The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel, though referring to Section 48 (h) of the Act, argued that for civil offences, a fine was supposed to be imposed but such submission is not convincing, as Section 48 of the Act nowhere creates a bar for imposing any other punishment as enumerated therein other than the fine. So far the submission of Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel regarding the receipt of letter by the appellant beyond the stipulated date for the purpose of nominating one person including a legal practitioner is concerned, it appears that no such plea was taken by the appellant before the appellate authority and no material is also placed in the record to prove such an allegation. Therefore, we do not find any error in the decision of learned Single Judge in the impugned judgment. In view of the foregoing discussions, it is held that the appeal is devoid of any merit and the same is, accordingly, dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of. (S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J (APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ SATABDI DUTTA Digitally Satabdi
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No. 85 of 2023
Dipankar Pramanik,
(No.069440621, Constable G.D),
S/o- Late Kanailal Pramanik of Village-Bhimpur,
Uttarpara, P.O. Bhimpur, Police Station-Kotwali,
District-Nadia, PIN-741167, Age-41 years, presently
camping at C/o. Satyajit Sutradhar, A. D. Nagar,
Road No.1, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799003.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Union of India,
To be represented by the Secretary,
Ministry of Defense, having its office at CGO Complex,
Lodhi Estate, New Delhi-110003.
2. The Director General of BSF,
Having his office at CGO, Lodhi Estate,
New Delhi-110003.
3. The Assistant Commandant,
74 Bn, Frontier Headquarter,
BSF, Salbagan, Agartala, West Tripura.
4. The Commandant,
74th BN, BSF, presently inducted in
Gujarat Frontier Service through the
Frontier Headquarters of BSC, Gujarat.
...... Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. D Paul, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Dy. SGI.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
01/04/2024
This appeal arises out of judgment & order dated 22.09.2022
passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.367 of 2022, whereby the
writ petition of the appellant was dismissed.
2.
The appellant was engaged as Constable (GD) in Border Security
Force (BSF) in the year 2006. A Summary Security Force Court (for short,
“SSFC”) was constituted to initiate a court proceeding against the appellant for
the alleged commission of offence punishable under Sections 46 & 22(e) of
BSF Act, 1968 (for short, “the Act”) whereby two charges under above said
provisions of law were framed against the appellant.
3.
The first charge contained the allegation that while deployed at
BOP Gorungula (Tent post) of 74 Bn. BSF, during February, 2019, he
deposited total amount of Rs.76,439/- on various dates, in the Bank accounts of
his younger brother, Sri. Dinesh Pramanik and his brother-in-law, namely, Sri.
Kalyan Shil, which was disproportionate to his known source of income, and
he could not satisfactorily account for the same and thereby committed an
offence under Section 46 of BSF Act, 1968 read with Sec.13(2) of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
4.
The second charge contained the allegation that during said period
of deployment at BOP Gorungula, he allegedly contravened an SOP issued by
74th Bn. BSF vide letter No.961-979 dated 19-4-2018 and Ftr. HQ BSF,
Tripura letter No.678-81 dated 22nd March, 2016 which prescribed that no
individual deployed on border was allowed to retain any amount more than
Rs.500/- at any given point of time in his possession, but in contravention
thereto, he got deposited the said amount of Rs.76,439/-.
5.
After completion of proceeding in the said SSFC the appellant
was found guilty of both the charges, and he was sentenced to be dismissed
from service vide an order passed by the Commandant, 74 Bn. BSF dated
19.04.2021. The appellant, thereafter, preferred a statutory appeal to the
Inspector General of BSF which was kept pending by the appellate authority,
and being aggrieved thereby, he preferred writ petition No. W.P.A. 19065 of
2021 in Calcutta High Court and vide order dated 06.12.2021, said High Court
directed the appellate authority to dispose of the appeal within twelve weeks.
The appeal was thereafter disposed of by way of rejection and then, the above
said writ petition bearing WP(C) No.367 of 2022 was filed before this court.
The relevant portion of observations and decision of learned Single Judge in
the impugned order are extracted below:“9
The submissions of learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner are too two-pronged.
Firstly, it is submitted that the petitioner was not
given enough opportunity to cross-examine the prosecution
witness no.2.
In view of the above submission, I have perused the
examination-in-chief and cross-examination. It is found that
the examination-in-chief part was made understood to the
petitioner, and thereafter he was given opportunities to crossexamine the prosecution witness no.2. As such, it is difficult
for this court to hold that the petitioner was not given
reasonable opportunity to cross-examine the prosecution
witness no.2. Accordingly, this submission of learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner is repelled.
10.
Second fold of submission of Mr. Ghoshal, learned
counsel for the petitioner is that the appellate authority while
disposing of the Memo of Appeal submitted by the petitioner
was found to be much inclined upon the findings of the
inquiring authority, and, according to learned counsel, the
finding of the appellate authority is a replica of the findings
of the inquiring authority.
I do not find any substance in the submission of
learned counsel for the petitioner because the appellate
authority is under obligation to discuss and appreciate the
findings of the inquiry authority to apply his independent
mind.
11.
That apart, Mr. Ghoshal, learned counsel for the
petitioner has submitted that the punishment imposed upon
the petitioner is disproportionate to the offence he had
committed.
I have considered the above submission. The
petitioner is a member of a disciplined Force of this country.
He must be honest, committed and sincere to his service
towards the nation in all respects whatsoever. Charge that
was framed against him is that some money had been
deposited to the accounts of his two relatives which is
disproportionate to his known source of income. The
prosecution witnesses appearing before the inquiry authority
during the course of proceedings had categorically stated that
those sums of money were given by the petitioner to them to
deposit the same to the accounts of his relatives. On the other
hand, the petitioner could not justify the source of this
money. Even if it is viewed otherwise, then, there will be a
natural question that from where those two witnesses,
namely, Tapesh Debnath and Sahalam Khan had received
the account numbers of the relatives of the petitioner. That
means, the petitioner had obtained the charged money from
illegal source while in service. It is a serious offence and
dismissal from service is appropriate punishment in this
nature of offence. I do not find any illegality in imposing
penalty of dismissal against the petitioner.”
6.
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the appellant,
argues that the appellant was not provided with a reasonable opportunity to
defend his case, which was a gross violation of the principles of natural justice.
He was also not given sufficient scope to cross examine the witnesses and the
questionnaires of examination were made in „YES‟ or „NO‟ format in a
preconceived manner. The learned counsel referring to Section 48(h) of the
Act, contends that the prescribed punishment so far as the first charge was
concerned, falls within the category of civil offences as defined in Section 46
of the Act and, therefore, imposition of a fine would be the proper punishment
as was prescribed under Section 48(h) of the Act.
7.
Learned counsel Mr. Bhattacharjee, further contends that PW-1 (a
civilian witness alleged to have deposited the money in the Bank account of
relatives of the appellant) though initially stated that total Rs.50,000/- was
deposited by him but subsequently he admitted that the appellant had paid him
Rs.500/- to facilitate such transaction. Learned counsel also argues that the
cross examination of the witnesses ought to have been conducted by an
advocate or any legal expert but the appellant was denied that opportunity.
Learned counsel submits that no scope was provided to the appellant to furnish
the name of his legal assistant and the letter of the department asking him to
furnish the name of his legal assistant or his legal practitioner was even
received by him after the expiry of stipulated date.
8.
According to Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel, the cross-
examination was recorded in a predetermined manner and the appellate
authority also failed to consider the grounds taken in the appeal by the
appellant. Learned counsel finally prays for setting aside the impugned order of
learned Single Judge and to pass necessary order by quashing the order of
dismissal of the appellant from the service.
9.
On the contrary, learned Dy. SGI, Mr. Bidyut Majumder,
appearing for the respondents-Union of India, argues that all reasonable
opportunities during the proceeding were provided to the appellant, including
the opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses and the appellant was also
given the liberty to engage any legal practitioner during the trial. Learned Dy.
SGI also submits that in said proceeding the appellant pleaded his guilt against
both the above charges and the offences committed by him were also serious in
nature, warranting dismissal from the service as he, being a member of a
disciplined force, indulged in financial corruption.
10.
According to Mr. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI, there were no
lapses in the said proceeding and all required legal formalities were complied
by the authority as per law before imposing the punishment. Mr. Majumder,
learned Dy. SGI, therefore, prays for the dismissal of this appeal.
11.
From the record, it is found that in total six witnesses were
examined in the said proceeding, including two civilians who stated about the
deposit of money by witness No.1 in the Bank account of said relatives of the
appellant at the instance of the appellant. Said witness Nos.1 & 2 were crossexamined by the appellant and other witnesses were not cross-examined by
him. Cross-examination done by him on witness Nos.1 & 2 was recorded in
question answer format by the Recording Officer. Just because the same was
recorded in question answer format, it cannot be said that he was not given the
opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses. As per Rule 48(4) of BSF Rules
1969, he was also given the opportunity to produce his own evidence, but he
declined.
12.
The appellate authority also elaborately discussed its decision in
the said appeal and it was also observed that the appellant himself pleaded his
guilt in the proceeding. He was also given scope to make a statement of his
defense.
13.
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel, though referring to Section 48
(h) of the Act, argued that for civil offences, a fine was supposed to be imposed
but such submission is not convincing, as Section 48 of the Act nowhere
creates a bar for imposing any other punishment as enumerated therein other
than the fine. So far the submission of Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel
regarding the receipt of letter by the appellant beyond the stipulated date for
the purpose of nominating one person including a legal practitioner is
concerned, it appears that no such plea was taken by the appellant before the
appellate authority and no material is also placed in the record to prove such an
allegation. Therefore, we do not find any error in the decision of learned Single
Judge in the impugned judgment.
In view of the foregoing discussions, it is held that the appeal is
devoid of any merit and the same is, accordingly, dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
signed by SATABDI DUTTA
SATABDI DUTTA Digitally
Date: 2024.04.18 16:59:59 +05'30'
Satabdi
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review