Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:23798
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 12124 of 2025
Reserved on : 24.04.2026
Delivered on : 15.06.2026
Dhagendra Kumar Sahu S/o Shri Salik Ram Sahu, Aged About 33 Years R/o
House No. 87/1, Sheetlapara Bhurkoni, District Mahasamund (C.G.)
--- Petitioner
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Water Resources
Department Mantralaya Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Ngar, Nawa Raipur, District
Raipur (C.G.)
2 - Chhattisgarh Professional Examination Board (CG-Vyapam) Through,
President, Vyapam Bhawan, North Block, Sector-19, Atal Nagar, Nava
Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
--- Respondents
For Petitioner
: Ms. Pratibha Sahu, Advocate.
For State/ Res. No. 1
: Mr. Sanjeev Pandey, Dy. A.G., Mr. Shailesh
Puriya, Mr. Manish Kashyap & Ms. Prachi Singh,
Panel Lawyers.
For C.G. VYAPAM/ : Dr. Saurabh Kumar Pande and Mr. Avinash
Res. No. 2.
Singh, Advocates.
Hon'ble Shri Narendra Kumar Vyas, J.
CAV ORDER
1.
In pursuance of direction given by this Court, the team of experts of
subjects constituted by the Chhattisgarh Professional Examination
Board/respondent No. 2 for the examination conducted towards
appointment on the post of Sub-Engineer in Water Resources
Department, have appeared in person before this Court to assist this
Court for analyzing the controversy raised in this petition.
Digitally
signed by
ARUN
KUMAR
ARUN
DEWANGAN
KUMAR
DEWANGAN Date:
2026.06.15
16:59:55
+0530
2.
The petitioner has preferred this writ petition challenging correctness
of the questions as well as model answers in the selection process
initiated by the Water Resources Department, Govt. of Chhattisgarh
for appointment on the post of Sub-Engineer through the Chhattisgarh
Vyavasayik Pariksha Mandal (for short “CGVYAPAM”). The petitioner
also seeks for issuance of direction to the respondents to re-examine
the objections raised by the petitioner as well as to re-evaluate the
petitioner’s answer-sheet on the basis of correct answers as
suggested by him.
3.
The brief facts as reflected from records are that the respondent/
CGVYAPAM issued an advertisement for appointment of 115 posts of
Sub-Engineer for the Water Resources Department. The petitioner
being qualified as having requisite qualification has applied for the said
post and appeared in the examination held on 20.07.2025. The
respondent/ CGVYAPAM published model answer key on 06.08.2025
by
inviting
objections
from
the
candidates.
The
respondent/
CGVYAPAM issued a revised final answers key along with the result
vide memo dated 04.09.2025. The grievance of the petitioner is that
the respondent/ CGVYAPAM while releasing the final answer key has
accepted only three objections raised by the petitioner and altered the
corresponding answers and the objection regarding remaining four
questions were rejected without assigning any reason which ought to
have been considered by them in favour of the petitioner.
4.
It is also case of the petitioner that the respondent authorities have
given wrong answers to few questions which have caused prejudice to
the petitioner as his marks and ranking have been down graded
depriving them from selection on the post for which advertisement has
been issued. Hence, this petition has been filed by the petitioner
challenging the correctness of the questions.
5.
The details of questions wherein the petitioner has raised objection
regarding correctness of the answers and the step taken by the
respondents regarding the objection are given in tabulation form as
under:S.No.
6.
Question No.
Remark
11 (Set- C)
Deleted
18 (Set- C)
Objection not considered
38 (Set- C)
Modified
60 (Set- C)
Deleted
73 (Set- C)
Objection not considered
76 (Set- C)
Objection not considered
81 (Set- C)
Objection not considered
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the impugned
action of the respondents is arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of
Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India as the evaluation
process lacks fairness and transparency. She would further submit that
the respondents have wrongly rejected valid objections raised by the
petitioner and have altered correct answers into incorrect ones in the
final answer key without any justification, therefore, the action is
manifestly arbitrary and academically unsound. She would further
submit that an examinee cannot be expected to assume errors in the
question paper or answer key and answer based on speculative
reasoning. The examination must be based on certainty and
correctness. She would further submit that the objections submitted
were rejected in a mechanical manner without proper consideration or
disclosure of reasons, thereby violating principles of natural justice.
She would further submit that correctness of answers must be
determined based on standard textbooks and not on inferential logic
as held by Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Kanpur University
Vs. Samir Gupta [(1983) 4 SCC 309]. She would further submit that
the respondents failed to undertake proper expert consultation or
provide reasoned justification, rendering the process arbitrary. She
would further submit that the petitioner had a legitimate expectation of
a fair and transparent evaluation process. Failure to disclose reasons
or expert materials violate this expectation. She would further submit
that the respondents are failed to disclose the reasons for accepting or
rejecting each objection or to publish the material relied upon by the
subject experts which is contrary to the doctrine of transparency in
public recruitment. She would further submit that the prejudice caused
outweighs administrative inconvenience, therefore, interference by this
Hon’ble Court is warranted. Alternatively she would further submit that
the respondents may kindly be directed to re-valuate the answer
sheets as per the answers suggested by the petitioner and would pray
for allowing the writ petition.
7.
On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent No. 2 opposing the
submissions made by learned counsel for the petitioner would submit
that the courts should exercise restraint in academic matters and
interference is warranted only in cases of patent illegality or malafide.
He would further submit that the answer key was finalized based on
recommendations of subject experts, therefore, the Court should not
substitute their views for that of experts. He would further submit that
the respondents have provided an opportunity to raise objections,
which were duly considered before finalizing the answer key. He would
further submit that the process adopted by them was uniform for all
candidates, therefore, there is no discrimination or violation of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. He would further submit that the
petitioner has no vested right to claim selection and mere possibility of
improved marks does not confer enforceable rights. He would further
submit that re-evaluation or interference at this stage would disrupt the
entire selection process and affect numerous candidates and would
pray for dismissal of the writ petition.
8.
To substantiate his submissions, he has referred to the judgments
passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Ran Vijay Singh &
Ors. vs State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors [(2018) 2 SCC 357], Uttar
Pradesh Public Service Commission through its Chairman &
Another Vs. Rahul Singh & Another [(2018) 7 SCC 254] as well as
judgments of Division Bench of this Hon'ble Court in Chhattisgarh
Professional Examination Board through its Controller Vs. Vikram
Singh Rana [2020 SCC Online Chh 2185], Umang Gouraha & Ors.
Vs. State of Chhattisgarh & Ors [Writ Appeal 165/2020 (decided
on 10.12.2020)], Manish Kumar & others Vs. State of Chhattisgarh
& others [WPC No. 4880/2022 (decided on 21.09.2023)], Alok
Kumar Jaiswal Vs. State of Chhattisgarh & others [WA No.
296/2024 (decided on 18.06.2024)], Chandraprakash Singh Kshatri
Vs. State of Chhattisgarh & others [WPS No. 4987/2018 (decided
on 08.07.2025)], Gaurav Gupta & others Vs. State of Chhattisgarh
& others [WPS No. 5577/2023 (decided on 10.08.2023)], Narayan
Prasad Sahu & others Vs. State of Chhattisgarh & others [WPS
No. 5644/2023 (decided on 16.08.2023)], Jitesh Kumar Patel Vs.
State of Chhattisgarh & others [WPS No. 9729/2023 (decided on
17.09.2025)] & Jitesh Kumar Patel Vs. State of Chhattisgarh [WA
No. 876/2023 (decided on 04.12.2025)].
9.
I have learned counsel for the parties and perused the documents
placed on record with utmost circumspection.
10.
On the above factual foundation and legal submissions made by the
respective counsel for the petitioner and respondents, following Point
emerged for determination of this Court is :“Whether this Court while exercising its power under Article 226
of the Constitution of India, can interfere with the answer key
and the report submitted by the committee of the experts on the
subject or can revaluate the answer as per the suggested
answer mentioned in the writ petition” ?
11.
This Court has called upon the experts of the subject also at the time
of hearing and the respondent/ CGVYAPAM has also placed on record
the report given by the experts on all the questions in which the
objections were raised which are extracted below:(i) For example- the expert while deleting question No. 73 (SET-C)
which is in Sr. No. 45, 42 & 60 in SET-A, B & D respectively has
opined that answer B is found to be correct and they have referred to
the book namely Concrete Technology Fifth Edition published by
the McGraw Hill Education (India) Private Limited.
(ii) So far as rejecting the objection of the candidates in Question No.
18 in SET- C which is in Sr. No. 3, 21 & 1 in SET- A, B & D
respectively, the experts have referred to the book Linux Bible, The
Comprehensive Tutorial Resources (Eighth Edition), accordingly,
they have recorded their opinion that the model answer D is correct.
(iii) The experts while rejecting objection of the petitioner regarding
question No. 81 (SET-C) which is at Sr. 75, 45 & 27 in SET- A, B & D
have found option D is correct. For deciding the said question, they
have taken into consideration the Guidelines for Capacity of Roads
in Rural Areas (first Revision) issued by the Indian Roads
Congress.
(iv) The experts while deleting question No. 76 (SET-C) which is at Sr.
35, 85 & 31 in SET- A, B & D have found option D is correct. For
deciding the said question, they have taken into consideration the
book R.C.C. Designs & Reinforced Concrete Structures Vol-I.
12.
From the opinion given by the experts, it is quite vivid that while
answering the final answer key, they have referred to the book written
by the expert on the subject which cannot be said to be without any
foundation or basis for answering the questions. Thus, this Court
which is not the expert on the subject, cannot supersede the opinion of
the expert of the subject. Even otherwise, it is well settled position of
law that the Court should not interfere on the opinion or report of the
expert unless suffers from acute malafide, arbitrariness, illegality which
are not available in the present facts of the case.
13.
It is also well settled position of law that court ordinarily refrain from
interfering in academic matters, particularly where decisions are taken
by expert bodies. However, such restraint is not absolute. Judicial
review is permissible where the decision-making process is shown to
be arbitrary, irrational, or in violation of statutory or constitutional
provisions.
14.
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Dr. B.R. Ambedkar University,
Agra Vs. Devarsh Nath Gupta & others [2023 SCC OnLine SC 970]
has examined the scope of judicial review with regard to the answers
and also held that the burden lies upon the candidate to dislodge the
opinion of the experts and also held that the High Court in absence of
any rule regarding revaluation cannot direct the examination body to
conduct revaluation of the answer sheet given by the candidate and
has held in paragraph 12 as under:“12. As regards the question of re-evaluation, the principles
enunciated by this Court could be usefully recapitulated as
follows:
12.1. In the case of Mukesh Thakur (supra) this Court observed
and held as under: “24. The issue of revaluation of answer book is no more res
integra. This issue was considered at length by this Court in
Maharashtra State Board of Secondary and Higher Secondary
Education v. Paritosh Bhupeshkumar Sheth [(1984) 4 SCC 27 :
AIR 1984 SC 1543], wherein this Court rejected the contention
that in the absence of the provision for revaluation, a direction to
this effect can be issued by the Court. The Court further held
that even the policy decision incorporated in the
Rules/Regulations not providing for rechecking/verification/
revaluation cannot be challenged unless there are grounds to
show that the policy itself is in violation of some statutory
provision. The Court held as under: (SCC pp. 39-40 & 42, paras
14 & 16) “14. … It is exclusively within the province of the
legislature and its delegate to determine, as a matter of policy,
how the provisions of the statute can best be implemented and
what measures, substantive as well as procedural would have
to be incorporated in the rules or regulations for the efficacious
achievement of the objects and purposes of the Act. …
16. … The Court cannot sit in judgment over the wisdom of the
policy evolved by the legislature and the subordinate regulationmaking body. It may be a wise policy which will fully effectuate
the purpose of the enactment or it may be lacking in
effectiveness and hence calling for revision and improvement.
But any drawbacks in the policy incorporated in a rule or
regulation will not render it ultra vires and the Court cannot
strike it down on the ground that, in its opinion, it is not a wise or
prudent policy, but is even a foolish one, and that it will not really
serve to effectuate the purposes of the Act.”
25. This view has been approved and relied upon and reiterated
by this Court in Pramod Kumar Srivastava v. Bihar Public
Service Commission [(2004) 6 SCC 714 : 2004 SCC (L&S)
883 : AIR 2004 SC 4116] observing as under : (SCC pp. 717-18,
para 7) “7. … Under the relevant rules of the Commission, there
is no provision wherein a candidate may be entitled to ask for
revaluation of his answer book. There is a provision for scrutiny
only wherein the answer books are seen for the purpose of
checking whether all the answers given by a candidate have
been examined and whether there has been any mistake in the
totalling of marks of each question and noting them correctly on
the first cover page of the answer book. There is no dispute that
after scrutiny no mistake was found in the marks awarded to the
appellant in the General Science paper. In the absence of any
provision for revaluation of answer books in the relevant rules,
no candidate in an examination has got any right whatsoever to
claim or ask for revaluation of his marks.” ***** ***** *****
26. Thus, the law on the subject emerges to the effect that in the
absence of any provision under the statute or statutory
rules/regulations, the Court should not generally direct
revaluation.” (emphasis supplied)
12.2. Further, in the case of Ran Vijay Singh (supra), this Court
has observed and held as under: “30. The law on the subject is therefore, quite clear and we only
propose to highlight a few significant conclusions. They are:
30.1. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governing an examination
permits the re-evaluation of an answer sheet or scrutiny of an
answer sheet as a matter of right, then the authority conducting
the examination may permit it;
30.2. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governing an examination
does not permit re-evaluation or scrutiny of an answer sheet (as
distinct from prohibiting it) then the court may permit reevaluation or scrutiny only if it is demonstrated very clearly,
without any “inferential process of reasoning or by a process of
rationalisation” and only in rare or exceptional cases that a
material error has been committed;
30.3. The court should not at all re-evaluate or scrutinise the
answer sheets of a candidate—it has no expertise in the matter
and academic matters are best left to academics;
30.4. The court should presume the correctness of the key
answers and proceed on that assumption; and 30.5. In the
event of a doubt, the benefit should go to the examination
authority rather than to the candidate.” (emphasis supplied)
12.3. Recently, in the case of Dr. NTR University of Health
Sciences v. Dr. Yerra Trinadh & Ors.: 2022 SCC OnLine SC
1520, this Court has, after referring to the previous decisions,
including that in the case of Ran Vijay Singh (supra), thoroughly
disapproved the process of the Court calling for answer sheets
for satisfying as to whether there was a need for re-evaluation
or not and thereafter, issuing directions for re-evaluation.
This Court has observed and held as under: “9. Applying the law laid down by this Court in the aforesaid
decisions to the facts and circumstances of the case on hand,
we are of the opinion that the High Court was not at all justified
in calling the record of the answer scripts and then to satisfy
whether there was a need for re-evaluation or not. As reported,
the High Courts are calling for the answer scripts/sheets for
satisfying whether there is a need for re-evaluation or not and
thereafter orders/directs re-evaluation, which is wholly
impermissible. Such a practice of calling for answer
scripts/answer sheets and thereafter to order re-evaluation and
that too in absence of any specific provision in the relevant rules
for re-evaluation and that too while exercising powers under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India is disapproved.””
15.
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Vikesh Kumar Gupta &
another Vs. State of Rajasthan & others [(2021) 2 SCC 309] has
examined the scope of judicial review with regard to the correction of
final key answer uploaded by the State Public Service Commission
and has held that the High Court while exercising power under Article
226 of the Constitution of India neither directs for revaluation nor
interferes in the field of expert in academic matters.
16.
Considering the facts of the case and also considering that the
respondent/ CGVYAPAM before issuance of final answer key has
called upon the objections and thereafter an expert committee was
constituted which has given its finding/ report as evident from the
documents annexed with the return. The record of the case would
further demonstrate that the petitioner is unable to dilute the
recommendation given by the expert by placing strong permissible
material though the burden lies upon them only. Thus, the final model
answer which has been prepared on the opinion of the experts of the
subject and also considering the legal position that the High Court’s
interference in the fields of expert, is very limited, this Court is of the
view that no case for interference is made out. Thus, the Point
determined by this Court is answered against the petitioner and in
favour of the respondents.
17.
Accordingly, the writ petition being devoid of merit is liable to be
dismissed and is hereby dismissed. No order as to costs.
Sd/(Narendra Kumar Vyas)
Judge
Arun
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review