Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:11109
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ORDER RESERVED ON 09.02.2026
ORDER DELIVERED ON 03.03.2026
ORDER UPLOADED ON 03 .03.2026
MCRC No. 43 of 2026
1 - Dipen Chawda S/o Jawahar Chawda Aged About 52 Years R/o
Chaitinaya Tower Ananta Vihar Colony, Daldal Senoi District - Raipur,
Chhattisgarh
... Applicant(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Acb/ Eow, District Raipur,
Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
For Applicant (s)
: Shri Sunil Otwani, Sr. Advocate assisted by
Shri Gagan Tiwari, Advocate
For Respondent/State
: Dr. Saurabh Kumar Pande, Dy.AG
(Hon’ble Shri Justice Arvind Kumar Verma)
C A V Order
The present application, preferred under Section 483 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, seeks the grant of regular
bail to the Applicant in connection with Crime No. 01/2024 of the
Economic Offences Wing/Anti-Corruption Bureau, Raipur, District Raipur
(C.G.), pertaining to offences under Sections 11, 13(1)(a), and 13(2) of
the Prevention of Corruption Act, 2018, read with Sections 120-B, 384,
and 409 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
2.
The prosecution case, in brief yet comprehensive terms, unfolds
as follows: On 09.01.2024, the State Economic Offences Investigation
Bureau
(SEOIB)
received
a
pivotal
communication
from
the
Enforcement Directorate (ED), Raipur, prompting the initiation of a
confidential verification exercise. This inquiry targeted widespread
allegations of illegal monetary collections orchestrated in connection
with custom milling processes across the State of Chhattisgarh—a
critical component of the State's public distribution system (PDS) under
which rice millers are allotted quotas for processing paddy into fortified
rice
for
government
procurement
via
entities
like
MARKFED
(Chhattisgarh State Cooperative Marketing Federation Ltd.).
3.
It was specifically alleged that certain influential office-bearers of
the Chhattisgarh State Rice Millers Association, acting in criminal
collusion and conspiracy with public servants, had systematically
extracted unlawful payments from registered rice millers. These
exactions were purportedly made as quid pro quo for securing
preferential allotments of custom milling quotas, facilitating processing
contracts, and ensuring smooth execution thereof. The implicated public
servants included senior officials of MARKFED, district-level authorities
responsible for quota distribution, and other regulatory functionaries,
who allegedly abused their official positions to favour the accused
association office-bearers.
4.
The modus operandi, as per the prosecution narrative, involved
the creation of fictitious demands for "association fees," "processing
charges," or "facilitation amounts" totaling substantial sums, siphoned
off under the guise of legitimate operational costs. This racket not only
undermined the transparency of PDS procurement but also caused
pecuniary loss to the state exchequer and individual millers coerced into
payments. The SEOIB's (State Economic Offences Investigation
Bureau)
verification,
documentary
grounded
evidence
such
in
the
ED's
as
ledgers,
inputs,
bank
uncovered
transactions,
communications, and witness statements corroborating the syndicate's
operations, leading to the registration of the instant FIR and subsequent
investigation under relevant provisions of the Indian Penal Code,
Prevention of Corruption Act, and allied statutes.
5.
Pursuant to the aforementioned communication, FIR No. 01/2024
dated 16.01.2024 was registered at the State Economic Offences
Investigation Bureau, Raipur, invoking offences under the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988, and relevant provisions of the Indian Penal Code,
1860. The allegations center on systematic illegal recoveries of
approximately ₹240 per quintal from rice millers during custom milling
operations, with investigations revealing that substantial sums were
handled and disbursed among the implicated individuals.
6.
Further, searches by the Income Tax Department, followed by
probing, yielded seizures of cash, documents bearing cryptic entries,
and digital records ostensibly documenting these illicit financial
transactions. During the investigation, the respondent agency submitted
its initial charge-sheet on 01.02.2025 before the Special Judge
(Prevention of Corruption Act), Raipur, arraying certain accused and
citing 144 witnesses. A supplementary charge-sheet dated 06.10.2025
followed, incorporating additional accused and expanding the witness
list to 205. Subsequently, a second supplementary final report dated
09.12.2025 was filed, wherein the present applicant was named as an
accused for the first time.
7.
As per the allegations contained in the said supplementary report,
the applicant was stated to be acquainted with co-accused persons and
allegedly involved in logistical aspects relating to the movement and
handling of funds. The prosecution asserts that the applicant facilitated
travel, meetings, and arrangements for certain co-accused persons and
allegedly handled cash at different stages, including storage, counting,
and transfer, at the instance of other accused persons. It is further
alleged that digital evidence recovered during investigation indicates
financial dealings among co-accused persons, which according to the
prosecution supports the involvement of the applicant.
8.
The applicant was arrested by EOW/ACB, Raipur on 11.09.2025
in connection with the said crime. After completion of investigation qua
the applicant, his name was incorporated in the subsequent
supplementary charge-sheet filed before the Special Court. It is not in
dispute that the charge-sheet has been filed and investigation, so far as
the applicant is concerned, stands completed.
9.
The applicant had earlier preferred an application for regular bail
before the learned Special Judge (Prevention of Corruption Act), Raipur,
which came to be rejected by order dated 15.12.2025. Thereafter, the
present application has been filed seeking grant of regular bail by this
Court.
10.
It is further alleged that the offence concerns organized illegal
collections in connection with public distribution and custom milling
operations causing substantial financial impact, and the investigation
involves examination of voluminous documentary and electronic records
along with a large number of witnesses. On the other hand, the
applicant asserts that the allegations against him are based primarily on
statements of co-accused persons and materials collected subsequently
during investigation, and that his implication surfaced only at a later
stage through supplementary reports. These, in substance, constitute
the factual background in which the present bail application has been
placed before this Court for consideration.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPLICANT
11.
Shri Otwani, learned Senior counsel appearing for the applicant
submits that the present prosecution, as projected in the charge-sheet
and supplementary reports, does not disclose any legally sustainable or
prima facie case warranting continued incarceration of the applicant. It is
submitted that the applicant has been falsely implicated on the basis of
belated, contradictory and legally inadmissible material, without any
independent evidence linking him with the alleged offence. It is
contended that the entire case against the applicant originates from a
communication issued by the Enforcement Directorate, on the basis of
which the subject FIR came to be registered, alleging illegal collection of
funds in connection with custom milling operations. It is alleged that
certain office bearers of the Rice Millers Association and officials of
MARKFED, along with other persons, formed a syndicate to collect
illegal kickbacks from rice millers.
12.
He contended that the prosecution case primarily revolves around
allegations
against
co-accused
persons,
including
Roshan
Chandrakar, Manoj Kumar Soni, and Anwar Dhebar, who are alleged
to have played principal roles in the alleged syndicate. The investigation
further named other accused persons including Anwar Dewar and Anil
Tuteja, among others, in supplementary reports. He submits that the
applicant’s name did not figure in the initial investigation or in the
first charge-sheet filed against principal accused persons. His
implication surfaced only in a later supplementary charge-sheet,
indicating that allegations against him are an afterthought introduced at
a belated stage.
13.
It is argued that the prosecution case against the applicant rests
primarily on statements recorded under Section 164 Cr.P.C. of certain
witnesses including Ankur Paliwal, Suraj Pawar, and Siddharth
Singhania, whose versions have materially changed over time and
appear tailored to suit the investigation. These witnesses are
themselves involved or interested persons who have admitted their own
participation in the alleged transactions, thereby rendering their
statements inherently unreliable. It is submitted that earlier statements
of witnesses did not implicate the applicant in the alleged illegal
collection or handling of funds, and his name surfaced only at a later
stage shortly before submission of supplementary reports, clearly
indicating an attempt to fill investigative gaps.
14.
In this context, learned Senior counsel for the applicant relied
upon the settled legal position laid down by the Apex Court in
Haricharan Kurmi v. State of Bihar (1964) SCC OnLine SC 28,
wherein it was held that confession or statement of a co-accused is not
substantive evidence and cannot form the sole basis for implication of
another accused. The same principle has been reiterated in
Somasundaram v. State (2020) 7 SCC 722, emphasizing that
statements of co-accused require independent corroboration.
15.
It is further submitted that the prosecution seeks to rely upon
selectively extracted WhatsApp chats allegedly exchanged among coaccused persons such as Anwar Dewar and Anil Tuteja. However, no
direct communication between the applicant and any co-accused person
has been demonstrated. The alleged chats do not disclose any specific
incriminating act attributable to the applicant.
16.
Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the investigating
agency never seized the applicant’s mobile phone, nor is there any
material to show that the applicant authored, sent, or received the
alleged messages. The chats are claimed to have been sourced from
devices seized by the Income Tax Department allegedly belonging to co-
accused persons, yet no lawful chain of custody or forensic
authentication has been produced.
17.
It is further submitted that there exists an unexplained break in the
chain of custody and no forensic laboratory report certifying integrity or
authenticity of electronic data has been placed on record. Additionally,
no valid certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act has been
produced. Reliance is placed upon the judgment of the Apex Court in
Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer (2014) 10 SCC 473, which categorically
holds that electronic evidence is inadmissible unless accompanied by
certification under Section 65B of the Evidence Act. In absence thereof,
the alleged electronic records cannot be relied upon.
18.
Learned counsel for the applicant further submits that no
incriminating recovery has been made from the applicant. Despite
allegations involving movement and handling of large sums, no cash,
documents, digital records, bank trail, or financial instruments have
been seized from him. No ledger entry, communication record, or
financial link connects the applicant to alleged proceeds of crime. It is
further submitted that allegations of transportation of funds through
vehicles allegedly linked to the applicant’s family remain speculative and
unsupported by evidence. Mere acquaintance or associationwith coaccused persons such as Anwar Dewar, Roshan Chandrakar, or
Manoj Kumar Soni cannot establish conspiracy or criminal liability.
19.
Learned counsel submits that even if the prosecution case is
accepted at face value, the materials only suggest that the applicant
allegedly facilitated travel or logistical arrangements at the instance of
co-accused persons, without any allegation of personal gain, decisionmaking authority, or participation in collection or distribution of funds.
There is thus complete absence of mens rea.
20.
It is further submitted that the applicant has been in custody
since 11.09.2025, investigation qua him stands completed, and
charge-sheet has already been filed. No further custodial interrogation
is required, and trial is likely to take several years, particularly when
more than 350 witnesses have been cited.
21.
Reliance is placed upon recent decisions of the Apex Court,
including Arvind Dham v. Directorate of Enforcement SLP (Crl.) No.
15478 of 2025, Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh v. State of Maharashtra
2024 SCC OnLine SC 1693, and Kapil Wadhawan v. Central Bureau
of Investigation SLP (Crl.) No. 16953 of 2025, wherein prolonged
incarceration pending trial was held to violate Article 21 of the
Constitution.
22.
Learned counsel for the applicant further submits that principles of
parity strongly operate in favour of the applicant. Co-accused persons
against whom substantially more serious allegations exist including
Roshan Chandrakar, Manoj Kumar Soni, and Anwar Dhebar, who
are alleged to be principal actors or kingpins of the syndicate have
already been granted bail by this Court. In comparison, the applicant is
attributed only a peripheral and derivative role. Continued detention
of the applicant, when principal accused persons are already on bail,
would amount to discriminatory treatment. It is therefore submitted that
in absence of recovery, lack of admissible electronic evidence, absence
of credible corroboration, absence of mens rea, completion of
investigation, and grant of bail to similarly or more seriously placed coaccused persons, continued custody of the applicant serves no lawful
purpose.
23.
It is submitted that the principle of parity squarely applies in favour
of the present applicant. The prosecution itself alleges that co-accused
persons Roshan Chandrakar, Manoj Kumar Soni, Anwar Dhebar,
and Anil Tuteja were principal actors and key beneficiaries of the
alleged syndicate involved in collection and diversion of funds.
Despite serious and direct allegations attributed to them, all the
aforesaid co-accused have already been enlarged on bail by this Court.
Notably, Roshan Chandrakar, alleged to be centrally involved in the
conspiracy, has been granted bail; Manoj Kumar Soni, alleged to have
misused his official position and played a pivotal role in the alleged
scheme, stands released on bail; Anwar Dhebar, projected as one of
the kingpins of the syndicate, has also been granted bail and Anil
Tuteja, a public servant alleged to have systematically facilitated
diversion and collection of funds, has likewise been enlarged on bail.
24.
It is further contended that out of the principal accused persons,
four have already been granted bail and only the present applicant
continues to remain in custody despite being attributed a comparatively
peripheral and derivative role. Thus, continued incarceration of the
applicant would result in unequal and discriminatory treatment, contrary
to settled bail jurisprudence. Learned counsel for the applicant fairly
submits that the applicant has been named in another case
registered by EOW/ACB, Raipur. However, it is well settled that the
mere existence of antecedents cannot automatically result in denial of
bail unless the prosecution demonstrates likelihood of misuse of liberty
or repetition of offence. The Apex Court in Ayub Khan v. State of
Rajasthan, 2024 INSC 994, Prabhakar Tewari v. State of U.P., (2020)
SCC OnLine SC 75, and Sandeep v. State (NCT of Delhi) 2024 SCC
OnLine Del 4919, has clarified that antecedents are only one of the
factors and cannot override other considerations such as strength of
evidence, length of custody, and stage of trial.
In the present case, investigation stands completed and the
applicant’s custody is no longer required. Hence, antecedents
cannot be treated as a standalone ground for refusal of bail.
25.
It is next contended by the counsel for the applicant in response
to the State’s allegation that the applicant was Director of AJS Agro
Company and the
prosecution itself states that the company was
formed and controlled by co-accused Anwar Dewar; no material shows
that any property was purchased by the applicant out of alleged illegal
proceeds; the applicant functioned merely in an employee-like capacity
managing day-to-day affairs on a salary basis. Thus, mere nominal
association with a company allegedly controlled by another accused
cannot establish criminal conspiracy or financial benefit.
26.
The applicant has remained in custody for a substantial period,
investigation qua him stands completed, and trial is not likely to
commence in the near future considering the voluminous record and
large number of witnesses. The Apex Court in Sanjay Chandra v. CBI,
(2012) 1 SCC 40, held that it is not in the interest of justice to detain
accused in custody for an indefinite period once investigation is
complete.
Similarly, in Manish Sisodia v. ED, 2024 SCC OnLine SC
1920, and Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh v. State of Maharashtra, (2024)
9 SCC 813, the Court reiterated that prolonged incarceration pending
trial violates Article 21.
27.
Further reliance is placed on Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb,
(2021) 3 SCC 713, wherein it was held that statutory rigours cannot
override constitutional courts’ duty to protect personal liberty where trial
is unlikely to conclude within reasonable time. The principle was
originally emphasized in Hussainara Khatoon (I) v. State of Bihar,
(1980) 1 SCC 81, recognizing speedy trial as a fundamental right under
Article 21.
28.
Charge-sheet and supplementary reports already stand filed and
prosecution relies on documentary material already secured. Custodial
interrogation is over and no further recovery remains to be effected.
Thus, continued incarceration serves no investigational purpose. The
Apex Court consistently upholds the principle that “bail is the rule and
jail is the exception”, as reiterated in State of Rajasthan v. Balchand,
(1977) 4 SCC 308, and followed in a long line of decisions thereafter.
29.
It is therefore submitted that bail proceedings are not intended as
a mechanism for pre-emptive punishment prior to adjudication on
merits. Detention pending trial must remain the exception, not the rule,
as consistently held by the Apex Court. In the instant case, where the
evidence is predominantly documentary, all recoveries stand complete,
and custodial interrogation has concluded without yielding any
incriminating material, the applicant's continued incarceration inexorably
amounts to punishment without trial, warranting immediate grant of bail.
30.
In light of the bail already granted to the principal co-accused, the
complete absence of any recovery from the applicant, the doubtful
admissibility of the purported electronic evidence, and the total lack of
direct evidence linking the applicant to the offence coupled with the
investigation
having
long
concluded,
the
applicant's
prolonged
incarceration, inexcusable delay in commencement of trial and
unassailable satisfaction of the triple test, continued detention stands
wholly unjustified. Settled constitutional principles, as enshrined in
Article 21 and reiterated by the Apex Court, unequivocally tilt the scales
in favour of individual liberty where the prosecution's case is bereft of
foundational probative material.
31.
Next contention on behalf of the applicant is that the prosecution
case itself attributes the primary role in the alleged offence to coaccused persons including Roshan Chandrakar, Manoj Kumar Soni,
and other principal conspirators alleged to have conceptualized and
operated the mechanism for illegal collection of funds from rice millers.
Despite such serious and direct allegations, this Court has already
granted bail to the principal accused persons. Co-accused Roshan
Chandrakar, who is alleged to have been actively involved in organizing
and executing the alleged collection mechanism, was arrested on
04.01.2024 and has been granted bail by this Court vide order dated
18.07.2025 passed in MCRC No. 2836/2025.
32.
Similarly, co-accused Manoj Kumar Soni, who at the relevant
time held the position of Managing Director of MARKFED and is
alleged to have played a pivotal and facilitating role in the alleged
syndicate by virtue of his official position, has also been granted bail by
this
Court vide order dated 09.05.2025 passed in MCRC No.
2078/2025.
33.
The allegations against these accused persons are substantially
graver and depict them as principal beneficiaries and decision-makers in
the alleged scheme. In stark contrast, the role attributed to the present
applicant is extremely limited and peripheral. According to the
prosecution’s own case, the applicant is alleged, at best, to have acted
in the collection, custody, or delivery of money at the instance of coaccused Anwar Dewar, without any allegation of planning, control,
conspiracy formation or personal financial gain. There is no material on
record to suggest that the applicant exercised any control over the
alleged syndicate or that he was a beneficiary of the alleged proceeds.
Thus, when principal conspirators and alleged kingpins have already
been enlarged on bail, continued incarceration of the applicant, whose
role is subordinate and derivative, results in hostile discrimination and
violates the settled doctrine of parity and equality before law.
The applicant satisfies all conditions necessary for grant of bail:
•
No likelihood of absconding;
•
The applicant is a permanent resident of District Raipur with
settled family and social roots. There is no possibility of flight risk.
•
No possibility of tampering with evidence;
•
All material evidence relied upon by the prosecution has already
been seized and forms part of the charge-sheet. The applicant
cannot influence documentary or digital evidence already
secured.
•
No likelihood of influencing witnesses:
•
Most witnesses cited are official or documentary witnesses, and
there is no allegation that the applicant has attempted to influence
any witness.
Reliance is placed on the decision of the Apex Court in P.
Chidambaram v. CBI, (2020) 13 SCC 337, which reiterates that once
the triple test is satisfied, detention pending trial becomes unwarranted.
The trial court, while rejecting bail, has not pointed out any specific or
cogent material showing likelihood of misuse of liberty. Mere
apprehension
without
substantiation
cannot
justify
continued
incarceration.
34.
It is settled law that bail proceedings are not punitive in nature.
The object of detention is only to secure investigation or ensure
presence of the accused during trial. The Apex Court in Gurcharan
Singh v. State (Delhi Administration), (1978) 1 SCC 118, has held
that the object of bail is neither punitive nor preventive.
35.
In the present case the investigation qua the applicant stands
completed; Charge-sheet and supplementary reports have already been
filed; No further recovery or custodial interrogation remains pending; trial
is not likely to conclude in the near future. Thus, continued custody of
the applicant amounts to pre-trial punishment, which is impermissible
under law. Even if the prosecution case is accepted in its entirety for the
purpose of bail consideration, the role attributed to the applicant remains
ancillary and subordinate. The prosecution does not allege that the
applicant planned or designed the alleged scheme,
he exercised
decision-making authority, he derived financial benefit, he controlled or
directed operations, or that illegal proceeds were recovered from him.
36.
The applicant is alleged merely to have acted under instructions
of other accused persons, without any independent authority or gain.
Thus, continued incarceration of a person alleged to have played only a
derivative role, when principal accused are already on bail, is wholly
unjustified.
37.
The entire case now rests on documentary and electronic
evidence already in custody of the prosecution. Custodial interrogation
of the applicant has concluded, and investigation against him stands
completed. Therefore, his detention serves no further investigative
purpose. The Apex Court has consistently reiterated that once
investigation is complete, bail should ordinarily follow unless exceptional
circumstances exist. No such exceptional circumstance is shown in the
present case.
38.
He therefore submits that in view of the bail already granted to the
principal co-accused, the applicant's limited role as attributed,
completion of investigation, total absence of recovery from him, lack of
any risk of absconding or tampering with evidence, prolonged pre-trial
custody, and settled constitutional principles favouring individual liberty
over punitive detention, the applicant deserves enlargement on bail.
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT/STATE
39.
Learned counsel for the respondent, submits the following
objections to the present application seeking grant of regular bail. The
submissions are made keeping in view the gravity of the offence, the
nature of evidence collected, and the ongoing investigation into a largescale organized economic offence having deep ramifications on public
administration and public funds.
40.
It is submitted that the present case arises out of a large-scale
organized conspiracy relating to illegal collection of money from rice
millers in the State of Chhattisgarh in connection with custom milling
operations and processing of incentive payments. The investigation
reveals a structured mechanism involving:
* illegal kickback/extortion from rice millers,
* deliberate manipulation of bill clearance processes,
* misuse of official position by public servants, and
* organized movement and handling of huge amounts of cash.
The case originated from material disclosed during investigation
conducted by the Enforcement Directorate in connection with moneylaundering proceedings relating to the Custom Milling Scam, where
predicate offences falling within the jurisdiction of ACB/EOW were
detected and accordingly shared with the State authorities.
41.
Upon receipt of credible information, the FIR was registered and a
comprehensive investigation commenced, which has since unearthed a
multi-layered criminal conspiracy involving public servants, office
bearers of miller associations, intermediaries and cash handlers.
42.
Investigation reveals that incentives payable to rice millers for
custom milling operations were artificially enhanced and thereafter
portions of such payments were illegally collected back as kickbacks for
facilitating clearance of bills. Payments were linked to compliance with
illegal cash delivery channels and processing of bills depended upon
participation in the illegal payment mechanism. The investigation has
disclosed deliberate manipulation of official processes, selective
approvals, and coordinated bill movements across districts. Statements
of millers and association office bearers recorded during investigation
clearly indicate demand and payment of illegal gratification for clearance
of bills and processing of incentive payments.
43.
The investigation has already resulted in filing of charge-sheets
and
supplementary
charge-sheets
before
the
competent
court.
However, considering the multi-layered nature of the conspiracy,
investigation continues with respect to additional beneficiaries, handlers,
delivery channels and proceeds of crime. The role of the present
applicant came to light in subsequent stages of investigation, following
collection of additional evidence and examination of digital and
documentary material. Investigation into further links, property trails and
concealment mechanisms is still in progress. Thus, filing of chargesheet does not signify closure of investigation in respect of the larger
conspiracy.
44.
Contrary to the submission that the applicant played only a
peripheral role, the material collected during investigation prima facie
establishes that the applicant functioned as a key operative in the illegal
cash movement mechanism. Investigation reveals that:
* The applicant actively participated in receiving, handling and delivering
huge amounts of illegal cash;
* He functioned as an executing link in the cash movement chain at
predetermined locations;
* A structured mechanism of delivery through vehicles and designated
drop points was in operation;
* Witnesses have specifically identified the applicant as the person
managing cash transactions at several delivery locations.
Test Identification Proceedings conducted before the Executive
Magistrate further corroborate the presence and role of the applicant in
handling cash deliveries.
Statements recorded under Section 164
Cr.P.C. disclose the operational chain of illegal collection and routing of
funds, clearly implicating the applicant as an entrusted link responsible
for physical handling of proceeds.
45.
Digital evidence seized during searches, including WhatsApp
chats and other electronic communications recovered from co-accused
persons, further corroborates the applicant’s role in receiving and
delivering illegal funds.
46.
Call Detail Records and location data substantiate the presence of
the applicant at delivery locations and meetings connected with cash
handling operations. Investigation also indicates use of encrypted and
alternate communication channels to avoid interception, including use of
specific digital accounts to coordinate movement of funds. Such material
prima facie establishes that the applicant was not a casual associate but
a trusted operational handler entrusted with movement of huge cash
amounts.
47.
Investigation further reveals that the applicant maintained close
association with principal accused persons including Anwar Dhebar,
who is alleged to be one of the central figures in the syndicate. Material
also indicates that the applicant acted as a trusted associate and
logistical
handler
for
movement
of
illegal
proceeds,
including
transactions involving very large amounts. There are also allegations
regarding his association with entities linked to principal accused
persons for acquisition and concealment of assets, which are under
investigation. Thus, the applicant’s involvement is not incidental but
integral to the operational execution of the conspiracy.
48.
Considering the applicant’s role as an operational handler and his
proximity to other conspirators, there exists a real likelihood that if
released on bail, he may:
* influence or intimidate witnesses;
* coordinate with co-accused persons;
* tamper with digital or documentary evidence; or
* obstruct further investigation.
Investigation is still ongoing regarding identification of remaining
beneficiaries and tracing of proceeds of crime, and release of the
applicant at this stage would seriously prejudice the process.
49.
The Apex Court has repeatedly emphasized that economic
offences constitute a class apart and need to be viewed seriously. In
State of Gujarat v. Mohanlal Jitamalji Porwal, (1987) 2 SCC 364, the
Apex Court observed that economic offences undermine the financial
system of the country and must be dealt with sternly. In Y.S. Jagan
Mohan Reddy v. CBI, (2013) 7 SCC 439, the Apex Court held that
economic offences involving deep-rooted conspiracies and huge loss to
public funds must be considered seriously at the stage of bail.
50.
Similarly, in Serious Fraud Investigation Office v. Nittin Johari,
(2019) 9 SCC 165, it was held that economic offences involving public
money stand on a different footing and require cautious consideration
while granting bail.
In P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement, (2019) 9
SCC 24, the Supreme Court reiterated that economic offences involving
laundering or diversion of funds have serious societal impact and courts
must consider gravity and potential influence of accused persons.
51.
The defence plea of parity is misconceived. Grant of bail to
another accused does not automatically entitle every co-accused to bail.
Parity applies only when roles are identical. The material against the
present applicant shows his operational role in the cash movement
chain. Bail granted to other accused persons does not dilute the
seriousness of evidence against the applicant.
The Apex Court in
Ravindra Saxena v. State of Rajasthan, (2010) 1 SCC 684, has
clarified that parity cannot be claimed when roles and evidence differ.
52.
It is well settled that mere filing of charge-sheet does not entitle an
accused to bail where risks of influencing witnesses or obstructing
investigation persist. The Apex Court in Nimmagadda Prasad v. CBI,
(2013) 7 SCC 466, held that in economic offences, filing of charge-sheet
alone is not sufficient ground to grant bail. In the present case,
investigation into proceeds of crime and wider conspiracy is still
ongoing, and the applicant’s release may frustrate further investigation.
53.
Considering the organized and large-scale nature of the offence,
which reveals a sophisticated syndicate involving illegal cash movement
exceeding crores, the applicant's pivotal operational role therein cannot
be discounted. Strong prima facie evidence, including corroborative
witness statements from independent sources and irrefutable digital
material such as bank trails and encrypted communications, firmly
establishes his complicity beyond mere surmise. The investigation
remains ongoing into the wider conspiracy and laundering of proceeds
of crime, with vital leads into upstream financiers and downstream
beneficiaries yet to be fully unravelled. Granting bail at this juncture
carries a grave likelihood of the applicant influencing key witnesses
several of whom have already expressed apprehension and obstructing
the probe, thereby frustrating the ends of justice. In economic offences
of this magnitude, where public exchequer stands imperilled and
societal trust in financial systems is eroded, the discretionary relief of
bail must be denied to safeguard the investigative process and prevent
impunity, as reiterated by the Apex Court in P. Chidambaram v.
Directorate of Enforcement (2019) 9 SCC 24 and State of Gujarat v.
Mohanlal Jitamalji Porwal (1987) 1 SCR 1.
54.
In view of the aforesaid facts, circumstances, and settled legal
principles governing grant of bail in serious economic offences involving
money laundering and organized crime, it is most respectfully prayed
that the present application seeking enlargement of the applicant on bail
be dismissed, lest it prejudices the ongoing investigation and subverts
the cause of justice.
FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION
55.
Heard learned counsel for the respective parties at length.
Perused the case diary, charge-sheet, supplementary charge-sheets,
and material on record with utmost care. The instant application seeks
regular bail in connection with Crime No. 01/2024 of Police Station
EOW/ACB, Raipur, pertaining to allegations of illegal money collection
qua custom milling operations and cognate financial irregularities.
56.
Learned State counsel has strongly opposed the bail application
contending that the applicant played an operational role in handling and
routing illegal cash and that investigation into the larger conspiracy and
proceeds of crime is still continuing. It is further contended that release
of the applicant at this stage may enable him to influence witnesses or
obstruct further investigation.
57.
Per contra, learned counsel for the applicant submits that the
applicant has been falsely implicated at a later stage, that no recovery
has been effected from him, and that his alleged role is derivative and
subordinate to that of principal accused persons who are already on
bail. It is also contended that investigation qua the applicant stands
completed and further incarceration would amount to pre-trial
punishment.
NATURE OF CONSIDERATION AT THE STAGE OF BAIL
58.
At the stage of consideration of bail, the Court is not expected to
conduct a detailed evaluation of evidence or record findings touching
upon guilt or innocence of the accused. The Court is only required to
examine whether continued custody is necessary having regard to the
nature of accusations, stage of investigation, likelihood of misuse of
liberty and the overall interests of justice.
59.
The Apex Court in Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, (2012) 1 SCC 40, has
held that detention pending trial should not be used as a measure of
punishment and that the object of bail is to secure the presence of the
accused at trial. Similarly, in Dataram Singh v. State of U.P., (2018) 3
SCC 22, it has been reiterated that bail is the rule and jail an exception,
and personal liberty under Article 21 cannot be curtailed unless
compelling reasons exist.
STATUS OF INVESTIGATION AND MATERIAL AGAINST THE
APPLICANT
60.
It is not disputed that charge-sheet as well as supplementary
charge-sheets have already been filed and investigation, so far as the
applicant is concerned, stands substantially completed. Custodial
interrogation of the applicant is no longer required. Though the
prosecution asserts continuation of investigation into wider aspects of
the conspiracy and proceeds of crime, the material against the applicant
now forms part of the charge-sheet and would be tested during trial.
Significantly, no recovery of illegal cash or assets has been effected
from the applicant. The allegations primarily relate to handling or
facilitating delivery of cash allegedly at the behest of other accused
persons. Whether such evidence ultimately establishes criminal liability
is a matter to be examined during trial and cannot be conclusively
determined at the stage of bail.
61.
A crucial factor that weighs with this Court is the principle of parity.
It is not disputed that principal accused persons against whom more
serious allegations of planning and controlling the alleged syndicate
have been attributed have already been granted bail by this Court.
When persons alleged to have conceptualized and controlled the
mechanism are already on bail, continued detention of an accused
whose role is projected as operational or derivative requires careful
scrutiny.
62.
The Supreme Court in Ravindra Saxena v. State of Rajasthan,
(2010) 1 SCC 684, has held that parity is a relevant consideration in bail
matters, though not the sole determinant. However, when co-accused
similarly or more seriously placed are already enlarged on bail, denial of
bail
to
another
accused
must
be
justified
by
distinguishing
circumstances. In the present case, no such exceptional distinguishing
circumstance has been demonstrated.
63.
The applicant has been in custody for a considerable period. The
prosecution proposes examination of a large number of witnesses and
reliance on voluminous documentary and electronic evidence. Trial in
such cases is unlikely to conclude within a short period. The Supreme
Court in Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb, (2021) 3 SCC 713, held that
where trial is unlikely to conclude within a reasonable time,
constitutional courts are justified in granting bail notwithstanding
seriousness of allegations. Prolonged incarceration pending trial would
offend the mandate of Article 21 guaranteeing personal liberty and
speedy trial.
64.
The State expresses apprehension that the applicant may
influence witnesses or tamper with evidence. However, most material
evidence in the present case appears to be documentary and digital in
nature and already stands seized by the investigating agency. Any
apprehension of interference can be adequately addressed by imposing
stringent bail conditions restricting contact with witnesses and ensuring
availability of the applicant during trial.
65.
It is true that the Supreme Court has repeatedly observed,
including in Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy v. CBI, (2013) 7 SCC 439, and
Serious Fraud Investigation Office v. Nittin Johari, (2019) 9 SCC
165, that economic offences are serious in nature and affect public
interest. However, even in such cases, the Court must balance the
seriousness of allegations with constitutional safeguards protecting
individual liberty. Bail cannot be denied merely as a mark of disapproval
of the alleged offence. The Court must ensure that custody does not
become punitive in nature prior to adjudication of guilt.
66.
It is not disputed that the applicant's name finds no mention in the
original FIR. His implication emerged only subsequently during
investigation, formalized solely through the supplementary chargesheet. While subsequent implication does not ipso facto exonerate an
accused, the conspicuous absence of the applicant's name from the FIR
underscores that he was not perceived ab initio as a principal
conspirator. This factor gains salience in evaluating the necessity of
continued custody. Notwithstanding allegations of handling and ferrying
substantial cash sums, no recovery of illicit cash, property, or
incriminating articles has been effected from the applicant or his
possession. The prosecution's case hinges predominantly on witness
statements and digital material seized from co-accused. Strikingly,
nothing
incriminating
has
been
recovered
from
the
applicant
establishing direct receipt, retention, or control of alleged proceeds. At
the threshold bail stage, such abject absence of recovery assumes
paramount significance in gauging the prima facie involvement
warranting prolonged incarceration, tilting the balance towards liberty.
67.
A compelling factor tilting in the applicant's favour is the doctrine
of parity. Admittedly, four co-accused against whom graver allegations of
masterminding, controlling, and profiting from the alleged syndicate
have been arrayed stand enlarged on bail by this Court. When principal
or managerial architects of the conspiracy have been deemed fit for
release, denying parity to the applicant whose role is merely portrayed
as operational or peripheral renders continued detention manifestly
arbitrary and unjustifiable. The Apex Court, in Ravindra Saxena v.
State of Rajasthan (2010) 1 SCC 684 and Dataram Singh v. State of
U.P. (2018) 3 SCC 22, has emphatically recognized parity as a pivotal
consideration in bail adjudication, absent distinguishing features
rendering role of the accused demonstrably more culpable.
68.
The prosecution has failed to articulate any such material
differentiator warranting disparate treatment. The investigation stands
substantially
concluded,
with
the
principal
charge-sheet
and
supplementary charge-sheets duly filed, incorporating all material
against the applicant. Custodial interrogation yields no further necessity.
Any residual probe, if at all, targets broader conspiracy strands and
proceeds-tracing, unconnected to prospective recovery from the
applicant, thereby obviating the rationale for his continued incarceration.
69.
The prosecution's case rests on voluminous documentary and
digital evidence, necessitating examination of a plethora of witnesses. In
such complex matters, trial commencement and conclusion are destined
to consume considerable time. The Apex Court in Union of India v.
K.A. Najeeb (2021) 3 SCC 713 has authoritatively held that prolonged
pre-trial incarceration offends guarantee of personal liberty under Article
21. Thus the Constitutional Courts are empowered to grant bail where
trial fruition within a reasonable horizon remains improbable.
70.
The State's apprehension of witness influence stands adequately
mitigating through stringent bail conditions, such as prohibiting contact
with witnesses/prosecution personnel, mandatory reporting to the trial
Court, and electronic monitoring if deemed necessary. Crucially, all
documentary and digital evidence lies seized and securely forms part of
the record, insulating it from prospective tampering.
71.
While the Apex Court has repeatedly underscored the gravity of
economic offences-observing as in Y.S.Jaganmohan Reddy Vs. CBI
(2013) 7 SCC 439 and Serious Fraud Investigation Officer Vs. Nitin
Johari (2019) 9 SCC 165 that they strike at the heart of public interestjudicial discretion demands a vigilant balance. The seriousness of
allegations must never eclipse the constitutional bulwarks safeguarding
individual liberty. Bail cannot be withheld as mere censure for the
alleged conduct; to do so risks transforming pre-trial custody into
impermissible punishment before guilt is adjudged.
72.
In cumulative consideration of the applicant's non-inclusion in the
FIR, total absence of recovery from him, grant of bail to four coaccused, substantial completion of investigation qua him, and the
inexorable prolongation of trial, his continued detention manifests as
unwarranted pre-trial punishment, devoid of compelling necessity.
Needless to observe, this Court expresses no opinion on the merits of
the prosecution case, reserved exclusively for trial adjudication.
Deeming the instant matter fit, the applicant deserves enlargement on
bail.
73.
In
light
of
the
following
compelling
circumstances,
the
investigation against the applicant stands complete; the charge sheet
and supplementary reports have been duly filed; no recoveries emanate
from the applicant; bail has been granted to the principal co-accused;
the trial is likely to be protracted and stringent conditions can effectively
curb any misuse of liberty, therefore this Court holds that the applicant’s
continued detention is neither necessary nor justified at this juncture.
Without venturing any view of the merits, reserved wholly for trial, the
applicant merits enlargement on bail.
74.
Accordingly, the bail application stands allowed. The applicant is
directed to be released forthwith on regular bail in Crime No. 01/2024 of
Police Station EOW/ACB, Raipur, upon furnishing a personal bond in
the sum of ₹1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh only) along with two local
sureties of the like amount to the satisfaction of the learned Trial Court,
subject to the following conditions:
(i) he shall surrender his passport, if any,
before the Trial Court;
(b) the applicant must cooperate with the
investigation and the trial proceedings;
(c) he shall not directly or indirectly make any
inducement, threat or promise to any person
acquainted with the facts of the case;
(d) he shall commit no offence whatsoever
during the period he is on bail; and
(e) in case of change of residential address
and/or mobile number, the same shall be
intimated to the Court concerned by way of
an affidavit.
(f) any stringent conditions as may be
imposed by the trial court.
Any breach of these conditions shall
empower the prosecution to move for bail
cancellation. These observations are strictly
limited to the bail adjudication and shall have
no bearing on the trial on merits.
75.
The application is allowed in the aforesaid terms. All observations
herein are expressly limited to the bail determination and shall not
impinge upon the trial proceedings.
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
SUGUNA
DUBEY
Digitally
signed by
SUGUNA
DUBEY
Date:
2026.03.03
17:29:05
+0530
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review