Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 10th September, 2025
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.51 of 2025
:
Petitioner
Dhan Bahadur Thapa and Others
versus
:
Respondents
State of Sikkim and Others
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tara Devi Chettri, Advocate for
the Petitioners.
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate with Mr. Sujan
Sunwar, Assistant Government Advocate for the Respondents.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioners No.1 to 5 claim to be owners of landed
property contiguous to one another, portions of which the
Government required from all of them, for the purposes of
construction of the Adampool Highway. Subsequently, the route of
the highway was realigned, as a consequence of the realignment,
some portions of the aforementioned lands lay unused.
It is the
claim of the Petitioner No.1 that, suddenly from 29-08-2025,
construction of walls on a war footing has commenced on a portion
of unused land, which belongs to him, hence the prayers in the
Writ Petition seeking inter alia a direction to the Respondents to
stay away from the unutilized portions of the properties of the
Petitioners. A writ or direction to the Respondents for payment of
compensation
as
per
the
Right
to
Fair
Compensation
and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Act, 2013 (hereinafter, the “Land Acquisition Act, 2013).
To
WP(C) No.51 of 2025
Dhan Bahadur Thapa and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
disburse the compensation with 100% solatium as per the said Act
and to restrain the Respondents from trespassing or taking forceful
possession of the Petitioners land, issue an ad interim or
permanent injunction restraining the Respondents or their men,
agent and any other person(s) from continuing any construction on
the land of the Petitioners.
2.
Having
heard
Learned
Senior
Counsel
for
the
Petitioners, and perused the averments in the Petition and the
documents annexed thereto, Notice dated 03-08-2021, indicates
that the Petitioner No.1 had sold an area of 0.3700 hectares to the
Government at a consideration value of ₹ 75,67,092/-.
As per
letter dated 29-11-2021, the Petitioner No.1 had requested for
return of the unused land (measuring 0.1280 hectares) to him
from the area of 0.3700 hectares, acquired for construction of the
alternative highway. The document also reveals that 80% of the
compensation amount against the acquisition of the land was
received by the Petitioner No.1 (Annexure-P3).
(i)
Correspondence dated 02-12-2021, addressed to the
Respondent No.5 (The District Collector, Gangtok District) by
Petitioner No.2 herein, reflects inter alia as follows;
“………………………………………………………………………………………………
With due respect, in reference to your Notice
No:East/Gangtok/11100771 dated 03/08/2021, I Dr.
Mohan Thapa, S/O Dhan Bahadur Chettri, also legal
heir of the land having Khatian No:304 and Plot
No:45, with area of 2.5297 Hectares, situated at
Ranka Revenue Circle, Salangthang would like to
state the following:
1.
That the said land is in the name of my father
Shri Dhan Bahadur Chettri and is our ancestral
property.
2.
That 0.3700 Hectares of the total land was
acquired by Roads and Bridges Dept. for the
construction of Road at a consideration value of
Rs.75,67,092/- of which we received about Rs.
32,19,293/- only.
3.
That due to realignment of the Road some
portion of the land acquired from us was left out.
WP(C) No.51 of 2025
Dhan Bahadur Thapa and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
4.
Thus I request you to hand back the land left
out by the road to us for which I am ready to return
back the compensation that is owed.
5.
Hence due to the above stated facts, I object to
the registration of the above mentioned land to
Secretary Roads and Bridges Department, till the
matters are resolved.
………………………………………………………………”
(Annexure P4)
The intent and purport of the correspondence of the Petitioner No.2
is clear and requires no further elucidation.
3.
On 19-12-2024, the Respondent No.3 (The Additional
Chief Engineer, Roads and Bridges Department) addressed a letter
to the Respondent No.5 (The District Collector, Gangtok District),
concerning the landed property owned by Petitioner No.3, identified
as Plot No.71/P under Ranka Block, which was “initially utilized”
during the planning of the double lane road, at Adampool Ranka
Sichey. It was explained therein that, due to a subsequent change
in the road alignment, the portion of land falling under the said plot
remained unutilized and was not incorporated into the final
construction plan.
That, Petitioner No.3 has expressed his
willingness to refund the compensation amount to the department
and have the unused land returned to him. That, this transaction
as per Respondent No.3 (The Additional Chief Engineer, Roads and
Bridges Department) would be subject to the following caveats; (a)
refund of the said compensation by the Petitioner No.3 to the
department; and (b) thereafter reversion of the land under Plot
No.71/P to the said Petitioner No.3 (Annexure P8).
(i)
In response thereof, vide letter dated 01-04-2025
(Annexure P9), the Deputy Director of the office of Respondent
No.5
(The
District
Collector,
Gangtok
District)
department
addressed to the Respondent No.3 (The Additional Chief Engineer,
Roads and Bridges Department), submitted therein that, 80%
compensation for an area of 0.0080 hectares was already received
WP(C) No.51 of 2025
Dhan Bahadur Thapa and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
by the Petitioner No.3 and 20% payment was pending. That, the
office of the Respondent No.4 required the copy of the approval of
the competent authority from the department of Respondent No.2
stating the reasons for cancellation of the acquired land and a
direction to be given to the land owner as to whether the
compensation
received
by
him
is
to
be
deposited
in
the
Government exchequer with or without interest.
4.
Vide File notings of the Respondent No.2 (Roads and
Bridges Department), the facts pertaining to the land of Petitioners
No.1 and 2 is clarified as follows;
“…………………………………………………………………………………
It is to mention that 0.3700 hectare of land
from plot no.45/P at Ranka Block recorded in the
name of Shri Dhan Bdr Thapa was involved in the
alignment of road for which the total compensation
including land & standing properties was assessed as
Rs.40,24,117/-. Further, it is to state that the land is
being purchased at the rate of Rs.100 per sq.ft by
Road & Bridges Department.
The registration process was initiated and
notice was issued on 03/08/21 but the registration is
pending till date. However, after issuance of notice
80% payment of Rs.32,19,293/- has been received by
the land owner.
Now, the land owner has objected for
registration of land and is requesting to revert back
the unused portion of land for which he is willing to
return the compensation back to the Road & Bridges
Department.
In order to ascertain the actual status of his
claim of unused portion of land a joint inspection may
be carried out along with Road & Bridges Department.
Further, the land owners may be informed to
approach Road & Bridges Department for reversion of
his land.
……………………………………………………………”
(Annexure P10)
5.
The Petitioner No.2, vide another letter which is dated
28-03-2025 (Annexure P11), addressed to the Respondent No.5
(The District Collector, Gangtok District), requested for return of
the portion of unused land and his willingness to handover the
compensation received in lieu of the said land. Pursuant thereto, a
WP(C) No.51 of 2025
Dhan Bahadur Thapa and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
joint inspection of the land appears to have been planned on 1904-2025 as apparent from Annexure P12.
(i)
Letter dated 08-05-2025, indicates that the joint
inspection was conducted and report thereof was forwarded to the
Superintending Engineer of the Respondent No.2 (Roads and
Bridges Department) by the Deputy Director of the Respondent
No.5
(The
District
Collector,
Gangtok
District)
department,
reiterating the request of the Petitioner No.2 for return of the
unused portion of the land.
(ii)
This correspondence for the first time clarifies that the
joint inspection revealed that an area of 0.1280 hectares out of the
total of 0.3700 hectares acquired from Petitioner No.1 was
unutilized for the construction of the road.
6.
Following this development correspondence dated 27-
08-2025 reveals that, the Revenue Officer cum Assistant Director
of the Respondent No.8 (Land Revenue and Disaster Management
Department) was informed by the Respondent No.4 (Assistant
Engineer, Roads and Bridges Department), that the department
was in receipt of a letter from the Member of the Legislative
Assembly, 28-Upper Burtuk Constituency, regarding a joint survey
and proper demarcation of private and Government land along
Adampool Highway, below Khelgaon, Gangtok.
It was further
informed that, the letter states that a local organic market was
being established in the said area where local produce was being
sold by the local entrepreneurs and youth.
7.
From all of the above correspondence, it appears that
the Petitioners each claim to have given some land for construction
of the road, which they now seek reversion of more especially
Petitioners No.1, 2 and 3 as can be gauged from the documentary
WP(C) No.51 of 2025
Dhan Bahadur Thapa and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
evidence relied on by the Petitioners and their averments in the
Writ Petition.
(i)
From Paragraph 3 of the Writ Petition it can be culled
out that “3. That among the Petitioners’ lands, the first two
portions of the land directly border the Adampool Highway and the
other three lie contiguously behind it. …………………”.
There is
evidently no exact identification of the land or its specific location.
It is not possible for this Court to come to a conclusive finding of
which property belonged to the Petitioners on the basis of such
averments and documents, which on the other hand establishes
that there are disputes on factual aspects, including demarcation of
land used and unused by the Respondents after acquisition.
(ii)
As the Petitioners claim to have land contiguous to
each other which were acquired for construction of the alternative
route, the Petitioners have to be able to identify exactly who the
land on which the construction is taking place belongs to. There is
ambiguity in the identification of the lands in the Writ Petition. In
fact, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners after annexing and
relying on all the documents filed with the Petition, wherein the
lands of the Petitioners are referred to as „acquired lands‟ for the
purposes of the construction of the Adampool Highway, now
alleges that, the lands were not acquired in terms of the Land
Acquisition Act, 2013. The stance of Learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioners is that the Respondents have now encroached into the
land of the Petitioners i.e., unused portion of land which they seek
reversion of.
8.
Learned Government Advocate who has appeared on
advance Notice submits that he has clear instructions that
Respondents No.2, 3 and 4 have not commenced any construction
WP(C) No.51 of 2025
Dhan Bahadur Thapa and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
on any land of the Petitioners nor given any direction to any
person, or Government authority, to construct any structure on any
portion of land which the Petitioners claim to be owners and are
seeking reversion of. It is urged that the Petitioners have not been
able to clarify in the Writ Petition, as to the location and area of
land where the alleged construction is taking place and the copies
of photographs furnished do not assist in such identification.
9.
Having given due consideration to the foregoing
submissions and having meticulously perused the averments in the
Petition and the documentary evidence relied on by the Petitioners,
I am of the considered view that the matter is essentially a civil
dispute between the Petitioners and the Respondents, resting on
several factual aspects. Questions of fact regarding the acquisition
or non-acquisition of lands of the Petitioners, ownership of the
contiguous lands of the Petitioners and its identification by way of
joint inspection and consequent demarcation, possession of the
said lands, whether compensation was paid to the Petitioners as
per law, are all issues which are to be tested on the anvil of
evidence to be furnished by the parties and cannot be determined
in the ambit of the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
10.
The Petitioners may accordingly approach the correct
forum for redressal of their grievances, if so advised.
11.
The
Writ
Petition
is
consequently
dismissed
and
disposed of.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
10-09-2025
Approved for reporting : Yes
sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review