Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010272262018
2026:GAU-AS:4243
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO.188 OF 2018
1.
Dibrugarh
Hanumanbux
Surajmal
Kanoi
Commerce
College,
Dibrugarh, Established and
constituted under Dibrugarh
University Act, 1965 represented
by its Principal and Secretary,
Dr. Khanindra Misra Bhagawati,
Dibrugarh
Hanumanbux
Surajmal
Kanoi
Commerce
College, Dibrugarh, DistrictDibrugarh, Assam
PIN: 786001.
2.
Dr. Khanindra Misra Bhagawati,
The Principal and Secretary,
Dibrugarh Hanumanbux Surajmal
Kanoi
Commerce
College,
Dibrugarh, District- Dibrugarh,
Assam, PIN- 786001
…….Petitioners
-Versus1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
Sri Kamal Chandra Gogoi
Son of Late Uma Kanta Gogoi
R/O- Banipur, Bye lane No. 2,
P.O. Banipur, P.S. and Dist:
Dibrugarh, Assam, PIN- 786002.
Mrs. Arun Chandra Gogoi
Wife of Late Arun Chandra
Gogoi
Sri Madhyrjya Gogoi
Son of Late Arun Chandra Gogoi
Smti Nilima Gogoi
Wife of Sri Arun Chandra Gogoi
Sri Susil Saikia
Son of Meghnath Saikia
Sri Pranab Gogoi
Son of Late Bhagyeswar Gogoi
Sri Tarun Gogoi
Son of Mukti Gogoi
Sri Arun Gogoi
Son of Late Dhajen Gogoi
Sri Barun Chandra Gogoi
Son of Mukut Chandra Gogoi
Sri Bipul Chelleng
Son of Not Known
Sri Girindra Nath Konwar
Son of Sri Pabitra Konwar
Sri Harinarayan Keot
Son of Sri Mahabir Keot
Sri Narayan Keot
Son of Sri Mahabir Keot
Sri Susil Saikia
Son of Sri Megnath Saikia
Smti Omen Menthom Deori
Wife of Late Tankeswar Deori
All are residence of Banipur, P.S
and Dist: Dibrugarh, Assam, PIN
786002.
…….Respondents
–BEFORE–
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
For the Petitioner(s)
:Mr. N. N. Upadhyaya, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:Mr. P. J. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Mr. A. K. Gupta, learned
counsel for the respondent Nos. 1, 4, 5,
6, 7 and 9.
Date of Hearing
: 24.03.2026.
Date of Judgment
: 24.03.2026.
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. N. N. Upadhyaya, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. P. J. Saikia,
learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. A. K. Gupta,
learned counsel appearing for the respondent Nos. 1, 4,
5, 6, 7 and 9.
2.
None appears for the remaining respondents on call
despite service being effected by way of paper publication
as observed by this Court earlier on 24.03.2025.
3.
By way of this Civil Revision Petition under Section
115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter
referred to as the “CPC”), the petitioners have assailed
the impugned Judgment and Order dated 06.09.2018
passed
by
the
learned
Additional
District
Judge,
Dibrugarh in Misc. Appeal No. 5/2017, whereby the order
dated 30.09.2014 passed by the learned Munsiff No. 2,
Dibrugarh in Misc. (J) Case No. 24/2013 under Order IX
Rule 13 of the CPC was set aside and quashed.
4.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioners,
as plaintiffs, instituted Title Suit No. 37/2006 before the
Court of the learned Munsiff No. 1, Dibrugarh against the
defendants/respondents seeking a decree for eviction of
the defendants/respondents from a portion of the suit
land and for perpetual injunction restraining them from
interfering with the peaceful possession of the plaintiffs
or committing any act detrimental to their rights over the
suit land.
5.
Despite service of summons, the defendants did not
appear to contest the suit. Consequently, the suit
proceeded ex-parte and was decreed by judgment and
decree dated 02.07.2009, declaring the plaintiffs as the
rightful owners having valid right, title and interest over
the suit land. The defendants were declared trespassers
and directed to vacate the encroached portion by
removing
their
structures,
and
were
permanently
restrained from interfering with the plaintiffs’ possession.
6.
Aggrieved by the ex-parte decree, respondent No. 1
filed an application under Order IX Rule 13 read with
Section 151 of the CPC, registered as Misc. (J) Case No.
24/2013, seeking setting aside of the decree. The learned
trial Court, by order dated 30.09.2014, rejected the
application holding that summons had been duly served
and refused by the defendant. Thereafter, respondent
No. 1 preferred Misc. Appeal No. 5/2017 before the Civil
Judge, Dibrugarh, and the appellate Court, by the
impugned order dated 06.09.2018, allowed the appeal
and set aside both the ex-parte decree and the order
rejecting the application under Order IX Rule 13 of the
CPC.
7.
Mr. N. N. Upadhyaya, learned counsel for the
petitioners, contends that the appellate Court erred in law
in disregarding substituted service effected through
newspaper
publication
in
Asomiya
Pratidin
dated
19.02.2008. It is submitted that the provisions of Order V
of the CPC are procedural and directory in nature, and
any
deviation
therefrom
constitutes,
at
best,
an
irregularity insufficient to warrant setting aside an ex-
parte decree. Reliance is placed on Basant Singh &
Anr. Vs. Roman Catholic Mission, reported in
2002 All SCR 547.
8.
Per contra, Mr. P. J. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel
for the respondents, submits that the appellate Court,
having recorded a categorical finding that summons was
not duly served, rightly set aside the ex-parte decree, and
such finding does not warrant interference in revisional
jurisdiction. It is further contended that compliance with
Order V Rules 17 and 20 of the CPC is mandatory.
Reliance is placed on Shri K. Raja Vs. V. Prabhakar,
reported in 2025 STPL 1616 (Karnataka).
9.
I have considered the submissions advanced by the
learned counsel for the parties and perused the materials
on record, including the authorities cited.
10. A conjoint reading of Order V Rules 17 and 20 of
the CPC makes it evident that where a defendant refuses
service or cannot be found despite due diligence, the
serving officer must affix a copy of the summons at a
conspicuous place of the defendant’s residence and
record the circumstances thereof. Substituted service,
including by newspaper publication, can be resorted to
only upon satisfaction of the Court that ordinary service is
not feasible, and such publication must be in a
newspaper having circulation in the locality of the
defendant.
11. Order IX Rule 13 of the CPC provides that an ex-
parte decree may be set aside if the defendant
establishes either that summons was not duly served or
that
he
was
prevented
by
sufficient
cause
from
appearing. However, the proviso makes it clear that mere
irregularity
in
service
is
insufficient,
provided
the
defendant had notice of the proceedings and adequate
opportunity to contest.
12. In the present case, the respondent specifically
pleaded lack of knowledge of the proceedings until
initiation of execution. The records reveal multiple
attempts at service, with inconsistent reports at times
indicating refusal and at others inability to locate the
defendant or his residence.
13. The appellate Court, upon evaluation of the service
reports, recorded a finding that the conclusion of the trial
Court regarding due service was perverse. It was further
found that even assuming refusal, the mandatory
procedure under Order V Rule 17 of the CPC, particularly
affixation, had not been followed.
14. Apt at this stage to refer to the decision of the coordinate bench of the Karnataka High court in the case of
Shri K. Raja (supra), wherein the co-ordinate bench
held that the procedure laid down under Order V Rule 17
of the CPC pertaining to affixation is not merely directory
but mandatory provisions. The relevant paragraphs of the
aforesaid judgment are reproduced hereunder for ready
reference:
“17. Having read the proviso to Order V Rule 17 as well
as Order V Rule 20, the Court has to read both the
provisions of Order V Rule 17 and Order V Rule 20
conjointly. The learned counsel also relied upon Division
Bench Judgment in Nova Granites (India) Ltd Vs. Coach
Kraft (Bangalore) Pvt. Lid, ILR 1994 KAR 52. This
judgment is relied on before the trial Court while
addressing the arguments in Miscellaneous Proceedings
and this Court in the above judgment has extracted Order
V Rule 17 of C.P.C and held that on a careful perusal of
the aforesaid provision would go to show that if the
serving officer finds that the person who is required to be
served refuses the summons and notice or not found, he
shall affix a copy of the same on the outer door or some
other conspicuous part of the house in which such
defendant ordinarily resides or carries on business or
personally works for gain and shall then return the
original to the Court from which it was issued, with a
report endorsed thereon or annexed thereto stating that
he has so affixed the copy, the circumstances under
which he did so and the name and address of the person
(if any) by whom the house was identified and in whose
presence the copy was affixed. The provisions of Order V
Rule 17 of C.P.C will have to be strictly construed. The
propositions cannot be stretched to the extent of holding
that one should be hyper technical in considering Order V
Rule 17 of C.P.C. If on a careful perusal of the return,
verified by the process server sworn to before the
authority competent to administer oath, on information
one can say that all the contentions are complied with,
but would be wrong to say that service is bad simply
returning that it is not exactly in the form prescribed
affixed in Code of Civil Procedure and same is discussed
in paragraph Nos. 15 and 19 of the judgment.
18. Having read conjointly the provisions under Order V
Rule 17 as well as Order V Rule 20 and sub-clause (1), it
is very clear that substituted service by way of affixture
as well as paper publication, in view of amendment to
sub-clause (1A) of Order V Rule 20 of C.P.C and before
proceeding to the same, Order V Rule 17 is also to be
taken note of, but in the case on hand it is not the case of
refusal, but he was not present at the time when the
postman
went
to
make
service
on
the
appellant/defendant. When he was not in station and no
such information was also given and nothing is
mentioned that an intimation was delivered and when
such being the case and when no such intimation is
given, question of it has come to the notice of
appellant/defendant does not arise. Without any notice,
he was placed ex-parte and invoked Order V Rule 20 of
C.P.C. The respondent ought to have taken once again
steps when the same was returned with an endorsement
"he was not in station' and there was no any intimation
or information with regard to the initiation of the suit and
did not comply with Order V Rule 17 of C.P.C or either
affixed the same on the conspicuous place of the
defendant where he resides or sought for any permission
of the Court to take substituted service by way of
affixture and no such affixture was also made and only
an application was filed by respondent/plaintiff before
the trial Court or notice was ordered for paper publication
and when such being the case, the trial Court fails to
take note of the very judgment which was relied upon by
the appellant before the trial Court comes to the
conclusion that postman went to the house on
24.12.2016, 26.12.2016 and 27.12.2016, he was absent
on those days and there is no endorsement that he has
intimated even any other adult member of the family, but
only endorsement was made 'party out of station' and the
same has been accepted by the trial Court while rejecting
the petition filed under Order 9 Rule 13 and hence, the
trial Court committed an error and though mentioned the
above cited judgment in paragraph No.17 which has been
relied upon by the appellant before the trial Court, comes
to the conclusion that it was only a directory procedure
and not mandatory procedure and not accepted the
contention of the appellant.
19. The proviso of Order V Rule 17 of C.P.C. is very clear
that when the serving officer cannot found the defendant
and there is no agent empowered to accept service of the
summons on his behalf, nor any other person on whom
service can be made, the serving officer shall affix a copy
of the summons on the outer door or some other
conspicuous part of the house in which the defendant
ordinarily resides or carries on business of personally
works for gain and shall then return the original to the
Court from which it was issued, with a report endorsed
thereon or annexed thereto stating that he has so affixed
the copy, the circumstances under which he did so, and
the name and address of the person (if any) by whom the
house was identified and in whose presence the copy
was affixed. But the wordings used 'shall' and when the
word used is 'shall' the very reasoning given by the trial
Court that it is directory not mandatory is a wrong notion
of the trial Court and had lost sight of the very proviso of
Order V Rule 17 and committed an error in coming to the
conclusion that it was only a directory and hence, the
very contention of the appellant that not complied with
mandatory provisions of Order V Rule 17 of C.P.C, there
is a true. The very contention of the respondent that the
proviso of Order V Rule 20 is very clear with regard to
amendment is concerned and to take the notice and
purposefully he avoided service of notice and hence,
Order V Rule 20 of C.P.C is pressed into service cannot be
accepted and hence it requires interference by this Court
and the trial Court committed an error in dismissing the
petition filed under Order 9 Rule 13 r/w Section 151 of
C.P.C and hence, I answer the above points in
affirmative.”
15. The contention regarding sufficiency of substituted
service
through
newspaper
publication
is
equally
untenable, as such publication was not preceded by due
compliance
with
the
foundational
requirements
of
affixation or proper attempts at personal service.
16. The revisional jurisdiction of this Court under
Section 115 of the CPC is confined to jurisdictional errors.
The appellate Court, having exercised its jurisdiction upon
proper appreciation of the material on record, cannot be
said to have committed any jurisdictional error warranting
interference.
17. In view of the above, I find no merit in the present
Civil Revision Petition.
18. Accordingly, the Civil Revision Petition stands
dismissed. No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review