The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. 06.2025 in I.A.No.333 of 2025 in O.S.No.49 of 2021 is of no avail in the light of the legal position referred to supra. Further, it is not known as to whether all the relevant decisions with reference to ascertaining the age of ink/signatures etc., were brought to the notice of the learned Judge while deciding the said application. Irrespective of raising any objection by the answering respondent / plaintiff, to the application in question, it is incumbent on the part of the Court to consider the relief sought for, by examining all the relevant aspects. Learned Trial Court, on consideration of the order in its entirety, in the considered opinion of this Court, has not committed any illegality in dismissing the application in question. Accordingly, the submissions made on behalf of the petitioner are rejected. 10) In the result, the Civil Revision Petition fails and the same is accordingly dismissed. No costs. 11) Consequently, the Miscellaneous Applications pending, if any, shall also stand dismissed. NINALA JAYASURYA,J Ssv THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3612 OF 2025 Ssv
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Orders Reserved on
Orders Pronounced on
Orders Uploaded on
: 06.03.2026.
: 22.04.2026.
: 22.04.2026.
APHC010669692025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3209]
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3612 OF 2025
Between:
1. DEVALAPALLE SATISH REDDY, S/O. D.VENKATARAMANA REDDY,
AGED 60 YEARS, OCC CULTIVATION, R/O. 19-12-127
BAIRAGIPATTEDA, TIRUPATHI, TIRUPATHI DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. B MANOHAR, S/o. B.Munirathnam,
aged about 55 years, Occ
Business,
R/o. 19-12-247, 1st Floor, Bairagipatteda,
Tirupathi,
Presently R/o. Plot No. 19 A, Sathyam Valley, Rajiv Gandhi Nagar,
Bachpalli Rangareddy District, State of Telangana.
...RESPONDENT
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. S V MUNI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. SAI AKASH N
The Court made the following ORDER:
The present Revision Petition is filed aggrieved by the order dated
18.11.2025, passed in I.A.No.621 of 2025 in O.S.No.96 of 2021, on the file of
the Court of Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Tirupati.
2)
The petitioner herein is the defendant in the said suit. The respondent-
plaintiff filed O.S.No.96 of 2021 for recovery of an amount of Rs.36,06,666/from the petitioner-defendant, on the strength of pronote.
In the written
statement, a plea that the suit pronote is forged and fabricated was taken.
The petitioner / defendant filed the above said I.A., under Section 45 of the
Indian Evidence Act to send the suit pronote dated 15.12.2019 along with his
admitted signatures for opinion of an expert and the same came to be rejected
by the impugned order.
3)
Learned counsel for the petitioner made his submissions to impress
upon the Court that the order under revision was passed without considering
the matter in its correct perspective. He submits that the learned Trial Court
committed an error in exercising its jurisdiction and rejecting the application in
question. He submits that a specific plea was taken in the written statement
disputing the signature on the suit pronote (Ex.A1), and in the said
circumstances, the disputed documents ought to have been referred for the
opinion of the experts. He submits that the opinion of the expert would aid the
Court in rendering complete justice and in fact, no prejudice would be caused
to the respondent/plaintiff. In the light of the decisions in G.V.Rami Reddy
Vs. D. Mohan Raju1and Namineni Audi Seshaiah Vs. Numburu Mohan
Rao2, the I.A. in question deserves to be allowed. He has also drawn the
attention of this Court to the material filed along with a Memo and addressed
arguments with reference to the same.
4)
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent made
submissions relying on the averments made in the written statement filed by
the petitioner / defendant.
He submits that it is the specific case of the
petitioner / defendant that the signatures were taken / obtained on blank
promissory notes, thus, the signatures are not in dispute. He submits that in
view of the admission
made by the petitioner / defendant in the written
statement, the only conclusion that can be drawn is that the application is filed
only for the purpose of the delaying the matter. He further submits that so far
as the relief sought for in the I.A., in question i.e., sending the disputed
documents for determining the age of the ink used for petitioner/defendant’s
signature in the pronote and the signatures of the attestors and scribe
thereon, he submits that a learned Judge in Polana Jawaharlal Nehru Vs
MaddiralaPrabhakara Reddy3, elaborately considered the issue with regard
to determination of the age of the ink and was not inclined to interfere with the
order of the learned Trial Court dismissing the application. He also placed
reliance on the decision of the learned Judge of this Court in Velagapudi
Kishore Kumar Vs Boppana Venkata Naga Krishna4 and an Order in
2019 (2) ALD 481 (AP)
2018 (6) ALD 751
2017 SCC OnLineHyd 74
CRP No.2 of 2025, dt.05.03.2025 (APHC)
Dnyaneshwar Eknath Gulhane Vs Vinod Ramchandra Lokhande5 passed
by a learned Judge of High Court of Judicature at Mumbai (Nagpur Bench).
He submits that the learned Trial Court after considering the matter in detail
had rightly rejected the request / application of the petitioner–defendant by
placing reliance on Kambala Nageswara Rao Vs. Kesana Balakrishna6,
rendered in similar fact situation. He submits that there is no illegality or
perversity in the order under challenge and, therefore, the Revision Petition is
liable to be dismissed.
5)
This Court has considered the submissions made and perused the
material on record.
6)
At the outset, it may be pertinent to mention that the petitioner /
defendant in the written statement had taken a stand inter alia to the effect
that the signatures were taken on blank promissory notes, used one of the
blank promissory notes for the purpose of the present suit. He is seeking to
send one such promissory note dated 05.12.2019 (EX.A.1) for opinion of the
expert vide I.A.No.621 of 2025.
No doubt, the learned counsel for the
petitioner made submission emphatically by placing reliance on decisions
cited supra. However, this Court had an occasion to consider the decisions
on the issue of referring the disputed documents for the opinion of the experts
with regard to the age of the ink in Smt. Uppala Veera Raghavamma Kumari
Jyothi & Another Vs. Reddy Veera Venkata Satyanarayana7. In the said
order, the decision in Polana Jawaharlal Nehru (3 supra) was relied on. The
Crl.W.P.No.542 of 2023 dt.02.11.2023 (High Court of Judicature at Bombay – Nagpur Bench)
2014 (1) ALT 636
CRP Nos.1379 & 1386 of 2024, dt.13.12.2024 (APHC)
relevant portion of the order in the said decision, for ready reference is
reproduced hereunder –
“15. It is an admitted fact that the science relating to forensic examination
of Handwriting, especially in relation to the fixation of the age of the ink, is
not perfect. In cases of this nature any reference of a document to the
Handwriting Expert just for the purpose of finding out whether the ink was 5
years old at the time of institution of the suit or 3 years old at the time of
institution of the suit, is not likely to bring any fruitful result. Interestingly in
one of the books relied upon by the learned Judge of the Madras High
Court, namely Handwriting Forensics by B.R. Sharma, Chapter 25 contains
a Glossary under the title Documenpaedia. In the said chapter, there is an
interesting portion relating to INK AGE. This portion reads as follows:
INK AGE : Age of the writing can sometime be given in relative terms.
Upkeep of the document plays an important role. Ink has been extensively
studied to fix the age of the documents. There are two aspects which have
been explored.
The compositions of inks in common usage have been changing
continuously. It was the carbon ink (known as Indian Ink) to start with. It
changed to irontannin inks, then to water-soluble dye inks and later to
organic solvent inks as for ball pens. New dye inks are coming up
continuously. Thin Layer Chromatography (LTC) can easily identify the ink
dye even from an ink line without visibly damaging the writing line. High
Performance TLC gives better results. The date of induction of a particular
ink, therefore can be ascertained with the help of its manufacturer. If a
document is purported to be written prior to its induction of the ink, it is
obviously false.
In some countries data relating to induction of various inks is kept for ready
reference.
Some inks fade with time. The extent of fading may give some idea about
the age of the writing.
Inks diffuse in the paper. The extent of diffusion may give some guess
about the age of writing.
Iron inks become darker in colour with age. The shade of the ink may give
some idea of the age of writing.
In some countries age marker chemicals, usually radioactive materials, are
added to the ink. They indicate the age of the writing.
Fresh ink is easily smudged. Older inks do not smudge easily. The ease of
smudging may give a rough estimate of the age of the writing.
The methods listed above look impressive. But in practice it is seldom that
correct age of the document can be determined as there are many
variables which affect the changes in the ink.
Age markers can give correct age of the writings. However, they are not
used in India.”
7)
In Velagapudi Kishore Kumar Vs BoppanaVenkata Naga Krishna8
the petitioner / defendant filed an application under Section 45 of the Indian
Evidence Act to send the suit promissory note for ascertaining the age of the
ink in the pen used for filling up the printed promissory note and the
subscription of the signatures on the revenue stamps affixed thereon. The
learned Judge after referring to a catena of cases including Kambala
Nageswara Rao case (6 supra) was not inclined to interfere with the order
passed by the learned Trial Court rejecting the said application. Though, in
the decisions relied on by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the disputed
promissory notes were directed to be sent to Nutron Activation Analysis
Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC), Mumbai, for determining the age of
the signatures, with due respect, this Court is not inclined to give any such
direction, more particularly in the light of the reasoning in Polana Jawaharlal
Nehru case (3 supra), extracted above.
CRP No.2 of 2025, dt.05.03.2025 (APHC)
8)
Further in Dnyaneshwar Eknath Gulhane (5 supra), the learned
Judge discussed about the facility available at BARC, Mumbai, and it is apt to
extract the relevant portion, for ready reference:
“8. As could be seen, the Assistant Director, Document Division, Forensic
Science Department, Chennai, the expert in the field, has stated that there
is no scientific method available anywhere in the State, more particularly in
the Forensic Sciences Department to scientifically assess the age of hand
writing and to offer opinion. The expert further stated that there is one
institute known as Nutron Activation Analysis, BARC, Mumbai, (which the
counsel for the respondent referred to), where there is facility to find out the
proximate range of the time, during which the writing would have been
made but the opinion is not exact and further the facility is available only to
atomic research and not to the documents relating to the prosecution and
other litigation. He has firmly stated that the age of writing cannot be found
out at all to offer any opinion.
9. This being the position, there is absolutely no justification to have futile
attempt to find out the age of the ink on the instrument under question.”
9)
Reliance by the learned counsel for the petitioner on the Orders dated
18.06.2025 in I.A.No.333 of 2025 in O.S.No.49 of 2021 is of no avail in the
light of the legal position referred to supra. Further, it is not known as to
whether all the relevant decisions with reference to ascertaining the age of
ink/signatures etc., were brought to the notice of the learned Judge while
deciding the said application. Irrespective of raising any objection by the
answering respondent / plaintiff, to the application in question, it is incumbent
on the part of the Court to consider the relief sought for, by examining all the
relevant aspects. Learned Trial Court, on consideration of the order in its
entirety, in the considered opinion of this Court, has not committed any
illegality in dismissing the application in question.
Accordingly, the
submissions made on behalf of the petitioner are rejected.
10)
In the result, the Civil Revision Petition fails and the same is accordingly
dismissed. No costs.
11)
Consequently, the Miscellaneous Applications pending, if any, shall also
stand dismissed.
NINALA JAYASURYA,J
Date:22.04.2026
Ssv
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3612 OF 2025
Date:22.04.2026
Ssv
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review