Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34e{ I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE ELEVENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
petition under Article 227 ofthe Constitution of lndia, aggrieved by the Order
dated 28.1O.ZO2S passed in C.E.P. No. 17 ot 2022 in C.O.P.No.6 of 2022 on the file of
the Court of the Special Court Jor Trial and Disposal of Commercial Disputes,
Rangareddy District.
Between:
Dr. Abid Ali Khan, S/o Late Mazharuddin Ali Khan, Aged about 28 years, Occ'
Doctor, R/o 6-2-30/C, Orthocare Clinic, Lakdikapool, Adjacent to Daulat Plaza,
Khairtabad, Hyderabad -500004.
...Petitioner/Judgement Debtor No.2
AND
54 years,
l. Mrs. Afia Rasheed Khan, Wo Late Mazharuddin Ali Khan, Aged about
MLA Colony'
Occ. Housewife Rto 8-2-293t821HHt82, Plot No. 82, HUDA Heights,
Road No.12, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad - 500034.
...Respondent No.1/Decree Holder
Z. Dr. ZainaAli Khan, D/o Late Mazharuddin Ali Khan, Aged about 26 years, Occ.
Doctor, R/o 8-1-21l93, Suryanagar Colony Tolichowki, Hyderabad, Telangana 500008
...Respondent No.2/Judgement Debtor No.3
3. Dr.Mazharuddin Ali Khan (Died) R (Not necessary)
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2025
Petition uttder Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to dismiss the
l.A. No. 2 of 2025 in the present Revision Petition by vacating the interim stay granted
on 21.11.2025 by this Hon'ble Court and may be pleased to direct the concerned
Station House Officer to extend adequate police protection to the Petitioner I
Respondent for the effective implementation and execution of the orders passed in
C.O.P. No. 6 c,f 2022, as specifically directed in E.A. No. 42 of 2024 enabling the
Petitioner I Respondent to peacefully retain and enjoy possession of her Schedule
Properties and ensuring non-interference by the Revision Petitioner. or any person
claiming througlt or under him and restraining and preventing the Revision Petitioner,,
his staff, employees, agents, henchmen or associates from causing any obstruction,
intimidation, threats, abuse or interference with the Petitioner / Respondent's laMul
possession and enjoyment of the Schedule Properties;
Counsel for ther Petitioner
assisted by Manasvi Reddy Jakka
: Sri Vikram Pooserla, Senior Counsel
Counsel for ther Respondent No.1
Sri D.R.Hari Prasad
: Dr. G.V.Rao, Senior Counsel assisted by
The Court mad,a the following
ORDER
L
HIGH COT'RT F.OR TIIE STATE OF TILANGANA
AT IIYDERABAD.
****
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
DATE ,ll-o,3-2o126
Between :
Dr.Abid AIi Khan
Petitioner
And
Mrs. Afia Rasheed Khan and two others.
Respondents.
ORDER:firer Hon'ble Justie Gadi Praueen Kumarl
Heard Mr.Vikram Pooserla, learned Senior Counsel assisted by
Ms.Manasvi Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioner and Dr.G.V.Rao,
learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr.D.R.Hari Prasad, learned counsel for
the respondent No.1.
2.
This Civil Revision Petition is filed by the revision petitioner/judgment
debtor No.2 challenging the order dated 28.LO.2O25 passed in C.E.P. No.17
of 2022 in C.O.P.No.6 of 2022 by the learned Special Court for Trial and
Disposal of Commercial Disputes, Ranga Reddy District (for short
Commercial Court), whereby the learned Commercial Court directed
removal of unauthorized boards from the petition schedule properties and
further ordered arrest and detention of the revision petitioner in civil prison
for a period of thirty (3O) days for wilful disobedience of the injunction order
dated L2.OT.2022 passed in C.O.P. No.6 of 2O22 under Section 9 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short, the 1996 Act).
3.
The b::ief facts of the case are that revision petitioner/ judgment
debtor No.2 is the son and respondent No.l/decree holder is the mother
herein. Judgment Debtor No. 1, Respondent No.l and Respondent No.2
entered into a partnership and established a lirm under the name and style
of 'M/s. Grer:n Acres Resorts' uide Partnership Deed dated 10.09.2003. The
partnership firm was established with capital contributions from the
partners ancl from out of such partnership funds, acquired two extents of
immovable Jrroperties, namely: (i) land admeasuring Acs.16.962 guntas in
Sy.Nos.386 (part) and 387 (part) situated at Manchirevula Village, Gandipet
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District (Schedule-A Property), and (ii) land
admeasuringl Acs.49.15 guntas in various survey numbers situated at
Damargidda Village, Chevella Mandal, Ranga Reddy District (Schedule-B
Property). These properties are collectively referred to as the Schedule
Properties.
4-
Respolrdent No.l was managing the affairs of the lirm, while the
judgment debtor No.1 was engaged in his medical profession. Subsequently,
respondent No.2 retired from the partnership under a deed dated
19.08.2013 and the petitioner/judgment debtor No.2, being the son of
respondent l\o.1 and judgment debtor No.l, was inducted as a partner in
the firm. Subsequently, disputes emerged between the parties in relation to
the administration, management and effective control of the schedule
properties. In the year 2022, respondent No.l fiIed C.O.P. No.6 of 2022
under Section 9 of the L996 Act before the learned Commercial Court
seeking interim protection in respect of the schedule properties. By order
dated 72.07.2022, the learrred Commercial Court granted a mandatory
injunction directing removal of certain boards erected over the schedule
properties and further restrained the revision petitioner from alienating,
creating third-party rights or interfering with the properties pending arbitral
proceedings.
5.
Alleging wilful disobedience of the said injunction order, respondent
No.l initiated execution proceedings in C.E.P. No.17 of 2022 under Order
XXI Rule 32 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 19O8 (for short, .CPCJ seeking
enforcement of the injunction and consequential arrest and detention of the
judgment debtors. The Executing Court after considering the facts and
circumstances of the case is satisfied that obstruction is caused. by
judgment debtor Nos.1 and 2 and directed removal of boards and detention
of the revision petitioner in civit prison for 30 days by order dated
28.10.2025, which gives rise to the filing of the present Civil Revision
Petition.
6.
Learned counsel for the revision petitioner contends that the
impugned order dated 28.10.2025 passed in C.E.P. No.17 of 2022 is wholly
unsustainable in law and on facts. tt is subrnitted that the Executing Court
has mechanically ordered arrest and detention without satis$ring the
mandatory preconditions contemplated under Section 51 of CPC read with
Order XXI Rule 32 of CPC. According to the petitioner, the order reflects
non-application of mind and is liable to be set aside.
T.
It is further contended that the injunclion order dated 12.07.2022
passed in O.O.P. No.6 of 2022 had already been complied with by the
revision petitioner. A11 boards allegedly erected over the schedule properties
were removed immediately after the order was passed. Therefore, there was
no subsistilg act of willful disobedience as on the date of filing or
adjudication of the execution petition. In the absence of continued violation,
the question of invoking coercive detention does not arise.
8.
Learnr:d counsel for the revision petitioner strongly urges that no
affidavit or application as required under Order XXI Rule 11A of CPC was
filed by the rlecree holder seeking arrest. It is submitted that Rule 11A is in
consonance with the proviso to Section 51 of CPC and mandates disclosure
of specific grounds justiSing arrest. In the absence of such compliance, the
Executing C)ourt lacked jurisdiction to order detention. To support his
contention, Learned counsel placed reliance on the decision of the Honble
Supreme Cc,urt in the case of Bhudea Mallick @ Bhudeb Mo,llick tt/s.
Ranajit Gh,oshaF to contend that omission to comply with Rule 11A of
Order XXI of CPC constitutes a jurisdictional defect.
9.
It is also contended by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the
Executing Court failed to record a clear and categorical Iinding of "wilful"
disobedience, as required under Order XXI Rule 32(1) of CPC. Learned
counsel submits that wilfulness implies conscious, deliberate and
intentional violation despite having opportunity to comply. According to him,
' 2ozs scconline sc 350
'\'\\\
\
no such finding based on cogent material has been recorded and the order
proceeds merely on assertions of the decree holder.
10. Learned counsel further submits that the Executing Court did not
afford an opportunity to the petitioner to comply with the order of injunction
before resorting to arrest. It is averred that detention in civil prison is a
drastic measure affecting personal liberty and can be ordered only as a last
resort.
11. It is also contended that sub-rule (5) of Order XXI Rule 32 of CPC
provides an alternative mechanism whereby the act required to be done
under the decree may be carried out through a third party at the cost of the
judgment debtor. The petitioner argues that the Executing Court ought to
have invoked such mechanism before ordering detention. Reliance is placed
on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Sannee Khan
u/s. Bindu Khan2 to contend that coercive detention is not intended to be
punitive but only to secure compliance.
L2. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the impugned
order is punitive in nature and contrary to the settled principle that
execution under Order XXI Rule 32 of CPC is not meant to punish past
disobedience but to secure obedience of a subsisting decree. Once the act
directed by the decree is perforrned or capable of being performed through
Court process, detention serves no lawful purpose-
'1rssa1 7 scc s9
\
13. It is elso contended that the Executing Court failed to consider \..
material devt:lopments in the arbitral proceedings, including the Memo of
Undertaking filed by the petitioner before the Arbitral Tribunal and the
subsequent prl66sdural order recording mutual assurances. According to the
petitioner, tttese developments demonstrate his bona ftd.e conduct and
negate any allegation of wilful violation. Suppression of these events by the
decree holder, it is argued, vitiates the impugned order.
14. Learne<l counsel raises constitutional objections, contending that
arrest and detention of a medical practitioner running a nursing home
infringes his Jundamental right to personal liberty under Article 21 and his
right to practice profession under Article 19(1Xg) of the Constitution of India.
It is submitted that the impugned order is disproportionate, arbitrary and
harsh, partictrlarly in the absence of strict proof of wilful disobedience. On
all these groutlds, the petitioner seeks setting aside of the impugned order.
15- On the other hand, learned senior counsel for respondent No.l
submits that r-he present Civil Revision Petition is wholly misconceived and
is an attempt to re-agitate findings of fact recorded by the Executing Court
after full-fledgr:d adjudication, the injunction order dated 12.OT.2022 passed
in C.O.P. No.6 of 2022 under Section 9 of the Lgg6 Act has attained finality,
as the revisiorL petitioner never challenged the same before a higher forum.
Having allowed the order to become final and binding, the petitioner cannot
now indirectly question its enforcement-
16. Learned counsel further contended that the violation of the injunction
order was continuous and deliberate. Respondent No.l was compelled to
initiate execution proceedings under Order XXI Rule 32 of CPC due to
persistent obstruction and interference by the revision petitioner. During the
course of execution, respondent No.l examined herself as PW-l and.also
examined independent witnesses as PW-2 and PW-3, who corroborated the
acts of obstruction and non-compliance. It is submitted that despite being
given sufficient opportunity, the revision petitioner neither effectively cross-
examined the witnesses nor adduced rebuttal evidence. Therefore, the
f-rnding of wilful disobedience is based on unrebutted oral evidence and
cannot be termed perverse.
17. Learned senior counsel submits that the objection regarding non-filing
of a separate application under Order XXI Rule 11A of CPC is purely
technical and devoid of substance. It is argued that the execution petition
itself, along with the supporting affidavit, clearly set out the grounds
constituting wilful disobedience and the necessit5r for arrest. Rule 11A
requires disclosure of grounds and not a separately captioned application.
Substantial compliance having been made, the Executing Court rightly
exercised its jurisdiction under Section 51 of CPC read with Order XXI Rule
32 of CPC.
18. It is further contended that sub-rule (5) of Order XXI Rule 32 of CPC
is inapplicable in the present case. The decree in question restrains
interference and obstruction, which are personal acts. Such obligations
cannot be performed by a third party on behalf of the judgment debtor.
Therefore,theExecutingCourtrightlyinvokedcoercivedetentionunder
sub-rule(1),e.Stheobligationwasinherentlypersonalandcontinued
disobedience w:ls e
stablished
Lg.Inarned'r:ounselalsosubmitsthatdetentionunderorderXXlRule32
nature' intended to secure obed'ience
is not prunitive but coercive in
of CpC
ofthedecree.Inthepresentcase,despitepoliceprotectionordersand
in disobedience' leaving the
opportunities, the petitioner persisted
repeated
to resort to detention. The order is therefore
but
alternative
no
with
court
emd in accordance with law'
proportionate
20. with regard.to the scope of revisional
the High cour'; cannot re-appreciate
jurisdiction' it is contended that
evidence or substitute its own findings
for those recorded by the Executing
court. Reliance is placed upon the
judgmentoft.heHon,bleSupremeCourtinGirrlndheVijogKumara/s.
in revisional jurisdiction the Court cannot
Illuljis, wherein it was held that
first appeal
act as a secor.d court of
of fact unless '-hey are
and interfere with concurrent Iindings
illegal or pelverse'
21. Further reliance is placed upon
the case of Hindustan
the constitution Bench judgment in
petroreum corporation Ltd. a/s. D*hahor singw,
whereinthe!{on,bleSupremeCourtcategoricallyheldthatHighCourt,s
or
jurisdiction is limited and does not permit re-appreciation
revisional
reassessment of evidence merely
lower appe[are authority. The
'o 51otsl L2scc576
QowlgsccTS
because it holds a different view from the
High court may interfere onl5r where findings
of fact are perverse, based on no evidence, involve misreading or nonconsid.eration of material evidence, or are so grossly erroneous that they
result in miscarriage of justice. Revisional power is supervisory in nature
and cannot be equated with appellate power to reconsider all questions of
fact.
22. lrarned counsel for respondent No.1 submits that in the present case
the Executing Court recorded a categorical finding of wilful and continued
disobedience based on oral and documentary evidence' No jurisdictional
error, itlegality or material irregularity is demonstrated' The contentions of
the petitioner regarding Articles 2l and 19(1)(g) of the constitution of India
are also misconceived, as detention is ordered strictly in accordance with
procedure established by [aw. Therefore, it is prayed that the Civil Revision
Petition be dismissed with costs.
23. We have given our earnest considerations to the contentions of both
the parties and perused the entire material placed on record.
24. The main point for consideration is whether the Executing Court was
justified in ordering the arrest and detention of the revision petitioner for
wilful disobed.ience of the injunction order dated L2.o7.2022. The injunction
order passed in c.o.P. No.6 of 2022 directed the revision petitioner to
him from
remove the boards erected on the Schedule Properties, restrained
interfering with the properties or creating third-party rights. It is
an
admitted fact that the said order was not challenged before any appellate
forum and has therefore attained finalit5r. Once an order of injunction 1
becomes final, the parties are bound to obey in strict sense.
25. The case of the petitioner is that he removed all the boards
immediately after the order and that there was no violation. However,
respondent No.1 alleged that the boards were not properly removed and that
interference with the properties continued even after the injunction. In
support of ht:r case, she was examined herself as PW-l and also examined
two indepenclent witnesses as PW-2 and PW-3 before the Executing Court.
They stated that the petitioner continued to obstruct and interfere with the
Schedule Properties. She further alleged that when she attempted to assert
her rights ov{:r the partnership properties, she was obstructed, abused and
even physically manhandled by the judgment debtors.
26. The re<:ord further discloses that the petitioner was given suflicient
opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses and to adduce evidence on his
behalf. However, no convincing material was placed before the Executing
Court to establish complete and bona fide compliance of the injunction
order. No proof was liled to demonstrate that the order was obeyed. After
considering t:he evidence on record, the Executing Court came to the
conclusion that the disobedience was wilful.
27. Wilful disobedience under Order XXI Rule 32 of CPC rr.reans
intentional arrd deliberate violation of a Court order despite knowledge. In
the present ,:ase, the evidence on record shows that petitioner did not
remove the boards even after passing tJle injunction order and that
respondent No.1 was subjected to obstruction and humiliation. Such
conduct cannot be treated as accidental or unintentional. The finding of the
Executing Court that the disobedience was wilful is therefore supported by
evidence and cannot be said to be arbitrary.
28- The contention regarding non-filing of a separate application under
Order XXI Rule 11A of CPC is only technical in nature. The execution
petition itself contained detailed averments regarding the acts of
disobedience and was supported by an affidavit. The petitioner was served
with notice, entered appearance and contested the matter on merits.
Therefore, it cannot be said that he was prejudiced or that the Executing
Court lacked jurisdiction.
29- The contention that tle Court should have adopted some other
method instead of ordering detention is also not acceptable in the facts of
this case. The injunction was mainly to restrain personal acts of
interference. Such conduct cannot always be corrected by asking a third
party to perform an act. If interference continues despite a clear order of the
Court, t}-re Court is empowered under Order XXI Rule 32 of CpC to order
detention to secure obedience.
30. It is important to note that detention under Order XXI Rule 32 of CpC
is not meant to punish, but to ensure compliance with the Court's order. In
this case, the Executing Court recorded that the violation continued even
after sufficient opportunities were provided. The detention ordered is only for
thirty days and is within the limits as prescribed by law.
L2
31. In this backdrop, the nature of the dispute also assumes relevance. In
the Indian s6cial context, the relationship between a mother and son is
regarded as siacred one and rooted in gratitude, care and lifelong respect.
When the exr:cution proceedings themselves arise out of allegations by a
mother that lrer own Son has abused her, prevented her from enteriqrg a
propert5r in which she has a lawful share and even physically manhandled
her, the matter cannot be viewed in isolation as a mere commercial or
partnership Cisagreement. Property disputes may arise in any family;
however, suc,h disputes can never justify conduct that undermines the
dignity, securit5r, and lawful entitlements of a parent'
32. Viewed from this perspective, if the allegations of obstruction, verbal
abuse, and physical intimidation are found to be true, such conduct would
not only con:stitute wilful disobedience of a binding Court order but would
also reflect a serious breach of familial and societal obligations. The power
under Order XXI Rule 32 of CPC is invoked precisely in circumstances
where compliance is deliberately withheld and where the authority of the
Court must tre uPheld.
33. Accordingly, while the Court is primarily concerned with enforcement
of its decree, it cannot be oblivious to the human dimension underlying the
dispute. Colrts adjudicate legal rights, but they do so within a social
framework that values dignity, especially of parents seeking protection of
their lawful r;hare and'personal security. Even amidst adversarial litigation,
the conduct ,:f parties is expected to exhibit restraint and basic civility, more
so where the contest is between a mother and her son. Therefore, the order
fi
i.'
of detention, being proportionate and tegally sanctioned,
cannot be faulted
either on statutory or equitable considerations'
34. on consideration of the above facts and circumstances'
satisfied that the Executing Court has given cogent
holding that the petitioner has wilfully disobeyed
that coercive steps were necessary to secure
this court is
and valid reasons for
the injunction order and
strict compliance of the order of
executing court dated, 2g.to.2o25. As such,
the impugned order does not
suffer from any illegality or material irregularity
warranting interference of
this Court
shall be no
35. Accordingly, the civil Revision Petition is d'ismissed' There
if any' shall also
order as to costs. Pending miscellaneous applications,
stand dismissed
36.Afterpronouncingtheord'erintheopenCourt,Mr.VikramPooserla,
learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner sought for suspension of
of the order'
the sentence for a period of four weeks for compliance
senior counsel
37. To meet the ends of justice, the request of the learned
impugned order including
is accorded by suspending the operation of the
debtor for a period
arrest and detention of the revision petitioner'/judgment
of four (O4) weeks from todaY'
D'. P.PONNA KRISHNA
STAN T REGIS
,/TRUE COPYI/
SECTION OFFICER
I
To,
1.
The Special Courts for Trial ad
Disposal of
Disputes RangareddY
Distict at L.B.Nagar'
REDDY JAKKA Advocate [OPUCI
2. One CC to SRl. MANASVI
BARIA Advocate [OPUC]
One CC to SRl. SHIREEN SETHNA
Two CD CoPies
BA/PSL
4,a
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1110312026
t
{
t
I
ORDER
TI.IE s
O
1 2 fiAq ?n?fi
*
CRP.No.4203 of 2025
DISMISSING THE CIVIL REVISION PETITION
a b
\0t
C
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review