Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No. 5868/2019
1.
Devkrishna S/o Late Prabha Devi W/o Ghisaram, R/o Kudiya
Ka Baas, Tehsil Phulera, Jaipur
2.
Rajkumar S/o Late Prabha Devi W/o Ghisaram, R/o Kudiya Ka
Baas, Tehsil Phulera, Jaipur
3.
Rishiraj S/o Late Prabha Devi W/o Ghisaram, Kudiya Ka Baas,
Tehsil Phulera, Jaipur
----Appellants
Versus
1.
Kaluram S/o Trilokchand, R/o Village Chakramasar, Tehsil
Jaipur Jaipur
2.
Ramlal S/o Hanuman, R/o Village Chakramasar, Tehsil Jaipur
Jaipur
3.
Ramesh Kumar S/o Ghisaram, R/o Mundota, Tehsil Amer,
Jaipur
----Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr.Himanshu Sogani
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr.J.P. Goyal, Sr. Adv. with
Mr.Abhi Goyal
Mr.Ronak Bansal &
Ms.Jyoti Swami
JUSTICE ANOOP KUMAR DHAND
Order
19/01/2026
Reportable
1.
By way of filing the instant civil misc. appeal, a challenge has
been led to the impugned order dated 09.04.2019 passed by the
Additional District Judge No.4, Jaipur, District Jaipur (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the trial Court’) by which the application filed by
the
defendants-petitioners
(hereinafter
referred
to
as
‘the
defendants’) under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC for setting aside the exparte judgement and decree dated 23.12.2011 has been rejected.
2.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of defendants submits
that a suit for cancellation of registered sale deed was filed by the
(2 of 11)
[CMA-5868/2019]
plaintiffs-respondents against the defendant and against one
person who was witness of execution of the aforesaid sale deed.
3.
Counsel submits that notice of the aforesaid suit was issued
to the defendants on 04.03.2008 and on 10.03.2008, the Process
Server submitted a report that the defendants have refused to
accept the notice of the plaint and on the basis of the aforesaid
report, the trial Court proceeded ex-parte by passing an order
dated 14.03.2008 and thereafter, the suit was decreed ex-parte
vide judgment dated 23.12.2011.
4.
Counsel submits that deliberately and intentionally one
witness of the aforesaid sale deed was impleaded as defendant in
the suit, who was neither a necessary nor a proper party, but in
spite of the above, he was impleaded as party in the array of
cause-title. Counsel submits that the aforesaid witness, after
service, submitted an admitted written statement in favour of the
plaintiffs and on the basis of the averments admitted by him in his
written statement, the suit was decreed ex-parte.
5.
Counsel submits that in fact two different sale deeds were
executed between the parties on the same date. Since one of the
suits was related to lesser amount, hence, the same was preferred
before the Court of Civil Judge and there also, the ex-parte
proceedings were initiated and ex-parte decree was passed
against the defendants, but the said suit was decreed, against
which an appeal was preferred by the plaintiffs before the
Appellate Court, however, the said appeal was rejected, hence, the
judgment passed by the Civil Court has attained finality. Counsel
submits that even the defendants appeared before the Appellate
(3 of 11)
[CMA-5868/2019]
Court in the said appeal, where also the plaintiffs never apprised
the defendants about passing of the ex-parte decree in the instant
case, hence, the defendants were not aware about the aforesaid
ex-parte
decree
dated
23.12.2011.
Counsel
submits
that
incorporating all these facts, an application under Order 9 Rule 13
CPC was submitted before the trial Court for setting aside the exparte decree, which came to be dismissed vide order dated
09.04.2019.
6.
Lastly, counsel argued that on the basis of the testimony of
the witnesses, in whose presence the notices were alleged to be
affixed on the conspicuous place at the residence of the
defendants, the refusal report was submitted by the Process
Server, were not the residents of the area, where the defendants
are residing. The defendants are the residents of Village Kudiyon
Ka Baas, Tehsil Phulera, District Jaipur, whereas both the above
witnesses are residents of some other village, i.e., residents of
nearby Village Mundota. Hence their presence on the place of
residence of the defendants is doubtful. He further submits that
even these two witnesses were also not produced in the witness
box in support of the refusal report submitted by the Process
Server. Hence, under these circumstances, interference of this
Court is warranted and the ex-parte decree dated 23.12.2011
passed against the defendants is liable to be quashed and setaside.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
plaintiffs-respondents (hereinafter referred to as ‘the plaintiffs’)
opposed the arguments raised by counsel for the defendants and
(4 of 11)
[CMA-5868/2019]
submits that the defendants were well-aware about filing of the
suit and one Ganpat Singh was also tracking the pending
proceedings on their behalf.
8.
Counsel submits that intentionally and deliberately the
defendants did not appear before the trial Court to delay the
disposal of the suit. Counsel submits that when an application
under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC was rejected, the reason of getting
knowledge has been prescribed as that one Bansidhar Jat, Adv.
informed the said Ganpat Singh about passing of the ex-parte
decree dated 23.12.2011. Counsel submits that neither the
Bansidhar Jat nor the Ganpat Singh have been examined, hence,
under these circumstances, it cannot be believed that the
defendants were not having any knowledge about pendency of the
suit against them. Counsel submits that the defendants were wellaware about pendency of the suit against them and the trial Court
has not committed any error in passing the ex-parte decree on
account of the absence of the defendants. He further argued that
there is no substance in the arguments of the counsel for the
defendants inasmuch as the two witnesses of the refusal report of
Process Server were not required to be examined by the trial
Court, as the report submitted by the Process Server is valid and
no doubt can be raised upon such report. Counsel submits that the
defendants could have submitted an application for summoning
these two witnesses, but no such application was submitted on
their behalf. Counsel submits that considering the overall facts
and circumstances of the case, the application submitted by the
defendants under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC has been rightly rejected
(5 of 11)
[CMA-5868/2019]
by the learned trial Judge by passing a reasoned and cogent order
dated 09.04.2019, which requires no interference of this Court
and the instant appeal is liable to be rejected.
9.
Heard and considered the submissions made at the Bar and
perused the material available on record.
10.
Perusal of the record indicates that two different registered
sale deeds were executed by the seller in favour of the purchaser
on the same day. It appears that the original purchaser passed
away and after her death, the suit for cancellation of sale deeds
have been submitted against her legal representatives, i.e., the
defendants before two different Courts, i.e., one before the Civil
Judge and another before the Additional District Judge No.4 Jaipur,
District Jaipur based on the fact that the valuation of one suit was
lesser and valuation of the instant suit was slight higher. It
appears that in both the suits, notices were issued to the
defendants and in both the suits, the defendants remained exparte and ex-parte decree was passed on the basis of the report
furnished by the Process Server.
11.
It is worthy to mention here that the suit filed before the
Civil Court was rejected against which an appeal was preferred,
however, the same was also rejected against which no further
appeal or revision has been preferred, hence, the said judgment
passed by the Civil Court has attained finality. It is worthy to note
here that though the defendants remained absent before the trial
Court and before the Civil Court, but they were served before the
Appellate Court, but the fact of passing of the ex-parte judgment
(6 of 11)
[CMA-5868/2019]
and decree dated 23.12.2011 was not apprised to the defendants
by the plaintiffs before the Appellate Court.
12.
This was the precise reason for which the suit has been
decided ex-parte against the appellant and it is the case of the
appellants that within three days of issuance of notice, the Process
Server has submitted a report of refusal as if the defendants have
refused to accept the notices of the plaint. It is worthy to note
here that the report of Process Server bears signatures of two
witnesses Godaram S/o Mansa Ram and Shankar Lal S/o Mahadev
Jat, but they are not the residents of the place where the
defendants are residing, i.e., Village Kudiyon Ka Baas, Tehsil
Phulera, District Jaipur and on the contrary, these two witnesses
are the residents of nearby Village Mundota. Hence, their presence
on the place of residence of the defendants at the time of
affixation of the notices at the house of the defendants appears to
be doubtful.
13.
It is settled proposition of law that if any ex-parte decree is
passed on the basis of refusal of notice, the Court below is duty
bound to examine the process-server. Herein the instant case,
neither the process-server nor the witnesses were examined by
the trial Court before initiating the ex-parte proceedings against
the defendants and before passing the ex-parte decree against the
defendants dated 23.12.2011.
14.
The provision of service of summons are mentioned in Order
V Code of Civil Procedure. The reference to provisions of Order V
Rules 17 and 19 Code of Civil Procedure are relevant in the facts
of this case and the same are reproduced as under:
(7 of 11)
[CMA-5868/2019]
“17. Procedure when defendant refuses to
accept service, or cannot be found.—Where the
defendant or his agent or such other person as aforesaid
refuses to sign the acknowledgment, or where the serving
officer, after using all due and reasonable diligence, cannot
find the defendant, 2 [who is absent from his residence at
the time when service is sought to be effected on him at
his residence and there is no likelihood of his being found
at the residence within a reasonable time] and there is no
agent empowered to accept service of the summons on his
behalf, nor any other person on whom service can be
made, the serving officer shall affix a copy of the summons
on the outer door or some other conspicuous part of the
house in which the defendant ordinarily resides or carries
on business or personally works for gain, and shall then
return the original to the Court from which it was issued,
with a report endorsed thereon or annexed thereto stating
that he has so affixed the copy, the circumstances under
which he did so, and the name and address of the person
(if any) by whom the house was identified and in whose
presence the copy was affixed.
19. Examination of serving officer.—Where a
summons is returned under rule 17, the Court shall, if the
return under that rule has not been verified by the affidavit
of the serving officer, and may, if it has been so verified,
examine the serving officer on oath, or cause him to be so
examined by another Court, touching his proceedings, and
may make such further enquiry in the matter as it thinks
fit; and shall either declare that the summons has been
duly served or order such service as it thinks fit.”
15.
Perusal of Rules 17 and 19 of Order V of the Code of Civil
Procedure shows that in order to accept the service as valid
service, particularly, when the report is to the effect that the
respondent refused to accept the summons then, it become duty
of the Court to examine the Process Serving Officer if his report is
not on affidavit. Even if the Process Serving Officer gives his
report on affidavit, discretion is with the Court to examine the
Process Serving Officer in order to ascertain, whether his report of
is correct or not in order to hold the service valid. After complying
(8 of 11)
[CMA-5868/2019]
with these mandatory requirements, the Court is required to
declare, whether the summons is duly served or not.
16.
Harmonious construction of Rules 17 and 19 of Order V of
the Code of Civil Procedure goes to show that acceptance of report
of the service of the summons is a serious and solemn act and not
merely an empty formality. Object to serve summons on the
respondent is to enable him to know about institution of the
proceedings against him and enable him to resist the said
proceeding filed against him. Law of procedure is framed in such a
manner that principle of natural justice is scrupulously followed.
The basic requirement of this rule is that the decision should not
be reached behind back of the affected party and such party
should not be precluded from participating in the proceeding.
Therefore, it becomes the prime duty of the Court concerned to
see that all procedural requirements are duly adhered to prior to
proceeding ex-parte against the concerned party to the litigation.
17.
Proof of the service of summons is essential condition for
proceeding ex-parte against the concerned defendant. It was
incumbent on the part of the trial Court to examine the Process
Server and the witnesses of the refused notice/summon on oath.
Obviously, the intention of such examination is to see that chances
of a false endorsement of such attempt to serve the summons and
refusal thereof are minimized. In the instant case, name of one of
the defendant No.3 is disputed and presence of the affixation
witnesses, who are not residents of the same vicinity is doubted.
Even these witnesses have also not been examined in the witness
box. The suit has been decreed ex-parte on the basis of admitted
(9 of 11)
[CMA-5868/2019]
written statement of the defendant No.4 who is simply an
attesting witness of the registered sale deed. Hence, considering
all the facts and circumstances, it was unsafe to proceed against
the defendants ex-parte.
18.
The primary function of the Court is to adjudicate the dispute
between the parties and advance the substantial justice. Rules of
limitation are not meant to destroy the rights of the parties. They
are meant to see that the parties do not resort to dilatory tactics,
but seek their remedy promptly. The object of providing a legal
remedy is to repair the damage caused by reason of legal injury.
The law of limitation fixes a lifespan for such legal remedy for the
redressed of the legal injury so suffered.
19.
This Court finds that the reasons of delay in filing the
application under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC along with delay
condonation application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act have
been well explained by the defendants.
20.
In view of the above, this Court is not satisfied with the
finding of facts recorded by the learned trial Judge while rejecting
the application submitted by the defendants for setting aside the
ex-parte decree/ judgment dated 23.12.2011. The impugned
order dated 09.04.2019 and the ex-parte judgment and decree
dated 23.12.2011 is not sustainable and is liable to be and is
hereby quashed and set-aside and the application submitted by
the defendants under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC stands allowed and the
instant civil misc. appeal stands allowed on the following terms
and conditions:-
(10 of 11)
(I)
The
defendants
would
[CMA-5868/2019]
pay
a
sum
of
Rs.25,000/- to the plaintiffs within a period of 15
days from the date of receipt of certified copy of
this order.
(II) The
defendants
would
plant
shade
bearing trees in their vicinity in public area. The
aforesaid process would be carried over by them
within a period of two weeks from the date of
receipt of the copy of this order and they are
further directed to look after these shade bearing
trees.
(III) The
defendants
would
submit
the
photographs of these shade bearing trees alongwith an undertaking before the trial Court to
show that the Condition No.II imposed by this
Court which has been duly complied with by
them and they would take care of these plants till
it grows and gets in proper shape and they would
submit the actual photographs of these trees at
the end of every three months in every year till
disposal of the suit.
21.
The reasons for passing this present order directing the
defendants to plant 25 shade bearing trees is in the interest of the
public at large and for the greater public good. Planting trees as
directed above, is one such initiative, which this Court considers to
be appropriate, as trees, for as long as they thrive whether for
decades or centuries will continuously and silently offer numerous
benefits to the city and the surrounding community. Future
generations will benefit from a cleaner, fresh and oxygen-rich
environment.
(11 of 11)
[CMA-5868/2019]
22. The matter is remitted to the learned trial Judge for its
adjudication, after taking the written statements of the defendants
on record. The parties are directed to appear before the trial Court
on 16.02.2026.
23.
Considering the overall facts and circumstances of the case
that the suit pertains to the year 2010 and more than 15 years
have passed, hence, it is expected from the trial Court to make all
possible endeavors to expedite the proceedings of the suit without
entertaining unnecessary request of adjournment to be made by
either side and decide the suit expeditiously as early as possible
on its merits on the basis of the evidence led by both the sides.
23.
Stay application and all pending application(s), if any, also
stands disposed of.
(ANOOP KUMAR DHAND),J
Aayush Sharma/11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review