Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung,
S/o Shri Kamal Kr. Gurung,
R/o House No.68,
Opposite SMIT Main Gate,
Majithar, East Sikkim.
….. Petitioner
Versus
1.
State of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
Health Care, Human Service & Family Welfare
Department,
Through the Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
…..Respondents
Application under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, 1950
(For quashing the impugned Office Memorandum No.1236/H & FW dated
08.12.2021 issued by the Director General cum Secretary, Health & Family Welfare
Department, Government of Sikkim.)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
Mr. Tashi Rapten Barfungpa, Mr. Hem Lall Manger,
Ms. Parvin Manger and Ms. Tshering Laki, Advocates
for the Petitioner.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Additional Advocate General, Mr.
Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate and Mr.
Sujan Sunwar, Assistant Government Advocate and
Ms. Neera Thapa, Advocate, for the Respondents.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
24.06.2022
O R D E R (ORAL)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
Vide Office Order No.1171/G/DOP dated 19.03.2021
the petitioner was appointed as General Duty Medical
Officer (GDMO) in the Junior Grade under General Duty &
Public Health Wing of Sikkim State Health Service, Health
and Family Welfare Department.
2.
On 23.02.2021 the National Board of Examinations
New Delhi inviting applications for National Eligibility cum
Entrance Test (NEET-PG 2021. It transpires that the
petitioner submitted the application online through the
National Board of Examinations website. The examination
was to be held on 18.04.2021 which was however
postponed till further orders. On 13.07.2021 notice was
issued by the National Board of Examinations
informing
that NEET-PG 2021 was rescheduled to be held on 11th
September 2021.
3.
On 08.09.2021 No Objection Certificate (NOC) was
issued bearing No.4589/H & FW stating inter alia: “The
Department of Health & Family Welfare, Government of
Sikkim has no objection to the following doctors (GDMOs) to
appear for the National Eligibility Entrance Examination
(NEET-PG
2021)
scheduled
on
11.09.2021
tentatively
(subject to postponement as per COVID-19 pandemic
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
situation)”. 23 doctors had been allowed to sit for NEET-PG
2021 including the petitioner. The NOC also specified that
the Department’s permission is subject to allotment of
seats in clinical subjects by the Institute as per the present
need in the State. It specified that the nomination shall be
within the sponsorship and was further subject to the
approval of the State Government. It also stated that the
NOC issued earlier for the entrance examination scheduled
on 18th April, 2021 stood cancelled.
4.
This document reflects that the Department of Health
& Family Welfare had clearly given its NOC to the petitioner
along with 22 others who were GDMOs of the State
Government to sit for the NEET-PG 2021 subject to the
condition prescribed therein.
5.
The
NEET-PG
11.09.2021
and
the
Examination
result
declared
was
on
held
on
28.09.2021.
The petitioner scored 408 out of 800 and obtained the rank
of 42677.
6.
On
09.11.2021
the
Additional
Director
(Medical
Education) Health & Family Welfare Department issued a
communication bearing No.4870/H & FW to the Medical
Superintendent, STNM Hospital and the Chief Medical
Officers of the District Hospitals at Gyalshing, Mangan,
Namchi and Singtam. It stated that the specified Post
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
Graduate Degree seats were allotted at Regional Institute of
Medical Sciences, Imphal (RIMS) for the beneficiary State of
Sikkim for the academic session 2021-2022. It specified
that the allotment of seats in Pathology, Mircrobiology,
Biochemistry,
etc.
was
subject
to
Departmental
undertaking. It also specified that the eligibility criteria for
admission laid down by the National Medical Commission
would be applicable; the nomination would be made in
accordance with the existing norms for allotment of Post
Graduate Degree Seats as the Departmental in-service
candidate; the application of willing candidates should
reach the
office of the
Additional Director, Medical
Education, Health Secretariat on or before 17th November,
2021. It further specified that the date of counselling would
be intimated as and when announced by RIMS, Imphal.
7.
By this communication the Health & Family Welfare
Department sought for nominations from the Medical
Superintendent as well as the Chief Medical Officers of all
four districts for allotment of Post Graduate Degree seats
from
Departmental
in-service
candidates
along
with
application of willing candidates. Similar communication
was made on the same date vide communication No.
4871/H&FW
for
nomination
of
candidates
for
Post
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
Graduate Degree Course in Sikkim Manipal Institute of
Medical Sciences (SMIMS).
8.
On 11.11.2021, pursuant to this information, the
petitioner
wrote
to
the
Additional
Director,
Medical
Education seeking his nomination for the post of Post
Graduate Degree Course in SMIMS and RIMS as per the
communication bearing reference Nos.4870 and 4871
dated 09.11.2021. It also specified that he had qualified in
the NEET-PG 2021 held on 11.09.2021.
9.
It is at this juncture that the Health & Family Welfare
Department
issued
No.1236/H&FW
dated
Office
Memorandum
08.12.2021
(impugned
bearing
office
memorandum) prescribing the eligibility criteria to undergo
higher medical courses (DNB/ MD/ MS/ Postdoctoral/
Diploma) amongst the NEET qualified candidates under the
State Quota Sponsored Category (Post Graduate Seat
allotted to the beneficiaries State) in clinical/non clinical
subjects, at any institute/college recognised by National
Medical Commission.
10. On 27.12.2021 the petitioner sent his representation
to the Director General–cum-Secretary, Health & Family
Welfare
Department
against
the
impugned
office
memorandum stating inter alia that the NEET-PG 2021
examination was supposed to be held in the month of
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
January
18.04.2021
due
which
to
was
the
however,
pandemic.
rescheduled
That
after
to
being
rescheduled for number of times, the NEET-PG 2021 was
finally conducted on 11.09.2021 and result declared on
28.09.2021. That the counselling process was scheduled to
begin on 25.10.2021 which was put on hold by the Central
Government due to the petition filed in the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India, with regard to Economically
Weaker Section Reservation in NEET. That on 08.09.2021
NOC was issued to 23 GDMOs for appearing in NEET-PG
2021. Those NEET-PG qualified candidates were invited for
Post Graduation Degree Course in RIMS and SMIMS vide
communication Nos.4870 and 4871 dated 09.11.2021
respectively. It was pleaded that the introduction of the new
eligibility criteria at the last moment was extremely
discouraging and demoralizing after serving the State in
difficult times during both the waves of COVID and
preparing for the exam in extreme conditions during the
pandemic.
11. On
10.01.2022
the
communication
from
the
Directorate General of Health Services (DGHS) New Delhi to
the Secretary National Medical Commission announced the
counselling dates as 20.01.2022 to 24.01.2022. At this
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
stage the petitioner approached this court challenging the
eligibility criteria in the impugned office memorandum.
12. The respondent nos. 1 and 2 (the respondents) have
filed their counter affidavit contesting the writ petition. The
fact that the petitioner had been appointed by the
respondents is not disputed. The fact that the petitioner
along with 22 others were granted no objection certificate
to appear in the NEET-PG 2021 is also not disputed. The
respondents have sought to provide this court with the
rationale and the object for issuance of the impugned office
memorandum. It is submitted that it was issued to
encourage graduate doctors to render service in rural areas
in Primary Health Centers and Community Health Centers.
It is submitted that the object is to strengthen the health
care facilities in the rural areas by incentivizing the
postings of graduate doctors in rural areas which is a
permissible classification. It is contested that the petitioner
do not qualify the eligibility criteria as he is still under the
probation period of one year and permitting the petitioner
under the State quota sponsored category would be unjust
and
unfair
to
other
government
doctors
who
have
completed three years of service.
13. The petitioner as well as the respondents filed
additional affidavits along with additional documents.
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
Although opportunity was granted, the facts stated therein
and
documents
annexed
thereto
are
not
contested.
Opportunity was also granted to the respondents to contest
the additional facts and documents appearing in the
rejoinder.
However,
the
learned
Additional
Advocate
General submitted that the writ petition may be decided on
the basis of the pleadings and documents already placed on
record by the parties.
14. In the additional affidavit filed by the respondents on
20.06.2022 the Sikkim State Health Service (Amendment)
Rules, 2001 (Amendment Rules, 2001) was annexed. The
learned Additional Advocate General submitted a perusal of
schedule II thereof would reflect that the eligibility criteria
for selection of candidates for undergoing in-service
training for post graduation degree were more rigid than
the impugned office memorandum.
15. In the additional affidavit filed by the petitioner along
with the various documents annexed therein the list of
candidates who had cleared NEET-PG 2021 and applied for
Post Graduate seats at RIMS and SMIMS for academic
session 2021-2022 under the signature of various officers
of the Health & Family Welfare Department is also annexed
which reflects the name of the petitioner at serial number 3
therein.
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
16. A perusal of the Amendment Rules, 2001 reflects that
selection of candidates for undergoing in-service training
for post graduation was to be made on the basis of
seniority-cum-merit. The candidates were required to be
deputed for the post graduate studies as per actual
requirement/need of department. The upper age limit was
45 years. The candidate should have served in the rural
areas for at least 3 years prior to be considered for post
graduation studies.
17. If the respondents had followed the Amendment
Rules, 2001 then they would not have issued the NOC to
the DGMOs who did not fulfil the eligibility criteria as was
done in the present case. None of the communications
placed before this court concerning the nominations
reflects the application of the Amendment Rules, 2001
including the impugned office memorandum. At this stage
the learned Additional Advocate General on a query from
the court, on instructions received, states that the
Amendment Rules, 2001 may not have been followed after
2016.
18.
In the rejoinder filed by the petitioner as well as the
additional affidavit the petitioner states that consequent to
the NOC granted on 08.09.2021 other similarly situated
candidates had also been nominated by the respondent
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
nos. 1 and 2. The learned Additional Advocate General
submits that all these nominations were done as per the
impugned office memorandum.
19. On 19.01.2022 on hearing the learned counsel for the
parties and considering the fact that NOC had been issued
to the petitioner on 08.09.2021 pursuant to which he had
appeared for NEET-PG 2021 and cleared it but still he was
not being permitted to sit for the counselling scheduled on
20.01.2022 solely on the ground that the subsequent
impugned
office
memorandum
dated
08.12.2021
prescribed eligibility criteria which had not been fulfilled by
the petitioner this court thought it fit to permit the
petitioner to appear for the counselling as per law subject
to the final outcome of the writ petition. This court was of
the prima facie view that not permitting the petitioner to sit
for the counselling would gravely prejudice him and cause
him irreparable harm.
After the passing of the interim
order the petitioner appeared for the counselling and
secured a seat for M.S. (General Surgery) at RIMS. It is not
the case of the respondents that the impugned office
memorandum was made effective retrospectively. Therefore,
the impugned memorandum could have come into effect
only after it would be notified.
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
20. At the hearing the learned Additional Advocate
General stated, on instructions, that between 2010 and
2018 there has been no appointment of DGMOs. However,
in the year 2018 and 2019 there were appointments.
21. It is quite evident that the respondent nos. 1 and 2
had issued the impugned office memorandum in ignorance
of the Amendment Rules, 2001. Admittedly in spite of the
Amendment Rules, 2001 the petitioner as well as others
similarly
placed
had
been
nominated
as
in-service
candidates for post graduate courses. The NOC granted to
the petitioner as well as other communications reflects the
clear intent of the respondents to permit the petitioner as
well as others to apply for the seats as in-service
candidates.
If
the
respondents
were
aware
of
the
Amendment Rules, 2001 at the relevant time there was no
need to issue the impugned office memorandum. If the
respondents sought to further amend the Sikkim State
Health Service Rules, 1993 it could have been done by yet
another amendment and not by the impugned office
memorandum.
22. Quite evidently the petitioner laboured to prepare and
succeed in the NEET-PG 2021 on the strength of the NOC.
The respondents while granting the NOC were fully aware
of the fact that the petitioner was a serving doctor who had
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
not done 3 years of service in the rural areas. The
communication No. 4870 dated 09.11.2021 reflects that
the application of the petitioners had been in fact sought
for.
23. Keeping in mind all the above facts the learned
Additional Advocate General fairly submits that at this
stage it would not be wise on the part of the respondents to
contest this writ petition further. More so because the
petitioner who is an in-service candidate would acquire a
post graduation degree which would further benefit the
State. It is his categorical submission that even if the writ
petitioner was not successful the seat which has been
allotted to him would go waste since the admission process
is already over. It is submitted that it would be better to
examine the Amendment Rules, 2001 as well as the
impugned office memorandum and come out with a clear
policy which is not only legal but also in sync with the
States duties as a welfare State.
24. Considering the facts and circumstances of this case
as well as the stand taken by the respondents the writ
petition is disposed confirming the interim order dated
19.01.2022 passed by this court. Pending application is
disposed off as well.
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2022
Dr. Deoraj Gurung vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
25.
It is made clear that this order has been passed in
the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case and
therefore, it shall not be taken as a precedent.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting
Internet
to/
: No
: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review