Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 222 of 2017
Date of Decision: 03.02.2021
Shri Dhaneswar Medhi
Vs.
The Union of India
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P.K. Borah, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Dr. N. Mozika, ASG with
Mr. J.I. Nongrum, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
ORAL
1.
The petitioner herein, has preferred this application before
this Court on the grievance that his application for appointment on
compassionate ground has not been duly considered and that he has
been deprived of the same due to the arbitrary acts of the respondents.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
3.
Mr. P.K. Borah, learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that the petitioner herein is the eldest son of the deceased employee
who expired on 29.06.2003 when the petitioner was still a minor aged
11(eleven) years old. The learned counsel submits that the petitioner
on attaining majority, had applied for appointment on compassionate
ground in the year 2009, and it was only in 2013 that the petitioner was
informed vide letter dated 21.03.2013 by the respondent No. 2 that he
was placed at Sl. No. 19 in the list for consideration for appointment
on compassionate ground. Learned counsel submits that the
respondents then by letter dated 10.11.2014 communicated that after
review by the Compassionate Appointment Committee, the petitioner
was placed at Sl. No. 37, and thereafter down the years, the Sl. No. of
the petitioner went to Sl. No. 40 in 2016, Sl. No. 41 in 2017 and Sl.
No. 49 in 2018. Learned counsel has also drawn the attention of the
Court to the fact that the appointment on compassionate ground is
based on the recommendations of the Compassionate Appointment
Committee as per the indigent index. In this context, learned counsel
submits that as per this index the petitioner is now placed at 10.1 and
it is the norm that a person whose indigent index is less than 10 (points)
is no longer considered eligible for appointment. Learned counsel
submits that on this aspect also, the respondents have acted arbitrarily
and delayed his case which has resulted in his low indigent index
ranking.
4.
Another contention, as submitted by the learned counsel
is that the respondents have not complied with the prescribed Scheme
for consideration of appointment which has resulted in the deprivation
of the petitioner of gainful employment. Learned counsel submits that
as per the Scheme which is contained in the Office Memorandum dated
09.10.1998 issued by the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances &
Pension (Department Personnel & Training),
it is incumbent as
provided in Para-12 (b) that immediately after the death of the
employee, the Welfare Officer should have met the family of the
deceased to advise and assist them in getting compassionate ground
and also that Para-12 (c) provides that application for compassionate
appointment should be considered by a Committee of Officers
consisting of 3(three) Members. Learned counsel submits that this was
not adhered to and that no Welfare Officer had come to meet the family
after the demise of the deceased employee and that also the
Committees set up were arbitrary with as many as 6(six) Members
being present. He also contended that the Committee did not sit as
prescribed, but it seems on the contrary, the report was made only on a
yearly basis. For all these lapses, it is contended by the learned counsel
that the petitioner had been illegally deprived of his legitimate claim
for compassionate appointment and that the non-adherence to the
Scheme has caused violation of the fundamental rights of the
petitioner. Learned counsel in furtherance to this contention, has
placed reliance on the judgment in the case of State Bank of India &
Anr. vs. Somvir Singh reported in (2007) 4 SCC 778 to establish the
point that compassionate appointment can only be granted by the way
of Scheme which he maintains has been violated. Reliance also has
been placed on the judgment rendered in the case of Mohan Mahto v.
M/s Central Coal Fields Ltd. & Ors. reported 2007 (9) SBR 449
wherein it has been held that the grant of appointment on
compassionate ground is an exception of Article 16 (1) of the
Constitution of India. Learned counsel lastly prays that a mandamus be
issued directing the respondents to grant appointment to the petitioner
on compassionate ground in view of the facts and circumstances as put
forth.
5.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned ASG assisted by Mr. J.I. Nongrum,
learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 & 2 has at the outset
submitted that the writ petition is hopelessly barred by delay and
laches, inasmuch as, the deceased employee had expired in 2003, the
application for compassionate appointment was only made in 2009, i.e.
6(six) years after the death of the employee, and that the petitioner has
come to Court only on July, 2017, by way of this instant writ petition,
i.e. a total of 14(fourteen) years after the demise of the employee.
Learned Senior counsel submits that this delay defeats the very purpose
of compassionate appointment which had been formulated to provide
immediate succor to the family of the bereaved to tide over the crisis
caused due to the death of an employee. In this regard, the learned
Senior counsel has placed reliance on the judgment of Government of
India & Anr. vs. P. Venkatesh reported in (2019) 15 SCC 613 and in
the case of State of J&K & Ors. vs. Sajad Ahmed Mir reported (2006)
5 SCC 766.
6.
On the other contentions raised by the petitioner such as
the delay in considering the application, the learned Senior counsel
submits that in no manner can any delay be attributed to the respondent
No. 1 & 2, inasmuch as, firstly the father of the petitioner did not
submit any nomination for retirement/death benefits but in fact had left
behind several claimants as after the death of first wife, he had also
taken a second and third wife from which he had issues, who
necessarily were eligible for consideration for grant of death benefits.
Learned Senior counsel also submits that this imbroglio was finally
settled before this Court by order dated 21.05.2008 passed in RFA No.
13 (H) 2006, whereby the family pension was disbursed amongst the
claimants who were the second wife and all the children of the
deceased employee. It is submitted that only after this was settled, was
the application for compassionate appointment taken up for active
consideration.
7.
Learned Senior counsel submits that consequently the
respondents did an appraisal and cases were reviewed and that as per a
revised priority list based on the indigent index, the petitioner was
placed at Sl. No. 19 in the list for the year 2013 and thereafter at Sl.
No. 37 in the year 2014. Learned counsel submits that the practice is
that cases which are placed at the priority list are reviewed every year
on receipt of fresh applications for compassionate appointment and
after considering the same and awarding points to various elements as
per the existing procedure i.e. number of dependent family members,
number of years of service left at time of death, amount of family
pension and terminal benefits received, the indigent index is computed.
Learned counsel further submits that fresh cases that arrive are
interpolated with the existing priority list and a fresh list is prepared
every year which accounts for the change in the priority list based on
the indigent index. The learned Senior counsel then submits that the
petitioner was intimated as to his position which was arrived at after
scrutiny by the Compassionate Appointment Committee. Moreover, he
submits appointment on compassionate is being considered every year
based on the serial numbers of the priority list of the particular year
within the prescribed 5% quota each year which amounts to only 3 to
5 vacancies, and it is impossible to provide appointment to every
applicant as at present there is a large number of applications with
higher indigent score index. The learned Senior counsel then submits
that there being no illegality in the process adopted nor any
arbitrariness on the part of the respondents, no case has been made out
to warrant any interference by this Court.
8.
Having heard learned counsels for the parties, it is to be
noted that the object of compassionate appointment which is an
exception to Article 16 (1) and as has been reiterated by a catena of
judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, is to address the immediacy
of the need and it is not meant to entertain stale claims. A scheme for
the grant of compassionate appointment does not constitute a
reservation of a post in favour of a member of the family of the
deceased employee, and there is no general right which can accrue to
the effect that a member of the family who was a minor at the time of
death would be entitled to claim compassionate appointment upon
attaining majority.
9.
In the instant case, a glaring fact that cannot be ignored is
the delay in pursuing the matter both at the level of the respondents
Department and also in approaching this Court. As held in the case of
Government of India & Anr. vs. P. Venkatesh (supra) which has also
relied on the judgment of Umesh Kumar Nagpal vs. State of Haryana
reported in (1994) 4 SCC 138, the essence of claim lies in immediacy
of need. The relevant part of the judgment is reproduced at Para- 9 &
10.
“9. In Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana, this
Court held thus: (SCC p. 140, para 2)
“2…. The whole object of granting compassionate
employment is thus to enable the family to tide over the
sudden crisis. The object is not to give a member of such
family a post much less a post for post held by the
deceased. What is further, mere death of an employee in
harness does not entitle his family to such source of
livelihood. The Government or the public authority
concerned has to examine the financial condition of the
family of the deceased, and it is only if it is satisfied, that
but for the provision of employment, the family will not
be able to meet the crisis that a job is to be offered to the
eligible member of the family. The posts in Classes III
and IV are the lowest posts in non-manual and manual
categories and hence they alone can be offered on
compassionate grounds, the object being to relieve the
family, of the financial destitution and to help it get over
the emergency”
10.Bearing in mind the above principles, this Court
held: (Umesh Kumar case, SCC pp. 141-42, para 6)
“6.For these very reasons, the compassionate
employment cannot be granted after a lapse of a
reasonable period which must be specified in the rules.
The consideration for such employment is not a vested
right which can be exercised at any time in future. The
object being to enable the family to get over the financial
crisis which it faces at the time of the death of the sole
breadwinner, the compassionate employment cannot be
claimed and offered whatever the lapse of time and after
the crisis is over.”
In the case of State of J&K & Ors. vs. Sajad Ahmed Mir (supra) the
Hon’ble Supreme Court while discussing delay and laches and that
such appointments are an exception to the general rule in Para 11 & 12
held as follows:“11. We may also observe that when the Division Bench
of the High Court was considering the case of the
applicant holding that he had sought “compassion”, the
Bench ought to have considered the larger issue as well
and it is that such an appointment is an exception to the
general rule. Normally, an employment in the
Government or other public sectors should be open to all
eligible candidates who can come forward to apply and
compete with each other. It is in consonance with Article
14 to the Constitution. On the basis of competitive
merits, an appointment should be made to public office.
This general rule should not be departed from except
where compelling circumstances demand, such as,
death of the sole breadwinner and likelihood of the
family suffering because of the setback. Once it is
proved that in spite of the death of the breadwinner, the
family survived and substantial period is over, there is
no necessity to say “goodbye” to the normal rule of
appointment and to show favour to one at the cost of the
interests of several others ignoring the mandate of
Article 14 of the Constitution.
12. In the State of Haryana v. Rani Devi, it was held that
the claim of the applicant for appointment on
compassionate ground is based on the premise that he
was dependent on the deceased employee. Strictly this
claim cannot be upheld on the touchstone of Article 14
or 16 of the Constitution. However, such claim is
considered reasonable as also allowable on the basis of
sudden crisis occurring in the family of the employee
who had served the State and died while in service. That
is why it is necessary for the authorities to frame rules,
regulations or to issue such administrative instructions
which can stand the test of Articles 14 and 16.
Appointment on compassionate ground cannot be
claimed as a matter of right.”
10.
By application of settled law therefore, no case has been
made out by the petitioner for issuance of any direction or for any
interference by this Court. Further, no discernable grounds have been
made out to show that there was any failure on the part of the respondent
No. 1 & 2 in complying with the Scheme for compassionate
appointment, nor any materials placed on record to substantiate the
allegations that there was any illegality or arbitrariness on the part of
the respondents.
11.
For the reasons and circumstances stated above, there is no
merit in the instant writ petition and the same is accordingly dismissed.
12.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
03.02.2021
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review