Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/50
GAHC010012752015
2026:GAU-AS:1262
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/2556/2015
DR. MANJIT KUMAR BHATTACHARYYA and 5 ORS,
S/O KABINDRA BHATTACHARYYA R/O JAYANAGAR, 2ND BYE LANE,
HOUSE NO. 31, NEAR NRL PETROL PUMP, P.O. KHANAPARA, GUWAHATI781022, DIST. KAMRUP M, ASSAM.
2: DR. SURESH KUMAR NATH
S/O SHRI BHADRESWAR NATH R/O REGISTRAR'S QUARTER
QUARTER NO. 9 ADM
GAUHATI UNIVERSITY
GUWAHATI - 781014
DIST. KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
3: SHRI ABHIJIT BARTHAKUR
S/OLT. GOLAP BARTHAKUR R/O RATNAGIRI PATH
BAMUNIMAIDAM
GUWAHATI- 781021
DIST. KAMURP M
ASSAM.
TONM Digitally signed
by TONMOY
KALITA
OY
Date: 2026.02.02
KALITA 15:27:36 +05'30'
4: DR. RAHUL MAHANTA
S/O SHRI P MAHANTA R/O D-3
PROFESSORS COLONY
COTTON COLLEGE
DIGHALIPUKHURI
GUWAHATI- 781001
DIST. KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
5: DR. DEBOJIT SARMA
S/O LT. A.K. SARMA R/O HOUSE NO. 6
2ND BYE LANE
BARNACHAL ROAD
BAMUNIMAIDAM
Page No.# 2/50
GUWAHATI - 781021
DIST. KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
6: DR. MAHADEV PATIGIRI
S/OLT. PRABIN PATGIRI
R/O LALITA BUILDING
NAVAGIRI PATH NEAR RED CROSS HOSPITAL
P.O. CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI- 781003
DIST. KAMRUP M
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and 5 ORS,
REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM,
HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, DISPUR, GUWAHATI- 781006.
2:THE CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE
GOVT. OF ASSAM
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006.
3:THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE
GOVT. OF ASSAM
HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-781006.
4:THE DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI- 781019.
5:THE PRINCIPAL OF COTTON COLLEGE
PANBAZAR
GUWAHATI-781001.
6:COTTON UNIVERSITY
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR
ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING
COTTON UNIVERSITY
HEM BARUAH ROAD
PANBAZAR
GUWAHATI-1
Page No.# 3/50
Advocate for the Petitioner
CHETRY,MR.J ABEDIN
: MR.U K NAIR, MR H K DAS,M KATAKY,MR. M P SARMA,MS.A
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, SC, HIGHER EDUCATION,,MR. P D NAIR
Linked Case : WP(C)/3808/2015
DR. AMALENDU CHOUDHURY and 6 ORS
S/O- LT. AJOY KUMAR CHOUDHURY
R/O- PROFESSORS QUARTER
HAFLONG GOVT. COLLEGE
BLOCK- I
UNIT- 6
P.O.- HAFLONG
DIST.- DIMA HASAO
PIN- 788819
ASSAM.
2: SHEKHAR CHAKRABORTY
S/O- SRI SIBO PRASAD CHAKRABORTY
R/O- PROFESSOR'S QUARTER
HAFLONG GOVT. COLLEGE
BLOCK- I
UNIT-3
P.O.- HAFLONG
DIST.- DIMA HASAO
PIN- 788819
ASSAM.
3: DEBBIE PAKHUONGTE
D/O- LT. BUONGA HMAR
R/O- C/O- MRS. C. HMAR
NEAR TAXI STAND
P.O.- HAFLONG
DIST.- DIMA HASAO
PIN- 788819
ASSAM.
4: SARBOJIT THAOSEN
S/O- LT. RINGINON THAOSEN
R/O VILL.- DIBARAI
P.O.- HAFLONG
DIST.- DIMA HASAO
PIN- 788819
Page No.# 4/50
ASSAM.
5: PUNYAMONI BARUAH
D/O- LT. SIROMONI BARUAH
R/O- PROFESSOR'S QUARTER
HAFLONG GOVT. COLLEGE
BLOCK- I
UNIT-II
P.O.- HAFLONG
DIST.- DIMA HASAO
PIN- 788819
ASSAM.
6: VALENTINA BAZELEY
D/O- SRI RANJIT KUMAR DEY
R/O- SUMMIT BUNGALOW
NEAR SYNOD SCHOOL
P.O.- HAFLONG
DIST.- DIMA HASAO
PIN- 788819
ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
REP. BY THE CHIEF SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
DISPUR
GHY- 6.
2:THE ADDL. CHIEF SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
HIGHER EDUCATION DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY- 6.
3:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
HIGHER EDUCATION DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY- 6.
4:THE DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GHY- 19.
5:THE PRINCIPAL
HAFLONG GOVT. COLLEGE
DIMA HASO DIST.
ASSAM- 788819.
Page No.# 5/50
6:COTTON UNIVERSITY
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR
ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING
COTTON UNIVERSITY
HEM BARUAH ROAD
PANBAZAR
GUWAHATI-1.
-----------Advocate for : MRS. S P NAIR
Advocate for : GA
ASSAM appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
- B e f o r e-
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Robin Phukan
Advocates for the petitioners
:
Mr. H.K. Das.
Advocates for the respondents
:
Mr. K. Gogoi,
Ms. K. Phukan,
Mr. H. Rahman.
Date of hearing
:-
09.12.2025.
Date on which judgment is reserved
:-
09.12.2025.
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:-
27.01.2026.
Whether the pronouncement of is of the
:-
N/A
:-
Yes.
operative part of the judgment?
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
Page No.# 6/50
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. H.K. Das, learned counsel for the petitioners in both
the writ petitions. Also heard Mr. K. Gogoi, learned standing counsel for
the Higher Education Department, being respondent No. 1, 3 and 4 in
WP(C) No. 2556/2015 & respondent Nos. 2, 3 & 4 in WP(C) No.
3808/2015; Ms. K.
Phukan, learned Junior Government Advocate for
the respondent No.2 and Mr. H. Rahman, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of Mr. P.D. Nair, for respondent No. 6 in WP(C) No. 2556/2015.
2.
In
these
two
petitions,
i.e.
WP(C)/2556/2015
and
WP(C)/3808/2015, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioners have challenged the impugned portions of the Notification No.
AHE.283/2009/Pt-II/48, dated 05.11.2014 (Annexure-16) and Office
Memorandum
vide
No.
AHE.283/2009/Pt-II/49
dated
05.11.2014
(Annexure-17) by which, the benefits of reviewed/modified dates for
placement in the Senior Grade Scale of Pay and Selection Grade Scale of
Pay were granted to the similarly situated Lecturers, but, laid down the
condition that the benefits given to those incumbents cannot be treated
as precedent and by the other Notification, the Govt. granted CAS
promotion to the similarly situated Lecturers after granting Senior Grade
Scale of Pay and Selection Grade Scale of Pay, but, laid down the
condition that the promotional aspect cannot be treated as precedent
and the period spent on ad-hoc shall not be counted towards promotion
Page No.# 7/50
under CAS; and also to issue direction to the respondent authorities to
review/ modify the placement dates of the petitioners for granting the
benefit of Senior Grade Scale of Pay, Selection Grade Scale of Pay and
the consequent promotion under CAS, as granted to the similarly situated
Lecturers, vide Notifications dated 05.11.2014; and also to issue direction
to the respondent authorities to provide the benefits of Senior Grade
Scale, Selection Grade Scale and the consequential financial up-gradation
and promotion under CAS, as provided to the similarly situated persons in
pursuance to the Judgment & Order dated 14.08.2012, passed by the
learned Assam Administrative Tribunal in Appeal Case No. 51 ATA/2010;
3.
As the issue involved in both the petitions are same and the relief(s)
being claimed are same and the parties are also almost the same, and as
agreed upon, this Court is inclined to dispose of these batch of petitions
by this common judgment and order.
Background Facts:4.
The background facts, leading to filing of the present writ petitions
are adumbrated herein below:“The petitioners in WP(C) No. 2556/2015, were initially
appointed as Lecturers under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam Public
Service Commission (APSC) (Limitation & Functions) Regulations,
1951 in Cotton College and Diphu College. Thereafter, their
services were extended from time to time. Subsequently, their
services were regularized as Lecturers upon recommendation of
the APSC, after the regular selection process. Thereafter, regular
appointments
were
made
with
effect
from
the
date
of
Page No.# 8/50
recommendation of APSC.
The University Grant Commission (UGC), in the year 1998, had
formulated a scheme, notifying revision of pay scale, minimum
qualification for appointments, i.e. Career Advancement Incentive
(CAI) etc. Then the Govt. of Assam, in the Education Department,
had issued Office Memorandum (O.M.) No. B(2)H.408/99/41,
dated 13.01.2000, for implementing the same. As per eligibility
criteria of UGC Scheme and OM, dated 13.01.2000, the petitioners
became eligible for placement in the Senior Grade Scale on
15.03.2002, 04.09.1998, 27.05.1999, 20.07.2001, 31.08.2000 and
02.09.2000, respectively and in the Selection Grade Scale on
15.03.2007, 04.09.2003, 27.05.2004, 20.07.2006, 31.08.2005 and
02.09.2005, respectively, by counting their past services, under
Regulation 3(f) as their Ad-hoc services being continuous over one
year without any break. Thus, as per the UGC Scheme and the
OM, dated 13.01.2000, the Ad-hoc services are reckonable for
placement in the Senior Grade Scale and Selection Grade Scale.
Thereafter, selections for Senior Grade took place and vide
Notification No. B(2)H.85/2000/402, dated 24.10.2008, results of
the said selection was published, wherein, the respective dates of
placement in the Senior Grade Scale of the petitioners were
reflected as 25.06.2005, 27.08.2007, 24.09.2006, 24.09.2006,
31.07.2005 and 31.07.2005, which were incorrect dates of
placement, without taking past services under Regulation 3(f)
though being reckonable as per Clauses 8.0.0. to 8.6.0 (a), (b)
and (c) of the UGC Scheme of 1998.
Page No.# 9/50
And the petitioners in WP(C) No. 3808/2015 were initially
appointed as Lecturers, under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam Public
Service Commission (APSC) (Limitation & Functions) Regulations,
1951 in Diphu College. Thereafter, their services were extended
from time to time. Their services were regularized as Lecturers
upon recommendation of the APSC, after the regular selection
process. Thereafter, the regular appointments were made with
effect from the date of recommendation of APSC.
As per eligibility criteria of UGC Scheme and OM, dated
13.01.2000, the petitioners became eligible for placement in the
Senior Grade Scale on 05.01.2001, 19.04.2001, 22.05.2001,
05.02.2002, 25.01.2004, 24.02.2005 and 26.03.2007, respectively
and
in
the
Selection
Grade
on
05.01.2006,
19.04.2006,
22.05.2006, 05.02.2007, 25.01.2009, 24.02.2010 and 26.03.2012,
respectively, by counting their past services under Regulation 3(f)
as their Ad-hoc services were continuous over one year without
any break. Thus, as per the UGC Scheme and the O.M. dated
13.01.2000, the Ad-hoc services are recokonable for placement in
the Senior Grade Scale and Selection Grade Scale.
The petitioners were granted the respective placements in the
Senor Scale Selection Grade, but such placement being made by
ignoring the ad hoc services, rendered by the petitioners under
Regulation 3(f), the same is clearly not sustainable and is violation
of the provisions of the UGC Scheme of 1998.
Because of objections from deprived Lecturers, a Review
Selection Board (RSB) was constituted, which took fresh decision
Page No.# 10/50
and vide communication dated 22.07.2010, modified (reviewed)
dates of placement of some other Lecturers and the Department,
vide Notification No. AHE 283/2009/Pt-II/46-A, dated 10.08.2010,
notified reviewed dates for placement in the Senior Grade Scale
and Selection Grade Scale. But, subsequently, vide another
Notification dated 24.09.2010, the reviewed dates were again
changed.
Being aggrieved, 4 Nos. of Lecturers approached the Assam
Administrative Tribunal (AAT),by filing Appeal Case No. 51
ATA/2010 (Smti. Basanti Medhi & 3 Others) challenging the
impugned Notification, dated 24.09.2010 and the Appeal Case was
finally decided vide Judgment & Order dated 14.08.2012,
whereby, the impugned Notification dated 24.09.2010, was set
aside and quashed, thereby, restored the Notification dated
10.08.2010. Thereafter, the State of Assam, represented by the
Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of Assam, Higher
Education Department, had preferred a writ petition, being WP(C)
No. 6845/2013, before this Court, challenging the aforesaid
Judgment & Order, dated 14.08.2012, of AAT. The said writ
petition was dismissed vide Order dated 18.12.2013, and 2 (Two)
months time was allowed to the State Govt. to implement the
Judgment & Order dated 14.08.2012, of AAT.
Notably, the petitioners in WP(C) No. 3808/2015 had also
preferred one appeal being Appeal Case No. 3ATA/2015, before
the learned Assam Administrative Tribunal praying for granting
them their respective placements in the Senior Scale as well as
Page No.# 11/50
Selection Grade Scale, by reckoning the period of service rendered
by them under Regulation 3(f). However, the learned Tribunal,
inspite of being apprised of the precedent available in the matter,
in a most arbitrary manner proceeded vide order, dated
21.02.2015 ,to dismiss the appeal which is not tenable and cannot
be sustained.
Consequently, the Commissioner and Secretary to the
Government of Assam, Higher Education Department, vide
Notification No. AHE.283/2009/ Pt-II/ 48, dated 05.11.2014,
(Annexure-16/pages-73 & 74) allowed the modified dates for
providing Senior Grade Scale by reckoning the past Ad-hoc period
of those 4 Nos. of petitioners along with 4 other incumbents and
Selection Grade Scale of Pay to 4 Nos. of petitioners along with 5
(Five) other incumbents. But, in the last portion of the said
Notification, it is mentioned that the benefits given to those
incumbents, cannot be treated as precedent. Further, vide another
Office
Memorandum
No.
AHE.283/2009/Pt-II/49,
dated
05.11.2014, (Annexure-17), allowed promotion under Career
Advancement Scheme (CAS) to those similarly situated Lecturers,
but surprisingly, in the last portion of the said Notification, it has
been pointed out that the said promotional aspect cannot be
treated as precedent and the period spent on ad-hoc shall not be
counted towards promotion.
It is the contention of the petitioners that the authority cannot
treat similarly situated persons in different manner, thereby; the
petitioners are aggrieved by the decisions mentioned in the last
Page No.# 12/50
portions of the Notification and Office Memorandum, which deny
the legitimate rights and dues of the petitioners, i.e. the correct
placement dates for grant of Senior Grade Scale, Selection Grade
Scale and consequent promotion under CAS as per the OM, dated
13.01.2000, and the UGC Guidelines and as provided to the
similarly situated persons vide Notification, dated 05.11.2014 and
Office Memorandum dated 05.11.2014 (Annexure-16 & 17).”
5.
The respondent No. 4, i.e. the Director Higher Education, Assam
has filed affidavit in opposition, wherein a stand has been taken that the
petitioners were appointed under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam Public
Service
Commission
(Limitation
&
Functions)
Regulation,
temporarily as Lecturers for a period for 4 (four) months with effect from
the date of their joining. The initial date of joining of the petitioners,
under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam Public Service Commission (Limitation
& Functions) Regulation, 1951 are as follows:
Sl.
No.
Name of the Petitioner
Order No.
Date
01.
Dr. Manjit Kumar
Bhattacharyya
B(2)H.242/95/185
14.03.1996
02.
Dr.Suresh Kumar Nath
B(2)H.346/92/59
03.09.1992
03.
Dr. Abhijit Barthakur
B(2)H.320/93/58
26.05.1993
04.
Dr.
Rahul Mahanta
B(2)H.242/95/168
19.07.1995
05.
Dr. Debojit Sarma
B(2)H.206/92/215
30.08.1994
Dr. Mahadev Patgiri
B(2)H.206/12/215
30.08.1994
And as per the Government Notification No. B(2)H.286/95/Pt-1/16 dated
26.05.2000, the persons who are working as Lecturers, under Regulation
Page No.# 13/50
3(f) of the Assam Public Service Commission (Limitation & Functions)
Regulation, 1951 shall be deemed to have been regularly appointed to
the posts from the dates they were recommended by the Assam Public
Service Commission. The date of recommendation by the Assam Public
Service Commission of the petitioners are as follows:Sl.
No.
Name of the Petitioner
Order No.
Date
01.
Dr. Manjit Kumar
Bhattacharyya
B(2)H.286/99/97
12.05.2000
02.
Dr.Suresh Kumar Nath
B(2)H.414/99/23
26.06.2000
03.
Dr. Abhijit Barthakur
B(2)H.286/99/97
12.05.2000
04.
Dr.
Rahul Mahanta
B(2)H.286/99/109
19.05.2000
05.
Dr. Debojit Sarma
B(2)H.286/99/97
12.05.2000
Dr. Mahadev Patgiri
B(2)H.286/99/97
12.05.2000
It is further stated that the services rendered by the petitioners on
appointment under Regulation 3(f), is not to be
counted for
determination of their seniority or granting benefit under career
Advancement Scheme (CAS). Counting of the past service under ad hoc
nature of appointment could not be provided to the petitioners as they
were not appointed on the recommendation of duly constituted Selection
Committee and also not by regular selection through the Assam Public
Service Commission. And their services are governed by the Rules and
Regulations framed by the University Grants Commission (UGC) and the
claim made by them are governed by the UGC Notification on Revision of
Pay Scales, Minimum Qualification for Appointments of Teachers in
Universities, Colleges & Other Measures for the Maintenance of
Page No.# 14/50
Standards, 1998. Clause 8.0.0 of UGC Regulation, 1998 deals with
counting of past service, which read as under:"8.0.0 COUNTING OF PAST SERVICE:
Previous service, without any break as a Lecturer or equivalent,
in a University, College, national laboratory, or other scientific
organization. E.g. CSIR, ICAR, DRDO, UGC, ICSSR, ICHR and
as a UGC Research Scientist, should be counted for placement
of lecturer in Senior Scale/Selection Grade provided that;
8.2.0 The qualifications for the post were not lower than the
qualification prescribed by the UGC for appointment as
Lecturers.
8.4.0 The concerned Lecturers possesses the minimum qualification
provided by the UGC for appointment as Lecturer.
8.5.0 The post was filled in accordance with the prescribed selection
procedure
as
laid
down
by
the
University/State
Government/Central Government /Institutions' regulations.
8.6.0 The appointment was not ad-hoc or in a leave vacancy
of less than one year duration. Ad-hoc service of more than
one year duration can be counted provided,
……………………..
…………………………………..
(b)
The incumbent was appointed on the recommendation of duly
constituted Selection Committee."
It is also stated that UGC Regulation, 1998 is mandatory in nature
and the Regulation clearly mentioned that the previous/past service can
Page No.# 15/50
be counted for placement of Lecturer in Senior Scale/Selection Grade
provided that the post was filled in accordance with the prescribed
selection
procedure,
as
laid
down
by
the
University/State
Government/Central Government/Institutions Regulation. The regulations
further clearly mentioned that the incumbent was appointed on the
recommendation of duly constituted Selection Committee. In the
case of the petitioners, the procedure as laid down in the UGC Regulation
1998 is not found to be followed. And that the petitioners were not
appointed on the recommendation of the duly constituted
Selection Committee and not by the regular selection through
Assam Public Service Commission. They were initially appointed
under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam Public Service Commission (Limitation
and Functions) Regulation 1951, for a period of 4 (four) months. As per
the provisions of the UGC Regulation, 1998 they were eligible for CAS
promotion/counting the seniority from the date of their regular
appointment after recommendation of Assam Public Service Commission,
provided fulfillment of the other eligibility criteria, as laid down in the
UGC Regulation and Government Guideline and that no case is made out
for interference of this Court by invoking extra-ordinary jurisdiction.
6. The respondent No.6, the Registrar of Cotton University has also filed
affidavit-in-opposition, wherein it is stated that Clause 8 of the UGC
Notification on Revision of Pay Scales, Minimum Qualification for
Appointment of Teachers in Universities, Colleges & Other Measures for
the Maintenance of Standards, 1998 relied on by the petitioners, lays
down certain preconditions for counting the previous service, without any
break, as a Lecturer of equivalent for placement of Lecturer in Senior
Page No.# 16/50
Grade/Selection Grade. The counting of the previous adhoc service as
Lecturer for placement of Lecturer in the Senior Scale / Selection Grade is
not automatic, but, is subject to satisfying the preconditions stipulated in
the said clause itself, particularly Clause 8.6 thereof. It is also stated that
as per Sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section 52 of the said Cotton
University Act, 2017, the teachers and staff of the erstwhile Cotton
College still constitute a separate cadre with respect to their service
conditions at the time of their appointments under the Government of
Assam. The matters of service, including promotions, of the teachers and
staff of the former Cotton College are decided and directed by the
Government of Assam, and the Cotton University and its authorities are
merely the executing authorities in respect of the directions so given. The
decisions and directions of the Government of Assam, insofar as the
employees of erstwhile Cotton College are concerned, are binding upon
it, i.e. Cotton University.
7.
In WP(C) No. 3808/2015, the respondent No.4 has filed separate
affidavit, wherein, it has taken a stand that the petitioners were
appointed by the Govt. of Assam, Education Department on ad-hoc basis
and with the condition that their appointment is subject to the clearance
of NET/SLET, as the case may be, in due course as per U.G.C norms. It is
also stated that the Government of Assam in the Education (Higher),had
issued an OM dated 10.05.2015, clarifying the services of Assistant
Professor/Librarians of provincialized colleges will count towards their
seniority from the date of appointment subject to the fulfillment of
following three conditions:(i)
Firstly, they must possess the required U.G.C norms
Page No.# 17/50
including NET/ SLET/Ph.D. as the case may be.
(ii)
Secondly, they should have been appointed against
valid sanctioned posts that were vacant at the time of
appointment.
(iii)
Thirdly, all the necessary formalities and procedures
as stipulated by the Government in respect of their
appointment should have been followed.
7.1.
Only those Assistant professors/Librarians whose appointment
satisfy all the above three conditions would be entitled to seniority from
the date of the initial appointment. In case, any Assistant Professors/
Librarians were initially appointed without NET/ SLET or Ph.D. or any
other qualification satisfying the required UGC norms, the seniority of
such Assistant Professors/Librarians will be counted with effect from the
date they secured required qualifications as per U.G.C norms. On the
above fact, their regular services will be counted after clearance of
required U.G.C norms. As the petitioners did not possess NET/SLET or
Ph.D. at the time of appointment, their seniority would be counted from
the date of their acquiring the required qualification and from that day
they will get the UGC scale of pay and other benefits.
7.2.
It is further stated that as per O.M., dated 10.07.2015, counting
seniority for Senior Scale of pay and Selection Grade of pay would be
eligible after possessing the required U.G.C norms i.e. NET/SLET or Ph.D.
and that ATA vide order dated 21.02.2015, in case No. 3ATA/2015, has
rightly held that seniority will be counted w.e.f. the date of
regularization/substantive appointment, not from the date of his
Page No.# 18/50
appointment under Regulation 3(f).
7.3. And in compliance of order dated 14.08.2012, in case No.51
ATA/2010 of the ATA, the Govt. of Assam, Education Department has
issued a Notification, dated 05.11.2014, rectifying the dates of senior
grade scale and selection grade scale in respect of appellants, where it is
clearly mentioned that the benefit arising out of the modified date, as
given in the Notification dated 10.07.2010, shall be confined to the
lecturers whose names appeared in the said notification and it cannot be
cited as a precedent by others. As such, the petitioners cannot take
shelter of the said notification to get any undue benefit. Further, it is
stated that the petitioners will get the benefit of Senior Grade Scale of
Pay, Selection Grade Scale of Pay and any other benefits, if they fulfill the
three conditions laid down vide OM, dated 10.07.2015. As such, the claim
of the petitioners, to count their ad-hoc services, to give the benefit of
Senior Grade Scale of Pay, Selection Grade Scale of Pay is not
maintainable and hence the writ petition is devoid of any merits and is
liable to be dismissed.
8.
In the additional affidavit filed by the respondent No.4, it is stated
that petitioners were appointed under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam
Public Service Commission (Limitation & Functions) Regulation, 1951
temporarily as Lecturers for a period for 4 (four) months, with effect from
the date of their joining. The initial date of joining of the petitioners
under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam Public Service Commission (Limitation
& Functions) Regulation, 1951 are as follows:Sl. No.
Name of the Petitioner
Date
Page No.# 19/50
01.
Dr. Amalendu Choudhury
05.01.1995
02.
Shri Shekhar Chakravarty
09.04.1995
03.
Ms. Debbie Pakhuongte
22.05.1995
04.
Shri Dinesh Tiwari
05.02.1996
05.
Shri Sarobjit Thousen
05.01.1999
06.
Ms. Punyamoni Baruah
24.02.1999
07.
Ms. Valentina Bezeley
23.03.2001
It is also stated that as per the Government Notification No.
B(2)H.286/95/Pt-1/16, dated 26.05.2000, the persons who are working
as Lecturers under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam Public Service
Commission (Limitation & Functions) Regulation, 1951 shall be deemed
to have been regularly appointed to the posts from the dates they were
recommended by the Assam Public Service Commission. The date of
recommendation by the Assam Public Service Commission of the
petitioners are as follows:Sl.
No.
Name of the Petitioner
Recommendation
Notification
Date
01.
Dr. Amalendu Choudhury
B(2)H.286/99/97
12.05.2000
02.
Shri Shekhar Chakravarty
B(2)H.286/99/162
21.11.2000
03.
Ms. Debbie Pakhuongte
B(2)H.286/99/97
12.05.2000
04.
Shri Dinesh Tiwari
B(2)H.286/99/161
21.11.2000
05.
Shri Sarobjit Thousen
B(2)H.57/97/Pt/306
30.08.2003
06.
Ms. Punyamoni Baruah
B(2)H.57/97/Pt/306
30.08.2003
07.
Ms. Valentina Bezeley
B(2)H.57/97/Pt/306
30.08.2003
It is also stated that since the petitioners were not appointed on the
recommendation of the duly constituted Selection Committee and not by
the regular selection, through Assam Public Service Commission and as
Page No.# 20/50
per the provisions of the UGC Regulation 1998 they were eligible for CAS
promotion/counting the seniority from the date of their regular
appointment after recommendation of Assam Public Service Commission,
provided fulfillment of the other eligibility criteria as laid down in the UGC
Regulation and Government Guideline and that no case is made out for
interference of this Court by invoking extra-ordinary jurisdiction.
Submissions of learned counsel for the petitioners:9.
Mr. Das, learned counsel for the petitioners in both the petitions
submits that the petitioners were selected for being appointed as
Lecturers under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam Public Service Commission
(APSC) (Limitation & Functions) Regulations, 1951 in Cotton College and
Diphu College and thereafter, their services were extended from time to
time and also regularized upon recommendation of the APSC, after the
regular selection process. He also submits that the UGC had formulated a
scheme in the year 1998, for revision of pay scale, minimum qualification
for appointments, i.e. Career Advancement Incentive (CAI) etc. and
thereafter, the Govt. of Assam, also issued one Office Memorandum
(O.M.) No. B(2)H.408/99/41, dated 13.01.2000, for implementing the
same.
9.1.
Mr. Das also submits that as per eligibility criteria of UGC Scheme
and OM dated 13.01.2000, the petitioners became eligible for placement
in the Senior Grade Scale and Selection Grade Scale on different dates,
by counting their past services under Regulation 3(f), as their Ad-hoc
services being continuous over one year and as per the UGC Scheme and
the OM dated 13.01.2000, the Ad-hoc services are reckonable for
placement in the Senior Grade Scale and Selection Grade Scale. But, the
Page No.# 21/50
benefit of the said scheme was granted to the petitioners without
counting their past services under Regulation 3(f) though being
reckonable as per Clauses 8.0.0. to 8.6.0 (a), (b) and (c) of the UGC
Scheme of 1998.
9.2.
Further submission of Mr. Das is that because of objections of
some of the deprived Lecturers, a Review Selection Board (RSB) was
constituted, which took fresh decision and a Notification No. AHE
283/2009/Pt-II/46-A, dated 10.08.2010, was issued for placement in the
Senior Grade Scale and Selection Grade Scale, which was subsequently,
withdrawn by another Notification dated 24.09.2010. Thereafter, 4 Nos.
of Lecturers had approached the Assam Administrative Tribunal (AAT), by
filing Appeal Case No. 51 ATA/2010 (Smti. Basanti Medhi & 3 Others)
challenging the impugned Notification dated 24.09.2010 and the Appeal
Case was finally decided vide Judgment & Order, dated 14.08.2012,
whereby the impugned Notification dated 24.09.2010 was set aside and
quashed, thereby, restored the Notification, dated 10.08.2010.
9.3.
He further submits that the then Commissioner and Secretary to
the Government of Assam, preferred a writ petition, being WP(C) No.
6845/2013, before this Court challenging the aforesaid Judgment & Order
dated 14.08.2012 of AAT, which was dismissed vide Order dated
18.12.2013.Thereafter, the Government of Assam, Higher Education
Department, vide Notification No. AHE.283/2009/ Pt-II/48, dated
05.11.2014 (Annexure-16) allowed the modified dates for providing
Senior Grade Scale by reckoning the past Ad-hoc period of those 4 Nos.
of petitioners along with 4 other incumbents and Selection Grade Scale of
Pay to 4 Nos. of petitioners along with 5 (Five) other incumbents. But, in
Page No.# 22/50
the said Notification, it is also provided that the benefits given to those
incumbents cannot be treated as precedent. Thereafter, by another Office
Memorandum, dated 05.11.2014, (Annexure-17), allowed promotion
under Career Advancement Scheme (CAS) to those similarly situated
Lecturers. However, Mr. Das submits that surprisingly, in the last portion
of the said Notification, it has been pointed out that the said promotional
aspect cannot be treated as precedent and the period spent on ad-hoc
shall not be counted towards promotion.
9.4. Lastly, Mr. Das submits that the authority cannot treat similarly
situated persons in different manner, and by the impugned Notification
and the Office Memorandum, the legitimate rights and dues of the
petitioners are denied and being aggrieved, they approached this Court
and there is merit in their claims and therefore, Mr. Das has contended to
allow these petitions.
9.5. Mr. Das has also referred following decisions in support of his
submissions:(i)
State of Karnataka v. C. Lalitha, reported in
(2006) 2 SCC 747;
(ii)
Mahatma Gandhi University v. Rincymol Mathew,
reported in (2022) 16 SCC 727;
(iii) State of Rajasthan & Others vs. Dharmendra Kumar
Jain & Others, reported in 2015 SCC OnLine Raj
8627.
Submissions of learned counsel for the repondents:10.
Per contra, Mr. Gogoi, learned Standing Counsel for the
Page No.# 23/50
respondents has vehemently opposed the petition. Referring to the order
of a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court at page 71 of the WP(C) No.
2556/2015, Mr. Gogoi submits that the UGC Regulation have to be
followed fully. Referring to Regulation 7.2.0 and also 8.6.0 (b), Mr. Gogoi
submits that the petitioners have failed to fulfill the requirement of the
said Regulation. Mr. Gogoi has also drawn the attention of this Court to
Assam Education Service Rules, 1982 and submits that the petitioners
were not selected by the Commission at the time of their initial
appointment. Mr. Gogoi also submits that this Court has already dealt
with the issue of counting of past services during ad-hoc appointment
under Regulation 3(f) and said decisions of this Court was not placed
before the Tribunal. Referring to a decision of a Division Bench of this
Court in Nabin Ch. Bordoloi vs. State of Assam and Others,
reported in 2003(2) GLT 147, Mr. Gogoi submits that in para No. 7 of
the said judgment, it has been held that the services rendered by the
incumbent who has been appointed in exercise of power under
Regulation 3(f) cannot be counted for the purpose of assigning the
seniority.
10.1. Mr. Gogoi also submits that the petitioners have failed to fulfill the
eligibility criteria and as such they are not legally entitled to the benefit
as claimed for and under such circumstances, Mr. Gogoi has contended to
dismiss the petition.
10.2. In support of his submission, he has referred following decisions:(i)
Anup Kumar Das (Dr.) vs. Sanjib
Kakati (Dr.) & Ors, reported in 2000(1) GLT
Page No.# 24/50
429;
(ii)
Rashi Mani Mishra and Ors….. vs.
State of Uttar Pradesh and Ors…, reported in
2021 SCC OnLine SC 509;
(iii)
Malook Singh and Others vs. State of
Punjab and Ors., reported in (2022)17 SCC 765;
(iv)
Rajasthan Agricultural University,
Bikaner through its Registrar vs. Dr. Zabar
Singh Solanki and Others, reported in 2024 SCC
OnLine SC 1885; and
(v)
State of Maharashtra and Another
vs. Tara Ashwin Patel and Others, reported in
(2016) 15 SCC 717.
11. Having heard the submission of learned Advocates of both the
parties, I have carefully gone through the petition and the documents
placed on record and also perused the impugned portions of the
Notification No.AHE.283/2009/Pt-II/48, dated 05.11.2014 (Annexure16) and Office Memorandum, vide No. AHE.283/2009/ Pt-II/49, dated
05.11.2014 (Annexure-17). Also gone through the decisions referred
by Mr. Das, learned counsel for the petitioners and also by Mr. Gogoi,
learned standing counsel for the respondent authorities.
Issue before this Court:12. In view of the contentions being made in their respective pleading
Page No.# 25/50
of the parties and the submissions advanced by their respective counsel,
the issue to be addressed by this Court is formulated as under:(i)
Whether the petitioners are arbitrarily/illegally denied the
benefits of ad-hoc services, while the same was granted to
some of the similarly situated lecturers and whether their
right to equality is violated?
Discussion and Analysis:13. From the contentions being made in the respective pleadings of the
parties and also from the submissions of learned counsel for both the
parties, following facts and circumstances emerges:(i)
The petitioners in WP(C) No. 2556/2015 and
WP(C) No. 3808/2015, were initially appointed as Lecturers
under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam Public Service Commission
(APSC) (Limitation & Functions) Regulations, 1951 in Cotton
College and Diphu College.
(ii)
Thereafter, their services were extended from
time to time. Their services were regularized as Lecturers
upon recommendation of the APSC, after the regular selection
process.
(iii)
The University Grants Commission (UGC), in the
year 1998, had formulated a scheme, notifying revision of pay
scale, minimum qualification for appointments, i.e. Career
Advancement Incentive (CAI) etc.
Page No.# 26/50
(iv)
Then the Govt. of Assam, in the Education
Department, had issued Office Memorandum (O.M.) No.
B(2)H.408/99/41, dated 13.01.2000, for implementing the
same.
(v)
OM
As per eligibility criteria of UGC Scheme and the
dated
13.01.2000,
the
petitioners
of
WP(C)
No.
2556/2015,became eligible for placement in the Senior Grade
Scale on 15.03.2002, 04.09.1998, 27.05.1999, 20.07.2001,
31.08.2000 and 02.09.2000, respectively, and in the Selection
Grade
Scale
on
15.03.2007,
04.09.2003,
27.05.2004,
20.07.2006, 31.08.2005 and 02.09.2005, respectively, by
counting their past services under Regulation 3(f) as their Adhoc services being continuous over one year without any
break.
(vi)
And the petitioners in WP(C) No. 3808/2015,
became eligible for placement in the Senior Grade Scale on
05.01.2001, 19.04.2001, 22.05.2001, 05.02.2002, 25.01.2004,
24.02.2005 and 26.03.2007, respectively and in the Selection
Grade on 05.01.2006, 19.04.2006, 22.05.2006, 05.02.2007,
25.01.2009, 24.02.2010 and 26.03.2012, respectively, by
counting their past services, under Regulation 3(f) as their Adhoc services were continuous over one year, without any
break.
(vii)
Thus, as per the UGC Scheme and the OM,
dated 13.01.2000, the Ad-hoc services are reckonable for
placement in the Senior Grade Scale and Selection Grade
Page No.# 27/50
Scale provided that they are selected by a duly constituted
Selection Committee.
(viii)
Thereafter,
vide
Notification
No.
B(2)H.85/2000/402, dated 24.10.2008, results of the said
selection was published, indicating the respective dates of
placement in the Senior Grade Scale of the petitioners in
WP(C) No. 2556/2015 as 25.06.2005, 27.08.2007, 24.09.2006,
24.09.2006, 31.07.2005 and 31.07.2005, which were incorrect
as the past services rendered by them under Regulation 3(f),
though being reckonable as per Clauses 8.0.0. to 8.6.0 (a),
(b) and (c) of the UGC Scheme of 1998 was not
counted.
(ix)
The petitioners were granted the respective
placements in the Senior Scale Selection Grade, but such
placement being made by ignoring the ad hoc services
rendered by the petitioners under Regulation 3(f), the same is
in contravention of the provisions of the UGC scheme of 1998.
(x)
Thereafter, on objection from some of the
deprived Lecturers, a Review Selection Board (RSB) was
constituted, and vide communication dated 22.07.2010,
modified (reviewed) dates of placement of some other
Lecturers and the Department vide Notification No. AHE
283/2009/Pt-II/46-A, dated 10.08.2010, notified reviewed
dates for placement in the Senior Grade Scale and Selection
Grade Scale. But, subsequently, vide another Notification,
dated 24.09.2010, the reviewed dates were again changed.
Page No.# 28/50
(xi)
Thereafter, 4 Nos. of Lecturers approached the
Assam Administrative Tribunal (AAT), by filing Appeal Case No.
51 ATA/2010 (Smti. Basanti Medhi & 3 Others) challenging the
impugned Notification dated 24.09.2010 and the AAT vide
Judgment & Order dated 14.08.2012, had set aside the
impugned Notification dated 24.09.2010,and restored the
Notification dated 10.08.2010.
(xii)
Thereafter, the respondent No.1 had challenged
the decision of AAT, dated 14.08.2012, by filing a writ petition
vide WP(C) No. 6845/2013 before this Court, which was
dismissed vide Order dated 18.12.2013 and 2 (two) months
time was allowed to the State Govt. to implement the
Judgment & Order dated 14.08.2012 of AAT.
(xiii)
Thereafter,
the
respondent
No.
vide
Notification No. AHE.283/2009/Pt-II/48, dated 05.11.2014
(Annexure-16) allowed the modified dates for providing Senior
Grade Scale by reckoning the past Ad-hoc period of those 4
Nos. of petitioners along with 4 other incumbents and
Selection Grade Scale of Pay to 4 Nos. of petitioners along
with 5 (Five) other incumbents. But, in the last portion of the
said Notification it is mentioned that the benefits given to
those incumbents cannot be treated as precedent.
(xiv)
Notably, the petitioners in WP(C) No. 3808/2015,
had also preferred one appeal, being Appeal Case No.
3ATA/2015 before the Assam Administrative Tribunal praying
for granting to them their respective placements in the Senior
Page No.# 29/50
Scale as well as Selection Grade by reckoning the period of
service rendered by them under Regulation 3(f). However, the
Tribunal, inspite of being apprised of the precedent available
in the matter, had dismissed the appeal, vide order dated
21.02.2015, in a most arbitrary manner.
(xv)
Thereafter, vide another Office Memorandum No.
AHE.283/2009/Pt-II/49, dated 05.11.2014, (Annexure-17),
allowed promotion under Career Advancement Scheme (CAS)
to those similarly situated Lecturers, but surprisingly, in the
last portion of the said Notification, it has been pointed out
that the said promotional aspect cannot be treated as
precedent and the period spent on ad-hoc shall not be
counted towards promotion.
(xvi)
The respondent authority had treated similarly
situated persons in different manner and thereby, deny the
legitimate rights and dues of the petitioners, i.e. the correct
placement dates for grant of Senior Grade Scale, Selection
Grade Scale and consequent promotion under CAS as per the
OM dated 13.01.2000 and the UGC Guidelines.
14. In this context, it would be appropriate to peruse the relevant UGC
Notification on Revision of Pay Scales, minimum qualification for
Appointments of Teachers in Universities, Colleges & other measures for
the Maintenance of Standard, 1998.
7.0.0
CAREER ADVANCEMENT
Page No.# 30/50
7.1.1 Minimum length of service for eligibility to
move into the grade of Lecturer (Senior Scale)
would be four years for those with Ph. D. five
years for those with M.Phil, and six years for
others at the level of Lecturer, and for
eligibility to move into the Grade of Lecturer
(Selection Grade)/Reader, the minimum length of
service as Lecturer (Senior Scale) shall be
uniformly five years.
7.1.2 For movement into grades of Reader and
above, the minimum eligibility criterion would be
Ph.D. Those without Ph.D. can go up to the level
of Lecturer (Selection Grade).
7.1.3 A Reader with a minimum of eight years of
service in that grade will be eligible to be
considered for appointment as a Professor.
7.1.4
The
Selection
Committees
for
Career
Advancement
shall be the same as those for
Direct
Recruitment for each category.
7.1.5 The existing scheme of Career Advancement
for
non academic staff namely, Assistant
Director
of
Physical
Education,
Assistant.
Registrar, Assistant. Librarian would continue.
7.2.0
LECTURER (SENIOR SCALE)
A Lecturer will be eligible for placement in a
senior scale through a procedure of selection, if
she/he has:
(i) Completed 6 years of service after
regular appointment with relaxation of one
year and two years, respectively, for those
with M.Phil. and Ph.D.
(ii) Participated in one orientation course
and one refresher course of approved
duration, or engaged in other appropriate
Page No.# 31/50
continuing
education
programmes
of
comparable quality as may be specified or
approved
by
the
University
GrantsCommission. (Those with Ph.D. degree would
be exempted from one refreshes course).
(iii) Consistently satisfactory performance
appraisal reports,
LECTURER (SELECTION GRADE)
Lectures in the Senior Scale who do not have a
Ph.D. degree or equivalent published work and who
do not meet the scholarship and research
standards, but fulfill the other criteria given
above for the post of Reader and have a good
record
in
teaching
and
preferably,
have
contributed in various ways such as to the
corporate life of the institution, examination
work, or through extension activities, will be
placed in the Selection Grade, subject to the
recommendations of the Selection Committee which
is the same as for promotion to the post of
Reader. They will be designated as Lecturers in
the Selection Grade. They could offer themselves
for fresh assessment after obtaining Ph.D. and/or
fulfilling other requirements for promotion as
Reader and, if found suitable, could be given the
designation of Reader.
8.0.0.
COUNTING OF PAST SERVICE
Previous service, without any break as a Lecturer
or equivalent, in a university, college, national
laboratory, or other scientific organizations,
e.g. CSIR, ICAR, DRDO, UGC, ICSSR, ICHR and as a
UGC Research Scientist, should be counted for
placement of lecturer in Senior Scale/Selection
Page No.# 32/50
Grade provided that:
8.1.0.The post was in an equivalent grade/scale
of pay as the post of a Lecturer,
8.2.0. The qualifications for the post were not
lower than the qualifications prescribed by the
UGC for the post of Lecturer,
8.3.0.The candidates who apply for direct
recruitment
should
apply
through
proper
channels;
8.4.0.The concerned Lecturers possessed the
minimum qualifications prescribed by the UGC for
appointment as Lecturers;
8.5.0. The post was filled in accordance with
the prescribed selection procedure as laid down
by the University/State Government/ Central
Government/Institution's regulations;
8.6.0. The appointment was not ad-hoc or in a
leave vacancy of less than one year duration. Ad
hoc service of more than one year duration can
be counted provided –
(a) the ad hoc service was of more than one
year duration;
(b) the incumbent was appointed on the
recommendation of duly constituted Selection
Committed, and
(c) the incumbent was selected to the
permanent post in continuation to the ad hoc
service, without any break.
15.
To dealt with the issue involved in the present petitions
with greater precision, the impugned Notification (Annexure-16) and
impugned Office Memorandum, dated 5th November (Annexure 17) are
Page No.# 33/50
extracted herein below:GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, DISPUR GUWAHATINOTIFICATION
Dated, Dispur the 5th November, 2014
No. AHE.283/2009/Pt-II/48: In pursuance of the Order dated 14-082012 passed by the Assam Administrative Tribunal in Case No STATA
2010 (filed by Smti Basanti Medhi, Shri Hiren Deka, Dr. Savitri Devi
and Shri Sankar Haloi), the Governor of Asam is pleased to notify
the modified date of Grade Scale and Selection Grade Scale of Pay
which were notified vide Notification No. AHC.283/2009/Pt-II/46
dated 10.07.2010 of the following Lecturers:-
Sl.
No.
Name of the Lecturers for Senior
Grade Scale of Pay
Modified date
of effect
1.
Dr. Garima Kalita, Lecturer in
English, Cotton College, Guwahati
17.09.1994
2.
Dr. Rakhi Kalita, Lecturer in
English, Cotton College, Guwahati
01.09.1996
3.
Smti. Basanti Medhi, Lecturer in
Philosophy, Cotton College, Guwahati
13-06-1998
4.
Dr. Sabitri Devi, Lecturer in
Philosophy, Cotton College, Guwahati
08-02-2002
5.
Dr. Mina Ram Nath, Lecturer in
Botany, Cotton College, Guwahati
28-11-1991
6.
Shri Sankar Haloi, Lecturer in
28-01-2005
Mathematics, Cotton College, Guwahati
7.
Dr. Hiren Deka, Lecturer in
09-08-2001
Mathematics, Cotton College, Guwahati
8.
Dr. Dipali Khargharia Kalita,
Lecturer in Physics, Prince of Wales
Institute Jorhat
16-01-1991
Sl.
No.
Name of the Lecturers for Selection
Grade Scale of Pay
Modified date
of effect
1.
Dr. Garima Kalita, Lecturer in
English, Cotton College, Guwahati
10.09.1998
Page No.# 34/50
2.
Dr. Rakhi Kalita, Lecturer in
English, Cotton College, Guwahati
01.09.2001
3.
Ms. Najma Kausar, Lecturer in
Assamese, Cotton College, Guwahati
17.11.2004
4.
Smti. Basanti Medhi, Lecturer in
Philosophy, Cotton College, Guwahati
13-06-2003
5.
Dr. Sabitri Devi, Lecturer in
Philosophy, Cotton College, Guwahati
08-02-2007
6.
Dr. Mina Ram Nath, Lecturer in
Botany, Cotton College, Guwahati
28-11-1996
7.
Shri Sankar Haloi, Lecturer in
28-01-2010
Mathematics, Cotton College, Guwahati
8.
Dr. Hiren Deka, Lecturer in
09-08-2006
Mathematics, Cotton College, Guwahati
9.
Dr. Dipali Khargharia Kalita,
Lecturer in Physics, Prince of Wales
Institute Jorhat
16-01-1996
The benefit arising out of the modified date as given in the
Notification dated 10-07-2010 shall be confined to the Lecturers
whose names appeared in the said Notification. It cannot be cited as
a precedent by others.
This disposes the order dated 14-08-2012 passed
Administrative Tribunal in Case No.51 ATA/2010
by
the
Assam
Sd.-(H. K. Sharma, IAS)
Commissioner & Secretary to the Govt. of Assam,
Higher Education Department
15.1.
And impugned Office Memorandum, dated 5th November
(Annexure 17) is extracted herein below:-
No.
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
DISPUR GUWAHATI-6
AHE.283/2009/Pt-II/49,
Dated Dispur the
November, 2014.
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
5"
Page No.# 35/50
On being recommended by the State Selection Board (since
dissolved), the Government in the Higher Education
Department issued an order No.AHE. 283/2009/P1-11/46
dated 10-07-2010 whereby modified dates of effect of
Senior Grade Scale of Pay and Selection Grade of Pay in
respect of 9 numbers of Lecturers were notified. It came
to light of the Government that while notifying the
modified dates of Senior Grade Scale of Pay and Selection
Grade of Pay the State Selection Board took into
consideration the period spent on ad-hoc service under
Regulation 3(f) of the APSC Regulations. The Government
rectified the error by issuing another Notification
against which the Lecturers in question, preferred an
appeal in the Assam Administrative Tribunal which was
registered as Case No.51ATA/2010. The Learned Assam
Administrative Tribunal disposed the Case No.51ATA/2010
on 14-08-2012 whereby it get aside the Notification. The
Government in the Higher Education Department restored
the actual date of Senior Grade Scale of Pay and
Selection Grade Scale of Pay in respect of the Lecturers
in
compliance
to
the
order
of
Learned
Assam
Administrative Tribunal given in Case No.51ATA/2010 on
14-08-2012.
The
Government
has
issued
another
Notification allowing Senior Grade Scale of Pay and
Selection Grade Scale of Pay as was recommended by the
State Selection Board.
Although
the
Government
in
the
Higher
Education
Department has allowed CAS Promotion to the Lecturers,
this will not be a principle before the Government
neither will it be a precedent. Period spent on ad-hoc
basis shall not be counted for giving promotion under
CAS.
Sd/-(H. K. Sharma, IAS)
Commissioner & Secretary to the Govt. of
Assam, Higher Education Department
16.
Now, let it be seen what is CAS. In the case of Dr. Zabar
Page No.# 36/50
Singh Solanki and Others (supra), while dealing with the scheme
and its intended purpose, Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the CAS
was distinct to a general increase or revision in pay-scales. The CAS was
intended for a specific purpose i.e., to encourage the teaching staff by
offering a higher pay-scale, subject to various conditions. It has also
been held that whenever a Scheme/Policy is brought into force,
ceteris
paribus, the Court could not and would not import
something which is not present therein and which may not be proper to
be interfered with, especially when it relates to financial matters, where
primacy is required to be granted to the pay-master as to what scale
was to be granted to the category of staff concerned. By its very nature,
such exercise would fall under the realm of policy-formulation. Further, it
has been held that the CAS itself envisaged that it was meant for
persons who were directly recruited as Assistant Professors. The CAS
specifically provided that every Lecturer was to be placed in a senior
scale of Rs.3000-5000 if he/she had completed 8 years of service after
regular appointment.
17. In the instant case, the petitioners have preferred the present writ
petitions with a prayer to reckon their services rendered in ad-hoc
capacity, while determining their eligibility for the grant of senior payscale under the CAS. While dealing with the issue specifically Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in the case of Dr. Zabar Singh Solanki and
Others (supra), has held as under:29. ………………………..
……………………………
Page No.# 37/50
“In
this case, respondents No.1 to 23 9,
before their regular appointment as Assistant
Professors in the University, served on an ad-hoc
basis in other educational institutions and also
in the University. These respondents preferred a
writ petition with a prayer to reckon their
services rendered in such ad-hoc capacity while
determining their eligibility for the grant of
senior pay-scale under the CAS. The relief claimed
was granted by the learned Single Judge and
affirmed by the Division Bench relying on the
judgment in State of Rajasthan vs. Milap Chand
Jain, (2013) 14 SCC 562. This Court, while
disposing of Milap Chand Jain (supra), relied on
its earlier judgment dated 10.03.2011 in Civil
Appeal No.469/2007, entitled State of Rajasthan
vs. Dr. Suresh Chand Agrawal, which was dismissed
in limine, leaving the question of law open.
Review Petitions (Civil) No.2124-2125/2011 filed
in Dr. Suresh Chand Agrawal (supra) were also
dismissed by this Court on 14.09.2011. In Milap
Chand Jain (supra), the State of Rajasthan had
moved this Court in respect of the same impugned
order therein, against which appeals stood
previously dismissed by this Court.
30. Notably, the State Government vide its Letter
dated 20.09.1994, had specifically clarified that
the period of ad-hoc service rendered by the
respondents/Assistant Professors shall not be
counted for giving benefit of senior pay-scale
under the CAS. We have already elaborated supra
(10) that the CAS is essentially a policy, and as
such, the respondents cannot claim, nor would they
have any vested right for claiming that the
Page No.# 38/50
clauses therein be interpreted in a particular
manner. Such an interpretative exercise would have
to be left, in the domain of the appellant,
subject to the State Government’s directives
unless patently perverse or arbitrary. The High
Court, hence, was not justified in counting of the
ad-hoc service rendered by the respondents for
reckoning the period of computation as required
for applying the CAS.”
18. Further, in the case of Nabin Ch. Bordoloi(supra), a Division
Bench of this Court has held that the service rendered by any
incumbent under the appointment made in exercise of power under
Regulation 3(f) of Regulation 1951, cannot be a ground for
regularisation of the incumbent on that basis. For the same reason, the
services rendered by the incumbent cannot be counted for the purpose
of assigning the seniority. The relevant para is extracted herein below:“7.
The Division Bench of this Court has taken a
categorical view that the appointments made under
Regulation 3(f) of Regulation 1951, does not
authorise the very person to claim regularisation on
the basis of appointment made under Regulation 3(f).
Thus, in other words, this Court has held that the
service
rendered
by
any
incumbent
under
the
appointment
made
in
exercise
of
power
under
Regulation 3(f) of Regulation 1951, cannot be a
ground for regularisation of the incumbent on that
basis. For the same reason, the services rendered by
the incumbent cannot be counted for the purpose of
assigning the seniority.”
Page No.# 39/50
19.
It is also to be noted here that while dismissing the appeal
being Appeal Case No. 3ATA/2015 (Annexure-13), preferred by the
petitioners of WP(C) No. 3808/2015, the Assam Administrative Tribunal,
while interpreting UGC Regulation 8.6.0 (f) has held that the words
used in the said clause are “duly constituted Selection Committee” and
duly constituted would mean constituted as per the rules laid down for
the selection of lecturer. The rules lay down that the selection of
lectures would be done by the APSC. The duly constituted Selection
Committee would, therefore, be a Committee that has been constituted
for this purpose by the APSC. All these appointments have been made
by a Committee constituted by the Government in the Education
Department.
They
have
not
been
made
on
the
basic
of
recommendations made by a duly constituted Selection Committee.
The stipulation laid down by Sub Clause (f) of clause 8.6.0 of the UGC
guidelines is, therefore, not fulfilled by these appointees.
19.1. The Tribunal has also dismissed the appeal on another ground
i.e. there is a Ruling of the Gauhati High Court which has dealt with this
issue specifically in the case of Anup Kumar Das (Supra), wherein
this Court has specifically held "the respondent petitioner will be entitled
to seniority with effect from the date of his regularization/substantive
appointment on 07.04.1987, and not from the date of his appointment
under regulation 3(f)".
19.2. Notably, in the case of Anup Kumar Das(supra),so referred by
Mr. Gogoi, learned Standing Counsel for the respondents another
Division Bench of this Court has held that the services rendered by an
incumbent to a post appointed under Regulation 3(f) is not to be
Page No.# 40/50
counted for the purpose of seniority. The relevant paragraph is
extracted herein below:“(9.)
It would appear that the instructions
provide for regularisation of the appointees made
under Regulation 3(a) and 3(f) of the Assam Public
Service Commission (Limitations of Functions)
Regulation, 1951 within the time limit specified
in the Regulation itself. We have carefully
examined the provisions of the Regulation of 1951
and we do not find any provision enabling the
authority to regularise the services of the 3(f)
appointees. The question for application of the
Executive Instructions contained in the above
circular will arise only when the appointments
made under Regulation 3(f) are regularised in
accordance with the provisions of the rules, if
any. But, in the instant case, there being no
provision incorporated in the Regulation to this
effect, we are of the definite opinion
that the conception of regularisation of the
services of the appointees under Regulation 3(f)
is also de-hors the rules. We are of the further
opinion that when a person is appointed under
Regulation 3(f), he has no option but to appear
before the Commission for consideration of his
case for recommendation when the post is
advertised and in the event he is recommended and
appointed, he will be entitled to all service
benefits with effect from the date of such
substantive appointment. The provisions contained
in Para-10.2(b) has no application in cases where
ad-hoc appointments are made de-hors the rules
under
Regulation
3(f)
and
regularised
Page No.# 41/50
subsequently. Therefore, the services rendered by
an incumbent to a post appointed under Regulation
3(f) is not to be counted for the purpose of
seniority.”
19.3. It is to be noted here that the petitioners, in both the petitions,
have made a specific averment in their petitions in para No. 7, in WP(C)
No. 2556/2015 and in para No. 10, in WP(C) No. 3808/2015, that their
initial appointment, under Regulation 3(f) were made after a due
selection process. However, the respondent No.4 in its affidavit in
opposition has refuted the same by stating categorically that the
incumbents were not appointed on the recommendation of
duly constituted Selection Committee, and the procedure, as
laid down in the UGC Regulation, 1998, is found to be not followed as
the petitioners were not appointed on the recommendation
of the duly constituted Selection Committee and also not
by the regular selection through Assam Public Service
Commission. It is also stated that the petitioners were initially
appointed under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam Public Service
Commission (Limitation and Functions) Regulation, 1951 for a period of
4 (four) months, and that as per UGC Regulations, 1998, they were
eligible for CAS promotion/counting the seniority from the date of their
regular appointment after recommendation of Assam Public Service
Commission, provided fulfillment of the other eligibility criteria as laid
down in the UGC Regulation and Government Guideline.
19.4. As stated herein above, after the Regulation of the University
Grants Commission (UGC), in the year 1998, being notified, formulating
Page No.# 42/50
the scheme for revision of pay scale, minimum qualification for
appointments, i.e. Career Advancement Incentive (CAI) etc., the Govt.
of Assam, in the Education Department, had also issued Office
Memorandum (O.M.) No. B(2)H.408/99/41, dated 13.01.2000, for
implementing the same. Said O.M. is enclosed as Annexure 7 in
W.P.(C) No. 2556/2015 and 6 in W.P.(C) No. 3808/2015,
respectively, in both the writ petitions. Clause 1 of the said O.M.
provides for recruitment and qualification, which read as under:(1) Recruitment and qualifications:- The direct recruitment to
the post of Lecturers, Readers and Professors in the Universities and
Colleges shall be on the basis of merit through all India
advertisement and selections are to be made by the duly constituted
Selection Committee, to be set up under the statutes/ordinances of
the concerned Universities or under the State Govt. Rules, framed
for selection of Lecturers in Colleges. Besides, such appointment
would be subject to appropriate Reservation quota, under State
Govt. Acts and Rules.
19.5. But, nowhere in the said O.M. counting of ad-hoc service for
granting career advancement for placement in senior scale, selection
grade is provided.
19.6. Further, from the order of the AAT in Appeal Case No.3
ATA/2015, it appears that while interpreting the word duly constituted
selection committee, it had recorded a finding that the rules lay down
that the selection of lectures would be done by the APSC. The duly
constituted Selection Committee would, therefore, be a Committee that
has been constituted for this purpose by the APSC. It has also been
Page No.# 43/50
held that the appointments of the appellants (herein the petitioners in
WP(C) No. 3808/2015, have been made by a Committee constituted by
the Government in the Education Department. They have not been
made on the basis of recommendations made by a duly constituted
Selection Committee. The stipulation laid down by Sub Clause (f) of
clause 8.6.0 of the UGC guidelines is, therefore, not fulfilled by these
appointees.
19.7. This finding, however, having not been challenged before any
higher forum, has already attained finality. In that view of the matter,
the submission of Mr. Das, learned counsel for the petitioners that the
petitioners were selected by a duly constituted selection committee,
cannot be concurred with, while such contention is specifically refuted
in the affidavit by the respondent No.4, in both the petitions.
19.8. It is also to be noted here that Rule 5 of the Assam Education
Service Rules, 1982 deals with method of recruitment of Lecturers of
Government Degree Colleges and Sub-Rule (1) to Rule 5 provides that
recruitment to the posts of Lecturers shall be made by direct
recruitment only and Rule 6 provides for direct recruitment to the post
of Lecturers shall made by the Government on the basis of
recommendation made by the Commission, in accordance with the
procedure provided in Sub-Rule (1), which read as under:“6. Direct recruitment.
(1) Direct recruitment to the posts mentioned in
sub-R. (1) of R. 5 shall be made by the Government
on the basis of recommendation made by the
Commission
in
accordance
with
procedure
hereinafter provided –
Page No.# 44/50
(a) Before the end of each year the Government
shall make an assessment regarding the
likely number of vacancies to be filled up
by direct recruitment during the next year
and shall intimate the same to the
Commission, together with the details
about reservation for candidates belonging
to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
or any other category as provided under R.
15.
(b)
The
Government
shall
simultaneously
request the Commission to recommend a list
of candidates for direct recruitment in
order of preference.
(c)
The Commission may hold such test or
interview as may be considered necessary.
(d)
The Commission shall furnish to the
Government
a
list
of
candidates
recommended by it in order of preference,
found suitable for direct recruitment. The
number of candidates in such a list may be
approximately
double
the
number
of
vacancies.
(e)
The
Commission
shall
simultaneously
publish the list in the Assam Gazette and
such other place as the Commission may
consider proper.”
19.9. Therefore, the duly constituted Selection Committee, herein this
case, is the Committee constituted by the APSC, as per the Assam
Education Service Rules, 1982. In the case in hand, admittedly, the
Selection Committee, by which the petitioners were selected, is not the
Committee constituted under the Rules, 1982.
Page No.# 45/50
19.10.
That being so, it cannot be said that the petitioners were
selected by a duly constituted Selection Committee, which herein this
case is the Committee constituted by the APSC, not by Committee
constituted by the Education Department for being selected the
petitioners under Regulation 3(f) of the Assam Public Service
Commission (Limitation & Functions) Regulations, 1951. For ready
reference, said provision is extracted herein below:“Regulation - 3.
It shall not be necessary for the Commission to be
consulted
in
matters
relating
to
methods
of
recruitment to civil services and post or the
suitability of the candidates for such appointments,
in the following cases, namely –
*
*
*
*
*
(f) when an appointment is to be made by direct
recruitment to a temporary post created in a
service, if it is necessary in the public
interest that the appointment should be made
immediately and reference to the Commission
would cause undue delay; provided that if the
post has been sanctioned for, or is likely to
last for more than four months, the Commission
shall, as soon as possible, be consulted in
all matters mentioned in sub-clause 3 of
Article 320 of the Constitution.”
19.11.
In view of above,the submission of Mr. Das, learned counsel
for the petitioners, that the petitioners were selected by a duly
constituted Selection Committee, left this Court unimpressed. It cannot
be accepted that the petitioners have been able to demonstrate that
Page No.# 46/50
they were selected by a duly constituted selection committee as per Act
and Rules as provided in the Regulation 8.6.0.(b) of the UGC, though
they have successfully demonstrated that they have fulfilled the other
two criteria, i.e., (a) and (c) of the said Regulation and also the
requirement of clause 1 of the O.M., dated 13.01.2000.
20.
Mr. Das, however, submits that in the two decisions, i.e., in the
case of Nabin
Ch.
Bordoloi
(Supra) and Anup
Kumar
Das
(Supra), counting of ad-hoc service for the purpose of seniority has
been dealt with, and the case of the petitioners in these two writ
petitions, relate to counting of ad-hoc service for the purpose of
granting CAS benefit to them.
20.1. Mr. Gogoi, learned Standing Counsel for the State respondents,
however, submits that such a submission is devoid of any force
inasmuch as the CAS was formulated to grant the Lecturers (Senior
Scale) as per Clause 7.2.0 and Lecturers (Selection Grade) as per the
same Clause, and all are based upon seniority.
20.2. There appears to be substance in the submission of Mr. Gogoi,
learned Standing Counsel for the State respondents. And a careful
perusal of Clause 7.2.0, indicates that the same was formulated to
place the lecturers in Senior Scale and in the Selection Grade.
Therefore, the submission of Mr. Das, learned counsel for the
petitioners, cannot be accepted.
21. This Court has also considered the contention of the petitioners
and also submission of their counsel that the authority cannot treat
similarly situated persons in different manner. Indisputably, after the
Page No.# 47/50
decision of AAT in Appeal Case No. 51 ATA/2010, and the same having
been affirmed by this Court in WP(C) No. 6845/2013, the respondent
authorities had implemented the same, granting benefit to the
appellants of the Appeal Case No. 51 ATA/2010 counting their ad-hoc
service period. The decision referred by Mr. Das, learned counsel for
the petitioners in C. Lalitha (supra) also fortified the same to some
extent.
“29. Service
jurisprudence evolved by this Court
from time to time postulates that all persons
similarly situated should be treated similarly.
Only because one person has approached the court
that would not mean that persons similarly
situated should be treated differently. It is
furthermore well settled that the question of
seniority should be governed by the rules. It may
be true that this Court took notice of the
subsequent events, namely, that in the meantime
she
had
also
been
promoted
as
Assistant
Commissioner which was a Category I post but the
direction to create a supernumerary post to adjust
her must be held to have been issued only with a
view to accommodate her therein as otherwise she
might have been reverted and not for the purpose
of conferring a benefit to which she was not
otherwise entitled to.”
21.1. There is, however, no quarrel about the proposition of law so
laid down in the said case. But, in view of well settled proposition of
law laid by two Division Bench of this Court in Anup Kumar Das
(supra)and also in the case of Nabin Ch. Bordoloi(supra), and
also by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case Dr. Zabbar Singh
Solanki and Ors.(supra), this Court is of the view that the
Page No.# 48/50
decision of AAT in Appeal Case No. 51 ATA/2010, and the decision of
this Court in WP(C) No. 6845/2013, affirming the said decision would
not advance the argument of the learned counsel for the petitioners.
Moreover, the decision of this Court in W.P.(C) No. 6845/2013, cannot
be read as a binding precedent, in view of the fact that the two
decisions of Divisions Bench of this Court, were not placed before the
learned Single Judge, at the time of deciding the WP(C) No.
6845/2013, and also in view of the proposition of law, laid down by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of National Insurance Company
Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680.
Therefore, grant of benefit to some of the similarly situated persons,
on the strength of the decision of AAT in Appeal Case No. 51ATA/2010,
and the same be affirmed in WP(C) No. 6845/2013, cannot be said to
be backed by any rule of law and on such count, the respondent
authorities, while granting the benefit had rightly recorded in the
impugned portion of the Notification, dated 05.11.2014, that the
promotional aspect cannot be read as a precedent. It is well settled
that if a benefit is irregularily granted to one person or groups, without
any legal basis, others cannot claim the same under parity. Reference
in this context can be made to a decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of State of Bihar vs. Kameshwar Prasad Singh,
reported in (2000) 9 SCC 94. Reference can also be made to a three
Judge Bench decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of R.
Muthukumar vs. Chairman and Managing Directory TANGEDCO,
reported in 2022 SCC Online SC 151, wherein it has been held that
Article 14 of the Constitution of India does not permit ‘negative
Page No.# 49/50
equality’ meaning as illegal or unjustified benefit given to same cannot
be extended to others as a right and as such, to the considered
opinion of this Court the proposition of law laid down in the case of C.
Lalitha(supra), also would not advance the argument of Mr. Das,
learned counsel for the petitioners.
22. This Court has also considered the other points, so raised by Mr.
Das, learned counsel for the petitioners and also gone through the
decisions referred by him and also considered the submissions
advanced by Mr. Gogoi, learned Standing Counsel for the respondent
authorities and the decisions referred by him. But, in the view of the
finding, so recorded on the core issue, as above, further, directing a
discussion to other limbs of argument, so advanced by them, are found
to be a futile exercise. There is, however, no quarrel about the
proposition of law laid down in the cases referred by learned counsel
for both the parties. But, to deal with the issue involved herein these
petitions, references to all those decisions are found to be not
necessary, except however, what has been discussed herein above.
Conclusion:23. Under the given factual and legal matrix, the issue, so formulated
herein above, has to be answered in negative and accordingly, the
same stands answered.
24. In the result, this Court finds no merit in these petitions. And
accordingly, both the writ petitions stand dismissed, leaving the parties
Page No.# 50/50
to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review