Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 46 of 2016
1.
Dr. C.P. Rai,
Son of Late Bhim Bahadur Rai,
Veterinary Officer,
Department of Animal Husbandry, Livestock,
Fisheries and Veterinary Services,
Government of Sikkim,
Hee Gyathang, Dzongu.
2.
Mrs. Keshari Rai,
Wife of Mr. Kishore Pradhan,
Lower Divisional Clerk (LDC),
Water Security & PHE Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Namchi, South Sikkim.
3.
Mr. Ganesh Chandra Dahal,
Son of Late Bhuwani Prasad Dahal,
Post Graduate Teacher,
Rhenock Secondary School,
East Sikkim.
4.
Mr. Roshan Kumar Pradhan,
Son of Late Shyam Pradhan,
Primary Teacher (Under Suspension)
Government Primary School,
Under HRDD Department,
Sakyong, North Sikkim.
5.
Mr. Mohan Subba,
Son of Chandra Singh Subba,
Primary Teacher (Language),
Tekpur Secondary School,
Government of Sikkim,
West Sikkim.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
6.
Mr. Dilip Tamang,
Son of Late Sriman Tamang,
Police Inspector,
Vigilance Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
7.
Mr. Mani Kumar Tamang,
Son of Late Nima Singh Tamang,
Meter Reader,
Energy & Power Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Soreng, West Sikkim.
8.
Mr. Sonam Bhutia,
Son of Dugo Bhutia,
Junior Accountant,
Building & Housing Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Namchi, South Sikkim.
9.
Mr. Kunzang Sherpa,
Son of Late Wangchuk Sherpa,
Primary Teacher,
Pureytar Primary School,
West Sikkim,
Under HRDD Department,
Government of Sikkim.
10.
Mr. Am Bahadur Rai,
Son of Shri Damber Bdr. Rai,
Primary Teacher,
Boomtar Primary School,
Namchi, South Sikkim,
Under HRDD Department,
Government of Sikkim.
11.
Mr. Lobsang Tamang,
Son of Late Dorjee Tamang,
Range Officer,
Fisheries Directorate Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Mangan, North Sikkim.
12.
Mr. Tek Bahadur Mukhia,
Son of Late Dhan Bdr. Mukhia,
LDC, District Collectorate,
Namchi, South Sikkim,
Under Land Revenue & D.M. Department.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
13.
Mr. Attal Singh Tamang,
Son of Kalue Singh Tamang,
Primary Teacher,
Barakhelay Dara Primary School,
Barakhelay Dara, West Sikkim,
Under HRDD Department,
Government of Sikkim.
14.
Dr. Subash Tamang,
Son of Shri K.D. Tamang,
Medical Officer,
Health Care, Human Services and Family
Welfare Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Jorethang, South Sikkim.
15.
Mr. Pem Norbu Bhutia,
Son of Late Rinchen Lama,
Primary Teacher,
Nandugaon Secondary School,
South Sikkim.
16.
Mr. Harka Raj Subba,
Son of Late Ramsher Subba,
Language Teacher,
Sinkuthang Junior High School,
Rumbuk, Sombaria,
West Sikkim
Under HRDD Department,
Government of Sikkim.
17.
Mrs. Bhumika Rai,
Wife of Shri Dawa Tshering Bhutia,
Primary Teacher,
Nandugaon Secondary School,
Jorethanbg, South Sikkim,
Under HRDD Department,
Government of Sikkim.
18.
Mr. K. S. Subba,
Son of Shri Sanchaman Subba,
Primary Teacher (Limboo),
Aho Kisan Jr. High School,
Government of Sikkim,
Ranipool, East Sikkim.
versus
… Petitioners.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
1.
State of Sikkim,
Represented by and through
the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Tashiling Secretariat,
P.O. Tashiling Secretariat,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
Department of Personnnel,
Administrative Reforms & Training,
Represented by and through
the Secretary, Government of Sikkim,
Tashiling Secretariat,
P.O. Tashiling Secretariat,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
3.
The Inquiring Authority,
Shri R.K. Purkayastha,
Service through Department of Law,
and P.A. Department,
Tashiling Secretariat,
P.O. Tashiling Secretariat,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
4.
The Secretary,
Department of Animal Husbandry, Livestock,
Fishery and Veterinary Services Department,
Government of Sikkim,
P.O. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
5.
The Secretary,
Water Secuirty & Physical Health
Engineering Department,
Government of Sikkim,
P.O. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
6.
The Secretary,
Human Resource Development Department,
Government of Sikkim,
P.O. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
7.
Vigilance Department,
Represented by and through
Director General of Police,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
8.
The Secretary,
Energy & Power Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
9.
The Secretary,
Buildings & Housing Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
10.
The Secretary,
Fisheries Directorate Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
11.
The Secretary,
Land Revenue & D.M. Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
12.
The Secretary,
Health Care, Human Services and
Family Welfare Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
… Respondents.
------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. A. Moulik, Sr. Advocate with Ms. K.D. Bhutia
and Mr. Ranjit Prasad, Advocates for the
Petitioners.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, Addl. Advocate General with
Mr. S.K. Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai, Asstt. Govt.
Advocates for State-Respondents.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
JUDGMENT
(18.07.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
Assailing the correctness and legality of the Final
Report dated 21st November 2015 holding the petitioners guilty
of the charges and the consequential order dated 11 th July 2016,
whereby the punishment of reduction of three annual increments
to the lower stage in the time scale of pay for a period of three
years with cumulative effect was imposed, the instant petition is
filed.
The
petitioners,
stated
to
be
working
on
regular
establishment of different departments under the Government in
various capacities, were served with memorandum of chargesheet on 04th February, 2010 alleging that the petitioners have
participated in a programme organized by political leaders at
Rolu, South Sikkim on 21st December 2009 and as such the same
was violative of provisions of Rule 3(i) (c) of the Sikkim
Government
Servants
(Conduct)
referred to as “the Conduct Rules”).
their
replies
separately
on
Rules,
(hereinafter
The petitioners submitted
19.02.2010
(Annexure
P-21),
30.03.2016 (Annexure P-22), 20.02.2010 (Annexure P-23),
08.09.2010 (Annexure P-24), 19.03.2016 (Annexure P-25),
10.03.2016 (Annexure P-26), 26.02.2010 (Annexure P-27),
18.02.2010 (Annexure P-28), 03.03.2010 (Annexure P-29),
25.02.2010 (Annexure P-30), 24.02.2010 (Annexure P-31),
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
20.02.2010 (Annexure P-32), 03.03.2010 (Annexure P-33),
dated nil (Annexure P-34), 12.03.2016 (Annexure
P-35),
dated nil (Annexure P-36), 26.02.2016 (Annexure P-37) and
20.02.2016 (Annexure P-38) respectively.
The third respondent
was appointed as the Enquiry Officer and recorded the deposition
of all the petitioners.
Considering the deposition, held the
petitioners as guilty on the basis that “there is an admission in
his deposition of having met political personalities (MLA, Shri P.S.
Golay) who was present at the political gathering, it is amply
clear that the Charged Official came there to meet him and
therefore, by implication despite his denial it has been proved by
his own admission that he met the political personalities,”
supported by an intelligence report.
The appointing authority,
accepting the Enquiry Report, imposed penalty, as aforestated,
by impugned order dated 11th July 2016.
2.
Mr. Moulik, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
petitioners submits that the petitioners have been held guilty of
misconduct of being unbecoming of a Government servant
without proving the allegation of charge. It is further submitted
that the petitioners have not admitted any misconduct of having
participated in a political meeting knowingly with intention. It is
further contended that the petitioners have been there as had
gone for a picnic on a holiday, when they noticed that there was
a meeting, some of the leaders were known to them and as such
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
they met them.
political
The petitioners were not aware that there was a
gathering/meeting.
Their
presence
was
neither
intentional nor was there any active participation in the meeting.
They are not a member of any political party.
The Enquiry
Officer had held the petitioners guilty after long about five years
without examining the allegation made against them. Rule 6 of
the Conduct Rules prohibits taking part in politics and election.
Note 3 appended to the aforestated Rule clearly provides that
attendance at meetings organized by a political party would be
construed as contravening if all the three conditions, stated
therein, are satisfied, namely, the meeting was a public meeting
and not in any sense a private or restricted meeting; the meeting
was not held contrary to any prohibitory order or without
permission where permission was needed and the Government
servant in question does not himself speak at, or take active or
prominent part in organizing or conducting the meeting. Even if
the petitioners have participated unknowingly, there is no proof
that the petitioners had either spoken in the meeting or taken
active part in organizing and conducting the meeting.
In such
view of the matter, it was wrongly held that the petitioners have
taken part in political meeting which is unbecoming of a
Government servant under Rule 3 (i) (c) of the Conduct Rules.
3.
Mr. Moulik would further contend that the Enquiry
Officer has held the petitioners guilty on the basis of alleged
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
admission which was never done without examining the relevant
witnesses on a conjuncture, stating therein that there was an
intelligence report which was neither referred to nor examined
and a copy of the same was also not furnished to the petitioners
affording
an
opportunity
petitioners guilty.
of
hearing,
before
holding
the
Mr. Moulik would also contend that the
respondent-authorities had adopted pick and choose policy.
Certain government employees, namely, Man Bahadur Tamang,
Teacher, Bimal Kharel, Teacher, C.K. Rai, Teacher, Milan Rai,
Teacher, M.N. Sherpa, LDC, Tarka Man Tamang, Constable, were
also served show-cause notices for the same charge and without
imposing
any
voluntarily.
punishment,
they
were
permitted
to
retire
Other persons, namely, M.K. Subba and Basant
Kumar Rai, who in fact participated in the meeting under the
banner of opposite political party repeatedly and spoke against
the Government, they were, without any enquiry, promoted to
the superior post.
This conduct of the Government authorities
clearly speak of biased attitude towards the petitioners. In such
view of the matter, the Enquiry Report deserves to be quashed
and the consequential order of punishment be also set aside.
4.
Expostulating the aforestated contention, Mr. J.B.
Pradhan, learned Additional Advocate General appearing for the
respondents, submits that the Enquiry Officer has examined the
intelligence
report
wherein
it
was
clearly
found
that
the
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
petitioners
actively
participated
and
also
addressed
the
gathering. A copy of the said report could not be given, as it was
confidential.
The Enquiry Officer satisfied himself on the basis of
the intelligence report, coupled with admission by the petitioners,
to prove the charges. There is no infirmity or perversity in the
Enquiry Report.
Mr. Pradhan would further contend that the
newspaper reports were produced before the Enquiry Officer,
wherein it was clearly stated that wide publicity was given to
holding of the meeting on the relevant date i.e. 21st December
2009 by the political leaders. The said fact was also corroborated
by examining editors of some of the newspapers.
Further
contention of the respondents is that the petitioners were well
aware of the nature of the meeting and they have participated in
the meeting deliberately and also had taken active participation
in the meeting. The said conduct of the petitioners come within
the definition of unbecoming of a Government servant as
prohibited under Rule 6 of the Conduct Rules. The punishment
imposed on the petitioners was in accordance with the gravity of
the offence committed by the petitioners.
Thus, the petition
deserves to be rejected.
5.
I have carefully examined the contentions put forth by
the learned counsel for the parties, analyzed pleadings and
evidence brought before the Enquiry Officer as well as other
documents appended to the petition herein.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
6.
Indisputably,
the
petitioners
were
Government
employees, working in the different departments, as described in
the cause title, of the State Government. It is alleged that the
petitioners participated in the meeting held on 21 st December
2009. Accordingly, they were charged for attending such political
gathering held in the guise of picnic at Rolu, South Sikkim,
knowing well that the said gathering was organized by a few
political functionaries for political purpose.
The charge framed
against them reads as under:
“………… attended a political gathering held in the guise of
picnic at Rolu, South Sikkim on 21.12.2009, though it was
well known through the local media and otherwise that the
said gathering was organized by a few political functionaries
for political purposes, and the announcement about the said
gathering at Rolu on 21.12.2009 had been made by one of
the said political personality at the launching of a web site
against the Government on 07.12.2009, during which he
had also made accusation against the democratically elected
State Government and launching of a movement for political
change.
2.
The above act of Dr. C.P. Rai, amounts to an act
unbecoming of a Government servant in violation of rules
3(i)(c) of Sikkim Government Servants’ Conduct Rules,
1981.”
7.
The list of documents along with charge-sheet and
also a list of three witnesses, namely Smt. Sonam Wangmu
Shenga, District Information Officer (East), Information and
Public Relation Department, Shri Prem Vijay Basnet, Deputy
Director, Information Technology Department, NK Shyam Bdr.
Rai, Sikkim Police, was served on 04th February, 2010.
The
petitioners replied to the show-cause notice, on different dates,
on almost in same line, denying their active participation and
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
also stated that they were not aware of the political meeting as
they do not subscribe any local newspaper, wherein the news
was
purportedly
published
that
the
political
parties
were
organizing a political meeting on 21st December 2009.
8.
The first petitioner in his reply stated as under:
“1.
That between 17.12.2009 and 21.12.2009 we had religious
worship (nag puja & graha shanti) at our home i.e. Namchi, South
Sikkim. On the concluding day of the puja as is customary and
ritualistic, we went to rolu mandir and to the near by river with
offerings and the statues to immerse in the flowing stream/river
with the direction of the priest chanting mantras (lamas) at around
9.30 am.
2.
That while returning home we chanced upon the sitting MLA
and Chairman and since we had some extra khadas we decided to
pay our respects to him and so offered the khada and moved on. ”
9.
The second petitioner, in her reply, stated that she
has not attended any meeting on that date.
10.
The third petitioner in his reply stated as under:
“1.
That 20.12.2009 & 21.12.2009 also being Lossong i.e. a
Government holiday, I had gone to visit my sister at her residence
at Jorethang. On my way home the next day i.e. 21.12.2009 I
attended a picnic party at Rolu, South Sikkim as I had been
verbally invited by some acquaintance. I was not informed nor did
I know that it was a “political gathering” as alleged. I did not
attend the said function in my official capacity but in my personal
capacity. The said gathering to the best of my understanding was
not a political gathering and it comprised of mostly non-political
people.”
11.
The fourth petitioner in his reply stated as under:
“1.
That 21.12.2009 being a state holiday i.e. Lossong I
attended a picnic party during held at Rolu, South Sikkim on
invited from an acquaintance. Neither the invitation card nor the
person who invited me indicated that it was a political gathering as
alleged. I attended the said picnic on my personal capacity and
not in the capacity of a Government servant since an acquaintance
had invited me. I left the picnic program soon after some politician
arrived and thereafter I have no idea what happened.”
12.
The fifth petitioner in his reply stated as under:
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
“1.
That I had admitted only to the fact that I had attended the
picnic organized at Rolu upon receiving invitation from my cousin.
This fact does not automatically prove that I had attended a
political function. Moreover, I even produced the invitation card of
the said picnic and witnesses which clearly proves that I had
attended a picnic.”
13.
The sixth petitioner in his reply stated as under:
“1.
That I had admitted only to the fact that I had attended the
picnic organized at Rolu upon receiving invitation from the
organizers thereof who were my acquaintance. This fact does not
automatically prove that I had attended a political function.
Moreover, I even produced the invitation card of the said picnic and
witnesses which clearly proves that I had attended a picnic.”
14.
The seventh petitioner in his reply stated as under:
“1.
That I was given an invitation card by the organizers of
“Lossong and Christmas Celebration Organising Committee” to
attend a picnic programme at Rolu on 21.12.2009. The same
being a state holiday i.e. Lossong I went and attended the said
picnic program. The said invitation card nowhere indicated nor was
I informed by the person who gave me the invitation that it was a
political gathering as alleged. I attended the said picnic on my
personal capacity and not in the capacity of a Government servant.
The said gathering to the best of my understanding was not a
political gathering and it comprised of mostly non-political people.”
15.
The eighth petitioner in his reply stated as under:
“That 21.12.2009 being a state holiday i.e. Lossong I went and
attended the picnic programme organized by the “Lossong and
Christmas Celebration Organising Committee” at Rolu on an
invitation which did not indicate any where that it was a political
gathering as alleged. I attended the said picnic on my personal
capacity and not in the capacity of a Government servant. The
said gathering to the best of my understanding was not a political
gathering and it comprised of mostly non-political people.”
16.
The ninth petitioner stated in his reply as under:
“1.
That I did not attend the alleged private political function on
7.12.2009 nor was I aware of the fact that such a meeting had
been conducted as alleged since 7.12.2009 was a working day and
I was very much present at my work place.
2.
That I was given an invitation to attend a picnic program at
Rolu on 21.12.2009 by some organizer of the “Lossong and
Christmas Celebration Organising Committee”. The said invitation
card nowhere indicated that it was a political gathering as alleged.
Since 21.12.2009 was a stated holiday i.e. Lossong I went and
attended the said picnic program on my personal capacity and not
in the capacity of a Government servant.
I left the picnic
programme soon after some politician arrived and thereafter I have
no idea what happened.”
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
17.
The tenth petitioner stated in his reply as under:
“That 21/12/2009 was a State holiday and I went and attended a
picnic organized by the “Lossong and Christmas Celebration
Organising Committee” at Rolu on an invitation by a friend who
was a member of the Organising Committee of the said picnic. The
invitation card did not indicate in any manner that the said picnic
was a political gathering. Having fallen on a government holiday, I
had attended the said picnic bonafide, believing that the same was
a social function and on my personal capacity. The said gathering
to the best of my understanding was not a political gathering and it
comprised of the mostly non-political people.”
18.
The eleventh petitioner in his reply stated as under:
“1
That I was given an invitation card by one of the organizers
of “Lossong and Christmas Celebration Organising Committee” to
attend a picnic programme at Rolu on 21.12.2009. The same
being a state holiday i.e. Lossong I went and attended the said
picnic program. The said invitation card nowhere indicated that it
was a political gathering as alleged. I attended the said picnic on
my personal capacity and not in the capacity of a Government
servant. The said gathering to the best of my understanding was
not apolitical gathering and it comprised of mostly non-political
people.”
19.
The twelfth petitioner in his reply stated as under:
“That 21.12.2009 being a state holiday i.e. Lossong I attended a
picnic party at Rolu, South Sikkim organized by some of my
friends. The person who invited me or the invitation card which I
received did not indicate that it was a political gathering as alleged.
I attended the said picnic on my personal capacity and not in the
capacity of a Government servant. The said gathering to the best
of my understanding was not a political gathering and it comprised
of mostly non-political people.”
20.
The thirteenth petitioner stated in his reply as under:
“1
That I was given an invitation card by some of the
organizers of “Lossong and Christmas Celebration Organising
Committee” to attend a picnic programme at Rolu on 21.12.2009.
On that day I was scheduled to go to Kalimpong to visit my
children at my in-laws residence. Since I received the invitation I
though it may not be proper for me not to visit even for a short
while. Therefore, on my way to Kalimpong I dropped in, stayed for
a while and left for Kalimpong. During my stay in the picnic there
was no political talk or speeches made by anybody. The said
invitation card nowhere indicated nor was I informed by the
persons who gave me the invitation that it was a political gathering
as alleged. I attended the said picnic on my personal capacity and
not in the capacity of a Government servant.”
21.
The fourteenth petitioner stated in his reply as under:
“1.
That I had admitted only to the fact that I had attended the
picnic organized at Rolu upon receiving invitation from the
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
organizers thereof who were my acquaintance. This fact does not
automatically prove that I had attended a political function.
Moreover, I even produced the invitation card of the said picnic and
witnesses which clearly proves that I had attended a picnic.”
22.
The fifteenth petitioner stated in his reply as under:
“1.
That I had admitted only to the fact that I had attended the
picnic organized at Rolu upon receiving invitation from the
organizers thereof who were my acquaintance. This fact does not
automatically prove that I had attended a political function.
Moreover, I even produced the invitation card of the said picnic and
witnesses which clearly proves that I had attended a picnic.”
23.
The sixteenth petitioner stated in his reply as under:
“That 21/12/2009 was a State holiday and I went and attended a
picnic organized by the “Lossong and Christmas Celebration
Organising Committee” at Rolu on an invitation. The invitation
card did not indicate in any manner that the said picnic was a
political gathering. Having fallen on a government holiday, I had
attended the said picnic bonafidely believing that the same was a
social function and on my personal capacity. The said gathering to
the best of my understanding was not a political gathering and it
comprised of the mostly non-political people.”
24.
The seventeenth petitioner stated in her reply as
under:
“1.
That I was invited by my cousin to attend the picnic at Rolu
on 21.12.2009. Since 21.12.2009 was a state holiday i.e. Lossong
I decided to attend the same. The said invitation card nowhere
indicated that it was a political gathering as alleged. I attended
the said picnic on my personal capacity and not in the capacity of a
Government servant.
The said gathering to the best of my
understanding was not a political gathering and it comprised of
mostly non-political people.”
25.
The eighteenth petitioner in his reply stated as under:
“ 3.
That 21.12.2009 being a state holiday i.e. Lossong I went
and attended the picnic program organized by the “Lossong and
Christmas Celebration Organizing Committee” at Rolu on an
invitation which did not indicate any where that it was a political
gathering as alleged. I attended the said picnic on my personal
capacity and not in the capacity of a Government servant since
some of my neighbours invited me. I left the picnic program soon
after some politician arrived and thereafter I have no idea what
happened. ”
26.
On receipt of the response, the third respondent was
notified as Enquiry Officer.
On perusal of the documents, it
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
appears that the Enquiry Officer has examined four other
witnesses, besides the delinquent employees.
Pema Wangchuk
Dorjee, the Editor and Publisher of local daily, Sikkim Now,
deposed that the news of the meeting held on 21st December
2009 at Rolu, wherein P.S. Tamang (Golay) was speaking for the
first time, was published and he openly spoke against the SDF.
The said statement, according to him, was made on the basis of
report of the reporter. There is no mention of presence of any
petitioner, except some Government employees.
Smt. Sonam
Wangmu Sherpa, deposed that the different newspapers have
published the news on different dates. Mr. Shyam Bdr. Rai, Head
Constable stated that he has processed the report regarding
attendance of picnic by Government employees and others. The
report only indicated about attending by political personalities.
Other witness, namely, Prem Vijay Basnet also did not state
anything about presence of the petitioners. One more witness,
K.K. Pradhan, O/C of the Special Branch deposed that presence
of Government employees and others without specifying the
name of any employee.
Presence and participation of any
petitioner was not stated by any of the witnesses, as above
referred.
27.
The Enquiry Officer in his report found the petitioners
guilty on the basis of intelligence report coupled with the
admission of charge.
The Enquiry Office has neither dealt with
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
intelligence report nor discussed any statement made by any
party, holding that it was a case of circumstantial evidence.
28.
The disciplinary authority accepted the report and
imposed punishment of reduction of three annual increments to
the lower stage in the time scale of pay for a period of three
years with cumulative effect, vide order dated 11th July,2016,
which is impugned in this writ petition.
29.
On
analysis
of
the
charge
framed
against
the
petitioners and also the so called admission, it is not established
that the petitioners have admitted participation of any political
meeting knowingly in unequivocal and clear terms and as such it
can safely be held that the enquiry finding is without any basis
on no evidence.
30.
A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Jagdish
Prasad Saxena vs. The State of Madhya Bharat 1, wherein
the appellant, permanently employed as distillery inspector, was
furnished with a charge-sheet on the basis of alleged admission,
the Supreme Court held as under: “(11) ……………… In such a case, even if the appellant had
made some statements which amounted to admission it is
open to doubt whether he could be removed from service on
the strength of the said alleged admissions without holding
a formal enquiry as required by the rules. But apart from
this consideration, if the statements made by the appellant
do not amount to a clear or unambiguous admission of his
guilt, failure to hold a formal enquiry would certainly
constitute a serious infirmity in the order of dismissal
passed against him. Under Art. 311(2) he was entitled to
have a reasonable opportunity of meeting the charge
AIR 1961 SC 1070
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
framed against him, and in the present case, before the
show-cause notice was served on him he has had no
opportunity at all to meet the charge. After the chargesheet
was supplied to him he did not get an opportunity to crossexamine Kethulekar and others. He was not given a copy of
the report made by the enquiry officers in the said
enquiries. He could not offer his explanation as to any of the
points made against him; and it appears that from the
evidence recorded in the previous enquiries as a result of
which Kethulekar was suspended an inference was drawn
against the appellant and show-cause notice was served on
him. In our opinion, the appellant is justified in contending
that in the circumstances of this case he has had no
opportunity of showing cause at all, and so the requirement
of Art. 311 (2) is not satisfied.”
31.
This proposition of law was further reaffirmed in
Channabasappa Basappa Happali vs. The State of Mysore 2,
held as under:
“5.
It was contended on the basis of the ruling reported
in R. v. Durham Quarter Sessions; Ex parte Virgo (1952 (2)
QBD 1) that on the facts admitted in the present case, a
plea of guilty ought not to be entered upon the record and a
plea of not guilty entered instead. Under the English law, a
plea of guilty has to be unequivocal and the court must ask
the person and if the plea of guilty is qualified the Court
must not enter a plea of guilty but one of not guilty. The
police constable here was not on his trial for a criminal
offence. It was a departmental enquiry, on facts of which
due notice was given to him. He admitted the facts. In fact
his counsel argued before us that he admitted the facts but
not his guilt. We do not see any distinction between
Admission of facts and admission of guilt. When he admitted
the facts, he was guilty. The facts speak for themselves. It
was a clear case of indiscipline and nothing less. ………”
32.
From the above, it is discernible that the statement
made by the delinquent employee admitting the guilt must be
clear, unambiguous and unconditional to dispense with holding of
a proper enquiry. In other words, if the admission is ambiguous
and conditional, the enquiry is mandatory before holding the
employee as guilty of charges. Applying the well-settled principle
of law to the facts of the case, it is manifest that the petitioners
have not admitted their participation in the said meeting
AIR 1972 SC 32
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
knowingly that the meeting was organized by political leaders.
The petitioners, except second petitioner, have further stated
that they have gone for picnic and wherein they found that there
was a meeting attended by some known leaders, they were
simply present without speaking or organizing or taking active
participation in the meeting.
The said statement cannot fall
within the ambit of admission of charges, as required within the
requisites of Rules 6 of the Conduct Rules. Thus, the purported
admission, not being clear, unequivocal or unconditional, cannot
form the basis to hold the petitioners guilty of the charge.
33.
Insofar
as
the
so-called
intelligence
report
is
concerned, seemingly the same was not produced before the
Enquiry Officer, as he has not adverted to in his Enquiry Report.
It is not disputed that neither the contents of the said intelligence
report was disclosed to the delinquent employees nor a copy of
the same was furnished to them to meet with the same.
In such
circumstances, I have no hesitation to hold that the Enquiry
Report was based on no evidence and as such it is perverse.
34.
The
Supreme
Court
in
Kuldeep
Singh
vs.
Commissioner of Police and others3, relied by Mr. A. Moulik,
examining the ambit of perverse finding, held as under:
“7.
In Nand Kishore vs. State of Bihar : (1978) 3 SCC
366, it was held that the disciplinary proceedings before a
domestic Tribunal are of quasi-judicial character and,
therefore, it is necessary that the Tribunal should arrive at
(1999) 2 SCC 10
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
its conclusions on the basis of some evidence, that is to say,
such evidence which, and that too, with some degree of
definiteness, points to the guilt of the delinquent and does
not leave the matter in a suspicious state as mere suspicion
cannot take the place of proof even in domestic enquiries.
If, therefore, there is no evidence to sustain the charges
framed against the delinquent, he cannot be held to be
guilty as in that event, the findings recorded by the Enquiry
Officer would be perverse.
8.
The findings recorded in a domestic enquiry can be
characterised as perverse if it is shown that such findings
are not supported by any evidence on record or is not based
on the evidence adduced by the parties or no reasonable
person could have come to those findings on the basis of
that evidence. This principle was laid down by this Court
in State of A.P. v. Rama Rao : AIR 1963 SC 1723, in which
the question was whether the High Court, under Article 226,
could interfere with the findings recorded at the
departmental enquiry. This decision was followed in Central
Bank of India Ltd. v. Prakash Chand Jain : AIR 1969 SC 983
and Bharat Iron Works v. Bhagubhai Balubhai Patel : (1976)
1 SCC 518. In Rajinder Kumar Kindra v. Delhi Admn. (1984)
4 SCC 635, it was laid down that where the findings of
misconduct are based on no legal evidence and the
conclusion is one to which no reasonable man could come,
the findings can be rejected as perverse. It was also laid
down that where a quasi-judicial tribunal records findings
based on no legal evidence and the findings are his mere
ipse dixit or based on conjectures and surmises, the enquiry
suffers from the additional infirmity of non-application of
mind and stands vitiated.
x
x
x
10.
A broad distinction has, therefore, to be maintained
between the decisions which are perverse and those which
are not. If a decision is arrived at on no evidence or
evidence which is thoroughly unreliable and no reasonable
person would act upon it, the order would be perverse. But
if there is some evidence on record which is acceptable and
which could be relied upon, howsoever compendious it may
be, the conclusions would not be treated as perverse and
the findings would not be interfered with.”
35.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan emphatically submitted that the
jurisdiction of this Court in dealing with departmental enquiry is
limited.
The finding recorded by the Enquiry Officer be not
interfered with lightly and as such the petition be rejected.
36.
In response, it was submitted that in normal course,
the court may not interfere with the finding of the Enquiry
Officer, however, if the enquiry is based on no evidence or it is
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
perverse, the Court has competent jurisdiction to interfere with
the Enquiry Report and consequential order.
37.
A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Union
of India vs. H.C. Goel4, examining the jurisdiction of the High
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India in case of
departmental enquiry, elucidated the proposition of law as under:
“(20) ………………. It is a conclusion which is perverse and,
therefore, suffers from such an obvious and patent error on
the face of the record that the High Court would be justified
in quashing it. In dealing with writ petitions filed by public
servants who have been dismissed, or otherwise dealt with
so as to attract Art. 311 (2), the High Court under Art.
226 has Jurisdiction to enquire whether the conclusion of
the Government on which the impugned order of dismissal
rests is not supported by any evidence at all. It is true that
the order of dismissal which may be passed against a
Government servant found guilty of misconduct, can be
described as an administrative order; nevertheless, the
proceedings held against such a public servant under the
statutory rules to determine whether he is guilty of the
charges framed against him are in the nature of quasijudicial proceedings and there can be little doubt that a writ
of certiorari, for instance, can be claimed by a public
servant if he is able to satisfy the High Court that the
ultimate conclusion of the Government in the said
proceedings, which is the basis of his dismissal, is based on
no evidence. …………………”
38.
In Kuldeep Singh (supra), the Supreme Court further
reaffirmed as under: “6.
It is no doubt true that the High Court under Article
226 or this Court under Article 32 would not interfere with
the findings recorded at the departmental enquiry by the
disciplinary authority or the Enquiry Officer as a matter of
course. The Court cannot sit in appeal over those findings
and assume the role of the Appellate Authority. But this
does not mean that in no circumstance can the Court
interfere. The power of judicial review available to the High
Court as also to this Court under the Constitution takes in
its stride the domestic enquiry as well and it can interfere
with the conclusions reached therein if there was no
evidence to support the findings or the findings recorded
were such as could not have been reached by an ordinary
prudent man or the findings were perverse or made at the
dictates of the superior authority.
AIR 1964 SC 364
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
x
x
x
9.
Normally the High Court and this Court would not
interfere with the findings of fact recorded at the domestic
enquiry but if the finding of "guilt" is based on no evidence,
it would be a perverse finding and would be amenable to
judicial scrutiny.”
39.
Keeping in view the fact that the Enquiry Report is
based on no evidence, this Court has jurisdiction to interfere with
this Enquiry Report and set right the injustice meted to the
Government employees.
40.
Mr. Moulik has attempted to submit that there was a
bias against the petitioners, as some officers namely, Man
Bahadur Tamang, Teacher, Bimal Kharel, Teacher, C.K. Rai,
Teacher, Milan Rai, Teacher, M.N. Sherpa, LDC, Tarka Man
Tamang, Constable, were charge-sheeted for participating in the
same meeting, but they were permitted to take voluntary
retirement,
under
what
circumstances
those
officials
were
voluntarily retired is not on record. It is further submitted that
one M.K. Subba and Basant Kumar Rai, also participated in
several political meetings but they were promoted. In this case
also
no
materials
have
been
produced
as
to
how
they
participated, whether it was proved and under what circumstance
they were promoted. The said persons have not been impleaded
as party-respondents, herein. Thus, I am not inclined to go into
the allegation made against them.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
41.
Presuming it is correct, in that event also, it does not
make out a case of bias against the petitioners, as alleged, as
bias has to be proved strictly and against the individuals and not
against the whole Government.
There is no specific allegation
against any persons and as such allegation of bias is noted to be
rejected.
42.
Let
me
now
proceed
provisions of the Conduct Rules.
to
examine
the
relevant
Rule 3 (i) (c) provides that
every Government Servant shall at all times do nothing which is
unbecoming of a Government Servant.
Rule 6 forbids taking
part in politics and election, which reads as under: “6.
Taking part in politics and election.-
(i)
No Government Servant shall be a member
of, or be otherwise associated with, any political party or
any organization which takes part in political movement or
activity.
(ii)
It shall be the duty of every Government
Servant to endeavour to prevent any member of his family
from taking part in, subscribing in aid of or assisting in any
other manner, any movement or activity which is, or tends
directly or indirectly to be, subversive of the Government as
by law established and where a Government Servant is
unable to prevent a member of his family from taking part
in, or subscribing in aid of or assisting in any other manner,
any such movement or activity, he shall make a report to
that effect to the Government.
(iii)
If any question arises whether any movement
or activity falls within the scope of sub-rule (i), the decision
of the Government thereon shall be final.
(iv)
No Government Servant shall canvas or
otherwise interfere with, or use his influence in connection
with or take part in, an election to any Legislature or Local
Authority:
Provided that –
(a)
a Government servant qualified to vote as
such election may exercise his right to vote, but where he
do so, he shall give no indication of the manner in which he
proposes to vote or has voted.
(b)
a Government Servant shall not be deemed to
have contravened the provisions of this sub-rule by reason
only that he assists in the conduct of an election in the due
performance of a duty imposed on him by or under any law
for the time being in force.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Explanation.-The display by a Government Servant on his
person, vehicle or residence of any electoral symbol shall
amount to using his influence in connection with an election
within the meaning of this sub-rule.
Note 1.A Government Servant who has reason to
believe that attempts are being made to induce him to
break the provisions of this rule by or on behalf of an official
superior or superiors shall report the fact to the Chief
Secretary to the Government.
Note 2.Proposing or seconding the nomination of a
candidate at an election or acting as a Polling Agent shall be
deemed as an active participation in the election.
Note 3.Attendance at meetings organized by a
political party shall be construed as contravening this rule
unless all the following conditions are satisfied: (a)
that the meeting is a public meeting and not
in any sense a private or restricted meeting.
(b)
that the meeting is not held contrary to any
prohibitory order or without permission where
permission is needed.
(c)
that the Government Servant in question
does not himself speak at, or take active or
prominent part in organizing or conducting
the meeting.”
43.
Charge
of
misconduct,
as
alleged
against
the
petitioners, is that the petitioners have participated in a meeting
organized by political leaders, which was duly published earlier
and as such willingly they took active participation. There is no
allegation that the petitioners are member of, or be otherwise
associated with, any political party or any organization which
takes part in political movement or activity.
It is also not the
allegation that there is any participation in aid of or assisting in
any manner, any movement or activity which is, or tends directly
or indirectly to be, subversive of the Government as by law
established.
There is no allegation of canvassing or otherwise
interfering with, or using the influence in connection with or
taking part in, an election to any Legislature or Local Authority.
The allegation of participation in the meeting is explained in
Note 3, which provides that attendance at meetings organized by
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
a political party shall be construed as contravening this rule i.e.
Rule 6, unless all the following conditions are satisfied. There are
three conditions - (i) that the meeting is a public meeting and
not in any sense a private or restricted meeting; (b)
that
the
meeting is not held contrary to any prohibitory order or without
permission
where
permission
is
needed;
and (c) that the
Government Servant in question does not himself speak at, or
take active or prominent part in organizing or conducting the
meeting.
Mere attendance may not come within the mischief
that he knowingly participated in a public meeting and also either
speaks or take active or prominent part in organizing or
conducting the meeting.
These aspects have also not been
examined in the Enquiry Report, as required under the charge
made against the petitioners.
In such view of the matter, the
Enquiry Report is to be held as perverse and on no evidence.
44.
The last contention put forth by Mr. Pradhan is that in
the event it is found that the enquiry was not properly
conducted, the disciplinary authority be permitted to conduct the
enquiry afresh from the point to be vitiated.
He relies on an
observation made by the Supreme Court in Chairman, Life
Insurance
Corporation
of
India
and
others
vs.
A.
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Masilamani 5 and
Union
of
India
and
others
vs.
P.
Gunasekaran6.
45.
In Chairman, Life Insurance Corporation of India
(supra), the Supreme Court held as under: “16.
It is a settled legal proposition, that once the Court
sets aside an order of punishment, on the ground that the
enquiry was not properly conducted, the Court cannot
reinstate the employee. It must remit the concerned case to
the disciplinary authority for it to conduct the enquiry from
the point that it stood vitiated, and conclude the same.
(Vide: ECIL v. B. Karunakar : (1993) 4 SCC 727; Hiran
Mayee Bhattacharyya v. S.M. School for Girls : (2002) 10
SCC 293; U.P. State Spg. Co. Ltd. v. R.S. Pandey : (2005) 8
SCC 264 and Union of India v. Y.S. Sadhu : (2008) 12 SCC
30).”
46.
In Union of India and others vs. P. Gunasekaran
(supra), it was held that if the enquiry is conducted in accordance
with the law, the High Court cannot venture into re-appropriation
of
evidence
or
interfere
with
the
conclusion
in
enquiry
proceedings; further the punishment may also not be interfered
with. In the case on hand, the enquiry is found not having been
conducted in accordance with law and it is perverse and as such
interference is necessitated.
The punishment imposed on the
petitioners cannot be permitted to continue till the charge made
against them is found proved and the petitioners are found
guilty. The charge was not found proved and as such the enquiry
is liable to be quashed and the consequential punishment also
deserves to be set aside.
(2013) 6 SCC 530
(2015) 2 SCC 610
W.P.(C) No. 46 of 2016
Dr. C.P. Rai & Ors. Vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
47.
Considering the entire factual matrix, as aforestated,
in its proper prospective, it is unhesitatingly held that the Enquiry
Report was perverse on the basis of no evidence and as such it is
quashed. The consequential order of imposition of punishment,
vide order dated 11th July, 2016, is also quashed and set aside.
However, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the Staterespondents are at liberty to initiate fresh enquiry, if so advised,
from the stage of submission of response by the petitioners and
may take appropriate action, in accordance with law.
48.
Resultantly, the petition is allowed.
No order as to
costs.
Chief Justice
18.07.2017
jk
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review