Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:4926
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 14142 of 2025
1 - Dhanendra S/o Takeshwar Aged About 26 Years R/o 265, Ward No.07,
Bajrang Chowk, Village- Kareli Badi District- Dhamtari (C.G.)
--- Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - Union Of India Through Ministry Of Personnel Public Grievances And
Pensions Department Of Personnel And Training Staff Selection Commission
Block No. 12, CGO Complex Lodhi Road New Delhi 110003,
2 - Directorate General CRPF (Recruitment Branch) East Block- 07, Level04, R.K. Puram New Delhi- 110066.
3 - Senior Commandant Group Centre CRPF Bilaspur Camp Bharmi DistrictBilaspur (C.G.)
--- Respondent(s)
(Cause title is taken from CIS system)
For Petitioner
: Mr. Nikhil Parakh, Advocate with
Ms. Mitisha Kotecha, Advocate
For Respondents No.1 to 3
: Mr. Ramakant Mishra, DSGI with
Ms. Shweta Rai, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Justice Parth Prateem Sahu
Order On Board
29/01/2026
1.
Petitioners have filled this petition seeking the following reliefs:“10.1 0.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to call for the entire records pertaining to the
case of the petitioner from the respondents in the
interest of justice.
10.2 Issue an appropriate writ, order, or direction
quashing the medical unfitness declared by the
respondents in the Review Medical Examination
conducted on 18/11/2025.
10.3 Direct the respondents to conduct a fresh, fair,
transparent, and properly supervised Review Medical
Examination of the petitioner at a Government Medical
College/Hospital, Composite CAPF Hospital, or any
other Government-approved medical institution, strictly
in accordance with the Ministry of Home Affairs O.M.
dated 04.05.2021.
10.4 Direct the respondents to consider the AIIMS
Raipur medical report dated 24-25/11/2025 while
assessing the petitioner's medical fitness.
10.5 Direct to the respondents decide the petitioner's
representation dated 27/11/2025 within a time-bound
manner.
10.6 Pass any other relief(s) or direction(s) that this
Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the interest
of justice, equity, and fair play, particularly keeping in
view that this is the petitioner's last opportunity to fulfill
his dream of becoming a member of the Defence
Forces.,”
2.
Learned counsel for petitioner submits that respondents have issued
an advertisement for appointment on the post of Constable (GD) to be
deputed in BSF, CISF, CRPF, ITBP, SSB, SSF and Rifleman (General
Duty in Assam Rifles. Petitioner submitted an application for
appointment on the post of Constable. During process of recruitment,
petitioner has to undergo his medical examination. Upon detailed
medical examination, petitioner was held to be unfit on the ground of
Hypertension vide Annexure P-3. Petitioner thereafter has submitted
an application for review medical examination on 18.11.2025, before
the authorities and accordingly petitioner was sent for review medical
examination by the board constituted by the respondents-authorities.
He contended that upon his examination by the Medical Board,
hypertension and blood pressure was found in normal level, but he
has been declared unfit due to deranged LFT levels mentioning as
Bilirubin to be 3.26 Mg/d. It is contention of learned counsel for
petitioner that medical examination by the Medical Board was on
21.11.2025. The blood test was conducted by the private pathology lab
having tie-up with the Arpa Medcity Hospital & Research Institute,
Bilaspur, and therefore, considering that report of the said hospital
may not be correct, petitioner got himself examined by the All India
Institute of Medical Science Raipur (AIIMS) on 24.11.2025 within few
days and in the report of investigation liver function test is reported to
be within normal range, therefore, the respondents authorities be
directed to keep the candidature of petitioner for further consideration
in the recruitment proceedings along with other candidates treating
him to be fit for employment on the post of Constable. He also made
submission that according to the Rules, which is enclosed by the
respondents along with reply, guidelines for review of the Medical
Board, there is specific clause that wherever the candidates, who have
been found to be unfit due to hypertension/tachycardia should be
admitted/hospitalized by the Board before giving their final opinion
regarding the candidate’s fitness or otherwise. The petitioner was not
hospitalized at any point of time, therefore, the respondents have not
followed the procedure as provided under the guidelines for Review
Medical Board. He lastly contended that during medical examination,
petitioner was declared unfit due to hypertension and therefore, the
Review Medical Board could have examined for that unfitness only.
Review Medical Board could not have examined petitioner for any
other purpose and test. The Review Medical Board has declared the
petitioner unfit for other new reason, which is not permissible. Learned
counsel for petitioner placed reliance upon the decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in case of Dharmvir Singh Vs. The State of Uttar
Pradesh & Anr., in Writ Petition (S) (Civil) No. 444 of 2019 decided
on 19.07.2019.
3.
Learned counsel for respondents would vehemently oppose the
submission of learned counsel for petitioner and would submit that
petitioner participated in the recruitment proceedings along with all
eligible candidates at that relevant point of time for appointment on the
post of Constable (GD), all the candidates have to undergo medical
test to assess their fitness to be appointed on the said post
accordingly petitioner was initially examined in detail by the doctor in
due course according to conditions as provided in the service
rules/advertisement and doctor, who examined petitioner declared
petitioner to be unfit due to hypertension. According to application
submitted by petitioner for his review medical examination, petitioner
was sent for review medical examination before the Review Medical
Board. Petitioner was thereafter admitted according to the guidelines
and again tests have been conducted. He also contended that as
petitioner was being examined by the Review Medical Board, other
test have also been conducted
including blood test in which liver
function test of petitioner has been found to be deranged, therefore,
petitioner was found unfit. It is further submitted that at Bilaspur,
respondents authorities are having the group Center Hospital and not
big a hospital, therefore, respondents have tie-up with the Arpa
Medcity Hospital and Research Institute, Bilaspur where all the
facilities for test etc. are available. Accordingly petitioner’s test was
conducted at Arpa Medcity Hospital & Research Institute i.e. blood test
and other test as mentioned in Annexure P-4 and in the report of liver
function test, total Bilirubin was found 3.26 mg/d, whereas biological
reference range is mentioned in the same document as 0.1 – 1.2. He
contended that according to the norms of respondents, the candidates
used to be posted and treated to be fit under the liver function test,
report should be within the range as per the norms under the biological
reference range as mentioned therein. He also submits that in the
documents, which is relied upon by counsel for petitioner I,e, report of
AIIMS, Raipur also total Bilirubin is found as 1.26, which is above
biological reference range. In the aforementioned facts of the case,
even otherwise petitioner liver function test is not within the biological
reference range, therefore, also no relief as prayed for can be granted.
He next contended that submission of learned counsel for petitioner
that petitioner was not admitted in the hospital at the time of his
examination by Review Medical Board is not correct. Respondents in
the Group Center for Hospital used to maintained two registers i.e.
OPD register and Detention Register. Detention Register means the
person who has been detained in the hospital or admitted in the
hospital for the investigation or any treatment. In the detention register
maintained by respondent authorities, petitioner has been shown to be
detained on 19.11.2025, his name is also mentioned along with other
persons who has been detained on 19.11.2025 or prior or further
dates. Original Detention register as also the OPD register is placed
before this Court for perusal.
4.
I have heard learned counsel for parties and also perused the
documents placed on record.
5.
It is the case of the petitioner that he submitted an application for
appointment on the post of Constable (GD) pursuant to the
advertisement
published
on
the
website
of
the
Commission/respondents on 24.11.2023. Procedure and conditions of
recruitment is also forming part of the notice/advertisement Online.
Clause 12 provides for scheme of examination i.e. computer based
examination
of
General
Intelligence
and
Reasoning,
General
Knowledge and General Awareness, Elementary Mathematics and
English and Hindi. Candidates thereafter has to undergo Physical
Standard Test (PST) and Physical Efficiency Test (PET) and minimum
requirements for becoming successful is also prescribed therein.
Clause 12.6 provides for medical examination, which mentions that
candidates will be shortlisted for Detailed Medical Examination (DME)
from the pool of candidates who qualify Physical Standard Test
/Physical Efficiency Test. Accordingly, petitioner was medically
examined on 18.11.2025 (Annexure P-3) by the doctor. Upon
examination, doctor has issued certificate in Form-01 holding
petitioner to be unfit due to hypertension. Perusal of Annexure P-3
would further show that petitioner in the prescribed formate has
submitted an application for his review medical examination, which
was accepted and petitioner was sent for review medical examination
before the Review Medical Board.
6.
The Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs (Police Division-II)
had issued guidelines for Recruitment Medical Examination in Central
Armed Police Forces and Assam Rifles i.e. revised guideline as on
May, 2015. By office memorandum Government of India/Bharat Sarkar
has issued an office memorandum under the head of “Revised
Uniform Guidelines for Review Medical Examination in Central Armed
Police Forces and Assam Rifles For Gos, & NGOs : Amendment
thereof.
7.
Relevant portion of Clause 3 of the Guidelines for Review Medical
Board under the Guidelines for Recruitment Medical Examination in
Central Armed Police Forces and Assam Rifles revised as on May
2015 is extracted below for ready reference :3. Few examples are being cited for the guidance of
Review Medical Board
a)
In
any
cardiac
case
like
valvular
defects
ECG/Echocardiogram must be carried out.
b) In cases of suspected lesions of chest like Hilar
lymphadenitis, calcified spots, Koch's infiltrations, any
mass detected in X-Ray chest etc CT Chest should be
carried out.
c) For vascular defects like Varicose vein, vascular
malformations etc Colour Doppler should be carried out
d)
To
rule
out
any
eye
surgery
like
Lasik/LASEK/PRK/PK/Glaucoma/Squint/Pterygium
Surgery
etc.
investigations
accordingly,
viz.
may
be
slit
examination/ophthalmoscopy/Corneal
carried
out
lamp
Topography/
OCT/ HVF / Tonometry/VEP/ERG /Synoptophore etc.
should be carried out.
e) For candidates who have been rejected on the
ground
of
hypertension/tachycardia
should
be
admitted/hospitalized by the Board before giving their
final opinion regarding the candidate's fitness or
otherwise. The hospitalization report should indicate
whether the rise in blood pressure is of transient nature
due to excitement etc. or whether it is due to any
organic disease. In all such cases X-Ray and electrocardiographic
examinations
examinations
like
of
heart
and
cholesterol/lipid
blood
profile,
S.creatinineetc, tests should also be carried out.
f) For any suspected case of CAD, TMT test should be
conducted
g) Any tremor in hands or other parts of body
thyrotoxicosis should be ruled out and neurologist's
opinion should be taken.
h) For suspected Diabetes Mellitus cases GGT and
Glycosylated Hb. test should be carried out.
i) For Knock knee, bow leg, cubitus valgus and varus
deformities, X-Ray plate with findings should be
attached.
j) For any type of deafness, audiometry should be
carried out.
k) For a case of dental points less than 14, OPG should
be carried out.”
8.
Revised Guidelines of 2021 provides guidelines for Review of Medical
Examination (RME) under Clause-6, which is extracted below for
ready reference :“6. Guidelines for Review Medical Boards:(a) Review Medical Board shall examine the candidate
specifically for the deficiency for which the candidate
has been declared unfit. [Also, the medical term used
as cause of unfitness during the Initial Medical
Examination may differ from that arrived at by the
Review Medical Board].
(b) It will be ensured that the Medical Officer who has
conducted DME of a candidate is not part of the RME
Board for the same candidate.
(c) The defect for which candidate has been declared
unfit should be examined thoroughly and the findings
must be supported by proper investigation reports, if
applicable.
(d) Review Medical Board may obtain opinion of
concerned specialists or super specialists of Govt.
Medical College and Hospital in case of any doubt.
Therefore, in cases of rejection In review medical
examination, clinical findings should be corroborated
with
confirmatory
tests/investigations/opinion
of
speciallsts/ super specialists of Govt. Hospitals/Medical
Colleges/Govt. approved private medical centers,
whichever and wherever applicable.
9.
In revised guidelines, which is relied upon by learned counsel for
petitioner and filed along with writ petition shows that earlier guidelines
for Review Medical Board has been replaced by Guidelines for Review
Medical Examination (RME) in Central Armed Police Forces and
Assam Rifles forming part of the guidelines as Annexure A.
10.
In this guidelines also, Clause-6 talks of Guidelines for Review Medical
Board and Clause 7-E provides for candidates who have been
rejected on the ground of hypertension/tachycardia should be
admitted/hospitalized by the Board before giving their final pinion
regarding the candidate’s fitness or otherwise. Further it provides that
in all such cases X-ray and electrocardiographic examinations of heart
and blood examinations like cholesterol/lipid profile, S. Creatinine etc.
tests should also be carried out.
11.
From the aforementioned guidelines relied upon by the learned
counsel for petitioner as also by respondent one thing is common that
if the doctor, who has conducted examination of candidate
participating in the recruitment proceedings declared a candidate to be
unfit on the ground of hypertension then in review medical
examination, he has to undergo many other test which is
consequential in nature and in the case at hand also the Review
Medical Board has conducted the the tests as as has been provided
under the guideline, therefore, submission of learned counsel for
petitioner that respondents could have assessed the suitability/fitness
of petitioner only with reference to hypertension, in the opinion of this
Court, is not correct.
12.
Guidelines itself in very clear and specific terms provides for several
other test including the blood test and creatinine. As submitted by
learned counsel for respondents that Bilirubin test as provided under
the guidelines, one test got conducted by Review Medical Board and
the other petitioner got himself examined before the AIIMS, Raipur
would show that total Bilirubin range which is mentioned in both the
tests is above than the biological reference range.
13.
In the aforementioned facts of the case, the submission of learned
counsel for petitioner that the test conducted by respondents through
Review Medical Board to be incorrect in view of the test conducted by
him in the AIIMS, Raipur and as per report of AIIMS, Raipur petitioner
is fit, is not sustainable as in both the report the total Bilirubin is
exceeding the biological reference range.
14.
In the aforementioned facts of the case I do not find present to be a fit
case to grant a relief as prayed for in the writ petition. Accordingly, this
writ petition is dismissed.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
Balram
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review