The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. The upshot of the above discussion will lead to the only conclusion that there are no merits in these applications. Accordingly, these applications are dismissed. Consequently, Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023 is rejected at the SR stage itself.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025 in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 03.02.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.ANAND VENKATESH
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025
in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
Divisional Railway Manager/Works,
Divisional Office, Southern Railways,
Palakkad – 678 002.
… Applicant in both applns.
vs.
K.V.Anilkumar
… Respondent in both applns.
Applications filed under Order XIV Rule 8 of Original Side
Rules r/w Section 151 of Civil Procedure Code seeking to condone the
delay of 125 days in filing the above petition challenging the orders dated
28.07.2025 passed by the learned Master in Application Nos.3430 &
3433 of 2025 in Arb.O.P.D.No.70261 of 2023 respectively.
For Applicant
[in both applns.]
: Mr.AR Sakthivel
For Respondent
[in both applns.]
: Mr.Rahul Balakrishnan
*****
1/10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025 in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
ORDER
These applications have been filed seeking condonation of
delay of 125 days in filing the petition challenging the order passed by
the learned Master dated 28.07.2025 in Application Nos.3430 & 3433 of
2025 in Arb.O.P.D.No.70261 of 2023.
2. Heard learned counsel on either side.
3. In the case in hand, the Southern Railways had initially
challenged the award before the District Court at Palakkad. The award is
dated 16.01.2023 and this award came to be challenged with a delay of
17 days. The petition was filed before the District Court, Palakkad, only
on 05.05.2023. The said Court returned the petition on the ground that it
lacks jurisdiction and that it has to be presented before the concerned
Court since the seat of arbitration was at Chennai.
4. Pursuant to the above decision taken by the District Court at
Palakkad, the present applications came to be filed before this Court on
01.06.2023. The Registry, on scrutinizing the papers, returned the papers
by pointing out various deficiencies and one such deficiency pointed out
was that there is deficit Court fee. Initially, the applicant had paid only a
2/10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025 in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
sum of Rs.400/- before the District Court at Palakkad. Therefore, there
was deficit Court fee at the time of filing the petition before this Court.
The papers were returned on 30.06.2023. Thereafter, the papers were
represented on 03.06.2024 at which point of time, the deficit court fee
was also paid and there was a delay of 447 days in representation and
also in payment of deficit Court fee.
5. Application Nos.3430 & 3433 of 2025 came to be filed to
condone the delay and the applications were heard by the learned Master.
6. The learned Master, on considering the reasons assigned for
the delay and after taking note of the fact that the applicant has not shown
sufficient cause for delay, proceeded to dismiss the applications by order
dated 28.07.2025.
7. Aggrieved by the above order passed by the learned Master,
the present applications were filed before this Court once again with a
delay of 125 days. These applications have been filed to condone the
delay of 125 days in filing the petition challenging the order passed by
the learned Master dated 28.07.2025.
3/10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025 in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
8. This Court carefully considered the submissions made on
either side and the materials available on record.
9. Learned counsel for applicant submitted that the delay in
representation will not fall within the scope of Section 34(3) of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 [for brevity ‘the Act’]. It was
further submitted that the delay of 447 days in paying the deficit court fee
will not be hit by the judgment of this Court in M.Gajendran and
another v. M/s.Everest Blue Metals and others [(2025) 6 MLJ 466]
since the actual filing had taken place before the District Court, Palakkad
and the present filing before this Court is merely a re-filing of the petition
and therefore, the said judgment will not stand in the way of this Court to
condone the delay in paying the deficit Court fee.
10. It was further submitted that sufficient reasons have been
assigned in these applications for the delay of 125 days in filing the
petition challenging the order passed by the learned Master. Hence, it was
contended that the valuable rights of the applicant should not be nipped
in the bud and this Court may consider condoning the delay and hearing
the petition on merits.
4/10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025 in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
11. Per contra, learned counsel for respondent contended that
the applicant had caused considerable delay at each stage of the
proceedings starting from the District Court at Palakkad till the filing of
the present applications. Learned counsel submitted that once the papers
were returned by the District Court at Palakkad, the subsequent conduct
of the applicant in filing the petition before this Court cannot be
construed as a re-filing and it has to be construed as a fresh filing before
this Court. It was further submitted that the judgment of this Court in
M.Gajendran [supra] will apply to this case and hence, the delay in
payment of deficit court fee cannot be condoned. Consequently, no useful
purpose will be served in dealing with these applications, which have
been once again filed to condone the delay of 125 days in filing the
petition challenging the order passed by the learned Master.
12. This Court finds that the applicant at every stage has been
lackadaisical. When the petition was first filed before the District Court,
Palakkad, it was filed with a delay. After the petition was returned, the
petition was filed before this Court on 01.06.2023 and the papers were
returned on 30.06.2023. Ultimately, the papers were represented along
with deficit court fee with a delay of 447 days. The applications were
dismissed by the learned Master on 28.07.2025 and once again, there is a
5/10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025 in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
delay of 125 days in filing the petition challenging the order passed by
the learned Master. Therefore, it is quite evident that the delay is a
common thread which runs right through and that shows the attitude of
the applicant.
13. While dealing with these applications, this Court has to
necessarily go into the core issue as to whether this Court will ultimately
have the power and jurisdiction to condone the delay of 447 days in
payment of the deficit court fee. If such power is not available to the
Court, allowing these applications and thereafter, considering the main
petition challenging the order passed by the learned Master will only
result in an academic exercise. Therefore, the main question to be dealt
with in these applications is as to whether this Court will have the power
and jurisdiction to condone the delay of 447 days in paying the deficit
Court fee.
14. As stated supra, learned counsel for applicant raised a
ground that the actual filing had taken place before the District Court,
Palakkad and on return of the papers, it was only re-filed before this
Court. Therefore, when proper court fee was paid before the Palakkad
Court and thereafter, the papers were presented before this Court, the
6/10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025 in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
payment of deficit court fee will arise by construing such filing before
this Court as re-filing.
15. This Court is not in agreement with the above submission
made by learned counsel for applicant. When the petition was filed
before this Court after the papers were returned by the Palakkad Court,
such filing has to be construed as a fresh filing before this Court. At that
point of time, if there is any delay in filing the petition before this Court,
Section 14 of the Limitation Act will come into play and the Court will
give credit to the time period during which the applicant was prosecuting
the petition bonafidely before the District Court, Palakkad. Hence,
admittedly, when the filing took place before this Court on 01.06.2023,
the petition was not accompanied with sufficient court fees. Therefore,
the papers were returned on 30.06.2023 pointing out various deficiencies
and one such deficiency touched upon the deficit court fee. If the
applicant had represented the papers on time by paying the deficit court
fee, the Court would have come to the aid of the applicant since the
difference in the court fees is paid and the same could have been taken
into consideration to regularize the filing of the petitions. However, the
papers were represented with an exorbitant delay of 447 days and the
7/10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025 in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
deficit court fee came to be paid only at the time when the papers were
represented. Hence, there is a delay of 447 days in paying the deficit
court fee.
16. In the considered view of this Court, the delay of 447 days
in paying the deficit court fees certainly goes to the root of the matter
since the filing gets regularised only after the payment of the deficit court
fee and such regularization has to take place within the condonable
period of 120 days and if it is does not takes place within such period, the
above judgment of this Court will apply and the Court will lack the
power and jurisdiction to condone the delay.
17. Apart from the above, it is seen that the applicant was
consistently causing delay at every stage of the proceedings. While
dealing with commercial matters, delay has to be considered in a strict
manner and it cannot be dealt with leniently as is done in regular civil
proceedings. This is in view of the fact that the main objective behind the
arbitration proceedings is to avoid delay in completion of the
proceedings. If delay is condoned leniently that will in fact go against the
very objective of the Act.
8/10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025 in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
18. This Court finds that the reasons assigned for delay in filing
the present applications are not satisfactory. Apart from that, the reasons
assigned by the learned Master to dismiss the applications to condone the
delay in representation and to condone the delay in payment of deficit
court fee also do not suffer from any perversity or illegality.
19. The upshot of the above discussion will lead to the only
conclusion that there are no merits in these applications.
Accordingly, these applications are dismissed. Consequently,
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023 is rejected at the SR stage itself.
03.02.2026
Index:yes/no
Speaking Order/Non-speaking Order
NCC:yes/no
gm
9/10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025 in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
N.ANAND VENKATESH, J.
gm
Application Nos.6250 & 6252 of 2025
in
Arb.O.P.Dr.No.70261 of 2023
03.02.2026
10/10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review