The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
4. The specific case of the petitioners is that, Ext.P15 order was issued based on various reports submitted by the Tahsildar (LR) on the basis of an enquiry conducted by the Village Officer etc., None of the records relied on by the District Collector to issue Ext.P15, were furnished to the petitioners. Petitioners submit that they have obtained these report as per the provisions of the Right to Information Act which is produced as Ext.P16. In the report, it is specifically stated that the road has been in existence since 1960 and at that point of time, it was the Panchayat Road. In 1980, it was converted to MLA road and in 2010, it was converted to a PWD road. A perusal of Ext.P16 report of the Village Officer, would reveal the entire finding that the said road was in existence in 1960 and later on, in 2010 was converted to PWD road etc, were all based only on a local enquiry WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022 2025:KER:15910 conducted by the Village Officer. If the road was a Panchayat Road as early as 1960, and later converted into an MLA road in 1980 and to a PWD Road in 2010, definitely records in this regard will be available with the Public Works Department and the Panchayath, which is not seen to have been perused or considered by the District Collector while issuing Ext.P15 order and the same has been issued only relying on the report submitted by the Tahsildar (LR), copy of which is…
5. In view of the above and taking into consideration that the property is stated to be the property of , I am of the opinion that, the matter requires reconsideration at the hands of the 4th respondent. Accordingly, Ext.P15 is set aside with a consequential direction to the 4th respondent to reconsider Ext.P10 request submitted by the petitioner afresh. The 4th respondent shall supply copies of all documents relied on by the 4th respondent to take a decision as per Ext.P15 to the petitioners within a period of one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. To verify the exact position and age of the road in existence, the District Collector shall take into consideration the panchayat’s asset register, if any, available or the documents available with the Public Works Department since it is claimed that the property has been taken over and converted to a PWD road in 2010. The petitioners shall be afforded an opportunity of being heard before taking a decision as directed WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022 2025:KER:15910 above. A decision shall be taken within an outer limit of two months thereafter. The 4th respondent shall take appropriate action in accordance with law, if the request in Ext.P10 is in favour of the petitioners. With the aforesaid directions, the writ petition is disposed of. Sd/- Continued at Page No.11 WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022 2025:KER:15910 W.P.(C)NO.4779/202…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
MONDAY, THE 24TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 5TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
PETITIONERS:
DEITY MAHAVISHNU INSTALLED IN ELOOKKARA PULLOORPILLY
SREE MOOKAMBIKA DEVI TEMPLE, REPRESENTED BY V.G. MURUKESH,
AGED 38, S/O. GOPALAKRISHNA MENON, PRESIDENT, ELOOKKARA,
MUPPATHADAM P.O., ALUVA-683110, RESIDING AT VALLOPPILLIL,
KADUNGALLOOR VILLAGE, ELOOKKARA, MUPPATHADAM P.O.,
ERNAKULAM-683110.
ELOOKKARA PULLOORPILLY SREE MOOKAMBIKA
DEVASWOM TRUST, ELOOKKARA, MUPPATHADAM P.O., ALUVA-683110,
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT V.G. MURUKESH, AGED 38, S.O.
GOPALAKRISHNA MENON, VALLOPPILLIL, KADUNGALLOOR VILLAGE,
ELOOKKARA, MUPPATHADAM P.O., ERNAKULAM-683110.
DIVAKARAN M.R.,
AGED 60 YEARS
S/O. RAVUNNI, SECRETARY, ELOOKKARA PULLOORPILLI SREE
MOOKAMBIKA DEVASWOM TRUST, ELOOKKARA, MUPPATHADAM P.O.,
ALUVA-683110, RESIDING AT KALANGARA MANAKKAPPARAMB HOUSE,
KADUNVALLOOR VILLAGE, ELOOKKARA, MUPPATHADAM P.O.,
ERNAKULAM-683110.
BY ADVS.
T.C.GOVINDASWAMY
KALA T.GOPI
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF
KERALA, STATE SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695001.
THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA,
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS, STATE SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695001.
THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA,
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, STATE SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695001.
THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
COLLECTORATE, ERNAKULAM-692030.
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
PWD ROADS DIVISION, ERNAKULAM-682021.
THE TAHSILDAR,
TALUK OFFICE, NORTH PARAVOOR, ERNAKULAM-683513.
THE DEPUTY COLLECTOR (LA),
COLLECTORATE, KAKKANAD, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT-682030.
THE SECRETARY,
KADUNGALOOR GRAMA PANCHAYATH, MUPPATHADAOM, ERNAKULAM683110.
THE VILLAGE OFFICER,
KADUNGALLOOR, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT-683110.
BY ADV DINESH MATHEW J.MURICKEN
GP- NIMA JACOB
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
ADMISSION
24.02.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 24th day of February, 2025
The
petitioners
have
approached
this
Court
challenging Ext.P15 and for a declaration that the part
of the PWD road in Survey No.214/9 of Kadungalloor
Village is part and parcel of the ‘thanathu’ property
settled in favour of the 1st petitioner Deity’s temple as
per the settlement register and that thus the 1st
petitioner is entitled to get compensation in so far as the
said property has been taken over by the PWD.
2. The 1st petitioner herein is a Deity consecrated and
installed in Elookkara Pulloorpilly Sree Mookambika
Devi Temple. The 2nd petitioner is the Eloorkkara
Pulloorpilly Sree Mookambika Devaswom Trust. It is
averred that the said Eloorkkara Pulloorpilly Devaswom
Temple with Lord Mahavishnu as the presiding Deity,
has been in existence since 500 years. The said temple
is situated in Survey No.214/9 of Kadungallor Village,
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
Paravoor Taluk. The entire area of 1 acre 9 cents
property, is in addition to 39 cents of land in Survey
No.214/8B, which also forms part and parcel of the
sanctum sanctorum of the Temple. Ext.P1 settlement
register would reveal that as per the erstwhile
Travancore settlement, which took place more than 100
years ago, in the settlement register the abovementioned properties in Survey No.214/8B and survey
No.214/9 are shown to be properties of Pullorpilly
Devaswom, and Ext.P1 would reveal that the said
properties are ‘Thanathu’ and ‘Karamozhivu’. The
petitioners submit that the right of ownership, as
regards the ‘thanathu’ lands, was considered by this
Court in Narayana pillai Madhavan Pillai vs.Kali
Gomathi Amma [2015(1) KLJ 531], and held in para 11
as follows:
“11. In the erstwhile Travancore settlement took
place more than 100 years ago. Exts.A1 and A2 are
copies of the settlement registers. In these registers the
plaint schedule properties are shown to be the
properties of Mannadi Bhagavthy. It is further shown
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
that it is ‘thanathu’ property. The name of Mangalath
tarwad does not find a place in the settlement registers.
In the Travancore State Manual published by the
Government of Kerala, it is shown that ‘thanathu’ lands
were originally government lands. ‘Thanathu’ lands
were lands for which no pattas were issued at the last
settlement and which were enjoyed by the tenants either
on payment of the rent fixed at the settlement or on
Kuthakapattam given by the department of government.
(See Travancore State Manual, Vo.III Ch.XV, pages 192
and 193 published by the government of Kerala in 1996).
In Malayalam ‘thanathu’ means ownership. (See
Malayalam – English Dictionary published by NBS).Exts.
A1 and A2 indicate that the plaint schedule properties
were originally government lands, which later came in
the ownership of Mannadi Bhagavathy Temple.”
3.
It
is
the
case
of
the
petitioners
that,
notwithstanding the above legal position regarding the
right and ownership of the petitioners over the property,
during the year 2016, the Kerala Public Works
Department constructed a road namely KadungalloorKayantikkara-Elloorkkara-Alupuram Road through the
Temple properties in Survey No.214/9 without notice or
payment of compensation. Thereupon, a petition was
filed before the PWD authorities seeking compensation.
Later on, Ext.P3 to P6 complaints were preferred. Then,
the 5th respondent issued Ext.P8, intimating the
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
petitioners that the Trust has not produced any
documents to prove that the property belonged to the
Temple and thereupon directed them to produce valid
documents from the revenue authorities. In the light of
the said direction, an application for measurement and
issuance of a sketch of the Temple ‘Thanathu’ property
in Survey No.214/9 of Kadungalloor Village taken over
for PWD road was filed before the 6th respondent
Tahsildar, as evident from Ext.P9. Due to inaction on the
part of the 6th respondent, Ext.P10 petition was filed
before the 4th respondent District Collector. Since no
action was taken on Ext.P10, the petitioners have
approached this Court by filing W.P.(C.) NO.17485/2021.
After hearing both sides, this Court by Ext.P11 judgment
directed the District Collector to consider and pass
orders on Ext.P10 request submitted by the petitioners.
In implementation of the said direction, Ext.P15 order
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
was issued by the District Collector rejecting the claim
of the petitioners.
4. The specific case of the petitioners is that, Ext.P15
order was issued based on various reports submitted by
the Tahsildar (LR) on the basis of an enquiry conducted
by the Village Officer etc., None of the records relied on
by the District Collector to issue Ext.P15, were
furnished to the petitioners. Petitioners submit that they
have obtained these report as per the provisions of the
Right to Information Act which is produced as Ext.P16.
In the report, it is specifically stated that the road has
been in existence since 1960 and at that point of time,
it was the Panchayat Road. In 1980, it was converted to
MLA road and in 2010, it was converted to a PWD road.
A perusal of Ext.P16 report of the Village Officer, would
reveal the entire finding that the said road was in
existence in 1960 and later on, in 2010 was converted
to PWD road etc, were all based only on a local enquiry
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
conducted by the Village Officer. If the road was a
Panchayat Road as early as 1960, and later converted
into an MLA road in 1980 and to a PWD Road in 2010,
definitely records in this regard will be available with
the Public Works Department and the Panchayath,
which is not seen to have been perused or considered
by the District Collector while issuing Ext.P15 order and
the same has been issued only relying on the report
submitted by the Tahsildar (LR), copy of which is
produced as Ext.P16. Secondly, another stand taken by
the
District
Collector
is
that
no
documents
to
substantiate the ownership of the property has been
produced by the petitioners. Ext.P1 is the settlement
register which clearly shows that the property is in the
name of the 1st petitioner Deity, and going by the
judgment of Narayan Pillai Madhavan Pillai(supra),
the mentioning of ‘Thanathu’ in the settlement register
denotes ownership.
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
5. In view of the above and taking into consideration
that the property is stated to be the property of , I am of
the opinion that, the matter requires reconsideration at
the hands of the 4th respondent. Accordingly, Ext.P15 is
set aside with a consequential direction to the 4th
respondent to reconsider Ext.P10 request submitted by
the petitioner afresh. The 4th respondent shall supply
copies of all documents relied on by the 4th respondent
to take a decision as per Ext.P15 to the petitioners
within a period of one month from the date of receipt of
a copy of this judgment. To verify the exact position and
age of the road in existence, the District Collector shall
take into consideration the panchayat’s asset register, if
any, available or the documents available with the Public
Works Department since it is claimed that the property
has been taken over and converted to a PWD road in
2010. The petitioners shall be afforded an opportunity
of being heard before taking a decision as directed
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
above. A decision shall be taken within an outer limit of
two months thereafter. The 4th respondent shall take
appropriate action in accordance with law, if the request
in Ext.P10 is in favour of the petitioners.
With the aforesaid directions, the writ petition is
disposed of.
Sd/-
VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
AP
Continued at Page No.11
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
W.P.(C)NO.4779/2022(V)
The sentence "In view of the above and taking into
consideration that the property is stated to be the
property of, I am of the opinion that, the matter requires
reconsideration at the hands of the 4th respondent."
Appearing
paragraph
of
the
judgment
dated
24/02/2025 in W.P. (C) No.4779/2022 is corrected as "In
view of the above and taking into consideration that the
property is stated to be the property of the 1st petitioner
Deity, I am of the opinion that, the matter requires
reconsideration at the hands of the 4th respondent." As
per the order dated 21/03/2025 in I.A.01/25 in W.P. (C)
No.4779/2022.
Sd/JOINT REGISTRAR
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 4779/2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
A TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGE OF THE
SETTLEMENT REGISTER MAINTAINED BY THE REVENUE
AUTHORITIES AS REGARDS THE SURVEY NO. 214/9 OF
KADUNGALLOOR VILLAGE.
Exhibit P2
A TRUE COPY OF PETITION DATED 24/08/2019 FILED
BEFORE THE 5TH RESPONDENT, EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
PWD, ROAD DIVISION, ERNAKULAM.
Exhibit P3
A TRUE COPY OF AN EMAIL PETITION DATED 08/10/2020
FILED BEFORE THE MINISTER OF STATE FOR PUBLIC
WORKS DEPARTMENT, KERALA.
Exhibit P4
A TRUE COPY OF AN EMAIL PETITION DATED 25/10/2020
FILED BEFORE THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR, ERNAKULAM.
Exhibit P5
A TRUE COPY OF PETITION FILED ON 30/10/2020
BEFORE THE HON'BLE CHIEF MINISTER, KERALA THROUGH
THE CM'S PORTAL WITH DOCKET NO. P201000716.
Exhibit P6
A TRUE COPY OF PETITION FILED ON 12/01/2021
BEFORE THE HON'BLE CHIEF MINISTER, KERALA THROUGH
THE CM'S PORTAL WITH DOCKET NO. P 210100284.
Exhibit P7
A TRUE COPY OF THE STATEMENT DATED 16/03/2021
FILED BEFORE THE 5TH RESPONDENT EXECUTIVE
ENGINEER PWD, ROAD DIVISION, ERNAKULAM.
Exhibit P8
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER BEARING NO. E-1527/17209 DATED 23/*03/2021 COMMUNICATED BY THE 5TH
RESPONDENT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD, ROADS
DIVISION, ERNAKULAM IN THE TRUST SECRETARY.
Exhibit P9
A TRUE COPY OF THE PETITION DATED 27/03/2021
FILED BEFORE THE 6TH RESPONDENT TAHSILDAR, NORTH
PARAVOOR.
Exhibit P10
A TRUE COPY OF DETAILED PETITION DATED 04/08/2021
FILED BEFORE THE 4TH RESPONDENT DISTRICT
COLLECTOR, ERNAKULAM.
Exhibit P11
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN WPC NO.17485/2021
DATED 08/09/2021 RENDERED BY THIS HON'BLE COURT.
WP(C) NO. 4779 OF 2022
2025:KER:15910
Exhibit P12
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER COMMUNICATING EXHIBIT
P11 DATED 21/09/2021 TO THE 4TH RESPONDENT
DISTRICT COLLECTOR.
Exhibit P13
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER BEARING NO. C8365933/20 DATED 08/11/2021 ISSUED BY THE DISTRICT
COLLECTOR INVITING THE THIRD PETITIONER FOR A
HEARING ON THE MATTER ON 17/11/2021.
Exhibit P14
A TRUE COPY OF THE STATEMENT DATED 17/11/2021
FILED BY THE PETITIONERS ALONG WITH ITS
ENCLOSURES.
Exhibit P15
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER BEARING NO. C8-365933/20
DATED 21/12/2021 INDICATING THAT THE CLAIM OF THE
PETITIONERS' STANDS REJECTED.
Exhibit P16
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT BEARING NO.
G2/4137/2021 DATED 09/12/2021 FROM THE TAHSILDAR
(LR) NORTH PARAVOOR, REFERRED TO IN EXHIBIT P15
ALONG WITH ENCLOSURES.
Exhibit P17
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT BEARING NO. A93816/2021 DATED 25/10/2021 FROM THE EXECUTIVE
ENGINEER, PWD ROADS DIVISION, ERNAKULAM.
Exhibit P18
A TRUE COPY OF THE BEARING NO. A1/EKMGL/4596/2020
DATED 15/11/2021 FROM THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD
ROADS DIVISION ERNAKULAM, REFERRED TO EXHIBIT
P15.
Exhibit P19
A TRUE COPY OF LETTER BEARING NO.A5/7991/2021
DATED 27/12/2021 ISSUED BY THE SECRETARY,
KADUNGALLOOR GRAMA PANCHAYATH.
Exhibit P20
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT OF THE HON'BLE
ADDITIONAL SUB COURT, NORTH PARAVOOR IN AS NO.
2/2019 DATED 15/01/2020.
Exhibit P-21
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 03.11.2022
ADDRESSED TO THE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER
KADUNGALLOOR AND ALSO THE REPLY BEARING
NO.10/2022 DATED 21.11.2022 ISSUED BY THE VILLAGE
OFFICER/PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review