Town and District.
...Petitioner/Accused
AND
. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Public Prosecutor, High Court of Telangana.
2. Mr. Dr.'Dhandem Lalaiah Kumar, Registrar, Telangana State Medical Council,
Having its office at P.B. 523, Sulthan Bazar, Hyderabad.
...Respondents/Complainant
Petition under section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in the
Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to quash
the proceedings against the petitioner herein in c.c. No. 212 o1 2026 on the file of lll
Additional Junior Civil Judge Court Cum Judicial Magistrate, First Class Court at
Mahabubnagar for the offences under section 318 and 319 BNS and Section 22 of
TMPR Act, 1968 and 34 RA,V Section 54 of NMC Act, 2019.
l.A. NO: I OF 2026
Petition under section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in the
Memorandum of Grounds of criminal Petition, the High court may be pleased to stay of
all further proceedings including the appearance of the petitioner herein in c.c. No. 212
of 2026 on the file of lll Additional Junior civil Judge court cum Judicial Magistrate,
First class court at Mahabubnagar for the offences under section 318 & 319 BNS and
Section 22 of TMPR Act, 1968 and Section 34 R^^/ Section 54 of NMC Act, 2019
pending disposal of the present Criminal Petition.
=!!TrtE!!E!E!7
This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Memorandum of Grounds of
Criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of Sri P Rajagopal Reddy, Advocate
for the Petitioner and Sri Jithender Rao Veeramalla, Additional Public Prosecutor on
behalf of Respondent No.1 and of Sri Sama Sandeeep Reddy (SC for TSMC), Advocate
for the Respondent No.2.
The Court made the following: ORDER
FOR
AT HYDERABAD
or
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J.SREENIVAS RAO
ilt
Datez t7.O6.2O26
Between:
Dr. G.Satya Sheela Reddy
...
Petitioner/ Accused
AND
The State of Telangana and another
...Respondents
ORDER
This criminal petition has been filed seeking to quash the
proceedings in C.C. No.212 of 2026 on the file of the III Additional
Junior Civil Judge's Court-cum-Judicial Magistrate of First C]ass Court
at Mahabubnagar, wherein the petitioner was arrayed as accused, for
the offences punishable under Sections 318 and 319 of the Bharatiya
Nyaya sanhita, 2023 (for short 'the BNS), section 22 of the Telangana
Medical Practitioners Registration Act, 196g (for short the TMpR Act,)
and Section 34 rlw 54 of the National Medicar commission Act, 2oLg
(for short the NMC Act).
2.
Heard Mr. P.Rajagopal Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioner,
and Mr' Jithendar Rao Veeramalla, learned Additionat Public prosecutor
for respondent Nos.1 and 2.
{l
J
I
I
3.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel for
submitted that thc issue raised in this criminal
covered by the order passed by this Court in
the petitioner
petition is squarely
Crl'P' No'9903 of 2025 '
dated 29 .lO .2025.
4.
Learned Additional Public Prosecutor has not
submissions made by the learned counsel for
5.
opposed the
petitioner'
Taking into consideration the peculiar facts and
well as the submissions made by the respective
circumstances as
parties and in view of
2025' dated
the order passed by this Court in Crl'P' No'9903 of
view that continuation of
29.10.2025, this Court is of the considered
the proceedings against the petitioner is a clear
abuse of the process of
law.
6.
Accordingly, the criminal petition is allowed and
the proceedings
Junior Civil
in C.C. No.212 of 2026 on the file of the III Additional
Court at
Judge's Court-cum-Judicial Magistrate of First Class
Mahabubnagar, against the petitioner/ accused are
hereby quashed'
Pending miscellaneous applications' if any' shall
stand closed'
SD/- N.CHANDRA SEKHAR RAO
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
CTION OFFICER
To,
.1. The lll Additional Junior civil Judge court cum Judicial Magistrate, First class
Court at Mahabubnagar
2. The Station House Officer, Devarakadra Police Station, Mahabubnagar
3. One CC to Sri P Rajagopal Reddy, Advocate [OPUC]
4. One CC to Sri Sama Sandeeep Reddy (SC for TSMC)' Advocate [OPUC]
5. Two CCs to PUBLIC PROSECUTOR High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad [OUT]
6. Two CD CoPies
ADK/KA
Alongwithacopyoforderdated2g.|o.2o25incrlp.No.9903of2025
/
x
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1710612026
ORDER
CRLP.No.8510 of 2026
I
4'r
I ti e STAIE
(
f,
o
o
2 5 JUN
C,
t
'l( r, -.
ALLOWING THE CRLP
@
a,tlL lau.
,^, j,
THE HON'BLE SMT, JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEV! EADA
CRIMINAL PETITION N o .9903 0F 2025
SDEE:
This Criminal Petition is filed by the petitioner-accused seeking
to quash the proceedings in Crime No.489 of 2O25 on the file of P.S.
Patancheru, Sangareddy District, registered for the offences under
Sections 318(4) and 319(2) of The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita' 2023
(for short 'BNS"), Section 20(ii) read wilh 22 of Telangana Medical
Practitioners Registration (for short 'TMPR') Act,1968 and Section
34 read with 54 of National Medical Commission Act, 2019 (for short
'NMCA',).
2.
The case of the prosecution is that the petitioner is a
registered Homeopathy Medical Practitioner vide Registration
No.305/H/2017. lt is alleged that the petitioner is practicing
Allopathy medicine, though he is qualified in BHMS and that the said
act of practicing allopathy medicine attracts the offences under
Sections 41 9 and 420 ol IPC and Section 15(2) of the lndian Medical
Council Act.
3.
Heard the submissions of Sri T. Srujan Kumar Reddy' learned
counsel for the petitioner, Sri Sama Sandeep Reddy' learned
Standing Counsel for TMC for respondent No.2 and Sri Jithender
ETD,J
Crlp.No.9903_2025
Rao Veeramalla, learned Additional Public Prosecutor for
respondent No.1 - State
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the
allegations faced by the petitioner are that though he is a qualified
Doctor in Homeopathy, he is prescribing the medicines under
Allopathy. He referred to the order, dated 02.09.2025, of the Co-
ordinate Bench in Criminal Petition No.7668 of 2025 and Batch,
wherein the Co-ordinate Bench has quashed the proceedings
against the petitioners therein.
5.
The learned Standing Counsel for TMC has argued that a
person who is qualified in Homeopahty, cannot prescribe the
medicines under Allopathy and that it is a clear violation of the
regulations and is punishable for the offences under Sections 318(4)
and 319(2) of BNS, Section 20(ii) read wilh 22 of the TMPR Act and
Section 34 read with 54 of the NMCA. He therefore, prayed to
dismiss the petition.
6.
Perused the record
7.
Since the offences alleged are under Sections 318(4) and
319(2) of BNS, Section 20(ii) read with 22 of TMPR Act and Section
-
ETD,J
Crlp.No.9903 2025
34 read with 54 of NMCA, the said Sections of are pertinent to be
refened in this context-
Sections 318(4) and 319(2) of BNS:
"318. Cheating
-
(1 ) xxx
(2) xxx
(3) xxx
(4) Whoever cheats and thereby dishonestly induces
the person deceived to deliver any property to any
person, or to make, alter or destroy the whole or any
part of a valuable security, or anything which is
signed or sealed, and which is capable of being
converted into a valuable security, shall be punished
with imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to seven years, and shall also be
liable to fine.
319. Ch
by personation
-
(1 ) xxx.
(2) Whoever cheats by personation shall be punished
with imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to five years, or with fine, or with
both."
Section 20(ii) and 22 of TMPR Act:
"20. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in any
other law for the time being in force,(i)
xxx
(ii)
no person other than a registered practitioner
shall, with effect from such date as may be
specified by the Government by notification in
this behalf, practice the modern scientific
medicine or hold himself out, whether directly or
by implication as practicing or as being prepared
to so practice;
ETD,J
Crlp.No.9903 2025
22. Whoever contravenes the provisions of clause(ii)
of Section 20 shall be punishable on first conviction
with imprisonment which may extend to three months or
with fine which may extend to five hundred rupees or
with both, and on any subsequent, conviction with
imprisonment which may extend to six months or with
fine which may extend to one thousand rupees or with
both."
Sections 34 and 54 of NMGA:
"34. Bar to practice - (1) No person other than a
person who is enrolled in the State Registrar or the
-
National Register, as the case may be, shall
(a) be allowed to practice medicine as a qualified
medical practitioner;
(b) hold office as a physician or surgeon or any
other office, by whatever name called, which is
meant to be held by a physician or surgeon;
(c) be entitled to sign or authenticate a medical or
fitness certificate or any other certificate
required by any law to be signed or
authenticated by a duly qualified medical
practitioner;
(d) be entitled to give evidence at any inquest or in
any court of law as an expert under section 45
ofthe lndian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872) on
any matter relating to medicine:
Provided that the Commission shall submit a list of such
medical professionals to the Central Government in
such manner as may be prescribed:
Provided further that a foreign citizen who is enrolled in
his country as a medical practitioner in accordance with
the law regulating the registration
medical
practitioners
that country may be permitted
temporary registration in lndia for such period and in
such manner as may be specified by the regulations.
in
of
(2) Any person who contravenes any of the provisions
of this section shall be punished with imprisonment for
a term which may extend to one year, or with fine which
may extend to five lakh rupees or with both.
f,
ETD;J
Crlp.No.9903_2025
nizance of offences - No court shall take
cognizance of an offence punishable under this Act
except upon a complaint in writing made in this be half
by an officer authorized by the Commission or the
Ethics and Medical Registration Board or a State
Medical Council, as the case may be."
8.
Thus, under the NMCA and the TMPR Act, no person shall
practice the modern medicine unless he is registered under the Act
forthe said purpose.
9.
The petitioner counsel has placed heavy reliance on the
judgment of the Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in Dr'
Mukhtiar Chand and Others Vs. Sfafe of Puniab and Othersl ,
wherein it was held in paragraph Nos.47 and 49 that;
(47):- A harmonious reading of Section 15 of the 1956
Act and Section 17 of the 1970 Act leads to the conclusion
that there is no scope for a person enrolled on the State
Register of lndian Medicine u the Central Register of lndian
Medicine to practice modern scientific medicine in any of its
branches unless that person is also enrolled on a Sfate
Medical Register within the meaning of the 1956 Act.
(49):- The upshot of the above dlscussion is that Rule
2(ee) (iil as effected from 14.05.1960 is valid and does not
suffer lrom the vice of want of legislative competence and
the notifications rissued by the State Governments
thereunder are not ultra vires the said Rule and are legal.
However, after sub-section (2) in Section 1 5 of the 1956 Act
occupied the field vide Central Act 24 of 1964 with effect
from 16.06.1964, the benefit of the said Rule and the
notifications issued thereunder would be available only
in those States where the privilege of such right to
practice any system of medicine is conferred by the
State Law under which practitioners of lndian medicine
qfz)
in the State, which is for the time being
in force. The position with regard to medical practitioners of
tndian medicine holding degrees in integrated courses is on
I (1998) ? Supreme court cases 579
ETD,J
Crlp.No.9903 2025
the same plane inasmuch as if any Stafe Act recognizes
their qualification as sufficient for registration in the State
Medical Register, the prohibition contained in Section
15(2)(b) of the 1956 Act will not apply.
10. Therefore, even according to the decision of the Constitution
Bench, a person qualified in a stream of medicine i.e., homeopathy
cannot prescribe medicines pertaining to another stream unless it is
conferred by a State Law which is in force. ln Telangana State, the
Telangana Medical Practitioners Registration Act is in force as
discussed above. ln simplest of terms, a person who is practicing
homeopathy medicine cannot prescribe medicines under Allopathy.
11. ln the present case the petitioner is alleged to have been
registered practitioner for Homeopathy, however he has been found
to be prescribing allopathy medicines as per the averments in the
complaint. Hence, there is a prima-facie case made out against the
petitioner and the investigation is still in progress.
12. The contention of the petitioner counsel is that the prosecution
needs to be launched by the Commissioner of Ayush and that the
present case is registered when the complaint is lodged by the
Registrar of the Telangana Medical Council, which is not tenable in
the eye of law and that there is a clear violation of Rule-8(7) of the
Andhra Pradesh Medical Council (Compulsory Rural Medical
Service and Compulsory Government Service_Renewal of
ETD,J
Crlp.No.9903_2025
-7
Registration, visiting or inspecting the Hospital or Nursing Home or
lnstitution) Rules, 2013 (for short, Ihe Rules') issued vide
G.O.Ms.No.129, dated 08.08.2013, where the de-facto complainant
failed to follow the procedure contemplated in Rule-8(7) of the Rules,
which is as under:'Whenever the Commissioner, AYUSH is in receipt of
information from the Council that a Medical Practitioner of
Ayurueda Siddha, Unani, Homeopathy and Yoga or
Naturopathy is found practicing Modern Medicine or
prescribing drugs of Modern Medicine, he shall initiate
appropriate action against such practitioner in terms of
Government Memo.No.9914/L2/97-1, dated 17.03.1997
appended to fhose rules as annexurell. The
Commissioner, AYUSH shall initiate appropriate action
within thirty days on receipt of such information from the
Council and intimate the action taken thereon to the
Council."
13. A bare perusal of Rule 8(7) of the Rules discloses that the
Ayush Commissioner shall initiate appropriate action against such
practitioner in terms of G.O. M.S. N o.891 4l L2197 -1, dated 17 .03.1997 .
The G.O.Ms.No.8914/12197-1, dated 17.03.1997, is a Circular
Memorandum issued by the Government of Andhra Pradesh, Health,
Medical and Family Welfare (L) Department which reads as follows:-
1. lt is to inform that the Supreme Court of lndia has given
a decision in the case cited above prohibiting the Medical
Practitioners from practicing and presaibing drugs in other
system of medicine in which they are not registered.
2. lt implies that a Medical Practitioner who is registered
under Allopathic system of medicine is prohibited from
practicing and prescribing drugs in other systems of
medicine like Ayurveda, Homeopathy, Unani etc.,
ETD,J
Crlp.No.9903_2025
3. Similarly, the Medical Practitioners in Homeopathy,
Ayurveda, and Unani etc., should confine their practice only
to the sysfems of medicine in which they are registered and
should not practice and prescribe drugs in any other system
of medicine in which they are not registered.
4. Thus, the sale of Allopathic drugs to the Medical
Practitioners who are not registered in the Allopathic system
of medicine is an offence under the provisions of Drugs and
Cosmefics AcL Similarly, sale of Allopathic drugs to a
patient on the prescription of a Medical Practitioner who is
not registered in the Allopathic system of medicine is a/so
an offence under the provisions of Drugs and Cosmetics
Act.
5. Likewise, drugs belonging to other systems of medicine
like Ayurveda, Unani Homeopathy etc., should not be sold
either to the Medical Practitioners or to the patients on the
prescriptions of Medical Practitioners who are not registered
in the respective sysferns of medicines.
14. Thus it is mentioned in the above said Circular that the person
who is practicing homeopathy cannot prescribe medicines in any
other system in which they are not registered. lt is pertinent to take
note of Rule-8(1) to (10) of the Rules in its entirety which is extracted
for the sake of reference:Rule-8(1) The Chairman of the Council may constitute
one or more Committees each consisting of two or
three members.
(2) The Committee or Committees so
constituted sha pertorm the following functions,
namely;
(a) lnquire suomoto or on a petition presented to the
Chairman.
(b) Visit or inspect, either by giving a notice or
surprisingly, any hospital or Nursing home or
institution or places where unethical practices are
alleged to be in vogue.
(c) Visit or inspect either any hospita! or nursing home
or institution or place wherc un-qualffied persons or
-
ETD,J
Crlp.No.9903_2025
quacks or doctors who do not belong to Modern System
Scientific Medicine but are practicing modern
modern
medicine and are prescribing drugs
medicine.
(d) Visit or inspect any hospital or nursing home or
institution or place where the medical practitioners
whose names were removed ftom the register are
alleged to be continuing to practice without sunendering
the certiftcate of registration without sufficient cause.
of
of
(3) Wenever information, is received that a Medical
Practitioner has been indulged in unethical practices
which are unbecoming on the part of any Medical
Practitioner, the Registrar shall make an abstract of
such information.
@) Any act of the Medical Practitioner shall be
construed as unethical, when he or she has indulged in
any act which is included in chapter 6 of lndian Medical
Council (Professional Conduct, etiquette and ethics)
Regulations-2lO2 or any act which in the opinion of the
Council is unbecoming on the part of a practitioner or
mod ern scientif ic m ed icine.
(5) Where the information in question relating to
practice of Modem Scientific Medicine or prescribing
drugs of modern medicine by a qualified practitioner of
other systems of medicine, such as Ayuruedic,
Homeopathy, Unani, Naturopathy or Sidda, the
Registrar shall make an abstract of such information.
(6) The abstract and where a complaint has been
lodged, the complaint and all other documents bearing
on the case shall be submifted by the Registrar to the
Chairman, who may ff thinks ft, instruct the Registrar to
furnish the institution concerned with a copy of the
complaint and other documents and invite the head of
such institution by means of a registered letter to submit
any explanation he may have to offer within a period of
ten clear working days.
(7) Whenever the Commissioner, AYUSH is in receipt
of infqmation from the Council that a Medical
Practitioner of Ayurveda, Siddha, Unani, Homeopathy
and Yoga or naturopaw is found practicing Modern
Medicine or presuibing drugs of Modern Medicine, he
shall initiate appropriate action against such practitioner
in terms of Govemment Memo.No.891tl/L2J97-1 , dated
17.03.1997 appended to those rules as annexure-ll.
The Commissioner, AYUSH shall initiate appropriate
action within thiry days on receipt of such information
l0
ETD,J
Crlp.No.9903_2025
from the Council and intimate the action taken thereon
to the Council.
(8) Whenever any information is received or evidence
is brought before any Committee constituted by the
Council under caluse (iv) of Section 20 of the Act that
drugs of Modern Medicine are dispensed by Druggists
or Chemlsfs on the prescription of practitioners of other
systems of medicine, the Council on receipt of such
report from the Committee shall communicate he same
to the Drug lnspector or Assistanf Director of Drug
Control Administration with
request
take
appropriate action on the Druggist
Chemist
concerned as per the provisions of Drugs and
Cosmetics Act, 1940 and the Rules made thereunder. lf
the council come to the conclusion that no action has
been initiated by the Drugs lnspector or fhe Assistant
Director, Drug Control Administration within a period of
thirty days, the Chairman of the Council may instruct the
Registrar to furnish the details to Director General,
Drugs Control Administration with a copy of information
received in this respect or copy of complaint and other
documents and request him
issue necessary
instructions to the Drug lnspector or Assistant Dhector
concerned.
a
or
to
to
(9) Where, in any clinic or hospital or nursing home or
other institution or place where un-qualified persons or
quacks are found practicing modern system or Scientiftc
Medicine or prescribing drugs of modern medicine,
criminal proceedings will be initiated by making a
complaint to the Station House Officer concerned as per
Section 22 of the Act.
(10) Where it is found that the Station House Officer
has not acted upon the complaint-petition of the
Council, the Chairman, APMC who may thinks fit,
instruct the Registrar to furnish the information together
with other documents on record to the Superintendent
of Police of the District Concerned or the Sub-Divisional
Police Officer with a request to instruct the Station
House Officer
initiate appropriate action in
accordance with the Law.
to
15. A conjoint perusal of Rule-8(9) and (10) of the Rules would
reveal that the Registrar is authorized to lodge a complaint as per
Section 22 of the TMPR Act. Therefore, in the present case, the
-
ETD,J
Crlp.No.9903 2025
complaint is lodged by the Registrar of Telangana Medical Council,
which is very much inconsonance with Sub-Rules 9 and 10 of Rule-8
of the Rules.
16. But, under Section 54 of NMCA, no Court shall take
cognizance of an offence except upon a complaint in writing by an
officer authorized by the Commission or the Ethics and Medical
Registration Board or a State Medical Council. Thus, it has to be a
complaint made in writing and the word 'complaint' is defined under
Section 2(d) of Cr.P.C., which reads as follows:
"2. Definitions
-
(a) xxx
(b) xxx
(c) xxx
(d) "Complaint" means any allegation made orally or
in writing to a Magistrate, with a view to his taking
action under this Code, that some person, whether
known or unknown, has committed an offence, but
does not include a police report."
17. Therefore, a complaint in writing has to be lodged before the
competent Court by the authorized officer and it does not include a
police officer. ln the present case, the complaint is filed before the
Station House Officer by the Registrar of the State Medical Council.
Under Section 54 of the NMCA, an officer authorized by the State
Medical Council can file the complaint. Thus, there is nothing wrong
if the Registrar files the complaint, but the said complaint has to be
t2
ETD,J
Crlp.No.9903_2025
made to the concerned Court and not before the Station House
Officer. Therefore, there is a lapse in the procedure adopted by the
concerned authority and the said lapse would affect the case in such
a way that cognizance of the offence cannot be taken by the Court.
18. As discussed supra, Sub-Rules 8,9 and 10 of Rule 8 of the
Rules empowers the Registrar to initiate the criminal proceedings by
making a complaint to the Station House Officer and when the
Station House Officer does not act upon the same, he shall furnish
the information along with other documents to the Superintendent of
Police to instruct the Station House Officer to initiate appropriate
action. As per Section 54 of the NMCA, an authorized person under
the Commission or the Ethics and Medical Registration Board or the
State Medical Council can initiate the proceedings. Thus, the
Registrar is competent to initiate the proceedings i.e., he can file a
complaint, but it has to be made in writing before the concerned
Court.
19. ln the present case, the Registrar has filed the complaint
before the Station House Officer. Hence, no Court can take
cognizance of the said complaint. Therefore, continuation of
proceedings in the present case against the petitioner is abuse of
process of law.
ETD,J
Crlp.No.9903_2025
20. Therefore, the proceedings in Crime No.489 of 2025 on the file
of P.S. Patancheru, Sangareddy District, are hereby quashed
against the petitioner herein. However, it is made clear that the
authorized officer is at liberty to initiate criminal proceedings strictly
in accordance with law i.e., in accordance with Section 54 of the
NMCA.
. Accordingly, the Criminal Petition is disposed of.
Miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVI EADA
Dale:29.10.2025
Ds/MD
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review