Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:422
Serial No.18
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl. Rev. P. No. 8 of 2023
Date of Hearing: 19.05.2025
Date of Decision:19.05.2025
____________________________________________________________
Dr. Dinesh Bhatia
Vs. 1.The Central Bureau of Investigation
Son of Shri Ashok Bhatia
ACB, Oakland, Shillong - 793001
R/o NEHU Campus, Umshing,
Through the Superintendent of
Shillong. East Khasi Hills District, Police.
Meghalaya.
2. Shri Raghuvendra Pratap Tripathi
S/o Shri Ram Krishna Tripathi
R/o Shyamdaspur, Atrauli, Hardoi,
P.O. Kaudiya- 241204,
Uttar Pradesh.
….. Petitioner.
……Respondents.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. S. Pandit Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with.
Ms. N.A.U. Sogra, Adv.(R:1)
Mr. S. Thapa, Adv. (R: 2)
2025:MLHC:422
(JUDGMENT AND ORDER)
The petitioner, who is an accused in Special (CBI) Case No. 1 of 2020, has
challenged the order dated 25-01-2023 of the learned Special Judge, Shillong
whereby the learned Special Judge tendered pardon to the respondent No.2.
1.
The fact of the case is that the respondent No.1 registered a case on 23-
11-2018 on the basis of a written complaint dated 22-08-2018 of the
respondent No.2, who was a student in the Department of Bio-Medical
Engineering, North Eastern Hill University, Shillong, against the petitioner,
an Associate Professor and head of Department of Bio-Medical Engineering,
North Eastern Hill University, Shillong. It was alleged in the complaint that
the petitioner was indulging in fraudulent practices and threatening the
respondent No.2 to hand over him the proceeds of fake bills sanctioned by the
petitioner in the name of the firms namely, M/s S. K. Enterprise, M/s Riddhi
Medical Store and M/s Vindhyavasini Enterprise. It was alleged that an
amount of Rs. 45,000/- was deposited in the bank account of the complainant/
respondent No.2 by one Ranjeet Kumar Gupta, which was proceeds of the
fake bills sanctioned by the petitioner and out of this the petitioner had asked
the complainant to withdraw Rs. 40,000/- in cash and hand over to him.
Since, the respondent No.2 did not want to hand over the illegal gratification
of Rs. 40,000/- to the petitioner, he lodged written complaint with CBI, ACB,
Shillong (respondent No.1) to take necessary action against the petitioner.
After conclusion of the investigation, the respondent No.1 filed charge-sheet
on 28-02-2020 against the three accused persons viz. A1(the petitioner), A2
(Ranjeet Kumar Gupta) and A3 (complainant/respondent No.2).
2.
On 04-02-2021, the respondent No.2 filed an application under Section
306 Cr.PC before the Trial Court praying for grant of pardon. After hearing
2025:MLHC:422
the parties, the learned Trial Court passed the order dated 25-01-2023
granting pardon to the respondent No.2 on condition that he will make a full
and true disclosure of the whole of the circumstances related to the offence.
The petitioner has assailed the said order dated 25-01-2023 in the present
revision petition before this Court.
3.
Mr. Pandit, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that
the learned Trial Court had committed a gross error of law by passing the
impugned order. He submits that the charge-sheet filed by the respondent
No.1 implicates all the three accused persons and in such a situation it was
improper for the Trial Court to tender pardon to the respondent No.2. He
submits that there was no proper application of mind by the learned Trial
Court and the materials on record were not taken into consideration at the
time of passing the impugned order. He further contends that learned Trial
Court has acted mechanically only on the basis of the no objection of the
respondent No.1 and has not even considered the fact that whether there was
sufficient evidence available with the prosecution before considering the
prayer for grant of pardon by the respondent No.2. He submits that the
application filed by the respondent No.2 before the Trial Court was motivated
and the passing of the impugned order is prejudicial to the interest of the
petitioner in the case. The learned Counsel placed reliance on a decision
dated 02-06-2023 of the High Court Punjab and Haryana in Somveer Singh
Vs. State of Haryana and others and submits that where there exists sufficient
prosecution evidence, grant of pardon cannot be held to be justified. He also
placed reliance on the decision of Apex Court in Central Bureau of
Investigation Vs. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal, (2013) 15 SCC 222 to impress
upon the Court that the revisional powers under Section 397 r/w Section 401
Cr.PC can be exercised by the High Court suo motu to examine the
2025:MLHC:422
correctness, legality and propriety of any order passed by the inferior Court.
He contends that the consequence of grant of pardon was required to be taken
into consideration and it was incumbent upon the Trial Court to compare the
culpability of the person seeking pardon qua the other co-accused. He submits
that for the reason of non-adherence to the principles of settled law, the
impugned order passed by the Trial Court cannot be sustained and is liable to
be interfered with.
4.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSGI appearing for the respondent No.1
supports that impugned order and submits that the learned Trial Court has
taken into consideration the relevant factors before passing the order. He
submits that the provision of Section 306 Cr.PC as well as the decisions of the
Apex Court in Lt. Commander Pascal Fernandes v. State of Maharashtra,
AIR 1968 SC 594 and Suresh Chandra Bahri V. State of Hibar, 1995 Supp
(1) SCC 80 were taken into consideration by the learned Trial Court while
passing the order dated 25-01-2023. He submits that the respondent No.1 has
no objection to the tender of pardon in view of the fact that the respondent
No.2 is ready to make a full and true disclosure privy to the offence before the
Trial Court. He submits that the learned Trial Court has not committed any
jurisdictional error in passing the impugned order and hence, the same does
not call for any interference by this Court.
5.
Mr. S. Thapa, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent No.2
endorses the submission made on behalf of the respondent No.1 and submits
that there is no illegality or infirmity in the order passed by the learned Trial
Court. He contends that the petitioner being a co-accused cannot question the
act of grant of pardon by the Trial Court to the respondent No.2. By placing
reliance on a decision dated 07-12-2021 of the High Court of Madras in Crl.
R. C. NO. 662 of 2000 and Crl. M.P. Nos. 4397 and 8167 of 2000,
2025:MLHC:422
Senthamarai Vs. S. Krishnaraj and Ors, the learned Counsel submits that the
tender of pardon and its acceptance is entirely between the Court concerned
and the person to whom it is made.
He submits that the plea of prejudice
raised on behalf of the petitioner has no base as the respondent No.2 will be
examined as a witness by the prosecution in the case and the petitioner will
have the opportunity of cross-examination. He submits that there is no merit
in this revision petition and prays that the same may be dismissed.
6.
On consideration of the submissions made by the parties and after
going through the materials on records, it is clear that though the respondent
No.2 has been made an accused in the case, the entire investigation was
conducted on the basis of the written complaint dated 22-11-2018 lodged by
the respondent No.2 resulting in filing of the charge-sheet dated 28-02-2020
by the respondent No.1. Therefore, it is apparent that the allegations made in
the written complaint dated 22-11-2018 will require the evidence of the
respondent No.2 to facilitate the prosecution to prove its case at the trial.
Without the recourse of Section 306 Cr.PC, the respondent No.2 cannot be
examined as a witness in the case against another accused. The fact that this
entire prosecution case came into light because of the written complaint dated
22-11-2018 makes it amply clear that the tender of pardon will be in the
interest of justice of a successful prosecution of the other offenders whose
conviction is not easy without the testimony of the respondent No.2.
7.
The application of the respondent No.2 before the Trial Court seeking
grant of pardon was not objected to by the respondent No.1 and therefore, it is
obvious that the prosecution endorsed the request that the respondent No.2 be
pardoned and made an approver and be examined as a prosecution witness.
The object of Section 306 Cr.PC is that the offenders of the heinous and grave
offences do not go unpunished on account of lack of evidence. The very
2025:MLHC:422
purpose of enacting Section 306 Cr.PC is with a view to obtaining the
evidence of any person supposed to have been directly or indirectly concerned
in or privy to an offence to which the section applies to help the prosecution
to bring offenders to account for their actions. In the present case, the learned
Trial Court while passing the order dated 25-01-2023 has taken notice of the
fact that the respondent No. 2 was the complainant and it was on the basis of
his complaint that the case came to be registered. The learned Trial Court has
also taken note of the statement made by the respondent No.2 in his
application that he was willing to make a full and true disclosure privy to the
offence in totality before the Court. On consideration of the above, coupled
with no objection to the tender of pardon by the respondent No.1, the learned
Trial Court proceeded to tender pardon to the respondent No.2 on the
condition that he should make a full and true disclosure of the whole of the
circumstances within his knowledge related to the offence and to every other
person concerned, whether as principle or abettor in the commission thereof.
Thus, it is clear that the learned Trial Court has passed the order dated 25-012023 by proper appreciation of the fact of the case and the provision of
Section 306 Cr. PC. There is no indication that the application filed by the
respondent No.2 before the Trial Court was filed with oblique motives.
8.
The decisions cited by the learned Counsel for the petitioner are of not
much relevance in the present matter in view of the fact that in none of the
cases the persons seeking pardon were the complainant. In the present case,
though the respondent No.2 was named as an accused (A-3), the fact remains
that he is the complainant in the matter. The contention that the tendering of
pardon has caused prejudice to the petitioner is not worthy of acceptance
since the prosecution is under obligation to examine the respondent No.2 as a
witness in the case and the petitioner will have the right to cross-examine him.
2025:MLHC:422
9.
In view of the above, the petitioner has failed to make out a case for
interference and consequently this revision petition stands dismissed.
Judge
Meghalaya
19.05.2025
“Biswarup PS”
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2025.05.20 18:10:24 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review