Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:549
Serial No.01
Supple List 1
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl. A. No. 24 of 2023
Date of Decision: 14.06.2024
Shri. Differson Makdoh @Makhon Vs. State of Meghalaya
Son of Lucymon Makdoh,
Through the Commissioner
Aged about 30 years,
& Secretary to the Government
Resident of : Iewmawlong, Ri-Bhoi
of Meghalaya, Department of
District, Nongpoh.
Home (Police), Civil Secretariat,
Presently serving sentence in Ri-Bhoi
Shillong.
District Jail, Nongpoh.
::::Applicant/Appellant.
::::Respondent.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Dr. P. Agarwal, Legal Aid Counsel.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. R. Gurung, GA.
Mr. A. H. Kharwanlang, GA
i)
ii)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:549
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
This criminal appeal is preferred against the Judgment and order of
conviction dated 03-01-2020 passed by the Court of the Sessions
Judge/Additional DC, Ri-Bhoi District, Nongpoh in Sessions Case No. 19
of 2018 whereby the appellant was convicted under Section 326 IPC and
Part II of Section 308 IPC and awarded sentence of 7 (seven) years
rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 10,000/- (ten thousand) and in
default of payment to undergo further simple imprisonment of one month.
1.
The fact of the case is that on 22-11-2017, a written FIR was lodged
by Smt. Rimisha R. Marak (PW-1) (sister of the victim) to the effect that
Shri. Banshemphang R. Marak (victim) was stabbed with a knife by Shri.
Makhon Makdoh (accused-appellant) on 21-11-2017 at around 10.30 PM at
Iewmawlong junction while the victim was coming from the house of his
employer Shri. Comingson Kharchandi. The injured victim was taken to
the Civil Hospital, Nongpoh from where he was referred to NEIGRIHMS
hospital, Shillong and kept in ICU.
On the basis of the FIR, Nongpoh PS
Case No.265 (11) 2017 u/S 326/307 IPC was registered and the matter was
investigated into. On the completion of the investigation, a charge-sheet
bearing No.45/2018 dated 05-06-2018 u/S 326/307 IPC was submitted and
the appellant was put to trial.
On 24-09-2018, charge under Section
2024:MLHC:549
326/307 IPC was framed against the appellant where he pleaded not guilty
and claimed trial. At the trial, the prosecution examined as many as 12
(twelve) witnesses, exhibited 11 documents and 4 (four) material exhibits
in support of its case.
After the conclusion of the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses, the appellant was examined under Section 313
Cr.PC. The appellant declined to adduce any defence witness. Thereafter,
the matter was finally heard and the learned Tril Court by impugned
Judgment and Order dated 03-01-2020 convicted the appellant under
Section 326 and Part II of Section 308 IPC and sentenced the appellant to
undergo seven years rigorous imprisonment and imposed a fine of Rs.
10,000/- and in default of payment, to undergo further one month’s simple
imprisonment.
2.
Dr. P. Agarwal, learned Legal Aid Counsel appearing for the
appellant in her argument does not dispute the occurrence of the incident
and involvement of the appellant in the incident. However, the learned
Counsel submits that the appellant has not committed any crime
intentionally and the act committed by him was under extreme provocation.
The learned Counsel further submits that it was the victim who by his
action provoked the appellant and the appellant has committed the alleged
act in his self-defense. There was no presence of “mens rea” in the act of
the appellant and it was a case of “actus reus”. The learned Counsel
2024:MLHC:549
submits that even the Trial Court in its impugned Judgment and Order has
specifically recorded that the accused was provoked by the victim. The
learned Counsel submits that the sentence awarded is not proportionate to
the nature of the crime and prays that the sentence may be reduced to the
period of detention undergone by the appellant and he may be released.
3.
Countering the submission advanced on behalf of the appellant, Mr.
R. Gurung, learned GA appearing for the State-respondent submits that the
contention raised on behalf of the appellant is not backed by any sound
proposition of law and is based on the premises of sympathy and mercy
which has no place in criminal law. He supports the conviction and the
sentence awarded by the Trial Court and submits that the injury inflicted on
the victim speaks of the mindset of the appellant while he committed the
crime. The learned GA further submits that during the course of trial, the
appellant did not put any effort to establish a case of extreme provocation
while cross-examining the prosecution witnesses.
He submits that the
appellant does not deserve any leniency from this Court and the appeal be
dismissed being devoid of merit.
4.
Heard the learned Counsels appearing for the rival parties and also
perused the materials available on record.
5.
The PW-1, the sister of the victim who lodged the FIR, in her
deposition before the Trial Court stated that two friends of the victim took
2024:MLHC:549
the injured victim to the Civil Hospital, Nongpoh and after that she was
informed that the victim was assaulted by the appellant. She also stated that
she went to the house of the appellant on the next day of the incident to ask
for medical expenses which was refused by the mother of the appellant.
On the same day she went to the police station and lodged the FIR (Exhibit
P1). She stated that the victim told her after his discharge from hospital
that the appellant stabbed him.
6.
The PW-2 and the PW-3, both of whom are friends of the victim and
were present with the victim at the time of the incident, deposed more or
less in the same line. From the deposition of the said witnesses, it can be
gathered that on the day of incident, i.e. on 21-11-2017 at around 9.30 PM
or 10.00 PM, while coming back together in an auto rickshaw driven by the
victim from the house of the employer of the victim, upon reaching
Iewmawlong junction, they noticed a truck had dashed one grocery shop.
On seeing this, the victim stopped the auto rickshaw and all of them headed
towards the truck. While the PW-2 and PW-3 were inspecting the damaged
truck and the said shop, the victim went to the driver side of the truck.
Suddenly, they heard victim’s call for help and rushed to the driver side of
the truck and saw the appellant was standing next to the victim who was
bleeding from stomach. They asked for help from the appellant for taking
the victim to the hospital, but the appellant refused and fled away.
2024:MLHC:549
Thereafter, they took the victim inside the auto rickshaw and rushed to the
hospital.
Later, the relatives of the victims were informed. Both the
witnesses asserted that the appellant was present at the place of occurrence
and committed the crime.
7.
The victim, who was examined as PW-4 in his deposition before the
Court stated that on the day of the occurrence, at around 9. 00 PM, while
returning from the house of his employer along with PW-2 and PW-3 by
the auto rickshaw driven by him, on reaching Iewmawlong junction saw
one truck dashed against one tea stall. On seeing the truck, they stopped
and got down. The two of his friends (PW-2 and PW-3) went towards the
left side of the truck and he climbed to the driver’s door of the truck and
saw the appellant sitting on the driver’s sit raising the accelerator of the
said truck to remove the said truck. He asked the appellant why did he act
smart by driving the said truck when he did not know how to drive, the
appellant remained silent with his hand at his back and when the victim
turned towards the truck, the appellant from behind stabbed him from his
left side of his chest. The appellant pulled him and at the same time
stabbed him four times. He could feel blood coming out and shouted for
help. Thereafter, the victim’s friends heard his cry for help and came
towards him and lifted him inside the auto rickshaw and took him to the
Civil Hospital Nongpoh.
2024:MLHC:549
8.
The PW-5 is the seizure witness and proved the seizure list Exhibit P
2 by which the grey T-Shirt (Material Exhibit 1) was seized. He also
identified the said material exhibit.
9.
The PW-6 is also another seizure witness who proved Exhibit P 5,
the seizure list, by which Material Exhibit 2 (Knife) was seized by the
police on being led by the appellant.
10.
The PW-7 is the doctor who attended the victim at Civil Hospital,
Nongpoh, when the victim was taken to the hospital. He stated that he
examined the victim with the assistance of his staffs and found two stab
wounds on the left side of the abdomen and two on the left upper back.
The injuries suffered by the victim was grievous in nature and sufficient
enough to cause his death.
11.
The PW-8 is also another medical expert who attended victim on
22-11-2017 when the victim was referred to NEIGHRIMS hospital. He
deposed that victim had multiple stab injuries on the left side of the chest
and upper abdomen and the final diagnosis was homicidal injury with left
diaphragmatic injury with fracture left 8 ribs with splenic injury.
12.
The PW-9 is a forensic expert who was holding the post of In-
charge Director, FSL, deposed before the Trial Court that he examined the
victim’s T-Shirt marked as Exhibit – A and two numbers of blood samples
marked as Exhibit – C and also the knife marked as Exhibit – B and
2024:MLHC:549
prepared the examination report which was intimated to the Superintendent
of Police. He exhibited the FSL report as Exhibit P 8.
13.
The PW-10 is another FSL expert who was holding the post of
Scientific Officer, Physical Division. He deposed that he examined the TShirt of the victim marked as Exhibit – A and the knife marked as Exhibit –
B and observed that the cut marks on Exhibit – A were found to be similar
with the tested cut marks by Exhibit – B. He stated that after he completed
the examination, the exhibits were sent to Biology Division along with the
report. He exhibited the report before the Court as Exhibit P 9.
14.
The PW-11, who is the Investigating Officer of the case, in his
deposition before the Court narrated in details of the steps taken during
investigation of the crime right from the visit of place of occurrence,
recording of statement of the witnesses and collection of material exhibit in
the matter. He also deposed that the appellant was arrested and during
interrogation he voluntarily admitted that he had stabbed the appellant. He
further stated that the knife by which the victim was stabbed was also
recovered on the leading of the appellant. He also stated that the appellant
has admitted to have committed the crime in his statement recorded under
Section 164 Cr.PC. and the evidence collected through forensic test also are
positive.
2024:MLHC:549
15.
The PW-12 is the Judicial Magistrate who recorded the confessional
statement of the appellant. The said witness deposed before the Court that
the appellant had confessed to the commission of crime without any
intention to hurt anybody.
She further deposed that the confessional
statement of the accused was recorded after following the due process of
law and after ascertaining that it is voluntary. The confessional statement
was exhibited as Exhibit P 11 before the Trial Court.
16.
A careful scrutiny of the entire evidence on record, as summarized
above, establishes beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant was
responsible for inflicting stab injuries by a knife on the victim.
The
statement of the appellant made under Sections 164 Cr.PC. and 313 Cr.PC.
lend further support to the above fact. However, the reason behind such
commission of crime by the appellant is not crystalized by the evidence on
record. In his statement under Sections 164 Cr.PC. and 313 Cr.PC. the
appellant asserted that he has committed the crime in self-defense. The
learned Trial Court seems to have accepted the assertion made by the
appellant and proceeded to convict the appellant under Section 326 and
Part II of Section 308 IPC by holding that charge under Section 307 IPC
has not been proved against the appellant. Nothing has been placed before
this Court to disturb the findings and the conclusion arrived by the Trial
Court. Hence, the impugned Judgment and order of conviction dated 03-
2024:MLHC:549
01-2020 passed by the Court of the Sessions Judge/Additional DC, Ri-Bhoi
District, Nongpoh in Sessions Case No. 19 of 2018 needs no interference
by this Court.
17.
Coming to the prayer made by the learned Counsel for the appellant
for reduction of sentence, it is seen that the victim had received 4 (four)
stab injuries caused by the appellant which, according to the medical
witness, were sufficient enough to cause death. That apart, perusal of the
charge-sheet filed in the case reveals that the appellant was involved in
another criminal case registered as Nongpoh PS Case No. 51(03) 2015
under Section 307/506 IPC. Hence, in the facts and circumstances, this
Court is not inclined to accede to the prayer made on behalf of the
appellant.
18.
In the light of the discussions made above, there is no merit in the
present Criminal Appeal and the same stands dismissed.
19.
Let an authenticated copy of this Judgment and Order be supplied
immediately to the appellant free of cost.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
14.06.2024
“Biswarup-PS”
BISWARUP
BISWARUP BHATTACHARJEE
2024.06.14 18:49:36
BHATTACHARJEE Date:
+05'30'
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review