The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. In the instant case as well, the dead body was already exhumed and recovered vide Ex. P/8 on 11/12/2017 and thereafter, on 12/12/2017, memorandum statement (Ex. P/5) was recorded, as such, the dead body cannot be said to have been recovered at the instance of the appellant. Therefore, in light of the decisions rendered by the Supreme Court in the matters of Boby (supra) and Suresh Chandra Tiwari (supra), it can safely be held that the trial Court has erred in convicting the appellant for the offence punishable under Sections 302 and 201 of IPC holding that the dead body of the deceased was recovered pursuant to the memorandum statement of the appellant. Thus, we are of the considered opinion that the prosecution has miserably failed to bring home the offence in question against the appellant and as such, we hereby set aside the impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence recorded by the trial Court convicting the appellant for offence punishable under Section 302 and 201 of IPC. Since the appellant is already on bail, he need not surrender, however, his bail bonds shall remain in operation for a period of six months in view of the provisions contained under Section 437A of CrPC.
17. Accordingly, this criminal appeal stands allowed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:3237-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Criminal Appeal No. 1708 of 2019
Dhaneshwar Sahu S/o Shiv Ram Sahu Aged About 25
Years
R/o
Village
Khajhri,
P.S.
Sarangarh,
District
Raigarh Chhattisgarh.
----Appellant (in Jail)
Versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through S.H.O. Police Station
Sarangarh, District Raigarh Chhattisgarh.
---- Respondent
For Appellant
:-
Mr. B.P. Singh, Advocate
For Respondent/State :-
Mr. Sharad Mishra, P.L.
[
Hon'ble Shri Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal
Hon'ble Shri Justice Sachin Singh Rajput
Judgment on Board
20/01/2026
Sanjay K. Agrawal, J.
1. This criminal appeal under Section 374(2) of CrPC has
been preferred by the appellant against impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated
31/08/2019 passed by learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Sarangarh, District Raigarh in Sessions Trial No.
04/2018 whereby the appellant has convicted for offence
punishable under Sections 302 and 201 of IPC and
sentenced to undergo life imprisonment with fine of Rs.
2,000/- and in default of payment of fine, additional R.I.
for six months and to undergo R.I. for 2 years with fine
of Rs. 1,000/- and in default of payment of fine,
additional R.I. for 3 months, respectively.
2. Case of the prosecution, in brief, is that in the
intervening night of 9-10/12/2017 in between 12-1 AM
at village Khajri within the ambit of Police Station
Sarangarh, the appellant herein along with co-accused
Shivram
Sahu,
in
furtherance
of
their
common
intention, strangulated Ku. Chanda Yadav, with whom
the appellant was having an affair, and caused her death
and in order to screen themselves from the offence,
buried her dead body inside a pit in the canal and
thereby, committed the aforesaid offence.
3. Further case of the prosecution is that on account of the
information given by Deepak Sahu (P.W.-16), after
taking
permission
from
the
SDM,
Sarangarh
on
11/12/2017, the dead body was exhumed from the spot
and dead body exhumation panchnama was prepared
vide Ex. P/8 and it was identified by father of the
deceased namely Kedar Yadav (P.W.-17) vide Ex. P/9.
Dehati merg intimation was registered vide Ex. P/13,
inquest was conducted vide Ex. P/4 and pursuant to
recording memorandum statement of the appellant vide
Ex. P/5, seizure of spade and shovel was made vide Ex.
P/6 and P/7. Statements of the witnesses were recorded
and the dead body was subjected to postmortem which
was conducted by Dr. Ritesh Sen (P.W.-9) and as per the
postmortem report (Ex. P/11), the cause of death is said
to be asphyxia due to throttling and nature of death is
said to be homicidal. After due investigation, the
appellant
herein
was
charge-sheeted
for
offence
punishable under Sections 302, 201/34 of IPC and coaccused Shivram Sahu was charge-sheeted for offence
punishable under Section 201/34 of IPC, which were
committed
to
the
Court
of
Sessions
for
trial
in
accordance with law. The appellant as well as the coaccused abjured their guilt and entered into defence.
4. In
order
to
bring
home
the
offence,
prosecution
examined as many as 24 witnesses and brought on
record 30 documents. Statements of the appellant and
the co-accused were recorded under Section 313 of CrPC
wherein they denied guilt and they neither examined any
witness nor brought any document on record.
5. Learned trial Court, after appreciation of oral and
documentary evidence on record, though acquitted coaccused Shivram Sahu for offence punishable under
Section 201/34 of IPC but proceeded to convict the
appellant for offence punishable under Section 302,
201/34 of IPC.
6. Mr. B.P. Singh, learned counsel for the appellant, would
submit that the three incriminating circumstances
cataloged by the trial Court in paragraphs 23-28 are not
at all established and therefore, appellant is entitled for
acquittal from the offence in question.
7. Per contra, Mr. Sharad Mishra, learned State counsel,
would support the impugned judgment and would
submit that prosecution has been able to bring home the
offence beyond reasonable doubt and there is sufficient
oral as well as documentary evidence available on record
to convict the appellant, as such, the conviction of the
appellant for the aforesaid offence is well-merited and
the instant appeal is liable to be dismissed.
8. We
have
heard
learned
counsel
for
the
parties,
considered their rival submissions made herein-above
and
went
through
the
records
with
utmost
circumspection.
9. The case of the prosecution is not based on direct
evidence and is rather based on circumstantial evidence,
which has been cataloged by the trial Court in
paragraph 22 of the impugned judgment as under :“(22) अब इस तथ्य पर विचार किया जाना है की क्या आरोपी
धनेश्वर साहू, मृतका चंदा यादव की मृत्यु उसके गला को घोंटकर
कारित किया है ? इस संबंध में प्रकरण में प्रत्यक्षदर्शी साक्ष्य का
अभाव है। अब यह देखना है की अभियोजन द्वारा अभिकथित
निम्नलिखित परिस्थिति को अभियोजन प्रमाणित करने में सफल
रहा है या नहीं ?
1 - क्या आरोपी धनेश्वर साहू को मृतका चंदा यादव के साथ
अंतिम बार देखा गया है ?
2 - क्या आरोपी धनेश्वर साहू ने न्यायिके त्तर संस्वीकृ ति कर
मृतका चंदा यादव की हत्या करने की बात कबूला है ?
3 - क्या प्रार्थी दीपक साहू को आरोपी धनेश्वर साहू के द्वारा दिये
गये घटना की जानकारी के आधार पर पुलिस को दिये गये सूचना
एवं आरोपी धनेश्वर साहू के द्वारा किये गये निशानदेही पर मृतका
चंदा यादव की शव बरामद की गई थी ?”
10. Now
we
will
consider
each
of
the
aforesaid
circumstances one-by-one in order to find out whether
they have been established to convict the appellant for
offence punishable under Section 302 and 201 of IPC.
I. Theory of last seen together :11. The trial Court, after going through the statements of
Kishan Jaiswal (P.W.-13), Kismat Prajapati (P.W.-13)
and Deepak Singh (P.W.-15), has clearly held in
paragraph 27 of the impugned judgment that the fact of
the appellant and the deceased, having been seen
together before the death of the deceased, has not been
found established, which is a correct finding of fact
based on evidence available on record. Therefore, we do
not find any perversity or illegality in this finding and
hereby affirm the said finding that theory of last seen
together has not been established.
II. Extra-judicial confession :12. It is the case of the prosecution that appellant has given
extra-judicial confession to Deepak Sahu (P.W.-16) but
since he has turned hostile, the trial Court has relied
upon the statement of Maharati Bakawle (P.W.-6), who
is the witness to dead body exhumation panchnama (Ex.
P/8) and a careful perusal of his statement would show
that it cannot be concluded that appellant, at any point
of time, has made extra-judicial confession before him
that he has caused the death of deceased Chanda
Yadav. As such, the incriminating circumstance of extrajudicial confession has also not been found established
by the prosecution.
III. Exhumation of the dead body pursuant to
memorandum statement of the appellant :13. It is the case of the prosecution that the dead body of
Chanda Yadav was exhumed and recovered from the
spot pursuant to the memorandum statement of the
appellant. In this regard, it would be appropriate to
notice that as per dead body exhumation panchnama
(Ex. P/8), the dead body of deceased Chanda Yadav was
exhumed on 11/12/2017 at 11 PM in the presence of
two witnesses namely Manharan Yadav (P.W.-8) and
Maharati Bakawle (P.W.-6) whereas the memorandum
statement of the appellant (Ex. P/15) has been recorded
on 12/12/2017 i.e. after the exhumation of the dead
body. As such, the finding recorded by the trial Court
holding that dead body of deceased Chanda Yadav was
recovered at the instance of the appellant is not a correct
finding of fact based on evidence available on record.
The dead body was already exhumed and recovered on
11/12/2017 whereas the memorandum statement of the
appellant was recorded on 12/12/2017. As such, the
whereabouts of the dead body, though may be within the
knowledge of the appellant, but it cannot be held that it
was recovered at the instance of the memorandum
statement given by the appellant.
14. The Supreme Court in the matter of Boby v. State of
Kerala1 has held in paragraphs 33, 40 and 41 as
under :“33. In the present case, leave aside the recovery
panchnama being in accordance with the
aforesaid requirement, there is no statement of
Boby (Accused 3-appellant herein) recorded under
Section 27 of the Evidence Act. We are, therefore,
of the considered view that the prosecution has
failed to prove the circumstances that the dead
body of the deceased was recovered at the
instance of Boby (Accused 3-appellant herein).
40. A perusal of para 71 of Suresh Chandra Bahri
case2 would reveal that the Court has reiterated
that the two essential requirements for the
application of Section 27 of the Evidence Act are
that (1) the person giving information must be an
accused of any offence and (2) he must also be in
police custody. The Court held that the provisions
of Section 27 of the Evidence Act are based on the
view that if a fact is actually discovered in
consequence
of
information
given,
some
guarantee is afforded thereby that the information
was true and consequently the said information
can safely be allowed to be given in evidence.
41. In the facts of Suresh Chandra Bahri case
(supra), the Court found that there was, in fact, a
confessional statement of the disclosure made by
the appellant Gurbachan Singh which was
confirmed by the recovery of the incriminating
articles. As such, the Court believed the
disclosure statement and the evidence led in that
behalf. As already stated hereinabove, in the
present case, there is no confessional statement
of Boby (Accused 3 – appellant herein) recorded
with regard to recovery of the dead body of the
deceased.”
15. Similarly, in the matter of Suresh Chandra Tiwari v.
State of Uttarakhand3, it has been held by the Supreme
1 2023 LiveLaw (SC) 50
2 Suresh Chandra Bahri v. State of Bihar, 1995 Supp (1) SCC 80
3 2024 SCC Online SC 3531
Court that disclosure statement is not admissible in
evidence because alleged discovery was not made
pursuant to that statement.
16. In the instant case as well, the dead body was already
exhumed and recovered vide Ex. P/8 on 11/12/2017
and
thereafter,
on
12/12/2017,
memorandum
statement (Ex. P/5) was recorded, as such, the dead
body cannot be said to have been recovered at the
instance of the appellant. Therefore, in light of the
decisions rendered by the Supreme Court in the matters
of Boby (supra) and Suresh Chandra Tiwari (supra), it
can safely be held that the trial Court has erred in
convicting the appellant for the offence punishable
under Sections 302 and 201 of IPC holding that the
dead body of the deceased was recovered pursuant to
the memorandum statement of the appellant. Thus, we
are of the considered opinion that the prosecution has
miserably failed to bring home the offence in question
against the appellant and as such, we hereby set aside
the impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence recorded by the trial Court convicting the
appellant for offence punishable under Section 302 and
201 of IPC. Since the appellant is already on bail, he
need not surrender, however, his bail bonds shall
remain in operation for a period of six months in view of
the provisions contained under Section 437A of CrPC.
17. Accordingly, this criminal appeal stands allowed.
18. Office is directed to transmit the lower court record
along with the certified copy of this judgment to the
court concerned forthwith for necessary information and
compliance.
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Sanjay K. Agrawal)
(Sachin Singh Rajput)
Judge
Judge
Harneet
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review