Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA 111 of 2022
Dr. Basu Maan Daas,
S/O- Mr. Usha Ranjan Das,
R/O- Housing Board Quarters (Type-IV, No.17),
Chanban Road, R.K Pur, Udaipur,
Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799120
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
To be represented by Principal Secretary, Directorate of Higher Education,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala, West
Tripura, Pin-799006.
2. The Director of Higher Education,
Govt. of Tripura, Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura
3. The Secretary
Department of Finance, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010
---Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing &
Delivery of Judgment & Order :
08.02.2024
Whether fit for reporting
Yes
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
This is an intra-court appeal preferred by appellant (here-in-after
referred to as writ petitioner) challenging the impugned judgment dated
12.07.2022 passed by learned Single Judge in connection with WP(C) No.320
of 2020.
2.
Before we delve into the judgment passed by the learned Single
Judge, it would be apposite to narrate the facts as projected in the writ petition
which are as under.
FACTS:2.1
Admittedly, the appellant was serving as Assistant Professor in
Karimganj College, Higher Education Department, Government of Assam.
The said college is governed by UGC Rules and Regulations. While the
appellant was discharging his duties as Lecturer in the said government
college, he responded to an advertisement vide Advt. No.04/2010 (Annexure 1,
page 35 to the Memo of Appeal) issued by Tripura Public Service
Commission, inviting applications from eligible candidates to fill up the post
of Assistant Professor, Government (General) Degree Colleges, Education
(Higher) Department, Government of Tripura. On verification of his
application, the authority concerned issued call letter in favour of the appellant
along with other applicants to participate in the selection process. The
appellant was selected and accordingly, offer of appointment was issued in his
favour vide memorandum dated 04.11.2010 (Annexure-2, page 39 to the
Memo of Appeal). On submission of technical resignation by the appellant
from the post of Assistant Professor, it was accepted by Principal, Karimganj
College w.e.f. afternoon of 19.11.2010 for his joining to the post of Assistant
Professor in Government Degree (General) College, Education (Higher)
Department, Government of Tripura vide Advt. No.04/2010 dt. 01.04.2010
vide communication dated 19.11.2010 (Annexure 20, page 95 to the Memo of
Appeal). It is further revealed that the petitioner was permanently released
from the post of Assistant Professor in the Department of Chemistry,
Karimganj College, w.e.f. afternoon of 20.11.2010 issued by the Principal,
Karimganj College(Annexure 5, page 50 of the memo of appeal).
2.2
It is pertinent to mention herein that prior to submission of his
application, the appellant had sought for no-objection from his previous
employer which was accorded by the said employer vide certificate dated
09.08.2010 (Annexure 4, page 49 to the Memo of Appeal).
2.3
The respondent/Education (Higher) Department, Government of
Tripura had issued appointment letter in favour of the appellant along with
other selected candidates vide notification dated 27.12.2010 (Annexure 3, page
41 to the Memo of Appeal) whereby and whereunder all the selected persons
including the appellant were directed to report for duties to the
Principal/Principal-In-Charge of their respective colleges as indicated therein
by 15.02.2011 as Assistant Professor. The appellant reported his joining on
14.02.2011 i.e. one day prior to the last date of joining as indicated in the
notification dated 27.12.2010. Since his joining, the appellant has been
discharging his duties as Assistant Professor under the Education (Higher)
Department, Government of Tripura as Assistant Professor.
2.4
Thenceforth his joining, the appellant had been pursuing his claim
for counting his past service, that is, the period he rendered in Karimganj
College, Assam in terms of the UGC regulations, 2010 as published in the
Gazette of India Part III Sector 4 dated 30.06.2010 (Annexure 25, Page 109 to
the Memo of Appeal), but it was denied by the respondents.
2.5
Lastly, the appellant has submitted his representation on
06.07.2013 which was also not responded by the respondents. Having failed in
his persuasions, the appellant had approached this Court claiming counting of
his past service under Karimganj College, Government of Assam.
2.6
The learned Single Judge after hearing the parties dismissed the
claim raised in the writ petition holding that the appellant had not reported his
joining on time and there was delay of 85 days to report his joining after his
resignation and release on 20.11.2010 by his previous employer. The learned
Single Judge accepting the plea of the respondents held that such delay amount
to break-in-service forfeiting the period he served under his previous
employer. Hence, this intra-court appeal.
3.
On the aforesaid background of facts, we have heard Mr. P. Roy
Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee and
Mr. Kawsik Nath, learned counsel appearing for the writ petitioner-appellant
and Mr. D. Sarma, learned G.A appearing for the respondents-State.
4.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of
the appellant has drawn out attention to Rule 26(2) of the CCS (Pension)
Rules. Learned senior counsel has also submitted that under Clause 10.0 of the
UGC Regulations, 2010, the appellant being a direct recruitee is entitled to get
the benefit of counting his past service he rendered in Karimganj College,
Higher Education Department, Government of Assam. It is further submitted
that since the appellant had reported his joining within the time stipulated in
the appointment letter, it would be wrong to say that there was break-inservice on the pretext that the appellant has joined his service after 85 days of
his release by the previous employer. Learned senior counsel has urged to set
aside the findings arrived at by learned Single Judge allowing the claim of the
writ appellant as aforestated.
5.
Opposing the submissions of learned senior counsel for the
appellant, Mr. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A has submitted that the appellant had
submitted his resignation prior to issuance of the appointment letter in favour
of him which created cloud in the minds of the respondents as to how he came
to know that he would be appointed under the respondents. Second fold of
submission advanced by learned Addl. G.A is that the writ petitioner/appellant
did not forward his application through proper channel and thus, he violated
Clause 10.1(c) of UGC Regulations, 2010.
6.
Learned Addl. G.A relying upon Sub-Rule (1) of Rule 26 of
CCS(Pension) Rules submits that due to delayed reporting by 85 days, the past
service of the appellant is forfeited and this delay of 85 days should be treated
as break-in-service disentitling him from counting his past service he rendered
in Karimganj College under the Higher Education Department, Government of
Assam. Lastly, learned Addl. G.A has further defended the finding and
conclusion arrived at by learned Single Judge while dismissing the writ
petition.
7.
We have considered the rival submissions advanced by learned
counsel appearing for the parties.
8.
Before entering into the merits of the arguments advanced by
learned counsel appearing for the parties, we deem it fit to reproduce the
conclusion arrived at by the learned Single Judge at Para 29 of the said
judgment:“29. If the prayer of the petitioner is considered by this
court and the said delay of 85 days is condoned, there is no
yardstick as to what extent this court in Article 226 of the
Constitution of India can exercise for purpose of condoning that
delay when the statute specifically empowers the Page 14 of 14
concerned authority for condoning, the High Court cannot enter
into the shoes of the concerned authority and condone the delay.
Though the petitioner has joined the service in time, the continuity
has not been extended and there is breakage in service and thus,
this court finds sufficient force in the submission of Mr. Sharma,
learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the respondents.”
9.
According to us, the correctness of the above finding of the
learned Single Judge has to be examined in line as per the provisions
mentioned in Rule 26 of the CCS(Pension) Rules and the Rules governing
counting of past service enumerated in the University Grants Commission
(Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers and other Academic
Staff in Universities and Colleges and other Measures for the Maintenance of
Standards in Higher Education) Regulations, 2010 (for short, “UGC
Regulations, 2010”). There is no quarrel that UGC Regulations, 2010 has a
statutory force in exercise of the power conferred under clause (e) and (g) of
Sub-Section(1) of Section 26 of University Grants Commission Act, 1956(for
short, “UGC Act”), and in pursuance of the MHRD O.M. No.F.23-7-2008-IFD
dated 23rd October, 2008, read with Ministry of Finance (Department of
Expenditure) O.M. No.F.1-1/2008-IC dated 30th August, 2008. UGC Act is
enacted under the provisions of Entry 66 of List-I of Seventh Schedule of the
Constitution. Clause 1.2 of Regulation 1 of UGC Regulations, 2010
contemplates that it will apply to every university established or incorporated
by or under a Central Act, Provincial Act or a State Act, every institution
including a constituent or a affiliated college recognized by the Commission,
in consultation with the university concerned under Clause (f) of Section 2 of
the UGC Act, and every institution deemed to be a university under Section 3
of the said Act. Admittedly, Tripura University is governed by University
Grants Commission Act and all rules and regulations framed under the UGC
Act are applicable to Tripura University. So, for violation or for enforcement
and proper implementation of the provisions of the UGC Act and Rules and
Regulations thereof, this Court can invoke its power of issuance of writ as
provided under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
10.
In addition, what is stated here-in-above, it is settled proposition
of law that the writ court in exercise of its extra-ordinary and discretionary
jurisdiction will issue appropriate writ in case the fundamental right is
infringed. High Courts’ writ jurisdiction is extensive and expansive. According
to Article 226 of the Constitution of India, High Courts can issue writ for “any
other” purpose, in addition to protecting fundamental rights. Therefore, it is
not necessary that the breach is of a fundamental or constitutional right to
invoke a writ petition under Article 226. For issuance of a writ, any action or
harm caused by the State or its instrumentalities or by any statutory authority
in violation of ordinary public law would be sufficient.
11.
Again, if any action of the statutory or executive authority is
found to be arbitrary, discriminatory and result capricious exercise of
administrative power and offends Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of
India, then the writ courts must come into the shoes of such authority to
remove or cure such illegalities or discrimination to set the law in its right
perspective and direction.
12.
Counting of past service in an appropriate case is one of such
statutory rights which an employee is entitled to get in an appropriate case.
Non-granting of such benefits in appropriate case is unreasonable and arbitrary
and thus offends Article 14 and Article 16 of the Constitution of India.
Keeping in mind the aforesaid principle, we have proceeded to decide the
claim raised in his writ petition.
13.
At the outset, it would be gainful to reproduce Clause 10.0 of
UGC Regulations, 2010 which is under:10.0 COUNTING OF PAST SERVICE FOR DIRECTOR
RECRUITMENT AND PROMOTION UNDER CAS
10.1. Previous regular service whether national or international,
as Assistant Professor, Associate Professor or Professor or
equivalent in a University, College, National Laboratories or
other scientific/professional Organizations such as the CSIR,
ICAR, DRDO, UGC, ICSSR, ICHR, ICMR, DBT, etc., should be
counted for direct recruitment and promotion under CAS of a
teacher as Assistant Professor, Associate Professor, Professor or
any other nomenclature these posts are described as per
Appendix III- Table No.II provided that:
(a) The essential qualifications of the post held were not lower
than the qualifications prescribed by the UGC for Assistant
Professor, Associate Professor and Professor as the case may be.
(b) The post is/was in an equivalent grade or of the pre-revised
scale of pay as the post of Assistant Professor (Lecturer)
Associate Professor (Reader) and Professor.
(c) The candidate for direct recruitment has applied through
proper channel only.
(d) The concerned Assistant Professor, Associate Professor and
Professor should possess the same minimum qualifications as
prescribed by the UGC for appointment to the post of Assistant
Professor, Associate Professor and Professor, as the case may be.
(e) The post was filled in accordance with the prescribed
selection procedure as laid down in the Regulations of
University/State
Government/Central
Institutions, for such appointments.
Government/Concerned
(f) The previous appointment was not as guest lecturer for any
duration, or an ad hoc or in a leave vacancy of less than one-year
duration. Ad hoc or Temporary service of more than one year
duration can be counted provided that:
(i) the period of service was of more than one year duration;
(ii) the incumbent was appointed on the recommendation of duly
constituted Selection Committee; and
(iii) the incumbent was selected to the permanent post in
continuation to the ad hoc or temporary service, without any
break.
(g) No distinction should be made with reference to the nature of
management of the institution where previous service was
rendered (private/local body/Government), was considered for
counting past services under this clause.”
14.
On perusal of sub-clause (10.1) of 10.0 of UGC Regulations,
2010, it is clear that if the service of an Assistant Professor or Associate
Professor or Professor or equivalent in a University, College, etc., is governed
by UGC Regulations, then, such Assistant Professor, Associate Professor or
equivalent thereof will be entitled for counting his past service on his joining
to such equivalent post under a different Government/ organisation which is
governed by UGC. In the instant case, admittedly the petitioner was serving
under the Karimganj College, Assam as Assistant Professor on regular basis
and his service conditions is governed by the UGC Regulations, 2010. From
the records it is evident that the petitioner had applied for the post of Assistant
Professor under the Government of Tripura through proper channel. That
apart, Clause 10.1(g) categorically stipulates that there should not be any
distinction to be made with reference to the nature of management of the
institution
where
previous
service
was
rendered
(private/local
body/government) for the purpose of consideration of counting past service. At
the cost of repetition, in the instant case, the petitioner had rendered his service
as Assistant Professor under concerned education department of the Govt. of
Assam.
15.
Next, it is necessary to reproduce Rule 26 of CCS(Pension) Rules
which deals with forfeiture of service on resignation. Rule 26 is reproduced
here-in-below:“26. Forfeiture of service on resignation
(1) Resignation from a service or a post, unless it is allowed to be
withdrawn in the public interest by the appointing authority,
entails forfeiture of past service.
(2) A resignation shall not entail forfeiture of past service if it has
been submitted to take up, with proper permission, another
appointment, whether temporary or permanent, under the
Government where service qualifies.
(3) Interruption in service in a case falling under sub-rule (2),
due to the two appointments being at different stations, not
exceeding the joining time permissible under the rules of transfer,
shall be covered by grant of leave of any kind due to the
Government servant on the date of relief or by formal
condonation to the extent to which the period is not covered by
leave due to him.
(4) The appointing authority may permit a person to withdraw his
resignation in the public interest on the following conditions,
namely :- * * * * * * *”
16.
On minute reading of Rule 26 of CCS(Pension) Rules which deals
with forfeiture of past service on resignation, it is clear that the case of the
appellant does not fall under Sub-Rule (1) of Rule 26 of CCS(Pension) Rules.
The case of the appellant is covered by Sub-Rule(2) and (3) of Rule 26 of the
CCS(Pension) Rules. Admittedly, the appellant submitted his technical
resignation as provided under Sub-Rule(2) of Rule 26 of the CCS(Pension)
Rules. Sub-rule (3) envisages the intervening period between the date of his
release by his previous employer and the date of his joining under the new
employer, and the said period can be regularized by granting leave due to such
employee provided that such employee is to report his joining under the new
employer within the period not exceeding the joining time permissible under
the Rules.
17.
In the instant case, the writ appellant had reported his joining
within the stipulated date mentioned in the appointment letter itself issued in
his favour by the respondents. It transpires that the appellant was released by
his previous employer, that is, Karimganj College, Assam on 20.11.2010. In
the appointment letter, the respondents had mentioned last date of joining as
15.02.2011. The appellant reported his joining on 14.02.2011, i.e. one day
prior to the last date of joining. So, there is no violation of sub-rule (3) of Rule
26 of the CCS (Pension) Rules vis-à-vis the time schedule mentioned in the
appointment letter issued by the respondents in favour of the appellant. As
such, this period may be regularized by granting leave due to the appellant and
it is condonable as contemplated under sub-rules (2) and (3) of Rule 26 of CCS
(Pension) Rules.
18.
Now dealing with the submission of learned Addl. G.A that the
appellant did not apply through proper channel as provided under Clause (c) of
the sub-clause (10.1) of 10.0 of UGC Regulations, 2010, it is noticed that
appellant had sought for permission, and in response thereto, the Principal,
Karimganj College issued no-objection certificate on 09.08.2010 stating inter
alia that the authority has no-objection if the appellant joins Govt. Degree
College, Education (Higher) Department, Govt. of Tripura. It is further stated
that the appellant would be released permanently for the same. So, the plea
agitated by learned Addl. GA in this respect is without any foundation, and is
accordingly repelled being contrary to records.
19.
Dealing with the second submission advanced by learned Addl.
G.A that the appellant submitted his resignation prior to the issuance of
appointment letter, and that as to how it was within his knowledge that he
would be appointed under the Government of Tripura, we find that the
respondents had issued offer of appointment in favour of the appellant vide
memorandum dated 04.11.2010. After receipt of the said memorandum issuing
offer of appointment, the appellant had submitted his technical resignation on
19.11.2010, which appears from the communication dated 19.11.2010 itself
issued by the Principal, Karimganj College (Annexure 20, page 95 to the
memo of appeal). So, this submission of learned Addl. G.A is also contrary to
the records and accordingly, this submission is repelled.
20.
Now, coming to the main issue whether there was 85 days delay
to report to his joining in the Govt. Degree College, Dharmangar, Tripura in
respect to the petitioner/appellant. We reiterate that the appellant reported his
joining one day prior to the last date of joining mentioned in the appointment
letter. The appellant was released by his previous employer on 20.11.2010.
The petitioner in his writ petition had explained that he could not join prior to
14.02.2011 because of the illness and death of his mother. According to us,
though the explanation was given in the petition, but the same was not a
necessity, since the appellant reported his joining within the date stipulated in
the memorandum of appointment dated 04.11.2010, which the respondents
failed to appreciate and according to us, the concerned respondents had
misconstrued and misunderstood Rule 26 of the CCS (Pension) Rules; and this
is the area where the court must step into the shoes of the respondents to get
the illegality cured and the defect rectified in exercise of its extraordinary and
discretionary power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
21.
In view of the discussion made so far, we respectfully disagree
with the view taken by learned Single Judge that “there is break in service”
and that the decision of the respondents disentitling the benefit of counting his
past service rendered under the previous employer is immune from
interference in exercise of writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
22.
For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, the present
writ appeal stands allowed. The judgment and order dated 12.07.2022 passed
in WP(C) No.320 of 2020 by learned Single Judge stands set aside and
quashed.
23.
Accordingly, we direct the respondents to count the past service
rendered by the appellant/petitioner in Karimganj College under Government
of Assam and reconstruct the service book accordingly.
The entire process shall be completed within a period of 3(three)
months.
JUDGE
Rohit
signed
SAIKAT Digitally
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2024.02.19
KAR 18:05:01 +05'30'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review