Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010570872025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3206]
FRIDAY, THE THIRTIETH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 2919/2025
Between:
1. DHULIPUDI RAMBABU, S/O. SATYANARAYANA, AGED ABOUT 57
YEARS, OCC. CULTIVATION,R/O. D.NO.2-235, EPURU VILLAGE,
KOLLURU MANDAL, BAPATLA DISTRICT-522301.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. DHULIPUDI MOHANA RAO, (DIED) (D. 1)
2. DHULIPUDI VERRA SEKHARA RAO, S/O. LATE MOHANA RAO,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, OCC. CULTIVATION,R/O. D.NO. 1-32-2,
HAWALDHL- STREET NAZEERPET, TENALI-522201.
3. DHULIPUDI SEETHA RAMAIAH, S/O. LATE MOHANA RAO, AGED
ABOUT 57 YEARS,
OCC. CULTIVATION,R/O. D.NO. 1-32-2,
HAWALDHAR STREET NAZEERPET, TENALI-522201.
4. DHULIPUDI SATYANARAYANA, (D.2) S/O. PUMA RAO, AGED
ABOUT 42 YEARS,
OCC. CULTIVATION,R/O. CHILUMURU
VILLAGE, KOLLURU MANDAL, BAPATLA DISTRICT-522301.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,praying that in the
circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein,the High Court may be
pleased toAggrieved by the Order in I.A No.758/2024 in O.S No. 152/1983
Dt.02.04.2025 on the file of Additional Civil Judge(Sr.Division) At Tenali,
Guntur District
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to grant STAY of all further proceedings in IA No.758/2024 in O.S
No.152/1983 on the file of Court of Addl.Judge(Senior Division) at Tenali,
Guntur District pending disposal of CRP in the interest of Justice.
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. PHANI TEJA CHERUVU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. J.V.PHANIDUTH
2.
The Court made the following Order:
The petitioner herein had filed O.S.No.152 of 1983 before the
Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Tenali, for partition of the property,
claimed to be joint family property. This suit was filed against two defendants.
The 1st defendant was set ex parte, even before the preliminary decree had
been passed. Subsequently, a preliminary decree was passed on 22.06.1984.
It may also be noted that the plaintiff, at the time of filing of the suit was a
minor and was represented by his mother as next best friend.
2.
The 1st defendant had passed away and the defendants 3 & 4
came on record as the LRs of the deceased 1st defendant. The defendants 1
to 4 filed I.A.No.758 of 2024 in OS.No.152 of 1983 for appointment of an
advocate commissioner for division of the suit schedule property into three
equal shares by metes and bounds and to submit a report regarding the said
division and for passing of the final decree in pursuance of the preliminary
decree.
3.
This application was resisted, by the petitioner herein, on various
grounds. About 16 grounds were raised by the petitioner. The Trial Judge, by
an Order dated 02.04.2025, allowed the application appointing a learned
advocate commissioner to take up the task of division of the schedule property
into three equal shares etc. The Trial Judge recorded that the counter filed by
the petitioner herein did not have any tenable objections.
4.
Aggrieved by the said Order, dated 02.04.2025, the petitioner has
approached this Court by way of the present Civil Revision Petition.
5.
Sri Phani Teja Cheruvu, the learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner, would reiterate the grounds raised in the counter affidavit filed by
the petitioner before the Trial Court. Apart from this, the learned counsel for
the petitioner would contend that the Trial Court could not have passed the
impugned order inasmuch as the following grounds had not been answered by
the Trial Court:a)
The preliminary decree, dated 22.06.1984, had abated as the 1st
defendant had passed away and appropriate steps were not taken to
bring on record the LRs of the 1st defendant.
b)
Order 32 Rule 12 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 [for short
“the CPC”] requires leave to be taken for proceeding in a case against a
minor who has attained a majority.
c)
The 2nd defendant, who was the 2nd petitioner in the application,
had already filed O.S.No.273 of 2022 before the Principal Junior Civil
Judge, Tenali, against the petitioner herein for an injunction, on the
ground that the 2nd defendant is in possession of the property.
d)
That a Trial should have been conducted in the matter before an
advocate commissioner was appointed, in view of the various
contentions
raised
by
the
petitioner
regarding
the
changed
circumstances after the passing of the preliminary decree.
6.
Sri Phani Teja Cheruvu, the learned counsel for the petitioner
would contend that Section 141 of the CPC which deals with miscellaneous
proceedings provides for such a Trial and relies upon the Judgment of the
erstwhile Andhra Pradesh High Court, in the case of Mothukuri Ranga Rao &
Anr Vs. Royyala Laxminarayana & ors1.
7.
Sri J. V. Phaniduth, the learned counsel for the respondents
would contend that none of these contentions are maintainable. He would
contend that once a preliminary decree has been passed the question of the
suit abating even upon the demise of the parties would not arise. He relies
upon the Judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, in the case of Kishan
Lal & Ors Vs. Nathi Lal2 as well as the Judgment of the Privy Council, in the
case of Lachmi Narain Makwary & Ors Vs. Balmakund Marwary & Anr3.
8.
Sri J. V. Phaniduth, the learned counsel for the respondents
would contend that Order 32 of Rule 12 of the CPC requires the plaintiff minor
to either proceed with the case or abandon the case and there is no
restriction, for the other parties to the suit, to proceed with their case. He
would submit that the minor plaintiff, who had turned major, cannot hold other
parties to ransom on the ground that the minor has to take a decision. He
would also submit that the pendency of OS.No.273 of 2022 before the
Principal Junior Civil Judge, Tenali, does not in any manner affect the
proceeding and the same would not be a bar.
9.
The first contention was that the demise of the 1st defendant had
resulted in an abatement of a suit. The question of whether there would be
such abatement on the demise of a party to a suit, where a preliminary decree
had already been passed, came to be considered by the Hon’ble High Court
(2007) 12 AP CK 0051
AIR 1971 Delhi 308
AIR 1924 PC 198
of Delhi, in the case of Kishan Lal & Ors Vs. Nathi Lal. The Hon’ble High Court
of Delhi following the Judgment of the Hon’ble Privy Council, in the case of
Lachmi Narain Makwary & Ors Vs. Balmakund Marwary & Anr had held that
once a preliminary decree has been issued, the rights of the parties are
crystallized by the said preliminary decree and the question of abatement
would not arise.
10.
In the Judgment of the Hon’ble Privy Council, in the case of
Lachmi Narain Makwary & Ors Vs. Balmakund Marwary & Anr, the Hon’ble
Privy Council was considering a case where the suit was sought to be
dismissed on the ground that the plaintiff, after the passing of the preliminary
decree, had not been prosecuting the case. The Hon’ble Privy Council had
held as follows:“Their Lordships do not think it necessary to determine whether the
word "hearing" should or should not have this particular limitation;
because they think that the decision can be supported on another
ground. After a decree has once been made in a suit, the suit cannot
be dismissed unless the decree is reversed on appeal. The parties
have, on the making of the decree, acquired rights or incurred
liabilities which are fixed, unless or until the decree is varied or set
aside. After a decree any party can (as already stated) apply to have
it enforced.”
11.
This principle would be applicable even in a case where one of
the parties, to the suit, passes away.
12.
For the aforesaid reasons, it must be held that there would be no
abatement in the event of the death of a party to a suit for partition, once a
preliminary decree has been passed.
13.
Order 32 Rule 12 of the CPC clearly provides an opportunity to a
minor plaintiff, who was attained majority, to decide whether he would be
interested in pursuing the suit, filed in his name, or he would prefer to
abandon the suit. This option can be expressed by the minor plaintiff, by
making an application to the Court. Upon such an application being made, the
Court can decide the issue ex parte. However, after notice to the next best
friend who had initiated the suit on behalf of the minor. The language in this
provision does not lend itself to a situation where leave is to be obtained by
the other parties to the suit to pursue the suit against the minor plaintiff.
14.
The filing of O.S.No.273 of 2022, by the 2nd defendant, seeking
an injunction against the petitioner does not in any manner place a bar on the
final decree proceeding in the present suit.
15.
Sri Phani Teja Cheruvu, the learned counsel for the petitioner had
also contended that 40 years have elapsed since the passing of the
preliminary decree and a Trial is needed for the purposes of ascertaining the
facts and changes in the situation on the ground, after the passing of the
preliminary decree. He would contend that without such a Trial appointment of
an advocate commissioner would be redundant.
16.
The normal course adopted, in final decree proceedings, is for the
Court to appoint an advocate commissioner, who would verify the situation on
the ground, consult the parties to the suit and for partition of the properties, by
metes and bounds and for allotment of these divided properties. The advocate
commissioner would then file a report with the recommendations of the
advocate commissioner. The report, filed by the advocate commissioner,
would be placed before the Court with liberty being given, to all the parties, to
accept or to raise objections to the proposals made by the learned advocate
commissioner, in the said report. It would be open to the parties to raise all
objections, including a request to reject the entire report filed by the advocate
commissioner.
17.
In those circumstances, the appointment of an advocate
commissioner, to verify these facts and to place a report before the Trial
Court, does not require any Trial to be conducted, before the appointment of
such an advocate commissioner. This is because the report of the advocate
commissioner would not be binding on any of the parties unless they chose to
accept the said report, in the Court. The appointment of an advocate
commissioner, especially since more than 40 years have elapsed, is a more
practical method of ascertaining the facts and for the Court to get an
understanding of the situation on the ground.
18.
For all the aforesaid reasons, I do not find any reason to
intervene or interfere with the Order of the Trial Court, dated 02.04.2025, in
I.A.No.758 of 2024 in OS.No.152 of 1983 and accordingly, this Civil Revision
Petition is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand
closed.
________________________
R. RAGHUNANDAN RAO, J.
BSM
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE R.RAGHUNANDAN RAO
Civil Revision Petition No.2919 of 2025
30-01-2026
BSM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review