Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SYED
ROSHAN
ZAMIR
ALI
Digitally signed
by SYED
ROSHAN
ZAMIR ALI
Date:
2026.01.21
19:42:20 +0530
2026:CGHC:3729
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Order reserved on 14.1.2026
Order delivered on 21.1.2026
WPS No. 11278 of 2025
1. Dr. Deepak Kumar Jaiswal S/o Chandrika Prasad Aged About
32 Years R/o Latori, Surajpur, Distt. Surajpur, Pin 497001,
Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioner
versus
1. State of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of
Agriculture, Mahanadi Bhawan, Mantralaya, Capital Complex
Naya Raipur, Atal Nagar, Distt. Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2. Indira
Gandhi
Chancellor,
Krishi
Krishak
Vishvavidyala
Nagar,
Through
Raipur,
Its
Distt.
Vice
Raipur,
Chhattisgarh, 492012.
3. Screening Committee Constituted For The Recruitment Of
Assistant
Professor
Vishvavidyalaya,
(Agronomy),
Krishak
Nagar,
Indira
Gandhi
Krishi
Raipur,
Distt.
Raipur,
Chhattisgarh, 492012
4. The Registrar Indira Gandhi Krishi Vishvavidyalaya, Krishak
Nagar, Raipur, Distt. Raipur, Chhattisgarh 492012
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner
: Mr. Ravi Singh and Mr. Benoon, Advocates for
petitioner
For Respondent No.1
: Ms. Anuja Sharma, Dy. Govt. Advocate
For Respondent No.2 to 4 : Mr. Sangharsh Pandey, Advocate
SB: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Parth Prateem Sahu
C A V Order
1. Petitioner has preferred this writ petition seeking following
reliefs:“10.1. The Hon’ble Court may kindly be pleased to
direct the respondent authorities to consider
the Ph.D. degree of the petitioner and award
the deserving marks to the petitioner in lieu
of the same.
10.2. The Hon’ble Court may kindly be pleased to
quash the impugned Score-Card dated
28/08/2025
issued
committee
of
by
Indira
the
screening
Gandhi
Krishi
Vishvavidyalaya, Krishak Nagar, Raipur, C.G.
wherein, marks of Ph.D. degree are not
awarded to the petitioner.
10.3. The Hon’ble Court may kindly be pleased to
further direct the respondent authority to grant
any other relief which this Hon’ble Court deems
fit and proper in favour of the petitioner as per the
facts & circumstance of the present case, in the
ends of justice.”
10.4. Cost of the petition.”
2. Facts relevant for disposal of this case, in brief, are that
pursuant to advertisement dated 04.10.2023 issued by
respondent No.2 inviting applications from eligible candidates
for appointment on different vacancies as advertised,
petitioner submitted an application for his appointment on the
post of Assistant Professor (Agronomy). After scrutiny of
application form submitted, the qualified candidates were
issued
score-sheet
on
28.8.2025
based
on
their
certificates/degrees of the qualification. After going through
the score-sheet, petitioner came to know that he has not been
awarded any marks for his qualification of Ph.D. Aggrieved
with which petitioner has filed this writ petition.
3. Learned counsel for petitioner would submit that petitioner
has completed Ph.D. Course much earlier in the year 2018
and provisional certificate in this regard was issued on
13.7.2023. Along with application form, petitioner submitted
certificate of Ph.D. Course Work Examination-2018 in which
it is clearly mentioned that petitioner has successfully
completed the Ph.D. course work which was published on
24.3.2019. Petitioner has secured 7.98 GPA. In Ph.D. Course
Work Examination 2018 of Vishwa Bharti Institute, calculation
of marks is also provided under the head of clarification of
results. Petitioner submitted these documents along with
application
form
for his
appointment
in response
to
advertisement subject matter of petition. He contended that
as per Clause 18 of the General Conditions of advertisement,
applicants are to fill online application form carefully.
Applicants can submit all documents as mentioned therein i.e.
certificates, degrees, mark-sheets/ transcripts in support of
academic qualification and experience. Petitioner uploaded
Ph.D. Course Work Examination certificate which provides
award of marks by the Institute wherefrom petitioner pursued
Ph.D. course and obtained said qualification. Said document
was essential for authorities to award marks accordingly
based on assessment of marks as made therein. Non-award
of marks under Column of Ph.D. to petitioner in score-card is
highly arbitrary. Even if the degree is not uploaded along with
application form, the petitioner can submit relevant document
at the time of verification of documents, which was obtained
by petitioner in the year 2018 and therefore, respondents
No.2 to 4 be directed to consider Provisions Degree
Certificate (PDC) of Ph.D. and certificate of fulfillment of five
conditions of Ph.D. award issued by the Registrar, Vishwa
Bharti Institute in the month of July 2023. In support of his
submissions, he placed reliance on decision in case of
Charles K Skaria and others vs. Dr. C. Mathew and
others, reported in (1980) 2 SCC 752; Dolly Chandra Vs.
Chairman, JEE and others, reported in (2005) 9 SCC 779;
Ram Kumar Gijroya vs Delhi Subordinate Services
Section Board and another, reported in (2016) 4 SCC 754;
and Food Corporation of India vs Rimjhim, reported in
(2019) 5 SCC 793.
4. Learned counsel for respondent No.2 to 4 vehemently
opposed submissions of learned counsel for petitioner and
submitted that a candidate who applied for any post
advertised has to submit/upload all relevant documents along
with application form as per clauses/conditions enumerated in
the advertisement. In advertisement, there is specific clause
under the general conditions i.e. Clause 17, which clearly
mentions that applications not uploaded with copies of
certificate, degrees, mark-sheets / transcripts in support of
academic qualification and experience shall be rejected.
Application of petitioner was considered because he was
otherwise eligible as he has cleared NET exam and filed
document in this regard and also awarded marks on having
NET qualifiation. Referring to Clause 18 of General
Conditions of advertisement, it is submitted that applications
without uploading proper certificates/ mark-sheet/ transcripts /
documents/reprints will not be scored. He contended that
above two clauses forming part of general conditions of
advertisement, clearly envisage that uploading of copies of
documents in support of academic qualification is mandatory
and application without documents in support of academic
qualification, will not be scored. When petitioner submitted
application with open eyes reading general conditions, then
he may not be permitted to take advantage of his own wrong.
He also contended that in email forwarded by the petitioner
dated 15.3.2025 (Annexure P-5), petitioner has admitted that
he has not attached transcript of Ph.D. degree or Provisional
Degree Certificate
(PDC) and certificate fulfilling five
conditions for the award of Ph.D. along with application form.
He has also mentioned in this email that Ph.D. course as per
criteria prescribed by University Grant Commission (UGC)
was successfully completed by him on 12.7.2023.
The
contents of email of petitioner clearly show that petitioner
failed to fulfill general conditions which are specifically
provided
in
the
advertisement
and
therefore,
after
participating in recruitment process, petitioner cannot claim
that he should be awarded marks based on document which
was not uploaded/attached along with application form.
5. Heard learned counsel for respective parties and perused the
documents available in record of writ petition.
6. Advertisement (Annexure P-2) was published on 04.10.2023.
As per advertisement, qualification for appointment on the
post of Assistant Professor in Agriculture Colleges, candidate
must have possessed Master’s degree and cleared the
National Eligibility Test (NET) along with one publication in
National Academy of Agriculture Sciences, New Delhi (NAAS)
rated referred journal. It further provides that essentiality of
NET can be waived off for the candidates holding Ph.D.
degree provided it has been done with course work as
prescribed by the UGC Regulations 2009 and candidates
have atleast two full-length publications having a NAAS rating
not less than four on the date of submission of application.
Candidates with Ph.D. degree without course work will not
qualify for NET exemption.
7. Along with writ petition, petitioner has annexed print out of his
application form for the post of Assistant Professor (Regular)
Academic Level 10 as Annexure P-3. Perusal of Annexure P3 would show that though in the column of ‘educational
qualification / examination passed’, petitioner has given
details of Ph.D. in online application form as also of NET,
however,
as
admitted
by
petitioner,
he
has
not
uploaded/attached PDC and certifiate on fulfillment of five
conditions of PhD award which are essential according to the
qualification enumerated in advertisement. No document was
uploaded in support of Clause-A (3) of advertisement except
the PhD course work examination result. As per attachment
details mentioned by petitioner, he has only attached
certificate of class 10th, CG domicile certificate; caste
certificate and non-creamy layer certificate for OBC.
8. Petitioner submitted copy of email dated 15.3.2025 as
Annexure P-5 to writ petition. A glance of this email would
show that it is in the form of claim objection against screening
report for agronomy. Relevant portion of email is extracted
below for ready reference:“Remark 1: Dcotoral Degree (PhD degree rejected)
I would like to clarify that I did not attach the
transcript of my PhD degree.
However, my PhD
Course Work Examination-2018 certificate should not
be confused with my PG transcript. The Course Work
Examination-2018 certificate was uploaded only to
justify my OGPA and the result was published on
24/03/2019.
I have successfully completed my PhD degree as
per the criteria prescribed by UGC on 12 th July 2023.
Please find attached my Provisional Degree Certificate
(PDC) and the certificate fulfilling the five conditions for
the award of the PhD degree as required.”
9. Perusal of above extracted portion of Annexure P-5 would
show that petitioner clearly mentioned that he did not attach
transcript of Ph.D. degree; only course work examination
2018 certificate was uploaded to justify OGPA. Course work
result was published on 24.3.2019. Provisional Degree
Certificate is attached with email and not with form.
10. Perusal of documents, as mentioned by petitioner in
aforementioned email, Annexure P-5, i.e. Ph.D. Course Work
Examination, 2018 certificate, would show that with regard to
said examination, result was published on 24.3.2019.
However, provisional certificate enclosed along with writ
petition issued by Vishwa Bharti would show that petitioner
has qualified for the decree of doctorate in Philosophy on
12.7.2023 on presentation of a thesis on ‘Weed Management
in dry seeded rice under different tillage practices and its
residual effect on succeeding yellow sarson” under the
Department of Agronomy. Prior to 12.7.2023, petitioner was
not having qualification of degree of Ph.D.
11. Course work as mentioned in the advertisement under
‘essential’ head for Assistant Professor in Agriculture
Colleges, it is mentioned as Ph.D. without course work will
not qualify NET exemption. From which it is clear that course
work is part of essential qualification for getting exemption of
NET which may be part of Ph.D. but the date of result of
course work will in itself would not be treated as Ph.D.
completed. From the say of petitioner and document
submitted, PDC (Provisional Degree Certificate) was issued
only in the year 2023 and the certificate fulfilling five
conditions for the award of Ph.D. was also issued later.
Therefore, even otherwise the document stated to be issued
on 24.3.2019, which is in the form of publication of course
work result mentioning GPA, will not amount to fulfillment of
requirements
clearly
specified
advertisement
under
Clause
and
mentioned
and
of
in
the
General
Conditions. In the letter (Annexure P-12) written by petitioner
to respondent No.2, he further admitted that he has not
submitted/uploaded PDC (Provisional Degree Certificate) and
certificate of fulfilling five conditions of Ph.D. award. From the
contents it is clear that the essential document(s) for award of
marks for Ph.D. qualification was not submitted.
12. In the above facts of the case, it cannot be said that
respondents have committed error in any manner in not
awarding marks for Ph.D. qualification to petitioner.
13.
In case of Bedanga Talukdar vs Saifudaullah Khan and
others, reported in (2011) 12 SCC 85, Hon’ble Supreme
Court has observed thus:“30. A perusal of the advertisement in this case will
clearly show that there was no power of relaxation. In
our opinion, the High Court committed an error in
directing that the condition with regard to the
submission of the disability certificate either along with
the application form or before appearing in the
preliminary examination could be relaxed in the case
of respondent No. 1. Such a course would not be
permissible as it would violate the mandate of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
32.In the face of such conclusions, we have little
hesitation in concluding that the conclusion recorded
by the High Court is contrary to the facts and materials
on the record. It is settled law that there can be no
relaxation in the terms and conditions contained in the
advertisement unless the power of relaxation is duly
reserved
in
the
relevant
rules
and/or
in
the
advertisement. Even if there is a power of relaxation in
the rules, the same would still have to be specifically
indicated in the advertisement. In the present case, no
such rule has been brought to our notice. In such
circumstances, the High Court could not have issued
the impugned direction to consider the claim of
respondent No.1 on the basis of identity card
submitted after the selection process was over, with
the publication of the select list.”
14. The subject matter in issue is recruitment on the post of
Assistant Professor and appointment on the said post is to be
made on the basis of merit. In the era of competition for
getting
employment,
more
particularly
in
government
institutions, there is throat-cut competition. A candidate could
not able to succeed by difference of even 0.001 mark in
aggregate at the time of assessment of merit. Therefore,
claim of petitioner is to be considered keeping in mind above
aspect.
15. In the case at hand, claim of petitioner is that he has not been
awarded marks for his qualification of Ph.D. In advertisement
under general conditions in Clause 17 it is clearly mentioned
that “application not uploaded with copies of certificates,
degrees, mark sheets / transcript in support of academic
educational and experience shall be rejected.
Thus, it is
apparent that, uploading of certificates. Degrees, mark-sheet/
transcripts along with application form was made mandatory
in proof of the fact that candidate is having requisite
qualification and consequence of not uploading the same is
also mentioned therein.
16. If petitioner’s score sheet, filed as Annexure P-1, is perused in
the light of aforementioned specific clause contained in
general conditions of the advertisement in question, it is clear
that petitioner was awarded marks for uploading mark sheets
of 10+2, graduation, post-graduate and NET. From this, it
can be culled out that, petitioner has been awarded marks
against the documents which he uploaded along with his
application form, except for certificate or transcript of Ph.D,
which was not uploaded.
17. Clause 18 of the General Condition of the advertisement
clearly mentions that application without uploading certificate,
mark-sheet/ transcripts / documents/ reprints will not be
scored. In this clause, the employer has clearly mentioned
that certificate, mark-sheet/transcripts / documents not
uploaded will not be scored.
When employer has
categorically and specifically mentioned the importance of
documents,
the
petitioner,
who
is
claiming
to
have
qualification of Post-graduation, Ph.D., has not uploaded
relevant documents with regard to Ph.D. along with his
application but for other certificates.
18. Under the scheme of selection, as is reflecting from the
advertisement and the procedure adopted, merit of a
candidate at first stage is to be considered based on the
marks to be awarded for all essential qualification, as
mentioned in advertisement. Required qualifications are
mentioned under the “essentials”.
Due to non-award of
marks for Ph.D., petitioner may have secured less marks than
many of other candidates/aspirants, who were competing for
getting appointment on the post of Assistant Professor
(Agronomy).
19. In case of Bedanga Talukdar (supra), Hon’ble Supreme
Court has observed thus;
“29. We have considered the entire matter in detail. In our
opinion, it is too well settled to need any further reiteration
that all appointments to public offices have to be made in
conformity with Article 14 of the Constitution of India. In
other words, there must be no arbitrariness resulting from
any undue favour being given to any candidate.
Therefore, the selection process has to be conducted strictly
in accordance with stipulated selection procedure as
specifically mentioned in general conditions clause of
advertisement.
20. Petitioner in his email dated 15.3.2025 admitted that he did
not attach transcript of Ph.D. degree and only uploaded along
with email, Provisional Degree Certificate (PDC) and
certificate fulfilling five conditions for award of Ph.D. Degree,
as required.
In letter dated 4.9.2025 (Annexure P-12),
petitioner admitted that he did not upload PDC and certificate
of fulfillment of five conditions of Ph.D. award. In the
aforementioned facts of case and admission of petitioner, it is
not in dispute that petitioner failed to upload essentials for
award of marks, which is first stage for assessing merit and
preparing merit list. After starting of process and completion
of part of selection process, petitioner cannot be permitted to
add something to his application form requesting for awarding
more marks on that, prejudicing the right of other candidates
who got higher marks in score sheet. According to admission
of petitioner, he uploaded course work exam certificate in
proof of Ph.D.. Merely obtaining Ph.D. course work exam
certificate itself is not complete document of Ph.D. As
mentioned in Ph.D., there may be Ph.D. of two modes, one is
plain Ph.D. and another with course work. After submitting all
relevant documents, before awarding Ph.D., a student has to
appear for viva-voce.
It is also one state of assessment
before degree of Ph.D. is awarded. Course work examination
certificate from its appearance is clear that result of which
was published on 24.3.2019, as mentioned therein whereas
certificate fulfilling five conditions for award of Ph.D. Degree
and PDC (Provisional Degree Certificate) was issued in 2023
and therefore, the course certificate cannot be considered as
Ph.D. degree/transcript for Provisional Degree Certificate. In
the above circumstances, submission of learned counsel for
petitioner that he has completed Ph.D. course in 2018-19 is
not acceptable and is contrary to documents.
21. In case of Charles K Sakariya (supra), which is relied upon
by
learned
counsel
for
petitioner,
the
question
for
consideration was with regard to admission for postgraduation degree in University. In case of Dolly Chandra
(supra) also, the issue of admission in college was involved.
In case of Rimjhim (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court after
taking note of facts and circumstances of that case,
considering advertisement published therein observed that it
is not specifically stating requirement of producing experience
certificate along with application and therefore, ruled in favour
of the respondent therein.
Hence, the cases relied upon by
the petitioner are of no help to him being distinguishable on
facts.
22. For the foregoing discussions, I do not find any merit in this
petition and accordingly it is dismissed.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
roshan/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review