Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC010215282021
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6992/2021
DIPANKER BORUAH
S/O- NUMOL BORAH, R/O VILLAGE- KACHAMARI DAKHIN NEGHERI
PATHAR, P.O- KACHAMARI, P.S- MERAPANI, SUB-DIVISION- GOLAGHAT,
DIST- GOLAGHAT
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 6 ORS
REP BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECONDARY DEPARTMENT OF
ELEMENTARY EDUCATION, GOVT. OF ASSAM, DISPUR, GHY-06
2:THE DIRECTOR
OF ELEMENTARY EDUCATION
KAHILIPARA
GHY-19
KAMRUP(M)
ASSAM.
3:THE DISTRICT SCRUTINY COMMITTEE
GOLAGHAT DISTRICT
REP BY THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
GOLAGHAT DISTRICT
4:THE DISTRICT ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
GOLAGHAT DISTRICT
5:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
GOLAGHAT WEST
ELEMENTARY EDUCATION BLOCK BOKAKHAT
6:SRI NIRMAL KACHARI AND NIRMALI KACHARI
Page No.# 2/15
TUTOR (ERSTWHILE HEAD MASTER)
NAVAJYOTI MISSING GAON ME SCHOOL
VILL- KACHAMARI DAKHIN NEGHERI PATHAR
P.O- KACHAMARI
P.S- MERAPANI
SUB- DIVISION- GOLAGHAT
DIST GOLAGHAT (ASSAM)
7:MOHESWAR GOGOI
TUTOR
NAVAJYOTI MISSING GAON ME SCHOOL
VILL- KACHAMARI DAKHIN NEGHERI PATHAR
P.O- KACHAMARI
P.S- MERAPANI
SUB- DIVISION- GOLAGHAT
DIST GOLAGHAT (ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. B K DAS, M N KHAN
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, MS. P BORAH (R-6,7),MR P H KONWAR (r-6,7),MR
H P NEPAL (r-6,7),MR S BORTHAKUR (r-6,7),SC, ELEM. EDU
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 11.06.2026
Heard Mr. B K Das, Learned Counsel for the Petitioner. Also heard Ms. P
Borah, Learned Counsel appearing for Respondent Nos. 6 & 7.
2.
This Court had, vide order dated 27.05.2026, required the Learned
Standing Counsel, Department of School Education, Assam, to produce the
orders passed by the Appellate Authority, in pursuance to the directions passed
by this Court, vide order dated 27.09.2022, in WP(C) No. 3480/2021. In the
first half, when the matter was taken up, there was no representation on
Page No.# 3/15
behalf of the Department of School Education, Assam. The matter was
accordingly adjourned to be taken up in the second half. When the matter is
called up in the second half, still there is no representation, on behalf of the
Department of School Education, Assam. The absence of the Learned Standing
Counsel, Department of School Education, Assam, leads this Court to presume
that the Department has got nothing further to add in the matter. Accordingly,
this Court is now proceeding to consider the issue, arising in the present Writ
Petition, on its merits.
3.
The Petitioner, in the present Writ Petition, has assailed the
provincialisation, effected, in respect of the Respondent No. 6 & 7, in Navajyoti
Missing Gaon M.E School. The Petitioner has projected that he was appointed
in the said School by the School Managing Committee, vide an order dated
02.03.2005. The Petitioner joined his services in the said School on 02.03.2005
itself. The Petitioner further projects that he was teaching the subject Social
Studies, to the students in the School, since the date of his initial engagement.
The Petitioner further projects that the Respondent No. 6, Smt. Nirmali
Kachari, who was functioning as the Head-Mistress of the School, was also
teaching the subject of English and the Respondent No. 7, Sri. Maheshwar
Gogoi was teaching the subject Hindi. The Petitioner has further contended in
the Writ Petition that the School, being found eligible for provincialisation of
Page No.# 4/15
the services of the Teachers in the said School, under the provisions of the
Assam Education (Provincialisation of Services of Teachers and Re-organisation
of Educational Institutions) Act, 2017, (as amended), the Head-Mistress of the
said School i.e. Respondent No. 6, had forwarded the particulars of the
Teachers of the School to the concerned Departmental authorities for placing
before the jurisdictional District Scrutiny Committee. The jurisdictional District
Scrutiny Committee, on scrutinizing the service particulars of the teachers of
the School, had recommended the names of Respondent No. 6 & 7, for
provincialisation of their services. Thereafter, the recommendation of the
jurisdictional District Scrutiny Committee, being processed in the manner, as
mandated under the provisions of Act of 2017, the services of Respondent No.
6 & 7, came to be provincialised in the said School.
The service of the Petitioner not being provincialised,
being aggrieved, he has instituted the present Writ Petition.
4.
Mr. B K Das, Learned Counsel for the Petitioner, after reiterating the
facts noticed hereinabove, has, by referring to the particulars of the Teachers
working in the said School, as forwarded by the Respondent No. 6, herein,
submitted that in the said particulars, the Respondent No. 6 had projected
herself, to be teaching the subject English, in addition to being the Head-
Page No.# 5/15
Mistress of the said School. Further, the Respondent No. 7 was shown to be
working as a Hindi Teacher. The Petitioner was shown, therein, to be working
as a Social Studies Teacher. Accordingly, he submits that in view of the
provisions of Section 3 (1) (xi) of the Act of 2017, the services of a Teacher,
teaching the subject Social Studies, being mandatorily required to be
provincialised, the services of the Petitioner, ought to have been provincialised,
before provincialising the services of the Respondent No. 7. He submits that
even if the services of Respondent No. 6 is provincialised, by considering her
to be a Language Teacher, inasmuch as, she was teaching the subject English
in the School, in addition to being working as the Head-Mistress in the said
School, the services of the Respondent No. 7, under no circumstances, was
mandated to be so provincialised, inasmuch as, he was teaching the subject
Hindi and Hindi being not grouped together with the other language subjects
like Assamese, English, Bodo, Bengali etc, the Respondent No. 7 was not a
Language teacher.
5.
In the above premises, Mr. B K Das, Learned Counsel for the Petitioner
submits that the provincialisation, effected in respect of the Respondent No. 7,
would mandate interference from this Court.
6.
Ms. P Borah, Learned Counsel appearing for Respondent Nos. 6 & 7,
Page No.# 6/15
was put a query by this Court, at the outset, to the effect, as to whether the
list of particulars of the Teachers, working in the said School, prepared under
the signature of the Respondent No. 6, was denied by her. Ms. P Borah,
Learned Counsel appearing for Respondent Nos. 6 & 7, has fairly submitted the
said list has not been disputed by the Respondent No. 6. Ms. P Borah, Learned
Counsel appearing for Respondent Nos. 6 & 7, further submits that the
Respondent No. 6, although was appointed as the Head-Mistress in the said
School, she continued to teach the subject English to the students and
accordingly, she must be deemed to be a Language teacher in the said School.
Accordingly, she submits that provincialisation of the services of the
Respondent No. 6, would not mandate an interference by this Court.
7.
With regard to the provincialisation, effected in respect of the
Respondent No. 7, Ms. P Borah, Learned Counsel appearing for Respondent
Nos. 6 & 7, has submitted that Respondent No. 7, was teaching Hindi subject.
The Hindi subject is deemed to be a compulsory subject in the Upper Primary
School, in the State of Assam and accordingly, the services of the incumbent,
teaching the said subject, must mandatorily be provincialised, in order to
facilitate the students studying in the School, to continue to receive their
learning, in the Hindi subject. Accordingly, she submits that the Hindi subject
being a special subject, the provincialisation of the Respondent No. 7, therein,
Page No.# 7/15
by considering the special status accorded to the Hindi subject in an Upper
Primary School, would not mandate an interference. She further submits that
for recognition/permission of an Upper Primary School, a Teacher teaching the
subject Hindi is mandatorily required to be so included in the list of Teacher
appointed in a Upper Primary School in question, otherwise, the School would
be denied the recognition, as well as permission.
8.
Mr. P N Sarma, Learned Standing Counsel, Department of Elementary
Education, Assam, while the Court was dictating the order, had joined the
proceedings and has submitted that the name of the Petitioner, not being
recognized by the jurisdictional District Scrutiny Committee, further processing
of the matter in his case, was not permissible to be done. He submits that the
jurisdictional District Scrutiny Committee had construed the Respondent No. 6,
to be a Teacher teaching the all the subjects, including the subject of Social
Studies, in the School and the Respondent No. 7 was found to be teaching the
subject Hindi, which is a special subject. Accordingly, the services of the
Respondent No. 6, was recommended for provincialisation as against the
subject Social Studies, while the Respondent No. 7, was so recommended for
provincialisation against the subject Hindi.
9.
I have heard the Learned Counsel for the Parties and perused the
Page No.# 8/15
materials available on record.
10.
From the materials brought on record, as well as the submissions
made by the Learned Counsel for the Parties, this Court finds that the issue
arising for consideration in the present Writ Petition, pertains to the eligibility
of the Respondent No. 6 & 7, for having their services provincialised, ignoring
the case of the Petitioner, herein. As projected by Mr. P N Sarma, Learned
Standing Counsel, Department of Education (Elementary), Assam, the District
Scrutiny Committee had construed the Respondent No. 6, to be teaching all
the subjects in the School and accordingly, she was treated to have been
teaching the subject Social Studies and accordingly, her services were so
provincialised as a Social Studies Subject Teacher. The Respondent No. 7 is
projected to be so provincialised in his services by construing him to be
teaching the subject Hindi.
11.
At this stage, this Court would take notice of the provisions of
Section 3 (1) (xi) of the Act of 2017. The said provisions being relevant is
extracted hereinbelow :
“3. Eligibility criteria for selection
institution
for
provincialisation
of
of educational
services
of
teachers/tutors:- (1) Subject to the provisions of Article
30 of the Constitution of India, the following categories
Page No.# 9/15
of Venture Educational Institutions shall be eligible for
being considered for provincialisation of the services of
their teachers and tutors:- ……………
…………………………………………………
…………………………………………………
(xi) In case of Venture Upper Primary School there shall
be minimum three teachers or tutors at least one
teacher each for (a) Science and Mathematics (b) Social
Studies and (c) Languages: Provided that for additional
posts it shall be considered in accordance with the
norms and standard stipulated in the Schedule under
Sections 19 and 25 of the Right of Children to Free and
Compulsory Education Act, 2009 (Central Act No. 35 of
2009);”
12.
A perusal of the main provisions of Section 3 (1) (xi) of the Act of
2017, would go to reveal that in respect of a Venture Upper Primary School,
services of minimum 3 (Three) teachers or tutors, are mandated to be so
provincialised. Amongst the 3 (Three) teachers or tutors, whose services are to
be so provincialised, the teachers, teaching the subjects of Science &
Mathematics, Social Studies and Language, are to be included.
Page No.# 10/15
13.
While Mr. P N Sarma, Learned Standing Counsel, Department of
Elementary Education, Assam, has projected that the District Scrutiny
Committee had construed Smt. Nirmali Kachari i.e. Respondent No. 6,
functioning as the Head-Mistress, to be also teaching the Social Studies
subject and accordingly, her services was provincialised, as a Teacher teaching
Social Studies subject, this Court finds that in the list of particulars of Teachers
of the School, prepared under the signature of the Respondent No. 6 herself,
for the purpose of placing before the Departmental authorities, for
consideration towards provincialisation of the services of the Teachers working
in the School, she had, therein, projected herself to be teaching the subject
English. The projections made in the said list of Teachers, has not been
disputed by the Learned Counsel representing the Respondent No. 6.
14.
Accordingly, this Court would proceed to hold that the
Respondent No. 6, having projected herself to be teaching the subject English,
was provincialised by construing her to be teaching the Language subject in
the said School and, in terms of the provisions of Section 3 (1) (xi) of the Act
of 2017, it is to be held that the Respondent No. 6, was so provincialised
against the requirement of provincialising the services of a Language teacher,
teaching in the said School. Accordingly, the provincialisation of the
Respondent No. 6, being found to be in tune with the provisions of Section 3
Page No.# 11/15
(1) (xi) of the Act of 2017, in the considered view of this Court, the challenge
presented by the Petitioner, to such provincialisation, effected in respect of the
Respondent No. 6, would not mandate an interference and the said challenge
stands rejected.
15.
Having drawn the said conclusions, this Court would now
consider the challenge presented by the Petitioner to the provincialisation,
effected in respect of the Respondent No. 7. As noticed hereinabove, the
Respondent No. 7, is projected by all the parties to be teaching the subject
Hindi in the said School. Mr. P N Sarma, Learned Standing Counsel,
Department of Elementary Education, Assam, has contended that the subject
Hindi has been grouped together with the other language subjects like English,
Assamese, Bodo, Bengali etc. The said contention, if to be accepted, the
Respondent No. 6, being now held to have been provincialised as a Language
teacher, in the said School, it would occasion that services of 2 (two) Language
teachers, came to be provincialised. Such a position would be in violation of
the main provision of the Section 3 (1) (xi) of the Act of 2017 and accordingly
the said position cannot be permitted to be continued with.
16.
This Court further notices the submission made by the Learned
Counsel for the Respondents, to the effect that Hindi being a compulsory
Page No.# 12/15
subject, required to be taught in Upper Primary School of the State of Assam,
services of a Teacher teaching the subject Hindi, in a venture Educational
Institution, must necessarily be provincialised. This Court has perused the
provisions of the Act of 2017 and does not find, therein, any stipulation made
to the said effect. In the School in question, given the student enrollment
position, services of only 3 (three) teachers was mandated to be provincialised
as Teachers and/or tutors, in terms of the provisions of Section 3 (1) (xi) of
the Act of 2017. Hindi not being a specified subject, in the provisions of
Section 3 (1) (xi) of the Act of 2017, the contentions raised by the Learned
Counsel for the Respondent No. 7, stands rejected, on finding the same to be
contrary to the positions of the Act of 2017.
17.
This Court further notices that in terms of the provisions of
Section 3 (1) (xi) of the Act of 2017, services of Social Studies Teacher, is
mandatorily required to be provincialised. This Court finds from the list of
particulars forwarded by the Respondent No. 6, that the Petitioner was the
only person teaching the subject Social Studies in the School, when it was in
its venture stage. Accordingly, this Court holds that the Services of the
Petitioner was mandatorily required to be so provincialised, in compliance with
the provisions of Section 3 (1) (xi) of the Act of 2017.
Page No.# 13/15
18.
In view of the above discussion, the Respondent No. 7, having
been found by this Court, to have been provincialised, in violation of the
provisions of the Act of 2017 and the Petitioner, herein, having been also found
to have been deprived of provincialisation of his services, in violation to the
provisions of the Act of 2017, more particularly the provisions of Section 3 (1)
(xi) of the Act of 2017, this Court proceeds to interfere with the
provincialisation, so effected, in respect of the Respondent No. 7, herein.
Accordingly, the provincialisation of the services of the Respondent No. 7,
stands set-aside.
19.
In view of the above conclusions, the case of the Petitioner, being
contented by the State Respondents to have not been recommended by the
jurisdictional District Scrutiny Committee, the Petitioner is directed to submit
an application before the Director of Elementary Education, Assam, within a
period of 30 (Thirty) days from today staking a claim for having his services,
provincialised under the provisions of the Act of 2017. The Director of
Elementary Education, Assam, on receipt of the said application, shall place
the same before the jurisdictional District Scrutiny Committee, within a further
period of 15 (Fifteen) days. The District Scrutiny Committee, on receipt of the
application submitted by the Petitioner, from the Director of Elementary
Education, Assam, shall proceed to verify the service particulars of the
Page No.# 14/15
Petitioner, strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Act of 2017, by
reckoning the list of Teachers working in the School during its venture stage,
as forwarded by the Respondent No. 6, for consideration of provincialisation of
their services, as well as, the conclusions drawn, hereinabove, by this Court, in
the present order. The District Scrutiny Committee shall initiate and complete
its process of verification and make its recommendation, within a period of 1
(One) month from the date of receipt of the application, preferred by the
Petitioner, in this connection, from the Director of Elementary Education,
Assam. The District Scrutiny Committee, shall, thereafter, place the
recommendations made by it, in respect of the Petitioner before the Director of
Elementary Education, Assam. The Director of Elementary Education, Assam, if
the recommendation so made by the jurisdictional District Scrutiny Committee,
is in favour of the Petitioner, shall process the matter further in accordance
with the provisions of the Act of 2017 and take the same to its logical
conclusion, within a further period of 2 (Two) months from the date the
recommendations of the jurisdictional District Scrutiny Committee, is placed
before her.
20.
In the event the Petitioner is found to be eligible for having his
services provincialised, upon processing the matter, in terms of the directions
passed, hereinabove, the provincialisation of the Petitioner shall be given effect
Page No.# 15/15
with all consequential benefits, from the date services of the Respondent No.
6, was so provincialised. In the event the Petitioner, is found to be not eligible
for having his services provincialised, the Director of Elementary Education,
Assam, shall pass a speaking order and, therein, incorporate the reasons, as to
why the Petitioner was found to be not eligible for having his services
provincialised, and communicate the same to the Petitioner, within a further
period of 2 (Two) months, w.e.f the date, the said decision is so arrived at in
the constituted Committees, under the Act of 2017.
21.
It is further provided that the benefits of provincialisation of his
services, received by the Respondent No. 7, shall not be recovered, till today,
however, no benefit of provincialisation of his services shall be granted to the
Respondent No. 7, w.e.f today.
22.
With the above observations and directions, the present Writ Petition
stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review