Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 57 of 2021
Date of order: 27.09.2023
Donbok Nongkhlaw Rngi & anr
vs
State of Meghalaya & ors
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Appearance:
For the Petitioners
:
For the Respondents :
Dr N. Mozika, Sr Adv with
Ms K. Gurung, Adv.
Mr S. Sengupta, Addl Sr GA
Mr V.G.K. Kynta, Sr Adv. with
Ms C. Nongkhlaw, Adv. [For R 2-4]
Mr L. Khyriem, Adv. [For R 5]
Mr K. Paul, Sr Adv. with
Mr S. Thapa, Adv. [For R 6]
Mr B. Khyriem, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The matter pertains to an Act by the name of the Khasi Hills
Autonomous District (Appointment and Sucession of Syiem, Deputy
Syiem, Electors and Rangbah Shnong of Mylliem Syiemship) Act, 2007
which was published in the official gazette on April 9, 2008. There is no
dispute that the Act that was published was somewhat at variance with
the proposed Bill that had been forwarded by the District Council to the
State government. As a consequence, by a letter dated May 12, 2017,
the legislative secretariat of the Khasi Hills Autonomous District
Council drew the attention of the State government to the perceived
mistakes in the statute and required such mistakes to be corrected.
2.
The relevant letter referred to two perceived mistakes: that in
Schedule II of the Act by which “Nongkhlaw” had been included
instead of “Nongkhlaw Rngi”; and that in the same schedule “Sankur,
Raid Mylliem” was appearing twice.
3.
The present matter is confined to the “Nongkhlaw” and
“Nongkhlaw Rngi” aspect and nothing herein will affect any other
matter referred to in the relevant letter.
4.
Following the receipt of such letter from the legislative
secretariat of the Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council, the State
government caused a set of corrigenda to be published in the official
gazette on July 13, 2017. The corrigenda has 14 items and the present
matter pertains to the first part of the 14th item.
5.
The 14th item in the corrigenda published on July 13, 2017
provides as follows:
“14. In Schedule-II Sl.No.5 insert the word “Rngi” after the
word “Nongkhlaw” and delete the words “San Kur, Raid
Mylliem” appearing below the words “Arphewlai jait, Raid San
Shnong”.
6.
Again, the present matter is confined only to the aspect of
“Rngi” and “Nongkhlaw” and has nothing to do with the repetition or
otherwise of “San Kur Raid, Mylliem”.
7.
After the publication of the aforesaid corrigenda, the executive
committee of the District Council, at its meeting of December 20, 2017
resolved, inter alia, that the corrigenda published in the official gazette
of July 13, 2017 ought to be recalled. The executive committee of the
relevant District Council, accordingly, forwarded its recommendation to
the State government along with a further resolution of January 9, 2018
by which it was resolved to denotify the entirety of the corrigenda
published on July 13, 2017.
8.
Upon receipt of copies of such resolutions, the State caused a
further publication to be made in the official gazette on February 13,
2018 by which the entirety of the corrigenda to the Act of 2007 that had
been published on July 13, 2017 was withdrawn.
9.
The grievance of the petitioners is that the original Bill that was
submitted by the legislative wing of the relevant District Council, which
was the appropriate authority to look into the matter, clearly indicated
“Nongkhlaw Rngi” and, upon the word “Rngi” being mistakenly left out
in statute in Schedule II, it was the legislative wing of the District
Council that required the correction to be made so that the statute
adhered to the suggestion that was forwarded in such regard by the
District Council.
10.
According to the petitioners, since this was a matter of enacting
a law, it was the legislative wing of the District Council which was the
appropriate authority and the executive committee could not have
overridden the legislative wing to require the State to withdraw the
corrigenda that had been published at the suggestion of the legislative
wing.
11.
The District Council has produced its records. It is submitted on
behalf of the District Council that the original Bill that was forwarded to
the State indicated “Nongkhlaw Rngi” in Schedule II and it was, upon
realising the mistake in the Act that was passed, that the corrigendum in
such regard was requested. The District Council, however, makes no
submission as to how the executive committee of the Council came to
advise or instruct or recommend to the State government contrary to
what had been indicated by its legislative wing.
12.
There appears to be some substance in the petitioners’
submission in such regard that when the matter pertained to the
enactment of a statute and a proposed Bill had been forwarded by the
legislative wing of the District Council, as to whether the resultant Act
was in accordance with the proposed Bill or not was a matter which,
ordinarily, would be within the exclusive domain of the legislative wing
of the District Council. However, it cannot also be said that the
executive committee of the District Council would have no authority to
rectify a mistake; though, ideally, there ought to have been some
communication between the executive committee of the District
Council and the legislative wing of the same District Council before the
executive committee’s decisions were forwarded to the State.
13.
The private respondent is also represented and claims that it was
an obvious mistake in the original suggested Bill to indicate
“Nongkhlaw Rngi” in the relevant schedule and the reference should
always have been to “Nongkhlaw” and not confined to “Nongkhlaw
Rngi”. Such contention is seriously disputed by the petitioners.
14.
What is evident is that a particular Bill was forwarded by the
legislative wing of the relevant District Council to the State for enacting
a law in terms thereof, but there were certain mistakes in the statute.
The legislative wing of the relevant District Council endeavoured to
correct such mistakes. In such a scenario, the executive committee of
the District Council could not have jumped into the fray and undone
what the legislative wing of the same District Council had caused to be
done, unless rules in such regard gave the executive committee due
authority thereupon.
15.
However, without going into the merits of the matter and the
propriety of either “Nongkhlaw” or “Nongkhlaw Rngi” figuring in
Schedule II to the said Act of 2007, the resolutions of the executive
committee of the Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council of
December 20, 2017 and January 9, 2018 are set aside in so far as they
relate to the reference in Schedule II to the Act of 2007 to “Nongkhlaw”
or “Nongkhlaw Rngi”.
16.
As a consequence, the withdrawal of the corrigenda by the
publication made in the official gazette on February 13, 2018 is also set
aside. That would result in the corrigenda published on July 13, 2017 to
be revived. However, in view of the further directions issued hereafter,
the petitioners herein will not be entitled to steal a march or obtain any
irreversible benefit or adopt any irreversible measure that cannot be
undone. Such direction is necessary in view of the order proposed to be
made herein. Since it appears that the legislative and executive wings of
the same Autonomous District Council may have been at loggerheads
and may have not consulted each other, at least to the reference in the
statute being “Nongkhlaw” or “Nongkhlaw Rngi”, the petitioners
should not take any precipitous step that may be difficult to be undone.
17.
WP (C) No. 57 of 2021 is disposed of by directing the Khasi
Hills Autonomous District Council to take a reasoned decision in the
matter as to whether the reference in Schedule II to the relevant Act has
to be “Nongkhlaw Rngi” or only “Nongkhlaw”. Such decision will be
taken within four weeks from date upon first hearing both the
petitioners herein and the respondent No. 6 or their authorised
representatives. In case it is the legislative wing which is deemed to be
the appropriate authority to take the call, a select committee of
legislators as may be formed by the legislative council to hear both the
petitioners and the respondent No. 6 or their authorised representatives
before taking a final decision in the matter as to whether Schedule II to
the said statute should refer only to “Nongkhlaw” or to “Nongkhlaw
Rngi”.
18.
The decision in such regard ought to be reasoned and such
reasons should be furnished to both the petitioners and the respondent
No. 6.
19.
It is hoped that the decision is taken by the appropriate body of
the Khasi Hills Autonomous District Council within a period of four
weeks and such reasoned decision is communicated to both the
petitioners and the respondent No. 6 within a fortnight of the decision
being taken.
20.
Nothing in this order will prevent either the petitioners or the
respondent No. 6 from questioning the relevant order passed by the
District Council on any ground available.
21.
In course of the hearing to be afforded pursuance to the direction
issued herein, the Syiem of Mylliem or a duly authorised representative
of such Syiem should also be heard.
22.
The validity of the corrigenda published on July 13, 2017 will
be subject to the decision to be taken by the appropriate authority within
the District Council as provided for herein.
23.
There will be no order as to costs.
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
27.09.2023
“Sylvana PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review