Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC010240862019
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7436/2019
DEEPJYOTI NEOG
S/O LT. BADAN CH. NEOG, R/O GRRNHOME APARTMENT, RUKMINIGAON
PATH, P.O. KHANAPARA, P.S. DISPUR, DIST. KAMRUP (M), GUWAHATI-22,
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 4 ORS.
REP. BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE TRANSPORT DEPTT. DISPUR,
GUWAHATI-6
2:THE COMMISSIONER
THE TRANSPORT DEPTT. DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6
3:THE SECRETARY
TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
THE TRANSPORT DEPTT. DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6
4:THE JOINT SECRETARY
TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
THE TRANSPORT DEPTT. DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6
5:UNDER SECRETARY
TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
THE TRANSPORT DEPTT. DISPUR
GUWAHATIAdvocate for the Petitioner : MR. A K BHUYAN, MS. Y S PHOM,MR. M BORAH,MS. P
PATHAK,MS. N CHOUDHURY,MS. B BHUYAN
Page No.# 2/10
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, TRANSPORT,
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 25.05.2026
Heard Ms. B Bhuyan, Learned Senior Counsel assisted by Ms. R Das,
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner. Also heard Ms. M D Borah, Learned
Standing Counsel, Transport Department, Assam, appearing for all the
Respondents.
2. The Petitioner, herein, by way of instituting the present Writ Petition,
has prayed for a direction upon the Respondent authorities, to promote
him to the post of District Transport Officer (DTO), with retrospective
effect, by granting notional benefit, with effect from the date, his junior
was so promoted.
3.
The Petitioner, who was working as an Enforcement Inspector, on
adhoc basis, since the year 1991, had appeared for recruitment against
the post of Enforcement Inspector, in a recruitment process, instituted
by Assam Public Service Commission (APSC). On conclusion of the said
selection process, the Assam Public Service Commission (APSC), vide its
communication dated 26.05.1995, recommended the name of the
Petitioner for appointment against the post of Enforcement Inspector, so
advertised. Accordingly, the Petitioner was regularized in his services,
Page No.# 3/10
w.e.f 26.05.1995.
4.
In the gradation list of Enforcement Inspectors, published on
11.05.2018, the name of the Petitioner figures at Sl. No. 6, thereof.
Accordingly, the Petitioner was within the zone of consideration for his
promotion to the post of District Transport Officer (DTO), in terms of the
provisions of the Assam Transport Service Rules, 2003. The Petitioner,
not being considered for such promotion and his junior being so
considered for promotion, had led the Petitioner to institute the present
Writ Petition, praying for the reliefs, as noticed, hereinabove.
5.
Ms. B Bhuyan, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner by
reiterating the facts noticed, hereinabove, has submitted that there was
no valid reason for depriving the Petitioner of his due promotion, w.e.f
the date, his junior Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, was so promoted, vide the
order dated 20.02.2019. Accordingly, Ms. B Bhuyan, Learned Senior
Counsel submits that the Petitioner is entitled to be so promoted to the
rank of District Transport Officer (DTO), w.e.f the date, his junior was so
promoted. Ms. B Bhuyan, Learned Senior Counsel has further submitted
that during the pendency of the present Writ Petition, the Respondent
authorities, vide an order dated 21.11.2020, proceeded to promote the
Petitioner to the cadre of District Transport Officer (DTO), under
regulation 4 (d) of the Assam Public Service Commission (Limitations &
Functions) Regulations, 1951. She submits that such promotion was
Page No.# 4/10
given retrospective effect, i.e. w.e.f 20.02.2019, i.e. the date when his
immediate junior Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, was promoted to the post of
District Transport Officer (DTO).
6.
Ms. B Bhuyan, Learned Senior Counsel further submits that the
Respondent authorities, while proceeding to regularize the promotion of
the Petitioner, committed an illegality in regularizing such promotion,
with effect from the date the Petitioner had assumed the charge of the
post of District Transport Officer (DTO), in pursuance to the order dated
21.11.2020. She submits that vide the order dated 12.06.2024, while
regularizing the promotion of the Petitioner, the retrospective effect,
already granted for such promotion, initially, was ignored and the
Petitioner’s promotion, was made prospective, w.e.f 21.11.2020. Ms. B
Bhuyan submits that the reasons assigned by the Respondent
authorities, for not regularizing the promotion of the Petitioner, w.e.f
20.02.2019, is clearly unsustainable and the Petitioner is entitled to have
his promotion, against the post of District Transport Officer (DTO),
regularized, w.e.f 20.02.2019.
7.
Per Contra, Ms. M D Borah, Learned Standing Counsel, Transport
Department, Assam, appearing for all the Respondents submits that
although the Petitioner was, vide order dated 21.11.2020, promoted to
the post of District Transport Officer (DTO), with retrospective effect, i.e.
w.e.f 20.02.2019, by maintaining parity with the promotion granted to
Page No.# 5/10
his junior Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, subsequently, it was found that Shri.
Dwijendra Nath Das was not entitled to be so promoted to the post of
District Transport Officer (DTO), w.e.f 20.02.2019, inasmuch as, on the
date, he was so considered for promotion, he had already crossed the
age of superannuation. Ms. M D Borah, Learned Standing Counsel,
Transport Department, Assam, submits that, vide an order dated
05.01.2026, the Respondent authorities had cancelled the promotion
granted to Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, vide the order dated 20.02.2019.
Accordingly, she submits that there arises no occasion for granting parity
to the Petitioner, in the matter of promotion to the cadre of District
Transport Officer (DTO), with that of Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, inasmuch
as, the promotion of Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, was already cancelled.
Ms. M D Borah, by producing a notification dated 18.05.2026, has
submitted that the Respondent authorities have now promoted the
Petitioner, w.e.f 14.12.2020 and the period, w.e.f 14.12.2020 and to
16.12.2020, i.e. the date on which the Petitioner had joined against the
promotional post, would be treated as to have been spent in the
promotional post and the Petitioner was held to be Senior to the said Sri.
Asif Ahmed, who was promoted, w.e.f 21.11.2020.
8.
I have heard the Learned Counsel for the Parties and also perused
the materials available on record.
9.
The name of the Petitioner, herein, was also forwarded before the
Page No.# 6/10
Departmental Selection Committee for consideration of his case against
the vacancies, available in the year 2018-19. The minutes of the
Selection Board meeting, held on 08.06.2018, would go to reveal that as
there was a departmental proceeding, pending against the Petitioner, on
the date of his consideration, his case was not recommended for
promotion to the post of District Transport Officer (DTO). The said
aspect of the matter would have required the Respondent authorities to
have kept the name of the Petitioner in a sealed cover. However, there is
no disclosure from the materials available on record that the
recommendation of the Selection Committee, in respect of the Petitioner,
herein, was kept in a sealed cover.
10. Be that as it may, the case of the Petitioner was, thereafter, again
considered by the Departmental Selection Committee, in its meeting held
on 03.02.2020 and it is found that the case of the Petitioner was
recommended for promotion to the post of District Transport Officer
(DTO). Basing on the recommendations made in favour of the Petitioner,
by the Departmental Selection Committee, the Petitioner was, vide order
dated 21.11.2020, promoted to the post of District Transport Officer
(DTO), invoking the provisions of Regulation 4 (d) of the said
Regulations of 1951. The promotion of the Petitioner was also made with
retrospective effect, i.e. w.e.f 20.02.2019, i.e. the date when his
immediate junior Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, was promoted to the post of
Page No.# 7/10
District Transport Officer (DTO). Thereafter, vide a notification dated
12.06.2024, on the recommendation of the Assam Public Service
Commission (APSC), the promotion of the Petitioner made under the
provisions of Regulations 4 (d) of the said Regulations of 1951, was
regularized. However, while regularizing the Petitioner’s promotion,
against the post of District Transport Officer (DTO), the same was so
regularized w.e.f his date of joining as District Transport Officer (DTO).
In other words, the retrospective effect given to the promotion of the
Petitioner w.e.f 20.02.2019, vide the order dated 21.11.2020, was
ignored by the Respondent authorities, while regularizing his such
promotion and his promotion, now, was made effective from the date he
had joined against the post of District Transport Officer (DTO), in
pursuance to the issuance of the order dated 21.11.2020.
11. It is to be noted that at this stage, the promotion granted to his
junior Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, to the post of District Transport Officer
(DTO), came to be cancelled. The promotion effected in respect of his
said junior Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, was cancelled by the Respondent
authorities, only with the issuance of an order dated 05.01.2026.
Accordingly, on the date the service of the Petitioner was so regularized,
Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, continued to be considered to have been
promoted to the post of District Transport Officer (DTO), w.e.f
20.02.2019. Accordingly, the Petitioner ought not to have been deprived
Page No.# 8/10
of his promotion, with retrospective effect, i.e. w.e.f 20.02.2019, which
was so granted to him, vide the order dated 21.11.2020. It is to be
noted that there is no order, brought on record, modifying the
retrospective effect, granted to the promotion of the Petitioner to the
post of District Transport Officer (DTO), vide the order dated
21.11.2020. This Court further would also notice that in the event the
promotion of his junior Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, was so cancelled with
retrospective effect, would result in a post of District Transport Officer
(DTO), remaining vacant, w.e.f the date he was so promoted.
12. Accordingly, the Petitioner, being senior to said Shri. Dwijendra Nath
Das, in the cadre of Enforcement Inspector and from the materials
brought on record, there being nothing adverse existing against the
petitioner, it is the Petitioner who is to be held to be now eligible for
being promoted, w.e.f the date Shri. Dwijendra Nath Das, was so
promoted. As noticed hereinabove, the Respondent authorities have not
placed on record, the nature of the departmental proceedings, instituted
against the Petitioner which was pending, when his case was so
considered by the Departmental Selection Committee, in its meeting held
on 08.06.2018. However, this Court finds that in the subsequent
meeting, the case of the Petitioner was duly considered and
recommended for promotion by the Departmental Selection Committee,
which can only be indicative of the fact that the departmental
Page No.# 9/10
proceedings, instituted against the Petitioner, came to be dropped.
Accordingly, in the event of such dropping of the departmental
proceeding, instituted against the Petitioner, the Petitioner would be
entitled to have his case considered for promotion, with retrospective
effect, upon opening of the sealed cover.
13. Considering the fact that the Petitioner has already superannuated
from his service, w.e.f 31.01.2024, this Court in view of the materials
available on record, more particularly the order dated 21.11.2020,
promoting the Petitioner to the post of District Transport Officer (DTO),
w.e.f 20.02.2019, proceeds to direct the Respondent authorities to deem
that the Petitioner, on such promotion was also regularized w.e.f
20.02.2019. The Petitioner in the present Writ Petition, having prayed for
only grant of notional benefits for the period, w.e.f 20.02.2019 till the
date he had assumed charge of the post of District Transport Officer
(DTO), in pursuance to the order dated 21.11.2020, the Respondent
authorities are directed to re-fix the pay of the Petitioner, as on the date
he had assumed charge of the post of District Transport Officer (DTO), in
pursuance to the order dated 21.11.2020, by notionally fixing of his pay,
w.e.f 20.02.2019, till the date of his such assumption of charge of the
post of District Transport Officer (DTO). Thereafter, the pay and
allowances of the Petitioner be re-computed till the date of his
superannuation, occasioning on 31.01.2024 and the arrears so working
Page No.# 10/10
out, be released to the Petitioner. The re-computation of the pay of the
Petitioner in the above manner, would also now call for a re-computation
of the pension and other pensionary benefits, received by the Petitioner,
the Respondent authorities shall also make the computation, in this
connection, and release to the Petitioner, his arrears of pension and
other pensionary benefits.
14. The said exercise be initiated and concluded within a period of 4
(Four) months, from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
The arrears of pay, as well as of pension and other pensionary benefits,
be also released to the Petitioner within the period of 4 (Four) months,
permitted for the completion of the exercise, now directed to be
undertaken for compliance of the directions passed, hereinabove.
15. With the above observations and directions, the present Writ Petition
stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review