Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:37980]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17951/2025
CNR: RJHC021018062025 | URN: CW / 40664U / 2025
Dr. Anish Nagda S/o Satyanarayan Nagda, Aged About 28
Years, R/o 18-H, Nakoda Nagar-2, Bedwas, P.o. Debari,
Girwa, Udaipur, Rajasthan - 313024
Dr. Saurabh Kathuria S/o Chander Mohan Kathuria, Aged
About 31 Years, R/o Kd-11 A, Ashok Vihar Phase - 1, H.o.,
Delhi - 110052
Dr. Aditi Bhandari D/o Harish Bhandari, Aged About 31
Years, R/o A - 18, Priyadarshini Vihar, Laxmi Nagar, Delhi
-110092
Dr. Jatin Prajapati S/o Hanumant Prajapati, Aged About
30 Years, R/o 240, Ward No. 13, P.o. Pataudi, Gurgaon,
Haryana - 122503
Dr. Shivani Vihan D/o Krishan Veer Singh, Aged About 34
Years, R/o H. No. 96, Mansi Vihar, Sector 23, Sanjay
Nagar, Ghaziabad, Kavi Nagar, Uttar Pradesh - 201002
Dr. Rakheeb Mohammed S/o Mohammed Thaha, Aged
About 33 Years, R/o Fazil Nivas, Krishnapuram P. O.,
Alappuzha, Kerala - 690533
Dr. Mamta Meena D/o Bharat Lal Meena, Aged About 32
Years, R/o 44, Thakur Dhani, Bhalpur, Mohcha, Sawai
Madhopur, Rajasthan - 322205
Dr. Pratiksha Tiwari D/o Ashok Sharma, Aged About 33
Years, R/o Near Swami Public School, Swami Nagar,
Bhuwana, Udaipur, Rajasthan - 313001
Dr. Narendra Kumar S/o Om Prakash, Aged About 42
Years, R/o Jheelara (Rural), Bharatpur, Rajasthan 321303
Dr. Rekha Dangi D/o Abhishek Dangi, Aged About 33
Years, R/o 456, Akhand Ashram, Shobhagpura, Udaipur,
Rajasthan - 313011
Dr. Arnab Sikdar S/o Pannalal Sikdar, Aged About 29
Years, R/o 39A/36, Bandh Road, Mokdumpur(P), Maldah,
West Bangal - 732103
Dr. Arjun S Menon S/o S Sreekumar, Aged About 32
Years, R/o Sreejayam, Thekkeparambu, Puthuppariyam-I,
(2 of 11)
[2026:RJ-JP:37980]
[CW-17951/2025]
Palakkad, Kerala - 678731
Dr. Akansha David D/o Samuel David, Aged About 30
Years, R/o Flat No. 306, 3Rd Floor, Tower Sun-5, Project
Migsun
Roof
Makarmatpur,
Sikrod,
Raj
Nagar
Ext.,
Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh-201017.
----Petitioners
Versus
State Of Rajasthan, Through Secretary, Department Of
Medical
Education,
Govt.
Of
Rajasthan,
Secretariat,
Jaipur, Raj.
The Commissioner, Department Of Medical Education,
Govt. Of Rajasthan, Chikitsa Siksha Bhawan, Near Pink
Square Mall, Govind Marg, Jaipur, Raj.
The Chairman, DM/ MCH/ MS / MD / Other Candidates
Allotment Board - 2026, S. M. S. Medical College, Jaipur,
Raj.
Chairman, Medical Counselling Committee (Mcc), Dghs,
Ministry Of Health And Family Welfare, Govt. Of India,
New Delhi.
The Principal, R. N. T. Medical College, Udaipur, Raj.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Arvind Kumar Singh
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Vigyan Shah, AAG
Ms. Tanvisha Pant
Mr. Shubham Choudhary for
Mr. Prashant Chaturvedi for
respondent No.4.
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDESH BANSAL
Order
18/09/2026
1.
Writ petitioners have filed this joint writ petition under Article
226 of the Constitution of India praying to declare their service
bond as null and void and not binding upon them, since at the
time of their admission in PG degree course in the year 2022-23,
[2026:RJ-JP:37980]
(3 of 11)
[CW-17951/2025]
there was no condition of furnishing service bond but later-on,
antedated service bonds have been got executed from the
petitioners by respondents under undue influence and coercion in
the month of June, 2023. A consequential prayer seeking direction
against
the
respondents
to
release
original
documents
of
petitioners has also been made.
2.
Heard learned counsels, appearing on behalf of respective
parties and carefully perused the material available on record.
3.
Factual matrix which has emerged from the pleadings of
present writ petition can be summarized as under:(i) Petitioners got admission in PG Degree Course in the year
2022-23 under different Non Clinical Branches i.e. Pharmacology,
PSM, Forensic Medicine, Anatomy, Biochemistry and Physiology
and have completed their two years Degree Course.
(ii)
Petitioners got admission during month of October to
December, 2022, and later on, in the month of June, 2023,
executed and furnished individual service bond. The copies of
service bond so executed and furnished by each petitioner have
been placed on record.
(iii)
Before executing their service bond, a joint protest was
raised on behalf of the petitioners by submitting a written
application dated 14.03.2023 (Annexure-2) before the Concerned
Authority of the College, but protest did not culminate to finality
and subsequent thereto, petitioners have executed the service
bond in the month of June, 2023.
(iv) After completion of PG Degree Course, petitioners have
raised the issue that service bond(s) were got executed under
undue influence and coercion, hence, be declared as null and void.
[2026:RJ-JP:37980]
4.
(4 of 11)
[CW-17951/2025]
According to petitioners, at the time of getting admission in
PG Degree Course in various Non Clinical Branches, the condition
of furnishing the service bond was never exposed by respondents,
rather on the website of MCC as well as in the notice, pasted on
the notice board of the College, no pre-condition of executing the
service bond, for admission in PG Course 2022-2023 was
mentioned. In support thereof, the document (Annexure-4),
photocopy of the details available on the website of MCC, and
(Annexure-5), photocopy of notice allegedly pasted on the notice
board of College, have been enclosed with the writ petition.
5.
In addition and alternative submission from the side of
petitioners is that an exemption from furnishing the service bond
was available to the candidates of batch 2022-2023, who got
admission in Non Clinical Branches and such exemption came to
be withdrawn by the respondents later on,
vide letter dated
02.03.2023, hence, no new condition, post to the admission, could
be imposed by the respondents against the petitioners.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents with their
reply to the writ petition have placed on record the Government
orders dated 12.07.2022 (Annexure-R/1), 27.09.2022 (AnnexureR/2) and copy of an order dated 02.03.2023 (Annexure- R/3) as
also have mentioned condition No. 13 of the Instruction Booklet in
Para No. 3 of reply to the writ petition and on the strength of
these particulars, submits that the condition of furnishing service
bond by all the candidates, either belonging to Clinical or Non
Clinical Branches, was well informed and notified through these
orders and in terms of condition No.13 of Instruction Booklet.
Later on, when the candidates like petitioners, belonging to Non
(5 of 11)
[2026:RJ-JP:37980]
Clinical
Branches
claimed
exemption
[CW-17951/2025]
from
furnishing
bond,
claiming equality with the candidates of previous Batch of 20212022, thereafter, need arose to pass an specific order dated
02.03.2023,
in
furtherance
to
the
previous
orders
dated
12.07.2022 and 27.09.2022, to make it clear that exemption from
furnishing service bond by candidates of non clinical branch, as
applicable to the previous batch of year 2021-2022 stands
cancelled, hence, no exemption was extended to the batch of
2022-2023, to which writ petitioners belong.
7.
Counsel for respondents have also disputed and denied the
documents Annexures 4 and 5 and submits that firstly, both
documents nowhere whispers about the particular date, period or
year nor can be considered authentic documents to draw an
inference that condition of furnishing the service bond for the
candidate belonging to Non Clinical Branches was not exposed.
Further, it has been pointed out that both documents on their face
value are contrary to the Government orders dated 12.07.2022
and 27.09.2022 (Annexures R/1 and R/2) so also against
condition No.13 of Instruction Booklet, hence, are not reliable
documents.
8.
On behalf of the respondents, it has also been argued that
the case of petitioners to get executed the ante-dated service
bond is an afterthought, as execution of the service bond on the
previous date, was indeed opted by the petitioners themselves
being in their interest and they chose the same date of
commencing their respective PG Degree Course. Further the issue
that the service bonds were got executed from the petitioners
under undue influence or coercion or force, is a complex question
[2026:RJ-JP:37980]
(6 of 11)
[CW-17951/2025]
of fact which can be adjudicated only after recording evidence of
parties and may not be entertained by the High Court in exercise
of its writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India.
9.
Heard and considered.
10.
Having pondered over the rival contentions and the factual
matrix as mentioned hereinabove, what has transpired before this
Court is that petitioners executed and furnished service bond, in
the month of June, 2026, obviously after obtaining admission in
their respective Non Clinical Branches of PG Course but without
any demur or protest. The protest as raised by petitioners against
asking to execute the service bond by way of written application
dated 14.03.2023 (Annx.2) prior to executing the service bonds,
was not pursued by them to the finality, hence virtually at the
time of executing service bond petitioners have waived their
protest and executed the service bond willfully and with free
consent.
11.
Further, what has transpired is that the service bonds were
executed by the petitioners in the month of June, 2023 but
thereafter, the issue of getting execution of service bond under
influence, coercion or force was never raised by petitioners, rather
has been raised, after about more than two years, that too, after
completion of their PG Course by way of filing this writ petition
which has been filed by petitioners on 18.11.2025. Hence,
apparently the issue of undue influence, coercion or force appears
to be an afterthought and has been raised after a gross and
unexplained delay, hence, presumption of acceptance of the
execution of service bonds goes against petitioners.
(7 of 11)
[2026:RJ-JP:37980]
12.
[CW-17951/2025]
In addition, in the opinion of this Court, the issue of undue
influence and coercion is a complex issue of facts, which can
better be adjudicated on merits, after recording and appreciation
of the evidence of parties, hence, ordinarily should not be gone
into by High Court while exercising writ jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, unless and until the parties are
not at factual dispute.
In the case at hand, as has been discussed hereinabove, it is
apparent on the record that a complex disputed questions of facts
have emerged between the parties, hence, on the face value, it
may not be inferred by this Court that the service bonds were got
executed by the respondents, from the writ petitioners, under any
undue influence, coercion or force, rather, in the given facts, a
prima facie presumption goes against petitioners.
13.
For recording the above findings and observations, this Court
finds support from the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court
delivered in case of Shubhas Jain Vs. Rajeshwari Shivam and
ors. [(2021) 20 SCC 454] and relevant para No.25 is being
reproduced hereunder:
"25. It is well settled that the High Court exercising its
extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, does not adjudicate hotly disputed
questions of facts. It is not for the High Court to make a
comparative assessment of conflicting technical reports
and decide which one is acceptable."
The
Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
an
another
judgment
delivered in case of M.P. Solar Power Management Co. Ltd. v.
Sky Power Southeast Solar India (P) Ltd. [(2023) 2 SCC
703], while dealing with the issue of exercise of writ jurisdiction
(8 of 11)
[2026:RJ-JP:37980]
[CW-17951/2025]
by a Court in deciding disputed questions of fact, held in para no.
82.7 as under:
"82.7 The existence of an alternate remedy, is,
undoubtedly, a matter to be borne in mind in declining
relief in a writ petition in a contractual matter. Again, the
question as to whether the writ petitioner must be told off
the gates, would depend upon the nature of the claim
and relief sought by the petitioner, the questions, which
would have to be decided, and, most importantly,
whether there are disputed questions of fact, resolution
of which is necessary, as an indispensable prelude to the
grant of the relief sought. Undoubtedly, while there is no
prohibition, in the writ court even deciding disputed
questions of fact, particularly when the dispute surrounds
demystifying of documents only, the Court may relegate
the party to the remedy by way of a civil suit."
14.
In addition to above, it has also transpired from the record
that respondents have issued orders dated 12.07.2022 and
27.09.2022 (Annex.R/1 and R/2) making it necessary to furnish
service bond by the aspirant candidates for admission in PG
Course in the year 2022-2023. The recital mentioned in these
orders nowhere make any distinction between the candidates of
Clinical and non Clinical Branches. If any exemption of furnishing
the bond to the candidates belonging to the non clinical branches
was available for the previous batch of year 2021-2022, the
position was made clear by the respondents, vide issuing an order
dated
02.03.2023
(Annexure
R/3),
which
was
issued
in
furtherance to the earlier two orders dated 12.07.2022 &
27.09.2022. For ready reference, the relevant condition Nos.1 and
12 of order dated 12.07.2022 and condition No.1 of order dated
27.09.2022 is being reproduced hereunder:
Condition Nos. 1 & 12 of order dated 12.07.2022:-
**1-
jkT;
ds
jktdh;
fpfdRlk
egkfo|ky;ksa
ls
LukrdksÙkj
,oa
lqij&Lisf'k;fyVh dkslZ iw.kZ djus ds mijkar lHkh Nk=@Nk=kvksa ls jkT; esa
[2026:RJ-JP:37980]
(9 of 11)
[CW-17951/2025]
jktdh; lsok nh tkuh visf{kr gSA orZeku esa bl gsrq 05 o"kZ dh vof/k dks ?kVk;k
tkdj bls 02 o"kZ fd;k tkrk gSA cU/ki= dh jkf'k iwokZuqlkj 25 yk[k :i;sa gh
jgsaxhA rn~uqlkj 'kSf{kf.kd l= 2022&2023 esa jktdh; fpfdRlk egkfo|ky;ksa esa
LukrdksÙkj ,oa liqj&Lisf'k;fyVh dkslZ esa izos'k ysus okys Nk=@Nk=kvksa ls 02 o"kZ
dh jktdh; lsok iznku djus gsrq 25 yk[k :i;sa dk lsok cU/ki= izkIr fd;k tkosA
12-
;fn LukrdksÙkj dkslZ djus okys fdlh Nk=@Nk=k dk vkxkeh o"kZ gsrq
liqj&Lisf'k;fyVh dkslZ esa p;u gks tkrk gS rks ,slh fLFkfr esa mls
lqij&Lisf'k;fyVh dkslZ iw.kZ djus ds mijkar 02 o"kZ dh jktdh; lsok iznku djus
dk cU/ki= fy;k tkdj mijksDr lqij&Lisf'k;fyVh dkslZ djus gsrq vuqer fd;k tk
ldsxkA**
Condition No. 1 of order dated 27.09.2022:-
**1- LukrdksÙkj ,oa lqij&Lisf'k;fyVh dkslZ iw.kZ gksus ij Nk= @Nk=kvksa dks nks o"kZ
ds fy, jkT; ljdkj@jktesl ds v/khu izkFkfedrk ls fuEukuqlkj fuEu inksa ij
jktdh; lsok nsus gsrq cU/k&i= dh 'krksZ ds vuqlkj ck/; fd;k tk ldsxk%&
¼1½ fpfdRlk egkfo|ky;ksa esa lhfu;j jsftMsUV
¼2½ fpfdRlk egkfo|ky;ksa esa lgk;d vkpk;Z ¼czkWM Lisf'k;fyVh ds Nk=@Nk=kvksa dks
lhfu;j jsftMsUVf'ki iw.kZ djus ds i'pkr½
¼3½ fpfdRlk ,oa LokLF; foHkkx ds v/khu dfu"B fo'ks"kK
¼4½ LukrdksÙkj ;ksX;rk ds vuq:i vU; dksbZ in**
15.
That apart, the respondents have also brought on record the
contents of condition No.13 mentioned in the Instruction Booklet,
which has been incorporated in Para No.2 of reply and for ready
reference is being reproduced hereunder:
"Service Bond
The students so selected (for the academic session 202223) (except students who are in service of ESI or Central
Government or Rajasthan Government or other state
Government and already filled service Bond for this
purpose) will have to fill a bond amounting to Rs. 25 lacs
(Rupees twenty five lacs) for commitment to serve the
State Government of Rajasthan for a period of two (2)
years (in the applicable bond format) (Refer copy of order
no. P7(86)CM/HM/Budget/DME/Acad/2015/8000, dated
12.07.2022 issued by the Government of Rajasthan).
It is clarified that a candidate, who on the date of
allotment is in the government service, joins the course
after resigning/leaving that service, shall have to fill the
above service bond. At the time of joining, all the original
certificates of the candidate shall be deposited in the
[2026:RJ-JP:37980]
(10 of 11)
[CW-17951/2025]
concerned allotted college towards execution of the
bonds. The concerned allotted college shall have the right
to retain all the original certificates of the students till
compliance of the conditions of the bonds. (Emphasis
supplied)."
16.
It is not the case of writ petitioners that they were not aware
of the Instruction Booklet and orders dated 12.07.2022 &
27.09.2022 or do not fall under such class of person. In the batch
of 2022-2023, the exemption of executing the service bond was
available only to those candidates who were in service of ESI or
Central Government or Rajasthan Government or other State
Government, but not to the candidates of non clinical branches.
17.
This Court finds that in the present writ petition, petitioners
have neither questioned the relevant conditions, mentioned in
orders dated 12.07.2022 and 27.09.2022 nor have questioned the
condition No.13 of the Instruction Booklet and even has not
challenged the order dated 02.03.2023.
18.
As far as information allegedly notified on the website of
MCC (Annex.4) and on the notice board of College (Annex.5) are
concerned, these documents do not inspire confidence as neither
the documents bear any date, year or period nor have been
uploaded from the official website, rather have been got from
Facebook account.
19.
The two affidavits sworn by petitioners to show that before
admission,
petitioners
were
informed
that
no
condition
of
furnishing the service bond is there for the non clinical branches,
same again lead to a disputed question of fact, in contrast to the
orders of the State Government dated 12.07.2022 & 27.09.2022
and condition No.13 of Instruction Booklet.
[2026:RJ-JP:37980]
20.
(11 of 11)
[CW-17951/2025]
In that view of the matter, it may not be held that at the
time of getting admission by petitioners in the PG Courses, they
were assured not to execute or furnish the service bond and such
condition of furnishing the bond, qua petitioners was imposed and
notified subsequently, nor it can be held that petitioners were
forced by the respondents displaying any undue influence or
coercion to execute antedated service bonds.
21.
For the discussions and enunciation made hereinabove, the
prayer made by petitioners in the present writ petition is not liable
to be accepted within scope of writ jurisdiction and deserves to be
rejected and is hereby rejected.
22.
As a consequence, instant writ petition is hereby dismissed.
23.
No costs.
24.
Stay application and pending application(s), if any, stand
disposed of.
(SUDESH BANSAL),J
Pcg/1/Riya
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review